Boy, I sure am glad this hack Hitchcock once lived. Otherwise, I probably would have never heard of TheCastorTroy, who is indubitably one of the great artists of the 21st Century.
For a 1942 movie it was good considering the standard cheesiness of films then.
The story has particular relevence. Recall the real life plot to overthrow Roosevelt in the 1930's and install a dicatatorship in the US that was funded by wealthy industrialists like in the movie.
Sadly that real life attempted right-wing coup has fallen down the memory hole even deeper than this movie.
I actually just saw that on TCM today and couldn't believe that was the ending. I just sat there staring dumbfounded at the screen. The scene works until the lame fall and abrupt fade to black.
This was such a good ending, he did it all over again 17 years later in North by Northwest. The composition of the shots in this scene is stunning. It makes the end of X-Men look like crap.
The ending could possibly have been put down to Hitchcock's decidedly English sense of fairplay - unlike Americans, us English like to see a chap get a fair chance you know.
It's obvious that Cummings needs the bad guy to clear his own name without dispute--plus, a ket saboteur would be a million times more valuable to the United States alive as an informer, not dead! And one more thing--it's NOT illogical to try to grab the guy's sleeve-it's made crystal clear(to me anyway) that if Fry lifts his gripping fingers one inch, he'll fall instantly. Cummings is also shown trying to save Fry's life to emphasize HIS humanity and basic decency.
-indeed the evil guy expects to be shot by him and then falls.
-Maybe in many films you have seen...He grabs the jacket sleeve because that can help without interrupting the grasp of hands on Lyberty surface. Three points are better than two.
Would you grab your enemy's hand in that circustance?
I liked this movie, but the end is ridiculous. Sure, he wanted to grab the guy who tried to kill him SO HE COULD BE JAILED AND PUTTED IN TRIAL, but the way that the movie ends, I couldn´t even believe that movie ended... (((
I was thinking music would be a good cue for the audience help nudge them into feeling what you want, but a lack of music can have a profound effect too. I think seeing it on YouTube and not in a theatre full off other people in the dark makes it so different. It's just quiet, instead of "hushed" and silent darkness.
Ah, c'mon, Castor! Hitch loved the illogical, it's one of the most entertaining moments (and films) in film history. He does make it clear witht he line "I'll clear ya...." You wanta great laugh, watch the Coen Brothers spoof this scene in "Hudsucker Proxy"
Boy, I sure am glad this hack Hitchcock once lived. Otherwise, I probably would have never heard of TheCastorTroy, who is indubitably one of the great artists of the 21st Century.
Cinema320 2 years ago
KHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAN!!!!!!!!!!! KHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAN!!!!!!!!!! LOL! (robot chicken episode)
visoredbhsgirl13 2 years ago
k, at 1st, he points a gun at him, and then he tries to save him from falling... w-t-f...
visoredbhsgirl13 2 years ago
2:17 - 2:21
he does look like gollum
shrigglemictiggles92 2 years ago
This criticism total crap. That ending was great.
"Lets save the guy who originally wanted to kill me! "
This attitude says volumes about the cultural differences between and then now. God help us!
tpellman 2 years ago 2
WTF is exactly what i thought when i saw this part of the film.
MrAppleby56 2 years ago
Sounds like he was yelling "GAAAAAAAAAAAYYYY" again... :/
mmtigan 2 years ago
yes it sounds like gaaaayyyyyyy :D
LiLStyle313 2 years ago
Play 2:17 - 2:21 It's Gollum!
john0174 2 years ago
For a 1942 movie it was good considering the standard cheesiness of films then.
The story has particular relevence. Recall the real life plot to overthrow Roosevelt in the 1930's and install a dicatatorship in the US that was funded by wealthy industrialists like in the movie.
Sadly that real life attempted right-wing coup has fallen down the memory hole even deeper than this movie.
Navywxman 2 years ago
I actually just saw that on TCM today and couldn't believe that was the ending. I just sat there staring dumbfounded at the screen. The scene works until the lame fall and abrupt fade to black.
theSuperMetroid 2 years ago
Norman Lloyd, incidentally, became HItch's associate producer on his weekly TV anthology series in the late '50s...
fromthesidelines 2 years ago
This was such a good ending, he did it all over again 17 years later in North by Northwest. The composition of the shots in this scene is stunning. It makes the end of X-Men look like crap.
milou66 2 years ago 3
of course he grabbed his sleeve. did you see his grip? grabbing at his hand would have dislodged him instantly.
milou66 2 years ago
for the age the movie was shot, that fall was awesome!
