I think a lot of the people who say Axl is better and that Weiland is trash have never heard STP. I'm not saying they can't think Axl is better, but Scott Weiland is one of the best singers in rock and roll history. IMO Scott is a better singer and lyricist and STP is a better band. GNR has mass appeal though.
Is not about getting famous... He played with Paulina Rubio and he was asked about that, you know what his answer was? "I didn't know she was a pop star". I'm sorry, but Slash doesn't play with a stranger just to be nice, a load of money was involved... I'm not saying that he playing a pop star is wrong (though I don't personally like it) what I'm trying to say is that in his words he didn't even know who she was, that sounds like a sellout right there!
I bet it was the same with Marta Sanchez... At least with Fergie, he said many times he liked her voice, that she had a rocker's voice, whatever! I'm aware you never talked to me but I just thought I should give my perspective so you try to understand us lol!
"Selling out" is the compromising of (or the perception of compromising) integrity, morality, or principles in exchange for money. That's what it means and that's what I knew, so I do know, thank you very much! What about a more developed response next time? At least I got facts for reasons to believe what I do...
THUMB DOWN FOR SCOTT :p HIS STYLE IN SINGING IS LIKE A DRUNK MAN, HIS 'LIVE' VOICE IS BAD,CAN'T BE COMPARED TO AXL VOICE WHICH IS ALWAYS GREAT. SCOTT<<<< AXL IT'S PROVED THAT SCOTT ISN'T IN VELVET REVOLVER AGAIN NOW,IT MEANS THAT HE'S NO GOOD QUALITY FOR SLASH :D
@xXMaidenVnaXx What do you mean he lost it? I'm not sure what you mean by that. I've seen him twice recently and he was amazing both times. To be honest I think it depends on his mood.
What??? No way dude. Scott is average at best and can never be compared with someone that can sing like Axl!!! And Chinese Democracy has sold more albums that Contraband! FACT!!!
@axlsgingerhair Actually Chinese Democracy has sold more copies then Contraband,Libertad,and Slash solo record put together:-) And yes,you are right,Axl is the greatest frontmen in rock history,and one of the greatest singers in rock history! Scott is light years away from him!
@ivanmayers Your out of your mind. Contraband broke over 1 million, Chinese Democracy didn't even pass the 400,000 mark. This is all very well documented. Everyone knows this, even the casual fan. Why the hell would you put out such a lie? Axl is a fag, he got a taste for it after sucking Elton John. Velvet revolver exposed the myth of Axl Rose. Chinese Democracy nailed Axl for the fraud he is and Velvet Revolver is now in position to release a third album once they find a lead singer.
@bryanjones007 You have no clue, Axl is lightyears ahead of weiland! And gnr would not have been if not for axl! THE greatest frontman in history!Maybe with all the lead singers VR go through, that should tell u something right there! Maybe axl isn't as much the douch as the rest!!!!
@markobaa Actually no,but you are not the first person to tell me that! Problem is that 90% of the people takes there information from Wikipedia,that is great for history,but is not good for something that changes every day (like record sales) beacuse is not updateing regullary! C.D. sale went over the roof in 2010-2011 after the tour,so it has sale 4.2 mil. till now,and that is more then bouth V.R. and Slash solo record! If you dont belive me you can check it out on Billboard!
WOAH! I didn't know Scott and Axl had a BEEF! Shit!!! Who's the best!?... I listen to Guns N' Roses, Stone Temple Pilots and Velvet Revolver! .... I Think Axl Rose has problems, But for what I know Axl Rose and Scott Weiland are the Greatest Vocals of all Time!!!
Scott owns this fag that uses a wig and can't sing a cheat, even in his prime. Scott had a lot of fases, his voice change a lot, but it still way better than Axl in any aspect.
Weiland is a fucked up asshole! Axl rose is a fucking genius! Chinese Democracy IS a great album. Axl has an amazing live voice and never lip synced like Scott Bellend has!! He can hardly string words together! That loser could only sing like Axl IN HIS FUCKING DREAMS!!!
@axlsgingerhair Axl no Doubt he the Best, but Scott has Well! They both Talented Best Vocals of all time!!! Guns N' Roses One of the best band of all time and STILL, but I got to say Velvet Revolver Contraband album made it Big, than Chinese Democracy! and no personal opinion! FUCKED HEAD!!! XD
Even if you don't like him as a person or don't like his style of vocals, you HAVE to admit Axl is one of the most skillful rock vocalists ever, and one of the best frontmen ever. Scott can't hit a note to save his life.
Weiland is faggot, your comparing him to one of the greatest hard rock frontman of all time? Wow you guys are funny guns n roses was the last great hard rock band in the world. You cant compare this shit bag to a god like Axl Rose, Axl Rose by himself still bring large audiences to his shows
ive seen weiland in person and he was amazing alot of energy and alot of crowd control but axl has a little bit more confidence scott seemed like he was working more off of drugs than axl was even though i know axl was fucked up
chinese democracy was the biggest joke GNR ever released, and to have anyone say they liked it is noob, its not even guns n roses man, its axl not letting go, GNR is done IMO, and yes Axl is the biggest drama queen in music sense Eminem, fuck the bs, who gives a fuck anyway
lol, axl is jealous of something, MAYBE BETTER MUSIC? he talks shit 1st about kurt, then scott n god knows who else. i think hes a little bitch, because he loves the drama. and girls looooove drama.
Axl sings like his pants are cutting off circulation to his genitalia. Weiland has a much better voice. Axl is just a prima donna, he's always jealous of other people having the spotlight. Sorry but Slash and the other instrumentalists made GNR what it was.
chances are that weiland actually did meet axl back in the day but was too fucked up to remember it haha... anyway, stone temple pilots is much better than the new gnr in my opinion.
