Added: 3 years ago
From: MollysIrishEyes
Views: 5,249
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (195)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Very nice!!

  • wow amazing cover guys what ever happened to jd does he have another account?? if so could you please send me a private msg thankyou Garry

  • BEAUTIFUL!

  • Very nice, Molly.

  • This was fantastic. And knowing you have no operatic training makes it all the more marvelous. I usually detest most covers of this song because no one can do it justice- but this was stunning. Although the ending "ah's" were a bit flat, I loooooove what you did with the last note, it left me with chills! Great work! Please continue sharing your gift.

  • Beautiful Very good.

    5 Stars

  • Beuatifull!!!!

  • **** B.e.a.u.t.i.f.u.l.!!! ****

  • This was the first broadway show I ever saw, so I have a very special connection to it. When I saw the title, I cringed, thinking someone would kill it again. I was proven wrong the minute your mouths opened. Thank you doing this song justice. It is an honor to hear it.

  • I read the description before watching the video and didn't expect much but I have to say, I was completely blown away!! This is a pretty amazing duet, considering you guys aren't opera singers. KUDOS!! I loved it!!

  • for no training, that was great!!! you both sounded very nice, and very in character!

  • WOW this is fantastic!!!!

  • I just saw this on Broadway about two weeks ago and you two were even better than the Christine and Phantom in the show (obviously they weren't Sarah Brightman and Michael Crawford though).

  • No formal operatic vocal training this is unbelievable.Don't get me wrong its VV gud as it stands but with some work & professional coaching you can hit those big finals I'm certain of it.Regardless I'd pay to hear it as it stands.Please don't knock your last note though. Through the strain to reach it you bring a bit of torture to the piece that obviously because of her amazing range and stamina Sarahs version lacks. I prefer your version in that respect by far.Adds a dramatic chill factor. +++

  • Thanks PoemsbyTom to share this extraordinary operates!5/5 * PREF.

  • Hi Molly * * * * * I listen to your voice and I find her/it stupendous * * * * * JD him I consider indeed it specile in all that that he creates: compliments for this beautiful job of couple!!5/5 * a cia. Pino

  • You are both stars. This was wonderful thank you for sharing with all of us

  • Superb! Considering the lack of training... simply superb.

  • GReat loved it!!!!!

  • Muy bueno la musica y la melodia exelente vos very good

  • both of u are pretty incredible. u both had amazing pitch up until Molly's last high notes (which i know are difficult) but u did amazing, hun not many people could do that without opera training. that last note was insane omg great job both of u

    please check out my vids! id luv the feedback!

    xox

    s

  • fantastic voices!!! =)

  • Nice work!

  • Woow! Wonderful duet;D

  • B R A V O!!!!!!!

  • You're just SO MUCH better than Emmy Rossum ! And as lovely as Sarah Brightman, but different ! :) Love it !

  • Shame on J.D. for not sending me this video. :)

    Wow... J.D. really is good as Phantom in this! And you really do nail Christine well too. Props for this. I saw the show in Portland, OR years ago and was exposed to an embarrassing performance where the phantom tripped down the ramp and his voice cracked very noticeably.

  • Hi Molly, I put this in my box of tubers you must see. Wonderful. Peace, Tom

  • One of my favourite songs ever and you two did absolutely nothing to drag it down. In fact, now I like it even more. :P

  • you have a beautiful voice!

    its so rich and, although you can sing the high notes, it sounds really good when you're singing the deep ones

  • amazing!!!!

  • you can hear that you're not an operasinger.

    but damn girl, that was soooo good. really!

    you'll kick it really far.

  • this is brilliant! just captivating!!! *****

  • The fool who runs this theatre is missing you!

    SING!,,,,,,and wear that green dress, me and T boff like it!

  • Lol! I'm confused... green dress?

  • while I was listening to THIS , I minimized "you" and went to your site, you are wit' Mr T and he AIN'T lookin' at the camera!!..........this time, the pitiful fool is not him,,,,,,,,,,now as long as I got your attention, lemme hear CLIMB EVERY MOUNTAIN,,,,,,ps, for youtube, there's no need for perfection, one take is all it takes!

  • ROTFLOL!!!

  • Simply amazing! Your voice is quite similar to Sarah Brightman's in parts..fantastic job!

  • Simply awesome you two. One of my favorites and always *****.

  • You were very flat on some of the high notes, but your tone was gorgeous and the final note was perfectly on pitch.

    Em

  • nice to hear a beautiful voice....

  • wonderful!

  • You both were excellent; awesome job!

  • Bravo !!!

    Both have magical voices !!!

    Hope to hear more of you both!

  • Beautiful ;)

    You have both very great voices. 5 stars!

  • WoWeeeeeeeeeee!

