Pink Floyd en Live 8

[AbsoluteZeroMusic]

I know you may get alot of mislead guidance with music nowadays.

but let me direct you to my channel. you like floyd? youll like us. love hendrix? youll love us. Give my channel a chance. trust me youve got nothing to loose and a new great psychedelic band to gain. Promise.

[kait494]

nice one .. i love it .. pink floyd the best

[SstalkerS]

Another masterpiece from Pink Floyd.

[MoonTh0]

Fantastic.

[JAYROX1969]

Long live PINK FLOYD!!!

[haitokiashi]

Vida longa PINK FLOYD!!!

Banda melhor não há

[bertins80]

semplicemente ...memorabili

[cradlemarioaleixo]

granda som....

[adaywithoutajew]

It's such a shame, I really hope to see Roger, nick, and David play a dedication show for mr. Wright. I thought i'd never have to say i'd wish you were here to two members of pink floyd. RIP Richard Wright

[ernestom72]

rip richard wright

pink floyd the best band ever in this planet

[AngelofKaos]

R.I.P Richard Wright :'( We will always miss you though you'll always be on our hearts...

Roger Waters tiene la voz hecha mierda xD

[tconnarn]

Rest in Peace Richard. Pink Floyd has truly changed my life.

[bohemianhysteria]

R.I.P. Richard Wright.

[HottRatt]

R.I.P Richard Wright...

[podboyz]

rest in peace my friend, rest in peace

[binayak360]

R.I.P Richard Wright!! We miss you. You were great

[tunespt]

There are magical moments. This is one of them, on the top!

eternal

[kawen54]

Pourquoi je ne suis pas né plus tôt !!!!

[Ledzeppefan814]

haha, TOO OLD FOR THIS SHIT. but good video, i love this song, one of my favorites from pink floyd.

[FFRANC19]

Superbe vidéo, superbe chanson.. Gilmore et Waters éternels..

[katis999]

love that shit baby.love that shit

[cachobeltran]

increible canción siempre eterna!!!!!!!!!!

[withnoregards]

i love the solo with the voice as well, its so clever and so much heart put into it :D

[fearluss]

theres nothing wrong with his voice, they have aged and he's singing with emotion, it sounds perfect to me.

[willi4l]

@fearluss agree hard fukn amazing

[555jazzyjay555]

spitt it out roger

[dizzyfire1]

i had the pleasure to listen to Roger Waters

live in Santiago de Chile (12-feb-07), and his voice sound absolutely amazing.

[Psychonautxx]

Waters must have some kind of throat problem there, 'cause you can listen leaving beirut, or other songs of the tour he made later in 2006, i saw him live, and his voice is completly different, and sounds great

[austin27332]

@Psychonautxx He was singing on an emotional level. He hadn't been on the stage with those 3 guys for 25 years. It would be quite an experience.

[Chateau24]

Por lejos mi canción favorita de Pink Floyd.

^^

[bede67]

epprecht. lets hope you dont get it eh. you twat

[vilsonmessias]

Nós brasileiros amamos o Pink Floyd, desde adolescentes até os coroas ...

Viva o Pink para sempre

Vocês massageiam nossas almas, obrigado por esixtirem

Vilson

BH-Brasil

[epprecht]

Waters sounds like he has stage 5 throat cancer.

Gilmour sounds decent! Time to call it a career guys. You cant improve on perfection!

[conjamcity]

What a great song. after all the year's it is still great.

Conjam

[liukgallagher]

gilmour is god

[buzzbahadur]

Wish I was there......

[Skeetos]

July 2005

[masigon]

Pink Floyd is amazing. When was recorded? Gilmore is too old.

[redhouse1985]

When I saw Roger on June 9th of this year, I got the whole thing on video, I was first row. props to you for this vid. If you want to check out the whole concert, go here. Think Pink

stage6.divx.c om/user/redhouse1985

[anamariasalerno]

por ejemplo, para este tema... cuál es el aporte de waters? además de cantar menos que Van Morrison

[viperx2]

perfect show!

[Alive4Metal]

a bigger shame is that they wont play like this together often...

[novembrine1]

Oh my god, I've never seen so many jerks posting in one single vid!!!

What else u don't like about this, about that..???

And I bet, all of you togather, can't even put 2 chords one next to the other..

Shame on you!

