Kelly Clarkson - Judas (MY DECEMBER)

[adnilxa]

LOVE THE MY DECEMBER ALBUM!

[adnilxa]

I'm a fan of both Kelly and gaga and listen to them both but I don't even think gaga would say she is as good a singer as Kelly...I've heard them both live...Kelly's voice is just incredible and not matchable but both are talented

[alexpiccirillo1]

OH MY GOD! just cus both gaga's and kelly's song has the same name doesnt mean u have to compare the two! leave gaga out of this! it doesnt make any sense at all to compare these two songs when they're both musically and lyrically different! seriously people -____-

[ladyAlfre]

kelly is better!!!



[raskncd08]

Gaga sucks. Kelly is better and isn't strange. This song came out way before Gaga. I should say GAG *twitches and dies*.

[8128shelby]

NO. GET OFF MY SCREEN ADAM LAMBERT. I'M HERE FOR KELLY.

[PianoChick36]

I love Lady Gaga's Judas, but I totally forgot Kelly was in love with Judas first! 

[Costanzina1997]

THE ORIGINAL JUDAS!

[ThePAPARAZZIGaGa]

JUDAS???? MUSICs kelly clarkson

[101californiachick]

Gaga who?

[THENATETYLER93]

If anything people need to stop comparing this song to Gaga and compare Gaga's to her bc this song was released before Gaga was even famous. This could actually be something that inspired Gaga to write her song.

[1026Monster]

Don't Compare Kelly To Gaga ...I Like Lady Gaga N All ...But ,.. Kelly's Beast! Nuff Said!!

[ThePrincessOfDark87]

in this photo, her face reminds me of hilary duff. am o the only one?

[Megaloprepus8]

Kelly Clarkson's Judas came before Lady Gaga's Judas. Kelly Clarkson is a way better musician than Lady Gaga.

[fullblodet123]

@Megaloprepus8 I definitely agree 

[Darrenc1995]

@Megaloprepus8 Musician? No. Kelly may be a better singer but that's it. Lady Gaga writes and produces her own music and is an accomplished pianist.

[MrSvRVideos]

@Darrenc1995 Sings better thank lady gaga? go see gaga live piano and dancing lol

[MrUniqueunknown]

@Darrenc1995 Good point she is good at piano, but Kelly is not just a singer, she's an actress and she's an amazing songwriter she wrote this song and all of the songs on my December and don't forget behind these hazel eyes and because of you, and she writes music for others such as 1D. but in all honesty both unique and amazing in their own way

[arolax06]

amazing song!

[David1sBored]

I came here to listen to a good song.

And then I looked at the comment section and realised it was full of fucking morons. I'll stick to my iPod next time...

[techslam]

@David1sBored ...no shit...

[xxLOLiHATEjoeJONASxx]

@David1sBored I know, right?

[WhenRomanceEnds]

Still like Gaga's better sorry Kelly ):

[David1sBored]

@WhenRomanceEnds They aren't the same song!!!! Why are you even mentioning Gaga's when it has absolutely nothing to do with Kelly's?? How dumb are you?!?!?

[loghen01]

@WhenRomanceEnds Who cares?

[Selah0412]

ＳＨＵＴ　ＵＰ　ＡＮＤ　ＥＮＪＯＹ　ＴＨＥ　ＭＵＳＩＣ！

[BeautyPrettySociety]

I don't see how people can like Gaga's version.. are we hearing the same song?

[fullblodet123]

@BeautyPrettySociety Yeah, Kelly is muuuch better than Gaga

[R0y4l1ty]

I think that Judas by GaGa is a comment on this song..

[josephdenis204]

who wouldve known that gaga would make a song with the same same 10000000X more known lol

[kittymonsterable]

guys guys guys lady gaga and kelly clarkson are both good singers. so.......stop.

[walkerciaran0602]

Why are people bitching about GaGa? It's the same fucking name, not the song. Jeez.

[MrLozerz]

There total different songs stop compairing lady gaga and kelly clarkson! >.>

[UlquiorraAvarice]

@LadyGagaBigCrowd Gtfo fanatic. Hate people like you that post in every female singer's videos about "GAGA."

[juanxD31]

This song came out first than gaga. Okay maybe the song talks about the same ''betrays'' but please... PLEASE! Stop talking shit, and fighting by SHIT. stupids shit. Is just music ENJOY THAT SHIT! and Shut the fuck up or GET THE FUCK OUT!!!

