dont like the version so much but its really nice to see a younger rock singer selecting such a good JT one to play on a concert. Eddie's feeling is great, his studio singing is incredible. but live he sounds as casual as most people who likes to sing. I like him and respect him so much, there's a Black live version among my favorite video materials ever, but there's no sense in calling him "the best" singer.
not only is he the best singer ever, he is well read, generous of heart and soul, a true humanitarian, and i feel blessed to be living in an era with Ed
not only is he the best singer ever, he is well read, generous of heart and soul, a true humanitarian, and i feel blessed to be living in an era with Ed
I was never much of a Pearl Jam fan when they first hit, but over the years thanks to YouTube I'm really becoming an Eddie Vedder fan. His influences are varied and deep - from The Who to Split Enz to James Taylor. This is a lovely reading of this song - true to the original but all Eddie. Well done!
I always thought that this was the best song that James Taylor played. It's beautiful, and I can't think of another song that illustrates the mundane existence of a lower-middle class worker.
It's a shame the audio and the arrangement are so weak. This is the type of song Eddie Vedder could flat out nail. He's outrageous on stuff that's not as hard as some of Pearl Jam's stuff (which I like).
thanks for the post.. had this a long time ago via filesharing,;the mp3. the sound quality of yours is better even though they were the same performace, so great job. there too.. peace~
I love that little Eddy. He is just the best...was reading all the spewage that some folks love to chant. Feel sad and ashamed for you, in your ignorance, you not only miss the light that music is, but you attempt to poison others with your ugly soul. Washing myself off, after reading this contaminated mess, glad I am not in your gene pool, creep.
Sorry for the delay in replying, but I don't spend my time in front of a computer with my pants around my ankles, Some of us have better things to do with our time. I'm only sorry that I wasted mine responding. Won't happen again.
If you ever DO move from the front of your computer, you might remember to pull your pants up from around your ankles. Wouldn't want you to trip up. D ickhead.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
listen s hit head,it took you only 7 hours to google all that information.your comments are in the same taste as your s hite music you fukin s hit head.go die you s hit face
I think it's a testament to the humanity, first of all of James Taylor for writing it and secondly for Bruce Springsteen and Eddie Vedder for covering it beautifully, passionately and giving voice to the millions on this planet who work in mind-numbing drudgery all their lives.
listen up muppets.james taylor did not write this song.all the experts leaving comments and they dont know jack s hit.thats what i am up against...and this clown is still s hite
Poor you... You're also up against the music publishers who credit James Taylor as the writer... Conspiracy....? Paranoia....? Or just persecution complex?
The song is from a musical that's based on a book written by Studs Terkel. So, James Taylor didn't write the book upon which the musical is based, but he DID write the song form the musical. clear enough for you? Fucking moron. And what's with the "s hite"? Can't type shite?
apostlecreed.....GO FUCK YOURSELF. Yes everyone knows that James is the only one who can sing this. But you seriously have no right to dis Eddie. And he did find his own songs.......about 10 albums filled with brilliant ones. You obviously are the Fuck up here cause you don't know your shit. Like i said, James is the only one who can sing his songs but Eddie was doing a tribute to him out of RESPECT.....That's huge when other artists idolize and play your songs. You Dick
that was an insult you dick not a tribute.he is that good i can only name one of his songs.he cant sing punk and get over it.you only like him for 1 of 2 reasons.1 he comes from where you do.2 you like him because your big brother does...idiot
Dud, i wonder how old you are? Somebody help me out here. you seriously have no idea about music. Oh and 1 Eddie and Pearl Jam are from Seattle you fuck. I'm from Kentucky and yeah so what if my brother listens to them? They have Award winning albums? evryone loves them. WHy the hell did you put he cant sing punk? He and Pearl Jam are GRUNGE they started GRUNGE with Alice. You need to get your shit straight brother cause you are clueless about the music scene. Once again, Pearl Jam is Grunge
One of my favorite songs, my grandmother worked in a mill. Eddie is an amazing musician with an incredible range of expression, from PJ through to folk song, and I'm constantly amazed by his facility with any song he gets it in his mind to sing. Incredible.
Flag is singer-songwriter James Taylor's tenth album. Released in 1979, it included songs from Taylor's music score to Studs Terkel and Stephen Schwartz's Broadway musical, Working ("Millworker", "Brother Trucker"). Please, do yourself a favor and google "Millworker". JT comes up more than Bette Midler's breast do these days.....
This song was not written by JT, He covered it from a broadway musical that only lasted a few weeks. I think the credit should go to the true writer of this song. Mostly, cause it's awsome...
The Musical actually has been very successfull and the monologue that comes right before this is very powerful, and I think everyone should get a chance to see the show its called "WORKING" by studs terkel
I saw Eddie perform this song on his solo tour in DC in August. I like it even better than JT's version. Incredible vocals with just the acoustic guitar. No annoying harmonica like Springsteen's.