[yuuzyil]

how I wish you were here..!

:'(

SYD..!

[insored]

Gilmour is older than ever, last time i saw him was at the PULSe gig

[evhmvye]

GENIUSES.

[evhmvye]

天才達。

[nonamer88]

Well, this still is one of the best bands ever. Shame songs like this never again will be written :( Listen to the music today, 2000, and compare to the 60-80s. I mean what happend? =(

[frankie1373]

U hit it straight on the nose. There will never be songs EVER written like this ever again. We just live in fucked times now. At least we still got our memories!!

[uglybutstupid]

Think they waited too long to make a reunion. Waters sounds like my grandpa when he yells for his medication.

Shame.

[klown1970]

I hate to admit it, but you're right. It's too little, too late. Wotta bummer.

[kirbyhater2]

the floyd, sheer english excellence

[eduardo10aguiar]

simply, the best of PINK FLOYD

[jwmfb50]

Roger sounds like he's trying to hard!

[qereksinim]

wish you were here, :(:(:( syd barrett

[bloodychopper]

I love Roger Waters but he simply cant sing as good as he used to. He should take singing lessons from Gilmour..... and for the record this song is about the lengendary poetic late Syd Barrett. Rogers is good on lyrics and he should stick to that. Gilmour was and is insane with guitar tunes and awesome voice. Waters didnt write ALL the Pink Floyd songs by the way so dont give soooo much credit.

[Zyke491]

best band of all time

[timbsm2]

Man Waters on this is kind of depressing. Makes me glad I didn't buy tickets for his show in Atlanta. I don't think I could handle a whole concert of that.

[arouska]

Gilmour sounds great, Waters not so much.

[Scrack3dAss]

Waters has to understand that he cant sing anymore. Even not the weird vocals in the Wall like the happiest days of our lives and ect...

[talentedshot1]

who stangled the cat

[cem1478]

ha ha ha ha ha ha hahahaaaaaa

[Anegdoteg]

Waters-->hahahahahahaa LOL

[juegas]

gilmour looks like a bird that just cracked out of his shell...

[boerni1976]

sorry, but i had to laugh really hard by reading this comment!

[kapustaa]

it makes me cry.

Syd <3

[MadTurk1984]

Pink Floyd hasn't left anything to comment on. Wish you were here...

[MaoBarBra]

fuck

[friederich76]

i lo ve you pink floyd

[Buccura]

I would do anything, and I mean anything, to be able to go back in time so I could witness this live.

[patwow]

God.. Best band ever, no doubt. RIP Syd, long live Pink Floyd.

[mcseixas]

It really was incredible. Sao Paulo, 24/03

I was there yesterday, crying out loud in WYWH

[driftke70]

He's not out of tune. His singing style just varies to that of gilmore's. They harmonize perfectly.

[TiaNinja]

does anyone know what acoustic guitar gilmour is playing??

[oshelmac]

A Gibson j-200 or j-100

[PaperthinHymn]

Waters sounded horrible in this song. I do love his song writing talents, and I'm not taking anything that he's given to the band. But he's old, and it's showing. His singing talent has diminished like hell, and it burns my soul and makes my ears bleed to hear it. I am a fan of Waters, but the one I'm a fan of could SING. This one, I'm just annoyed by.

<3 David Gilmour for keeping his talent.

[TiaNinja]

waters can still sing. i saw him live a few weeks ago. in this video i'm guessing he couldn't hear the band properly, i mean you must admit he sounds good in this video apart from being totally out of tune.

[has123456]

I think so (no doubt): Waters is just emotion in his voice in this song nothing wrong there!

Many people told that the RW show (Pink) in São Paulo BRAZIL yesterday was just emotion too!

[plonkey]

No GILMOUR rules!

[Anegdoteg]

Water rules!!:D:D:D:D:D

[keepuntitled]

la mejor banda de todos los tiempos sin duda alguna sigan escuchando la buena musica jajaja viva el alcohol y el rock

[gosblessyou]

único, histórico, marcante. Quem viu, viu. GOD BLESS YOU. Renato (São Paulo / Brasil)

[dario31780]

aguante david roger no existis!!!

[AngelofKaos]

Si te gusta Pink Floyd, mostrá algo de respeto por todos sus integrantes...

