I'd like to echo what @farshnuke said. Babelcolour- THE Babelcolour- did a DW tribute to this song and this one still absolutely holds its own against it- is an equal to it- is still my favorite DW fanvid ever. Wow.
I've turned this (incredible) vid into a game- I try to call out the character or the episode each clip is from as it appears on-screen. So far, no one has beat me at this game. I am proud of this, and I LOVE this video!
I couldn't have said it better than maketheworldnicer did. This was AMAZING. The fact that you included Liz Shaw- who always seems to get forgotten- makes it just that better. And having Ace and Martha on screen within seconds of each other? I think you might have blown up the internet from too much awesome in too small a time frame!
Wow. Excuse me while I get my n00b self some more Classic Who. This vid is already amazing with my small knowledge of old series. I bet it would be a million times better after I shotgun a bunch of old episodes.
it's a little bit too literal, but it's a common, easy trap for fanvideos to fall into. sometimes it's just too tempting! and I feel like the clips always changed too fast. Enjoyable and fitting, however. :)
I really love this video, I can't think of this song without thinking of Doctor Who know! I liked your first version too, is there anyway of getting ahold of it?
I might have to agree with the "too many clips" people; but the way the clips flow together with movements carrying on from one to another? Masterful, absolutely masterful. It must have taken you forever to edit them so precisely.
This is amazing. Really well done, a great song, and just awesome. I love seeing all of the Doctors in one video, along with pretty much every Companion and major Villain, except you did seem to leave off Roberts!Master, Corpse!Master, and the Rani. Just something I noticed. Still, I love that you ended on Four/Romana. It's just so right. They really are the true pairing in Doctor Who. Time Lord Love. = )
I love this song, and I love that you did such a beautiful homage to all the Doctors, BUT, and I make this critique with the greatest of respect, your cuts are too fast. You need to cut your clip count in half. The clips move by so fast it detracts from the video as a whole.
I am enjoying your other videos very much, but please remember, sometimes "less is more". :)
I kind of miss the first one you did, Calapine, but this is brilliant too. You were the first person to connect this song with Doctor Who, weren't you? It's perfect. I picked up that album because of your fanvid.
It's brilliant , and yet strange that it all started with something you'd never get away with today; a couple of teachers following a fifteen-year-old girl home.
@CrazyCarl1992 Boy, have you missed out! Where have you been, hidding in a cave somewhere? Doctor Who is the longest running Science Fiction TV series ever, older than even Star Trek. In 2013 Doctor Who will be 50 years old, I wonder what the BBC will do to celebrate that?
Oh, man, this version is wonderful. I love both <3333 but this one, for some reason, I got all teary in the multi-doctor scenes, particularly old!Five raising his hat.
BRILLIANT. I loved the audio clip of the Second Doctor at the beginning - what a line. I especially adored the edited clips of Eight and Romana, which I imagine was used to represent the Time War - it was very well done.
U know there was one thing that i was quite wrong about. I said the other one was the best thing ive ever seen... Sorry this one tops it, but only just...
Though I enjoyed this very much, I do agree with the comment on quick cuts. The first version seemed to linger on scenes more.. fit with the music more maybe? It isn't a particularly fast, energetic song after all.
Brilliant, you must have gigs worth of clips hanging around to put all this together, and it's edited wonderfully (something which must have taken ages). Marvellous work.
The criticism about "too many cuts" just beggars belief. Mozart would be appalled [/Amadeus reference]. The rapidfire nature of the video is just beautiful; Doctor Who has a lot of history, and you've captured the spirit of the song and the show with remarkable beauty. It's wonderful how you've given each era an equal amount of attention, with special emphasis on the most notable companions.
Bah, I love this one, even better than the first. I think you chose some slightly more affecting shots for some of the lines in the song. I love how Three's 'broken car' is now his TARDIS and how you showed Sarah Jane's 'future made'. Those were just two highlights for me among many. :)
I liked the first version better, personally. Least I'm pretty sure I did; hard to tell when you've taken it down. I'd still favorite them both though.