  • HOW DID I MISS THIS ONE?! Oh my. This is absolutely incredible. I'm in complete awe over the both of you! WOWOWWOWOWOW. Well done! :D

    What do you use to record Molly? Your voice sounds clearer! :D

    Jordana xxx

  • SWEEEEEEEEET!!! I ♥ The Phantom of the Opera....almost more than anything else and am so glad I got to see it in NYC recently.

  • WOW!!!! AMAZING!!!!!

  • very pretty just like pretty in pink little me LOL, i liked it, now why can't we C u 2 live, in person, singing this very pretty song, i want 2 C u 2 live!

  • Beautiful!! Fabulous!! You both sound fantastic!! I really enjoyed this wonderful duet!!

    Sandy xx

  • * jealousy * thatas all I can say lol of you, of him, of ur ranges xD 5*

  • ps: I just noticed u used the broadway version, what turns it even better(and tougher)... you should definetly audition! btw, have I ever told u look a lot like Angelina Jolie in your profile pic? XD

  • Great work!

  • oh my god JD ! you found your vocal mirror !!!! so perfect song :) thanks to Molly too !

    both voices give us so much emotions !!!! 5 stars from France !

  • love the video.

  • good Lord, if you think your voice isn't up to contemporary professional standards,you need a SPANKING!

    you really shined at the end, would LOVE to SEE you "reaching"

  • your better than Emmy Rossum, and that guy is better than gerard buttler... everythings alright! 10/10 I LOVED IT!

  • this is a very difficult song to sing but you both did well. i'm impressed by JD's dynamic and molly's high pitch.

  • oh molly... don't listen to any of the haters :( you and JD are both fantastic!! major props for even ATTEMPTING the end parts... im sure if i even tried, i'd probably break a few windows :P

  • Molly-doll!!! I'm sorry it's taken me so long to comment! You tone here is beauuutiful!! So full and just UH-MAZ-ING! You buddy is fantastic also! I was especially impressed with the notes leading up to that last impossible one (which you got!!! ^_^) They were so stong!! A very impressive perfomance from the both of you!

  • That was really excellent and shows great ability. Rated 5 stars by MrTWS

  • Very good :P

  • Ah, ha, ha, ha. That last comment was made with the wrong channel. Oops. ^_^

    BTW, have you checked it out yet? ;)

    At least this way I get to give you 10 stars. :D

    Great job, again.

  • There are not enough stars in heaven to give for this performance. You both were incredible! JD, at first I thought that it was a clip from the actual song. Then I realized it actually WAS you singing!

    Molly, I was waiting for the "ahs" at the end, curious if you would go through with it, or avoid them. You did really well with them! But, was that last note really you?

    Amazing job, both of you. I can't help but favorite this.

  • Fantastic vocals! Beautiful vid, well worth the effort! 5 stars - *****

  • Bravo, Molly & JD! You both put your souls into this one and it is beautiful! Thanks, JD for sending this on.....

  • i love your voices really!!maybe you´re pushin to hard from 3:40 on but you´re both really great singers=)and the vid´s amazing too.. keep on going like that

  • WOW, WOW!!! This is not my normal genre' of music, but WOW, what a stellar performance!!! Thank you bear6120! I agree, I was blown away and I don't even know who they are like you do. Great send, thanks!

    mc

  • You are completely out of pitch from 3:40 on. You are also screeching from that point on. How could you post this being so out of tune? All the yelling in the world won't make a difference if you can't sing on pitch! The guy is amateuris at best. Don't quit your day jobs.

    Not bashing. You're just not good.

  • oh,justin,if you were'nt in a mental wheelchair,people would say bad things about you,but alas.

  • Mental wheelchair is funny coming from someone who writes 'weren't' as 'were'nt.'

    Sorry. I'm not saying she can't sing, she can, she just needs to stop pushing her voice. That's where her pitch problems lay. I'm not some horny old dude who wants to score. I'm going to tell it like it is whether you like it or not.

  • hi 'Simon'.. before you bash others' grammar, check your channel -- where you use 'your' where 'you're' is what you were looking for =) lol

    you know, you are? (you're).

    anyway thank you for your time in listening to our duet. neither of us are professionals and both of us have day jobs =)

    cheers and PEACE! JD

  • You are quite right. I meant to correct that. If you look closer though he was bashing me. I was pointing out to him that he had no reason to tell anyone they are in a mental wheelchair (bad analogy as it is). My apologies to you as well. I was under the impression you were both striving to be musical theatre actors. She really does have a lovely voicem she just needs to accept she's not a chest belter. She has a pretty voice that is being ruined and is pitchy because I feel she wants to belt.

