Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (102)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • At 0:35, when she says "Never FEEL left" , on feel you can clearly hear the autotune. FAIL. MOTLEY CRUE FOREVER!!

  • Looove this song... Carrie sounds amazing!!

  • Comment removed

  • no one can compare with Underwood!

  • i hate this version wtf wheres the guitar solo fuck her she did a terrible job she took the rawness out of the song and made it into bullshit thats why motley was good beacues they keept there songs raw and real unlike this version it sounds to digitalized

  • I love this Song!! by Motley Crue. Carrie sounds right but the only reason I like this cover It´s because I will make people go look after the original song by Motley Crue and realize how good It´s this band for those who never listen to it before! Rock and Roll!!!

  • Motley is better than this

    but its still good

  • Does anyone know the names of the 3 guitarists on American Idol Season 8 Finale when Carrie sang Home Sweet Home?

  • i hate all of carrie's shit, but i love

    this cover. (NOT better then Motley Crue's version)

  • i love both carrie's version & the original by motley crue, but the crue's version is much better

  • I've read the comments about the motley version so I just listened to it and it is good, but I prefer this version, think it is better suited to a girl's voice.

  • First of all some would say Vince Neil does sound like a girl. No knock on Vince Im just being honest... This remake by miss underwood is awesome. I would have given it an A hand down, but I cant. Why? Because they did not do the guitar solo justice. That solo is just as important as any of the lyrics in this song. No worries people Im a drummer so lm not biased toward guitar solos. Also what version did you listen to. If you listen to the 2009 live in concert version. You might change yoru mind

  • This beautiful song will always make me remember this season 8 of American Idol, not only because of the fights about Danny, Adam and Kris, but also because we (I mean everybody in the whole world, including myself) had had the opportunity to give our opinion on FACEBOOK!!!!! Isn't that great!!!! Global Communication and the Internet are the best of this century!!!! I love that

  • LOL 2nd row main stage for motley crue, , NO one can cover this song, and I bet 98% of you dont even know the meaning behind the song, This isnt just some random song you morons, do some research before you post shit about some stupid tv show

  • whats the meaning behind the song

  • This is a song about motley crue's Vince Neil, getting out of Jail!

  • No bro you are mistaken Nikki Sixx is the heart & soul of this band pretty much. He wrote this song & according to Nikki Sixx its about being on the road so much that its your home sweet home... Now Nikki Sixx has been known to bull shit some questions, so Im not saying he is or is not doing that in this particular instance. However, if we take the man at his word. Its about being out on the road for soooooo long that it becomes your home. Because your real home is empty if you get what I mean??

  • I downloaded this song at itunes and to my ipod

  • omg i just love this song so much :) carrie underwood is my idol

  • Well...go out and buy the original by Motley Crue! One of the greatest rock ballads ever! You people have heard of Motley Crue right? You know this is not her song right?

  • of course, but what's the difference.. really? Do you think Motley Crue mind making tones of money b/c Carrie's version of the song sells well? If I was the song writer, I'd be honered that she'd taken my song and introduced it to legions of new listener and new fans... I preffer Heavy Metal to country.. but I still LOVE Carrie's version even more than the Crue's ;) That's how the world works my friend ... everyone is different

  • Better than Motley's version? Are you insane? Well if you like this watered-down version better so be it

  • Lee/Neil/Sixx are the song writers

  • Nikki and Mick are the primary songwriters. Vince doesn't really write anything in the Crue, except for vocal melodies.

  • That sure is funny you say that, like you KNOW that for a fact. Let me be my normal dickhead self & splain it to ya just like this. From 1981 to 1989 Motley Crue released five albums: Too Fast for Love, Shout at the Devil, Theatre of Pain, Girls Girls Girls & Dr. Feelgood. Vince Neil wrote (1/3) one/third of all the music & or lyrics on those albums combined. So please before you make yourself look like a complete & utter moron. Check your facts please??? I cant stand when people say stupid shit

  • It's awsome when you tell me to check my facts. Vince co-wrote 2/10 songs on Feelgood. 2/10 songs on Girls. On the previous 3, he co-wrote 4 or 5 songs per album. Now, that would be 19 CO-WRITES. In overall material they released Vince wrote like...10-15% of it. Clearly that is one third of Motley's 80's material, thus meaning you are right and I am a complete and utter moron. Looks like you won.

  • Well I respect your opinions guys but instead of writing how many song and Who write it or not. You should write about how good are this musicians and all the years they dedicated to this Awesome band! Motley Crue!

  • GeeeeeeeeeeeeeezUS Some people's kids!!!

  • Mick Mars is just as important to the song writing as anyone else (including Nikki Sixx) Mick Mars shaped and groomed Nikki into the song write that he is today.

  • yeai aws trying to loook for this song i was like who sings this it sounds great

  • Carrie sounds great.

  • i cant belive Allison's gone. it's finally sinking in that 'yes, Adam's still in....but Allison's gone'.....-about 2 cry-

  • visually-impaired guys name is scott. he was really good..i cried to when he had to leave..i'm positive we will see more of him!

  • yea really

  • i love the way she sings this

  • this song makes me cry everytime someone leaves especially when they sent home the blind guy (i forgot his name) i wanted him to stay

  • lmao. that made me laugh.

  • love it searched for it for a quite time

  • good cover but i like montly crue version better but best cover ive heard

  • I LOVE this cover of hers...and God Bless her for taking this song for charity!..LOVE her so much

  • didnt expect it to be by carrie underwood

  • Carrie Underwood is good for the kind of music she sings but Mötley Crüe sang this song way better.

  • well of course they did...they're the creators of it.

  • since when are remakes better than the original?

  • Pantera's version of Cat Scratch Fever was about a billion times better than Ted Nugent's.