Yo digo:

Aguante Nick Mason

Aguante David Guilmour

Aguante Roger Waters

Aguante Syd Barret (Q.E.P.D)

AGUANTE PINK FLOYD!!!

[wacksi]

Very emotional indeed: just consider the difference compared to live at pompeii

[kondurperu2]

Viva Pink Floyd,carajo!!

[uesleijunior]

verry good

[EverybodysSenator]

Pink Floyd we owe them for helping to bring down the Wall.

Wish I were there.

Robert Gerald Lorge

[jurivrljicak]

PaperthinHymn if i catch then youre dead...you ignorant..waters..listen caira..ignorant

[winniejackie06]

they was nothing wrong with Gilmours smile.He is just happy to be together again, ask any pure floydian.

[NepeaNHoodratZ]

u ppl r retarded david gilmour and pink floyd would be nowhere without waters writing all of the songs after syd left. I loooove david gilmour hes one of my fav guitarists ever but get ur facts straight before u knock roger waters.

[gayatri91192]

thank you!!theres someone with sense around here.

[alkyflint]

Unfortunately, waters was completely overshadowed by Gilmour here. He thought he would be missed when he walked away, sadly for him he wasnt. Am going to see Waters in Manchester playing with Snowy White, wish it was the Floyd but better than nothing and maybe Snowy will sing Bird of Paradise.

[PaperthinHymn]

roger waters needs to hurry up and die

he lost all of his singing talent, but luckily! he kept a full head of hair

[gayatri91192]

i saw him this year in his DSotM tour- his voice is fine now and 1000 times better than what it was in 2005

[kondurperu2]

una cancion d la puta mare

[sethmanjette12]

i have this on dvd, glad i saw roger live

[reinhard1988]

I WISH I WAS THERE SO BADLY!!! im almost crying, no one will ever be like pink floyd, not even close, I LIVE BECAUSE OF PINK FLOYD

[moondy1]

why dont you marry them

[brennda]

gives me chills

[trickmast]

Even at his old age david sounds absolutely fantastic, amazing.

[MrCarlsberg]

very well played...! Great song

[toocool420]

i cried when i seen them play together again...

what a special moment in history

what an amazing band

nothing will ever come close to pink floyd

[76002804]

Superriff, this song is about Syd Barret not about Roger's father, anyway is an excellent song.

[mustafarel1]

olay bitmiştir

[dorukanozer]

david is god

[KubrickIsAGod]

Best version of the song, that was pure beauty.

[cum2roll]

Brain Surgery is for Syd. I don't think they were still caught up with him on this album. They had done 'Dark Side' and had so much $. I can't assume every slow song by Floyd is about Barrett. Who knows; kids-stay away from acid!

[superiff12]

Wish you were here is about Roger water's father.

[sorginia]

"Wish you were here" is about Syd Barret himself...

[superiff12]

In part yes as the Album was generally and the song was partly about Barret but I heard an interview on the BBC that indicated that it was partly Waters' dissapointment with the music industry and a reference to his own past, his father was killed in Anzio in WW2. If you listen to the lyrics its obvious.

[sorginia]

Talking about the Water´s past (or his father) we should mention "The final cut". As far as I know "Wish you were here" is about Barret...anyway, never mind, I go for some links, maybe I find some more special information

[the06rebel]

Yeah he whole Wish you were here albumn is about Syd.

[Rankawino]

Gracias Pink Floyd.

Quien nace chicharra muere cantando,

Y en este caso , siempre con mucho estilo.

Its been almost 40 years, thanks for the music

[1337jazzdrums]

its a shame that they had to play on a station that fuels the "machine" that they mention in there songs

[MickaMan]

Come to Israel Gilmour!!!1

[stratosphere240]

a chinga tu madr epor k chingados no los he visto todavia maldita sea! algun dia...

[loststar967]

animalhugo? waht r u talkin about haha every floyd fan knows this is for Syd. no1s denying it. its obvious.

[shayanrafizadeh]

That because syd is a part of the band etheir alive or dead

[kwastormayt]

yes he is, but he died poor, no money from pink floyd only his name remained :)

[tragictheory]

correction... if your talking about Syd, his royalties paid him over 6 figures a year up till his death, managed by his family. Gilmour made sure of that ;)

[shayanrafizadeh]

yep that was for syd

[animalhugo]

yes. you right. but so many people dont want to believe it. that song is for Syd Barret.