  • hi no problem whatsoever!

    i am just glad you listened and that you at least have an opinion you are not afraid to voice. this duet was a lot of fun for both of us and of course we are far from perfect!

    hope you have a great weekend! =)

  • I'm sorry but I disagree. If they were to strive for that I think their chances are both very good I don't feel that they exhibit any delusions of grandeur with regard to their obvious talent. And you are 'bashing' by saying they should almost be embarrassed to have posted this you make yourself look petty in the extreem. I agree the pressure on the top end needs improvement but I think it's within reach for her. However the last note has a wonderful eerie quality - it needs that torture to it

  • I did not see this song on your own site, GREAT JOB, and of course I have a request!

    "when all is said and done" ,,,it's in Mamma Mia .......I'm hoping Molly will sing Slipping Through My Fingers from the same movie

  • re: You're just not good.

    to listen to her is to love her

  • This is really good!!!

    I don't what write :)

    Graet!!!

    5*

  • Bear sent me this fantastic video*****`S

  • Wow !!! A great collaboration !!! You two are awesome singers. 5*****

  • Nicely done. You two complement each other very well. Keep it up.

  • Molly, you BOTH were Amazing! I actually liked him better than Michael Crawford, his tone is not as nasal. Sarah was Phenomenal in concert, "La Luna" tour, she performed this. The upper range on this is inhumanly high, and you did a Tremendous job with it. Dont discount your fabulous voice, I am Instantly hitting subscribe to you, then JD. Kudos and Brava to you. Appreciatively, NaughtyPuppetShow ;-P

  • Didn't know your work, Molly, but I've been a fan from JD for quite a long time:) Really enjoyed your partnership!!! I've been telling JD he should apply to a theatrical company or something... Now I think you should too:) Great stuff!!! Keep those collabs coming:)

  • poemsbytom sent me this.Quite remarkable.

  • SUPERB!!! Molly you have a beautiful voice, and congratulate JD for me...he did an amazing vocal performance

  • excellent cover!

  • You not to be compared to Sarah Brightman... I will compare you are real. Sarah Brightman is not a classical artist no matter what the media tells us (she is a crossover artist), and they can do a lot of touching up in studios. Yours is naturally beautiful. The only criticism I will give you is that I would love to hear you do this a lower larynx.Try yawning deeply and sing with the same openness, and you will get a more mature and operatic sound. The high notes will come more easily :-)

  • You have great voices!

  • its good song!

  • great job

  • wow this track is old

  • this was incredible !!

    wow !

    JD what an awesome voice !

    and Molly, you sing just fabulous !!

    5*****

  • It's wonderful!

  • WOW! I am seriously stunned at all the amazing comments! Thank you all so much! It was an honor to sing with JD and I never expected out lil duet to have this response! Cool :)

  • u should be stunned by how well u can sing!

    when 2 great singers come together they create a wonderful piece of music! C: keep it up and keep me posted! love ya..

  • Lady, you have a future! Continue singing and learning! You're really amazing!

  • brava brava ,very nice ,hello from italy

  • WOW!! Very Great job!! love you both!! peace

  • Huh? This is not the original! WTH :D It's absolutely wonderful ^_^ awesome version :D

  • Congratulations to both !

  • Marvellous mate , brilliant ;-)

  • Very good!

  • Love it!!!!

  • oh wow molly u go gurl! i dunno about sarah brightman i dont get why people like her i find her automated and harsh on the ear,you sing with emotion ur above sarah in my book! n jd well he's jd hes up there too isnt he great work u two xx

  • Very cool!

  • brilliant , really enjoyed that , well done

  • love your version.many thanks u r awesome both of u.thank you again

  • Wow, that was so great! Since I am a mezzo soprano, I would never even attempt that! If I did I would never be able to speak again, lol! You guy's did awesome! :)))

  • Oh my goodness! You and JD make a spectacular Phantom and Christine. I've seen POTO 7x and this is an equally extraordinary version. So grand and powerful are your joint vocals. You should be on Broadway, Molly. :o) Marina

  • And JD - you always knock my socks off and this is no different. But I really do love your Broadway show tunes more than anything else as I think they really show off your incredible range. Cheers, friend!

  • of course, except for your poemsbytom collabs - they are so brilliant that Webster is creating new words for his dictionary to describe THOSE (hehe)

  • thanks Marina!  I do enjoy singing the Broadway stuff. And this was an incredible opportunity. I am happy Molly was so kind as to do this. She is a super talent!!!

  • 23 favorites off 300 views is pretty impressive for this type of piece of music...I'm not an opera fan but I favorited it - (golf clap, or whatever they do in appreciation at the opera, hehe)

  • how impressed i am with your singing and this video.

    super job.

    michael

  • Pretty cool collaboration. I already love JD and he only lives approximately 90 miles from me. So I love to show support for a relative neighbor. I enjoyed listening to the 2 of you as well. What a difficult song.

    Peace!!

  • OMGosh...I am so excited for you!!! Congrats!

    You got honors!!!

