reply to refutation of dr. Israr Ahmad(urdu only)

[nokia5095007]

i m not satisfy with this Answer

[adeelalam084]

as long as u remain civilized u have every right to disagree with me..

thanks

[zo0mmax]

mujhe lagta hai k kesi b firqa main nahi parna chahye

pata nahi hum loog q firqo par bahis karte hain

aaj muslims ithne divide hain es ki bari wajha yahi firqay hain

[harmonicamajor]

and actually whoever said that Dr. Isar's aqeedah is that of Salafi, he is the MOST ignorant person. Salafi's will clearly denounce Allama Iqbal as a Sufi and Quaid e Azam as a kaafir. According to Salafis if someone likes these personalities, his aqeeda is messed. I do agree that Quaid e Azam's character is a bit shady and that Iqbal was Sufi-oriented. But I will take whatever good Iqbal had to say.

[harmonicamajor]

very nice and open-minded video! pakistani people have narrow-mindedness and they think that if I liek some quality in a kaafir then I become a kaafir!!! astagfriullah

[farz72]

New comment 8. You should remember this al-Firqatun Naajiyah (the Saved Sect) are few among the people. Allah’s Messenger prayed for them in the following words: “Tooba (a tree in Paradise) is for the Strangers †the people who are righteous among a people who are mostly wicked, those who disobey them are more than those who obey them.”[1]

And Allah says in the Qur’aan: "But few of My servants are grateful.” [Soorah as-Sabaa (34): 13]

[farz72]

New Comment 6. If you see on his website a topic on Shirk( 5 PDF small files) you will find introduction of Wahdatul Wajood and the people of his source of inspiration are not the Salf Saleheen but they are the people of Tasawwuf which are refuted and criticize by all. Also he has never refuted any Jamaat in a clear cut way in the light of Quraan and Shahee Ahadeeth. It shows that all are correct near him and this is a great fitnah of this age. See my comm continuation so will understand.

[farz72]

New comment 5. You should think that if people are criticizing him, then there is something wrong. He might be using his mind more and in other way, than the way of Salf al Saleh. Dont say that he has done a lot again and again. What he has done if accepted then he will get Hasnaat. Dear brother I will advice you not be impressed by the hardship and sacrifices of people. But see what they are selling in the name of Deen.

[adeelalam084]

bro..the people r also criticizing your group..infact everyone is criticizing each other!

so i want to avoid this whole stuff...have my aqeeda and than do something for the religion..i m not that much interested in minutes theological details for now...becoz they just cause difference..btw do u know that even salafis differ each other and call each other deviant?...i can name some of them if u want!

[farz72]

New comment 4. You should remember the saying of the Messenger - SallAllaahu alayhi wa sallam:

The Jews had split up in to 71 sects and the Christians had split up into 72 sects, and my nation will split up into 73 sects all of whom will be in the fire except one. The Companions asked, Which one O Messenger of Allaah? He replied: The Jamaaaah. In another narration: What I am upon and my Companions are upon.. You can understand this groups will include their Head also.

[farz72]

New com3. I think you have not understood thisAqeedah of Wahdatul Wajoodwhich comes from Hinduism and Christianity as you said what if he is having different thinking in this matter. It is like you do 99 good thinks and at the same time oneShrirkand this will destroy all your good effort. I will advice you to study one story in one Deobandi Book Tazkiratul Rasheed about a prostitute and then this matter will be clear to you and you will realize the seriousness and deviation of Dr. Israr.

[farz72]

New Comment 1. It seems you have enough time to defend these people and making videos for them. You forgot that this is the tradition of Salf Al Saleh to denounce what is wrong. If they do not do this, then how ordinary people will know that what is right and what is wrong. I advice you to study some nice books on Tasawwuf and see how dangerous the Aqeedah of Wahdatul wajood is. It is totally against the Aqeedah Tawheed what we get from Qura;an and Shahee Ahadeeth

[farz72]

New comment 2. As you said what is the problem if he is having that Aqeedah. No one will have problem as long as he is not spreading this Kufr/ Shirk in Muslims in the name of Dawate Islam. This Aqeedah of Wahdatul Wajood which comes from Tasawwuf is the basis of all types of shirk in most of the groups/ Jamaats in our countries. If they are treated as deviated sects then of course his Jamaat also comes in the same category.

[farz72]

New Com. 1

[farz72]

Comment 18. From this point many of the sects of old and new have deviated, when they did not pay heed to the evidence in the previous Ayah, and to the significance of the hadeeth of the Sunnah of the Rightly Guided Khulafaah, and likewise the hadeeth of the splitting of the Ummah.

[farz72]

Comment 17. Therefore, it is necessary for us and this being our situation - to constantly repeat always and forever this fundamental principle. If we intend to understand our Aqeedah, understand our worship, and understand our manners and behavior. It is necessary for us to return to our Salaf-us-Saalih to understand all these matters, which are necessary for a Muslim, so that he can actualize in himself - with sincerity that he is from the Saved Sect.

[farz72]

Comment 16. The proof from this hadeeth is also the same evidence from the answer of the Messenger - SallAllaahu alayhi wa sallam -about the previous question (about the 73 sects). In as much as he compelled his nation to follow the characteristics of his Companions due to their adherence to his Sunnah, and he did not limit it to just that, but rather he said: And the Sunnah of the Rightly Guided Khulafaah after me.

[farz72]

Comment 15. He said: I advise you to hear and obey, even if an African slave rules over you, and indeed whomsoever from you lives will see many differences, so hold on to my Sunnah and the Sunnah of the Rightly Guided Khulafaah after me, bite on to it with your molar teeth. To the end of the hadeeth.

[farz72]

Comment 14. What resembles this hadeeth perfectly in respect to its fruits and benefits - is the hadeeth of the Rightly Guided Khulafaah, which is narrated in the books of as-Sunnan from the narration of al-Irbaad bin Saireeyah - may Allaah be pleased with him. He said that the Messenger of Allaah - SallAllaahu alayhi wa sallam -gave us an admonition which caused hearts to tremble, and eyes to shed tears.

So we said, It is as if this is a farewell speech, so advise us O Messenger of Allaah!

