Added: 5 years ago
From: JVCFelix
Views: 2,288,811
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (6,371)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Without the sound how am I supposed to know how George Lucas came up with the his Lord of The Rings masterpiece?

  • no sound

  • "Um...my friend Francis Ford Coppola suggested I use Marlon Brando as Gimli, I said whatever." Great line haha :)

  • worst : what if george lucas made a blu ray of the lords of the rings O_O

  • Lucas really fucked up with the prequel trilogy and this is so accurately portraying how he fucked up

  • well, at least the star wars prequels had sound :P

  • Cool video, really funny!

  • @SvenTviking if they had stayed completely true to the books then the movies would have been a lot longer and a lot more boring.

  • I heard that he made star wars with the intention of getting people interested in God

  • hahahaa fkn hilarious I love how the animation is so crude but the characters are spot on and hilarious top job

  • M Night did the same thing with The Last Airbender

    in fact George Lucas is M Night's mentor

  • The banana part was genius. A great satire of the "fun" that Lucas now throws into movies, like the Gopher in Indiana Jones 4.

  • So did Peter Jackson stick to the original novel? Like fuck he did! Arwen with a sword. Lets make Elrond's motives completely opposite to the original. I bet Jackson never realised that Aragorn and Arwen are cousins!

  • NEEDS MORE 3D

  • no sound?

  • George Lucas

  • @Furryloveshentai Click on the link in the annotation or the link in the description to check it out with sound :)

  • George lucas disliked this video 4162 times

  • Galactic Funk by meco

  • I've found a video of Lucas and Tom Cruise together in LA, I've popped it on as my featured video on my page. I swear Lucas has joined Scientology, you'll see what I mean.

  • I've added this video with SOUND.

  • YouTube is real crap for disabling the sound! The sound is still there ... if you save the vid using SaveVid, you can hear it. There was no cause for that though. I guess Lucas got to them.

  • I understand you are all mad at George lucas for making crappy prequels. But you need to uunderstand that he's doing the best he can! Of course he can't make good stories now, because we all run out of ideas some time. Geoge Lucas is my favorite movie producer, and look up to him. Peter Jackson himself admires George Lucas's work.

    Besides, let's just all agree that Michael Bay and M. Night Shayalaman are disgraces to Cinema. Deal?

  • 911Truth.org

  • can anybody please tell me the remix of the song being used in the background? It sounds like some kind of party techno remix and its awesome and I need it.

  • @PSCricket3 Star Wars disco remix by Meco.

  • @JVCFelix thanks a lot for the fast response!!

  • @JVCFelix Also briliant saying Lucas is inloyal to fans when he has fans who don`t understand good films hate intelectual things advsncement in tecnhnology, more depth, realidticly akward dialogue, more subtle acting, showing a friendship which like the one between Han and Luke is simpily flawed showing a good person also have anger like Luke etc just horrible, and also yeah everyone stayed the same ae cause we all know that when you change from 14 to 24 you age the same as from 7 to 17 sure!!!

  • Peter Jackson flim lord of the ring not j k token

  • Dude you fuckin suck! Why u hate Lucas

  • Shit!? What happened?! This video is important! It needs its soundtrack back!!

  • Sound doesn't work for me

  • FIX THE FUCKIN SOUND MOTHERFUCKER!!

  • Sounds please...

  • is this up anywhere else like Vimeo or anything? I'd love to watch it with sound

  • Really bummed out there's no sound on this, it's wicked funny. Hope it gets sorted soon.

  • Is there anywhere else I can watch this? I really want to. I loved you other one about George Lucas and Indiana Jones 4. I watched it 3 times.

  • No sounds!  Damn you George!

  • i wish i could help.. i have no idea about this kind of thing. good luck though! i can't wait to see it again =)

  • i've been trying to show my friend this for days, but no sound =( hope it works soon! i love this video! haha

  • @JeliBaggins4444 I don't know what to do!

  • @JVCFelix reupload it?

