Let's face it. All countries did not-so-savory things to get where they are today. That doesn't mean we should bring them up in every possible Youtube video.
Why don't China, US, and other countries just give back all the land they stole and let everyone be truly free...then everybody will be happy and free and we wouldn't have these debates. Until then...let's just enjoy the song. It is truly sad to be conquered and not be truly be free, but you know maybe that's a journey for those to free themselves from those who conquered them...this is for everyone around the world...cause I know there is more than one group of people who feel this way...
@paddotk , you are the indeed retard not Khamnouan, because he telling the truth and the truth hurt brother.
Tibetan are more free than the American Indian, they still have they land, monestry and buddhism temple and besides that the Chinese did not put them in the reservation like the US did to the American Indian.
You are obvious ly a US and nationalist and white supremacist as well.
You guys "debating" politics on here totally ruin the feel of the song. Even if for some reason you hate China as a country you can't deny that their ancient culture and language and architecture are beautiful. Just listen to this nice song and stfu for once.
just listen to the songs and enjoy it...no politics should be debated here...this is not the place to discuss it......songs conquer our hearts and mind...
No one can rule the world, because god created this world for us to shares. So those white men in US keep dreaming, because even in the billions years they will not able to achieves they goal.
China is preparing to gives a big welcome to US if they tries to attack us and that why we builts up our military force.
No one can rule the world, because god created this world for us to shares. So those white men in US keep dreaming, because even in the billions years they will not able to achieves they goal.
China is preparing to gives a big welcome to US if they tries to attack us and that why we builts up our military force.
The US (or the white man) still wants to conquer the world. They killed, not disease, the Native American, it culture, its women, children, they were the original american.
and by the way, The China owns more the 70% of the US debt. so, the US has to respect CHINA. I love Asian countries.
stop arguing everyone, unfortunately, sad events happened in everyone's history now wars still happened. but lets just enjoy the few beautiful things we still have.
@karilily Our people in America do not want to conquer anyone, and we are much more than white people, in case you haven't noticed - our president is of color. As an American Indian, stop getting governments mixed up with their peoples. My ancestors died of diseases mainly, that was the biggest killer. If your government is so stupid as to own a debt, I wouldn't go around and brag about it.
Talking about the Native American died of disease that is bullshit!, I thinks white people murdered or killed them and then took their land from them.
American Indian suppose to borned with the strong immune system than the Caucasian and how can they died of simple of sickness, such as flu and cold.
Talking about the Native American died of disease that is bullshit!, I thinks white people murdered or killed them and then took their land from them.
American Indian suppose to borned with the strong immune system than the Caucasian and how can they died of simple of sickness, such as flu and cold.
@Hongtairang sorry, but my ancestors died primarily of the new diseases introduced by explorers. and that is why they were defeated, explorers went ahead of armies and spread disease, which is why small armies were able to defeat large populations. Yes we died of many other reasons but disease is the primary reason we were defeated. non of that matters now so chill out. We have risen and are strong.
@wildersara I hear the locals in America were killed by domestic animals. Most contagious diseases jump from livestock to the human population. The Europeans had built up a resistance and a set of customs to limit the spread of diseases. The indigenous people had neither, so diseases tore through whole regions.
Oh and don't forget the USA "Annexed" (Stole) Hawaii. You fuckers have the hide to complain about invading a country when you have done it yourselves. How dare you. STFU and don't speak again
Dont listen to the USA, the people in the State of Tibet are better off than before. Americans invaded Iraq and Afghanistan and distribute their bullshit propaganda, see where it's got them now. Where were they when Cyprus was invaded. The USA should GTF back to their own country and mind their own business. Stop fucking other countries up.
@drdavidfu i agree 100% USA should stops to think they are the masters of universe and don't continue to fool the world with false war covers to steal the goods in other countries cause that's the only reason of their presence in Afghanistan and Iraq. now in Libya they want some oil too!
