@sdmitch16 My demand was that non-English dubs be LABELLED AS SUCH. Don't make a weasel argument that I demanded censorship of non-english dubs, that is deceptive on your part.
Respect for the original dub is a mere request. You can handle that? A request to preserve the artist's original intent of a work?
@Treblaine I don't see how respect for Japanese anime means English dubs should be labeled. I don't see how respect a show means dubs in a different language should be labeled.
@sdmitch16 It's supposed to help you realise the principal that I prefer the original for genuine artistic reasons, not some kind of English-Language imperialism.
This video is in no what identified by non-original dubs in the title, description or tags. So my recommendation feed is full of clips like these, with the butchered non-original dubbing.
@Treblaine You prefer the original. Some people prefer live action t.v. Neither of those people belong here.
Respecting the original doesn't mean everything else has to be labeled as such. If it were, and someone respect two things, everything, including the respected things would have to be labeled.
Preference for live action TV is completely irrelevant as it is obvious before you click through this is NOT live action. Yes, everything SHOULD be properly labelled, originals and non-original dubs. So I know to avoid the poor dubs. This show lives or dies on the original voice actors and the foreign dubs almost universally don't live up to that standard.
@Treblaine You said "the same should be extended to American cartoons". Just because you respect the original doesn't mean original voices should be respected. That'd be like the art community saying "we respect Picasso, therefore everyone else should, too" or saying people 'should' respect modern art just cause they do. The art community does that and people hate them because the art community acts and talks like its better than everyone else. This also applies to opera.
@sdmitch16 yes! The director of this episode had a vision with a certain voice acting performance that the dub completely fails to capture even fully understanding Italian.
@Treblaine So you believe that original voice acting should be respect for being original. You can respect original voicing, but can't say that it should be respect just for being original. That's like an art culture type saying people should respect art because it came from the artist soul or because it came from the artist soul and he was troubled.
Just because you respect a trait doesn't mean everyone should.
@Treblaine and I can reply to that whatever I like.
I actually believe dubs should be labeled, but to make it easier to sort through videos and improve efficiency, not because the original is respected. There are people who don't respect animation, so using your values animation dubs wouldn't get labels.
@Treblaine But what about things that aren't respectable? Should be with different poor taste or trying out something different have to waste their time?
@Treblaine The artist's original intent of a work?
We're not talking about random people doing voiceovers, we're talking about professional actors doing stuff for television broadcast, approved by the author himself
Yes, but if you're going to post a video of a TV-show that is originally in English, you could at least put a little note in your title saying this clip is not.
this is italian not spanish or other languages....
MrSpammo 2 months ago
THE INTERNET WAS INVENTED BY ENGLISH PEOPLE, LEARN IT
LongClawzHidden 3 months ago
@LongClawzHidden HTML was invented by Swiss people.
icovada 3 months ago
@icovada and the computer by the germans. so americans have really no reason to complain :)
BigAl2207 2 months ago
This video sucks. I speak America.
finzfan92 3 months ago
Ahahah... American nationalism at its finest.
Wait what was that ? USA USA USA ! You guys are hilarious xD
NienteFantasia 4 months ago 10
@NienteFantasia Yeah I agree with you my also foriegn brother I hate the estupid americans! Them and their pride! -_-
lastEvergreen 1 month ago
Those two who were arguing are sad. . . And should respect me!
TheViper3D 4 months ago
the internet is in english
TheEruIluvatar 4 months ago
If the video is going to be in Fucking SPANISH, then make the fucking TITTLE IN SPANISH for the rest of the 90% of people who speak english!!!!!!
Chasemeister101 4 months ago
@Chasemeister101 its italian genius. Maybe you should spend less time in youtube and more time looking this stuff up
Doctor4077 4 months ago
well,i can understand a bit,because its kinda similar to my language,spanish
freedomphamtom1 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
FUCK YOU, THE INTERNET IS IN ENGLISH!
Phelan666 5 months ago 32
@Phelan666 oh, come on. why dont you learn italian ? I learnt english. (just a little bit, ok)
ObiwaNNNNNNNNNNNNN 5 months ago
@ObiwaNNNNNNNNNNNNN You know, if you had the title in Italian then you wouldn't draw so many English speakers who then get disappointed.
Futurama was originally done in English. I respect Japanese anime and it's original dub, the same should be extended to American cartoons.
Treblaine 4 months ago
@Treblaine You can respect as you will, but that doesn't give you the right to demand that American cartoons only be in English.
sdmitch16 4 months ago
@sdmitch16 My demand was that non-English dubs be LABELLED AS SUCH. Don't make a weasel argument that I demanded censorship of non-english dubs, that is deceptive on your part.