  • @JVCFelix Leave Lucas alone, eople are being totally unfair to him and the whole way Lucas bashing started is pretty sad. He is a great filmaker and all six SW films rock, people just had unreasonabl expactations, he is also one of the two creators of the great Indiana Jones movies and American Graffiti, he also influenced tge technology for many other great movies and he made: Body Heat and The Land Before Time.

  • @reviewreviewer1 Erm... wrong? The prequel "films" suck harder than a starving hooker, and he didn't make the Land Before Time, Don Bluth did. And you might want to learn how to spell "unreasonable expectations" before unfairly accusing people of having them.

  • @TheAle89515 The prequels were great and no Don Bluth direct and co-mainproduced The Land Before Time but Lucas co-mainexcective produced it together with Spierlberg, they were the 2 main excecutive producers!!!!!!!!!

  • @reviewreviewer1 You're the dumbest fucker on the internet. Whether you like them or not is irrelavent, what matters is their objective quality as films. Objectively these are three of the worst films ever.

  • @razorath92 Oh so what you say is fact and I am dumb for having a diffeent opinion, that is trolling!!! Films are subjective and my opinion isn`t less then yours!!!!!!!

  • JVC, the soundtrack is gone.....

  • @aemmel1970 Holy shit, look at that! Does anyone know what to do? I've been researching the issue but to no avail. It wasn't flagged for Copyright violation at all.

  • @JVCFelix Not sure. Maybe ILM hacked Youtube to get rid of it. :)

  • @JVCFelix  I would just re-up it and add a click-a-ble link on it as an annotation......as a temporary stop-gap...perhaps its just a glitch...oh and I frickin love these BTW....

  • The sound isn't working....

  • Your Rick McCallum impersonation is dead on, "Sweet green!"

  • "Gritty suburban nine year old." LOL

  • I love star wars and Lord of the Rings AS THEY ARE, but this was the greatest spoof I HAVE EVER SEEN!!!!!!!! R O F L !!!!!!!!!!!!

  • This was great! But please, lay off of George all you haters! He's a genious! All though Christopher Lee (or Lloyd) has a point @ 7:49, come on! George is doing the best he can to make something for a younger audience! When you first saw the Star Wars OT, you were kids and you LOVED them. Now you are an adult, you saw the Prequels and Clone Wars, and your kids loved them! So LOTR is aimed for mature viewers while Star Wars is aimed for younger ones! Simple as that!

    ps Han shot first!

  • @darthqueen45 You really think that those galactic senate meetings and trade disputes in the prequels were intended for younger audiences? Maybe to put them to sleep.

  • @JVCFelix Okay, I agree. Those debates were more like CNN or FOX news material. But the action sequences kicked butt. Although IV-VI are way better. But the prequels give me memories. Different generations.

    Ps If you look closely, you can see E.T. and his buddies in the senate scene. It's true!

    For those of you LOTR fans, One Ring to rule them all...

    Those of you Star Wars Fans, May the Force be with you all...

  • @darthqueen45 well the problem was that 80% of the prequel audience were Original Trilogy fans, and he basically shit in everyone's face! kids who dont know better are only people who like Prequels................George was in it for the $, not to innovate filmaking and telling a great story w/ great characters like the Originals

  • @darthqueen45 shut the fuck up faggot. what George Lucas is raping his once beloved artwork and stabbing cinema in the chest.

  • @darthqueen45 If these movies are for people at a young age, Why is there a lot of confusing politics in the first prequel, scenes suggesting sexual violence in the second and in the third film an overlong fight scene which kills dramatic tension? Another question is why is the the plot so convoluted in the 1st prequel ? Watch Red Letter Media to understand what I mean. George was a good director in 1977 but since then, he has done fuck all See Spielberg who went from Jaws to Schindler's List.

  • @declannorton i guess so yeah.

  • @declannorton

    The politics had to happen. It's kind of hard to explain how a Republic becomes an Empire without them, and it's not like politics was all the movies were about.

    What sexual violence? The closest thing that could be thought of with that is Anakin's mother being tortured in the Tusken Raider camp, where they gave absolutely no indication of that. It seemed like she was more turned into a slave who they savagely abused.

