Added: 3 years ago
From: remixxatstage
Views: 42,081
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (115)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This kicks ass for generation I like it!

  • Love SHANIA's version! ~ let's appreciate what we can get since all of Cher's versions were unable to be heard because of... ????  LOVE both of these very talented ladies!

  • Mutt said that she caught Shania Twain in bed with Cher and The entire 2008 Harlem Globetrotters basketball team taking turns with Chers 14 inch John Holmes double headed vibrating dildo.

  • Shania does her own songs well.... but she should have left this to Cher who clearly has the strongerst version.... and a way stronger voice. This is so forgetable.

  • @windsong1a I think she did it better..

  • @railroadlover .....It's a free country and you are entitled to your opinion. Have you ever heard Cher do

    Half Breed?.... Cher does it waaaay better. But Shania does her own songs very well.

  • @windsong1a I have heard her sing it.

  • i think this verson is for people who like a bit more rock music while Cher's verson is a bit more pop. i like this one more

  • Great cover :)

  • Cher is so much better!!!

    Cher is the only half breed!!!

    Love you CHER! <3

  • i guess i like both but cher better

  • she should not half touched this. :O omfg!

  • so easy to tear a man (or woman) down..but to build someone up..it takes a REAL man ! that's what's wrong with people today they don't brag on their friends or other people it's me.me.me.well if you'd try to build someone else up for a change i gaurantee somebody would reconize it and say that is somebody special.a real true person, he can do this,or that.back to Shania..She's good, I like Cher, but I don't judge,i'll just go to her page..you should go to a whatever the fuck page.ya know.peace

  • half breed what..... DOG

    she was married to a MUTT

  • shania is a half breed ...

  • @playwitFiire no shes not

  • @shaniaisgod  yeah she is.. why would she even bother with this song if she wasnt.. her real dad was part Cree

  • @playwitFiire not Cree but an Ojibwa

  • Lol yeah she is  Fuck yur dumb

  • Comment removed

  • @RedZoneJuJu do u just stalk all the people commenting to prove your right.. when really you are talking for nothing because you are wrong.. her biological father was part Cree.. so yes that makes her a half breed... n its dumb not dumd lmao... i wont respond to a fool like yourself again.

  • One of the best ways to pay tribute to an artist or a song is to cover one of the songs by that artist.

  • *paused* I refuse to listen to this. Fuckers disabled the audio on the original Cher vidz...

  • There is a reason why CHER has been in the public eye for over 4 decades!! She is a great rounded performer!!

  • Cher does it better!

  • i love shania twain..i have since iwas a kid..an she deff screwed this song up!!!!

  • Shania grew up on a rez in Canada.

  • for some reason i think this is tanya tucker... not shania.

  • Just not a strong enough voice to carry this song off.

  • to all the haters this isnt a contest on shania vs cher

  • Now this is just an Opinion but i've listened to both versions of the song "Cher&Shania" but i honestly like this one more then Cher even if she made the song and made it popular and shes huge with music her voice made me gag not that shanias doesnt sometimes but yeah thats just my opinion on both song versions No offence to Cher fans "which there appears to be alot of them"

  • I'm not dissing shanaia...she's a good singer...for her own songs...cher made this song famous and is the voice of it...

  • booooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooo=-(

  • I love Shania, but this song is totally Cher.

  • @boolmh

    I wouldn't buy it! It pales in comparison to the original. There are some songs that should be "sacred", and thus "blasphemous" to cover. Half-Breed is such a song. It is, and always will be, CHER!!!!!!!

  • I did not think any one could redo this song but Shania proved she could do it her way and I love Cher

  • This is an outrage! Cher is sooo much better!!!!

  • to all the haters this isnt a contest on shania vs cher. shania sang it in 1989 - get over it! sounds better then you wouldve done?

  • Shania Twain is a "half-breed" as well. Maybe it's just me, but DAMN these so-called "half-breeds" are DAMN fine!!!

  • Comment removed

  • @RedZoneJuJu actually she has some native.Her stepfather was native

  • Comment removed

  • Ohhh she sings it well, but its true this song will never be sung better then when cher sings it :')

  • It's true that Cher sings is better...

    But Shania is also good :)

    Not as good of course, but still... Good.

  • wow this song is great!!!! shania is fantastic i locve shania...

  • In the early 1970's, there was a BIG push and resurgence in Native American culture, both in pop culture and in political activism.

