This woman's voice is wonderful. The piano is perfect, but the violin drowns out all that is good. The violinists are good, but not for this song. They tried to make it overly grand, but it's not Edith's style, so the song sounds wrong with the extra instruments.
All I can say is that I'm proud of her for getting the opportunity to stand & sing on a stage like that. That's a BIG deal ! Nice tribute to Piaf. La business de musique est merveilleuse !
Quel est le malade qui a arrangé les cordes aussi mal ? Ce pseudo quatuor qui nous couine ses truismes en arpèges. Beurk ! Ils savent vraiment plus quoi aller chercher pour faire Frenchy ... A quand la Galerie des Glaces reconstituée pour un live de Trust ?
the funny thing is this lady is a much better singer than Edith Piaf: just goes to show how little actual talent really matters in today's media consumer mindset. It's about the gimmick, the memorable.
Examples: Susan Boyle Birdy Bieber
All decent singers catapulted to fame by their gimmicks
@shakethesh Are you sure?I think Piaf has a stronger voice.To be sure Boulay has a wonderful voice also but I don't believe it is as vibrant as Piaf's.
@iworavnagora Edith Piaf's is the original. Everyone else can only be compared to her. Only Chopin is Chopin. One can come close to but cannot exceed the original.
It is not Isabelle that bothers me, I really think she sings quite OK this famous song (you should never ever compare two artistic interpretations asking the second to equal the first). It's the most unfortunate accompaniment score, the violins and the piano that sound totally out of place...
jai toujours aimer cette chanson !! et avec Isabelle Boulay qui fait hommage a Piaf !! chapeau !! c pas une imitation ici salsillo mais bien un HOMMAGE !!! j'adore !!
it isn't as good as edith piaf's version.this doesn't give you the same sensation edith piaf's does and she can;t sing it correctly.you listen to her and you realise that something isn't right.I believe that all true fans of edith piaf will agree with me.
Quite a few naysayers here, but apparently Boulay's audience disagrees, and so do I. Her voice is perfect for this song. An outstanding performance. Bravo!!
The accent is wrong, the voice is too weak - sorry, dear Isabelle, but you just failed at trying to sing Edith Piaf's greatest song. Please don't try to do it again.
obviamente la versión de Edith Piaf gusta más porque fue la primera que se escuchó, pero la versión de Isabelle es igualmente bella, con la diferencia de que Isabelle es una mujer muy bella y le da una interpretación tierna a la canción.
Pourquoi hair quand l'interpretation etait evidemment un hommage a l'artiste originalle. Isabelle ne fais pas la chanson pour des comparaisons ou pour se prouver supperieure. Elle le fait pour re-actualiser un grand classique. Elle n'a aucune obligation quand a l'interpretation. Elle donnes sa version et je l'aimes beaucoup.
@salsillo though i agree with you, credit where credits due,,, its impossible to do the lady as she was pure genius, but brave to try it, i thought, x
@salsillo The difference you are hearing is the improvement in the quality of the recording in stereo vs the recording of Edith Piaff which was all with poor quality mono equipment which gave her a nasal sound that she did not have in real life. Her daughter is everything her mother was in talent and quality and the "Little Sparrow" lives on in this beautiful woman.
@philipgaley Even though i was not a part of the original conversation i am going to do what you do best, give my opinion anyway. No matter how intellectual your answers sound your behavior is similar to a teenager. As a classmate of mine said "Am I right or are you wrong", showing off your brain must give you a sense of superiority which you don't get in real life, or else why would be on youtube 24/7 leaving comments that are long enough to make "war and peace" look like a short story.
Oops, I left out the word "examples." ...insults as I gave examples of a few comments ago...
Also, I am not insensitive to the ailments of others, whatever they may be, but to throw up your disabilities, and dental condition after piling insults on others is low. You don't know what disabilities they may or may not have. That's it. There will be no more answers from me on this thread.
You are still excusing your behavior by putting "the other guy" down. It's as I said, you simply blame others never acknowledging your own bad behavior. You seem to have acquired just enough "book learning" to try to hit others over the head with, or to make yourself sound smart to whoever you can fool temporarily.
@escritura48 Oh, gosh, I missed your post: 1) the simplest ROG (rules of grammar) require the "temporarily" before the "fool"; 2) You seem: "things are not as they seem"; 3) your "It's as I said" follows such puerile logic as, "And if you don't believe me, I'll say it again."; 4) "without acknowledging your own bad behavior." (without is the correction to never); 5) taking the other guy to have been asleep, I just gave him a simple jab or two, to see whether he'd stand as homo sapiens and get
@phillipgaley There's nothing wrong with my grammar. It's perfectly acceptable to put the adverb before or after the verb. "Ran quickly" or "quickly ran"--either one is fine. It would take me hours to mark up your writing, however, it's immaterial on a youtube comment. You are proving my points with your actions. You haven't acknowledged any wrongdoing on your part, but now you're crying elder abuse.
@escritura48 I think that, while, to point out the differences which are characteristic of the different age groups as indicators of relative maturity is not "crying elder abuse", it is but one item which stands for your immaturity as regarding a suspect claim of 50yr. on your channel. Nor, do I care much what you do, but just to say that, I done been 20 or 30, without training in use of logic, and, I'm on to ya', . . .
However, if you would please inform me of wrongdoing, I should be quite ple
@phillipgaley The only thing left for me to respond to that I haven't already answered, is to ask how old you think I really am? I vow to tell you my true age whether or not you "guess" right.
@escritura48 As before—and for the conflicted reasons given—sensing falseness in play, I kind of lean toward keeping out of the personal arena—so far as I have been made aware of, you have expressed no opinion on Isabelle Boulay's presentation; you appear to have merely dropped in for a momentary entertainment in—at the very least, attempting—to beat up on a tired, disabled, worn out, toof'luss old man, . . . here's to you, kid—hope ya' had fun, . . .
@phillipgaley Why would I give my opinion of the singer and thereby lay myself open to your insults as I gave of a few comments ago? You are such a textbook case. Now you're the victim. You rudely insult everyone who dares to give their opinion on this page, and now I'm committing elder abuse on a poor, disabled, toothless, old man? Do you also have a cane and a wheelchair? One thing's for sure, your internet connection is at least still intact.
@phillipgaley Is wi-fi to be routinely found in the nursing homes nowadays? As for me, I'm just hoping the dorm marm won't catch me up typing after curfew. If you could only see the tears welled up in my eyes as I bear my reproach and regret for having brought pain to such a decrepit one as you must be. I hope my fellow scholars will not be awakened by my sobs. And as for becoming personal, aren't you the one who first expressed question about my stated age?
