Yeah riiiight he "ruined" it, he altered the time so you cannot listen the original piano version from now on :/ Stop bitching about every little thing and go away.
@AmaoNoBolso Bah! this is a "piece" of cake for the piano, hehe :) but gitar, its very different, i mean its transcribing an instrument utilizing 10 fingers with 88 keys for an instrument with 6 strings.
hmm.. why not just enjoy music and not worry about this stuff? I think the arranger of this piece did a remarkable job in conveying the essence in just 6 strings!
Das Arrangement ist gut aber die Umsetzung doch sehr "schülerhaft".
Aber warum dieses Stück nicht auf Gitarre gespielt werden sollte oder sogar generell nur auf Klavier will mir nicht einleuchten.
Es gibt Stücke die sind für einen bestimmten Klang "komponiert" und klingen auf anderen Instrumenten schlecht. Aber klassische Gitarre past wunderbar zu diesem Stück.
Chopin is said to have said, the only thing more beautiful then the guitar is two guitars. he loved guitar, and i have heard he perhaps wrote a few peices for the guitar (although i have never been able to find them, at least not yet). there are some fabulous arrangements of Chopins pieces for guitar, including 19th century arrangements when he was still alive, notably, Polish guitarist Jan Bobrowicz, who perhaps met Chopin and had input from him when arranging his music to guitar.
I didn't say the guitar doesn't have it's preferred genres. Obviously heavy metal sounds better on the guitar, but heavy metal is crap anyway. Try playing raindrop prelude on guitar. Listen to the result.... Really poor compared to the equivalent on piano. I love the guitar. I have been playing it for 6 years. I'm just saying the piano is the superior instrument. And it is.
Piano in Rock, Heavy Metal, etc: worse than guitar. I still like the sound of a piano better, but in certain genres the guitar is easily better. In the above video however, it is not.
Good God, what an unbelievably childish discussion! What is better, eating or drinking? Breathing or heartbeat? Guitar or piano?
The guitar has 6 strings so you are limited to playing 6 tones simultaneously opposed to 10 on the piano plus some more if you let them cling. On the other hand on the guitar you operate the strings directly giving you more possibilities to influence the sound and therefore a broader spectrum of expression.
You can extend that line: violins 4 strings even more expr.!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Please, if you are going to play songs of complexity, put it on a classical guitar! the tones are not muddled that way :). Not anything wrong with your playing, just that steel strings are made for standard strumming, and single melody lines, not both harmony and melody
mskerjanc that is completely incorrect. Barrios played steel strings. I play steel strings. I play this piece on steel strings and move audiences. Nylon is only one way, heh
unbelievable man. i play this on piano and i can still respect the effort here. don't forget this one. i'd love to see it mastered and back up on here. so close to perfect. way to go!
stop, stop, STOP! ruining a beautiful piano piece! I was waiting to see how you handled the deeper, minor part, but thankfully you stopped before you got to it!
lol athedon, it's a good effort though, chopin doesn't ever lay well on the guitar :/ I've got an arrangement myself, which I can send an mp3 of if you want
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
go for it! I'm shocked my post wasn't shunned by everyone! Yay! Of course it is a good attempt, and I think if I didn't know the piano 'version'it would sound quite good... but yeah.
please please can you send me the Tabs on a text of this song.. it is good... a couple of dead notes.... nees just a lil bit more of fluency.. heheh thats all.. please send me the tabs please..
I think it's good, especially since i've yet to see anyone else with the balls to try to play this on guitar. it needs work, sure, but at least he tried.
add me on this. I arranged this song today will post video soon. This arrangement is not taking advantage of certain sonic capabilities of the guitar. You'll see with my arrangement. Plus your choices for dominant 7th chords are very not chopin, it'd be better in fact to omit the 7th and play the 9th instead on MANY of these...
You ever listen to people play it on the piano? Man, they don't even bother with a tempo. Free time is crap imo. But I agree this song needs a steady rhythm.
T'es presque la mon ami. Comme les autres disent, juste un peu plus de pratique et ce sera une performance excellente. Il n'y a pas beaucoup de gens qui peuvent joeur des chansons comme ca a la guitare alors courage car tu es special, toi.
Yes, it is in"Popular Classics of the Great Composers" Arranged for the classical guitar by Jason Waldron, vol 1.
gutplucker 1 year ago
Hello There, Do you you have this TAB? I love this song...
eduardogaletti 1 year ago
Cool, I've actually never heard this pice performed on a guitar before. It was awesome!
MrProgrock 2 years ago
Charming piece,very nice.
hydraTV 2 years ago
I wanted to learn this song on guitar but it's not nearly as dramatic as on the piano...
Enayjay16 2 years ago
bravo, is exelent
arufer10 2 years ago
thanks! nice of you to say so!
gutplucker 2 years ago
Aww man where did you find the standard notation? I don't know how to read it for guitar but I'll try JUST for this song =)
ariadarabi 2 years ago
Comment removed
postmodernschism 2 years ago
thanks, it is fun to play those classics you've heard all your life on a guitar!
gutplucker 3 years ago
I bet it was hell trying to play that on steel string like that. Bet you got sore fingers.