  • Great video. 

  • Undisputedgreatest you are a complete moron, Lord of the Rings are some of the most in depth and epic fantasy novels. You obviously are a complete idiot who salivates over Twilight

  • This is so good :D

  • In short, this is brilliant

  • In long, briiiiiiiiiiiiiilliant.

  • @JVCFelix

    Yeah that sounds how Redlettermedia does it

    paaaaaart ooooooooooneeeee

  • @matzoball101 lol I love that guy.

    WHAT'S WRONG WITH YOUR FACE

  • @JVCFelix

    Oh hello, Sorry im in the middle of my new star wars review, we can talk- OH MAH GAWD! WHUTS WRONG WITH YOUR FACE!

  • @JVCFelix She probably just smoked too many cigarettes

  • haha ,George:''i don't use locations ,i have computers'' LOL  :)

  • search : LORD OF THE RINGS CHRISTCHURCH!! watch the first one on the list

  • LMAO Epic

  • wheres the fucking SOUND

  • @mrstcloud Plays fine for me.

  • Where does this Starwars vs Lord of the Rings or George Lucas vs Peter Jackson come from? I like both...

  • Wow, so many expirienced critics here :D

    I loved the original 3 movies and I loved the prequels as well, I don`t give a fuck if it`s got a lot of FX and what not, still fucking good movies.

    my opinion

  • This is right on the money for those over at Skywalker ranch.

  • =| without Star Wars the original... The movie Lord of the Rings wouldnt have happened...

    George Lucas and Stanley Kubrick did for cinematography, animation, and SFX what Earnest Hemingway did for writing...

    im not putting this Video down, im just saying to all the LotR lovers that hate George Lucas... without him, your movie wouldnt have happened...

    so...maybe some respect?

  • @gitnerd look, we all respect lucas from the 70s, but hate the modern lucas thats milked star wars until its tits have rotted and fallen off.

  • @gitnerd i agree, though i think LOTR is so fucking boring. What I thought GL did right in the Prequels was the insidious plot to overthrow a govnmt through lies, persuasion and love. I liked the metaphor of the Dark Lord literally taking one of the good guys, The Chosen One of all people and using him to destroy the Order. It's like capturing a leader, cutting his dick while his back is broken lying paralyzed and raping him w/ his own prick. The Prequels shouldve been that way from the very st

  • @gitnerd

    I think the main thing this video points out is the what-if scenario on george lucas ruining the Lord of the Rings movies as he did the prequel trilogy. It doesn't suggest that the original Star Wars trilogy was bad.. though, I guess there are some out there who will swear up and down that the prequel trilogy was great. To each his/her own!

  • Honestly, the new Star Wars fims were all shit. Really shit.

  • BTW frankio3 an apology? Seriously? Yeah here's how an honest apology would sound: "I'm sorry for making one of the greatest stories ever told. I'm also sorry for co-creating the Sony digital camera that every camera is modeled after now because of it's ability to be digital without the downside of losing analog quality. I'm also sorry for bringing 3 new Star Wars films into existence and it not meet your expectations. Also, I'm sorry for being really rich and very very successful." OMG!!!

  • @bobillub I dont care that hes rich and successful off of it,....He should be, he definitely deserves it for such an amazingly crafted story that brings imagination and wonder to millions of people and especially the kids..... However 'the prequels" were a slap to the face compared to the work lucas turned out before hand, and also great in collaboration projects with spielburg....  There is no emotion within the new movies....It feels STERILE with immense CG and unmemorable characters..

  • It was really funny, but they are making fun of Lucas's ability to use computer graphics in movies... but what most people don't know is that skywalker ranch was on the payroll of The Lord of the Rings.  They gave a helping hand to the CGI department of TLOTR. So, yeah... Lucas arts and Skywalker ranch really is everywhere because they are the best at what they do.

  • @bobillub The CGI department of the TLOTR should have helped the team at skywalker ranch in return... lol....... The effects in the The Two Towers are way better than any prequel in the star wars films...I mean they looked pretty cool when they first came out but. I dare you to watch Avatar side by side to the star wars prequels... lol youll think your watching a kid play star wars battlefront...

