I cannot tell how much I love this scene: When Benedict decides to have a duel with his friend Claudio to win the love of his Beatrice; who wishes to be a man to avenge her kinswoman; also Shakespeare of course lacks any real tragic ability: His feuds and fights are those of men and women being indifferent to life and sharing a contemplative melancholy; compare this with the Greek tragedies about Oedipus by Sophocles or Agamemnon by Aeschylus for example.
I prefer this version over Branagh's simply because I find Robert Lindsay more dramatic and intense,Branagh plays Benedick very lightly.Perhaps an unmarried couple in real life can play the roles with less certainty.Only my opinion and I love Branagh's vision with Shakespeare I just prefer Lindsay's acting.
Lunghi is brilliant in this scene -- cold and unrelenting to Benedick as she has been all along, but with a heartbreaking vulnerability. She is convincing both when confessing her love for Benedick and in demanding Claudio's death. Much as I love Emma Thompson, I feel her Beatrice shows too much warmth in this same scene.
I really dont like the directing on this one [4:01 onwards], Robert Lindsay and Cherie Lunghi are awesome actors, but it just seemed a bit wooden? I mean, this scene is one of the most dramatic in the play, with so many mood changes, but none of them were shown in this version. Branagh's version is MUCH better. Its also funny to see Emma Thompson's face turn about 90 shades of purple ^-^ x
I don't think it's wooden at all. It's just very, very, oh, so very, English. To keep the your feelings in check, especially body language, is appropriate to the time period this play was written in and for. I like seeing the struggle of Benedick trying to be in control of his feelings and through his acting, you see he is only holding onto it by a thread, which also creates a contrast for Beatrice who lets all her feelings out. It gives an extra intensity to the scene.
thx for vid, helpful for my theater class
peteypablo396 1 month ago
where is scene 2 of this act
tashamhishi 5 months ago
I am playing Benedict for the Utah Shakespeare Festival this year so this video really helped me with my lines :{D thanks
torchofice16 5 months ago
aghh i really need a few lines before!!
lovetwilightsooomuch 7 months ago in playlist Much Ado about Nothing
In this scene that man is funny and i hate those other man
takhar1998 10 months ago
4:58
mikaelamoretti 1 year ago
haha benedick is cute without the beard, I love this production.
luna4ever36 1 year ago 2
I cannot tell how much I love this scene: When Benedict decides to have a duel with his friend Claudio to win the love of his Beatrice; who wishes to be a man to avenge her kinswoman; also Shakespeare of course lacks any real tragic ability: His feuds and fights are those of men and women being indifferent to life and sharing a contemplative melancholy; compare this with the Greek tragedies about Oedipus by Sophocles or Agamemnon by Aeschylus for example.
GreatGrumbledook 1 year ago
Comment removed
plllll0 1 year ago
I'm Playing Beatrice In my schools production of this play. This vid Really helped me with my lines!!! :D I wish people talked like that today
lexabayy 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hey this is gay.
xirawrryoux 1 year ago
@xirawrryoux Hey fuck you.
TnCbINkewl 10 months ago
Please post all the vids for this version it is so well done!
Lily21043 2 years ago 6
lol this video is going to help me memorize my lines
prfarb 2 years ago 4
wow. i like this version.
blackbird12790 2 years ago 5
im doin this for a drama assesment at school from the lady beatrice have u wept all this while and i must say it is brilliant
bfmvfanmega 2 years ago
I prefer this version over Branagh's simply because I find Robert Lindsay more dramatic and intense,Branagh plays Benedick very lightly.Perhaps an unmarried couple in real life can play the roles with less certainty.Only my opinion and I love Branagh's vision with Shakespeare I just prefer Lindsay's acting.
6Solace6 2 years ago 9
I love how Benedick actually has his beard shaved in this version!
nclysander 3 years ago 6
@nclysander I know, I was thinking that too!
luna4ever36 1 year ago
"I love you with so much of my heart that none is left to protest."
God. Why don't we speak like this anymore?
orangecatwoman14 3 years ago 21
This was so helpful, i'm playing Margaret in my school's production of Much Ado.
lyd888 3 years ago 3
Lunghi is brilliant in this scene -- cold and unrelenting to Benedick as she has been all along, but with a heartbreaking vulnerability. She is convincing both when confessing her love for Benedick and in demanding Claudio's death. Much as I love Emma Thompson, I feel her Beatrice shows too much warmth in this same scene.
GovernorSlaton 3 years ago 21
This comment has received too many negative votes show
god the acting in this scene KILLED ME! IT WAS SOOOOO CRAP!!! kenneth's version RULED!
JemLouisa 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
to be honest i think the other one is better :S ..it helps more i think XD ...lmao
VeronicaGxx 3 years ago
fuck SATS suck
BlaNcGames 3 years ago
SATS This Week Thiss Is Goin To Help Me Loads!
0305Jess0305 3 years ago
thx man this will help with my SATs
shivz222 3 years ago
I really dont like the directing on this one [4:01 onwards], Robert Lindsay and Cherie Lunghi are awesome actors, but it just seemed a bit wooden? I mean, this scene is one of the most dramatic in the play, with so many mood changes, but none of them were shown in this version. Branagh's version is MUCH better. Its also funny to see Emma Thompson's face turn about 90 shades of purple ^-^ x
crashbangb000m 3 years ago
I don't think it's wooden at all. It's just very, very, oh, so very, English. To keep the your feelings in check, especially body language, is appropriate to the time period this play was written in and for. I like seeing the struggle of Benedick trying to be in control of his feelings and through his acting, you see he is only holding onto it by a thread, which also creates a contrast for Beatrice who lets all her feelings out. It gives an extra intensity to the scene.
Concetta20 3 years ago 6
what uprich said
Fallenwings27 3 years ago
Holy crap! The acting in this scene is so fabulous! I believe the actors and Robert Lindsay was never so hot, to me, as he is in this scene!
Concetta20 3 years ago 8
i think the acting in this scene is terrible.
its so boring and monotone.
Its a caase of shakepspear gone bad.
. its just ah sooo boring
Conversewannabe 3 years ago
yeah man.
warrioramin 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yay some one with sence
x
Conversewannabe 3 years ago
thank you this is going to help me with my english SAT soo much
uprich 3 years ago
I can't believe how much better the Kenneth Branagh version is.
queenjaime 3 years ago