[farz72]

Comment 13. But it is necessary, primarily to return in all of this back to what the Companions of the Prophet - SallAllaahu alayhi wa sallam -were upon, because they were which is clear from their traditions and their biographies the most sincere to Allaah Azza wa Jal in worship. They had more of an understanding of the Book and the Sunnah than us, and many other praise worthy characteristics with which they were shaped, and cultivated with its exquisite manners.

[farz72]

Comment 12. Therefore, it is not allowed for the Muslims generally and the callers to Islaam specifically - to be content with just understanding the Book and Sunnah using the means of understanding which are well known. Such as knowledge of the Arabic language, the knowledge of abrogated and abrogative texts and other such rules.

[farz72]

Comment 11. It is from his - SallAllaahu Alayhi wa Sallam  perfect kindness and his complete mercy for his Companions and his followers, that he - SallAllaahu Alayhi wa Sallam clearly illustrated for them the distinction of the saved sect. Which implies that the are people and companions of the saved sect are upon what the Messenger - SallAllaahu Alayhi wa Sallam was also upon, and what his Companions were upon after him.

[farz72]

Comment 10. Perhaps this would actually be sufficient for the Muslim who truly understands the Book and the Sunnah. But he - SallAllaahu Alayhi wa Sallam adapted practically Allaahs saying, when Allaah characterized His Prophet that he was:

"For the Believers he is full of pity, kindness, and mercy"

[farz72]

Comment 9. So we find the Prophet's answer, agreeing perfectly with the previous Ayah:

"Follows other than the path of the Believers"

Therefore, those who primarily enter into the generality of this Ayah are: the Companions of the Messenger - SallAllaahu alayhi wa sallam, since the Messenger - SallAllaahu alayhi wa sallam - was not content in this hadeeth with just saying: What I am upon..

[farz72]

Comment 8. You should remember the saying of the Messenger - SallAllaahu alayhi wa sallam:

The Jews had split up in to 71 sects and the Christians had split up into 72 sects, and my nation will split up into 73 sects all of whom will be in the fire except one. The Companions asked, Which one O Messenger of Allaah? He replied: The Jamaaaah. In another narration: What I am upon and my Companions are upon.

[adeelalam084]

and what was that way?..

the way was the struggle to dominate the deen of ALLAH subhana wata'ala hu and show poeple the islamic system of justice! Rasool ALLAH(SAW) is rahmatullilalameen..and one aspect of his rahmat is the system(sharia) and the way of life given to him by ALLAH..and this is what the Prophet(SAW) and the Sahabs struggled to spread!

its not just a mere aqeeda..its a whole way of life including economical,political and etc aspects of human life

[farz72]

Comment 7. It is not only sufficient for a Muslim to be sincere and serious in respect to acting with the Book and the Sunnah and calling towards it. But, in addition to this, his methodology should be correct, good and upright; and his methodology cannot be complete in itself except by following what the righteous Salaf of this Ummah were upon may Allaah be pleased with them all.

[adeelalam084]

dr sahab is following the methodology of Prophet(SAW)...he is calling poeple towards Quran and Islam and many many many people have left their older  lifestyle which was full of kuffar and they were earning lots of haram money with it..and now they have left everything,earning very less but halal are with dr Sahab and struggling for the deen of ALLAH..and this is something my brother! this is something!

[farz72]

Comment 6. Dear Brother

Assalamu Alaikum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barkatahu

This is a knowledgeable refutation of Dr. Israr which deals with Aqeedah. Hence it should be handled by Dr Israr himself and it does not require your video posting. Even you do not know the Aqeedah of Wahdatul Wajood which he is having.

[adeelalam084]

by the way..i know pretty much what this aqeeda is and dr Sahab is against it too...atleast the commoon understanding of this aqeeda which u can find amongst common people and not scholars..

[farz72]

Comment 5. From amongst these types of people, there may be some who may very well in the depths of their hearts be righteous and sincere people. However, this alone is not sufficient for its possessor to be successful and for one to prosper with Allaah Azza wa Jal. Due to this it is necessary for the Muslim to combine two points:

• Having truthful sincerity in ones intention, with Allaah Azza wa Jal.

• Following correctly what the Prophet - SallAllaahu alayhi wa sallam - was upon.

[adeelalam084]

here i want to ask a question..is there any movement from those who claim to follow Aslaf?

please show me one movement from u people working politically(which is an essential part of Islam!) and trying to dominate the deen of ALLAH?..i know u people do preaching and i love it..i m the fan of many of those who call themselves assalafiya(although it is wrong as salafi means a dead rightious person if i m correct!)

bro again...do not restrict the things

[farz72]

Comment 4. The Messenger - SallAllaahu Alayhi wa Sallam - emphasized this section of the noble Ayah:

"follows other than the path of the believers"

He - SallAllaahu alayhi wa sallam - emphasized it by using an eloquent emphasis, in more than just one authentic prophetic ahadeeth.

[farz72]

Comment 3 From this point, numerous groups, old and new deviated because they never sufficed themselves to adhering to the path of the Believers. Instead, they rode on their own intelligence. Instead, they followed their own desires in trying to understand the Book and the Sunnah. Then they built upon their desires, their very dangerous results, and with that they left what the Salaf-As-Saalih may Allaah be pleased with all of them- were upon.

[farz72]

2. It seems that you are not aware of the importance of Manhaj of salf al Saleh so you are wasting your time in defend these people. I am sending these comments so that you can understand what is Manhaj. This is the tradition of Salf al Saleh to denounce what is wrong. These comments I am sending in order for your information.

[adeelalam084]

second thing..Dr sahab follows the manhaj of As Salafiya...and plz keep in mind that amongst the sahabs there were all type of people..there was Abu Bakar Sidiqque (RA) who said on the death of Propeht(SAW): whoever worships the Prophet should know that he is no more but whoever worships ALLAH should know that ALLAH is ever living(sorry if i mistranslated!)...and there was Umer(RA) who said: whoever says that Prophet(SAW) is dead..ill kill him!

(continue)

[adeelalam084]

post-3:

so u see that even sahabs had different metalities..but the were one when it came to spread Islam and when it came to the dominance of deen of ALLAH..

i have listened dr Sahab for over 2000 hours! and he often apraises the manhaj of salafi infact in oen of his lectures he even said that those who dont follow it spread a fitna..and he himself follows the manhaj of as salafiya(which is nt like" one straight line"..there were sahabs who practised Islam different than the others (continue)

[adeelalam084]

post-4:

and this simmply prooves that there can be more than one ways to understand the things) one famous example:

hazrat Ali(RA) said that Rasool ALLAH(SAW) saw ALLAH on the occaision of Meraj... hazrat Ayesha(RA) said that no can see ALLAH and whoever says so (and she said a bit more!)"..now who is right?..one of them is making mistake but its not deliberate ..its just a matter of opinion and Islam allows this..there existed always multiple opinions amongst sahabs too!