[S0M3TiiM3S]

@juanxD31 Bless this comment

[juanxD31]

@S0M3TiiM3S Amen.

[runaway817]

So apparently 2 artists can't use the same title? Both songs are about betrayal. It just comes down to which song you like better listening to.

[LadyGagaBigCrowd]

@whorexstudios what does that mean

[Zeidlik1219]

Seeing as the only similarity between Gaga's version and Kelly's version is the title of the song, everyone needs to STFU. If they had sang the same song, yes, I can see there being an argument. Both songs are great in their own regards, so please, stop talking about Gaga's/Kelly's being better. They're too different to compare.

[inesinhaaa7xshadows]

stop talking about gaga --''

i like both but kelly is better in my opinion

so don't talk about gaga here -.-

[CentralPerkHangout]

@inesinhaaa7xshadows GaGa's is better. =-)

[BrasilJaqueline]

JUDAS again?..... Why? The "Hell Boss" needs more midia?

[RoxyIsInYourHouse]

Gaga and Kelly's songs are completely different...how can you compare them at all? They just have the same name. Sorry, but so many artists have the same name as another artist's song. It does not mean they must be compared.

[im3LS3WH3R3]

@RoxyIsInYourHouse An excellent point.

[dimketr]

why this has1119,000 and lady gaga's 59 milions.This is zillion times better

[TheMehMovies]

Seriously, this song sucks so much, Gaga is much better

[EpicHobos]

@TheMehMovies what do you mean? KC dominates gaga a thousand times over!

[TheBrIaNaMusic]

Both songs by Gaga and Kelly are amazing, and after listening to Gaga's I finally understood the meaning of "Judas."

The lyrics in Kelly's even make more sense; without referring to religion.

Gaga was still in love with Judas, Kelly was against him after her realization.

Both are great and I'm with anyone's opinion.

[im3LS3WH3R3]

Went to visit Lady Gaga's "Judas" to see what it was... Oww... I had the volume full blast cuz I was working through my Kelly Clarkson favorites... I muted it.

[wiseguyknowsit]

This was released in 2007. Sorry Gaga fans. Kelly was first.

[kellyqueenofpop]

@wiseguyknowsit lol duhh she came wayy before gag and is wayyy better. :)

[darklee6666]

Qué carajos tiene que ver Gaga con Clarkson... Sólo por el titulo de la cancion? Coño!!! Dejen de fastidiar con eso!!!

[Adolpho78]

i want to listen "because of you", but i still in love with judas, baby;

[zanessa4ever3]

at least this song says something, lady gaga just repeats the same thing over and over

[Nickevolution3000]

This is good, but i like gaga's version more, its deeper. :D

[simsInnovation]

@Nickevolution3000 what version?

[Nickevolution3000]

@simsInnovation HAHAHAHA, sorry, i used the wrong words xD . i like the Judas song from GaGa a lot more. But Kelly is just great, i love her too xD

[Cheer4Savannah]

16 ppl dont know what good music sounds like for shit

[floydfoxxx]

Lady gagas song and kellys are nothin alike I've come across alot of songs that have the same names,..... GAGAS BETTER ;)

[daveed022]

Hmm, alright let me lay this out for everyone...this song was written WAYYYYYY before Lady GaGa was even on the scene, so I just shut everyone up who thought it was a "copy" of GaGa's song or that this was a "test run" song before GaGa released her song. The "My December" album was out YEARS before GaGa released "Born This Way" or any of those songs from her new album, so if anything GaGa took it FROM Kelly Clarkson. So< stupid people who are all about GaGa, I just put you in your place. =)

[Mydogisthecuttest]

why the heck is Miley up next???? >o<*

[bloodofrrreptile]

ok fine i give in, you all haev no idea how the musics industry works, so i will explain for you: they were testing gagaga's song by making kelly release it in this time instead of now, so it is the same song but you are all just too stupid to hear it lolololol

[simsInnovation]

@bloodofrrreptile Gaga didn't exist at the time, and the song was written by Kelly Clarkson, not "people testing gagaga's song", and she wouldn't make a song for a nobody. But if you think that way, than maybe they were also testing Born This Way on Express Yourself of Madonna back in 1989, certantily they were predicting the sucess of a 3 year old Gaga...

[elduendeverde92]

GAGAS JUDAS IS BETTER THAN THIS!