Almost as brilliant as the first, and a damn good video in its own right! Have to agree that some of the clips went by too fast, but still great fun. Loved all the scenes the multi-Doctor eps, especially 5 tipping his hat from the ep of "Time Crash."
this is brill! i just want to say i think the clasics are better than the new! more vilonce plz but not enuf to get ur self canceled! just saying. god that feels good to get that out my sistems lol! ( p.s im 11) go classics!
Wonderful, felt the greater structure ie all the scenes of the Doctor versus the Master together, events on Gallifrey, all the Doctor reunions worked really well. Only criticism (constructive I hope)was some of the clips passed too quickly before I could even tell what they were
I remember the first one- I loved it so much. It was my favourite of favourite fan vids. I used to watch it for hours on end. Hope this one is just as good.
What a nice thing to wake up to! I wasn't anticipating any more videos from you until the new season. As usual, nice editing and a great selection of moments - and did you do something different with the encoding? It looks a lot sharper than usual.
It certainly did not switch Too rapidly! Some vids at times can do that, and this one verily didn't. It was all wonderfully balanced and went to the beat, without losing the visuals. A very nice video.
And the lovely Troughton! That's a great clip! I also really liked the 'rumbling' and 'hard to steer' references to the Tardis, that whimsical old girl.. ;)
Excellent. I love, love, love the clip with Patrick you chose at the beginning. My only complaint would be, and this is somewhat hard to articulate, that you cut so often between different scenes (and sometimes in the same scene) that it gets a bit disorienting.
That's exactly what I was trying to say. But it seems I chose my words in the wrong way. Well, at least someone else saw what I was trying to explain. :D
i actually had to make an effort to stop my lip from shaking! wonderufl vid, great choice of song and you used some of the BEST clips from the new and old series...loved it!
ALL OF THE FEELINGS.
myopicfriend 2 months ago
I just came from the video BabelColour did for this same song and I can't decide which one of the two is my favorite! This is a fantastic video!
JennyWildcat 3 months ago
i just cant get enough of this song :D
annafrancan 4 months ago
I'd like to echo what @farshnuke said. Babelcolour- THE Babelcolour- did a DW tribute to this song and this one still absolutely holds its own against it- is an equal to it- is still my favorite DW fanvid ever. Wow.
AceofGallifrey 5 months ago
I just came from Babelcolour's take on this song and yours is just as magnificent.
farshnuke 5 months ago in playlist Videos from Calapine
absolutely loved it!
vilmod 5 months ago in playlist vilmod's Favorited Videos
Man, I can't stop watching this. Even years after seeing it for the first time, it is STILL the best Doctor Who video out there. = )
NicxCoay 6 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Romana..... I CAN'T STAND THAT STUPID TIMELADY!!!!!!! RAHHHHHH!!!!!!!!
20meerkat 7 months ago
@20meerkat how could you not like Romana? she was like, the one of the best companions ever! let me guess...you like Rose?
thebaloobearbeat 6 months ago
@20meerkat So I take it your a Rose fan?
DFTWProductionsLTD 5 months ago
Brilliant!
touristemily 8 months ago
what happened to the first what about everything vid? that was my fav of every vid on youtube.
vanillabean1215 10 months ago 5
@vanillabean1215 I agree, I'm going a bit mad now trying to find it...!
EdiePryde 5 months ago in playlist What About Everything?
This is absolutely brilliant! Really made me smile, really also made me think of all the tragic stuff in this long, crazy show. And I loved it.
mygeeklife 10 months ago
I've turned this (incredible) vid into a game- I try to call out the character or the episode each clip is from as it appears on-screen. So far, no one has beat me at this game. I am proud of this, and I LOVE this video!
AceofGallifrey 1 year ago
what ep is :49 from? 2nd Doctor cried? Whaaaaat? So sad!
MandaMeena 1 year ago
Just thought I'd pop back and drop another comment on here, because I have watched this video now about forty times, and it's STILL awesome.
And suddenly, it occurred to me, that I could identify every single episode from which the clips came. Goal of being a real Whovian: accomplished!