[farz72]

In post 4 you are wrong again and you have misunderstood the things. It is not necessary that every one should be a scholar but we should know the basics of Deene Islam. What is proved from Shahee Hadeeth has been accepted which is the case of Amma Aaeysha RaziAllahu Taala Anha hadeeth about seeing Allah Subhanahu Taala on the day of Meraj of Nabi (SAS). It is not the case of different of opinions but the case of authenticity of Hadeeth.

[adeelalam084]

post5:

the problem is that u want to understand it in a particular way which supports the aqeeda adopted by as-salafiyah...

dr sahab based his opinion on sound verses and references and by the way Shah Waliullah(RA) also had the same aqeeda about Arwah!

[farz72]

1. Brother you should study the history of sects in the light of Quraan and Sunnah and instead of promoting Dr. Israr ,promote the Manhaj of Salf al Salih. Following or not following the path of the Believers is a very important matter in relation to complying or denying that path. So whosoever follows the path of the Believers, then he is successful with the Lord of the worlds and whosoever differs from the path of the Believers, then Hell is sufficient for him and what an evil destination.

[adeelalam084]

assalamoalaikum brother

i know one thing...there arnt many people in pakistan and all over the muslim world who r struggling for the dominance of deen of ALLAH in the way dr Sahab is doing

second the one who preaches and calls others to Quran can never be GUMRAH(losse the straight path)...and dr sahab has been doing this and he even sacrificed his whole medical carrier for this cause..not many people do that!

[shiapigs]

long live DR ISRAR

HE is the best

shia kafir muttah ki gandi nasal per lanat beyshumaaaaaaaaaaaaar

[muneer2908]

thanks for this audio bro ...to those people who says that "Dr. Sahab should be refuted because he follows and is very close to maulana maududi" ..this cause is just absurd and stupid. Maulana Maududi was a great servant to Islam. He had a clear view of Islam and a great target of achieving khilafah. May be he would have some mistakes but it does'nt mean people should forget his great work.

[esrimi]

dr israr ahmed is a great scholar of islam ...he has done more to uplift islam more than any of us ...may ALLAH bless him and give him ajar-e-azeem

[muneer2908]

aameen ...

[chviky]

Dear Muslim Bro and sis please listen to the links to find whats going on in the world, leave these baseless and nonsense shias on their own. ALLAH Has putted a seal on their heart as a reward of badmouthing and shirk!

just add

tanzeemarchive (dot) org

Before the links

/tanzeemeislami/Misc/yahood%20­quran%20aur%20hum.ra

/tanzeemeislami/Misc/dajjal%20­aur%20khwateen.ra

/tanzeemeislami/Misc/terrorinu­sa.ra

[bluemountain20]

This is the time when this Ayat was revealed that wives of Prophet Muhammad pbuh are your mother,now do not think even a,bout them once they come into the Nikkah of Prophet Muhammad pbuh.

Now,Adeel Alam,again did you understand the mentality,knowledge and vision of Sahabas and the true Shan-e-Nazool and reason of Ayat of Ummahatul-Momineen ?

And ofcourse again i presented the above Shan-e-Nazool of Ayat and interpretation from Ahley Sunah Book.

[bluemountain20]

Salam,

That` the knowledgewise dishonesty by th majority of Ulmeas of Ahley Sunnah brotehrs.

Now listen the reason for Wives of Rasool pbuh as Ummahat-ul-Momineen ,again as usual one of your Sahabi perhaps he is included in So Called Ashra-Mubashira ,while holy prophet pbuh was alive,that Sahabi insolently said that "now Muhammad pbuh makes his wives in Hijab all the time even before us,Quraish,Ok when he pbuh would die ,we will do Nikkah with his wives" ,then,holy prophet pbuh hurt.

[bluemountain20]

Do you wanna know who was he reallly that Insolent,Accursed Person ....?

Ummer Ibne Khattab..............holy prophet Muhammad pbuh expelled him from his Room before he died .... !

I will not say anything without Proof but your own books insha Allah.now see following and get yourself surprised :

1-Sahih Bkhuari (Vol-5 and Vol-3 repeatedly)

2-Sahih Muslim (Vol-2 Chapter Waseea)

[bluemountain20]

The man who denied Openly to Obey the Command of Holy Prophet Muhammad pbuh,while Allah says in Quran ,Muhammad pbuh is nothing but a Prophet all the time,Whatever my prophet gives it to you ,take it and whatever he forbids ,leave that.......Even Allah says ,my prophet does not utter a word without my Consent.....

[adeelalam084]

bro...i dont ever understand y did hazrat Ali(RA) co operated with hazrat Umer(RA) even if he was bad as u claim...y did he let him rule?...y did he do BAYT on his hand and y did hazrat Ali(RA) accept him as caliph?????...y didnt he stand up against Umer(RA) as imam hussain(RA) stood up against yazeed?

[bluemountain20]

The man who Insulted Last and Holy Prophet Muhammad pbuh even on his dying bed among several Sahabas......

The man who first time introduced Deviation and Disobediency of Quran and Sunnah ...

The man who even put blame on Holy Prophet pbuh as Mad ....saying rubbish...?(Astaghfirulah)

[bluemountain20]

We are followers of Ali ibne Abi Talib as ,Ali as who born into Holy Kaba where all Sunnis have to direct for their Namaz and Circle to make Hajj Valid .!

We are Folowers of Ali as,Ahley Bait as ,who never ever bowed their heads against Idols just as their beloved prophet Muhammad pbuh.

and You followers of Sahabas..

Sahabas who worshiped Idols for 30/40 years.

Who did Adultery,Zinna,Burreid Daughters.

Who even after Islam,Teased,Insulted,Disobeye­d ,Allah,Muhammad and Ahley Bait as.

[bluemountain20]

Abbasiali....

I wanted to talk to you and have knowledgeable discussion as Holy Prophet Muhammad pbuh did to preach others,to convince others with proof,logic,quran etc.