@spezzo I am a Mescalero Apache The US Lets us Govern our own land as if it was our own country. Yes there is still problems but not as bad or as terrible as some parts of the world I have been around the world to me the world is grand. You cant judge all as I have learned what was done in the past by those foolish people are long gone and dead. I look forward these day you still have a very few idiots out there in the world.
khamnouan, not only is your analogy poor, but its incorrect. China conquered Xinjiang and Tibet, and quite frequently enforces the peace with a gun. The Manchus and the Mongolians conquered China in their day, and if you look back far enough, the Tibetans once invaded as far as Xi'an. The best weapon the Americans had was disease; the empire building in the new world was on the coat tails of catastrophic population collapse.
@alecesne well said!! I hope that your excellent comment will help our nationalistic comrade see beyond the simplistic 'one-china' 'harmonious society' rhetoric, but I doubt that it will!
China accquired the new territories not by force or invasion. Because Chinese culture is so powerful when the invader comes into China they becomes Chinese
Its was Mongolia who invaded China not China Invaded Mongolia. Tibet is part of China before America was borned.
White people genocide the native America and took over they land and then they lied that American died, because they caught the cold from white people and you know that lied.
LOL I believe Khamnouan your misleading here, if China didn't do that Tibetan wouldn't left their homelad. Second of all I don't think they're proud to be part of China. Don't get me wrong I don't hate Chinese people my people live in China themselves. China and America are exactly the same conqured other people land to make their own by force or by death.
You fool of shit! why don't you give back the America to the Indian or the native American. Tibetan, Xinjiang, Inner Mongolia and others automous region are proud to be part of China.
China never force these people with the gun point to the head to be part of China. Unlike US which force Hawaii and 48 states to becomes known as US with the gun point to the head.
@khamnouan actually, China did force Tibet to become part of it. It was during the time when Mao Zedong came to power. You could refer to "The 14th Dalai Lama" by Tetsu Saiwai.
Beautiful music, but you are wrong and are once again showing the ignorance of ultra-nationalism. The Chinese regime frequently forces its power onto anyone that disagrees and dares to raise a voice against it.
How can you have an open mind when EVERYTHING you hear within China is controlled by the CCP. You are falsely taught to believe that criticism of the CCP is criticism of China. It isn't. You are brainwashed and one day you will see it. Two words; Great Firewall.
@khamnouan YOU are the fool here. It's worldwide known the Chinese army took over Tibet with force and against the will of the Tibetans. Once in 1959, a second time not too long ago. I've even seen a video of fleeing Tibetan villagers, trying to escape from the Chinese, getting shot for no reason by Chinese soldiers. Is that what you call peace?
You are obviously a nationalistic Chinese, and a bastard as well.
@khamnouan that is true what you said they were overtaken by them it is a true injustice. its a shame that american politics are this way. they show no mercy just greed. god have mercy on there souls. truly america lost its christian foundation its fear for god is lost.
@sdapr2610 China is an Evil Imperialist country composed of occupied territories - Tibet, Mongolia and East Turkestan. Real China is behind the Great Wall.
Your idiotic and offensive topic is not relevant to this video. Please listen and learn. Tibetans have their freedom already. China gives them security so that they can practice their lovely culture. As for Mongolia, you can clearly see that Inner Mongolia and Outer Mongolia have their prides and regrets about being no longer a part of China. Don't encourage Xinjiang to be as stupid as you.
@Lululusk No they don't have their freedom, Mandarin is imposed and the Chinese Government sends a lot of Hans in this region with the purpose that Tibetans are going to be more and more minority in their region.Plus, Tibetans don't have the right to leave the country for India (where they can learn and speak Tibetan) That's why a lot of parents in Tibet send their children in India accompanied by someone who help them to leave China, it's illegal & dangerous. Do you call this freedom ?