I just laugh at Axel, He is half the Man he used to be, and a 1/4 of Scott's talent, with 10 x's the wanna be attitude. For him to even say anything about any musician shows his insecurity as a former musician. Any real musician would appreciate what Scott says and does. He is Humble and thankful for his gifts. We all know who the real poser is, he's just jealous, he can't write music as good as Scott and his former band mates didn't ask him to be in Velvet Revolver. Grow up Axel. Just ask Izzy
Guns may have only released 3 albums compared to STP's 6 BUT ight i add, guns saved rock, had the best sellign debut album ever made, AND still get alot of credit for their music. GNR wins
F**k Axl Rose.... Hes always starting bullshit with ppl and acting all badass. He done the same thing to Kurt. Axl sucks and he is jelious of ppl who make TRUE good music!
axl rose sucks ass... he should drop dead stupid piece of shit... always acting tough and bullshit... u are fucking dead man... u had your time... now you are a nobody... a fkin loooooooooooooooooooooooser! die already
1st of all the people that criticize and make fun of Scott & STP are a bunch of jerks. I'm a huge fan of both GNR & STP. I'm also a fan of both singers. But comparing both bands?! Obviously, if u do that u don't know s... about music, let alone rock 'n roll. STP doesn't create the same kind of music and is very different from GNR. Both bands r great. Scott is already a legend for anybody that loves rock 'n roll. Btw, who's dead and doesn't exist anymore??? GNR, Axl & co. of course!!! Go STP!!!
1st of all the people that criticize and make fun of Scott & STP are a bunch of jerks. I'm a huge fan of both GNR & STP. I'm also a fan of both singers. But comparing both bands?! Obviously, if u do that u don't know s... about music, let alone rock 'n roll. STP doesn't create the same kind of music and is very different from GNR. Both bands r great. Scott is already a legend for anybody that loves rock 'n roll. Btw, who's dead and doesn't exist anymore??? GNR, Axl & co. of course!!! Go STP!!!
1st of all people that criticize and make fun of Scott & STP are a bunch of jerks. I'm a huge fan of both GNR & STP. I'm also a fan of both singers. But comparing both bands?! Obviously, if u do that u don't know s... about music, let alone rock 'n roll. STP doesn't create the same kind of music and is very different from GNR. Both bands r great. Scott is already a legend for anybody that loves rock 'n roll. Btw, who's dead and doesn't exist anymore??? GNR, Axl & co. of course!!! Go STP!!!
1st of all the people that criticize and make fun of Scott & STP are a bunch of jerks. I'm a huge fan of both GNR & STP. I'm also a fan of both singers. But comparing both bands?! Obviously, if u do that u don't know s... about music, let alone rock 'n roll. STP doesn't create the same kind of music and is very different from GNR. Both bands r great. Scott is already a legend for anybody that loves rock 'n roll. Btw, who's dead and doesn't exist anymore??? GNR, Axl & co. of course!!! Go STP!!!
1st of all the people that criticize and make fun of Scott & STP are a bunch of jerks. I'm a huge fan of both GNR & STP. I'm also a fan of both singers. But comparing both bands?! Obviously, if u do that u don't know s... about music, let alone rock 'n roll. STP doesn't create the same kind of music and is very different from GNR. Both bands r great. Scott is already a legend for anybody that loves rock 'n roll. Btw, who's dead and doesn't exist anymore??? GNR, Axl & co. of course!!! Go STP!!!
you cant even compare them?! Guns n roses much more of a legendary band than STP/VR. Plus Axl is a much greater singer than weiland. Sure he has issues but regardless Axl is a better performer than Scott Weiland
you can not campare W. AXL ROSE with scott gayland .... AXL is a LEGEND he will never be forgotten on the other hand scott is just a singer that everybody wil be forgotten well and scott is fat too just look at the concerts and he is a gay when he tries to dance hahahaha xD!!
idc what anyone says the old GnR at the time it was together was the best at its time better than STP ever will and if they were to get back together they will a force to be reckoned with in the music industry
...STP may have all the albums and all the songs you want...but GUNS N ROSES have the best albums and the best songs...i like both but GNR is my favorite band EVER EVER AND FOREVER
Putting Axl down is the words of the younger generation and not listening to what slash says. slash has admitted that alot of negetiveness towards Axl is because of slash and his negetiveness towards everything and everyone because of the booze and drugs. Scott looked alot better and sang better before all his addiction problems.
@UseYourIllusionz no, sorry I worded it that way, I actually do like their music, they wrote some masterpieces, but some of Axls hissy fits caused riots and he went way too over the top telling people to "fuck up" audience members he didn't like, I can understand being pissed off, but telling people that look up to you (some of which are not too bright) to fuck up a fan in a crowd that size is just asking for shit to happen. I would just have liked them more if axle wasn't so fast to snap.
Early Guns N' Roses ("Appetite for Destruction" to "Use Your Illusion II" along with their covers of "Since I Don't Have You" and "Sympathy for the Devil") was awesome, but it all went to shit. Axl's ego grew way too big. I only liked one track from "Chinese Democracy", and that was the title track. STP on the other hand has ruled with each and every one of their (now) 6 albums, and they've never had to replace any members. Anything Scott Weiland touches turns to gold. He's the real legend.
@DethklokNirvana Except Kurt pretty much caused the one with Nirvana since Axle said he loved Nirvana and Cobain, and right after Cobain started talking shit about Axle (Not that I blame Kurt).