But...as people like you are Illegitmate Sons of Abdul Wahhab...and ...Muwiya ...

You do not understand polite language .

You need to be told your Suspicious Lineage unfortunately.

Still suggesting you to dare to talk to me direct and exchange our point of views.

And all other Sunnis, You Cowards,Talk Direct

[chviky]

All bad mouthers should now shut their Mouths. Dont spit on such a knowledgeable person who devote his whole life for QURAN. He is a Dr he could built anything for him in this world if he wants to waste his life like all of u. Matric pass Jahils are still criticizing a Real Student of QURAN. What a shame!!!

May ALLAH give Dr Israr More life and health!

[adeelalam084]

those who abuse him should first of all check their own charactors...how many people have come to "Quran" thprough their preaching....how many of those who abuse dr Israr have sacrificed their careers and professional life for Islam and try to divert epoople's attnetions to Quran...

[abbasiali28]

Read link below to find out who u ppl really are

JEWS

[abbasiali28]

jewishencyclopedia(dot)com/vie­w(dot)jsp?artid=189&letter=A

[bluemountain20]

Give me your msn ids or contact number !

[abbasiali28]

lol

What you gonna kill me/?

O follower of Abululu the damned

answer here

You have jewish background

keep on deleting conspiracy minded suckers

Abdullah bin Sabah will rot in hell with Abululu INSHAALLAH

[bluemountain20]

Dear Abbasiali28,

First one is a Wall of Sand of your people against the Victorious Attack of Zulfiqar-e-Hyderi of Shiaane-e-Ali as Ibne Abi Talib as.

to lull and let your people in fragile dream.

And Second one was who ended the Second rule of Tyranny and Oppression of Encroachers onto the right of Ahley=Bait as,the right ordered by Allah himself and Announced by Holy Muhammad pbuh on many times and many occassions.

Any body who would like to dare to talk to me an Advocate of Allah ?

[viruscirus]

though you have heard this bastard israr ahmed blaiming hazrat ali (AS) for receiting the quran wrongly, even though you are supporting him. This guy (Israr Ahmed)is a real bastard, son of yazeed. Dont come with this bull shit. Go through Tarmizi and dig for your self regarding "Fazael" of Hazrat Ali.

[adeelalam084]

or y dont u first of all check the date of this video......this is from 23rd april ..and that programm was shown on 12nd june if i m correct...dude this is a response to salafis...my other videos r response to shias blaming dr Israr for something which he didnt do and through abusing (like u) showing me their iman

[adeelalam084]

12th..not 12nd

[sadafyasir]

adelbhai ur work is gr8 ,we r proud of u,ALLAH bless u

[adeelalam084]

thanks bro..ALLAH bless all of us with wisdom and openmindedness

[adeelalam084]

assalamoalaikum and i m sorry...u r a sis..not bro..

[bluemountain20]

Salam,

Swearing at someone is wrong ofcourse,whoever does that is totally wrong.

But the tyrant,lier and false person who voilated Quranic and Prophetic Clear orders,is a Crimanal and needs to be condemened always to keep prominent and seperate Haq and Quran which are only with Muhammad pbuh and His Holy Ahlu-Bait as .....from the path which is Na-Haq and against Quran.

We cannot immune anyone including Sahaba who did henious crimes ,we cannot treat them as Brahmans in Hindus are at large

[abbasiali28]

Dear blue mountain,

Just who is Abdullah bin Sabah(jewish) and Abu lulu(murderer)your baba in iran?

Face the facts

[bluemountain20]

I did say what you own books say.

And for your kind information, Abu Bakr was the person who initiated Torcher along with Ummer onto the holy family of Prophet Muhammad pbuh.He was never and cannot be ever,beloved by Holy Muhammad pbuh.

If you really think you are on right path, then,dare to speak to me direct over the phone or through msn.

give me your contact details,we will see.

Take care

Allah Hafiz.

Ya Mehdi as Al-Ajal Adrikni !

[sadafyasir]

bluemountain its really ashamed of u ppl coz u r still in darkness,n a thng is that u pl don wanna come in light,just gmme an answer y u ppl hve changed kalima TAUHEED,u ahletashi have added ur own kalimat in it?answer me y,is anybdy can dare tochange namaz as directed by sarwer-e-kaynaat HAZRAT MUHAMMAD(PBUH),BRO our religion doesnt allow to fight wd our fellow bro so humble request plz try to concieve a right meaning of islam n implement in ur lives.may ALLAH guide u(amin)

[YourDearFriend]

I invite all sincere muslims to read my blog to clarify the misconceptions that some may have:

propgandaagainstisrarahmedDOTb­logspotDOTcom

[adeelalam084]

ill b there bro..inshaALLAH

[manora007]

qiyamat key rooz sab logoon koo unn kii maa key naam key ssath pukara jayee gaa taa key koi haramzada sherminda naa hoo mager ALLAH ki qasam yeh hadis too tum logoo ki apni books mey hai RISAALETMAAB(SAWV) ney fermaya k sab logoo koo unn ki maa k naam k sath pukara jayee gaa mager YA ALI(as) tery shiyon koo unn k baap k naam k ssath pukara jayee gaa. plz think about it yaar tumharey molvi tum logoo ko esy hadis kiyo nahi sunatey meri jaan ye sub roti kaa cheker agley jahan mey molvi kam nahi aay

[adeelalam084]

yahan tum jo bhi kehna chahtay ho saaf safa keh do..maan k naam say aur shioon ko baap k naam say...aap kya kehna chah rahay ho?...

[bluemountain20]

Salam

What happened Adeel ?you are even not reply now

Only one Hadeese-e-Saqlain,Quran and Ahlul-Bait as from 17 top Ahley-Sunnah Books including 3 of Saha-Sitta books could not digest

Know Ahley-Bait

That`s the pain of Shias is and the Truth being hidden by Dr.Israr and others.

I have got lot to tell you about even Quran itself throught eyes of Ahlul Bait as....

Remember always,

Quran is such a safe whose Code number Holy Prophet Muhammad pbuh gave only to Ahlul-Bait as !

[nommocnezitic]

Pity on you, you are refuting the holy Quran which says that We have made it easy for you to understand. Also it says that we have opened it for you so is there anyone who shall ponder?

