Regarding a Muslim man complaining about Muslims being "attacked" in America, Ayaan Hirsi Ali responded, "Critical reflection on existing dogmas is not equal to an 'attack.'"
Just when I think I'm an intelligent and wise person, I hear Ms. Ali say something like that, and I realize how far I have to go.
Most of the black people i know and interact with happen to be somalian (which are a lot in my masjids) . Other accents i hear happen to be in my mind as 'other' african accents but i can't quite pin them down (i can just compare them with accents i've heard from tv). She DOES NOT have a somalian accent ... but she's supposed to be a somalian who left islam.
The qur'an is not a religious book it is a political book with cover for social acceptance of anyone to follow or die, big difference in presentation!
I find more passion in this women for the truth, than any wifes and daughters of our american society and I feel that is because the men and the women of her past islamic cult are hidden and cannot truely discover the joys and the pleasures of true freedom of expression even when poor there is still should be the love of freedom not slavery to not a god but a man who is made a god by order of the cult! Muslims can't vote out mohammad, allah, we can if we dare to vote out obama!
Allies are the terrorist and everyone who support there illegal operations speak about that Ayaan Hirsi speak about the true radicalism and extremist called the United State of America
(the rest of the first message) over or invading other countrys but rather they are being attacked and simply defending themselves from rape and pillage defending themselves against those who seek wordily gain and kill there family at all cost, bombing babys ,women, children,and non ,military person ale. In this case the shoe is in the wrong foot Because this country and it
This lady deliberately attacks Islam and is not with trying to help the Muslim community but rather portray a certain image against the Muslims which is a dangerous thing to do Muslims and others take there belief to heart as one should and things of this nature takes a different affect on different individuals which is why her colleague Theo van gogh was murdered my advice to everyone who watches this video is to not judge the religion based on what other people think of it but read about it
Allah says in the Quran " for those whom he has guided you will find no misguidance as for those whom he has let astray for them you will find no guidance " there is no such thing as radical Islam, but I will say in some places Islam is not practiced properly all to say that strapping bombs to your chest "NO" that is not what the quern teaches but it does teach you to defend yourself your family and your religion which is why we find that the problems with the Muslims is not about them taking o
I 'm ex christian now converted to Islam..and i don't agree wid ayan..i guess she is paid for all this bullshit n her passport..well this is very common any1 who speak against Islam is highly respected n honoured in christianity..n as long as she is getting money n fame from christians she will do these bulshit lies.
Her books are popular with xenophobic people blaming Muslims for everything, as it fits in with their prejudices. She is a hack tool useful only to her neo-conservative employers in the United States.Her recent exhortations to Muslims to convert to Christianity make her sound more like Billy Graham. Hack tools such as Ayaan, "professional" former "alleged" ex-Muslims have long provided respectable cover for the bigotry and, more often, plain ignorance of mainstream western commentators on Islam.
@fromwilliams trust me sweetheart, many people are beginning to wake up to the stupidity and evil of islam, not just 'xenophobic', 'neo-conservatives'. you are scared little muslim male with a small dick. ali hirsi is worth a 100 of you. i've read a lot of your deceptive posts and you are a joke. BTW, many hindus, buddhists, sikhs, apostates, jews, christians, atheists are seeing the truth now. you weiner must be shrivelling even more. that is why your prophet raped so many women. lol
I think it may also prove helpful to some of the viewers here to try to evaluate many of the more strident claims of the anti-theist critique ("brights") from a ideological/ metaphysics perspective. Check out the recent article by Jackson Lears in the May 16, 2011 issue of the The Nation entitled "Same Old New Atheism" .The article offers a compelling analysis of Sam Harris' works. Consideration is given to general secular social perspectives
You didn't answer the question posed by one youngman saying if as you claim islam is horrible why islam is growing in the west in this 21 century, had it been a horrible doctrine?
hmmm, how snaky! "I'm not religious, but I didn't change my religious name to be more compelling." All this propagandist is talking is exaggeration about Islam misleading. If she said the truth and were confident enough, she would have had a debate with a REAL ISLAMIC OR RELIGIOUS representer. she doesn't represent Islam by what she's claiming.
@Sol009 Yes. And apparently, he is very ashamed of his face too, because he told his followers to murder anyone who dared to draw a picture of him that showed his face.
Miss Ali, with all the respect for your intellect and freedom of speech, the qur'an poses a very difficult condition of guilty. If you found them guilty.....with 4 persons (witnesses) who saw them at the same time with their own eye withness doing intercourse..."male genital into female genital..in and out" .