  • "This is the digital age, we have computers, electricity, and money, we dont need a script."

    Hey, sounds like the way Avatar was made!

  • @d2eux Agree!

  • @d2eux Well I like Avatar.

  • @d2eux Dude ur so right, I can't believe it is the highest grossed film in the world. But at least it beat Titanic.

  • @d2eux

    fuck you avatar was awesome.

  • @Jammed9000 hey watch the language bro. Its just my opinion

  • @d2eux

    Geeze how old are you?

  • @Jammed9000 old enough to the point where I don't need to say "F you" to people who have different tastes in movies than I do

  • @d2eux

    If your offended then it's your fault.

  • @Jammed9000 You're the one who's obviously offended otherwise you didnt need to say F you and defend your opinion why you like avatar.

  • @d2eux

    Dude, I'm not offended. Sorry, but I really don't like people who get all caught up about 'naughty words'. Do you believe in god too?

  • @Jammed9000

    How are his theistic beliefs relevant?

  • @MatzoRocks

    Usually people with religious beliefs also get very offended by curse words.

  • @Jammed9000

    Thats just a generalization

  • @MatzoRocks

    It's also the truth.

  • @Jammed9000

    I know dedicated christians who swear 24/7 it does not apply to everyone

  • @MatzoRocks

    I never said it applies to everyone. Please stop getting so worked up about it.

  • @Jammed9000

    You said the generalization was the truth so basically yeah u said it

  • @d2eux Taste is not the only factor that matters, you also have to look at a film objectively. Which you lovers of the prequels refuse to do.

  • @razorath92 We give logical arguments we simpily disagree.

  • @baschome Like? What is one of these arguments? How do you make up for the wooden acting, horrible plot, gigantic plot holes, horrible direction, overabundance of CGI, contrived romance, racial stereotypes, bad continuity, bad choreography and terrible characters you're supposed to like until the end? George Lucas is a fucking cunt. I'm not insulting you, I'm just curious

  • @razorath92 Tell me what plotholes, the CGI looks real, the acting is simpilypart of the caracters resered, the caracters have manty traits, what continuety, the goreography is very complex, how is the romance contrived, what is wrong with some steroe types for, how is a complex political plot bad, how is the direction bad??????????/

  • @baschome Cop-out time, watch Red Letter Media's, Confused Matthew's, and The Distressed Watcher's review of these god-awful films and watch in awe as they desecrate these horrendous piles of monkey shit. The direction, was horrible. Lucas had the cop-out of using almost nothing but CGI, they're practically animated films. Does this automatically make them bad? No. But the fact that Lucas made the CGI as horrible as he did is a testament to his horrible direction. It's cartoonish.

  • @razorath92 There is 108 page rebutall Redlettermediaz which proofed thins he said were factually wrong and dishonest, amd butcher all but a few points. The CGI was incredibily detailed hard and ough, had real size an massd and depth, anmd was well ligt, it was ofcourse done by the geatest effecs company with a very high budget.

  • @baschome You give the writer of that essay far too much credit. His review of the review didn't even start until page 12! Plus, there are almost 50 pictures throughout that "essay"! He also clearly doesn't understand a LOT of what RLM said. He really likes to pretend he knows what he's talking about, but in the end he comes off sounding like a confused fan boy instead of a person who can clearly articulate his ideas. He's just a kid, and his objectivity seems to be way too clouded.

  • @garamonde Um it still is many pages and you don`t articulate your thoughts welll, he analyses things in the movie where you and Plinket make things up, also if you are really that certyain, actually debate with me, you act like you are so certain but you refuse to respond to my points so it is a bluf!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @baschome Me debating you? We went down that path over a year ago(for MONTHS) and you never listened to a word I said, so it's basically pointless to debate because you're never going to listen. I tried to be fair and listened to what you had to say, but I had a counter for every single one of your arguments and you just came back with the same things over and over again. There is not one good reason to engage you in debate ever again. You will understand what I am saying when you grow up.