How can Allah give the code no. to any human being (not even to Holy Prophet)

You prove yourself to be leading a self proclaimed belief which has no link with Islam. We respect Ahl-i-bait, sahaba & Aal-i- rasool (mind you aal DOES NOT mean physical descendants as quoted by the Holy Prophet)

[adeelalam084]

i second to that..Quran asks everybody to consider it with care...and u dont need interpretations from others

[adeelalam084]

dr Israr isnt hiding anyting from us...tell me how many shiaas r being schooled about complete sunni school of thought in their darul alooms???????...similarly its not the duty of dr Israr to completely explain the Shia mazhab to everybody...he is doing his own job which of course is the right thing to do

[gulamt4]

abe shiya laug allah se daro aur har chhz min galt mat dekhaiye

[johnzaidi]

Please Dr. Israr ko kuch na kaho kiyon keh Dr. Israr Sahib Hazrat Yazeed (L.A) ki aulad mein sey hein. Please Muslim bhaio Dr. Israr ko kuch na kahon kiyon ke kasoor is ka nahin.

[superfly78614]

ye such baat hai ke israr yazeed ki aulad mae se hai? aap ko kasay maloom? aap ko kya 100% yakeen hai ke israr yazeed ke aulad mai se hain?

[abbasiali28]

All should see this link how Abdullah bin Sabah(son of a jew)misled muslims

jewishencyclopedia(.)com/view.­jsp?artid=189&letter=A

[abbasiali28]

Abu Lulu stabbed Hazrat Umar(R.A) to death.Today, the modern day Shia venerate Abu Lulu, and they call him "Baba Shuja-e-din" which can be translated as "Honored Defender of Religion." These Shia have a shrine erected for this murderer, located in the Iranian city of Kashan called the Abu Lulu Mausoleum wherein he is buried. The Shia travel from far distances to pray inside this shrine, and many of the Shia fast on the day that Hazrat Umar(R.A) was killed, and even pass out sweets

[abbasiali28]

Jew by the name of Saba bin Shamoon (whose son would be Abdullah Ibn Saba, the notorious founder of the Shia movement). Saba despised the Muslims who had expelled the Jews on charges of conspiracy. All three of these individuals--Harmuzan the Zoroastrian, Jafeena the Christian, and Saba the Jew--belonged to peoples who had grievances against the rise of Muslim dominance

They hired Feroz Abu Lulu, a Persian, who had recently been captured by the Muslims as a POW(a slave under a Muslim master)

[bluemountain20]

If Ali as says himself,i was feed up by Muhammad pbuh as a Sparrow instill food into its kids.

Ali as says himself ,i was all the time with Prophet Muhammad pbuh as a kid of Camel remains all the time with camel,morning,evening,eating,s­leepting etc

If Ali as is to be blamed for Drinking,It means Muhammad pbuh is blamed too as he was the person who was teaching him all the life till his death.

Think and ask me more about Ali as before uttering a word against him and hurting Muhammad Soul

[bluemountain20]

And without Ahlul-Bait as Quran cannot be understand fully,Quran says itself Ask Those Who Are Learned and Ahlul-Bait as are the most learned among Ummah after Holy Muhammad pbuh.

How a Sahabi can be equal to Ahlul-Bait as when all main Sahabis did Idolworshiping,Drinking,Adulte­ry etc before Islam, but Ahlul-Bait as did never even before Islam.

Ali as is Imam,an Individual of Ahlul-Bait ,not a Sahabi.Sahabi has to believe in him to become a Momin.

Ali has been brought up by Muhammad!

[bluemountain20]

Salam to all,

Miss Zainab specially and all other muslims,you must need to understand the difference between Sahaba and Ahlul-Bait as.

They are not same,they cannot be same.

How a Sahabi can equal to those Ahlul-Bait as ,when a Sahabi has to send Darood on Ahlul-Bait as.

How a Sahabi can equal to Ahlul-Bait as ,when Allah himself shows his intention to keep Ahlul-Bait as Pious from all evils etc.

[adeelalam084]

bawjood iss k k main nay aap jaisay logoon k liye aik poori video post ki hay..jis main aap loog khud sun saktay hain k dr sahab nay hazrat Ali(RA) ko hazrat Umer(RA) say bhi ooncha maqam diya hay aur un ko shakar-e-risalat kaha hay...aap loog phir bhi un ki niyat per shak ker rahy hain..shias ka yahi rawaiya raha hay k woh dil ki baatain jo k sirf ALLAH janta hay , un ko jaanay k daway daar ban jatay hain..ALLAH -o-akbar

[bluemountain20]

Salam,

Brother,you have not been told yet who Ahlul Bait as are !

First you have to know Ahlul-Bait as from eyes of Quran ,Hadeeth and their own words,then,i will ask you how can this be real.

I hope,we will have next session soon,insha Allah,if you are lover of Ahlul-Bait as.

Tell me please,when you get free time ,which day is your off etc.

I am waiting eagerly !

I may call you over the phone too,if it is easy for you.

Take care.

Allah Hafiz.

Ya Mehdi as Al-Ajal Adrikni !

[abbasiali28]

/watch?v=q2RJGnU9Kt0

A clear picture showing Shias abuse on companions of Hazrat Muhammad (S.A.W)

Dr sahab pe ilzaam aisay hai

jaisa ulta choor kotwal to daantay

[sadafyasir]

i agree abbasali

[bluemountain20]

If you are truly strong believer and on a right path.

Then,speak to me direct.

I will tell you the dishonesty of Dr.Israr and all others in history.

Would wait for your reply.

Take care

Allah Hafiz.

Ya Mehdi as Al-Ajal Adrikni !