    #68 - Most Discussed (Today) - Music

    #84 - Top Rated (Today) - Music

  • Ah molly and JD, I forgot to add that poemsbytom sent this, and I am glad he did, lovely!

  • NO doubt, this is one of the finest Phantom covers on Youtube. Great job, JD and Molly!

    ~David

  • Great job to the two of you.

    Fantastic.

    Peace~Rod

  • great job

  • Incredible!!!

    ALW's people will be calling your people:-)

    Break a leg.

    Bravo-more!!

    ~Ric~

  • What a pleasure to listen to!Many thanks to Blaid for sharing you with us.5***** a sub and a favourite!Hugs.Jan and Susan.x

  • This was wonderful!! Bravissimo!!!

  • OH i just love this;) hugs shelly

  • furstly Jd thanks for sending i have 2 versions on here so i camme to listen i have sent this to 3 friends the word Fantastic does not do it for this cover u have gone beyond that word regards Blaid

  • GREAT JOB!!

  • I'm totally with elpilotoazul. You both did an amazing job!

  • Very nice.

  • great !!!!!

  • BRAVO!!!!

  • Beautiful....just beautiful. *****

  • that was sweet performance!!! sounds better than the original!!

  • Wow JD and molly!

    AMAZING job

  • the ending was incredible.... wow

  • great stuff... it's hard not to get excited about this singing !!!

    Fantastic voices. Love it !

  • Very well done

    Great job

    Beatlesfan310

  • I read your write up first. Who in their right mind would bash you for this? You're terrific, and only a geek would disagree. And where did you find this recruit to sing with you? He's top shelf. Loved it.

  • Awesome!

  • pro job molly and jd 5*****to you

  • Beautiful vid, amasing visuals + music!!☺☺☺

  • That is quite a professional perfomance from the both of you...Molly, you sound brilliant! This is a keeper! Share time. Peace, TOm

  • Wow you two are so awesome. I just love this. What a great job you two did. I faved it and 5 stars. Way to go you two.

  • fantastic! thanks to Brianna for sharing

  • Wow that was wonderful: I just love the phantom of the Opera. PeaceX

  • Great colab, both well controlled voices and suit this song so well.

    Hugz. Emma.xXx

  • and so you have to do a part in the opera "the phantom of the opera"?compliments!!!the teather is an amazing thing i'm glad because this thing is hold in life by actor and actress compliments!!!!!

  • very nice!

  • you both did a great job on this well done 5 stars ***** awesome version!

  • Sounds very convincing

    Version

  • WOW! AMAZING! I LOVED IT! i LOVE opera whether it be classical opera or musical theatre kind! =) Keep singing.

  • wait did you actually sing the last high note? it sounded like it was fake for some reason.

  • BRILLIANT!!! This is absolutely terrific, what a wonderful collaboration you took my breath

    away 5* & favourite.....Barbara

  • This is FANTASTIC!!! WOW!!

    Excellent performance!!!!

    G

  • wow.., 1000*

    great song, beautiful voices and great video!

    congratulations!!!

  • Great Voices,like the background too.

    5 Stars

    Were did you get the backing track from?

  • you sound like Emmy but only with better melody and a better vabratto great job! im stunned!

  • I feel so lucky to communicate with you;your talent is soooo amazing. this is just amazing!!!!. My favorite of all...I knew as soon as I heard your voice your were great!!!

  • beautiful!

  • Yes JD is amazing and you did great! This is one of my favorite songs! Favorite it!

  • you guys are great! wonderful, beautiful duet :).

  • Thanks for share bear6120 !!!

    Beautiful video and great song !!!

    5*****

  • Beautiful voices!

  • Awesome video!

    5*****

    Thanks to bear6120 for the share!

  • fantastic

  • thanks bear6120 for the share sweetheart ' you guys are real good thanks 'issy

  • You two did a great job together!!

  • Amazing job with this classic.

    Scott

  • BRAVISSIMI!! Excellent, both of you!

    JD & I are currently working on "The Confrontation" from "Les Miserables" - he's going to be a very sought-after duet partner, as are you, Molly!

    *****

    ~R

  • U guyz sound awesome!Keep it up.I luv this song!!!!

  • This is very good, well done both of you.

    Amy xx

  • OMGosh...you are better than amazing...awesome...incredible­!! You are PHENOMENAL!!! WOW!!!I so giving you a standing ovation!!! Here is a trillion zillion stars!!!

  • after hearing it again...I am sharing this!!! It's that great!!!

  • awesome..Brianna!! thanks!!

  • The ending notes way too high for you. Still, good effort. Try slowing down and waiting for the groove.

    JD made a good choice by not doing the ending dialogue; it's amazingly hard to make those spoken-word parts sound convincing and in-character. I couldn't do it either when I tackled the song on two separate videos.