@Lululusk Tibetans, Mongolians and East Turkestanis do not need the Chinese occupation. Hmmm freedom in Tibet with Chinese occupation army everywhere? Are you on drugs?As far as Mongolia - pride or regrets, half of Mogolia is outside of Real Mongolia and is overrun by Chinese people. East Turkestan is an independent country under occupation. China is a cultural and territorial thief and rapist. It is yellow poisonous snake, not a dragon. To sum up, China is an imperialist piece of CRAP!
@sdapr2610 Nothing better to say than swear? Well, let me say this - China is an Evil Empire that consists of occupied countries - Tibet, Mongolia and East Turkestan. Real China is behind the Great Wall that it built to guard itself. Any Evil Empire is doomed to failure. May China fall apart soon! Down with IMPERIALIST CHINA! FREE TIBET! FREE EAST TURKESTAN! FREE MONGOLIA!
Beautiful Song , Beautiful Music , Beautiful Lady , Beautiful Video
khatpandwa 4 days ago
LOL. This whole conversation is so funny.
Let's face it. All countries did not-so-savory things to get where they are today. That doesn't mean we should bring them up in every possible Youtube video.
WorldProblemsAndYou 1 week ago 2
Why don't we just forget about all these political ramblings and enjoy the song! Gong Yue (or Xiao Yue, whichever you want to call her) is amazing!!
shazzzr 1 month ago
it has been done reconstructing the voice and vision of indigenous people is a long road
maisecret1 2 months ago
Top comment shit, people really know nothing of tibetan or CHINESE history for that matter. READ BEFORE COMMENT.
Feili642 2 months ago
too many minds of occidental peoples are clean ,so interesting！
123zhonghua 2 months ago
连西藏历史都不学，这些鬼佬还在这大言不惭？脸皮厚啊
123zhonghua 2 months ago
Why don't China, US, and other countries just give back all the land they stole and let everyone be truly free...then everybody will be happy and free and we wouldn't have these debates. Until then...let's just enjoy the song. It is truly sad to be conquered and not be truly be free, but you know maybe that's a journey for those to free themselves from those who conquered them...this is for everyone around the world...cause I know there is more than one group of people who feel this way...
xky8 2 months ago
@xky8
i agree
kppc4444 1 month ago
Have your political debates elsewhere. Stop ruining the song.
rubberpower 2 months ago 4
I need this on my ipod :D
xxEmoxxBunny1 3 months ago
@paddotk , you are the indeed retard not Khamnouan, because he telling the truth and the truth hurt brother.
Tibetan are more free than the American Indian, they still have they land, monestry and buddhism temple and besides that the Chinese did not put them in the reservation like the US did to the American Indian.
You are obvious ly a US and nationalist and white supremacist as well.
Hongtairang 3 months ago in playlist Liked
Wow :)
steve4123253526262 4 months ago
You guys "debating" politics on here totally ruin the feel of the song. Even if for some reason you hate China as a country you can't deny that their ancient culture and language and architecture are beautiful. Just listen to this nice song and stfu for once.
Crenepo 4 months ago
just listen to the songs and enjoy it...no politics should be debated here...this is not the place to discuss it......songs conquer our hearts and mind...
xiejianfa 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
No one can rule the world, because god created this world for us to shares. So those white men in US keep dreaming, because even in the billions years they will not able to achieves they goal.
China is preparing to gives a big welcome to US if they tries to attack us and that why we builts up our military force.
Hongtairang 5 months ago
No one can rule the world, because god created this world for us to shares. So those white men in US keep dreaming, because even in the billions years they will not able to achieves they goal.
China is preparing to gives a big welcome to US if they tries to attack us and that why we builts up our military force.
Hongtairang 5 months ago
@Hongtairang Sounds like China isn't really up for sharing the 'whole' world with everyone either...