[blindwilliehighlight]

Gilmour is playing a Gibson

[wme5555]

this make`s my cry, men...beautyfull song, beautyfull moment.

[betankurt]

simply wonderful... the best band of the world!

[mariule2]

What's the name of the guitar Dave is playing here, the acoustic on wish you were here?

[fizbong88]

wonderful...and this could be the last time together...

[indipink]

Thank you fot this video,hope one day I`ll be able to see them myself in Russia...or somewhere else...I`ve seen only Roger so far on the Red Square-it was one of the greatest events on my life!

[DaHokie]

Rog smoked way too many cigarettes when he was younger.

[VegasPhoneMan]

I thinking Roger is old, but damn he sounds good, i hope i sound that good when im 623 yrs old

[mikeen912]

I think Roger Waters was just nervous

[plateaunn]

roger's voice is so funny, but in the good sense!!

keep with hope people... we may see them together again

[outforawalkbitch]

I watched the whole of LIVE 8, it was a great concert. Love this song, I cried watching this.

[elvira2262]

Great , Roger i love you !

[VegasPhoneMan]

nooooo, Its Rolger Walters, get it strait dammit

[kdvincent1982]

Uh, Waters. not Walters.  get it straiGHt dammit.

[lipevolcom]

Old school Lov it

[bluewonder136]

great song

[tilsimsoner]

they are created for us and them

[Ultimateairhockeyp]

yeah i agree gilmour is the best guitarist ! not jimi or anyone else! gilmour!

[simongallup]

:'(

[MelissaSatta]

THanks for the memoriesssssssssssssssss

[Tuty140787]

only I can say is fantastic

[MKFaizi]

Waters reminds me of the Colonel with Elvis. All promotion. I won't go further.

[jptrol]

They never said it was for anything but promotion.

[ASTROS74]

la unica banda que se salva .. bravo...

the only GREATEST band... great..

[Goldberi]

got it all on "tape" made me fkn tear up!wasn't even pmsing haaaaa!

[YornStar]

luv <3

[stockjonebills]

LEGENDS!

[Nouakchott]

I wish they would perform with Varttina. I don´t know why, I just think it would sound really good.

[jamesturner676]

pink floyd r the best they r my fav band. they have the best songs ever and there lyrics are wikid syd barrets lyrics were soo good when he wrote there songs.. dave gilmour it the best guitarist ever!! R.I P. SYD BARRET

[TomGroove]

great to hear that excellent song again, but what happened to Roger's voice ??

[mozgthegreat]

what wrong with Roger?! i thought his vocal on the Wall :(

[jasonguy13]

Nice..got a minute? Check out Mathew Smith (Rodregeus) ...

[duncanfoster]

Amazing footage. Hope its not the last time we see them together.

[beastieboy7]

one of the best songs i see in my life

[saturday83]

pink floyd sont les plus grands !

[Sazzyjb]

Pink Floyd always has been there<

[fizik2112]

Wow, my friend was right, Roger can't sing lol. Pink Floyd is awesome, fave band. I just think that this song is proof that Roger and David were much better song writers than Syd ever was, I'm sorry.

[liz28liz]

Te extraño Ruben...

[cantthink2143154]

wow... "Shine On You Crazy Diamonds" .. Pink Floyd is definatly the best band ever.. I love them <3

R.I.P Syd

[Ernii13]

Pink Floyd is the best band <3

R.I.P Syd Barrett

[blessedLebanon]

Homage to Syd Barrett!(R.I.P)

[razzai]

Very Beatifull a like Pink Floyd always!!Thanks!

[polpocari]

IL MEGLIO DEL MEGLIO DEL MEGLIO!!!!

[ausdylan2005]

arguably best band at live 8 and one of the best ever

[adrileproso]

Viva Pink Floyd!! los mas grandes

[claudiojornal]

Fantástico, maravilhoso, espetacular, fora de série

[zxkjr]

second video of PF ive seen today...i think i'll became a huge fan if i continue to watch

[mikeen912]

There a great band, nobody else sounds like them

[shwilly]

Nah, they won't get together again. Maybe for one or two special occasions like this one, but that's it. That's why this performance was so special: you were watching a hystorical musical performance, something your grandchildren will be talking about, only it was live.

[peemcp]

surperb go ed floyd still got it