My cousin works at a rehab facility in Pasadena & met Scott a couple of years ago when he brought his girlfriend in for treatment. He was real down to earth & friendly with my cousin. Axl Rose is a waste of humanity & needs to shut his obnoxious mouth already. He's not a likeable guy.
como van a comparar scott cn axl por dios, scott esta muy lejos a años luz de axl rose. son comparaciones estupidas. es como q compararan en el futbol a brasil cn honduras jaja
Poor Axl, he has lost his voice, he is fat and stoopid, now he wants some attention by saying stupid stuff about Scott. Axl u used 2 be great now you are pathetic, you should retire with a little bit of dignity now, new GNR are a fucking joke
o Axl pode ter sido um grande vocalista e um grande frontman, mas hoje em dia já não é!!! O Weiland continua a partir tudo e o Axl está preso ao passado, tá na altura de acordar! E se os Guns acabaram foi por culpa dele e das merdas dele...
ya mesmo...o Scott era e é bom o Axl é um excelente vocalista ainda mas a musica dele agora não vale um caracol e por isso tem necessidade de andar para aí a insultar os Velvet Revolver em especial o Scott e o Slash alem de tambem não morrer de amores pelo Matt e tambem pelo Duff a partir do momento em que ele deixou a banda
vai se- fode todo mundo seus verme otario,AXL REPRESENTA ATÉ HOJE, e vcs são um puta de um viadinho, que não sabe nem oq fala, da uma cherada nas minhas bolas, talves refresque a mente de vcs..
"he never really wanted GN'R to become so big" WTF are you talking about??? GNR did more videos and more large money making shows than pretty much any one.. and their videos are bullshit and glam to sell more records and pad their pockets.. he would have made records and then stayed out of the spotlight if this was true.. GNR is awesome and appetite is one of the best records EVER but axl is a fucking LOSER.. has been and always will be.. now he is just a washed up loser and he deserves it
My opinion: 1 Kiss has nothing to do with STP or GNR. 2 Weiland does not mess with AXL, so what gives? 3 Maybe Axl has better voice but STP has rocked longer and more constantly than GNR
Just because we dont agree doesnt mean you have to insult. GNR as the original band only has produced 3 albums, SI does not count. STP has 5 and is about to release num 6. Axl has become GNR so I dont count Chinese democracy. STP only broke up for 5 years, Axl's ego wont let him get the band back. So there it is: STP has rocked longer than guns
that´s bs we both know it, Guns has produced 4 albums. illusion 1 and 2 doesn´t count as one album, Guns sold way more then stp ever did or ever will do and even now that almost everyone (including myself) think that Guns suck they still sound way better then Stp. Sure i can agree on the fact that stp has "rocked" more constantly the guns but no way that they have done it longer or better!
STP has rocked longer than GNR. STP has released more original material in their first four albums than GNR did in their existance. GNR released a cover album (wtf is that). Each of STP's albums was different from the others. You can think that the new GNR is better than STP but you are the severe minority. Plus anyone who supports that fuck Axl who fired Izzy(he wrote the most material) and tore the band apart isn't a real GNR fan to begin with.
dude, if you´re gonna talk shit about guns perhaps you should know something about them, Axl never fired izzy, izzy left. and no yea maybe stp has been together longer then guns but guns still got WAY more albums sold and did WAY bigger shows and bigger tours. STP sucks
Actually Izzy was late most of the time and showed up when he wanted too. (IE Dont Cry video Featuring the t-shirt saying "wheres IZZY" )
Izzy and Axl both wanted to be "the man" and butted heads in the process. Yes Most of this is googled if you want to search but I say read the 3rd party book "watch you bleed" for some in dept facts.
dude Izzy quit the band before the music vids were mad, he quit affter the american leg of use your illusions world tour, then they hired gilby clarke to finish the tour and they used him for the music videos, but i thin axl is the most ass kicking frontman ever (in the '80's and 90's)
Kiss is all about money from the first start. Their image made kiss famous but not their music. Even the music industry know that. Axl don't care about money. By the way he put his money in chinese democarcy album. Chinese democarcy is a brillant album and the everyone in the music industry know that. Axl did't promote his album but sold 5.1 millions copies. Something kiss and stp can't do, so case close. Just watch chinese democarcy going to sell, just like appetite of destrution.
fuck no.i stopped reading after better then axl. r u fucking out of ur mind. axl rose has one of the widest singing ranges in the world scot wieland sounds like the jonas brothers trying to sing while getting fucked by barney.
You want range? Scott Weilland has perhaps the most diverse voice in history. His voice changes so much it seems like it's a different person singing on each song. Listen to how he sounds in Wicked Garden compared to how he sounds in Lady Picture Show. I'm not saying he's a better singer, but never say he doesn't have range.
november rain is a masterpiece and peoples all around the world love that song. Even people don't listen rock muisc but they listen november rain. That prove how great music gnr made.
November rain is a masterpiece, Right, but how many Songs guns are making now? Guns nowadays is just one band for making money, worst than KISS maybe, because at least, kiss is still making Kickass songs...
ummmm...why is dis even an issue?.... Weiland is amazing and is so recharged.........sorry Axl,...I'm thinking yr Tour here will be 'postponed' due to Personnel reasons as well...please see Def Leppard ticket sales as reference
AXel rose gotta realize that his time is up. He was amazing. WAS amazing. Scott Weiland was a little immature for saying that, but y did axel rose gotta say that.
I think a lot of the people who say Axl is better and that Weiland is trash have never heard STP. I'm not saying they can't think Axl is better, but Scott Weiland is one of the best singers in rock and roll history. IMO Scott is a better singer and lyricist and STP is a better band. GNR has mass appeal though.
Y2JLionHeart 1 week ago
no idiots can do sold out concerts!!
i lke them both but i love axl deeply
Gocim52 4 weeks ago
I love the old Axl. Velvet revlover will take my heart anytime tho
76tropicalrose 2 months ago
Well Scott Weiland & Axl Rose have one thing in commen they both have the same attitude in music
resdsox1 5 months ago
hmm I like Weiland a lil better both are great, but when you pick between a douche and a junkie I'd rather chill with a junkie
SOMAxxTHExxBAND 5 months ago
is it a bad thing to like both axl and weiland?
xxsolidsteelxx 6 months ago
Axl sucks dick
isn't he the idiot who sold out? and changed literally all his band members? fukin idiot thinks he's a cowboy
RusPrideAK 7 months ago
@RusPrideAK Actually slash sold out! Pop star slash! Axl is who he is, and has always stayed true to it!
jsb123ish 2 weeks ago
@jsb123ish apparently you do not know the meaning of selling out. Just because someone got famous doesn't mean he sold out.
