What mosed performers and opera directors don't realise is that you can't base a whole stage performance on voice alone, its not a concertante, it's an opera and drama is extremly important. A bad performance can have a huge effect on the music. Happily you see performances that realise that...p.s thankyou Callas for making that quite clear
I wish you had posted the whole number, including the dance at the beginning. It's amazing. I saw this live at Covent Garden last night with Christine Rice as Carmen - previously Antonacci was my favorite Carmen mainly because of her acting, but I always thought her voice wasn't the best suited for it. Now Rice is my favorite because she sings and acts flawlessly.
I wish the Covent Garden audience were more responsive-they always seem reluctant to applaud, let alone show any enthusiasm. There should have been cheers here
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This is once again a bloody awful production from the ROH. The opera itself tends to bring the worse from directors , Zefferelli, Hall, etc They forget this is a Frenchmans view of Spain, it's a very French opera indeed. The best production I ever was involved in was in 1981 in Nancy, director Antoine Boursellier with Nadine Denize as Carmen, then again on tour 1982/83 with Glenys Linos
...hm..i`ve seen better than this...but...it`s very good...in spirit of carmen...you`re right, she is not stripper,but it`s just carmen...she does all that to seduce everyone around her...i love her...i must say...in some parts i don`t think that antonacci is right for the part...but in others she is good...jonas kaufman...omg...he has the most wonderful voice, and i cried when i watched 4.act when he kills her...they did it so great...whole show is very,very good...but jonas is the best!!! <3
i agree 100%! but in this case why do you think that a free woman who enjoys her own body and has sex for fun is a whore?? and a stripper?? when i dance i also remove my jacket to be more comfortable... maby i am a stripper and didnt know it before!! lol!! :-D
You have to remember this is a stage production though, everything is done for a reason. As well as the fact that it is set some ago. So, the fact that she's being depicted ON STAGE taking of her top in those times and behaving in that manner suggests she is a whore. Comparing it to someone dancing in a club today NOT in a production is irrelevant.
@myrtha77 I think that is the charactor of the carmen from its original story...She was a gypsy in old time.. I feel like this carmen was just walked out from the book
have a talented actress, a nice handelian voice sing this role and you have a sensuous, neat rendition of the role. Ms Antonacci is not the best singer ever but she is Carmen to the core
I wonder if this scene is somewhat what the choreography for "Be Italian" in "NINE" is based off of!
MissVishkah 3 months ago 3
@MissVishkah I've been asking the same...So very alike...
DanUCB 3 months ago
stupendo
youfeda 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Anna Caterina Antonacci IS Carmen!
schoolhousenews 7 months ago
Anna Caterina Antonacci IS CARMEN!
schoolhousenews 7 months ago
Bravissima Anna Caterina!
kajagubic 8 months ago
What mosed performers and opera directors don't realise is that you can't base a whole stage performance on voice alone, its not a concertante, it's an opera and drama is extremly important. A bad performance can have a huge effect on the music. Happily you see performances that realise that...p.s thankyou Callas for making that quite clear
Phersephoie 8 months ago
Anna Cate is fantastic!
MrPiea 9 months ago
bravo anna caterina.......mesmerizing......i m a big Callas fan but u r also amazing
TheTonyk1711 10 months ago
bravo anna caterina.......mesmerizing......i m a big Callas fan but u r also amazing
TheTonyk1711 10 months ago
Her voice is wonderful! But Christine Rice is good as well
FloriaTosca90 10 months ago
Stunning, exciting, makes me smile...I bought the video and this is a marvelous version.
EddieJJ 10 months ago
Anna Cantonacci is the best Carmen I have ever seen and Jonas Kaufmann is a very good Don Jose.
Raserernst 11 months ago
Anna Cate is superb as Carmen.
MrPiea 11 months ago
je viens de revoir cet opéra sur France 2. Vraiment le meilleur des cadeaux pour 2011.
I've just watched this on France 2 TV. What a gift for 2011
DrMusBel 1 year ago
Iemand van Kualg, weten jullie nog leuke antwoorden op 3.8?
Shyamora 1 year ago
I think the is the best Carmen ever
heyhey33345 1 year ago
FORMIDABLE!
MsPestpokke 1 year ago
I watched the performance live in covent gardens - its fabulous, incredible stuff, but christine rice instead thx for uploading x
annabella1211 1 year ago
I wish you had posted the whole number, including the dance at the beginning. It's amazing. I saw this live at Covent Garden last night with Christine Rice as Carmen - previously Antonacci was my favorite Carmen mainly because of her acting, but I always thought her voice wasn't the best suited for it. Now Rice is my favorite because she sings and acts flawlessly.