This song is from the musical, Working, based on Studs Terkel's book. Stephen Schwartz was the main composer, and James Taylor added this song and a few others.
I was there! Grand Rapids october '04. I had no idea what song this was at the time, but was awestruck by how beautiful and sad it was. Thanks so much for posting it!
millworker is a hell of a song
SurbanCommando 2 weeks ago
dont like the version so much but its really nice to see a younger rock singer selecting such a good JT one to play on a concert. Eddie's feeling is great, his studio singing is incredible. but live he sounds as casual as most people who likes to sing. I like him and respect him so much, there's a Black live version among my favorite video materials ever, but there's no sense in calling him "the best" singer.
apoena313 4 months ago
not only is he the best singer ever, he is well read, generous of heart and soul, a true humanitarian, and i feel blessed to be living in an era with Ed
colletgrad 1 year ago 12
not only is he the best singer ever, he is well read, generous of heart and soul, a true humanitarian, and i feel blessed to be living in an era with Ed
colletgrad 1 year ago 3
I was never much of a Pearl Jam fan when they first hit, but over the years thanks to YouTube I'm really becoming an Eddie Vedder fan. His influences are varied and deep - from The Who to Split Enz to James Taylor. This is a lovely reading of this song - true to the original but all Eddie. Well done!
ipykipyk 1 year ago 4
great cover!
I always thought that this was the best song that James Taylor played. It's beautiful, and I can't think of another song that illustrates the mundane existence of a lower-middle class worker.
lamentconfig100 1 year ago 2
As a former millworker I can say Eddie rocks.
Buanand 1 year ago 7
It's a shame the audio and the arrangement are so weak. This is the type of song Eddie Vedder could flat out nail. He's outrageous on stuff that's not as hard as some of Pearl Jam's stuff (which I like).
SterlingRe 1 year ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Boy did this version suck! Try plugging your ear monitors in to stay on pitch or drink some lemonade (non-spiked). Sorry, didn't like it.
mytakmar 2 years ago
EDDIE VEDDER THE BEST SINGER EVER :)
mattias884422 2 years ago 25
thanks for the post.. had this a long time ago via filesharing,;the mp3. the sound quality of yours is better even though they were the same performace, so great job. there too.. peace~
AngryCPU 2 years ago
I love that little Eddy. He is just the best...was reading all the spewage that some folks love to chant. Feel sad and ashamed for you, in your ignorance, you not only miss the light that music is, but you attempt to poison others with your ugly soul. Washing myself off, after reading this contaminated mess, glad I am not in your gene pool, creep.
ranchroper1974 2 years ago 2
@ranchroper1974 DAMN! So because someone doesnt like the way this guy sings, they have "An ugly soul" and they are a "Creep"...SHEEESH!!
emjee 1 year ago 2
Sorry for the delay in replying, but I don't spend my time in front of a computer with my pants around my ankles, Some of us have better things to do with our time. I'm only sorry that I wasted mine responding. Won't happen again.
If you ever DO move from the front of your computer, you might remember to pull your pants up from around your ankles. Wouldn't want you to trip up. D ickhead.
velvetunderpants44 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
just pulling up my trousers again after seeing your mother on rude tube being fucked sideways by your step father.sick and sad shower of individuals
apostlecreed 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Hey, it's a living! And we are in a recession...
You often masturbate to 86 year old naked women...?
velvetunderpants44 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
listen s hit head,it took you only 7 hours to google all that information.your comments are in the same taste as your s hite music you fukin s hit head.go die you s hit face
apostlecreed 2 years ago
I think it's a testament to the humanity, first of all of James Taylor for writing it and secondly for Bruce Springsteen and Eddie Vedder for covering it beautifully, passionately and giving voice to the millions on this planet who work in mind-numbing drudgery all their lives.
velvetunderpants44 2 years ago
listen up muppets.james taylor did not write this song.all the experts leaving comments and they dont know jack s hit.thats what i am up against...and this clown is still s hite
apostlecreed 2 years ago
Poor you... You're also up against the music publishers who credit James Taylor as the writer... Conspiracy....? Paranoia....? Or just persecution complex?
The song is from a musical that's based on a book written by Studs Terkel. So, James Taylor didn't write the book upon which the musical is based, but he DID write the song form the musical. clear enough for you? Fucking moron. And what's with the "s hite"? Can't type shite?
velvetunderpants44 2 years ago
Eddie Vedder N.1
AndrewRocker89 2 years ago 2
Eddie did this on his solo tour in Memphis June 2009. Really awesome song. Blew me away.