RusPrideAK 2 weeks ago
@RusPrideAK
Is not about getting famous... He played with Paulina Rubio and he was asked about that, you know what his answer was? "I didn't know she was a pop star". I'm sorry, but Slash doesn't play with a stranger just to be nice, a load of money was involved... I'm not saying that he playing a pop star is wrong (though I don't personally like it) what I'm trying to say is that in his words he didn't even know who she was, that sounds like a sellout right there!
LiRoseify 5 days ago
@RusPrideAK
I bet it was the same with Marta Sanchez... At least with Fergie, he said many times he liked her voice, that she had a rocker's voice, whatever! I'm aware you never talked to me but I just thought I should give my perspective so you try to understand us lol!
LiRoseify 5 days ago
@LiRoseify you obviously do not know what "sell out" means.
RusPrideAK 5 days ago
@RusPrideAK
"Selling out" is the compromising of (or the perception of compromising) integrity, morality, or principles in exchange for money. That's what it means and that's what I knew, so I do know, thank you very much! What about a more developed response next time? At least I got facts for reasons to believe what I do...
LiRoseify 5 days ago
The biggest difference between Axl and Scott is that Axl doesnt take cock up the ass
clbaumer 9 months ago
Axl sux and he's an idiot and a fag
666Eternus666 10 months ago
@666Eternus666 And you must be 15...ha
mhollod 4 months ago
@666Eternus666 Another stupid gnr fanboy?
666Eternus666 4 months ago
He's Jealous :)
PrimusCaN 10 months ago
Navarro and Weyland?
thehornypuppy 11 months ago
axl's a douche bag, guns and poseurs lol
StrokedGT 11 months ago
I'm tired can not fail to compare with axl rose scott Weyland, one is not better than another, just different, dammit!
nahuel6088 11 months ago
just play rock n roll and stfu. thanks.
paintedwarriors 1 year ago
Myles Kennedy>All
lilORANG 1 year ago
axl... shut the fuck up
luffy555 1 year ago
THUMB DOWN FOR SCOTT :p HIS STYLE IN SINGING IS LIKE A DRUNK MAN, HIS 'LIVE' VOICE IS BAD,CAN'T BE COMPARED TO AXL VOICE WHICH IS ALWAYS GREAT. SCOTT<<<< AXL IT'S PROVED THAT SCOTT ISN'T IN VELVET REVOLVER AGAIN NOW,IT MEANS THAT HE'S NO GOOD QUALITY FOR SLASH :D
AxlRoselovesJulie90 1 year ago
@Kerintji
haha exactly XD
MedusaWitch 1 year ago
A wig-wearing, fat, botox fuck!? That's hilarious!
MotorTourerPA 1 year ago
@MotorTourerPA It most certainly is! :D
DiLibraSkyArt 11 months ago
f**k axl rose
lubietosty1 1 year ago
@xXMaidenVnaXx What do you mean he lost it? I'm not sure what you mean by that. I've seen him twice recently and he was amazing both times. To be honest I think it depends on his mood.
axlsgingerhair 1 year ago
What??? No way dude. Scott is average at best and can never be compared with someone that can sing like Axl!!! And Chinese Democracy has sold more albums that Contraband! FACT!!!
axlsgingerhair 1 year ago
@axlsgingerhair Actually Chinese Democracy has sold more copies then Contraband,Libertad,and Slash solo record put together:-) And yes,you are right,Axl is the greatest frontmen in rock history,and one of the greatest singers in rock history! Scott is light years away from him!
ivanmayers 1 year ago 12
@ivanmayers WRONG, WRONG, WRONG!
staubfc 1 year ago
@ivanmayers Your out of your mind. Contraband broke over 1 million, Chinese Democracy didn't even pass the 400,000 mark. This is all very well documented. Everyone knows this, even the casual fan. Why the hell would you put out such a lie? Axl is a fag, he got a taste for it after sucking Elton John. Velvet revolver exposed the myth of Axl Rose. Chinese Democracy nailed Axl for the fraud he is and Velvet Revolver is now in position to release a third album once they find a lead singer.
bryanjones007 7 months ago
Comment removed
TheScrubnub 7 months ago
@bryanjones007 You have no clue, Axl is lightyears ahead of weiland! And gnr would not have been if not for axl! THE greatest frontman in history!Maybe with all the lead singers VR go through, that should tell u something right there! Maybe axl isn't as much the douch as the rest!!!!
jsb123ish 2 weeks ago
@ivanmayers i like axl and i think new gnr are ok but your statement is wrong.velvet revolver alone has sold more albums than new gnr.
markobaa 2 weeks ago
@markobaa Actually no,but you are not the first person to tell me that! Problem is that 90% of the people takes there information from Wikipedia,that is great for history,but is not good for something that changes every day (like record sales) beacuse is not updateing regullary! C.D. sale went over the roof in 2010-2011 after the tour,so it has sale 4.2 mil. till now,and that is more then bouth V.R. and Slash solo record! If you dont belive me you can check it out on Billboard!
ivanmayers 2 weeks ago in playlist Liked videos
WOAH! I didn't know Scott and Axl had a BEEF! Shit!!! Who's the best!?... I listen to Guns N' Roses, Stone Temple Pilots and Velvet Revolver! .... I Think Axl Rose has problems, But for what I know Axl Rose and Scott Weiland are the Greatest Vocals of all Time!!!
TheDonKillahminati 1 year ago
@aslxgingerhair ITS SCOTT FUCKING WEILAND NOT BELLEND
brosqee 1 year ago
Weiland > Axl
End of conversation.
Kastiell977 1 year ago
Scott owns this fag that uses a wig and can't sing a cheat, even in his prime. Scott had a lot of fases, his voice change a lot, but it still way better than Axl in any aspect.
