Fly To The Sky - Goodbye

[Bloodbathian]

2012..

[truongchauthy]

Hwanhee is really special!!!! 

[BlueHikari354]

Beautiful

[heroaddict1]

i prefer the american vrsion by alk 4 one.

[BBW198720]

@heroaddict1 both are awesome. I Like both But I love this one more Because Hwanhee Voice Go straight to your heart.

[Vietsteh]

Whats the story line?

[littlemisshowei]

@Vietsteh Read the top comment =)

[breakingmyheart43]

I almost didn't recognize Brian without his diva face, but he made me cry here DX

[GitaKawaii]

I really love their voices

i miss the good ol' days

[juhee589]

i broke down completely lost it at 4:45 - 4:52 omg the look on brian's face...

[doanvudung]

i love this song

[Mazzmarach]

Bomiiiiiii..... she always gets the tragic roles. TwT

[MayIHelpYouFreak]

oh i luuuuv this song so much!!!!!!!!!

[davkim]

please support another Asian by visiting my channel and watchin' its two most recent videos! =) did a shout-out to Brian and small tribute to snsd and kara

[kaysie89]

yes, they are still FLY TO THE SKY!! just doing solo activities now.

&& taking a LIFETIME to get back together! Lol.

[Annydelperu]

The best version of this song, Fly To The Sky FOREVER.....

[great281a]

she is one of the team members "The Grace" under SM Ent

[chuotcuteiujae]

@great281a She's Lina from "The Grace" :x

[heeseul1]

who's that girl?

seems familiar~

[MsLovelyBot]

@heeseul1 She's Lina from former SM ent.'s "The Grace!!!"

[CocoKaniMaki]

this song is realy beautiful

[UOmetropark]

i love the part when hwanee starts singing. great harmony~!

[luvsgnu]

Ahhh~! Love this song!!! Brings back memories. :)

[jjy33p]

hwanhee n brian should reunite since both of their solo LPz didnt do as well as F T T S. no hating just sayin.

[rainbowromanceabc]

The first MV that i cried along :((

[luvb2st]

i miss them :(

[sleepingforest215]

I miss them soo much xc

[boogisan]

question... What were the ladies doing in the hospital? what was the condition all about?

[janghongmin]

lina acts beautifully & i miss boomi so much. I hope lina can get her dream to be an actress

[jazhly07]

nice song.. it so very sad, i like this song

[jazhly07]

nice song.. it so very sad

[heartpranker]

is it a luv triangle or what....+WHATEVER+ i just luv it =)

[itsmhiegrace25]

i love the song..it made me cry...:((((

[sckb4]

The piano is beautiful.

[yezzey3]

can someone explain the video?

[Qrizta]

@yezzey3 Brian's gf (played by Bomi) was in a similar condition as Hwanhee's gf which was played by Lina. But then Bomi died in that same hospital. Upon seeing Lina in that situation, he was reminded by his gf who wished to go to the beach with him so he decided to take Lina with him to the beach as promised to his deceased gf. In the end Hwanhee found them.

[yezzey3]

@Qrizta thanks :)

[Poedie9000]

I really do not understand the language, but the music tells me enough

[Missmurderkaulitz002]

aww brian oppa is so hot... =)

[lovely10ten]

Good songs and good music!

When I listened to this , I was likely to be close to tears...

[YeonAeKim]

long time didnt listen to their songs ady.... both of them are good singers....

all the best ya~~~ even both of u disband, but all who love ur songs will still remember both of u~~~~ ^^v

[vpclove]

My first FTTS song I've heard I think I almost cried.

[xXPrinsezzXx]

@vpclove

wuahh~ D:

meeh tew :'(

[hannelyn28]

can u pls tell me why the girl need to go to hospital?is she sick?im sorry i dont know..

[anile14]

Hwanhee is good looking there but now he looks much better!!

[lady2rainy1dayz6]

someone eng sub it plz

[lady2rainy1dayz6]

i luv this video, it's like a mini drama...lol

[mcr4lyf213]

OMG i had NO IDEA hwanhee was in fly to the sky!

[kokothing]

3:37 this guy has black man voice o.O

[Karoke77]

Sooooooooooo sad =(

[HanFanyVal]

OMO Hwanhee :) 

[NazrulSyah]

Lina CSJH in here~

[HowHello]

Nw i start to love brain.. after this song

[MonkeyDLuffy77]

my heart hurts whenever i hear this song even though i don't understand a thing. why are they all crying ? is she sick ? whats happening D: uugggh

[angskeet]

@MonkeyDLuffy77 she is sick & i know this mv is very very confusing. 4 some reason ftts's mvs are always confusing except 4 some..basically lina is sick & the doc was going to give her a shot, which side effects makes her lose some of her memory. she didn't want that cause she did not want to forget fany which is her lover but the reason she went w/ brian when she bump into him was because......continue

[angskeet]

.continue..... brian wanted to help her out &escape fr the hospital & give her the freedom bcuz brian also went through a similar situation as what lina/fany are going through which brian also lost his girlfriend in a similar way that's why they show those flashbacks of brian and his girl...and that's why at the end fany was there seeing lina and brian together...

hopefully this helps a little bit :)

[MonkeyDLuffy77]

@angskeet thank you so much i totally get why brian is crying so hard, just seeing him makes you cry 4:50 ,so sad. gotta love ftts thanks again !