mechtonia 2 years ago
apostlecreed.....GO FUCK YOURSELF. Yes everyone knows that James is the only one who can sing this. But you seriously have no right to dis Eddie. And he did find his own songs.......about 10 albums filled with brilliant ones. You obviously are the Fuck up here cause you don't know your shit. Like i said, James is the only one who can sing his songs but Eddie was doing a tribute to him out of RESPECT.....That's huge when other artists idolize and play your songs. You Dick
dmcgtr7 2 years ago 2
that was an insult you dick not a tribute.he is that good i can only name one of his songs.he cant sing punk and get over it.you only like him for 1 of 2 reasons.1 he comes from where you do.2 you like him because your big brother does...idiot
apostlecreed 2 years ago
Dud, i wonder how old you are? Somebody help me out here. you seriously have no idea about music. Oh and 1 Eddie and Pearl Jam are from Seattle you fuck. I'm from Kentucky and yeah so what if my brother listens to them? They have Award winning albums? evryone loves them. WHy the hell did you put he cant sing punk? He and Pearl Jam are GRUNGE they started GRUNGE with Alice. You need to get your shit straight brother cause you are clueless about the music scene. Once again, Pearl Jam is Grunge
dmcgtr7 2 years ago
Dude you listen to Creed! LOL
corduroykelly 2 years ago
this idiot fuc ks this tune up.taylor is the only one that can do this song.go find your own songs edddie you useless prick
apostlecreed 2 years ago
apostlecreep is a complete ignorant moron..........lmao
THEmusicfreak69 2 years ago
can we get a little slide show with this or what?
crjb78 2 years ago
One of my favorite songs, my grandmother worked in a mill. Eddie is an amazing musician with an incredible range of expression, from PJ through to folk song, and I'm constantly amazed by his facility with any song he gets it in his mind to sing. Incredible.
BelindaKyle 2 years ago
hearing this for the first time this morning--been looking thru yt for millworker covers and this is truly beautiful--second only to James himself
eyescandeceive 2 years ago
really beautifull covered by Eddie Vedder...love it!!!
lethe2008 3 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I dont know what internet you all are on but Bette Midler wrote the song and the musical ran for a few weeks on broadway. Look it up...
unavailible2222 3 years ago
MillworkerWords and Music by James Taylor(c) 1979 Country Road Music. There....that internet.
kenneyj 3 years ago 4
Flag is singer-songwriter James Taylor's tenth album. Released in 1979, it included songs from Taylor's music score to Studs Terkel and Stephen Schwartz's Broadway musical, Working ("Millworker", "Brother Trucker"). Please, do yourself a favor and google "Millworker". JT comes up more than Bette Midler's breast do these days.....
kenneyj 3 years ago 2
This song was not written by JT, He covered it from a broadway musical that only lasted a few weeks. I think the credit should go to the true writer of this song. Mostly, cause it's awsome...
BuBBa
unavailible2222 3 years ago
The song was written by JT. The broadway musical you speak of just never started. Get yo facts straight before acting like you some JT Casey Casem.
kenneyj 3 years ago
The Musical actually has been very successfull and the monologue that comes right before this is very powerful, and I think everyone should get a chance to see the show its called "WORKING" by studs terkel
composer is Stephen Schwartz
FriendsFan123 2 years ago
I saw Eddie perform this song on his solo tour in DC in August. I like it even better than JT's version. Incredible vocals with just the acoustic guitar. No annoying harmonica like Springsteen's.
rnuconn 3 years ago
This song is from the musical, Working, based on Studs Terkel's book. Stephen Schwartz was the main composer, and James Taylor added this song and a few others.
Too much info?
marcsmith8 3 years ago 4
agarrenme que me desmayoooo xd!!!!!
korne05 3 years ago
AMAZING......
robbyc30 3 years ago
I was there! Grand Rapids october '04. I had no idea what song this was at the time, but was awestruck by how beautiful and sad it was. Thanks so much for posting it!
Storolf 3 years ago
omg loved it. My daddy used to sing this to me when i was little to put me to sleep :) But eddie could put me to sleep anytime he wants lol.
musicjunkie207 3 years ago 2
this is great Eddie Vedder aucoustic performance ever
inmytree29 3 years ago
That's why they're saying "versions"...Springsteen covered this too...moron.
Nevertheless, this VERSION is incredible. Not that I'm surprised. Vedder's the man.
arob34 3 years ago
James Taylor you fucking morons.. He wrote this song...
trooper744 3 years ago
Springsteen's cover is easily the best.
KleWdSide 3 years ago
This is a James Taylor cover dipshits...
stickymiki 3 years ago
Really? Thanks asshat.
Fotrane 2 years ago
Sorry, but this is nowhere near as Springsteen's version.
It's simply an inspired performance.
XDevonousX 3 years ago
Simply beautiful.
dirtyfrank09 3 years ago
BEAUTIFUL
pearljamfan01 3 years ago
One of the best eddie cover songs ever!
fucko31 3 years ago
Great artist,great voice
alexxxfi 4 years ago 2
What a wonderful version. Every bit as good as Bruce's, even though the quality obviously isn't as good.
mschwartz8 4 years ago
Grand Rapids Vote for Change.....great show, great cover
inmytree29 4 years ago
make me cry
alessiana 4 years ago