. . . . quite pleased to entertain any constructive opinion.
As for YT comments being a thing of lesser value or note, in the nature of things, that is a strike against the world's fund of wealth and happiness; for, each thing in it's place is best, and that which appears but idle show, strengthens and supports the rest, simply to say that, nothing useless is or low, but that it is deserving of our best efforts because that which we do, is an expression of the self and what our society has produ
And but of course, you'd have to think carefully—which is where that book larnin' and rubbage with scholars might come in for ya', the constraint there, being, you appear not to be so interested—oh, well, . . . at least, we've found a point or two of basic disagreement, . . . and, your use of the: "And if you don't believe me the first time, I'll say it again." twist to logic, appears to stand as a bar in maintenance of arrested intellectual development—oh, well, . . .
. . . . homo sapiens, and get himself out of the traffic. And please rest assured, your opinion will be accorded the full measure of consideration and esteem as it may appear to merit.
But in all, I sense falseness to be in play: while your channel claims age 50, you claim to be young. But ppl 49+ don't exercise themselves in gratuitous abuse of the elderly because, they themselves, begin to see the light at the end of the tunnel as not so far distant, and well apprehend of the day when they
. . . . when they also, will be frail, worn out, toof'lus, and perhaps worthless.
On YT, one younger man says: "Never listen to anything anyone over 50, says.". But, beside insulating himself against transmission of the fruit of years or knowledge, the younger man reinforces the age boundary, but perhaps never considering that, those 50+ have done been where he is and so, we're on to 'em. Your self-stamped and self-assured sense of rectitude, your weak conceptual constructs, and weak use of the
. . . . weak use of the logic of grammar, at least these mark your work as of that of one's youth to be discounted for the latent effects of inexperience.
While I wouldn't see you marked down for having created a straw channel, for the reasons just given, your offerings are such that, although, as siege thrown up against the experience of age—and thus far unwarranted in reason—they may or may not be worthy of hard entertainment, plainly, they cannot be taken as meritorious of gravity or moment
@escritura48 . . . gravity or moment in thought. While, in your claiming to be 50, I don't understand what purpose might be attempted, and while I can answer your stuff, I do feel that, I am perhaps, the occasion of but wasting the precious time of your youth—and except that, both in writing and in plain intent you make yourself to appear as one whom they would not cheerfully advance, I would say that, for your immaturity, beyond much needed book larnin', you would need rubbage with scholars.
. . . . rubbage with scholars; and further, should you attain that which is referred to as the knowledge and experience of age, you might reference for future use when advising the young that, at, say, the 3rd grade level, children begin to think such that, sensing something perhaps touching themselves, they might devise such a turn in subject or topic as: "So, who speaks your reality into existence—Mr. Grownup?", then encouraging them concerning the errors counted against themselves in
. . . . against themselves in bridging, expanding, and diffusing, giving examples of each—though, not now to be done in the 500 character limit, . . .
And, you might have provided at least some bar against gratuitous abuse of me, by comment of your opinion concerning Ms. Boulay's presentation—and should you decide so to do, I do hope that, you'll let me know, . . . I learn too, in opportunities to be made aware of the mental courses of the youth of the nation, . . .
She looks good and sounds too. But someway it all looks lotta excessive. She obviously bother too much of how her voice is trembling. It doesn't help at all.
You are the one who grouped humor in with the things you (wrongly) deem as weakness/flaw. Here's quoting you: "Also, if one experiences humor, annoyance, irritation, etc., most generally, that is due to their own internal susceptibility or character flaw."
@escritura48 m-m-m-m, in the conclusions of your rationale, then, if "murder" and "benevolence" are in the same sentence, that is a plain inference to say that, the two words are in the same ontological category, . . . and, need I further to point this up as a manifest discombobulation in logic? The quote then stands on its own if but aided by a comma after "susceptibility" so that, beyond the natural and usual understanding acceptance of any one's weakness, or proclivity, or propensity towards
@phillipgaley Everyone is susceptible to humor, annoyance, and irritation; and it is not necessarily a character flaw to experience irritation or annoyance. That's just your way of passing off your own behavior as being someone else's problem rather than taking your own responsibility. I am a native English speaker, with high scores in English, so you don't need to waste our time trying to teach me how the English language works. I'm also not going to waste mine trying to force you to make sense
@escritura48 "Thou wilt keep him in perfect peace, whose mind is stayed on thee."; "Stayed upon Jehovah, finding as he promised, perfect peace and rest.".
But the weak mo which you rely on—and which Wally Carson, of your own state, upon his retirement, was quoted front page in recitation of—comes from the ancient Greek schools of oratory, Francis Bacon used it, but especially in our time, the Moslems and other of the foolish or unlearned: "That which is aggressively asserted and plausible suppo
. . . . "That which is aggressively asserted and plausibly supported is the law.". And, by extension, in their cargo cult mentality, many Christians also, use it—they call it "speaking things into existence" (usually, money and health).
Sadly, they and the many Moslem apologists et al, are simply unable to entertain of the fact that, upon merely saying something is so, doesn't make it so—reality depends, rather, not on what is spoken, but upon who speaks it—if you say: "You're a menace to societ
. . . . say: "You're a menace to society.", that's no where near a judge having said so. Although, you would see bad behavior, justified—probably, as normal or natural—use of the Greek rule, can never make it so.
Naturally, to follow in the Greek mo—logic be damed—you buttress your illogic with: "passing off your own behavior as being someone else's problem rather than taking your own responsibility.", a mere ad hominem thrust.
Then, insofar as, "I am this, and I am that." is to be of concern
@phillipgaley •• @russiangirl0123 Actually, the tonic spread allows greater space for the vocalist—y'need some book larnin', there, Buddy, and some rubbage with scholars, . . ."
phillipgaley 1 week ago
• @Madved07 Sounds like you're a boring personality and irritable, . . .
phillipgaley 1 week ago
• @frankluko Sounds like you're just too damned cheap and chinsey—y'gotta spring w'the cash for a decent sound system;
@escritura48 For each one of these thrusts to dissimilar instance, person, and purpose, which you here recite, than to have made any useful thing of contextual analysis, you sum these into personal invective; and upon which, I kind of wonder if, as is sometimes said, "To each, his own.", your summation isn't characteristic rather, of a somewhat mediocre personality type
To your own mind, you are free to accept self-justified feelings of annoyance or irritability, though not to me; and in your
. . . . in your own mind, while you are free to blink the facts pertaining to the point which was at issue, I would marvel to know of the basis in fact, experience, or psychology by which you are persuaded that, I would traipse along behind as though these simplistic attempts at use of logic made sense—I would say, "your simplistic attempts", except that, that kind of ad hoc thing is the common ground of all illiterate and the otherwise unlearned.