Then, the qur'an says: "The woman and the man guilty of illegal sexual intercourse, flog each of them with a hundred stripes. Let not pity withhold you in their case, in a punishment prescribed by Allâh, if you believe in Allâh and the Last Day. And let a party of the believers witness their punishment. (This punishment is for unmarried persons guilty of the above crime but if married persons commit it, the punishment is to stone them to death, according to Allâh's Law)"..(S 24..V2)
The woman and the man guilty of illegal sexual intercourse, flog each of them with a hundred stripes. Let not pity withhold you in their case, in a punishment prescribed by Allâh, if you believe in Allâh and the Last Day. And let a party of the believers witness their punishment. (This punishment is for unmarried persons guilty of the above crime but if married persons commit it, the punishment is to stone them to death, according to Allâh's Law)[].
Sorry, but not everyone is going to be forced to conform to your way of life. There is a little something called "Freedom of Religion" that protects people's rights to practice any religion freely without the harassment of others. Also, female circumcision has nothing to do with Islam, that is from tribal African culture.
The mere fact that this lady's live has, for years, been under threat from some Islamic adherents and as usual not explicitly condemned by moslems speaks volumes of Islam. Islamic adherents love their "extremists." They condemn their acts with great restraint. Its all an exposed cunning denial of the reality of the violent faith. It started and grew through violence. It is intolerant as its followers are. Advancing a religion through fear rather than reason is already a failed project.
She SCHOOLED that boy who spoke up with ignorant indignation. She is not attacking you or muslims at all. She is pointing out the antiquated, unjust, violent culture that needs to change. So shut up and sit!
hahahaha, its has being know, those their HUNGURI makes them fail in trap, u know what who u r and denying it makes u the ugliest human living on earth.
Hey maaligirl, What the hell are you talking about?! Get an education. "Wise voice card," that is completely ridiculous. Also you should know that Nazism was defeated in Europe, it did not just disappear. Also, she very clearly answers the issue about Islam growing. In fact she answered that point with not one but two historical examples. So yes...you are the only one that thinks she is stupid. Grow up!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I'm I the only one who find this woman's answers stupid? Yeah great, she plays the whole ''wise voice'' card but if you analyse carefully you will find many errors. Eg. she compares Nazism to Islam but forgets the fact that Nazism DISAPPEARED whilst Islam is still around and growing. So in essence she has not answered the question. Of course, dumbasses fall for her words!!!
Hey maaligirl, What the hell are you talking about?! Get an education. "Wise voice card," that is completely ridiculous. Also you should know that Nazism was defeated in Europe, it did not just disappear. Also, she very clearly answers the issue about Islam growing. In fact she answered that point with not one but two historical examples. So yes...you are the only one that thinks she is stupid. Grow up!
Regarding a Muslim man complaining about Muslims being "attacked" in America, Ayaan Hirsi Ali responded, "Critical reflection on existing dogmas is not equal to an 'attack.'"
Just when I think I'm an intelligent and wise person, I hear Ms. Ali say something like that, and I realize how far I have to go.
What an amazing woman.
Huntington12345678 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Most of the black people i know and interact with happen to be somalian (which are a lot in my masjids) . Other accents i hear happen to be in my mind as 'other' african accents but i can't quite pin them down (i can just compare them with accents i've heard from tv). She DOES NOT have a somalian accent ... but she's supposed to be a somalian who left islam.
Umar93121 2 months ago
The qur'an is not a religious book it is a political book with cover for social acceptance of anyone to follow or die, big difference in presentation!
JOHNTHEBAPTIST11 3 months ago
I find more passion in this women for the truth, than any wifes and daughters of our american society and I feel that is because the men and the women of her past islamic cult are hidden and cannot truely discover the joys and the pleasures of true freedom of expression even when poor there is still should be the love of freedom not slavery to not a god but a man who is made a god by order of the cult! Muslims can't vote out mohammad, allah, we can if we dare to vote out obama!