LaraElSupergirl 1 year ago 2
@LaraElSupergirl Exactly. I'm mostly 4/Romana, but I do love some 8/Romana. Or 6 or 7 or just about any Doctor. But mostly 4... And 8....
NicxCoay 1 year ago
I couldn't have said it better than maketheworldnicer did. This was AMAZING. The fact that you included Liz Shaw- who always seems to get forgotten- makes it just that better. And having Ace and Martha on screen within seconds of each other? I think you might have blown up the internet from too much awesome in too small a time frame!
Gorgeous, and a great tribute to the BEST show.
LaraElSupergirl 1 year ago 2
Wow. Excuse me while I get my n00b self some more Classic Who. This vid is already amazing with my small knowledge of old series. I bet it would be a million times better after I shotgun a bunch of old episodes.
PeterRabid 1 year ago 6
it's a little bit too literal, but it's a common, easy trap for fanvideos to fall into. sometimes it's just too tempting! and I feel like the clips always changed too fast. Enjoyable and fitting, however. :)
LadyAdokenai 1 year ago
Thank you for combining my two favorite things: Carbon Leaf and Doctor Who! This is really well done. :)
eclecticavatar 1 year ago
Excellent job. Bravo.
Brigadierbob 1 year ago
....
Excuse me while I die of fangirlish glee.
SciFiFangirlsFTW 1 year ago
This is one of the finest doctor who vids. I can't stop watching it.
ImaTimeLord 1 year ago 2
This continues to be the best vid in the history of anything ever.
lithrae1 1 year ago
This is so beautiful. An incredible tribute to a wonderful show : D
Whoventures 1 year ago 2
This video ranks right up there with the best of Seduff or Babelcolour; indeed, one of the best Doctor Who fan videos ever made :)
barnabascrowe 1 year ago
Absolutely fantastic video. :)
raevyn17 1 year ago
I really love this video, I can't think of this song without thinking of Doctor Who know! I liked your first version too, is there anyway of getting ahold of it?
theforthwright 1 year ago
WOW!!
It's amazing how well these lyrics fit the Doctor!
The Ring
Aliens
That midnight phonecall...
im903yearsold 1 year ago
The Doctor and Jamie at 3:43 - 3:45 Classic:)
im903yearsold 1 year ago
Actually, I'm going to change my mind about the too many clips. The Sarah Jane sequence from 1:26 to 1:35 is lovely. :)
penguinsloveDW 1 year ago
I might have to agree with the "too many clips" people; but the way the clips flow together with movements carrying on from one to another? Masterful, absolutely masterful. It must have taken you forever to edit them so precisely.
penguinsloveDW 1 year ago
what happened to the original ? that was awesome : )
york68 1 year ago
A fitting tribute to the best Television Series of all time. As the Ninth Doctor would say: Fantastic!
Kaagh178 1 year ago
This is amazing. Really well done, a great song, and just awesome. I love seeing all of the Doctors in one video, along with pretty much every Companion and major Villain, except you did seem to leave off Roberts!Master, Corpse!Master, and the Rani. Just something I noticed. Still, I love that you ended on Four/Romana. It's just so right. They really are the true pairing in Doctor Who. Time Lord Love. = )
NicxCoay 1 year ago 2
@NicxCoay Amen about EVERYTHING you just said. Four + Romana (or, for that matter, any Doctor + Romana) = OTP!
LaraElSupergirl 1 year ago
Wow... just wow. You actually gave time to all the doctors. The clips were amazing, well timed. Wow.
MantisSage 1 year ago
This is a really good video. You have pretty much everybody in it. I love that you ended on Four and Romana. Great job.
NicxCoay 1 year ago 3
I love this song, and I love that you did such a beautiful homage to all the Doctors, BUT, and I make this critique with the greatest of respect, your cuts are too fast. You need to cut your clip count in half. The clips move by so fast it detracts from the video as a whole.
I am enjoying your other videos very much, but please remember, sometimes "less is more". :)
DrMLoveless 1 year ago
I miss your first one but this is fantastic and it really captures the essences of Doctor Who. Are we going to see a third one...?
Robert60384 1 year ago
I love this-thankyou!