  • nice cover, but nothing can touch the original.

  • She has it all, Beauty & Class & an amazing voice!!

  • aguante carrie!!! jaja barbie este comentario te lo dedico =P

  • She has a good voice, not a bad effort, although the original is 10,000 times better.

    Chester Bennington ( Linkin Park) version is way better, no doubt.

    Although Motley´s version is a timeless classic.

  • Don't be so rude!!!! She is an amazing singer!! I'm sorry you don't like her!!! I think she is great! Everybody has an opinion, but you don't have to put it so rudely

  • This version is amazing! I love it! Carrie brought a whole new life to this tired old song. I like motley crue and the original too, but there is something about Carrie's voice that cuts glass, it is so clear. Great job Carrie!

  • Even if I wasn't a Carrie fan, I would favor this one over the original. Either the negative comments here are such a far cry from being not true or either the person admits they are the original artists fans. I've seen a lot of bad covers and this is not one of them. What you don't want to see is that if you even knew everything Carrie has sang up to this point, you will quickly know she can sing her ass off.

  • wow i love this!

  • I respect your point of view. I am a Carrie fan and I like everything she does, but it's all about likes and dislikes, obviously. However, I have noticed that Carrie's voice has become a little bit gutural and that she screams way too much. I like it better when she just sings naturally without forcing her voice. On the other hand, I have never understood this thing about "real music". It's all music. What happens is that we have this tendency to think the past was better than it really was.

  • ive never come across "fake" music before.

    anyway.

    i love this song :]

    keep doing your thing carrie!

  • Motley Crue version is much better. Vince Neil is just better at singing this song. At least she tried to pay homage to a metal song though.

  • carrie is amazing! she can sing anything! this is wonderful! LOVE IT! thanks for posting! =D

  • carrie rocks. she's the best singer out there. she's authentic, she can actually sing unlike those singers who just have good techies, and she's gorgeous. i know that has nothing to do with how good of a singer she is, but it completes the package. GO CARRIE!!

  • really good song !!! cant whai tto hear it on idol !!

  • The original is SO much better than this

  • The original sucks!

  • Loved all the pics you used for this!! =)

    The song is just amazing -- of course it's Carrie singing it!! I can't wait to hear this week after week on AI.

    If you haven't, please go to ITunes and download this song. Half of the proceeds are going to Carrie's favorite charity -- The Humane Society. Thanks! ;)

  • Excellent video. Very enjoyable!

    I really like this song!

  • You obviously haven't heard her sing Paradise City or Sweet Child Of Mine...This is just another one of Carrie's amazing covers=)

  • Agree with you all the covers Carrie do are awesome......

  • Yes Carrie has done many amazing covers, I Told U So, I'll Stand By You, Praying For Time, etc .... Go Carrie, all the Carrie haters go to ....... someone else, if you think the song sucks why is it on number one on Itunes i guess you are the ones who suck.....

  • IF YOU ARE GOING TO SING THIS SONG IT TAKES BALLS... no, actually I'm just kidding about that. Actually what it takes is a serious amount of cocaine and heroine to be properly song and man named Vince Neil. Oh and popularity has nothing to do with quality... but if you enjoy that is all that matters. I was just screwing around with my first comments.

  • It's number one because America is obsessed with American Idol

  • You are Great!! Go Carrie Fans LOL!!! She is Amazing and we know it!!! It dosen't matter wat other ppl say! We know carrie is AMAZING and can sing watever and make it sound Great!!! This song just proves Carrie is WONDERFUL!!!

  • This clip made me rewatch clip of Carrie on the stage with Vince in his performance "Kick start My Heart" in Nashville, Tennessee

    She was quite crazy, dancing & jumping a lot hahaha

    <3 her

  • Love Love LOVE this! Carrie can sing anything and make it sound fantastic!

  • Gotta this love this song guys! No reason to hate the elimination week on Idol anymore. Just listening to this re-make by Carrie Underwood is awesome!!

  • AMAZING!!!!!!!!I LOVE THIS!!!!!! I can't buy it on iTunes though....I don't have enough money:( I'm SOOO sad! This is really awesome though. She can sing anything!:) I LOVE HER!

  • I Love Love Love This!

  • you don't havce to be a rock singer to sing rock songs

    i think you can like it or not, but every singer can choose what they sing

    when she sang "praying for time" by george michael, wich is not a country song, she made also an amazing job

    i respect if you don't like it, but it's not fair blaming her for singing a rock song, she's a singer before a country singer only.

  • I agree with you she also did an amazing job with "i'll stand by you", and "i told you so" she has made awesome covers not to mention her original songs are amazing too.

    She can sing the phonebook if she wants too lol = )

  • If you knew anything about Carrie then you would know she likes Motley Crue, and If anything by covering their song she is trying to pay tribute to them. Why is everyone always so negative. It's not as good as the original but no cover ever is. Just take it for what it's worth. A good cover by an amazing country voice.

  • It's not Carrie that sucks, it's your mom.

  • She did a great job stop trashing her, like you can sing better than her you can't so fuck off!!

  • Carrie did great job and it's for charity. Happy birthday Carrie.

  • Oobviously the 28 in your screen name is your IQ. No it's not as good as the original, not cover ever is as good. Ever listen to a singer try to cover a Carrie Underwood song? Most are downright hideous.

  • She's helping the Humane Society with this song. God bless her. She has such a beautiful heart for animals.

  • Pucha me encantó!!!

    Carrie Feliz cumpleaños!!!!!

  • Love it, think she did it justice!!!

  • Carrie did a good job with the song, the one that say that shge sucks are crazy, she is great.

  • hah...very nice clip. I like the last one

    I want to see her perform this live !

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more