[CowsLoled]

woahhhhh i didnt even know it was lina 0.o

i was like omg the girl is really pretty at first xD

never knew it was her shes really pretty with her natural hair.

[mrsmileyface]

its lina from csjh!!! XD shes so pretttyy

[kdzzpoot]

this song is so good....... its better than the american goodbye.... WAY better.... i feel so sorry for brian........

[TohruXKisa]

Brian made me cry because he's crying

[Toomanyvideogames]

Is it me or does the beginning remind you of another song? Some American song.....

[trongie]

@Toomanyvideogames the whole song is from an american song actually by all 4 one - goodbye

[Toomanyvideogames]

@trongie Yeah I figured that out by watching All 4 One's video. Thanks dude.

[IOBL49]

cuando estoi feeling.. sin duda escucharlos a ellos dos...... pero porque ahora??? jaja esque cantan tan HERMOSAMENTE!!!!!!!!!!!

[IOBL49]

waa!!! nuc ni q signifik pero parec muy trist... xq se separaron si kntan hermoso!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[grangerBby]

wow... their voices

melt my heart in an instant..

and this is my 1st time hearing and

watching this groups music...... they're so good :D

[LOTR26]

I'm a massive fan of korean music, but I think this MV and song is one of the best songs I have heard. My heart feels unsettled when I heard the girl scream, and u feel the sorrows from the two amazing singers.. love it.

[ambeeryang]

why did they break uppp? its sad they were better as a duo than they are promoting single!

[superZvegetto]

who put dislikes on any ftts songs? must be obviously retarded deafs

[HishnK]

still my favorite song forever

[MidoriWorld]

I really lik the song, their voice is great but i wish this video has english sub

[wstcw]

I love the music and the music video. I think it's a beautiful song, but I don't understand Korean. I don't understand the things that was said in the beginning of the video, before the music begins. Would someone so kind to explain to me?

Thanks!

[yoomijung]

@wstcw The girl (lina from csjh) doesn't have long to live. brian suddenly bumps into her and starts being reminded of this girl (who he used to love) who stayed at the hospital too, and whose last wish was to see the sea before she dies. So when brian sees the "new" girl, he asks her: "do you want to see the sea?"

[kabamz]

@yoomijung

Do you know what's going on with hwanhee following them to the sea? Is he upset that the girl went with Brian? I was always confused about the rest of the music video.

[yoomijung]

@kabamz hwanhee is in love with lina and finds out that he doesn't have long to live (according to what the doctor told him before the 2nd stanza started playing). it wasn't explicitly stated, but i suppose he found out that the girl ran away from the hospital so he went to find her. basically this mv is about how the 2 guys have the exact same experience, albeit being complete strangers. the difference is that brian no longer have the chance, but hwanhee still does.

[wstcw]

@yoomijung Thank you so much for the explanation! Now I understand and truly enjoy the music video thanks to you. :)

[Makeveni]

I know this is not their song but they make the best ballad songs.

Can't believe this group broke up...sad.

[aoifan90]

@Makeveni This is a late reply, but Brian said in an interview recently that they never broke up, their just taking a break. :)

[cathao92]

@aoifan90 what?! Really?!

[aoifan90]

@cathao92 Yeah he said it in the interview for KoreAm in March

[megster266]

copy... ALL4ONE - "Not Ready for Goodbye"

sounds good and a good vid though =].

[momolovelygang]

This MV remind me of a 2008 Thai MV of "CLASH"

But I love this song so

[TheJapanfanforever]

i love this song so much

[maitheerak]

This is the song that i like Brian's voice most.

Luv Hwanhee's voice every single song.

[ImmyMacKay]

It's not often you see videos like this one; makes me want to cry.

[soccerDITTOetc935]

it seems that everyone loves hwanhee, but i've always liked brian more :)

but anyhow i still love this song and mv, even though i can't understand it [anyone wanna give me a summary?? lol thanks] it SOUNDS beautiful ^-^

[deannadeee]

@soccerDITTOetc935 yea, me to. it seems like everyone loves hawanee more than brian... idk y, but i like brian more. =D

[soccerDITTOetc935]

@deannadeee

i know right!!! and brian's had to work so hard and hiss life is was so hard!!! he told these stories and he was like 'we wer guests on a show and aftrward the dj said to hwanhee "good job, ur a great singer" and to me he just said "u've worked hard."'