. . . . steer toward some form of book-larnin', I kind of wonder if than simple acquisition, your difficulties with the logic of discussion don't have more to do with embrace of a mentality which is somewhat beyond knowledge and logic; and in such regard, I would wish to not waste any more of your time; so, for the most which might be said, I do hope that, you'll have a fun day, . . .
. . . . towards, or for items of humor, the comma then unequivocally denoting a distinction between a susceptibility toward something, and anything misshapen in character or personality—comma after something, and for the reason that, as here, character or personality make reference to the same thing holding a flaw, no comma—they are the same, . . .
this is girl is not so sofisticated in her voice and it looks she love more with foreign for her language, but she seems to be a bit closer to original .
@Madved07 Yeah, as E.P.'s, I've been searching YT for another—even, a similar—frozen robotic stare—any soloist, anywhere—and not one do I find—one absolutely cold music teacher, for sure, . . .
@russiangirl0123 Actually, the tonic spread allows greater space for the vocalist—y'need some book larnin', there, Buddy, and some rubbage with scholars, . . ."
@phillipgaley Now i hate being rude, but maybe you should go out and get a life instead of sitting all day and telling your pompous opinions to every single person who commented on this video. Have a nice day :D
Well, I would say that, you're being only about 1/2 rude, but you could have avoided it entirely and still gave the same opinion.
"get a life", and: "your pompous opinions" are rather common and poorly put expressions which show lack of originality and lack of imagination. In each of my offerings, is presented at least one succinct reason showing cause for defense; and, your present response goes some distance to prove the rule which says that, to truth—and, especially as may be in criticism—
@roses845 I'm trying t'help ya', . . . although, I have not yet been able to find one showing those locked luster eyes, in her: "Tanya performs 'You Dont Know Me' from her new album My Turn", TT has a brief moment with her fists—I mean, not keeping time and threatening to clock the pianist, but you may like it, TT is most expressive, really connects with the song which she has chosen; I intend, of course, my op. only; I hope that, yours doesn't simply copy me—G0D Bless, . . .
@phillipgaley i really dont need help -_- you maystruggle to believe that people on here dont need your opinion or to have their opinion "corrected" by you xD
@roses845 10-4 good buddy, of course you really don't, . . . sorry to see our intercourse reduced to such level as to be required to make explanation for elementary construction, (unless, yer jest funnin' me—you are sometimes, so silly.) but perhaps, I may be of some assist to your grasp of ordinary things in mention of the fact that, dialogue isn't always all nuts and bolts, sometimes, employment may be made of a filler phrase or two, too—right? G B, . . .
@roses845 No, of course not—I bait up and troll most anywhere—I felt like Isabelle deserved some defense: On "Baltimore Protest Calls For Economic Justice", I was trolling for any left-wing bottom lunker, and "bonnevie9" bit on: "warehouse the criminals", telling me that, they're people, too. I felt fairly sure that, she had never been gang raped, or shot while suffering robbery, but, like all of the left-wing bottom feeders, she also, has memorized the lyrics to "Coddle the Criminals", . . .
. . . . in criticism—those of poorly formed character will respond, negatively.
But, be the reason in the criticism well placed, your proper response might have been in debate, or perhaps such as: "Why, thank you honorable sir; truly, I stand corrected; be assured, henceforth, I shall put this information to the best use possible; and should we meet again, I'll do my part that it be pleasing circumstances—I assure you that, I shall be in best form.", : ) , . . . And, if you'll look again, altho
. . . . again—and although could have been said—I offered comment to those only, whose negative comments appeared to have merited at least some small redress, . . . and just so you know, in spelling, to plan something in the past tense would be to have "planned" it, except that, most likely, you that and so, that was a simple typo—a mere thing upon which to have presented any criticism would have been my own breech.
And if sincere, I do value your well wish—I'm just a poor worn out toothless old
. . . . toothless worn out old tom (cat); and, knowing you as I do, to be a sensitive and careful thinker, and in the same moment, looking forward to the day when I shall begin uploading, I shall be glad to entertain for possible benefit, any bit of thoughtful criticism which you may deign to present, . . .
@phillipgaley if you are truly that passionate on letting the world know your opinion, write a book or create a blog. Otherwise just let people leave comments without making a big fuss out of every single word written. @roses845 is right its like you trolling this page.
@phillipgaley EVERYBODY CLEARLY LIKES HIM THOUGH AND THINKS HES A SERIOUS CREDIT TO THIS VIDEO ^_^ OMG BLESS HIS SOUL FOR HAUNTING THIS VIDEO <3 <3 TELLING THE NAY SAYERS WE ARE WRONG AND PROVING IT WITH HIS VAST KNOWLEDGE OF THE HUMAN MIND!! I bet he's thought about starting a cult where he's right and everyone is wrong, like that mental christian group in america that louis theroux keeps visiting :)
@roses845 While much more might have been pointed out—and, although I am not possessed of much knowledge—I meant to only show that, before slamming a pretty fair performer, you and some others would have better in some further thinking, . . .
And yes, I had thought about starting a cult, except that, even upon cursory examination, I find there to be quite enough of those.
Also, if there is a Christian group in America, . . . I'd like to know about it, . . . thank you for your interest, . . .
@phillipgaley thats the thing, i only said she didn't connect with the song like Edith Piaf did, the second top rated comment says basically the same thing! You really shouldn't feel the need to do this, it makes you look like a troller douche. i have no idea what the group was called because i spent too much time laughing at them, you're actually right about there being enough cults, its all the crazy charismatics who dont become sales people ;)
@roses845 Well, again, as beauty is in the eye, . . . the beautiful and arbitrary sensation of musical and lyrical connectedness must originate and remain with the sentience in capacity and type of the hearer. I'm careful to seldom apply the better than stereotypical opinions, simply because, as say, you were up there, singing, each is so unique.
But to your thrust, the recordings of Edith live, she reminds me a little too much of the voice and piano music teacher type, clenching her fists in ti
would like to see Lara Fabian do it....
callred100 1 week ago
sounds kinda Quebecky
y512516 1 week ago
elle est superbe,Isabelle Boulay!!!!!!!!!!Je t'aime autant!!!!!!
luiseqr 1 week ago
240 are deaf and morons!!!!!!
luiseqr 1 week ago
bravo,,,la voix de Edith,,,belle vibration,,,,
atinap53 2 weeks ago
sucksssssss...