[rafaelvincent17]

@elduendeverde92 OF COURSE IT IS, uhm WHO'S KELLY CLARKSON? ;)

[Sharriska]

I'm here to heal my ears after listening to Gaga's Judas...

[EpicHobos]

@Sharriska you took the words right out of my mouth.

[IdRatherBinADream92]

@Sharriska  haha!

[BenGladuOFFICIAL]

@Sharriska watch it 

[isim3000]

wow... the only artist that didn't copy gaga with style and music....... I <3 gaga & Kelly (but gaga wayyyyyy more lol)

[RudeliciousTV]

@isim3000 umm.. Kelly DID NOT copy Gaga.. Gaga copied Kelly's idea... Kelly's song came out in 2007.

[isim3000]

@RudeliciousTV ur fuckin stupid i said she didn't copied gaga... i just said i like gaga's version more

[RudeliciousTV]

@isim3000 U like "Gaga's Version"??? Version of what??? It's NOT THE SAME SONG! Ignorant cunt!

[tiki8761]

@isim3000 how the hell could she copy gaga if she wasnt famous then

[21ctm21]

Kelly did it first, and Kelly did it better c(=

[fuckingSPARKY]

OMG LOL

there ir no doubt that judas song of kelly was first!!!

when she did this song GAGA didn't exist in the music world

so all i have to say is : LOL :'D

[FreddieGum]

@fuckingSPARKY ERMM she was.. but she wasn't famous yet

[LittleMonster459]

GaGa is better ;))

[WasWasLo]

Voice:Gaga Wins

Talent:Oviously Gaga

[za9427]

@WasWasLo

LOOOL! Good Joke

[BubbleGumDexter23]

Gaga didnt copy you idiots! Gaga's stands for something so much different. The lyrics are very Gaga and this isnt the two songs sound NOTHING alike. Just so happens its the same title and conflict. Duh -_-

[bloodofrrreptile]

@Vividpuppets LOL no

@SasClips hahahahaha nup gaga did it frst

[bloodofrrreptile]

OMG KELLY IS COPYING LADY GAGA

WAT A COW!

[Vividpuppets]

@bloodofrrreptile LOL Kelly was first

[SasClips]

@bloodofrrreptile As you can see, Kelly was earlier. So that horrible Gaga Copied.

[carolinagirl009]

@bloodofrrreptile Um Kelly didn't copy Lady Gaga because first of all Kelly's "Judas" came out four years ago, and just because you use the same song title as another artist doesn't mean you copied that certain artist. And Kelly is not a cow.

[whitelighter15]

@bloodofrrreptile I dont mean to be rude, but pls do some research before you accuse somebody. This song was released in 2007. So, Kelly didnt copy Gaga, and certainly Gaga didnt copy Kelly. It's just that the song title's the same. Totally different song, different melody, different lyrics... how can that be copying? She's not a COW!

[verYCreepyDoll]

@bloodofrrreptile LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOL u idiot actually think gaga was first! LOLOLOL fyi this song was out since 2007

[tarheelterritory06]

Surprise, Surprise seeing Gaga's fans here. Well I'm on this video because I like it a million times better than Gaga's. Her beat is horrid along with her vocals. Kelly is much better!

[awesomeperson981]

@tarheelterritory06 Yes!

[92mydecember92]

ya'll are crazy hating on someone just cause their overrated.well this is entertainment/hollywood/pop culture.people ur not goin to be famous base on your music alone.its the whole package.

[Musicandmovies4life]

@92mydecember92 Well, I don't like Gaga's music or her style. I think her music sounds the same and she is nothing speciel. That's why I think Gaga is overrated! ;P Kelly Clarkson has the best voice in the music industry, she is a great songwriter, she has a great personality etc. ♥ KC is a real artist unlike some others in the industry ;)

[shirusubemonaku]

@Musicandmovies4life too bad no one listens to her anymore, poor kelly LOL

[Musicandmovies4life]

@shirusubemonaku You are so wrong. Kelly has a big fanbase. And you can't compare these two, they are complete different to eachother. Both music and performance is different. I love Kellys music more. And you like Gaga's more. That's OK! But don't come here if you don't like KC. If I don't like a artist, I don't search on them on youtube and write mean things about them. And I'm done with you! :P

[Jennibot]

My December is Kellys BEST album! The songs are amazing! The Lyrics are beautiful.

[92mydecember92]

@Jennibot but her worst selling album ever.she shouldve listened to clive.

