Thanks Vijay for your reply. I have also gone through some of replies to other quairies. You are very open and frank. It is a good virtue. I am pleased by your answer and l iked it being a disciplined teacher.
May Godeess Saraswati be with yu in your endeavour.
I just watched in Yout-tube your playing 'Vichitra Veena'. It is quite nice to listen. Will you please clarify my dount whether this instrument is same as 'Gotu Vadyam' , and now a new name is given to it and whether the Gotu Vadaym is different.
Thank you for your observations. Yes it is Gotu Vadyam and its given names were Hanumath Veena and Vichitra Veena and Gotu Vadyam is a name that it came to be known under, much later. I preferred to have its original ancient name Vichitra Veena as it s indeed a Vichitra Veena. Thanks.
i don't like the fiddle. Is this a Saraswati Veena played with slide...this looks different than other vachitr veena i've seen they look more like rudra veena than this.
As long as the accompanying instrument doesn't disturb mine, it is fine. I know that veena probably doesn't require a violin. But I enjoy to share my playing with the violin sometimes. And I would like to bring it to your kind attention, this violinist, Mr. M.A. Krishnaswamy comes from an illustrious violinists' family (Parur tradition) and is one of the very best. Saraswathi veena has frets and this has no frets. It is similar in shape to a Saraswathi veena though.
I never get tired of listening to this. Yes, now I remember Bala Kanakamaya as Atana. This weekend I found myself trying to learn Shivaranjani and listened to the Gundechar brothers and Rajan and Sajan Mishra for hours. Would love some other recommendations. Thank you!
Thanks. Carnatic Pa and Hindusthani Pa are the same. And komal dha is the same in carnatic too. Notes won't change from this system to that. Listen to it again with tambura on and you can see. Bala Kanakamaya is a Krithi of Thyagaraja in raga Atana and it has no connection to Hindolam. Good luck with your Sitar learning.
Oh my gosh it's you in the video? Way cool! Is a Carnatic pa like a khomal dha? Yes, I was thinking of Hindolam; isn't Balakanakamya from the movie Sankarabharanam based on Hindolam? I will check out your other vidoes. I'm in Chicago, learning sitar.
south asian blues...
keeelane 11 months ago
Dear Sri Vijay
Thanks Vijay for your reply. I have also gone through some of replies to other quairies. You are very open and frank. It is a good virtue. I am pleased by your answer and l iked it being a disciplined teacher.
May Godeess Saraswati be with yu in your endeavour.
Prof.hbpv
MrHBPV 1 year ago
Dear Sri Venkatesh,
Thank you for your kind words and wishes. May God bless you and your family with all good things.
Regards
VijayVenkateshwar 1 year ago
Dear Sri Vijay
I just watched in Yout-tube your playing 'Vichitra Veena'. It is quite nice to listen. Will you please clarify my dount whether this instrument is same as 'Gotu Vadyam' , and now a new name is given to it and whether the Gotu Vadaym is different.
Prof. Venkatesh, Bangalore-79
MrHBPV 1 year ago
Dear Prof. Venkatesh,
Thank you for your observations. Yes it is Gotu Vadyam and its given names were Hanumath Veena and Vichitra Veena and Gotu Vadyam is a name that it came to be known under, much later. I preferred to have its original ancient name Vichitra Veena as it s indeed a Vichitra Veena. Thanks.
VijayVenkateshwar 1 year ago
i don't like the fiddle. Is this a Saraswati Veena played with slide...this looks different than other vachitr veena i've seen they look more like rudra veena than this.
KillinDaWelfareMCs 2 years ago
Friend,
As long as the accompanying instrument doesn't disturb mine, it is fine. I know that veena probably doesn't require a violin. But I enjoy to share my playing with the violin sometimes. And I would like to bring it to your kind attention, this violinist, Mr. M.A. Krishnaswamy comes from an illustrious violinists' family (Parur tradition) and is one of the very best. Saraswathi veena has frets and this has no frets. It is similar in shape to a Saraswathi veena though.
VijayVenkateshwar 1 year ago
wow.. its amazingggly played.. kudos to vijay!
maheranju 2 years ago
I never get tired of listening to this. Yes, now I remember Bala Kanakamaya as Atana. This weekend I found myself trying to learn Shivaranjani and listened to the Gundechar brothers and Rajan and Sajan Mishra for hours. Would love some other recommendations. Thank you!
nnuhnoh 2 years ago
Thanks. Carnatic Pa and Hindusthani Pa are the same. And komal dha is the same in carnatic too. Notes won't change from this system to that. Listen to it again with tambura on and you can see. Bala Kanakamaya is a Krithi of Thyagaraja in raga Atana and it has no connection to Hindolam. Good luck with your Sitar learning.
VijayVenkateshwar 3 years ago
My vote is Sa ga ma dha ni because I think it's the Carnatic of Hindustani's Malkauns.
nnuhnoh 3 years ago
Hi, It is sa ga ma pa ni and it has no connection to Malkauns. Hindolam is the Carnatic equivalent of the raga Malkauns of Hindusthani
VijayVenkateshwar 3 years ago
Oh my gosh it's you in the video? Way cool! Is a Carnatic pa like a khomal dha? Yes, I was thinking of Hindolam; isn't Balakanakamya from the movie Sankarabharanam based on Hindolam? I will check out your other vidoes. I'm in Chicago, learning sitar.
nnuhnoh 3 years ago
hi selvibbbb
its sa ga ma pa ni ,,,,,, it does not have dha,,, is it typing mistake? anyway
very nicely played,,,,,i love this instrument,,,, hope to see more videos from this player.
svr79ind 3 years ago
Like the western pentatonic blues scale, correct?
cartoontortoise 3 years ago
this sounded kinda liked shuddha satvananda revathi
un4getablefriend 4 years ago
thank you for posting this. The kottuvadyam/chitraveena are beautiful sounding instruments. I hope you post more!
guitarguy1381 4 years ago