Lechoni21 3 years ago
Should have gone to the tailors...dammit!!
Air0h3adsoftware 3 years ago
The ending could possibly have been put down to Hitchcock's decidedly English sense of fairplay - unlike Americans, us English like to see a chap get a fair chance you know.
abigmuff 3 years ago 3
At least the special effects were good, given the technology they had bck then.
Scrapheap71 3 years ago
of course, grabbing his hand would be completely STUPID.
MyNameIsNotHereNow 3 years ago
wtf why he sounds like GGGgggaaaayyyyyyyyyy.... or something.
P0rKK4na 3 years ago
I love watching characters fall to their deaths in Hitchcock films, they're always great
ali711arab 3 years ago 4
The point is that Nazis saboteurs wear cheap suits.
poetcomic1 3 years ago 2
It's obvious that Cummings needs the bad guy to clear his own name without dispute--plus, a ket saboteur would be a million times more valuable to the United States alive as an informer, not dead! And one more thing--it's NOT illogical to try to grab the guy's sleeve-it's made crystal clear(to me anyway) that if Fry lifts his gripping fingers one inch, he'll fall instantly. Cummings is also shown trying to save Fry's life to emphasize HIS humanity and basic decency.
blackwingy 3 years ago 3
-indeed the evil guy expects to be shot by him and then falls.
-Maybe in many films you have seen...He grabs the jacket sleeve because that can help without interrupting the grasp of hands on Lyberty surface. Three points are better than two.
Would you grab your enemy's hand in that circustance?
assandthem 3 years ago
I liked this movie, but the end is ridiculous. Sure, he wanted to grab the guy who tried to kill him SO HE COULD BE JAILED AND PUTTED IN TRIAL, but the way that the movie ends, I couldn´t even believe that movie ended... (((
Swordman85 3 years ago
...Is it just me or does it look like he can just slide down her arm then climb up her head. Then it looks like he can just sit there.
I hate having to disregaurd my reality to watch this.
stinkomanfan 3 years ago
I think it's actually pretty dang cool, anything involving Lady Liberty is interesting to me, and for the time, the effects are pretty decent!
JohnnySwitchblade 3 years ago 2
SMOKE WEED EVERYDAY
DEACONAP4LOVE 3 years ago
The poster of this vid is obviously quite obsessed with it. What, TheCastorTroy, is your point?
lifeafter3pints 3 years ago
why is there music? it'd make the scene ten times more effective. it just seems crappy without any music.
Genesis28v12 3 years ago
the lack of music heightens the realism.
jazz4 3 years ago 2
I was thinking music would be a good cue for the audience help nudge them into feeling what you want, but a lack of music can have a profound effect too. I think seeing it on YouTube and not in a theatre full off other people in the dark makes it so different. It's just quiet, instead of "hushed" and silent darkness.
Adom 2 years ago
It shows the best in an
american that he tries to
save him in the end after everything.
dave98503 4 years ago 2
Ah, c'mon, Castor! Hitch loved the illogical, it's one of the most entertaining moments (and films) in film history. He does make it clear witht he line "I'll clear ya...." You wanta great laugh, watch the Coen Brothers spoof this scene in "Hudsucker Proxy"
GAndreiev 4 years ago
It's like...in the middle of doing a barrel roll, his N64 controller comes unplugged and he screams "GAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY!!"
Tristanvash38 4 years ago
Kaaaaaaaaaaaaaaannnnnnnnnnnnnne.............
MichalTCZ 4 years ago 2
OMG lol GAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY
djnoreg 4 years ago 2
...hssss... grrbahhh... Ill get your sleeve
gotgot4242 4 years ago 3
THE SLEVE!!!!!!
Soilsnack 4 years ago 3
Fuck.
wolfer339 4 years ago 2
dude, thinking about it, u should do a "brown noise" video of some sort and make us all shit our pants
kudjo24 4 years ago 3
cuz grabbing onto his hand would make too much sense, lol
kudjo24 4 years ago 3
'GAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY'
that's what he said.
DrMattDestruction 4 years ago 2
COME ON FRY
jsXanatos 4 years ago 3