8DJUNIOR8D 1 year ago
Weiland is a fucked up asshole! Axl rose is a fucking genius! Chinese Democracy IS a great album. Axl has an amazing live voice and never lip synced like Scott Bellend has!! He can hardly string words together! That loser could only sing like Axl IN HIS FUCKING DREAMS!!!
axlsgingerhair 1 year ago
@axlsgingerhair Axl no Doubt he the Best, but Scott has Well! They both Talented Best Vocals of all time!!! Guns N' Roses One of the best band of all time and STILL, but I got to say Velvet Revolver Contraband album made it Big, than Chinese Democracy! and no personal opinion! FUCKED HEAD!!! XD
TheDonKillahminati 1 year ago
Even if you don't like him as a person or don't like his style of vocals, you HAVE to admit Axl is one of the most skillful rock vocalists ever, and one of the best frontmen ever. Scott can't hit a note to save his life.
pianomano69 1 year ago
Weiland is faggot, your comparing him to one of the greatest hard rock frontman of all time? Wow you guys are funny guns n roses was the last great hard rock band in the world. You cant compare this shit bag to a god like Axl Rose, Axl Rose by himself still bring large audiences to his shows
SKITTLESQUADFTW 1 year ago
ive seen weiland in person and he was amazing alot of energy and alot of crowd control but axl has a little bit more confidence scott seemed like he was working more off of drugs than axl was even though i know axl was fucked up
KingCobraOutlaw 1 year ago
chinese democracy was the biggest joke GNR ever released, and to have anyone say they liked it is noob, its not even guns n roses man, its axl not letting go, GNR is done IMO, and yes Axl is the biggest drama queen in music sense Eminem, fuck the bs, who gives a fuck anyway
ServerWar2Ru 1 year ago
That punk Rose couldn't hold a candle to Scott Wieland, you can't even compare them.
jgraz42 1 year ago
axl =hasbeen
nsra1933 1 year ago
lol, axl is jealous of something, MAYBE BETTER MUSIC? he talks shit 1st about kurt, then scott n god knows who else. i think hes a little bitch, because he loves the drama. and girls looooove drama.
2001lateralus 1 year ago
after have bin a big GNR fan, I now think that STP is better really love thier stuff.
TBoneMontana 1 year ago
Axl sings like his pants are cutting off circulation to his genitalia. Weiland has a much better voice. Axl is just a prima donna, he's always jealous of other people having the spotlight. Sorry but Slash and the other instrumentalists made GNR what it was.
Sickass7 1 year ago
@Sickass7 no shit
fyrstikken 1 year ago
chances are that weiland actually did meet axl back in the day but was too fucked up to remember it haha... anyway, stone temple pilots is much better than the new gnr in my opinion.
ledzeprocks21 1 year ago
PR is f**king sucks!
119kvartal 1 year ago
axl rose is a prick with ears
geeter68 1 year ago
@geeter68 Amen..
BloodHarvest21 1 year ago
axl is a pos... a poser... weiland makes ax-hole look like a bitter kook! he wishes he could have .01% of weiland's stage swagger....
slotstikskimboards 1 year ago
Comment removed
slotstikskimboards 1 year ago
scott weliand fucking rocks!!!
axl is just patetic....
brandox37 1 year ago
I just laugh at Axel, He is half the Man he used to be, and a 1/4 of Scott's talent, with 10 x's the wanna be attitude. For him to even say anything about any musician shows his insecurity as a former musician. Any real musician would appreciate what Scott says and does. He is Humble and thankful for his gifts. We all know who the real poser is, he's just jealous, he can't write music as good as Scott and his former band mates didn't ask him to be in Velvet Revolver. Grow up Axel. Just ask Izzy
bigskycharlie 1 year ago
Guns may have only released 3 albums compared to STP's 6 BUT ight i add, guns saved rock, had the best sellign debut album ever made, AND still get alot of credit for their music. GNR wins
Gnrfan04396 1 year ago 6
@Gnrfan04396 Yes what u said! and to add every single song from guns is excellent
jsb123ish 2 weeks ago
guns n roses ahora es un asco
MsSlash666 1 year ago
F**k Axl Rose.... Hes always starting bullshit with ppl and acting all badass. He done the same thing to Kurt. Axl sucks and he is jelious of ppl who make TRUE good music!
thejakeludwig 1 year ago
This Scott is soooo gay --'
Kacetedemerda 1 year ago
axl rose sucks ass... he should drop dead stupid piece of shit... always acting tough and bullshit... u are fucking dead man... u had your time... now you are a nobody... a fkin loooooooooooooooooooooooser! die already
elhombredemierda 1 year ago
@potatogod5 see the video slither. he kinda looks gay if you ask me
bman899 1 year ago
Axl sucks balls!!!! Egotistical prick that ruined a great band!! STP is way better!!!
SWBJR1 1 year ago
scott just made axl look like the biggest dushe hahaha and thats coming from a big GnR fan
SixStringSolid 1 year ago
weiland is gay but he can sing pretty good
firelord7567 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1st of all the people that criticize and make fun of Scott & STP are a bunch of jerks. I'm a huge fan of both GNR & STP. I'm also a fan of both singers. But comparing both bands?! Obviously, if u do that u don't know s... about music, let alone rock 'n roll. STP doesn't create the same kind of music and is very different from GNR. Both bands r great. Scott is already a legend for anybody that loves rock 'n roll. Btw, who's dead and doesn't exist anymore??? GNR, Axl & co. of course!!! Go STP!!!
FrenchRockNRolla7 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1st of all the people that criticize and make fun of Scott & STP are a bunch of jerks. I'm a huge fan of both GNR & STP. I'm also a fan of both singers. But comparing both bands?! Obviously, if u do that u don't know s... about music, let alone rock 'n roll. STP doesn't create the same kind of music and is very different from GNR. Both bands r great. Scott is already a legend for anybody that loves rock 'n roll. Btw, who's dead and doesn't exist anymore??? GNR, Axl & co. of course!!! Go STP!!!