Chitenza 3 weeks ago
She is lovely. Piaf was a dog. I hope Isabelle shaves her armpits ???
MrCagivaman 4 weeks ago
@MrCagivaman - Isabelle is Canadian; so she probably does.
gal5131 1 week ago in playlist edit piaf jaques brel
wonderful
juancarlosbejarano 1 month ago
I like her very much, great voice and beautiful smile.
1820sept 1 month ago
The violin killed it
manoelfranco 1 month ago
Она прекрасна, но, но, но.. это не голос Эдит.
parfy1000 1 month ago
Это не просто шикарная женщина, это ангел!!!
aktivist69100 1 month ago
This woman's voice is wonderful. The piano is perfect, but the violin drowns out all that is good. The violinists are good, but not for this song. They tried to make it overly grand, but it's not Edith's style, so the song sounds wrong with the extra instruments.
iLLjusNeedaLilCrisco 1 month ago
The crappy violin intonation ruined this
natsfan44 1 month ago 3
She just perfectly Nailed it..... and with all due respect paid to Edit with this rendition. Bravo..!!
itsmefergal 1 month ago 4
I worship you Edith Piaf and Sabelle Boulay not a half bad job. Your accent isn't quite as whorish as Edith's but you should be proud.
MsKecee 1 month ago
Comment removed
brendabest 2 months ago
All I can say is that I'm proud of her for getting the opportunity to stand & sing on a stage like that. That's a BIG deal ! Nice tribute to Piaf. La business de musique est merveilleuse !
brendabest 2 months ago
jaja la renplasaron
Devilathor 2 months ago
Quel est le malade qui a arrangé les cordes aussi mal ? Ce pseudo quatuor qui nous couine ses truismes en arpèges. Beurk ! Ils savent vraiment plus quoi aller chercher pour faire Frenchy ... A quand la Galerie des Glaces reconstituée pour un live de Trust ?
Altafux 2 months ago
Not Edith .. but sings it her way wonderfully.
Roaminoz 2 months ago
That was beautiful.
jim1088 2 months ago
Beautiful job. I think she sings this with all her heart. Don't hate. Her voice is beautiful. It's just NOT Edith. And that is a big DUH. :P
GoddessYoga 3 months ago in playlist edith piaf
luv piaf and mirieille mathieu for singing this because of their passion which is lacking in this performance
tracegnet 3 months ago
Only Piaf Mothafukaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaas NO ONE COMES CLOSE
FROM NEW YORK WITH LOVE
Midogroup2008 3 months ago
@Midogroup2008 more like with hate lol
Cocoaplata 1 month ago
Beautiful song and beautiful performer. The female Charles Trenet.
frankscheers 3 months ago
the funny thing is this lady is a much better singer than Edith Piaf: just goes to show how little actual talent really matters in today's media consumer mindset. It's about the gimmick, the memorable.
Examples: Susan Boyle Birdy Bieber
All decent singers catapulted to fame by their gimmicks
shakethesh 3 months ago
@shakethesh Are you sure?I think Piaf has a stronger voice.To be sure Boulay has a wonderful voice also but I don't believe it is as vibrant as Piaf's.
Westyrulz 2 months ago
definitely only edith can sing this song....
IsukeSahora 3 months ago 2
MOI JE LA TROUVE SUPERBE.
tekaya9 4 months ago
@tekaya9 moi aussi
moi49724 3 months ago
tout a fait d'accord avec le 2eme commentateur:))))))
nsitini72 4 months ago
Une belle interprétation de cette chanson de Piaf intemporel. Je t'aime Isabelle. Merci.
IX19UT8O 4 months ago
this song is from a some movie soundtrack???
chocheymas 4 months ago
@chocheymas Inception
SamedOkutucu 4 months ago
@chocheymas Recently this track is used in movie 'Inception' as a Trigger to wake characters up from their dream.
manya2002 4 months ago
J'aime beaucoup cette version qu'Isabelle donne de ce méga succès d'Edith Piaf.... cette chanson est intemporelle et le restera .... Merci Isabelle.
Mireille959 4 months ago
WDF????
ZamirAPa 4 months ago
edith piaf is better but i don't like the way piaf sings the 'R' sry
musicalr15 4 months ago
bravissima
modifica23 4 months ago 2
muy bueno! nya nya!
CarmillaCloudiaHDL 4 months ago
Linda interpretação!!!
jrdalpiaz0307 4 months ago
i dont know how old are u but, this version is better than edith's.
iworavnagora 5 months ago
@iworavnagora Edith Piaf's is the original. Everyone else can only be compared to her. Only Chopin is Chopin. One can come close to but cannot exceed the original.
whaddupmf 4 months ago 2
@whaddupmf
compared with Edith, no offense, I like this version.
iworavnagora 4 months ago
@iworavnagora I don't know how old you are... but stop telling nonsenses pls...
animaldan 4 months ago
@animaldan this is no nonsense
wtf is wrong with u?
why can't u aceppt else appinion?
iworavnagora 3 months ago
não nao nao sem condições essa melodia somente edith piaff sem maais
josebordo 5 months ago
She doesn't even get close to Piaf.She has a nice voice but Piaf had an incredible and stunning voice!
1985eleniathens 5 months ago
No. There is another.
1kittin 5 months ago
Fabulous..........Joseph
fredschreffler 5 months ago
la interpreto muy bien pero le hizo falta algo que solo edith le podia dar pero muy bien de todos modos
jarm2810 5 months ago
Hay canciones que solo las puede cantar una persona, y esta solo edith piaf puede, solo a ella se le siente la pasión que esta canción representa
haroldso89 5 months ago
qué linda ella.. y qué exigentes! jaja me gusta.. lo hace bien
kotres 5 months ago
@kotres y seguro los que se quejan canta igual que edith
Rebecky66 5 months ago 2
@Rebecky66 eso mismo digo yo. Es una melodia dificil de interpretar. Por supuesto que nadie suena igual que Edith, pero esta chica suena muy bien.
cvt74 5 months ago
@cvt74 hay millones de tesituras, ademas si ella se escuchara como Edith , la gente la tacharia de imitadora ¿crees que me equivoco? jejeje
Rebecky66 5 months ago
hay muchas cantantes buenas pero nadie como edith piaff para interpretar esta cancion
TheNoble2889 5 months ago
BEAUTIFUL WOMEN GREAT COVER , JUST PERFECT.