RuthFL 1 year ago
I kind of miss the first one you did, Calapine, but this is brilliant too. You were the first person to connect this song with Doctor Who, weren't you? It's perfect. I picked up that album because of your fanvid.
1michelemichele1 2 years ago
It's brilliant , and yet strange that it all started with something you'd never get away with today; a couple of teachers following a fifteen-year-old girl home.
ApocalypseNext 2 years ago
@ApocalypseNext whoooooooo i looove this song :D
LucariosOnlyFan 1 year ago
That was brilliantly done, a great song too!
dancingmonkey08 2 years ago 3
I don't know who Doctor Who is, but I'm a huge Carbon Leaf fan.
CrazyCarl1992 2 years ago
Carl - get into Dr Who - you don't know what yoou've missed over the years!
Majocu 2 years ago 7
@CrazyCarl1992 Boy, have you missed out! Where have you been, hidding in a cave somewhere? Doctor Who is the longest running Science Fiction TV series ever, older than even Star Trek. In 2013 Doctor Who will be 50 years old, I wonder what the BBC will do to celebrate that?
LoriCiani 1 year ago
Oh, man, this version is wonderful. I love both <3333 but this one, for some reason, I got all teary in the multi-doctor scenes, particularly old!Five raising his hat.
dragoncat 2 years ago
Great video! The really brings back memories of my wonder years!
coloneljackmustard 2 years ago
Very good. The best of your Doctor mash-ups so far.
4isling 2 years ago
BRILLIANT. I loved the audio clip of the Second Doctor at the beginning - what a line. I especially adored the edited clips of Eight and Romana, which I imagine was used to represent the Time War - it was very well done.
1SHAZ1 2 years ago 4
just amazing. best doctor who music video ive ever seen
Cyclonius49 2 years ago
Best. Fan. Video. EVER.
54spiritedwill54 3 years ago
IAWTC!
lessrest 3 years ago
Ah yes, so it is - thank you!
thedoctor1812 3 years ago
What's the clip with the green energy bolt and the TARDIS around 3:00, and who's in it?
thedoctor1812 3 years ago
I love that scene with number 2 grabing Jamie's hand and then throwing away realizing it's not Victoria's
DoctorWhoisit 3 years ago 2
Conratulations on making a great tribute to the greatest series EVER..."Doctor Who"!
What an amazing almost 50-years it's been...with plenty more amazing years to come! :)
Alan1701b 3 years ago
Very good, glad you have done a second one!
alanbowlermail 3 years ago 2
this is an awesome song this is epic man its great!!!!!
p.s u got good taste
phitenmen08 3 years ago
Brilliant! I want one with a cool opening speech from all ten, soon to be eleven.
gracechild1 3 years ago 2
U know there was one thing that i was quite wrong about. I said the other one was the best thing ive ever seen... Sorry this one tops it, but only just...
leviathon74 3 years ago 3
This is probably the best Doctor Who fan video on YouTube, and it really shows that Doctor Who is the greatest show ever.
maketheworldnicer 3 years ago 50
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you would think that Julia
3Spider1Monkey3 3 years ago
@maketheworldnicer If u like this vid than u should check out mine
Howyaduing 1 year ago
@maketheworldnicer Yeah this is right up there withthe 50th Anniversary Cinema trailer- except it has MORE classic Who clips in it!
LokianEule 4 months ago
Every time I watch this it gets better. I like the quantity of clips, it makes it fun to revisit, to let all the little things sink in. :)
lithrae1 3 years ago 3
THAT WAS AMAZING.
The editing was so superb, and the song was perfect. I LOVE it!!
DuchessAliana 3 years ago 5
Agreed!
RiderJetfire 3 years ago
My mother said this kind of made her want to watch all of Doctor Who. I think your work here is done. :)
starsfell 3 years ago 39
This first one was brillaint...But his one has John Simm in it. :).
Well done...Soon you'll have to do version 3 though. Aha.