JOHNTHEBAPTIST11 3 months ago
So she wants to ban some verses in Quran or what?
bima1979ol 4 months ago
Allies are the terrorist and everyone who support there illegal operations speak about that Ayaan Hirsi speak about the true radicalism and extremist called the United State of America
Yungsalafmuslim 5 months ago
(the rest of the first message) over or invading other countrys but rather they are being attacked and simply defending themselves from rape and pillage defending themselves against those who seek wordily gain and kill there family at all cost, bombing babys ,women, children,and non ,military person ale. In this case the shoe is in the wrong foot Because this country and it
Yungsalafmuslim 5 months ago
This lady deliberately attacks Islam and is not with trying to help the Muslim community but rather portray a certain image against the Muslims which is a dangerous thing to do Muslims and others take there belief to heart as one should and things of this nature takes a different affect on different individuals which is why her colleague Theo van gogh was murdered my advice to everyone who watches this video is to not judge the religion based on what other people think of it but read about it
Yungsalafmuslim 5 months ago
Allah says in the Quran " for those whom he has guided you will find no misguidance as for those whom he has let astray for them you will find no guidance " there is no such thing as radical Islam, but I will say in some places Islam is not practiced properly all to say that strapping bombs to your chest "NO" that is not what the quern teaches but it does teach you to defend yourself your family and your religion which is why we find that the problems with the Muslims is not about them taking o
Yungsalafmuslim 5 months ago
I 'm ex christian now converted to Islam..and i don't agree wid ayan..i guess she is paid for all this bullshit n her passport..well this is very common any1 who speak against Islam is highly respected n honoured in christianity..n as long as she is getting money n fame from christians she will do these bulshit lies.
aryany2k7 5 months ago
she is so amazing the way she answered that last comment was brilliant, I have nothing but immense respect for her.
lanatur 6 months ago 3
"critical reflection on existing dogmas are not attacks"
manidontgiveafuck 11 months ago
AND SHE'S BEAUTIFUL!!!
manidontgiveafuck 11 months ago
Her books are popular with xenophobic people blaming Muslims for everything, as it fits in with their prejudices. She is a hack tool useful only to her neo-conservative employers in the United States.Her recent exhortations to Muslims to convert to Christianity make her sound more like Billy Graham. Hack tools such as Ayaan, "professional" former "alleged" ex-Muslims have long provided respectable cover for the bigotry and, more often, plain ignorance of mainstream western commentators on Islam.
fromwilliams 1 year ago
@fromwilliams trust me sweetheart, many people are beginning to wake up to the stupidity and evil of islam, not just 'xenophobic', 'neo-conservatives'. you are scared little muslim male with a small dick. ali hirsi is worth a 100 of you. i've read a lot of your deceptive posts and you are a joke. BTW, many hindus, buddhists, sikhs, apostates, jews, christians, atheists are seeing the truth now. you weiner must be shrivelling even more. that is why your prophet raped so many women. lol
shebakali6 11 months ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
I think it may also prove helpful to some of the viewers here to try to evaluate many of the more strident claims of the anti-theist critique ("brights") from a ideological/ metaphysics perspective. Check out the recent article by Jackson Lears in the May 16, 2011 issue of the The Nation entitled "Same Old New Atheism" .The article offers a compelling analysis of Sam Harris' works. Consideration is given to general secular social perspectives
shieldsff 8 months ago
You didn't answer the question posed by one youngman saying if as you claim islam is horrible why islam is growing in the west in this 21 century, had it been a horrible doctrine?
belid2010 1 year ago
@belid2010 birth rates? early indoctrinations?
beside that...what about death penalty for apostacy? no freedom of speech and expression in islamic countries.
dude, are u aware of these things or do you live behind the moon?
Serpico261 1 year ago 4
hmmm, how snaky! "I'm not religious, but I didn't change my religious name to be more compelling." All this propagandist is talking is exaggeration about Islam misleading. If she said the truth and were confident enough, she would have had a debate with a REAL ISLAMIC OR RELIGIOUS representer. she doesn't represent Islam by what she's claiming.
eloexplorer 1 year ago
Soft-spoken, yet determined... I love Ayaan!
Linu86 1 year ago
She is such an amazing woman
Hammerhead730 1 year ago 2
the devil has a name and face.
Sol009 1 year ago
@Sol009 Yes. And apparently, he is very ashamed of his face too, because he told his followers to murder anyone who dared to draw a picture of him that showed his face.
GluttonForSex 1 year ago
she is a transgressor a great transgressor!
GoodBinGood 2 years ago 2
Yes, and we're all lucky to have her, religion needs to be told it is wrong, over and over again. Keep on transgressing Ayaan!
onehairybuddha 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It's obvious that she has little knowledge of Islam.