AtomicRollingStone 6 months ago
It is not Isabelle that bothers me, I really think she sings quite OK this famous song (you should never ever compare two artistic interpretations asking the second to equal the first). It's the most unfortunate accompaniment score, the violins and the piano that sound totally out of place...
ipb7883 6 months ago 3
not nearly asmuch passion as Edith has!
tearzdagoddess 6 months ago
Very beautiful. well done interpretation, different but beautiful. Edith was perfect. It's a well done version.
marcus8451 6 months ago
jai toujours aimer cette chanson !! et avec Isabelle Boulay qui fait hommage a Piaf !! chapeau !! c pas une imitation ici salsillo mais bien un HOMMAGE !!! j'adore !!
soncollin 6 months ago
QUERO ISSO PARA MEU EPITAFIO.
rcevora 6 months ago
meme si elle ne peut remplace Edith Piaff elle chante tres bien:)
billds97 6 months ago
laissez les gens s'exprimer au lieu de les abattre à chaque fois...
isabelle boulay est une chanteuse , une vraie, et , en plus, une personne humaine
J'ai vu un de ses concerts et c'est une femme hyper chaleureuse .....
ESSAYEZ DE CHANTER COMME ELLE ET ON EN REPARLE APRES OK?
profbatt 6 months ago
it isn't as good as edith piaf's version.this doesn't give you the same sensation edith piaf's does and she can;t sing it correctly.you listen to her and you realise that something isn't right.I believe that all true fans of edith piaf will agree with me.
TheSpiros1234ful 6 months ago
She can sing and she's beautiful but she's no Edith Piaf.
florastone4 6 months ago
Quite a few naysayers here, but apparently Boulay's audience disagrees, and so do I. Her voice is perfect for this song. An outstanding performance. Bravo!!
guitarista666 6 months ago
The accent is wrong, the voice is too weak - sorry, dear Isabelle, but you just failed at trying to sing Edith Piaf's greatest song. Please don't try to do it again.
ClowerFray 6 months ago
obviamente la versión de Edith Piaf gusta más porque fue la primera que se escuchó, pero la versión de Isabelle es igualmente bella, con la diferencia de que Isabelle es una mujer muy bella y le da una interpretación tierna a la canción.
Qué espectáculo !!
RaulRozada 6 months ago
very, very week performance :)
04ainars 6 months ago
pretty miserable attempt... shadow of divine Edit will always overwhelm any singer who'll try to cover her..
BlackCrowNavajo 6 months ago
Thumbs up if inception brought u here
lampsidetable1 6 months ago 2
Es una hermosa cancion, pero solo me gusta como la canta Edtih Piaf. Saludos desde México.
Martwatcher 6 months ago
APESTA LA QUE CANTA VIVA LA MUSICA TRAANCCE!!!!!!!!!!
ssarmientoP 6 months ago
con todo respeto eres idiota ,imbecil o solo tarada o quizas tambien retardada mental? TU CANCION ES UNA SOBERANA MIIIIIERRRDA!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ssarmientoP 6 months ago
She needs more attitude to sing this song right.
mehmetcesit 7 months ago
a valiant effort but it just dont cut it but trying to do a cower version of this is like asking to fail :/
2200calle 7 months ago
elle est pasz au point coincée dans un modele la bonne eleve
TheAxellle 7 months ago
A stunning beauty with an brilliant voice....bonus!
ThePainterr 7 months ago
Ohh no the kick!!
WoWDemondays 7 months ago
look at the performance of Cassia Eller ( brazil ) you will change your opinion
vincebauer 7 months ago
Pourquoi hair quand l'interpretation etait evidemment un hommage a l'artiste originalle. Isabelle ne fais pas la chanson pour des comparaisons ou pour se prouver supperieure. Elle le fait pour re-actualiser un grand classique. Elle n'a aucune obligation quand a l'interpretation. Elle donnes sa version et je l'aimes beaucoup.
yfrancoeur 7 months ago 48
@yfrancoeur je suis d´accord avec tois .
renovaratendimento 6 months ago
@yfrancoeur D'accord!
garciagar64 6 months ago
Boa interpretação ... Mas , ninguém se compara a Edith Piaff !!! ♥
Alguém sabe onde consigo um download do filme : Piaff- Um hino ao amor . ???
MrHigorpierri 7 months ago
good voice but edith piaf is way better !
Vanilleblaubeere 7 months ago
WOW ..
AtomicRollingStone 7 months ago
justement elle ne tente pas d'imiter Piaf
maxelia2 7 months ago
Uma linda mulher, com uma voz sensual e maravilhosa
Negrine 7 months ago
What a veeeeeeery nice Lady!!!! And a beautiful voice!
TheMuellerlein 7 months ago
Que belleza de mujer y que hermosa voz!!
patta32 7 months ago
Moreover, she sings with sensuality, and the meaning of the song is to be strong, not to be pretty or something else.
salsillo 7 months ago
It's impossible to performance this song, i'm sorry. Only Piaf version is valid. She tries, but she can't sing it.
What a song, my god
salsillo 7 months ago 63
@salsillo so true, theres none of the heart behind this one.
shabbykins 7 months ago
@salsillo though i agree with you, credit where credits due,,, its impossible to do the lady as she was pure genius, but brave to try it, i thought, x
kgnwayne 6 months ago
@salsillo The difference you are hearing is the improvement in the quality of the recording in stereo vs the recording of Edith Piaff which was all with poor quality mono equipment which gave her a nasal sound that she did not have in real life. Her daughter is everything her mother was in talent and quality and the "Little Sparrow" lives on in this beautiful woman.
Tomweightloss 5 months ago
@salsillo i agree.
shinningwindgod 5 months ago
I don't think she'is doing so bad. It'a quite dificult song
barghe67 4 months ago 9
Édith pour toujours <3
KhoiTroiMenhMong 7 months ago
Edith could have sung like this when she was 5.
sammy0630 7 months ago
Ninguém canta essa música como Edith. Jamais. Não fosse ela, essa música não estaria nas nossas mentes como está hoje.
rogerio12gaucho 7 months ago
Essa canção na voz de Isabelle fica mais bonita do que na de Edith. (Excusez moi, mais c'est vrai!)
bloomchoper 7 months ago
A refreshing interpretation, I personally prefer Edith. (and Rammstein) haha
SandWraith123 7 months ago 3
@SandWraith123 yeaah, merci,TX 4 pour le rammstein tip, didn't now, wow!!