UniversalTruths 4 months ago
The US (or the white man) still wants to conquer the world. They killed, not disease, the Native American, it culture, its women, children, they were the original american.
and by the way, The China owns more the 70% of the US debt. so, the US has to respect CHINA. I love Asian countries.
stop arguing everyone, unfortunately, sad events happened in everyone's history now wars still happened. but lets just enjoy the few beautiful things we still have.
karilily 5 months ago
@karilily Our people in America do not want to conquer anyone, and we are much more than white people, in case you haven't noticed - our president is of color. As an American Indian, stop getting governments mixed up with their peoples. My ancestors died of diseases mainly, that was the biggest killer. If your government is so stupid as to own a debt, I wouldn't go around and brag about it.
wildersara 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Talking about the Native American died of disease that is bullshit!, I thinks white people murdered or killed them and then took their land from them.
American Indian suppose to borned with the strong immune system than the Caucasian and how can they died of simple of sickness, such as flu and cold.
Hongtairang 5 months ago
Talking about the Native American died of disease that is bullshit!, I thinks white people murdered or killed them and then took their land from them.
American Indian suppose to borned with the strong immune system than the Caucasian and how can they died of simple of sickness, such as flu and cold.
Hongtairang 5 months ago
@Hongtairang sorry, but my ancestors died primarily of the new diseases introduced by explorers. and that is why they were defeated, explorers went ahead of armies and spread disease, which is why small armies were able to defeat large populations. Yes we died of many other reasons but disease is the primary reason we were defeated. non of that matters now so chill out. We have risen and are strong.
wildersara 4 months ago
@wildersara I hear the locals in America were killed by domestic animals. Most contagious diseases jump from livestock to the human population. The Europeans had built up a resistance and a set of customs to limit the spread of diseases. The indigenous people had neither, so diseases tore through whole regions.
Hikikomori013 4 months ago
#^_^超好听
zminpoh 6 months ago
As soon as she started singing, I was brought to the verge of tears.
So beautiful..
Vaioleto 6 months ago
Enjoy the music and stop arguing everyone! Sheesh....
0FallenSerendipity0 6 months ago
西藏的现状是历史的产物。
欣赏龚玥的天路需要讨论政治吗？
我只感到她的歌声优美动听，又朴实无华。这就足够了。
任何想在YOUTUE上把艺术政治化的各类政治愤青们请到一边休息去！这儿不是政治论坛！！！
tianfangye 6 months ago
Oh and don't forget the USA "Annexed" (Stole) Hawaii. You fuckers have the hide to complain about invading a country when you have done it yourselves. How dare you. STFU and don't speak again
drdavidfu 7 months ago
Dont listen to the USA, the people in the State of Tibet are better off than before. Americans invaded Iraq and Afghanistan and distribute their bullshit propaganda, see where it's got them now. Where were they when Cyprus was invaded. The USA should GTF back to their own country and mind their own business. Stop fucking other countries up.
drdavidfu 7 months ago
@drdavidfu i agree 100% USA should stops to think they are the masters of universe and don't continue to fool the world with false war covers to steal the goods in other countries cause that's the only reason of their presence in Afghanistan and Iraq. now in Libya they want some oil too!
lisheron01 6 months ago
...here we go more pointers on political views which has nothing to do with the vid ! ill save my views 4 a polictical vid! tsk
andytubeism 7 months ago
高亢的感覺沒有了, 變成親切的聲音,還真有點不習慣.
dd111118 8 months ago
ＳＨＵＴ ＵＰ ＡＮＤ ＥＮＪＯＹ ＴＨＥ ＭＵＳＩＣ！
SantanaLovesBrittany 8 months ago 7
cant you people just enjoy the music? why does everyone hate so much...peace is the same in all languages
Senseilargol337 9 months ago
@Senseilargol337 So are guns
MrRedspark51 8 months ago
@MrRedspark51 douche
Senseilargol337 8 months ago
can you put english lyrics!!!!!!!!!!!!!