KatherineXIX 1 year ago
it is one of the best operas what i´ve seen.......she sings great and both men are handsome!.....it is the bast Carmen!very very goooooooooood
kolarovami 1 year ago
Que fabulosa!!
purpuraopera 1 year ago
Really one of the best Carmen ever)))
ALIKJ09 1 year ago
I wish the Covent Garden audience were more responsive-they always seem reluctant to applaud, let alone show any enthusiasm. There should have been cheers here
elephantbarbiegirl 1 year ago
BEAUTIFUL INTERPRETION. THANK YOU.
Tenorbravo 1 year ago 3
agnes baltsa is the best carmen,but also antonacci is not bad!!!
Shadommina 2 years ago 2
J'aime bien cette voix plus légère que de coutume..
isabelle070209 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is once again a bloody awful production from the ROH. The opera itself tends to bring the worse from directors , Zefferelli, Hall, etc They forget this is a Frenchmans view of Spain, it's a very French opera indeed. The best production I ever was involved in was in 1981 in Nancy, director Antoine Boursellier with Nadine Denize as Carmen, then again on tour 1982/83 with Glenys Linos
jamesjmertins 2 years ago
el baile wooow me encanto jajaja tra lalala tra lalalala tralalalalalalal!
moraspin 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She's surprisingly mediocre for a major production at ROH.
Lindow 2 years ago
Maria Ewing is better as Carmen in my opinion;)
DoMa444 2 years ago
I agree!! Maria Ewing is beautiful!!!
Bubbete1 2 years ago
...hm..i`ve seen better than this...but...it`s very good...in spirit of carmen...you`re right, she is not stripper,but it`s just carmen...she does all that to seduce everyone around her...i love her...i must say...in some parts i don`t think that antonacci is right for the part...but in others she is good...jonas kaufman...omg...he has the most wonderful voice, and i cried when i watched 4.act when he kills her...they did it so great...whole show is very,very good...but jonas is the best!!! <3
jovana014 3 years ago 11
@jovana014 you've seen better? can you please tell me which version then because i'm looking for the best version of carmen.
angela4993 1 year ago
@angela4993 i think marina domaschenko ist one of the best carmens
Xxmichiru90xX 1 year ago
This is so wrong! Carmen is neither a stripper nor a whore!
Roe27Ger 3 years ago
i agree 100%! but in this case why do you think that a free woman who enjoys her own body and has sex for fun is a whore?? and a stripper?? when i dance i also remove my jacket to be more comfortable... maby i am a stripper and didnt know it before!! lol!! :-D
antonacci looks so carmen to me!! ;-)
myrtha77 3 years ago 25
You have to remember this is a stage production though, everything is done for a reason. As well as the fact that it is set some ago. So, the fact that she's being depicted ON STAGE taking of her top in those times and behaving in that manner suggests she is a whore. Comparing it to someone dancing in a club today NOT in a production is irrelevant.
minstrel05 2 years ago
Comment removed
shimmyjung 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@myrtha77 I think that is the charactor of the carmen from its original story...She was a gypsy in old time.. I feel like this carmen was just walked out from the book
shimmyjung 1 year ago
in your opinion, even though it may be the popular opinion around the opera snobs, its still that.
jmahlon 2 years ago
jmahlon, who are you replying to with this somehat enigmatic response???
Roe27Ger 2 years ago
blufffffffffffffffffffffff
sussanin80 3 years ago 2
1/1
ness906 3 years ago
1:51=beautiful girl
Loomesy55 3 years ago
Better performance of Carmenn i have seen. Shame the translation is so poor.
LonelyElle 3 years ago
What a vivacious performance!! Encore!
jeffbrak 3 years ago 2
magnifica!!!!
nardones73 3 years ago
Magique!!!!!!!! J'adore!!!
Yayahouette 3 years ago
hot!
Klassizismus 3 years ago 3
have a talented actress, a nice handelian voice sing this role and you have a sensuous, neat rendition of the role. Ms Antonacci is not the best singer ever but she is Carmen to the core
idraote 3 years ago 3
bravo!!
flute1982 3 years ago
she sounds like soprano, defenetly, but I like it!
cantanteporsiempre 3 years ago 2
Gosh! the end is just great!
fer1179 3 years ago
mierrrrr...que buena la actuacion....esta muy chevere...uffffffffffffffffff
neymusic19 4 years ago