I only play bass electrics, so i can only imagin what It took to even get Raindrop to sound that good.
Good work.
thooko 3 years ago
oh my gosh!
This was so well played, and such as the version on the piano, soo touching! Thanks a lot for this Video!
angel18black 3 years ago 2
You did a very good job on this :P
dragonferno 3 years ago
dude this is so awesome can you give me the tab please?
SUBLIME1416 3 years ago
sorry, I'm reading this from standard notation.
gutplucker 3 years ago
@gutplucker do u know where i could find the score
jeff551z 1 year ago
Simply perfect
victorbite 3 years ago
thank you.
gutplucker 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
thanks for ruining my favorite song
there is a reason it is played on the piano
ella8668 3 years ago
Yeah riiiight he "ruined" it, he altered the time so you cannot listen the original piano version from now on :/ Stop bitching about every little thing and go away.
Jagguar20 3 years ago 9
Where did you find the tab for this ? I can't seem to find it lol...
Names44556 3 years ago
check out 'popular classics of the great composers' by Jason Waldron, vol 1 p 46 &47
gutplucker 3 years ago
thats a nice job. i believe it s harder learning this on a guitar than a piano and i play both.
i dont understand some people s comments..why assimiling guitar with heavy metal????
music is beutiful why dont you enjoy!!!
(or maybe is it about jealousy or you dont even play any music instrument?)
AmaoNoBolso 3 years ago 4
I entirely agree! thanks for your comments.
HeyBuddy7 3 years ago
@AmaoNoBolso Bah! this is a "piece" of cake for the piano, hehe :) but gitar, its very different, i mean its transcribing an instrument utilizing 10 fingers with 88 keys for an instrument with 6 strings.
0blacone 1 year ago
Dude this is really cool.I've never thought of Raindrops being played on the guitar.
sukininja 3 years ago
wie gewollt und nicht gekonnt.
Wer kein Klavier spielt, sollte dieses Stück in Ruhe lassen.
Aber der Versuch an sich....ok.
peace
Weissbierforlive 3 years ago
hmm.. why not just enjoy music and not worry about this stuff? I think the arranger of this piece did a remarkable job in conveying the essence in just 6 strings!
gutplucker 3 years ago
Zum 1. ja, zum 2. nein!
Das Arrangement ist gut aber die Umsetzung doch sehr "schülerhaft".
Aber warum dieses Stück nicht auf Gitarre gespielt werden sollte oder sogar generell nur auf Klavier will mir nicht einleuchten.
Es gibt Stücke die sind für einen bestimmten Klang "komponiert" und klingen auf anderen Instrumenten schlecht. Aber klassische Gitarre past wunderbar zu diesem Stück.
Tholomaios 3 years ago
Chopin is said to have said, the only thing more beautiful then the guitar is two guitars. he loved guitar, and i have heard he perhaps wrote a few peices for the guitar (although i have never been able to find them, at least not yet). there are some fabulous arrangements of Chopins pieces for guitar, including 19th century arrangements when he was still alive, notably, Polish guitarist Jan Bobrowicz, who perhaps met Chopin and had input from him when arranging his music to guitar.
kpcart 3 years ago
Watching this video I now realise how much more superior an instrument the piano is. The piano really is the king of all instruments.
Nineteen80Nine 3 years ago
Try playing heavy metal on the piano...
DarthMart2 3 years ago
I didn't say the guitar doesn't have it's preferred genres. Obviously heavy metal sounds better on the guitar, but heavy metal is crap anyway. Try playing raindrop prelude on guitar. Listen to the result.... Really poor compared to the equivalent on piano. I love the guitar. I have been playing it for 6 years. I'm just saying the piano is the superior instrument. And it is.
Nineteen80Nine 3 years ago
Sorry, guess I didn't have a good point. I can't even play the guitar anyways, only piano. But heavy metal DOES NOT SUCK! We all have our tastes.
Gorgool 3 years ago 2
Dammit, I answered with my other user, sorry.
DarthMart2 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol ok. Also i think the piano is harder to learn as i'm trying to learn it too. anyways good day
Nineteen80Nine 3 years ago
Piano in general: better than guitar.
Piano in Rock, Heavy Metal, etc: worse than guitar. I still like the sound of a piano better, but in certain genres the guitar is easily better. In the above video however, it is not.
ponchato 3 years ago
Heavy Metal is not crap.
Jagguar20 3 years ago
Good God, what an unbelievably childish discussion! What is better, eating or drinking? Breathing or heartbeat? Guitar or piano?
The guitar has 6 strings so you are limited to playing 6 tones simultaneously opposed to 10 on the piano plus some more if you let them cling. On the other hand on the guitar you operate the strings directly giving you more possibilities to influence the sound and therefore a broader spectrum of expression.