[carolinagirl009]

You Gaga fans are nuts. Kelly didn't steal anything and Kelly wrote this song like five years ago so back off.

[shirusubemonaku]

WHO THE FUCK IS KELLY CLARKSON? THATS NOT GAGA'S VOICE!

[Musicandmovies4life]

@shirusubemonaku Kelly Clarkson is the best singer in the world ♥ And keep in mind that there is songs with the same name out there! ;)

[carolinagirl009]

@shirusubemonaku Yeah like you don't know who Kelly Clarkson is. Everybody has at least heard of Kelly one time in the past nine years.

[shirusubemonaku]

@carolinagirl009 maybe?? some fat-arse from either american idol or britain's got talent or whatever shit, i suppose

[carolinagirl009]

@shirusubemonaku Kelly is not some fat ass.

[supercalzfm]

@shirusubemonaku You are retarded for not knowing who she is.

[kcROCKShard]

@shirusubemonaku Thank God it's not Gaga's voice, why ruin a good song.

[shirusubemonaku]

@kcROCKShard if this were gaga's voice, thise video would have at least 30 mil views, not the pathetic 100 000 views lol

[Musicandmovies4life]

@shirusubemonaku Gaga is so overrated :P And why are you here if you don't like KC? Don't waste you time here, if you don't like her. Search on Gaga on Youtube instead of writing comments about something you don't like!

[carolinagirl009]

@shirusubemonaku Hardy, har, har you're so funny...not. Gaga is overrated and I'll take Kelly over Lady Gaga any day.

[Musicandmovies4life]

@kcROCKShard I agree with you! :) Don't like Gaga at all :P

[farmgirlnicole]

nothing like the lady gaga one, people settle down

[Noepopstar]

LADY GAGA FANS, get out of here .. THIS IS REAL MUSIC!!!!

[solangesand]

for people saying lady gaga stole kelly clarkson song just because it had the same name consider this : My December was the name of a linkin park song long before this album came out.

[DevoutMusician]

Like this if Lady GaGa's similar song title brought you here. (:

[7ABIBIintaalbi]

ok this song and lady gaga's song are nothing alike

just because they have the same name

~omg!!1111!!!!1111!!!!one they are the same, gaga stole from you"

lol, calm down

[nick20311]

i dont really think gaga stole kellys song. i love them both. they are both amazing singers. there have been alot of songs with the same names. (:

[peacencarrots]

@nick20311 based on the same religious idea :/

[shirusubemonaku]

FUCK! that's not Lady Gaga's voice!!!!!!!

[jazzymcjazzster]

Dear Kelly, someone by the name of gaga stole your song. Just so you know.

[peacencarrots]

this is better than lady gaga.

[HannahJayneDee]

@peacencarrots

[EGZOZIT]

@peacencarrots

she is much more better than Lady Gaga!!=D

[EGZOZIT]

@peacencarrots

she's much more better than Lady Gaga:D

[CloakedDeception]

@peacencarrots So so so much better :-)

[DexterGenial46]

La gente estúpida comenzará a comparar esta canción que tiene un gran significado (habla de la traición) con la nueva "canción" de Lady Gaga ._.

So sad....

[Noepopstar]

@DexterGenial46 tienes razon! D: estupidos fans de Lady gaga

[bu11com]

Jesus is my virtue!

Judas is who i cling to!

Judas-gagagagagagagaag

[nisper]

Jesus is my virtue, but judas is the demon I cling to

[NathanxNeon]

I'M JUST A HOLY FOOL OH BABY HE'S SO CRUEL. I'M STILL IN LOVE WITH JUDAS, BABY.

[thelostinwonderland1]

that pic is epic

[DrMattDestruction]

this song has something in common with these songs :

placebo - this picture

miley cyrus - start all over

david usher - ugly is beautiful

what is it?

[LoboAscuridad]

@DrMattDestruction The common thing is that it has nothing in common.

[DrMattDestruction]

@LoboAscuridad no. they all have that 3 note beat. dun dun dun. dun dun dun. dun dun dun.

[LoboAscuridad]

@DrMattDestruction Oh wow I can't believe I didn't notice that lol.

[takad0]

I looooooooooooooove this song!!(: Kelly clarkson is my #1

When gaga's "Judas" comes out, hopefully this will get a little more popularity!!! :D

[AaronRBB11]

it is actually a great album. I have all her albums and this is one of her best! Breakaway, All I Ever Wanted, My December then Thankful! Still I recommend getting all of them!