[industani5]

deewane pane ke daleele dena chod,

All sunni,shia and even wahabis have a big reputation of HAZRAT ALI

WHO THE HELL YOU THINK COMMENT ON THIS

BLOODY IDIOT,STUPID AUR B-A-S-T-A-R-D

[adeelalam084]

yaaar yeh meri 3 months purani video hay jis main main nay kissi aur baat per dr sahab ki taraf say explanation di hui hay...iss ki tareekh dekho..23rd april!!!!

uss waqt tak to yeh waqiya bhi nahi hua tha

[adeelalam084]

yaaar yeh meri 3 months purani video hay jis main main nay kissi aur baat per dr sahab ki taraf say explanation di hui hay...iss ki tareekh dekho..23rd april!!!!

uss waqt tak to yeh waqiya bhi nahi hua tha

[LadooCrew]

Reply 1, Dr israr is a Illeterate nasiby whose Knowledge on hadith and rijal is questionable, He is of wahabhi salafi deobandi faction whose hatred for ahle bait is beyond recongnition, shah moinuddin ahmed nadwi addrese's this lie in his book " sayyidina ali al murtaza" page 108 published by idara islamiyat lahore- karachi pakistan, he after mentioning, tirmidhi and ibn dawud says, "it was not considered a sin but ofcourse against the morals. But the other narration do not confirm it

[LadooCrew]

reply 2 "THAT HE EVER TASTED LIQOUR. This is the reason we do not accept such a narration authentic." he then reveals the reason why it is a fabricated hadith, the shah says , " The real fact is that the last narrator of this hadith was in the begining a supporter of sayyidina Ali (ra) but later on he became his oponent and joined the fold of the supporters of sayyiduna uthman." I.e muwaiya and other nasiby and Co,. when acording to sahih muslim and tirmdihi itself to Love Ali is faith and

[LadooCrew]

Reply3 to hate Imam Ali is a sighn of hypocrasy how can we accept a narration of a nasiby it defies even the logic of ilm al rijal of the ahle sunnah. shah ahmed nadvi also of same faction as dr israr then says , " Now Mustadarak of hakim is also available and through this explanation, it is clear Ali told this story of being drunk ABOUT SOME OTHER MAN BUT HIS OPPONENT PUT THE NAME OF SAYYIDINA ALI THERE".. AND ALI (AS) LIKE ALL AHLE BAIT IS MAHFOOZ ACORDING TO SUNNIS FROM EVERY KIND OF RIJS

[LadooCrew]

Reply4 alcohol is a type of rijs ,dirt filth , so either Allah, (swt) desire or promise (Quran 33:33) whatever you wish to call it is not true then you become munkir eh Quran, or as stated in "siyyidina ali al murtaza " by Shah moinuddin ahmed nadvi page 108 is true that its a fake fabricated hadith by a enemy of maula Ali (as) and evrything i,e your iman is intact we the Followers of Muhammed and Ahl Muhammed (as) Reject anything which is against established proof from Quran.

[LadooCrew]

Reply5 as for Your confusion he is salafi , and wahabhi, NO question he appears on wahabhi chanells like peace Tv and islam channel Tv, he qouted al bani as his reference in his speech on Imam Ali (as) YOu prat al bani is the head or kingpin of modern day salafies, Name me one sunni alim that looks upto albani its pure Wahbhism, and what many prats dont realise is israr qouted a few books like tirmidhi and ibn dawud, it dont mean its different hadith its the same one, WITH a NASIBY IN the CHAIN

[Taqwa110]

doc israr kon hey islam ko budelney wala ye abujehel hey-islam ye nahen keheta jo achi lagey wo ley lo--jo rasool ney deen diea qieamet tek k liey hey

[tahir843]

zalim aadmi to to gya ree.

tere sath jo ho ga wo sab qyamat ke din dekheinn gein. jazak Allah.

[adeelalam084]

tahir...yaar meri video dekho jis ka title hay

"dr israr Ahmad's thoughts on hazrat Ali(ra)"

[karachi99]

*Brothers & Sisters*

Hazrat Ali or Deegar Sahaba ki taazeem har musalman per frz hay.

Dr. Israr's clip was from dars of Soorah Nisah Ayat43, he quoted Tirmizi Sharif, this riwayat is also mentioned in Sunan Abu Dawood sharif, Tafseer Ibne Kaseer, Tafseer Ibne Jareer, Majmooa-e- Ahadeeth e Sahiha of Allama Nasir uddin Albani & in famous Tafseer of Mufti Muhammad Shafi.

Yeh waqiah sharab ki hurmat say pehlay ka hay,

Is waqiayh say Hazrat Ali (RA) ya kisi or sahabi ki shan per koi hurf nahi aata

[gappub]

Good job !

[pakistani1989]

adeela alam u r just a sectarian violence creator ...moreover in past it was yazid the beast and today's its dr zakir naik and dr israr ahmed ................ well, there places iz only hell .

[adeelalam084]

no it isnt...ALLAH is "AL-ADL"

everybody makes mistakes..but it deosnt mean that becoz of one mistake he or she is going to hell although he has been serving Islam for his whole life(dr Israr) and is still serving Islam

[waseemsg]

Ager in sahab ne jo mun chupa ker Dr. Israr ki himyat ki hai, woh surah-e-aaraf phar lain, zalim ka sath dene wala aur zulm dekh ker khamosh rehne wala bhi zalim hoota hai, aur Allah kabhi zalim ko hidayat nahi kerta

[adeelalam084]

waseemsg..i posted a new video

"Doctor Israr Ahmad's thoughts about Hazrat Ali(RA)" check it out please

[geemanigee]

Khatam-e-paak ka halwa Haram!!

Sharab Tonic!!!

Kistarah ka islam hai

[geemanigee]

double standard loog, adahi book theek hai adhi book wrong iska kiya matlab hai

[adeelalam084]

dude..there is something which is called JUST(insaaf)...and it is not necessary to agre wit everybody's every statement....and on the basis of one statement it isnt also suitable to hate him...people hate molana Moududi for his criticism on hazrat Usman(RA)...and that was wrong , he shouldnt have done it..but he has also doen lots of good work and one can take advantage from is work like tafheem-ul-Quran

[adeelalam084]

only Quran is the perfect book...everything else contains mistakes...so it is not obligatory to beleive in everything in a book except Quran

[geemanigee]

Humain sharam aati hai, jab doctor ki baat aiyee tow sirf Quran Sacha ha,

Tum log Ab Ahle-Hadees ki tarah Ahle-Quran ho gayee ho. . . .

jis Scholor ko yeh he nahi pata keh quran main SHARAB KEY TAZKARAY MAIN NAFAY KI BAAT KIS LIYEE HOWI HAI WOH HUMAIN KIYA SAMJAYEE GA...

NAFA KI BAAT KA MATLAB TONIC NAHI BALKA UN LOGGON KEH LIYEE NAFA JIN KA SHARAB KA PURANA BUSINESS THA AUR ROZGAR MUNSLIQ THA

SHAME ON YOUR UNDERSTANDING OF HOLY & GLRIOUS QURAN. . . .