You can extend that line: violins 4 strings even more expr.!
Tholomaios 3 years ago 3
rhytm ! :)
gagusha 3 years ago
In a parallel universe a hillbilly called Fred Chopin once sat down with his banjo and composed a very similar tune ;)
SmiertSpionem 3 years ago
And that's awesome.
forscyvus 3 years ago
wow man that was great, but if you wouldn't mind ,could tell me ware I can find the cords for that. if you could "thanks"
mocooltwo 3 years ago
excellent rendition. anyone who think creating such music is very much mistaken.
YouTu8e 3 years ago
great!
jimbojimbojimbojimbo 3 years ago
wow very good playing! Im trying to learn this piece myself. Keep up the good work!
NieblaProductions 3 years ago
me too, but i've just headed straight for finger-picking that beefy bass riff (not featured here), that's where the money's at in IMO.
Barca87 3 years ago
You're absolutely right. I have played a lot of these pieces. I think Bach would have loved the modern guitar!
gutplucker 3 years ago
its good for trying but this piece is definitely better on piano... just not meant for guitar
amnobody0703 3 years ago
Sorry I didnt saw the comment above.
Jagguar20 4 years ago
How much do your guitar cost? It sounds nice.
Jagguar20 4 years ago
This is like standard tunning but the 6th cord is the only thing that changes right? Nice vid!
Jagguar20 4 years ago
that's right, DADGBE
gutplucker 4 years ago
woww i can play this on piano but not on guitar :O greatt job
flubberdubber 4 years ago 4
wow, how much did u pay for that guitar..., its a sant cruz right?
clpton62 4 years ago
that's right, they're not cheap, but have a lovely tone. It is nice to play classical pieces on a steel string occasionally.
gutplucker 4 years ago
this was a beautiful rendition of a beautiful song
metalgod2347 4 years ago 2
sry dude, but u should let it stay at the piano.
gopackers61 4 years ago
I agree.
You definatley are very skilled no doubt about it, but I just don't think that this song sounds very good on guitar..
=/
Nordo666 3 years ago
i liked it =)
methodicalman271192 4 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Please, if you are going to play songs of complexity, put it on a classical guitar! the tones are not muddled that way :). Not anything wrong with your playing, just that steel strings are made for standard strumming, and single melody lines, not both harmony and melody
mskerjanc 4 years ago
sez who?
gutplucker 4 years ago
mskerjanc that is completely incorrect. Barrios played steel strings. I play steel strings. I play this piece on steel strings and move audiences. Nylon is only one way, heh
jazzpsalti 3 years ago
i like it if only it had sheet music cuz i play the acoutic guitar :(
pielordmitch 4 years ago
unbelievable man. i play this on piano and i can still respect the effort here. don't forget this one. i'd love to see it mastered and back up on here. so close to perfect. way to go!
CardMe 4 years ago 2
stop, stop, STOP! ruining a beautiful piano piece! I was waiting to see how you handled the deeper, minor part, but thankfully you stopped before you got to it!
athedon 4 years ago
lol athedon, it's a good effort though, chopin doesn't ever lay well on the guitar :/ I've got an arrangement myself, which I can send an mp3 of if you want
jazzpsalti 4 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
go for it! I'm shocked my post wasn't shunned by everyone! Yay! Of course it is a good attempt, and I think if I didn't know the piano 'version'it would sound quite good... but yeah.
athedon 4 years ago
the notes are good, but the playing is only decent... it's hard to believe that someone can transcribe this haha
thejugglenaut91 4 years ago
please please can you send me the Tabs on a text of this song.. it is good... a couple of dead notes.... nees just a lil bit more of fluency.. heheh thats all.. please send me the tabs please..
pichichi010 4 years ago
I think it's good, especially since i've yet to see anyone else with the balls to try to play this on guitar. it needs work, sure, but at least he tried.
deadlikeme667 4 years ago
add me on this. I arranged this song today will post video soon. This arrangement is not taking advantage of certain sonic capabilities of the guitar. You'll see with my arrangement. Plus your choices for dominant 7th chords are very not chopin, it'd be better in fact to omit the 7th and play the 9th instead on MANY of these...
jazzpsalti 4 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
shit
Arminhothebest 4 years ago
clean it a bit
zombiehitman666 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
don't like this on guitar... it should have a rhythm (it's a rain! )...
alexrach99 4 years ago
You ever listen to people play it on the piano? Man, they don't even bother with a tempo. Free time is crap imo. But I agree this song needs a steady rhythm.
Kneescrape911 4 years ago
T'es presque la mon ami. Comme les autres disent, juste un peu plus de pratique et ce sera une performance excellente. Il n'y a pas beaucoup de gens qui peuvent joeur des chansons comme ca a la guitare alors courage car tu es special, toi.
pierre6891 4 years ago
Merci ! Vous etes très gentille !
gutplucker 4 years ago
practice it more till it's perfect
AlexShulhan123 4 years ago
Needs cleaning up.
boobtuber06 5 years ago