FrenchRockNRolla7 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1st of all people that criticize and make fun of Scott & STP are a bunch of jerks. I'm a huge fan of both GNR & STP. I'm also a fan of both singers. But comparing both bands?! Obviously, if u do that u don't know s... about music, let alone rock 'n roll. STP doesn't create the same kind of music and is very different from GNR. Both bands r great. Scott is already a legend for anybody that loves rock 'n roll. Btw, who's dead and doesn't exist anymore??? GNR, Axl & co. of course!!! Go STP!!!
FrenchRockNRolla7 1 year ago
Comment removed
FrenchRockNRolla7 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1st of all the people that criticize and make fun of Scott & STP are a bunch of jerks. I'm a huge fan of both GNR & STP. I'm also a fan of both singers. But comparing both bands?! Obviously, if u do that u don't know s... about music, let alone rock 'n roll. STP doesn't create the same kind of music and is very different from GNR. Both bands r great. Scott is already a legend for anybody that loves rock 'n roll. Btw, who's dead and doesn't exist anymore??? GNR, Axl & co. of course!!! Go STP!!!
FrenchRockNRolla7 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1st of all the people that criticize and make fun of Scott & STP are a bunch of jerks. I'm a huge fan of both GNR & STP. I'm also a fan of both singers. But comparing both bands?! Obviously, if u do that u don't know s... about music, let alone rock 'n roll. STP doesn't create the same kind of music and is very different from GNR. Both bands r great. Scott is already a legend for anybody that loves rock 'n roll. Btw, who's dead and doesn't exist anymore??? GNR, Axl & co. of course!!! Go STP!!!
FrenchRockNRolla7 1 year ago
This dude look like a fag
Panther704 1 year ago
you cant even compare them?! Guns n roses much more of a legendary band than STP/VR. Plus Axl is a much greater singer than weiland. Sure he has issues but regardless Axl is a better performer than Scott Weiland
bman899 1 year ago
@bman899 lol have u seen Scott dance? He's a wayyyyyy better performer.
Axl is a better singer... but yeah is ego gets in the way of everything.
potatogod5 1 year ago
you can not campare W. AXL ROSE with scott gayland .... AXL is a LEGEND he will never be forgotten on the other hand scott is just a singer that everybody wil be forgotten well and scott is fat too just look at the concerts and he is a gay when he tries to dance hahahaha xD!!
huguex92 1 year ago
idc what anyone says the old GnR at the time it was together was the best at its time better than STP ever will and if they were to get back together they will a force to be reckoned with in the music industry
ZombieRedeemer 1 year ago
...STP may have all the albums and all the songs you want...but GUNS N ROSES have the best albums and the best songs...i like both but GNR is my favorite band EVER EVER AND FOREVER
Stephymusic 1 year ago
@Stephymusic Gee, you sound like a 2-year-old.
Were your parents related?
800988 1 year ago
@Stephymusic
ACTUALLY I DONT UNDERSTAND WHAT THE FUCK AXL IS FUCKING SAYING AND GNR FUCKING SUCKS
Fr4nTiC109 1 year ago
Putting Axl down is the words of the younger generation and not listening to what slash says. slash has admitted that alot of negetiveness towards Axl is because of slash and his negetiveness towards everything and everyone because of the booze and drugs. Scott looked alot better and sang better before all his addiction problems.
pinkpanther446 1 year ago
Gnr was the voice of a generation.. axl blew it but he is one of the greatest rock icons of all time... amazing artist..
316creed 1 year ago
Axl was a jerk to Cobain as well.
Kurtagx 1 year ago
@Kurtagx actually, axl liked nirvana and invited then to open for them but nirvana dissed them saying they sucked...axl just defended himself
UseYourIllusionz 1 year ago
well, if it wasnt for axl and his fucking attitude i would like GNR, i just cant stand the prick.
Smokinjoewhite 1 year ago
@Smokinjoewhite ??? tht makes no sense, so you dnt really care for the music then
UseYourIllusionz 1 year ago
@UseYourIllusionz no, sorry I worded it that way, I actually do like their music, they wrote some masterpieces, but some of Axls hissy fits caused riots and he went way too over the top telling people to "fuck up" audience members he didn't like, I can understand being pissed off, but telling people that look up to you (some of which are not too bright) to fuck up a fan in a crowd that size is just asking for shit to happen. I would just have liked them more if axle wasn't so fast to snap.
Smokinjoewhite 1 year ago
@Smokinjoewhite damn typo on the last Axl, sorry, youtube needs an edit function badly.
Smokinjoewhite 1 year ago
Early Guns N' Roses ("Appetite for Destruction" to "Use Your Illusion II" along with their covers of "Since I Don't Have You" and "Sympathy for the Devil") was awesome, but it all went to shit. Axl's ego grew way too big. I only liked one track from "Chinese Democracy", and that was the title track. STP on the other hand has ruled with each and every one of their (now) 6 albums, and they've never had to replace any members. Anything Scott Weiland touches turns to gold. He's the real legend.
SalsaShark542 1 year ago
Damn.......I thought this was one of those cool mashup mix videos
316whatup 1 year ago
Axl Blows, he's long gone and yesterdays news, Scott is still kickin it
mclprinter 1 year ago
Axl Is A Legend Man
Phoenix00777 1 year ago
Ohh Sure Is Axl Rose Man Scott Is Good But Axl Rose Is Very Better
Phoenix00777 1 year ago
Scott Gayland
TheShakler 1 year ago
Incomparable!!!! es un muerto scot !!!!!!! aguante axl rose culiadosssss
PiLiLiNGnR 1 year ago
axl sure liked to pick fights, first with kurt then with scott, what a prick.
