Am I right to consider the 2nd Dance to be the one with the nastiest technical problems? I've been a long-time fan of the 1st Dance, but never paid much attention to the 2nd, possibly due to its pianistic as well as musical problems.
Hello all Bartok performers and enthusiasts - I believe that there is an error in measure 94 ( 3 bars before the FF return at Tempo 1) - the third LH chord has an e# resulting from an earlier accidental in the measure, but I personally believe that Bartok is playing e natural and also that e nat. fits the chord structure correctly - all of the gestures in that bar are exact transpositions and the other 3 chords are half diminished sevenths in quality. Dover edition - bet all editions are wrong.
Thanks for your reply John11 - I knew it was not Bartok - I finally found the one I was looking for. Bartok plays Bartok - give it a listen - the pitch is off a little but WOW!!! I truly think I am right about the misprint as well.
Hello - I would like to know who the performer is....there was a recording of Bartok playing this himself but I can longer locate it. I am chasing after what I think is an error in the score - and I think the key is hearing that performance again. I recall hearing it and noticing that he played a particular chord as I do - without an accidental that appears earlier in the bar - and it is a spot where all figures are exact transposed sets.
Oh, also, an attempt to upload a recording of a sonata by Scriabin which was owned by Warner Music Group has put me on youtube's shit list. Which basically means they will be actively checking for third party content on all videos from here forward, so they will probably all have that little advertisement. Not my doing.
Am I right to consider the 2nd Dance to be the one with the nastiest technical problems? I've been a long-time fan of the 1st Dance, but never paid much attention to the 2nd, possibly due to its pianistic as well as musical problems.
eurisko618 1 month ago
thank you!
grandepittore 5 months ago
Hello all Bartok performers and enthusiasts - I believe that there is an error in measure 94 ( 3 bars before the FF return at Tempo 1) - the third LH chord has an e# resulting from an earlier accidental in the measure, but I personally believe that Bartok is playing e natural and also that e nat. fits the chord structure correctly - all of the gestures in that bar are exact transpositions and the other 3 chords are half diminished sevenths in quality. Dover edition - bet all editions are wrong.
mbmkeyboard 6 months ago
Thanks for your reply John11 - I knew it was not Bartok - I finally found the one I was looking for. Bartok plays Bartok - give it a listen - the pitch is off a little but WOW!!! I truly think I am right about the misprint as well.
mbmkeyboard 6 months ago
@mbmkeyboard
What measure is this misprint supposed to be at, and in which edition, and what is the misprint?
John11inch 6 months ago
Hello - I would like to know who the performer is....there was a recording of Bartok playing this himself but I can longer locate it. I am chasing after what I think is an error in the score - and I think the key is hearing that performance again. I recall hearing it and noticing that he played a particular chord as I do - without an accidental that appears earlier in the bar - and it is a spot where all figures are exact transposed sets.
mbmkeyboard 6 months ago
@mbmkeyboard
I do not remember. However, the performer here is not Bartok.
John11inch 6 months ago
Probably the best version of this song on youtube...
But I find it too slow (just personal opinion)
PRObifidus 7 months ago
great music - thanks :)
jamiebyrne77 1 year ago
Oh, also, an attempt to upload a recording of a sonata by Scriabin which was owned by Warner Music Group has put me on youtube's shit list. Which basically means they will be actively checking for third party content on all videos from here forward, so they will probably all have that little advertisement. Not my doing.
John11inch 2 years ago