!!! i felt soo bad

and he said these girls also pretended to be his fans then kinda like "harassed" him for being "white" aftr some white soldiers killed some koreans or something like that

I LOVE BRIAN!!! XD hahaha

[deannadeee]

@soccerDITTOetc935 awwwww poor Brian. But i do still like both of them because they are both very talented

[soccerDITTOetc935]

@deannadeee

hahaha yeah i know, me too. i love fly to the sky. but i only got into them aftr they kinda separated!!! =(

[deannadeee]

@soccerDITTOetc935 OMG!!!! Me too =D =( I hope they get back together. They were so good and their songs were beautiful!!!

[soccerDITTOetc935]

@deannadeee

yesss!! normally im not a huge ballad fan but i would definitely like to see some more from themm <3

[deannadeee]

what is their newest song?

[aphostrophea]

love the main lady in there ;)

[StephHProud]

This song is sooo beautiful

Like I don't speak korean, could someone tell me what is the story about the girl in the hospital please ?

[Tubekmon]

ohh this is the first song i heard... is cool...beautifull

[monynice89]

all 4 one is an old band...i think fly to the sky took the song from them ...its not similar to their song...it's the same!!! it's not ready for goodbye

[smilesasa00]

could someone pls explain the MV. :)

[shobe0118]

but what does the video means?

[martin0118]

nice song :)

[JaejoongLoveXxXxX]

ok, so even though this song is sort of old, i can still fall in love with it all over again <3

[kiyoni]

@mitokhandria wow you are so right. I have never heard of All4One, I just knew that the melody sounded familiar.

[kiyoni]

OMG! Has anyone else notice? This song is the same melody as "This I Promise You" by NSync, except they have different lyrics.

[waterflowzz]

@kiyoni are you deaf? how is this anything like This I Promise You by Nsync

[mitokhandria]

@waterflowzz I think kiyoni meant "Not Ready For Goodbye" by All4One

[waterflowzz]

Thanks for clearing that. I always knew this song sounded like something i heard before but i just couldn't pinpoint it. Now I know.

[cheecheepong]

lol. it is exactly the same melody.

i wonder who came up with it first?

[Popstar16]

hey is the girl in the mv Lina from CSJH?

this must have came out when FTTS was still at SM Ent.

[Yellowfirefly]

i love them and this song too

but the mv is confused me what have to the girl

[Yellowfirefly]

nvm i understand know it so sad

but wonder what kind of illness that you have to put them to sleep like that

[gariella]

I really love this MV

[Arielleyy]

stiiillllll the bestt :]

[TVXQLOV3]

so sad but fanys HOT!

[LaoSouI]

such a great band, yet it doesn't get much view over the past 4 years

[014isaiah]

What is the name of the R&B group that also sings this?????

[nauticalstar131]

Wow! Dis song made me cry ='( Very sad....

[totlavrilvr]

why does korean r&b have to be so sad? :(

[snipplebipp]

Hey guessing here b/c i can't get the lyrics;

does she shave amnesia or shorterm emm loss? like int that movie 50 first dates? b/c that would make sense in which case it would jsut be a sedative no? like w/ ppl w/ alsheimers

[darkcinderellaisabel]

By the way, what does Brian say at 1:05???

[jeffurrey]

do you want to go see the ocean ?

[aznangell01]

@darkcinderellaisabel want to go to the beach

[darkcinderellaisabel]

... so the family will give the ok for her to be put to death, but not by the patient's choice herself????? O.O In what circumstances would this be? (just asking, and curious)

Such a sad MV...

[Cimegs5088]

sounds like korean.

[chica2022]

beautiful song

[s0addicted2u]

i love it <3. . .

[lildEVILxD]

i absolutely LOVE hwanhee's voice. i love the deepness feel of it. His and Brian's voice blend well :)

[12iLoVeYa12]

hwanhee is so hott

and brian is so cute (:

and they sing beautifully together

hahah what is there not to LOVE

[KitiaraSkie]

they could just kill a human off like that

[12iLoVeYa12]

its not really the doctors choice.. the patients families are the ones that give them the okay.

[FishingtheSkyxd]

ahh this is the first ftts song i heard :] it's what made me like them soo much ^^

this song was just too good XD

now that im watching the mv again, Brian looks so agonized D: don't you just want to hug him? :D

[deannadeee]

@FishingtheSkyxd llol, so weird because i just looked them up from reading comments on sm town and this is the first song that i am hearing of theirs :D and they are AWESOME!!!! I dont know who the individual people are... yet :D i will learn them :D

[FishingtheSkyxd]

@deannadeee haha ikr? brian's voice is so angelic in this song. hwanhee is the one with the sunglasses and turtle neck and deeper voice, and brian's the one who cries at the end

[deannadeee]

@FishingtheSkyxd k thanks, but do you know their newest song?