JUGAopet1 7 months ago
que bonita cancion
chentit01 7 months ago
Good, but no Edith, of course. ;)
brrrrr12 7 months ago
fruhling in Paris!
rezzoc91 8 months ago
@philipgaley Even though i was not a part of the original conversation i am going to do what you do best, give my opinion anyway. No matter how intellectual your answers sound your behavior is similar to a teenager. As a classmate of mine said "Am I right or are you wrong", showing off your brain must give you a sense of superiority which you don't get in real life, or else why would be on youtube 24/7 leaving comments that are long enough to make "war and peace" look like a short story.
russiangirl0123 8 months ago
Fantastico!!!
pepeglamour 8 months ago
Oops, I left out the word "examples." ...insults as I gave examples of a few comments ago...
Also, I am not insensitive to the ailments of others, whatever they may be, but to throw up your disabilities, and dental condition after piling insults on others is low. You don't know what disabilities they may or may not have. That's it. There will be no more answers from me on this thread.
escritura48 8 months ago
Comment removed
escritura48 8 months ago
You are still excusing your behavior by putting "the other guy" down. It's as I said, you simply blame others never acknowledging your own bad behavior. You seem to have acquired just enough "book learning" to try to hit others over the head with, or to make yourself sound smart to whoever you can fool temporarily.
escritura48 8 months ago
@escritura48 Oh, gosh, I missed your post: 1) the simplest ROG (rules of grammar) require the "temporarily" before the "fool"; 2) You seem: "things are not as they seem"; 3) your "It's as I said" follows such puerile logic as, "And if you don't believe me, I'll say it again."; 4) "without acknowledging your own bad behavior." (without is the correction to never); 5) taking the other guy to have been asleep, I just gave him a simple jab or two, to see whether he'd stand as homo sapiens and get
phillipgaley 8 months ago
@phillipgaley There's nothing wrong with my grammar. It's perfectly acceptable to put the adverb before or after the verb. "Ran quickly" or "quickly ran"--either one is fine. It would take me hours to mark up your writing, however, it's immaterial on a youtube comment. You are proving my points with your actions. You haven't acknowledged any wrongdoing on your part, but now you're crying elder abuse.
escritura48 8 months ago
@escritura48 I think that, while, to point out the differences which are characteristic of the different age groups as indicators of relative maturity is not "crying elder abuse", it is but one item which stands for your immaturity as regarding a suspect claim of 50yr. on your channel. Nor, do I care much what you do, but just to say that, I done been 20 or 30, without training in use of logic, and, I'm on to ya', . . .
However, if you would please inform me of wrongdoing, I should be quite ple
phillipgaley 8 months ago
@phillipgaley The only thing left for me to respond to that I haven't already answered, is to ask how old you think I really am? I vow to tell you my true age whether or not you "guess" right.
escritura48 8 months ago
@escritura48 As before—and for the conflicted reasons given—sensing falseness in play, I kind of lean toward keeping out of the personal arena—so far as I have been made aware of, you have expressed no opinion on Isabelle Boulay's presentation; you appear to have merely dropped in for a momentary entertainment in—at the very least, attempting—to beat up on a tired, disabled, worn out, toof'luss old man, . . . here's to you, kid—hope ya' had fun, . . .
phillipgaley 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@phillipgaley Why would I give my opinion of the singer and thereby lay myself open to your insults as I gave of a few comments ago? You are such a textbook case. Now you're the victim. You rudely insult everyone who dares to give their opinion on this page, and now I'm committing elder abuse on a poor, disabled, toothless, old man? Do you also have a cane and a wheelchair? One thing's for sure, your internet connection is at least still intact.
escritura48 8 months ago
@phillipgaley Is wi-fi to be routinely found in the nursing homes nowadays? As for me, I'm just hoping the dorm marm won't catch me up typing after curfew. If you could only see the tears welled up in my eyes as I bear my reproach and regret for having brought pain to such a decrepit one as you must be. I hope my fellow scholars will not be awakened by my sobs. And as for becoming personal, aren't you the one who first expressed question about my stated age?
escritura48 8 months ago
. . . . quite pleased to entertain any constructive opinion.
As for YT comments being a thing of lesser value or note, in the nature of things, that is a strike against the world's fund of wealth and happiness; for, each thing in it's place is best, and that which appears but idle show, strengthens and supports the rest, simply to say that, nothing useless is or low, but that it is deserving of our best efforts because that which we do, is an expression of the self and what our society has produ
phillipgaley 8 months ago
. . . . has produced.
And but of course, you'd have to think carefully—which is where that book larnin' and rubbage with scholars might come in for ya', the constraint there, being, you appear not to be so interested—oh, well, . . . at least, we've found a point or two of basic disagreement, . . . and, your use of the: "And if you don't believe me the first time, I'll say it again." twist to logic, appears to stand as a bar in maintenance of arrested intellectual development—oh, well, . . .
phillipgaley 8 months ago
. . . . homo sapiens, and get himself out of the traffic. And please rest assured, your opinion will be accorded the full measure of consideration and esteem as it may appear to merit.
But in all, I sense falseness to be in play: while your channel claims age 50, you claim to be young. But ppl 49+ don't exercise themselves in gratuitous abuse of the elderly because, they themselves, begin to see the light at the end of the tunnel as not so far distant, and well apprehend of the day when they
phillipgaley 8 months ago
. . . . when they also, will be frail, worn out, toof'lus, and perhaps worthless.
On YT, one younger man says: "Never listen to anything anyone over 50, says.". But, beside insulating himself against transmission of the fruit of years or knowledge, the younger man reinforces the age boundary, but perhaps never considering that, those 50+ have done been where he is and so, we're on to 'em. Your self-stamped and self-assured sense of rectitude, your weak conceptual constructs, and weak use of the
phillipgaley 8 months ago
. . . . weak use of the logic of grammar, at least these mark your work as of that of one's youth to be discounted for the latent effects of inexperience.