abc12342927 11 months ago
5/5
ikhamo 1 year ago
love this version its so chilled out its like dub :)
Ono42012 1 year ago
龚玥與阿蘭的天路;各有千秋;不過龚玥的聲線;多了那麼一點''親切感''^o^
babababa11ify 1 year ago
Nice voice and really enjoing this song...My favorite song.
sinyong11 1 year ago
beautiful mesmerising song.......with a golden voice
xiejianfa 1 year ago
不知道這跟阿蘭唱的哪個比較好
這部感覺更可以感覺天路的偉大
wl01543088 1 year ago
好像比阿蘭唱的好聽那麼一點
wl01543088 1 year ago
@spezzo I am a Mescalero Apache The US Lets us Govern our own land as if it was our own country. Yes there is still problems but not as bad or as terrible as some parts of the world I have been around the world to me the world is grand. You cant judge all as I have learned what was done in the past by those foolish people are long gone and dead. I look forward these day you still have a very few idiots out there in the world.
romanobritish 1 year ago
Where can I buy/download this?
darlingdee167 1 year ago
@darlingdee167 - try gosong or video2mp3. outside of that, i'm not sure. :/
blabityblabblab 1 year ago
Well atleast China did not genocide the native people like the white people did in America.
Andrew Jackson is cool blood killer of the the American Indian and known as "Trail Of Tear"
Jiangkaivong 1 year ago
khamnouan, not only is your analogy poor, but its incorrect. China conquered Xinjiang and Tibet, and quite frequently enforces the peace with a gun. The Manchus and the Mongolians conquered China in their day, and if you look back far enough, the Tibetans once invaded as far as Xi'an. The best weapon the Americans had was disease; the empire building in the new world was on the coat tails of catastrophic population collapse.
alecesne 1 year ago 23
@alecesne well said!! I hope that your excellent comment will help our nationalistic comrade see beyond the simplistic 'one-china' 'harmonious society' rhetoric, but I doubt that it will!
risingsun08107 1 year ago
This is a beautiful song, lets enjoy it together :D Peace...
sompasongs 1 year ago
China accquired the new territories not by force or invasion. Because Chinese culture is so powerful when the invader comes into China they becomes Chinese
Its was Mongolia who invaded China not China Invaded Mongolia. Tibet is part of China before America was borned.
White people genocide the native America and took over they land and then they lied that American died, because they caught the cold from white people and you know that lied.
Jiangkaivong 1 year ago
China acquire the new territories after she had been invade by the Mongol, manchu and others.
Jiangkaivong 1 year ago
Very sweet voices and lovely song,
Thanks!
linkway88 1 year ago
@spezzo HAHAHA i'm not American :). And don't get me wrong, i don't hate China at all, actually i'm learning Chinese.
WhouuuuuOKAY 1 year ago
LOL I believe Khamnouan your misleading here, if China didn't do that Tibetan wouldn't left their homelad. Second of all I don't think they're proud to be part of China. Don't get me wrong I don't hate Chinese people my people live in China themselves. China and America are exactly the same conqured other people land to make their own by force or by death.
Opetlao 1 year ago
You fool of shit! why don't you give back the America to the Indian or the native American. Tibetan, Xinjiang, Inner Mongolia and others automous region are proud to be part of China.
China never force these people with the gun point to the head to be part of China. Unlike US which force Hawaii and 48 states to becomes known as US with the gun point to the head.
khamnouan 1 year ago 29
@khamnouan haha you are so wrong...is that why Tibet is fighting back?
bosnianmuslimah 1 year ago
@khamnouan actually, China did force Tibet to become part of it. It was during the time when Mao Zedong came to power. You could refer to "The 14th Dalai Lama" by Tetsu Saiwai.
kebbie19 1 year ago
@khamnouan Are you chinese? You write very good english
MrRedspark51 8 months ago
@khamnouan
Beautiful music, but you are wrong and are once again showing the ignorance of ultra-nationalism. The Chinese regime frequently forces its power onto anyone that disagrees and dares to raise a voice against it.