DethklokNirvana 1 year ago
@DethklokNirvana Except Kurt pretty much caused the one with Nirvana since Axle said he loved Nirvana and Cobain, and right after Cobain started talking shit about Axle (Not that I blame Kurt).
nimaside 1 year ago
i love Axl, hes a legend
anelSOAD 1 year ago
Axl rose is my idol my hero he is amazing ur awsome axl
Modernwarfareman2 1 year ago
Axl > Wasteland
GnRKiD2k7 1 year ago 9
@GnRKiD2k7 Axl<Weiland<Kurt Cobain
aScentlessApprentice 1 year ago
Scotts a legend and Axels a fat weazel
41senna65 1 year ago
agreed! I was at the 91' riot in St.Louis (I'm from STL) but I don't dislike Axl because of that anymore, now he's just a ...dousch bag,LMAO!
slickrickmonty 1 year ago
scott is gay, i hate the way he look..go suck ur own dick...i.,
bhugzy7890 1 year ago
I would give anything to punch this fuckin faggot !!!
TheShakler 1 year ago
@TheShakler classy
deeeznuts00 1 year ago
My cousin works at a rehab facility in Pasadena & met Scott a couple of years ago when he brought his girlfriend in for treatment. He was real down to earth & friendly with my cousin. Axl Rose is a waste of humanity & needs to shut his obnoxious mouth already. He's not a likeable guy.
dualityofman999 1 year ago
Axl Rose of course he is amazing
200anee 1 year ago
axe rose is a pussy bitch faggot fuck who play 80s butt rock
boxybrown588 1 year ago
como van a comparar scott cn axl por dios, scott esta muy lejos a años luz de axl rose. son comparaciones estupidas. es como q compararan en el futbol a brasil cn honduras jaja
GUNSURVIVOR89 1 year ago
Scott cagon!!
Gdibenedetto1 1 year ago
Scott Weiland>>>>>Axl Rose seriously
ZGippe40GK 1 year ago
@ZGippe40GK - Damn right.
SaikouSaikoPsycho 1 year ago
scott weiland!!! and dave navarro!!
tomyorke9 1 year ago
dont be stupid guys!! guns and roses are in a south america tour right now and axl still has an amazing voice!!
danadao01 1 year ago
you can't be serious. Amazing voice? Hey had a great one back in the day..come on....
cybersmoothy 1 year ago
go up to your URL bar, put a Q between the words you and tube and then press enter or click go
theun703 1 year ago
Poor Axl, he has lost his voice, he is fat and stoopid, now he wants some attention by saying stupid stuff about Scott. Axl u used 2 be great now you are pathetic, you should retire with a little bit of dignity now, new GNR are a fucking joke
fabixyard 1 year ago
@fabixyard Dude this was said 3 years ago. VR is no longer, STP has reformed, and GNR are doing their own thing in South America
crimsonred17 1 year ago
eddie vedder's a douche. staley and cornell over vedder in an instant.
towelie7688 1 year ago
I wouldn't be surprised if Rose was just trying to get attention for himself since he's less relevant these days.
That being said, I actually rather liked Chinese Democracy.
Zeldovich 1 year ago
agreed with drbike and remstyle vedder ftw
salmon020 2 years ago
Im wi remstyle. Vedder rules
drbike1963 2 years ago
Eddie Vedders better than both of them...
remstyle 2 years ago
Scott Weiland SABES LO Q TE FALTA A VOS PARA SER AXL TDA UNA VIDA PEDAZO DE GIL L)
createnachitoo 2 years ago
o Axl pode ter sido um grande vocalista e um grande frontman, mas hoje em dia já não é!!! O Weiland continua a partir tudo e o Axl está preso ao passado, tá na altura de acordar! E se os Guns acabaram foi por culpa dele e das merdas dele...
trendzone 2 years ago
ya mesmo...o Scott era e é bom o Axl é um excelente vocalista ainda mas a musica dele agora não vale um caracol e por isso tem necessidade de andar para aí a insultar os Velvet Revolver em especial o Scott e o Slash alem de tambem não morrer de amores pelo Matt e tambem pelo Duff a partir do momento em que ele deixou a banda
WarningPunkSpirit 1 year ago
sos una mierda weiland morite
fabroscot 2 years ago
vai se- fode todo mundo seus verme otario,AXL REPRESENTA ATÉ HOJE, e vcs são um puta de um viadinho, que não sabe nem oq fala, da uma cherada nas minhas bolas, talves refresque a mente de vcs..
underoathryan 2 years ago
"he never really wanted GN'R to become so big" WTF are you talking about??? GNR did more videos and more large money making shows than pretty much any one.. and their videos are bullshit and glam to sell more records and pad their pockets.. he would have made records and then stayed out of the spotlight if this was true.. GNR is awesome and appetite is one of the best records EVER but axl is a fucking LOSER.. has been and always will be.. now he is just a washed up loser and he deserves it
diggler773 2 years ago
STP and GNR are two of favorite bands but the new GNR cant touch stp..
DefsoundsKingz 2 years ago
LOL what did scott called Axel
stevntylertoy 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
R U Talkin' 2 me punk ? Didn't tink so, I do here voices even win nobody's talkin', shut up me, fuck us, U !!!
WTF R I SAY N ?
GNR cool, STP better, RAMMSTEIN ROCKS
DragonovSVD 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Fuck Axl Rose and his horrible voice !!!! It's technical but so hard to hear :-) STP and Scott Weiland are the best !!! Real Rock'n roll !
kannettte 2 years ago
Its not technical, its just flat out horrible. it's okay on some studio stuff, but when we hear the truth Live, its disgusting
StreeTRacR008 2 years ago
fuck yeha weiland, youre the man. i wish we coulda met him in moncton. oh well sick show moncton and halifax
fannysnake 2 years ago
My opinion: 1 Kiss has nothing to do with STP or GNR. 2 Weiland does not mess with AXL, so what gives? 3 Maybe Axl has better voice but STP has rocked longer and more constantly than GNR
Oskarft 2 years ago
What!? STP has rocked longer then Guns?? are u fucking kidding me?! idiot
JT2534 2 years ago
Just because we dont agree doesnt mean you have to insult. GNR as the original band only has produced 3 albums, SI does not count. STP has 5 and is about to release num 6. Axl has become GNR so I dont count Chinese democracy. STP only broke up for 5 years, Axl's ego wont let him get the band back. So there it is: STP has rocked longer than guns
Oskarft 2 years ago 7
that´s bs we both know it, Guns has produced 4 albums. illusion 1 and 2 doesn´t count as one album, Guns sold way more then stp ever did or ever will do and even now that almost everyone (including myself) think that Guns suck they still sound way better then Stp. Sure i can agree on the fact that stp has "rocked" more constantly the guns but no way that they have done it longer or better!
