I totally agree that there are some major inconsistencies in Star Trek's scripting, but the acting was decent, or better, and they did employ some thought provoking physics. It is my understanding that the heavy phaser cannons are able to create an electromagnetic pulse effect, as well as being a directed energy weapon. Maybe the cannon caused the Klingon shield systems to light up like a Christmas tree? We could either ask the writers, or we could build one and test it. Which is easier?
To qualify the lighting up like a Christmas tree, I refer you to the Ion Cannon on The Empire Strikes Back when it finds it's mark on the Star Destroyer in orbit around Hoth.
There is a book out there.. "the physics of star trek" or something like that.. it explains some backstory and how far the actual probablity of some of the tech being used. You'd be surprised how possible some of the things are (including warp drive)... came with all kinds of equations and detailed matematics for the true nerd if I remember correctly.
Shields were given on a ad-hoc basis on Star Trek (gazillion examples of this) with no consistency whatsoever. Except the ship with the main characters on board always had shields. As the plot OR budget dictated.
Well they were just shooting up a hospital ship, and then they were TOTALLY taken by surprise by Enterprise attacking from below, just as if... I don't know... three-dimensional movement was possible in space or something...
wow well timmed !
frostymoviesjp 2 years ago
Gotta love character shields.
AndycorpPro 2 years ago 2
I totally agree that there are some major inconsistencies in Star Trek's scripting, but the acting was decent, or better, and they did employ some thought provoking physics. It is my understanding that the heavy phaser cannons are able to create an electromagnetic pulse effect, as well as being a directed energy weapon. Maybe the cannon caused the Klingon shield systems to light up like a Christmas tree? We could either ask the writers, or we could build one and test it. Which is easier?
brianwesley28 3 years ago
To qualify the lighting up like a Christmas tree, I refer you to the Ion Cannon on The Empire Strikes Back when it finds it's mark on the Star Destroyer in orbit around Hoth.
brianwesley28 3 years ago
There is a book out there.. "the physics of star trek" or something like that.. it explains some backstory and how far the actual probablity of some of the tech being used. You'd be surprised how possible some of the things are (including warp drive)... came with all kinds of equations and detailed matematics for the true nerd if I remember correctly.
FreedomNeocon 2 years ago
Shields were given on a ad-hoc basis on Star Trek (gazillion examples of this) with no consistency whatsoever. Except the ship with the main characters on board always had shields. As the plot OR budget dictated.
EVariation 3 years ago
Interesting that the warbird had no shields. =)
EVariation 4 years ago
Lol, that'd be bad guys for you.
Moriatti 4 years ago
star trek never seems to give klingons shields. like they never bother to turn them on whenever they're actually in danger.
garglebargledargle 3 years ago
SHIELDS ARE FOR WUSSIES!
Moriatti 3 years ago
no, the beam cannon (its actually called that) on the front penetrates any shields.
haloN00B2000 3 years ago
Well they were just shooting up a hospital ship, and then they were TOTALLY taken by surprise by Enterprise attacking from below, just as if... I don't know... three-dimensional movement was possible in space or something...
AndiJF 3 years ago
Those are warbirds belonging to Klingons who want to cheat the system and get an easy "die in battle" death :P
berner 3 years ago
it isnt a warbird it is a negh var
crypto555 3 years ago
those are called negh var class ship
crypto555 3 years ago 2
NICE!!!
Charmingwizkidclone 4 years ago