  • no I did listen to what you said countered it and you just said no noo. If you are truelly right, proof it, also you didn`t even keep your promise. Also you say things just cause you say them, you called al the caracter od Dooku I discribed as extranous, even when they were in all the scenes he was in. You ignored my traits discription and focuaed on thew backstory saying that isn`t caracter when a caracters backstory shapes them, and you said it could be added at the last minute for no reason.

  • @garamonde Again why should the Jedi invade Tatoinre when it is not part of the republic so they have no right to do it, it would be similar to the Nazis it would be supression they have no right to do it. Also again klet`s analyse how Dooku is underexplained you se we don`t know what he wanta well e wants to help Sideous take over the republic and power and because he is a fornmer Jedi and Obi Wan is the aprentice od jhis aprentice he wants to turn them evil. So no dynamic.

  • But also how did Anakin just kill Dooku whgen he was helples befoere this he dfought Dooku who was arnme and defeated him, this is fact which you ignore, yo ignore all the heroic thingsa Anakin did, yo also clain that Lasrs can`t be trusted cause is in a weelchair anb is weaker then the Sandpeope, he is that not being a good person, Luke lost to Vader, you ignore that Anakin is pilot in service of Watto etc. you are a troll who claims he is right based on nothing bur that hew sais he is!!!

  • @baschome Do you have a disability that prevents you from being able to read? I said I am not getting into this with you again. I'll tell you what, when you grow up(another 30-40 years) we'll talk, okay?

  • @d2eux Even Avatar had a story.

  • lol the hayden part killed me hahahahaaha

  • Ha,..... Lucas REALLY needs to watch this.... lol.............. i mean he seriously just needs to come out of hiding in skywalker ranch........ and openly hold a giant Festival where he would give a long apology speech, admit his faults, and suggest his plans for future projects and more intertwine them with both experienced advisors, writers, and the fanbases.... Just holding that one apolagetic event would release so much tension and hatred that the fans feels for him..

  • what is that yellow thing at 0:32? I would be less freaked out if I knew.

  • @TheLegolasguy Some piece of shit Naboo Fighter thing.

  • What's the actual name of that weird money obsessed fat guy. I knew he appeared AFTER the original trilogy, so he was one of the head CGI...ists.

  • @Carnage1235 I use his real name - "Rick McCallem."

  • heres, how you sum this up, NEVER EVER mix the word "George Lucas" with "prequels". NEVER

  • I'm SO glad George Lucas had NOTHING to do with Lord of the Rings. I love the original trilogy, but the prequels fell short. I watch LOTR way more than I watch the original trilogy now.

  • brilliant

  • haaaayyyden i neeeeed you! Whaaaaaaaat

  • LMFAO LMFAO " i dont use locations, i have computers"

  • If George Lucas made LOTR each movie would have at least had 1 time were someone yelled NOOOO! for 10 seconds non-stop just like vader and luke

  • screw the rules i have money

  • i might be alone on this, but i actually want to see his version of lord of the rings.

  • @054martinm it would be better than Jacksons version.

  • @chridgy um jackson's movies are considered the benchmark of fantasy. the prequels are loads of shit, apart from 3 to an extent.

  • @054martinm No, they are considered the benchmark of boredom. Harry Potter had more fantasy and was more entertaining than anything Jackson could come up with.(and i dont like HP very much). The only fantasy in LOTR was how it wanted to be a gay soft core porn.

  • @chridgy hahahah wow are u gay ans STUPID. ur right they are considered bored to retards with the attention spans of a fruit fly. lmfao harry potter islike the worst pop tart garbage of all time...it was massacred by the critics while lotr i considered the best movies of all time...lets do a check lotr :most oscars of all time. harry potter: 0

    go watch harry potter thats the best insult i can giveu lmfao

  • @ac689 I just compared LOTR to HP and i hate them both you raving jackass. Its people like you who made Avatar into such a big deal. And LOTR is no where considerd the "best" movie of all time, where do you get this crap? What are you some 30 year old guy living with his mom? Are you guys just dissapointed that 300 kicked your crapy LOTR movies ass with twice the action and story done in just 1 movie to your 3 boreing ass movies?