JT2534 2 years ago
Guns N Roses- 1986-1994
STP- 1986-2002, 2007-
STP has rocked longer than GNR. STP has released more original material in their first four albums than GNR did in their existance. GNR released a cover album (wtf is that). Each of STP's albums was different from the others. You can think that the new GNR is better than STP but you are the severe minority. Plus anyone who supports that fuck Axl who fired Izzy(he wrote the most material) and tore the band apart isn't a real GNR fan to begin with.
TheFreshness11 2 years ago
Awesome comment!!!!!!!
rfsorrenti 2 years ago
dude, if you´re gonna talk shit about guns perhaps you should know something about them, Axl never fired izzy, izzy left. and no yea maybe stp has been together longer then guns but guns still got WAY more albums sold and did WAY bigger shows and bigger tours. STP sucks
JT2534 2 years ago
Comment removed
ZenQuirity 2 years ago
Actually Izzy was late most of the time and showed up when he wanted too. (IE Dont Cry video Featuring the t-shirt saying "wheres IZZY" )
Izzy and Axl both wanted to be "the man" and butted heads in the process. Yes Most of this is googled if you want to search but I say read the 3rd party book "watch you bleed" for some in dept facts.
YiuTeub 2 years ago
dude Izzy quit the band before the music vids were mad, he quit affter the american leg of use your illusions world tour, then they hired gilby clarke to finish the tour and they used him for the music videos, but i thin axl is the most ass kicking frontman ever (in the '80's and 90's)
Slash7a 2 years ago
you are right about the vids. Also he quit before the American Leg not after November 7 1991.
YiuTeub 2 years ago
@Oskarft
Well yeah but i think old Guns Rocks way more than Stone Temple Pilots, but i agree with the "Axl has become GNR" part!
TheMariusDuaas 1 year ago
@JT2534 STP has rocked longer then GNR.
Mrjimms 2 years ago
thats right? who cares about axl..who was amazing back then with slash & duff, now hes fucked...scott's awesome! STP rocks!
pinoymetaljoe 2 years ago 12
@pinoymetaljoe ya that right
michael1izzy 1 year ago
scott weiland = fucking amazing
stpunderground 2 years ago 6
Kiss is all about money from the first start. Their image made kiss famous but not their music. Even the music industry know that. Axl don't care about money. By the way he put his money in chinese democarcy album. Chinese democarcy is a brillant album and the everyone in the music industry know that. Axl did't promote his album but sold 5.1 millions copies. Something kiss and stp can't do, so case close. Just watch chinese democarcy going to sell, just like appetite of destrution.
sugarwolf8 2 years ago 2
@sugarwolf8 ur wrong chinese democracy is a sad attempt classic guns were good cuz azl could sing then and slash is fucking awesome guitar player.
STP is a great band and scott is a great singer-better than axl
and mcr07853 ur right axl is a whiney little bitch
Lexolo999 2 years ago
fuck no.i stopped reading after better then axl. r u fucking out of ur mind. axl rose has one of the widest singing ranges in the world scot wieland sounds like the jonas brothers trying to sing while getting fucked by barney.
daoldGNRrox 2 years ago
You want range? Scott Weilland has perhaps the most diverse voice in history. His voice changes so much it seems like it's a different person singing on each song. Listen to how he sounds in Wicked Garden compared to how he sounds in Lady Picture Show. I'm not saying he's a better singer, but never say he doesn't have range.
PoeticJustice05 2 years ago 3
november rain is a masterpiece and peoples all around the world love that song. Even people don't listen rock muisc but they listen november rain. That prove how great music gnr made.
sugarwolf8 2 years ago 3
November rain is a masterpiece, Right, but how many Songs guns are making now? Guns nowadays is just one band for making money, worst than KISS maybe, because at least, kiss is still making Kickass songs...
tiagomeneseslopes 2 years ago
Fuck Axle. 1980's are over. Get over it.
wojtek0000 2 years ago 2
ummmm...why is dis even an issue?.... Weiland is amazing and is so recharged.........sorry Axl,...I'm thinking yr Tour here will be 'postponed' due to Personnel reasons as well...please see Def Leppard ticket sales as reference
animelover4848 2 years ago
Scott is a genius lyrically.
spaceorbison 2 years ago
oh pls GnR had SLASH STp had SCOTT both bands r great but axl is a bitch great voice but immature bitch
rock2metal666 2 years ago
AXel rose gotta realize that his time is up. He was amazing. WAS amazing. Scott Weiland was a little immature for saying that, but y did axel rose gotta say that.
Frankificationify 2 years ago
layne staley tops axl and scott
Xexons 2 years ago
damn right!!!!
mmmtsp 2 years ago
axls all washed up, gotta face the facts u die hard gnr fans
nofingerthumb 2 years ago
weiland lol , weiland lol
yeahlucciano 2 years ago
"...and weiland responded by calling him a wig-wearing, fat, botoxed expletive."
i love axl, but i must say that scott's comeback cracks me up. pwned. XD
electricsheep93 2 years ago 2
There's nothing to compare, the guy who posted this video gave people the wrong idea.
Still, I think they were/are both great and sadly Axl is getting a little better but can't return to the greatness of his former time
caduh111 2 years ago
whats the name of the song that they are playingP
chrishunterg 2 years ago
crackerman
By STP
im pretty sure
IbaneZxiLe 2 years ago
scott cant sing anything live axl still can check out the guns n roses 2006 tours assholes scott is so bad live
TKDKobioshi 2 years ago