[adeelalam084]

mani.ALLAH k banday.jao ja ker kissi doctor say pooochu.ya kissi gooray say chat kero jo k thanday mulk main rehta hay...woh tumhain bataye ga k sharaab main waqai kuch fawaid hain..na sirf business ki wajah say balkay yeh aap kay jism ko garam rakhti hay...(continue)

[adeelalam084]

i m living in germany currently and i have talked to many people and they told me that while working on the roads in winter they drink(minor quantitiy of) alcohol to keep their bodies warm..now i dont know upto which extent this statement is true..but sharaab has this TONIC sort of advantage in it

[geemanigee]

dr sahib ki fiqar hai, apni nahi

[geemanigee]

you all are sulfi

[adeelalam084]

do u still think that i m a salafi after listening to this one?????

[bluemountain20]

Your mother even did not fear lying ot Holy Prophet Pbuh ,Allah in Holy Quran condemned her ........

And Even threatened to divorce her ....

And put all these in form of Verse of Quran to read by all Billions of Muslims till Judegement day and know truth about Her.

[geemanigee]

shut your mouth

[bluemountain20]

And none of the mother including the mothers of all prophets of Allah can reach to the status of Chairperson of Ladies of Paradise Fatima Zahra as...!

Your mother teased Fatima Zahra as many times.

Your mother gave false witness in way of Encroaching Garden of Fadak given by Prophet himself on order of Allah by Quranic verse.

Your mother Jubilate on Martyrdom of Fatima Zahra as and Ameerul-Momineen Ali as ,go and read your Books first.

Your mother is a Killer of Hundreds of Sahabas.

[adeelalam084]

bro...just a question..u called Ayesha(RA) my mother..i accept that...tell me one thing..why does Quran call her the mother of moumineens?????????..didnt ALLAH know that she is going to do what u r accusing her of?...ALLAH still called the mother of moumineens...y do u reject Quran by not calling her your mother too???????

[bluemountain20]

Mr, Adeel Alam,

Would you like to listen the Hadeeth from the mouth of your own mother about the Sexual Organ of a Na-Mahram person ?

[geemanigee]

tu dr sahib ka potra hai bachu

[adeelalam084]

lol......nahi yaar...main un ka pota nahi hoon

[geemanigee]

go and enjoy till the day of judgment

[Kerbalae224]

MR.Youtube pay Yeah Video Upload kerna Asan hai Pehlay apny baap dada ka hasab nasab daikhlo k shayad wooh bhee sharaab tu nahi peety thay.Hazart Ali(a.s)k liyea Abby tumhari badnasi yeahi hai k tumko HAQ ko samjhna hi nahi aya Abby,,,Ali a.s kaa maqam kisi ko mill hi nahi sakta yeah Rasool(saw) k Alfaaz hain.124 hazar nabiyon ko Khuda k gher main paida hony ka sharaf hasil nahi huwa Sirf Hazrat Ali.a.s koo Mila yeah wohi Ali hai jisko khuda na apni tarf say talwar ata ki.aurtum sharabikehrhy ho

[adeelalam084]

mr bewkooofoon ki tarah meray hasb o nasb k baray main kuch boolnay say pehlay tum iss video ki date daikh lo k yeh kab ki hay...yeh video 23rd april ki hay...aur iss main main nay kissi aur ko reply kiya tha about dr Israr....

aur aap k ALLAH k ghar main paida honay walay criterian k mutabiq hazrat Ali(RA) ka maqam to hazoor (SAW) say bhi ooncha ho gya(nauzubillah)

[bluemountain20]

Go and read Sahih Bukhari ,about which wife holy Prophet Muhammad pbuh says himself in front of hundreds of Sahaba ..that .Fitna/Troulbe will rise from theire ...its Ayesha !

Who Quran Condemns about lying to Holy Prophet and threatens even to divorce ... Its again Ayesha ?

Who killed Hundreds of people and Looted Basra Baitul Maal ... Its Ayesha ?

Who fought with Ameerul Momineen Ali as and is responsible to thousands of Sahaba killings ...its Ayesha ?

Are they still Respectable

[geemanigee]

you have not studied whole islam's histry,

you only heard shia scholors

[bluemountain20]

Especially for Sunna,the 3 or 4 main Sahabas and wives,its better to read Ahley-Sunna brothers own books,just a litlle example here,go and read Sahil-Bhukhari 3rd Edition,the top book,who refused to obey the Holy Prohphet Muhammad pbuh when the holy messenger was taking last breaths and hurt the messenger and even holy messenger sent him out of his camp in his last moment and what holy prophet decided to give to his nation to avoid dispute/differences was refused by Who who was that insolent ?

[bluemountain20]

we respect all thgose Sahabas and Wives who did not perform any thing against the Commands of Holy Prophet and Holy Quran and the Holy Imam as appointed by Allah himself.

If somebody has concern or questions, may contact me i will give them insha Allah satisfactory answer from Holy Quran,Holy Traditions of Holy Muhammad pbuh from Ahlye-Sunnah brothers Books and from Historical books of their own writers.

[KanizeFatima]

Whether Alcohol was oficially forbidden or not, please have the common sense to understand that Prophet is superior to you, since alhamdulillah you dont drink, neither would your Prophet. Neither would Ali. Ali is the only person among all the Caliphs who never drank in his lifetime, that is why he was the only one qualified to admister lashes for drunkeness. All the others were not free of this crime.

[stylishhassan]

Bhai meray go and read your books. Read Tirmizi and Bokhari then come and talk. Touheen e Risaalat hai in books main.

[KanizeFatima]

At least give the Prophet a few inches of honor and foresight and accept that he would never engage in the filth of Alcohol and therefore a child raised by him(Ali)would never have drank.Moreover, it should occur to you that ever since the propaganda campaign of Muawiyah against Ali the ummah has never again heard such vile accusations against Ali. Where is this suddenly coming from? Why are accounts of drunken prayer which are famously attributed to the likes of Muawiya being attributed to Ali?