    Paul Revere & Raiders with "Cherokee People" song. #1 for 3 weeks in 1971.

    The popular "Don't Litter" TV commercials featuring a crying, full-blooded Apache. 1973-1976

    Ed Ames (a Jewish actor who everyone thought was Native American) "Who Will Answer?"

    Leonard Peltier's last stand in North Dakota in 1972 (full-blooded Chippewa, real-life bloodshed.)

  • Shania has a good voice, but this song just doesn't sound right without Cher's voice, smooth and deep as 40 yr bourbon.

  • I love this song, and Chr was the best..No offence to Shania!! I still love her too!!

    But I have to ask, is it just me or does Shania sound different in this video?

  • Wish there was a picture of Shania to look at while I listen to her singing. She turns me on big time.

  • everyone glorifies being half aboriginal, but but like the song it was a curse for me

  • I like Shania, but nothing will ever compare to Cher's version. Cher has been there since I was a little girl and her songs bring back such good and bad memories for me, guess thats why her music is so powerful! Can take you back in time, like any good artist!

  • @cupidandcuddles ummm Shanias version was better!!!!!!! and she can sang her butt off!!!!

  • Are you an idiot or just retarded?

    Cher can out sing "Shania" any day.

  • Not as good as Cher's, but Shania definitely has a closer relation to it since she was close to her stepfather.

  • this version is way better than the original... the words are explicit and it was sang straight and sharp....another thing is the factor that it rocks...this would have made it in 80's if only Shania oficially accepted the rock offer of her career.....this version would have been a hit like the hit songs of Heart, Roxette,Def Leppard and other late 80's rock song.Shania outsold Cher, with just 4 albums made..imagine that!!!!Her Come on over album is the best selling album by a female solo artist

  • Hate this version. Cher is of course better. You can tell Cher was mixed with NA look at her features and that hair, loved her hair. LMAO @ ioport, that was funny.

  • Does anyone knows what cher´s mom s name is??

  • Georgia

  • last name??

  • Holt

  • I think this version is 10X better. And tho she isn't physically half Indian her adoptive father was a full-blooded Indian. But I think she sang it just because it's a good song.

  • Cher wasn't half breed either. She was half Armenian, and she claimed her blond blue eyed Marilyn Monroe like mother was indian. Right.

  • hey you cant say that i have both cherokee and aboriginal blood on my dads side (cherokee in his mothers and aboriginal in his dads) and i have blonde hair blue eyes and am pale because of my german blood but i also tan quite darkly and never burn... cher's mum also has german in her ....you cant just assume you know what your talking about!!

  • there are people who are part native and have blond hair and blue eyes...it's all in the genes.

  • I know. But what I am saying is I dont believe Shania is part Indian. I believe her STEPFATHER was. Cher is also not one hundred percent truthful when she says she is half, as she has admitted. Cher is more like one quarter IF that. Cher is half armenian and looks like she is half cherokee so she capitalized on it. She admitted it. Also, I took many genetics courses in biology etc, so yes I know all about genetics. Im talking about the truth and statements made and how they are stretched.

  • yap you're right her stepfather is Ojibwa indian if i'm not wrong...i don't know if she ever claimed that she has some native heritage.

    she just took the name-Shania,means light( i'm not sure i'm that's the right meaning:)),and maybe she just fell in love with the native culture...who knows.

    Cher is actually 1/8 Cherokee or even less but i think her Armanien half had more to do with her looks.she still rocks and is a living legend.

    well i think everybody would like to be native this days.

  • What fucking right does this white bitch have singing this?

  • Her father was Cree

  • Yeah, yeah, one of those "my father was 1/16th Native American" deals

  • This version sucks!

  • it rocks!!!!!! it sounds similar to the rock band in 80's like Roxette, heart, and def Lepard....She sings country, and she can rock also... But cher can't....hehehehehe.........

  • Cher sings a multitude of genres. Ever watched the Cher show and Sonny and Cher clips on here? Even back then she sang half the songs ever written on those shows.

  • there is some roll mixed into Cher's Rock. Add add it to Rock you get Rock and Roll. Cher has an intense beautiful voice and will rock forever

  • My moms half indian / half white but she's never complained.

    i know being a quarter is awesome, tho. I'm just like a white person with really high cheekbones and a shitload of scholarships.

