@IshyIMB017 Well it's in a movie so who knows what the director had in mind a when it was being sung, and I'm sure it was what she wanted, but in most opera houses this wouldn't fly. Not because of the pitch, but she's pretty sloppy with her diction and how she releases her notes, but it's really impressive that she could sing that high, the tenor too. It's usually high already for a tenor, and he takes it up even more.
What captivates me in this scene which you do not get in the opera itself is Alfredo singing directly to Violetta in plain sight. I also appreciate the fact that these two are already lovers with a romantic past, where as this moment means everything! Love this movie.
Me cautivò esta pelìcula;soy Cantante tambièn y cada vez que quiero, la veo.Aquì se combina el talento de dos jòvenes que sueñan con triunfar en el mundo de la òpera.
I sign but there is nothing to compare too. My mom has the real voice not me.. i tried doing some musicals in my past but i could never achieve anything like that. i got the singing DNA, but without practice its useless
Hi. I didn't expect to say hello to Dinah Bryant's daughter!!!
You know there a bunch of people who knew Dinah Bryant in this movie and became opera fan or took a course to become a music composer.
After seeing this movie I ordered all of your mom's CD even to USA. There were limited number of CD available and I wanted more but I did not have a clue. There was no Amazon those days.
I am still fan of this particular performance.
Maybe this was my first Sempre Libera and became my standard.
I am so happy.. by what you said and ill pass it on to my mother.. Thank you so much. She is know a teacher at the Brussels Music Conservatory. Maybe you could take a course there with her in the Summer. Hint!
I always have to watch when i miss mother, because i am in the United States right know and i miss hearing her sing as i did went i lived at home. Well anyways, i know its hard to find, mostly because my mom as not recorded anything in a long time. She does mainly concerts and operas these days. She worked in Argentina for a while and she teaching in at the music school in Brussels.
Quién es la soprano y el tenor?
Enero745 4 weeks ago
TAMBIÉN DIGO: GRACIAS!!!! ESTA PELÍCULA LA VERÍA MIL VECES, Y ESTA ESCENA EN HACE ESTREMECER. QUIENES SON LAS QUE CANTAN?
Enero745 4 weeks ago
GRACIAS TOTALES LLEVABA AÑOS BUSCANDO ESTE LINDO EPISODIO DEL MAESTRO DE MÚSICA UNA DE LAS MEJORES PELÍCULAS QUE HE VISTO.
RPRMASTER 1 month ago
Beautiful soprano (and tenor)!
Judill 1 month ago
Grande qualité de la voix, mais elle sonne un peu acide. Le son est trop métallique. Mauvaise captation ?
mariasarda 1 month ago
Was this played at a higher pitch?
IshyIMB017 6 months ago
@IshyIMB017 Yes it was. A second up if I'm not mistaken.
Loismustdie26 6 months ago
@Loismustdie26 Yeah, I noticed she doesn't sing it bad at all, but I think those high notes sound a bit annoying.
IshyIMB017 5 months ago
@IshyIMB017 Well it's in a movie so who knows what the director had in mind a when it was being sung, and I'm sure it was what she wanted, but in most opera houses this wouldn't fly. Not because of the pitch, but she's pretty sloppy with her diction and how she releases her notes, but it's really impressive that she could sing that high, the tenor too. It's usually high already for a tenor, and he takes it up even more.
Loismustdie26 5 months ago
@IshyIMB017 No
erminiospalla 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WONDERFUL movie ... one of the best ever !
Sashakie 6 months ago
THE MOST BEAUTIFUL AND SIMPLE MOVIE EVER!!!
Karl4242 9 months ago 4
bravo, bravísimo...!
agripaYT 9 months ago
I agree...one of the best ever........
Charlieface008 1 year ago
this movy is not so much about lyric singing than about being a teacher
becassine38 1 year ago
What captivates me in this scene which you do not get in the opera itself is Alfredo singing directly to Violetta in plain sight. I also appreciate the fact that these two are already lovers with a romantic past, where as this moment means everything! Love this movie.
yankeepoppa13 2 years ago
The singer is Dinah Bryant.
erminiospalla 2 years ago
Qué película preciosa!
MaruchiAFS 2 years ago
haha soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
obvious she isnt singing!!
please WHO is singing????
katesinger 2 years ago
I've always loved this movie. This Violetta is exquisite!
7inga7 2 years ago
me encantooooooo esta cancion!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! es demasiado bella, que pena que no este la pelicula completa =(
JotaDeeLe 2 years ago
Bueno, el drama de la Traviata siempre me cautivò e impresionò, al punto de mojar los ojos.
acitipo 2 years ago
Me cautivò esta pelìcula;soy Cantante tambièn y cada vez que quiero, la veo.Aquì se combina el talento de dos jòvenes que sueñan con triunfar en el mundo de la òpera.
sangeles2526 2 years ago
Well, I loved this film. Please, share with us other wonderful scene...Rose Van Dan singing with the actris by coach.
Ronaldvieira2 3 years ago
PERFECT 10!!! Who is the real singer?
godequaljesus 3 years ago
My mother Dinah Bryant Look her up on googel
angelevelyndoyle 3 years ago
your mother?
godequaljesus 3 years ago
yes i am daughter of Daniel Blumenthal the pianist and Dinah Bryant the opera singer.
angelevelyndoyle 3 years ago
If it is true, you are a very lucky girl. Are you a musician also?
godequaljesus 3 years ago 2
No i am not... never was permited to learn what i wanted which was the sax or the electric violin. So i told them i will no longer play if so.
angelevelyndoyle 3 years ago 2
If that is true, you are a very lucky girl. Are you a musician also?
godequaljesus 3 years ago 2
I sign but there is nothing to compare too. My mom has the real voice not me.. i tried doing some musicals in my past but i could never achieve anything like that. i got the singing DNA, but without practice its useless
angelevelyndoyle 3 years ago
How do you like my mother singing???
My mom Is the one singing not the actress.
Dinah Bryant.
angelevelyndoyle 3 years ago
Hi. I didn't expect to say hello to Dinah Bryant's daughter!!!
You know there a bunch of people who knew Dinah Bryant in this movie and became opera fan or took a course to become a music composer.
After seeing this movie I ordered all of your mom's CD even to USA. There were limited number of CD available and I wanted more but I did not have a clue. There was no Amazon those days.
I am still fan of this particular performance.
Maybe this was my first Sempre Libera and became my standard.
bokensdorf 3 years ago
I am so happy.. by what you said and ill pass it on to my mother.. Thank you so much. She is know a teacher at the Brussels Music Conservatory. Maybe you could take a course there with her in the Summer. Hint!
angelevelyndoyle 3 years ago
I always have to watch when i miss mother, because i am in the United States right know and i miss hearing her sing as i did went i lived at home. Well anyways, i know its hard to find, mostly because my mom as not recorded anything in a long time. She does mainly concerts and operas these days. She worked in Argentina for a while and she teaching in at the music school in Brussels.
angelevelyndoyle 3 years ago
The US release of the DVD is taking too long to happen. May I request the duel of voices part. Please?
Thanks so much for sharing.
SIBE07 3 years ago
i love this movie.
Sthemingway 3 years ago
thanks for posting this part off this wonderful movie!
letufi 4 years ago
Thank you so much for putting this up. Have looked in a lot of places for this video. Hard to find. Love this part!
MastaAsia1 4 years ago 5
one of the most beautifull movies ever made
salmancis 4 years ago 9