I can understand how people with little knowledge of Islam can get sucked in by what she is saying.
fromwilliams 2 years ago
Miss Ali, with all the respect for your intellect and freedom of speech, the qur'an poses a very difficult condition of guilty. If you found them guilty.....with 4 persons (witnesses) who saw them at the same time with their own eye withness doing intercourse..."male genital into female genital..in and out" .
yaboua 2 years ago
Then, the qur'an says: "The woman and the man guilty of illegal sexual intercourse, flog each of them with a hundred stripes. Let not pity withhold you in their case, in a punishment prescribed by Allâh, if you believe in Allâh and the Last Day. And let a party of the believers witness their punishment. (This punishment is for unmarried persons guilty of the above crime but if married persons commit it, the punishment is to stone them to death, according to Allâh's Law)"..(S 24..V2)
yaboua 2 years ago
@yaboua Allah was created by humans, not the other way.
GluttonForSex 1 year ago 5
The woman and the man guilty of illegal sexual intercourse, flog each of them with a hundred stripes. Let not pity withhold you in their case, in a punishment prescribed by Allâh, if you believe in Allâh and the Last Day. And let a party of the believers witness their punishment. (This punishment is for unmarried persons guilty of the above crime but if married persons commit it, the punishment is to stone them to death, according to Allâh's Law)[].
yaboua 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
She is a L-I-A-R and a F-R-A-U-D
The Government of Netherlands must be congratulated for kicking her out of the country.
fromwilliams 2 years ago
Comment removed
NeedsEvidence 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Sorry, but not everyone is going to be forced to conform to your way of life. There is a little something called "Freedom of Religion" that protects people's rights to practice any religion freely without the harassment of others. Also, female circumcision has nothing to do with Islam, that is from tribal African culture.
fromwilliams 2 years ago
The mere fact that this lady's live has, for years, been under threat from some Islamic adherents and as usual not explicitly condemned by moslems speaks volumes of Islam. Islamic adherents love their "extremists." They condemn their acts with great restraint. Its all an exposed cunning denial of the reality of the violent faith. It started and grew through violence. It is intolerant as its followers are. Advancing a religion through fear rather than reason is already a failed project.
Biafrans7 2 years ago 2
She SCHOOLED that boy who spoke up with ignorant indignation. She is not attacking you or muslims at all. She is pointing out the antiquated, unjust, violent culture that needs to change. So shut up and sit!
neenersellis 2 years ago 4
ISLAM =TERROR
alfankosh1 2 years ago
hahahaha, its has being know, those their HUNGURI makes them fail in trap, u know what who u r and denying it makes u the ugliest human living on earth.
AyanleHaybe1 2 years ago
I support Ayaan!
bnbalenda 2 years ago 3
Hey maaligirl, What the hell are you talking about?! Get an education. "Wise voice card," that is completely ridiculous. Also you should know that Nazism was defeated in Europe, it did not just disappear. Also, she very clearly answers the issue about Islam growing. In fact she answered that point with not one but two historical examples. So yes...you are the only one that thinks she is stupid. Grow up!
isotopefun 3 years ago 6
I support her!
drauke 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm I the only one who find this woman's answers stupid? Yeah great, she plays the whole ''wise voice'' card but if you analyse carefully you will find many errors. Eg. she compares Nazism to Islam but forgets the fact that Nazism DISAPPEARED whilst Islam is still around and growing. So in essence she has not answered the question. Of course, dumbasses fall for her words!!!
maaligirl 3 years ago
Hey maaligirl, What the hell are you talking about?! Get an education. "Wise voice card," that is completely ridiculous. Also you should know that Nazism was defeated in Europe, it did not just disappear. Also, she very clearly answers the issue about Islam growing. In fact she answered that point with not one but two historical examples. So yes...you are the only one that thinks she is stupid. Grow up!
isotopefun 3 years ago
oh jesus
steveoreiot 2 years ago
She answered the question perfectly. You haven't been listening.
vilgessuola 2 years ago 4
she is extremely smart
123president 3 years ago 5
i adore this woman!!!!
8mukushla8 3 years ago 29
Me too!
Denisehealthnut 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ayaan Hirsi Ali is a fake, liar.
watch this film made by dutch TV about her hidden life. exposed Ayaan Hirsi
/watch?v=wwa1-8U5w2I
activemuslim 3 years ago
She has been very, very clear time and time again that:
1) she criticizes the religion and wants it to reform, not to be destroyed
2) her criticism is of Islam the religion, not Muslims the people
Because of this, people that feel offended by what she says are either not listening to her, or they are fundamentalists.
oaklandj 3 years ago 19