[dimketr]

i just love this song

[Saryn88]

Gosh I am freaking in love with this song

[kc1rock]

what a great "fuck you" song. i love this girl.

[chocalietje]

You know what?

I think those Twilight fans will seriously try to make even this song about them.

It's so freakin annoying.

Kelly is the best!

[jmfrench76]

i like this song, but what is Judas???? that's never even metioned in the song!!!!!!

[addicted2kelly19]

@jmfrench76 Judas is like betrayal/Traitor.... it comes from the biblical times

[Stevie061089]

@jmfrench76 judas screwed over jesus, and she got screwed over by a guy, and sometimes people refer to others as judas when they've backstabbed them in some way or another.

[vampiress222]

I LOVED "My December". I have no idea why it didn't do that well.

[HaleyDewit]

love the pic,love the song,love her!!!!

[MelGemmaRichardson]

Yep, I've had someone betray me too. I love this song. And I've got two copies of this album, I like it better then her 'All I ever wanted' album actually

[joeldavid90]

Jesus had a group of men who He really trusted in, and Judas was one of them, He was like a brother for Jesus; but after all of Jesus love for him, Judas betrayed Him and just turned around.. Yeah, it's in the Bible and that's what the song is about, it's not about any brother in the world..

[jazzymcjazzster]

@joeldavid90 Reminds me of Jesus christ superstar lol I love that musical! :)

[Stefany3Garcia]

I dedicate this song to my older brother. After our only other brother was murdered at 16 years old, he has just been so cold with me. I'm his sister/brother cause I'm girly but at the same time tough. He has let down a lot these past years and he betrays me a lot also :(

I love how Kelly connects with her fans and doesn't just do whatever they tell her to

[JeannetheMCRfan]

This song is so sad, but beautiful <3

I love love My december because it's so personal and .. well sad.

I can't describe how much i love Kelly for fighting to release the album! She knew that it woulden't sell as much as Breakaway, but still she made it :) No singers do that! Kelly is more than nice to us fans :]

Does anyone know why she doesn't sing this song live? And haunted? I really want to know, i haven't heard her talk about it. I love that she sings maybe though! (; <3

[junkybox]

heard this song in a shop today... it suddenly sounded all awesome again... :)

[Suitelife210]

I can so relate to this song. Love it.

[studdley84]

absolutely amazing. Love everything she does

[BecomingJane1010]

Amaazing song!!!!

[crazycrazydancersss]

Judas, Hole, Haunted, Never Again, Maybe, Irvine & Chivas. These songs tell exactly the situation I'm in

[BelleFlower15]

@crazycrazydancersss Chivas is the bomb. So blunt and honest and just perfect.

[ZacGladiator]

Judas, Maybe, Sober - my favourites song from this album

[sacera101]

I don't know what it is about Kelly. I've always loved her music and voice, and even people that aren't inot the pop/rock kind of music and stuff, her voice is just undeniable. You have to like it, if not love it! And her personality, a chill down to eart , kind of like me, is cool too! She's relatable. And I like that. I'm a lyrics kind of girl so thoug her voice and rythm is a deifnite bonus, her lyrics speak more for me. Anyone, girls especially, can relate to her lyrics, which is awesome!

[sacera101]

I just learned the story behind this song. About Jesus and how he was betrayed by Judas. And the other story about Kelly and her dick of a bf who used her for fame and then dumped her for an ex girlfriend. I would pretty pissed too. And the fact that they almost deleted this album b/c it was "too negative" and dark. Whatever. It kicks ass and it's real. Poor kelly. Her life really sucked at this time. She was so angry and hurt and needed to speak out. She needed to lash out. I would do the same

[FFslut]

so do you mean graham colton cheated on her??

if it's true then i was right.. no wonder graham colton is not famous. i wish his career will go down.

[sacera101]

Not him exactly. Lol. It was another dude. David Hodges of the band Trading Yesterday. He cheated on her and then dumped her for his ex and ran off and married her instead. Behind These Hazel Eyes was inspired by him...

[FFslut]

so do u know about graham colton? why they broke up...and which one she date first?

[KellyKrazy95]

As well as 'Never Again'

[sacera101]

No. Colton didnt cheat on her. He really cared about her. It really was the hodges dude. He cheated on her for almost all of thier relationship then married his x gf. Graham and Kelly broke up b/c they never saw each other. They still remain friends I guess...not sure where they stand today thugh....