How can you have an open mind when EVERYTHING you hear within China is controlled by the CCP. You are falsely taught to believe that criticism of the CCP is criticism of China. It isn't. You are brainwashed and one day you will see it. Two words; Great Firewall.
WORLD8NSH5KNIGHT1 7 months ago
@WORLD8NSH5KNIGHT1 Like USA and Fox news :)
Baleur 7 months ago
@khamnouan poor person, full of typical brain wash
wildersara 4 months ago
@khamnouan YOU are the fool here. It's worldwide known the Chinese army took over Tibet with force and against the will of the Tibetans. Once in 1959, a second time not too long ago. I've even seen a video of fleeing Tibetan villagers, trying to escape from the Chinese, getting shot for no reason by Chinese soldiers. Is that what you call peace?
You are obviously a nationalistic Chinese, and a bastard as well.
paddotk 3 months ago
@khamnouan that is true what you said they were overtaken by them it is a true injustice
lilyofthevalley1970 3 months ago
@khamnouan that is true what you said they were overtaken by them it is a true injustice. its a shame that american politics are this way. they show no mercy just greed. god have mercy on there souls. truly america lost its christian foundation its fear for god is lost.
lilyofthevalley1970 3 months ago
@khamnouan then why is china trying to kill the tibetan leader the dali lama
HanDynasty26349 2 months ago
@HanDynasty26349
I don't think there has been any documented instances of China sending out assassins to kill Dalai Lama, either before or after he fledi n 1959.
Bournetolive 1 week ago
嘿家伙，这是一个美妙的歌声，而不是一个政治声明
BaerenzCao 1 year ago
@sdapr2610 China is an Evil Imperialist country composed of occupied territories - Tibet, Mongolia and East Turkestan. Real China is behind the Great Wall.
toctc 1 year ago
Love your country and love yourself, be a great Chinese.
choochengyt 1 year ago
Your idiotic and offensive topic is not relevant to this video. Please listen and learn. Tibetans have their freedom already. China gives them security so that they can practice their lovely culture. As for Mongolia, you can clearly see that Inner Mongolia and Outer Mongolia have their prides and regrets about being no longer a part of China. Don't encourage Xinjiang to be as stupid as you.
Lululusk 1 year ago
@Lululusk No they don't have their freedom, Mandarin is imposed and the Chinese Government sends a lot of Hans in this region with the purpose that Tibetans are going to be more and more minority in their region.Plus, Tibetans don't have the right to leave the country for India (where they can learn and speak Tibetan) That's why a lot of parents in Tibet send their children in India accompanied by someone who help them to leave China, it's illegal & dangerous. Do you call this freedom ?
WhouuuuuOKAY 1 year ago
@Lululusk Tibetans, Mongolians and East Turkestanis do not need the Chinese occupation. Hmmm freedom in Tibet with Chinese occupation army everywhere? Are you on drugs?As far as Mongolia - pride or regrets, half of Mogolia is outside of Real Mongolia and is overrun by Chinese people. East Turkestan is an independent country under occupation. China is a cultural and territorial thief and rapist. It is yellow poisonous snake, not a dragon. To sum up, China is an imperialist piece of CRAP!
toctc 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Beautiful video. This shows Chinese-occupied Tibet. Down with IMPERIALIST CHINA! FREE TIBET! FREE EAST TURKESTAN! FREE MONGOLIA!
toctc 1 year ago
@toctc free yourself
sdapr2610 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@sdapr2610 Nothing better to say than swear? Well, let me say this - China is an Evil Empire that consists of occupied countries - Tibet, Mongolia and East Turkestan. Real China is behind the Great Wall that it built to guard itself. Any Evil Empire is doomed to failure. May China fall apart soon! Down with IMPERIALIST CHINA! FREE TIBET! FREE EAST TURKESTAN! FREE MONGOLIA!
toctc 1 year ago
@toctc and fuck yourself
sdapr2610 1 year ago