Spoonicide 3 years ago
I'm actually not as crazy about the editing in this one - too many quick cuts - but I really love the footage you used this time. I love your videos!
xAnimatedEntropyx 3 years ago 2
Though I enjoyed this very much, I do agree with the comment on quick cuts. The first version seemed to linger on scenes more.. fit with the music more maybe? It isn't a particularly fast, energetic song after all.
Chaoticfinale 3 years ago
Your love for the subject matter shines through. Bravo, very well done.
BlakeCarlileITM 3 years ago 3
Brilliant, you must have gigs worth of clips hanging around to put all this together, and it's edited wonderfully (something which must have taken ages). Marvellous work.
tangerinealarm 3 years ago 2
Fantastic - the first vid was superb but you have outdone yourself with this one. :)
queerlybeloved 3 years ago 2
The criticism about "too many cuts" just beggars belief. Mozart would be appalled [/Amadeus reference]. The rapidfire nature of the video is just beautiful; Doctor Who has a lot of history, and you've captured the spirit of the song and the show with remarkable beauty. It's wonderful how you've given each era an equal amount of attention, with special emphasis on the most notable companions.
thecolourofherhair 3 years ago
this was a great video.
the only thing i can offer is that there might have been to many cuts. but thats a small critique. Great Work!
VoiceoftheEmpire 3 years ago 3
Best. Fan. Video. EVER.
codyw1 3 years ago 7
My god this keeps getting better...
usmc75 3 years ago 2
I think you out did yourself this time. Great job.
ogilviep 3 years ago 2
Bah, I love this one, even better than the first. I think you chose some slightly more affecting shots for some of the lines in the song. I love how Three's 'broken car' is now his TARDIS and how you showed Sarah Jane's 'future made'. Those were just two highlights for me among many. :)
EclecticMuse4 3 years ago
I've figured out what I don't like as much about this one - you've tried to fit too many clips in! You gotta let it flow, man.
Xyzzyka 3 years ago
I liked the first version better, personally. Least I'm pretty sure I did; hard to tell when you've taken it down. I'd still favorite them both though.
Xyzzyka 3 years ago
Magnificent, absolutely love this one and it's predecessor. I have showed this to some friends of mine and they all love it too...truly fantastic.
clomiancalcifer 3 years ago
I love the video! Just as good as the last What About Everything one was!
I like how you kept the clip with Jamie and the Doctor from the Tomb of the Cyberman as in your other video! (I love that scene :D )
draB102 3 years ago 2
Fantastic as usual!!!
Yarsian 3 years ago
Fantastic as usual!!!
Yarsian 3 years ago
Almost as brilliant as the first, and a damn good video in its own right! Have to agree that some of the clips went by too fast, but still great fun. Loved all the scenes the multi-Doctor eps, especially 5 tipping his hat from the ep of "Time Crash."
All in all, awesome stuff as always. :)
NATEdamnZ 3 years ago 4
*brain explodes*
classrule 4 years ago
I really love the new set of clips that you've chosen for this -- you did another exceptional job. STILL jonesing on the original of course.
thedorkygirl 4 years ago
this is brill! i just want to say i think the clasics are better than the new! more vilonce plz but not enuf to get ur self canceled! just saying. god that feels good to get that out my sistems lol! ( p.s im 11) go classics!
adriciscute3 4 years ago
I heartely agree! I was 10 when I first discovered the classics, now I'm 13 and I'm still loving them ^-^
mccoy4eva 3 years ago 3
This one was really good. What happened to your first version? That one was amazing!!!
vanillabean1215 4 years ago
Brilliant!
FlashForeward 4 years ago
Wonderful, felt the greater structure ie all the scenes of the Doctor versus the Master together, events on Gallifrey, all the Doctor reunions worked really well. Only criticism (constructive I hope)was some of the clips passed too quickly before I could even tell what they were
CelestialToymaker 4 years ago
This is a study in brilliant editing! I loved the first but I'm in love with this one. ;-)
And I'm so glad you didn't change the final scene with 4 and Romona2
boobabycluebaby2 4 years ago
Love it. Better then the first one [not that there was anything wrong with it]. Hope this one dosent get removed.
AsylumLawless 4 years ago
Loved it. I prefered the original, but that was good.