  • ha ha ha its like that here in australia with the aboriginal blood i have both aboriginal and cherokee blood but im white with blonde hair and blue eyes (german side) and i tan incredibly well nuthing like being a blonde that can tan well in summer lol

  • Comment removed

  • The music is great... but Cher's vocals are better.

  • i am Native American,and European. So I guess I am a half breed

  • You cant even spell Armenian.

  • um why is shania twain doing this song? because cher created it.

  • people do covers of songs you know.

  • cher is greatt

  • she sounds really nice, makes me want the album !

  • I like Shania Twain, but it is very hard to comete with Cher's version. Cher's voice is much more powerful and well suited for the song...but Shania is a great singer.

  • i loved hearing Cher singing this song, and it is so true, this happened so much to my people. ='( wish i could rewrite history and change that, but for some reason the Great Spirit let it happen, I have yet to know what reason that is ='(

  • Hah, nice try Father O'Reilly, go diddle some more kids and respect my beliefs and ill respect yours

  • what a way to stain the name of christans.

    be respectful of others ideals.

  • You know i am a christian, and guess what, with talk like that you aint one. Native american religion is much more spiritual and comited than christianity. And im sure god is more wili to let them into his kingdom in the after life than any christian.

  • he is willing to let any one in his kingdom that seeks to please him. i seek to please him. any Christian that seeks to please him will, also.

  • you're an idiot. everyone has their own religion, don't have to be a racist cunt about it.

  • WHAT HAPPENED TO MY PEOPLE?!?!! LOOK IN YOUR HISTORY BOOKS, LOOK AT WHAT YOU WHITES DID TO MY PEOPLE, YOU TOOK OUR LAND, RAPPED OUR WOMAN AND KILLED OUR CHILDREN. If it was possible I'd ripe the white part of me out and be a pure Indian. I know who the Great Spirit is, thank you very much. It's you whites that call him Jesus, MY people call him by a different name, it doesnt mean we think him to be someone else. I do not appriciate your racists comment at all!!!!!

  • ^rip

  • my granpa was half native american, and i have a deep respect for them. I find what happened to NA to be the most terrible thing to ever happen. ur people and culture were almost wiped out.

  • i have read your comments and i must say, thank you. you have stood up for my people better than many do. my people are still strong, just not as we used to be. but again thank you for standing up for us, it is well thanked!

  • Wow! I love this song. Great music!

  • Shania u r alryt i spose buh cher juss rocks it in the original!!!

  • How could you spell original right but struggle with alright?

  • cher sounds like a man lease Shania Twain sounds like a hot women not like a cat in heat cher is a horrible singer

  • Cher is a horrible singer, yeah right. And btw Cher made Half Breed popular because it is a original not a COVER. And if Cher would be a horrible singer than she wouldnt be one of most recognized woman because of her voice, Shania Twain has a voice thats whatever Cher has a voice that not every woman can say they have it. Tina Turner and Mariah Carey are a exaomple of Chers voice. Shania cover is good. But Chers is way better. Btw CHER is a way bigger icon in music than Shania

  • Shania is the 10th best selling female artist of all time,,,Her album "Come on over" sold 39milion copies making it the best selling album by a female solo artist of all time...her album "the woman in me",and "Up", sold 19 million and 16 million copies respectively...She is the female artist who made the most ''diamond album'' in the history...She only released 4 albums and yet it made her so huge....however, Cher is not in the list of top15 best selling female artist.maybe she's at #16 and up

  • @cherlover124 i dont think shania was trying to compete.

  • @cherlover124 Thank you! Finally someone that says even tho This will always be Cher's Song. Shania didnt do bad and she is overall a good artist in her own right! THANK YOU, Thumbs up for you!

  • no cher does sound like a women, ur just used to hearing young girls. she sounds like she dfoes cuz she is a women not a girl. listen to her younger concerts and you can tell a difference

  • I love it!

  • NO! Shania Twain does it great!!! Shania!!!!♥♥♥♥

  • wow no your amazing & everything

    but no stick with man i feel like a woman & gonna getcha good, leave this song to the legend who sang it CHER is the fucking queen of all female singers <333

  • i miss shania's voice.

  • DAMN! You go girl! I love Cher..but Shania does a great job..

  • I don't want to compare Cher's performance. Way to go Shania!

  • Hmmm....Yeahhh Shania Did It Okay I Guess, Cher Is Defo The BEST

  • The original is by Cher..THE QUEEN OF MUSIC! Shania did a good cover but it can't be compared with the original!!

    CHER IS THE BEST!!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more