Respect for the original dub is a mere request. You can handle that? A request to preserve the artist's original intent of a work?
Treblaine 4 months ago 6
@Treblaine I don't see how respect for Japanese anime means English dubs should be labeled. I don't see how respect a show means dubs in a different language should be labeled.
sdmitch16 4 months ago
@sdmitch16 It's supposed to help you realise the principal that I prefer the original for genuine artistic reasons, not some kind of English-Language imperialism.
This video is in no what identified by non-original dubs in the title, description or tags. So my recommendation feed is full of clips like these, with the butchered non-original dubbing.
Treblaine 4 months ago
@Treblaine You prefer the original. Some people prefer live action t.v. Neither of those people belong here.
Respecting the original doesn't mean everything else has to be labeled as such. If it were, and someone respect two things, everything, including the respected things would have to be labeled.
sdmitch16 4 months ago
@sdmitch16 Don't be pedantic
Preference for live action TV is completely irrelevant as it is obvious before you click through this is NOT live action. Yes, everything SHOULD be properly labelled, originals and non-original dubs. So I know to avoid the poor dubs. This show lives or dies on the original voice actors and the foreign dubs almost universally don't live up to that standard.
Treblaine 4 months ago
@Treblaine You said "the same should be extended to American cartoons". Just because you respect the original doesn't mean original voices should be respected. That'd be like the art community saying "we respect Picasso, therefore everyone else should, too" or saying people 'should' respect modern art just cause they do. The art community does that and people hate them because the art community acts and talks like its better than everyone else. This also applies to opera.
sdmitch16 4 months ago
@sdmitch16
I'm not saying "respect this JUST because I respect this" I'm saying "respect this for what it is"
Every single one of your posts you have just completely made shit up.
Treblaine 4 months ago
@Treblaine Respect things for what it is? What about things that suck? Did you mean respect original voice acting for being original voice acting?
sdmitch16 4 months ago
@sdmitch16 yes! The director of this episode had a vision with a certain voice acting performance that the dub completely fails to capture even fully understanding Italian.
Treblaine 4 months ago
@Treblaine So you believe that original voice acting should be respect for being original. You can respect original voicing, but can't say that it should be respect just for being original. That's like an art culture type saying people should respect art because it came from the artist soul or because it came from the artist soul and he was troubled.
Just because you respect a trait doesn't mean everyone should.
sdmitch16 4 months ago
@sdmitch16 It's a waste of time arguing with anti-intellectual philistine who rants with "That's like an art culture type"
PS: I can say whatever I like should be respected. First Amendment of US Constitution, look it up.
Treblaine 4 months ago
@Treblaine and I can reply to that whatever I like.
I actually believe dubs should be labeled, but to make it easier to sort through videos and improve efficiency, not because the original is respected. There are people who don't respect animation, so using your values animation dubs wouldn't get labels.
sdmitch16 4 months ago
@sdmitch16 good, dubs should be labelled, we in agreement!
Treblaine 4 months ago
@Treblaine But what about things that aren't respectable? Should be with different poor taste or trying out something different have to waste their time?
sdmitch16 4 months ago
@Treblaine The artist's original intent of a work?
We're not talking about random people doing voiceovers, we're talking about professional actors doing stuff for television broadcast, approved by the author himself
icovada 2 months ago
@Phelan666 no, fuck YOU the internet is international!
Uneducated morons!
JRMtruelover 3 months ago
@JRMtruelover The internet may be international, but apparently sarcasm is not.
Phelan666 3 months ago
@Phelan666 laugh can be heard through every country and language.
PLUS sarcasm and comedy was born and developed in Greece.
So, should I start cursing out every American comedy show?
JRMtruelover 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@JRMtruelover "...sarcasm and comedy was born and developed in Greece."
Congratulations, you have successfully uttered one of the most dim-witted and uninformed statements in all of history. Well done.
Phelan666 3 months ago
Yes, but if you're going to post a video of a TV-show that is originally in English, you could at least put a little note in your title saying this clip is not.
Rymdpandan 3 months ago
@Phelan666 I forgot spanish used internet, and chineese, and well ALL OTHER LANGUAGES! FUCK YOU
xXCrwlrXx 3 months ago
@Phelan666 as you could see in this video, it actually is not! (i couldn't understand it as well, but I just clicked at a version i could)
FreaQU 3 months ago
Riiiiiiight.
iCornyJoke 7 months ago