StefJR14 4 years ago
I remember the first one- I loved it so much. It was my favourite of favourite fan vids. I used to watch it for hours on end. Hope this one is just as good.
StefJR14 4 years ago
Absolutely amazing.
baffledking 4 years ago
Wonderful!
ladylucilla 4 years ago
Amazing.
dreemac 4 years ago
Fantabulous. :D
KilroyM 4 years ago
Oh, this was wonderful. Really, really cheering and uplifting and all about the love. Thank you so much.
snowgrouse 4 years ago 2
What a nice thing to wake up to! I wasn't anticipating any more videos from you until the new season. As usual, nice editing and a great selection of moments - and did you do something different with the encoding? It looks a lot sharper than usual.
jacobkosh 4 years ago
Wow. I never imagined you could top the last one. But you did. You did. Bless you.
LizaLeech 4 years ago
Loved Loved Loved! Ah, I love the short cuts between scenes. Such Brilliant Videos :)
DoctorWhoRocker 4 years ago
Absolutely brilliant!
maketheworldnicer 4 years ago
That was fantastic!
spikelilgirl 4 years ago
Not bad! I liked the original better, but I'm glad you included the latest stuff in there! Thank you, Calapine!
LilaKooks 4 years ago
Another great Vid, Calapine!! and I shared too...
5/5!
StelyDn 4 years ago
I thought I wasn't going to like it, because of the whole rebound factor, but this is just as good, perhaps even better.
CuteGallifreyian 4 years ago
Brilliant as ever.
Tardisrules 4 years ago
it's ok. a little too many clips, kinda hurts to have it switching all the time. :D but it's cool. But my favorited goes to your first version.
SoulRythm 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
your eyes are crap then
Tardisrules 4 years ago
now now, be nice. there's no need for insults. its a free country and critizm can be taken to anyone who cares to listen.
Besides, I said it was cool. which is why I gave it 5 stars either way. :)
SoulRythm 4 years ago
Dude, relax. Everyone's entitled to their opinion and I don't mind crit at all.
Calapine 4 years ago
@Calapine What ever happen to your first What about everything Video? do u still have it and if so can U upload it agien?
Howyaduing 1 year ago
It certainly did not switch Too rapidly! Some vids at times can do that, and this one verily didn't. It was all wonderfully balanced and went to the beat, without losing the visuals. A very nice video.
And the lovely Troughton! That's a great clip! I also really liked the 'rumbling' and 'hard to steer' references to the Tardis, that whimsical old girl.. ;)
Thanks for making this.
warg29 4 years ago
Excellent. I love, love, love the clip with Patrick you chose at the beginning. My only complaint would be, and this is somewhat hard to articulate, that you cut so often between different scenes (and sometimes in the same scene) that it gets a bit disorienting.
vargaboy 4 years ago 2
That's exactly what I was trying to say. But it seems I chose my words in the wrong way. Well, at least someone else saw what I was trying to explain. :D
either way, it's a wicked cool video!!!
SoulRythm 4 years ago
GREAT!!!!!!!!
(BTW If one looks the original is still out there)
Mascro1977 4 years ago
WOW
awesome vid!!!!!!!!!!!
SJAtributes 4 years ago
The first one was awesome. This one is mega-super-duper-stupendous awesome.
Fives and favores.
DarthBombshell 4 years ago
Fantastic video tribute!!! Love it!!! Incredibly moving!!!
What a amazing phenomenon this program is! 45-years of amazing TV! It is an absolute delight and pleasure to be a fan of "Doctor Who"!
Alan1701b 4 years ago
i actually had to make an effort to stop my lip from shaking! wonderufl vid, great choice of song and you used some of the BEST clips from the new and old series...loved it!
Genne 4 years ago
OMG! AWSOME! Perfect in everyway. The clips were well chosen, the track was sweet and very fitting. Snappy editing. Loved it!!!!!
xebecatt 4 years ago
Yes!!!!!!! I loved the first incarnation of this - and number two is even better.
*favourites*
faithlessone423 4 years ago
First comment! First comment! *flails and squees* awesome bloody vid once more.
kesomon 4 years ago