  • @chridgy wrong faggot. im a martial arts instructor, u on the other hand must be a fat gay bastard who lives in his parents basement wacing off to anime porn of ron blowing harry. where do i get this crap? lmfao u actually are retarded arent u? as i said lotr HAS won the most oscars all time and is considered the benchmark of a masterpiece in film

  • @ac689 No, i'm a game tester and computer programer. I have 2 third degree Black belts in Chun ku do and Kempo. I recently went to vegas with my friend JJ who is considerd one of the best MMA out ther right now. And you talk about gay people ALOT for someone who is suposed to be strait.

  • @chridgy lmfao im sure you do my friend...online you can have blackbelts in ALL the martial arts ouuu you went to vegas with you friend "jj" lmfao sound romantic. all that aside game testing must be a sweet job. and lotr IS the best trilogy ever no arguing reality, money, and oscars

  • Clerks 2 said it best it's just a movie about walking.

    So in your opinion then you find Titanic to be a masterpiece also.

  • @PaulVonHindenberg Whats your favorite movie? mines "UP"

  • @possem33

    The Iron Cross

  • The iron cross is just another drama, singing in the rain is just another song, gone with the wind is just another war movie. to kill a mocking bird is just about one murder. The Shawshank Redemption is just about a guy going to jail. the godfather is just about some gansters Citizen Kane, the holy grail, die hard. Casablanca, Schindler's List, the green mile, The dark knight, The Exorcist. BIG FUCKING WHOOP. any movie is bad if i dont give it justice, like your not to the lord of the rings.

  • @possem33

    What I love is how I can't say the same for UP. It's just a old man and a boy finding their dreams come true.

  • @PaulVonHindenberg lol, sounds kinda dirty.

  • @chridgy and some1 like you wud find epic battle sequneces, beautiful dialogue, and perfect acting boring...lmfao maybe u shud watch a movie more suited to your intelligence...try alvin and the chipmunk or something u queer

  • @chridgy funny how gay softcore features two marriages of boy and girl at the end. and harry potter is based in reality. the only differences being a secluded world where people use magic and there are magical creatures mixed with non magic ones. lord of the rings has an entirely fantasy world with ancient demons and an evil ring that turns people into gollum. plus it has better acting, better battles and more oscars. but fine if you think its boring and gay.

  • @054martinm Even 3 is a load of shit.

  • @DigitalPh333r meh. it has better acting and storytelling than the first two. and the lightsabre battles are cool. i just wish they didnt fuck up the first two. then 3 would have been heaps better and longer.

  • @054martinm Not really, the love scenes were still awkward as hell. And cool action can't make up for a bad movie. 3 was terrible, the acting was still stale, the dialog was still awkward to sit through and like the first two nothing made sense.

  • Great job, there must be a sequel or a prequel of this!

  • I've watched this about twenty times and have never gotten tired of it. the voices and body movements and timing are perfect. not mention its HILARIOUS

  • this was accurate ^^

  • welli really need to find somebody who clicks with me

  • "I respect Tolkien as a writer, but I didn't really think he captured Lord of the Rings the way I would have."

    Lolololol

  • the prequel trilogy was fucking awful.

    "lost his abilities a long time ago in a galaxy far far away" lol

  • jake lloyd lmao!

  • lolol

  • awesome and funny as hell.

  • If George mucus has made this film, then entire movie would have been cgi casting and only one real actor. In short, movie would have been crap.

  • @Stingerbillion You mean just like Jacksons version?

  • Well, to be fair. It's not like he could rape it any worse than Peter Jackson. Anyways this video's really funny, good job =3

  • "...and then I realized, we dont need a script.... we have computers and money." That got quite a laugh out of me.

  • Now there's a movie i would watch:)

  • man. You're all looking at this the wrong way. EVERYONE IS PRESENTING THEIR OPINION AS FACT

    i just want some fuckin comments about the animation. even just an "OMG LOL!" this lotr vs star wars argument is silly!