[FishingtheSkyxd]

@deannadeee they disbanded for independent works last year i think. but their last album was decennium, and the main song for that was restriction

[deannadeee]

@FishingtheSkyxd k thanks :D i LOVE K-POP and Im now starting to listen to C-POP too :D although I am american :D I just find K-POP and C-POP more interesting, even though I have no idea what they are saying. One of my favorite bands of K-POP is SHINee :D and SNDS

[stych]

So sad. Why does Brian always get the short end of the stick...?

[mathildalano]

so sad :(

[whitedaisie29]

i still don't understand what happened in the video

what were the doctors trying to do?

[hyesuneonni]

They were trying to put Hwanhee's girl to sleep (to rest in peace) but she got out and Brian took her to the ocean since he promised his girl who went through the same process as the other girl so he took her instead.

[buckweed226]

wait what? y would they put her to sleep tho? it doesnt mke sense

[soization]

Korean know this song is remake song

[POPLINable]

Is the girl on 1:02 Lina from The Grace?????

[soization]

Yes

[shayshay852]

This Song Is Sung In English By All 4 One "Not Ready To Say Goodbye" Oh I Didn't Know Brian Sung It Too It Sounds Nice In Korean

[pretichinita]

This MV is very sad... both of the girls experience the same situation that's why BRIAN save the girl of FANY to live not like what happened to his Girl, I think they'll inject some medicine to kill "Mercy Killing" to stop the suffering immediately... (that's what I observe about the VIDEO I'm not korean so I don't understand what the Old man was talking just understanding the plot of the MV)

[sunniesunshine]

Omg I didn't know that they made a Korean version of this song. I've only herd the English one. I love this version!

[wildstyled]

?? there's an english version?

[tengty]

Yea. Its called not ready for goodbye by all 4 one

[wildstyled]

thanks ^^!

[shayshay852]

Yeah By All 4 One "Not Ready To Say Goodbye"

[dizwunofakind]

can someone explain to me what going on in the video please??? sorry i'm not korean so i don't understand what the old man was saying.

[joycekim9696]

isnt one of the guys from over the rainbow drama?

[freakyysmiles]

yeah. Fany acts as Rex in Over the Rainbow.

[ALfans27]

love it...<3<3!! ^^

[yusan2]

BRIAAAAN!!!!!!! :D

and OMG LINA AND BOMI???? o.o

unexpected xD

Waaa~ this is so sad T^T

[PATATATONS]

oh my god linaaa unnie *__* XDD

[mikaaka20]

yep ^_^

[ONLYNEIL]

FUCKING FAGGOT

[Zanibug]

To make my previous comments more simple. ^^

I simply love this song. Its amazing. Who cares if it wasn't originaly their song. : ) Its beautiful either way.

Brian and Fany are awesome.

[mikaaka20]

I think both versions are beautiful although I heard FTTS version fist

[BakaMaree]

i think this song is Not Ready For Goodbye..By All 4 one..isnt' it?

[oyioyioi]

yeah it is

[jessikuur]

favorite song :)

[Akahimeify]

Linaaa xD

BRIAN <3333

[maiyervang777]

omgeee..ii luv dis song..saranghaeyo brian joo<333

[Devilsoul8888]

can anyone tell me the lyrics in english? i luv the song

[ljilji11]

Brain girl friend die~!!!so he was cry

[ChrmdThree]

WAH SO CUTE! BRIAN! HWANHEE!XD<3

[blackstarsx]

why was Brain crying please someone tell me

please.love the song.

[o8dooboo8o]

his ex died the same way the girl was about to die, and since his ex had always wanted to go to see the ocean, he went. the girl he took, he doesn't really know her, but she reminds him of his ex because she's in the same situation. and so in this way, he's sort of fulfilling the wish of his dead girl.

[oyioyioi]

does fly to the sky sing this song in english at all?

[o8dooboo8o]

i'm not sure... i feel like i've heard an english version before, but i dont know if it exists or if i imagined it.

[oyioyioi]

Oh. Becasue I heard All 4 One's version of this before these guys and I wanted to see how people found out about them, beautiful song though in ANY language

[tie1323]

i think NO!

[darkcinderellaisabel]

Too bad Fly to the Sky is disbanded... =( Decennium was a great last album... I feel so sentimental after watching this MV

On another hand, Lina is a really good actress. She's so diverse!

[o8dooboo8o]

i know!!!! but i think it's a good thing they disbanded when they were still good. if they disbanded after like an album failure or something(due to getting old or not having good songs anymore...), i don't think it would have become as great an impact as it was right now. :P i still miss them being together though. and i miss looking forward to what they'll sing next.. their voices are just too awesome.... i never get tired of listening to their songs. :P