While I wouldn't see you marked down for having created a straw channel, for the reasons just given, your offerings are such that, although, as siege thrown up against the experience of age—and thus far unwarranted in reason—they may or may not be worthy of hard entertainment, plainly, they cannot be taken as meritorious of gravity or moment
phillipgaley 8 months ago
Comment removed
phillipgaley 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@escritura48 . . . gravity or moment in thought. While, in your claiming to be 50, I don't understand what purpose might be attempted, and while I can answer your stuff, I do feel that, I am perhaps, the occasion of but wasting the precious time of your youth—and except that, both in writing and in plain intent you make yourself to appear as one whom they would not cheerfully advance, I would say that, for your immaturity, beyond much needed book larnin', you would need rubbage with scholars.
phillipgaley 8 months ago
. . . . rubbage with scholars; and further, should you attain that which is referred to as the knowledge and experience of age, you might reference for future use when advising the young that, at, say, the 3rd grade level, children begin to think such that, sensing something perhaps touching themselves, they might devise such a turn in subject or topic as: "So, who speaks your reality into existence—Mr. Grownup?", then encouraging them concerning the errors counted against themselves in
phillipgaley 8 months ago
. . . . against themselves in bridging, expanding, and diffusing, giving examples of each—though, not now to be done in the 500 character limit, . . .
And, you might have provided at least some bar against gratuitous abuse of me, by comment of your opinion concerning Ms. Boulay's presentation—and should you decide so to do, I do hope that, you'll let me know, . . . I learn too, in opportunities to be made aware of the mental courses of the youth of the nation, . . .
phillipgaley 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
She looks good and sounds too. But someway it all looks lotta excessive. She obviously bother too much of how her voice is trembling. It doesn't help at all.
although not so bad. But boring
Madved07 8 months ago
You are the one who grouped humor in with the things you (wrongly) deem as weakness/flaw. Here's quoting you: "Also, if one experiences humor, annoyance, irritation, etc., most generally, that is due to their own internal susceptibility or character flaw."
phillipgaley 1 day ago
escritura48 8 months ago
@escritura48 m-m-m-m, in the conclusions of your rationale, then, if "murder" and "benevolence" are in the same sentence, that is a plain inference to say that, the two words are in the same ontological category, . . . and, need I further to point this up as a manifest discombobulation in logic? The quote then stands on its own if but aided by a comma after "susceptibility" so that, beyond the natural and usual understanding acceptance of any one's weakness, or proclivity, or propensity towards
phillipgaley 8 months ago
@phillipgaley Everyone is susceptible to humor, annoyance, and irritation; and it is not necessarily a character flaw to experience irritation or annoyance. That's just your way of passing off your own behavior as being someone else's problem rather than taking your own responsibility. I am a native English speaker, with high scores in English, so you don't need to waste our time trying to teach me how the English language works. I'm also not going to waste mine trying to force you to make sense
escritura48 8 months ago
@escritura48 "Thou wilt keep him in perfect peace, whose mind is stayed on thee."; "Stayed upon Jehovah, finding as he promised, perfect peace and rest.".
But the weak mo which you rely on—and which Wally Carson, of your own state, upon his retirement, was quoted front page in recitation of—comes from the ancient Greek schools of oratory, Francis Bacon used it, but especially in our time, the Moslems and other of the foolish or unlearned: "That which is aggressively asserted and plausible suppo
phillipgaley 8 months ago
. . . . "That which is aggressively asserted and plausibly supported is the law.". And, by extension, in their cargo cult mentality, many Christians also, use it—they call it "speaking things into existence" (usually, money and health).
Sadly, they and the many Moslem apologists et al, are simply unable to entertain of the fact that, upon merely saying something is so, doesn't make it so—reality depends, rather, not on what is spoken, but upon who speaks it—if you say: "You're a menace to societ
phillipgaley 8 months ago
. . . . say: "You're a menace to society.", that's no where near a judge having said so. Although, you would see bad behavior, justified—probably, as normal or natural—use of the Greek rule, can never make it so.
Naturally, to follow in the Greek mo—logic be damed—you buttress your illogic with: "passing off your own behavior as being someone else's problem rather than taking your own responsibility.", a mere ad hominem thrust.
Then, insofar as, "I am this, and I am that." is to be of concern
phillipgaley 8 months ago
@phillipgaley •• @russiangirl0123 Actually, the tonic spread allows greater space for the vocalist—y'need some book larnin', there, Buddy, and some rubbage with scholars, . . ."
phillipgaley 1 week ago
• @Madved07 Sounds like you're a boring personality and irritable, . . .
phillipgaley 1 week ago
• @frankluko Sounds like you're just too damned cheap and chinsey—y'gotta spring w'the cash for a decent sound system;
phillipgaley 1 week ago
Who's "speaking" your behavior into existence?
escritura48 8 months ago
@escritura48 For each one of these thrusts to dissimilar instance, person, and purpose, which you here recite, than to have made any useful thing of contextual analysis, you sum these into personal invective; and upon which, I kind of wonder if, as is sometimes said, "To each, his own.", your summation isn't characteristic rather, of a somewhat mediocre personality type
To your own mind, you are free to accept self-justified feelings of annoyance or irritability, though not to me; and in your
phillipgaley 8 months ago
. . . . in your own mind, while you are free to blink the facts pertaining to the point which was at issue, I would marvel to know of the basis in fact, experience, or psychology by which you are persuaded that, I would traipse along behind as though these simplistic attempts at use of logic made sense—I would say, "your simplistic attempts", except that, that kind of ad hoc thing is the common ground of all illiterate and the otherwise unlearned.
And while some, I might try to steer toward some
phillipgaley 8 months ago
. . . . steer toward some form of book-larnin', I kind of wonder if than simple acquisition, your difficulties with the logic of discussion don't have more to do with embrace of a mentality which is somewhat beyond knowledge and logic; and in such regard, I would wish to not waste any more of your time; so, for the most which might be said, I do hope that, you'll have a fun day, . . .
phillipgaley 8 months ago
. . . . towards, or for items of humor, the comma then unequivocally denoting a distinction between a susceptibility toward something, and anything misshapen in character or personality—comma after something, and for the reason that, as here, character or personality make reference to the same thing holding a flaw, no comma—they are the same, . . .
phillipgaley 8 months ago
Что за самодеятеятельность. спасибо..
legioru 8 months ago
Ужасно..
legioru 8 months ago
Move your hands woman! And say 'je ne' faster.
jenshu7 8 months ago
Beautiful
yfrancoeur 8 months ago
Couldn't feel the the sort of combustion which Piaf possessed
chengchunnam 8 months ago
Singing a signature song of Edith Piaf? I give her points for bravery.
muatlas 8 months ago
for fun: just compare to this
watch?v=Uid9XvlN64s
this is girl is not so sofisticated in her voice and it looks she love more with foreign for her language, but she seems to be a bit closer to original .
Though nobady cold compare to E.P.