[KanizeFatima]

I think you may have completely misunderstood "refutation of Dr. Israr Ahmed". The people who posted that are not Salafis, but Shias. The point is not some notion of being "purist" but that when a person takes a public platform under the banner of "islamic authority" and then declares that Ali (a.s.) was drunk and lead namaz drunk, this is a major slander, and unfortunately this claimant must be condemned. As a Sunni you believe that Ali "converted" in childhood and was raised by Muhammad (as)

[adeelalam084]

i think u r posting on the wrong video...this was my response to anohter video made about Dr Israr Ahmad from Salafis..

my other video regarding the statement of Hazrat Ali(ra) is my latest video for which i have been abused heavily by shiaas and they kept on telling me that they r sayyeds..so probably they thnik that they have a right to abuse my mother

[abbasiali28]

Actually shia is misquoting hadith.

I dont see how Dr. Israr insulted Hazrat Ali(R.A).

Ppl dont know that most mufassir say that this incident led to SHAANE NAZOOL of verse regarding SHARAAB.

mind u Sharaab was not HARAM @ that time. So if Hazrat Ali(R.A) did that it was not haram.

Why is such hype created I promise u SHIA n Brelviz that Dr. Israr loves Hazrat Ali(R.A) more than u claim. So dont go on words. see background of Hadith.

And come on how can Shia Aalam explain trimzi shareef.

[adeelalam084]

Israr ahmad said "Ali performed namaz while drunk, and Ali recited soorah wrongly"

can u please tell me the name of his lecture...he never said anything like this..he might b refering to somebody who said this...but he never said anything like this..can u post the audio or video or tell me the website where i can listen to his words

[EM1COUPE]

the video of his latest lecture is on youtube. He clearly says that those people [Sahaba] could not leave alcohol due to it being in their Ghutti. He then claims that Hazrat Ali (RA) attended a feast of food and wine at the house of Abdur Rahman ibn Awf. He claims Hazrat Ali (RA) was drunk and read Surah Kaafiroon wrong. Astaghfirullah.

This is against the majority of Muslim belief that Ali (RA) never drank alcohol before or after the prohibition.

[adeelalam084]

yes ... this is also against the majority of muslim belief to abuse sahabas(khulafaye-rashideen) the way people do ..and ude Shabas were human beings...secondly even if Hazrat Ali(RA) drunk it, it wasnt forbidden so thats not a problem

[valiantpk]

I think every rational Muslim is thinking in the same way and especially Muslims brothers and sisters sitting outside Pakistan like Myself are really disturbed. May Allah Pak with the blessings of the beloved Prophet Hazrat Muhammad (SAWW) forgives us all and show us the right path Aamin. Thanks for your patience anyways.

[valiantpk]

Brother we can not ignore some one who did this once and remember someone who did that more time. In ym eys both are same because a Muslim can not accept that even once from anyone. I truly condemn this and again Dr. Israr should be answerable to all the Muslims and he should give explaination for his deeds.

[valiantpk]

This is the question that everyone is looking for the answer and its only Dr. Israr who can give the answer himself. So I hope he will come forward to answer that ans I demand an Appology of Dr. Israr from all the Muslim who got heart with his comments.

[adeelalam084]

bro..please check out my new video..i(infact Dr sahab) have given the answer

[valiantpk]

Brither Hussain, before dutch director, think about Rushdi (Laanat Ullah) who wrote that idiotic book. We have forgotton that. I have not yet find any solid response from Dr. Israr to criticse him. So we should try not to forget any incident and only to remember the latest.

[valiantpk]

Every person has freedom of expression but it should not be at the cost of other people's emotions. Simply imagine how many people in the world follow Dr. Israr and what he did. So knowingly saying anything against 'Ashaba-e-Ikram' is not acceptable for any one from any sect. So I think Dr. Israr should openly tender his applogies before Muslims.

[adeelalam084]

wait a minute bro...Dr sahab never said anything against Sahab-e-Krama..i have listened to his lectures over a 1000 hours..and believe me that he respects Sahabas more than a normal person...ca u explicitly point out what he said about Sahab which u think to b wrong?

[Patriot47]

JAzak Allah Adeel.

Dr. Israr's speeches, in his own words, is for intelligent minority in a muslim society. These quasi scholars certainly belong to that section of the society so i guess that explains all.

Some go as far as saying he is MOSAD's agent.

Soon people will call him a devil worshipper the way things are going against him.

[adeelalam084]

assalamoalaikum and thanks bro

if u also confused about the new statement of Dr Israr Ahmad regarding Hazat Ali(RA) than check out my latest video..

[sardarzain]

Nice effort. I agree to you on some aspects, as Salaffis have this tendency to refute people and throw them out of Islam But it is about knowledge. Dr.Israr (who I respect alot) said something which can disarray many and disarray to limits of shirk. Thus it was a good thing to listen to that refutation but I wouldnt agree to expel anyone out of islam. I agree that may be Dr. Israr got it wrong he is a human too. One should always study many sources of knowledge on one topic before concluding.

[adeelalam084]

thanks...well i dont have any problems ..they can disagree with dr Israr Ahmad..but i do have a problem with the people who while refuting call other disbelievers..and i think u also heard those 13 parts where that mullah was telling us that these type of people should b killed and it has been happening....if somebody knows the services of Dr Israr Ahmad for the cause of Islam than he should really think twice before saying something like the molvi sahab said

[adeelalam084]

thanks for listening brother..

assalamoalaikum

[sardarzain]

I have listened to them and have read others thoughts about the topic. No doubt about Dr.Israr and his services but everyone has the right to know right information. My advice to everyone is please don't follow one person. One should study other scholars about same topic before getting into conclusion. So please don't follow one scholar. Every scholar is bound to be verified as anyone can make mistake. May Allah guide us all to right Path and gave us knowledge to understand his Word. Thanks

[awais123]

Mashallah, wonderful, superb, excellent.

[adeelalam084]

thanks brother

[reply2qadanis]

great brother i am totally agree with you.

i love khalafat and i love dr israr ahmad.

may Allah bless him.

[adeelalam084]

thanks brother...his lectures r eye openers and his nalysis of the situation is very unbiased ..and inshaALLAH KHILAFA will b the rule of the earth..

[adeelalam084]

dr Israr Ahmad doesnt do hero worship... and its not necessary for him to agree on everything with somebody and this is the right approach

[Aosaf]

Im with you bro

good work.

[adeelalam084]

thanks bro!!!

[sadafyasir]

ji adeel bhai i m sister not bro ,well i must say that the work u r doin is a grt job for those who had been lying in darkness as it is a stuggle on ur part to convince them 4 straight path,JAZAKALLAH