In the later part of his life Ray probably felt more spiritual- understood those other forces-- probably. This film is entirely different from all other films of his. Each word uttered by Utpal Dutta makes me think whether RAy is asking these questions to himself. Like " Ke debe alo, Ke debe pran" The character's confrontation with the lawyer ( Dhritiman Chattopadhyay) is the essence of the movie. Outstanding.
@lahiridilli Was it spiritual or a kind of frustration with the system, that continues to remain stuck up even today...am wondering...spiritualism did not easily come to theses people - especially those from my grandfather's batch +/- a few years..
Outstanding movie. but i felt that Ray was a little confused......probably not able to fathom the new way of living.....dialogues like nesa na nasa etc. But the world has to progress and with any progress we'll have to carry some extra baggage. I felt this way.... probably i'll understand better some day.
Ray's progressiveness need not be confused with the character in the character. In fact, the character indeed is so typical ...of "self made" individuals who has been away from his roots for a best part of his life...a certain mindset / belief system that the develop is quite different from the typical "family man".
this film is SO awesome! it's such a smart script and there's so much depth and wisdom in the dialogue. it feels like a truly mature film, not one that a young man can make.
ki kotha... ki shur aar ki gayoki... couldn't have been done any better... puro ganer ontornihito nirjash jeno beriye ashchey... the song is the king... and nothing else. Kobiguru and Satyajit... Bangla and Bengali's unforgettable gem ever
Each of Ray's films document an entirely different aspect - rural Bengal, detective, contemporary Calcutta, folktales, stories...Each of them is an masterpiece in that genre. Any idea how he rated this film of his ?
darun gaan! ami ekta blog baniechi with rabindrasangeet videos and lyrics IN BENGALI script... link-ta amar profile-e ache... if u guys visit and correct any lyrics errors that will be great... kobiguru rocks :-)
I have a CD of Rano Guhathakurta singing seven of Tagore's songs. His voice is so warmly expressive that it's hard for me now to hear past it. But this is such an evocative rendering of this song by Sromona Sen that it's a true joy to listen to.
Satyajit Ray should have directed singers to sing and publish records of RabindraSangeet. We would have gotten many such gems from not-so-great singers! A genius, as he was, he used to reach to the very core of the songs and was able to bring in the proper "ras" of the song from the singer every time, without fail.
The song is very well sung here, in a movie which may not be nowhere near Satyjit-babu's own extraordinary high standard.
why aren't there any subtitles?
CiscoNast 2 months ago
ashadharon
butunful 11 months ago
Excellent Superb Tanks for sharing. Tagore150yrs
Tagore150yrs 1 year ago
If that is so I'll be honoured as I have faced criticism for having this view.
lahiridilli 1 year ago
Simply awesome, superb!!!
FRS
mayajosna 1 year ago
In the later part of his life Ray probably felt more spiritual- understood those other forces-- probably. This film is entirely different from all other films of his. Each word uttered by Utpal Dutta makes me think whether RAy is asking these questions to himself. Like " Ke debe alo, Ke debe pran" The character's confrontation with the lawyer ( Dhritiman Chattopadhyay) is the essence of the movie. Outstanding.
lahiridilli 1 year ago
Comment removed
Sreejata186 1 year ago
@lahiridilli Was it spiritual or a kind of frustration with the system, that continues to remain stuck up even today...am wondering...spiritualism did not easily come to theses people - especially those from my grandfather's batch +/- a few years..
roganjosh2008 10 months ago
Tagore is a very great poet and composer.
pandulche 1 year ago 3
@pandulche great you understood finally!!!!!! Idiot!
boiragirules 11 months ago
@boiragirules
why don't you go perform autofellatio, you bitch licker?
pandulche 11 months ago
Outstanding movie. but i felt that Ray was a little confused......probably not able to fathom the new way of living.....dialogues like nesa na nasa etc. But the world has to progress and with any progress we'll have to carry some extra baggage. I felt this way.... probably i'll understand better some day.
lahiridilli 1 year ago
Ray's progressiveness need not be confused with the character in the character. In fact, the character indeed is so typical ...of "self made" individuals who has been away from his roots for a best part of his life...a certain mindset / belief system that the develop is quite different from the typical "family man".
Ray was neither.
roganjosh2008 1 year ago
Outstanding song and movie,I've ever seen.
manas8k3 2 years ago 2
this film is SO awesome! it's such a smart script and there's so much depth and wisdom in the dialogue. it feels like a truly mature film, not one that a young man can make.
1yellafella 2 years ago
Oshadharon.....
ki kotha... ki shur aar ki gayoki... couldn't have been done any better... puro ganer ontornihito nirjash jeno beriye ashchey... the song is the king... and nothing else. Kobiguru and Satyajit... Bangla and Bengali's unforgettable gem ever
deshantor 2 years ago
ray is great no doubt....... but aguntuk makes him greater............. this song is fantastic, absolutely wonderful lip by mamata sankar....
iloveche87 2 years ago
AGONTUK ...is very nice film by Satyajeet..
but it seems much more nice in his book " ARO BARO" .there itz called "ATITHI" ...thaks for uploading this nice song =)
nepolini99 2 years ago
wasnt this saong sung by Mamata Shankar herself?
amipothik 3 years ago
As far as my knowledge goes its srimana guhathakurata (playback)
anikbh 3 years ago
It was Sromona Guhathakurta
birajghosh 2 years ago 4
agantuk....to me the best of Ray's films....this song is wonderful...but the dialogues...matchless!
senguptanilanjan 3 years ago 4
Each of Ray's films document an entirely different aspect - rural Bengal, detective, contemporary Calcutta, folktales, stories...Each of them is an masterpiece in that genre. Any idea how he rated this film of his ?
maharshichakrabarti 3 years ago
I believe he did not get much chance.
But this film falls far short in quality than his own extraordinary high standard previous works.
gautamdeusa 3 years ago
i wouldn't say this film fell in quality at all.
kidcaper007 2 years ago 3
Gautam - do you attribute this to his failing health during the make of this movie?
roganjosh2008 1 year ago
darun gaan! ami ekta blog baniechi with rabindrasangeet videos and lyrics IN BENGALI script... link-ta amar profile-e ache... if u guys visit and correct any lyrics errors that will be great... kobiguru rocks :-)
jerkosome 3 years ago
i cudnt find it...pls can u post the link here
horshodg 3 years ago
darun gaan!
jerkosome 3 years ago
Aha..aha...
boiragirules 3 years ago
I have a CD of Rano Guhathakurta singing seven of Tagore's songs. His voice is so warmly expressive that it's hard for me now to hear past it. But this is such an evocative rendering of this song by Sromona Sen that it's a true joy to listen to.
spookysaurus 3 years ago
simply love it,this movie is unique,love this song and love the dance of the santhals
rupluspeaks2u 4 years ago
Satyajit Ray should have directed singers to sing and publish records of RabindraSangeet. We would have gotten many such gems from not-so-great singers! A genius, as he was, he used to reach to the very core of the songs and was able to bring in the proper "ras" of the song from the singer every time, without fail.
The song is very well sung here, in a movie which may not be nowhere near Satyjit-babu's own extraordinary high standard.
gautamdeusa 4 years ago 2
utpal dutta was one of the finest actors .. his performance over a myriad of roles is peerless.
timegone 4 years ago 11
beautiful
kaushikitultulbrahmo 4 years ago
Such a haunting melody... ti seeps rite into ur hrt..
dhutterika 4 years ago 2
Raga Jhinjhoti... but probably the best song ever written based on this raga - by a very young poet and composer!
gautamdeusa 4 years ago 2
Great film
RaviUMIST 4 years ago