Madved07 8 months ago
@Madved07 Yeah, as E.P.'s, I've been searching YT for another—even, a similar—frozen robotic stare—any soloist, anywhere—and not one do I find—one absolutely cold music teacher, for sure, . . .
phillipgaley 8 months ago
She looks good and sounds too. But somehow it all looks excessive. She obviously bother much as her voice is trembling. It doesn't help.
although not so bad. But boring
Madved07 8 months ago
@Madved07 Sounds like you're a boring personality and irritable, . . .
phillipgaley 8 months ago
shouldn't the people who planed this concert hear that a violin shouldn't be like an octave higher then the singers voice?
russiangirl0123 8 months ago
@russiangirl0123 Actually, the tonic spread allows greater space for the vocalist—y'need some book larnin', there, Buddy, and some rubbage with scholars, . . ."
phillipgaley 8 months ago
@phillipgaley Now i hate being rude, but maybe you should go out and get a life instead of sitting all day and telling your pompous opinions to every single person who commented on this video. Have a nice day :D
russiangirl0123 8 months ago
Comment removed
phillipgaley 8 months ago
Well, I would say that, you're being only about 1/2 rude, but you could have avoided it entirely and still gave the same opinion.
"get a life", and: "your pompous opinions" are rather common and poorly put expressions which show lack of originality and lack of imagination. In each of my offerings, is presented at least one succinct reason showing cause for defense; and, your present response goes some distance to prove the rule which says that, to truth—and, especially as may be in criticism—
phillipgaley 8 months ago
@phillipgaley do you just troll this page?
roses845 8 months ago
@roses845 I'm trying t'help ya', . . . although, I have not yet been able to find one showing those locked luster eyes, in her: "Tanya performs 'You Dont Know Me' from her new album My Turn", TT has a brief moment with her fists—I mean, not keeping time and threatening to clock the pianist, but you may like it, TT is most expressive, really connects with the song which she has chosen; I intend, of course, my op. only; I hope that, yours doesn't simply copy me—G0D Bless, . . .
phillipgaley 8 months ago
@phillipgaley i really dont need help -_- you maystruggle to believe that people on here dont need your opinion or to have their opinion "corrected" by you xD
roses845 8 months ago
Comment removed
phillipgaley 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@roses845 10-4 good buddy, of course you really don't, . . . sorry to see our intercourse reduced to such level as to be required to make explanation for elementary construction, (unless, yer jest funnin' me—you are sometimes, so silly.) but perhaps, I may be of some assist to your grasp of ordinary things in mention of the fact that, dialogue isn't always all nuts and bolts, sometimes, employment may be made of a filler phrase or two, too—right? G B, . . .
phillipgaley 8 months ago
Comment removed
phillipgaley 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@roses845 No, of course not—I bait up and troll most anywhere—I felt like Isabelle deserved some defense: On "Baltimore Protest Calls For Economic Justice", I was trolling for any left-wing bottom lunker, and "bonnevie9" bit on: "warehouse the criminals", telling me that, they're people, too. I felt fairly sure that, she had never been gang raped, or shot while suffering robbery, but, like all of the left-wing bottom feeders, she also, has memorized the lyrics to "Coddle the Criminals", . . .
phillipgaley 8 months ago
. . . . in criticism—those of poorly formed character will respond, negatively.
But, be the reason in the criticism well placed, your proper response might have been in debate, or perhaps such as: "Why, thank you honorable sir; truly, I stand corrected; be assured, henceforth, I shall put this information to the best use possible; and should we meet again, I'll do my part that it be pleasing circumstances—I assure you that, I shall be in best form.", : ) , . . . And, if you'll look again, altho
phillipgaley 8 months ago
@phillipgaley WHO THE ARE YOU TALKING TO?
roses845 8 months ago
. . . . again—and although could have been said—I offered comment to those only, whose negative comments appeared to have merited at least some small redress, . . . and just so you know, in spelling, to plan something in the past tense would be to have "planned" it, except that, most likely, you that and so, that was a simple typo—a mere thing upon which to have presented any criticism would have been my own breech.
And if sincere, I do value your well wish—I'm just a poor worn out toothless old
phillipgaley 8 months ago
. . . . toothless worn out old tom (cat); and, knowing you as I do, to be a sensitive and careful thinker, and in the same moment, looking forward to the day when I shall begin uploading, I shall be glad to entertain for possible benefit, any bit of thoughtful criticism which you may deign to present, . . .
phillipgaley 8 months ago
@phillipgaley if you are truly that passionate on letting the world know your opinion, write a book or create a blog. Otherwise just let people leave comments without making a big fuss out of every single word written. @roses845 is right its like you trolling this page.
russiangirl0123 8 months ago
@russiangirl0123 Maybe, you're right, . . . nobody likes me, . . . I'm never going to write, ever again, . . .
phillipgaley 8 months ago
@phillipgaley EVERYBODY CLEARLY LIKES HIM THOUGH AND THINKS HES A SERIOUS CREDIT TO THIS VIDEO ^_^ OMG BLESS HIS SOUL FOR HAUNTING THIS VIDEO <3 <3 TELLING THE NAY SAYERS WE ARE WRONG AND PROVING IT WITH HIS VAST KNOWLEDGE OF THE HUMAN MIND!! I bet he's thought about starting a cult where he's right and everyone is wrong, like that mental christian group in america that louis theroux keeps visiting :)
roses845 8 months ago
@roses845 While much more might have been pointed out—and, although I am not possessed of much knowledge—I meant to only show that, before slamming a pretty fair performer, you and some others would have better in some further thinking, . . .
And yes, I had thought about starting a cult, except that, even upon cursory examination, I find there to be quite enough of those.
Also, if there is a Christian group in America, . . . I'd like to know about it, . . . thank you for your interest, . . .
phillipgaley 8 months ago
@phillipgaley thats the thing, i only said she didn't connect with the song like Edith Piaf did, the second top rated comment says basically the same thing! You really shouldn't feel the need to do this, it makes you look like a troller douche. i have no idea what the group was called because i spent too much time laughing at them, you're actually right about there being enough cults, its all the crazy charismatics who dont become sales people ;)
roses845 8 months ago
@roses845 Well, again, as beauty is in the eye, . . . the beautiful and arbitrary sensation of musical and lyrical connectedness must originate and remain with the sentience in capacity and type of the hearer. I'm careful to seldom apply the better than stereotypical opinions, simply because, as say, you were up there, singing, each is so unique.
But to your thrust, the recordings of Edith live, she reminds me a little too much of the voice and piano music teacher type, clenching her fists in ti
phillipgaley 8 months ago