New Moon Book Recap: Chapter 24 "Vote"

[SarahMMartini]

They all love Bella and want her to be in the family but Rosalie said no because she thinks it's not a good life to live for her

[Rebornsrocke]

Carlisle

[teamEdward199725]

I think rosalie wanted to say yes but couldnt and carlise wanted to say no but he does want to lose his son

[rustylisingg]

FUCK THIS

[tpuahsiewA]

I think the new moon movie is better than than the book because jacob is so mean in the books but jacob in the movies he is rally nice and mean at the same time time but jacob in the books is such a jerk.

[twilightdawn1]

jasper was close to saying NO but then he remimbered is would piss off alice if he didn't say YES.

that what I think so don't respond to this if you have nothing nice to say.

[sexylexi975]

@twilightdawn1 i think so too cuz he looked like he was gonna say no but he hates pissing off alice

[hornsby1001]

@sexylexi975 ya but the acutal reason is so he wontt wanna eat her anymore

[PinkFirefly14]

@twilightdawn1 Actually Jasper voted yes..but he was close to saying no...he said yes because he doesn't want to kill her all the time....also when Edward left Bella..Edward was giving Jasper a sad climate to him...So Jasper didn't want Edward like that anymore.....

but what do you get..It's Alice

[OfficialCrystalBand]

@twilightdawn1 Yea me too. Or maybe he wanted her in there family?

[tigerwoman188]

I tihnk if Rose wanted her life as she is that she will glady voted yes and Carlisle had another choice he will choose no keeping on Edward's side

[ToonGirlSodaPop]

the movie doesn't do the book justice... the book rocked! the movie .... no. I did like the cast though 5 stars on that.

[sudmalis100]

jacob was casted PERFECTLY

[xoxobsessedxox]

i like Emmets response "Hell Yes!" LOL

but i think Esme maybe would have vote the other way

oh and the marry me thing was so funny in the movie

oh and he dosn't 'duck out' he hid in her closet lol wow this was long lolzzz

[xoxobsessedxox]

it sounds weird when some one else talks about the book...........

oh and i like Emmett's resopnse "Hell yes!"

the end of the book is great (and sorta funny) lolzz

[nicklastheoneandonly]

The blond girl vote no the rest vote yes, and edward's "father" vote yes also because he dont want lose his "son"

[BabeyKeoNguyen]

Umm, Edward didn't duck out, he hid in her closet.

[TwilightGirlyGirl15]

No. Because they all think of her as family already. Edward is only worried about Bella's soul. But they all are a yes besides Rose and Edward.

[rileyjames09]

In the movie i like jaspers reason... "Yes. It would be nice not to want to suck your blood everytime I see you or something really close to that.."

[monkeyrocks13]

I think Jasper was closed!

[kkannie99]

Maybe Jasper might of voted no because he wants her blood

[xstrawberry86x]

they all like her that is why they voted yes on changing her :)

[Jmarie131]

100%! I read all the books more than 2 times each... Rose only says No because she is jealous that she can't have children.

[Wooaaahhh]

Rosalie only says no because she's jealous of bella. she can have children and she she got turned into a vampire befor she could.

[nanny496]

no they were not

[KLishotterthanRP]

Probably not.

[NaturePrincesses]

well one went like hell yeah so only the girl

[changerhps]

i dont know . I mean shes kinda annoying and shes very loud . who would want her? Her own father wanted her to go to florda.

[kyliechikk]

only because he thought her mother could pull her out of her depression over edward leaving because bella loves the hot florida weather

[vampiregirl2455]

i agree with iluvfunny209

[iluvfunny209]

i don't any of them wanted 2 say yes cause they're all like Edward and doesn't want 2 'ruin her life'. they said yes because:

Alice and Esme: love her and want her 2 join the family so much

Jasper: probably thinks it's the safest thing (read Midnight Sun).

Emmett: 2 make life more intresting (funner)

Rosalie said no

Carlise: the same with most of the family

i think Edward wants her 2 b a vampire the most, but doesn't want 2 ruin her life.

[lizziebizzy10]

they were not 100 percent sure the ydidhave a dought of hpe

[soccercrazy999]

i bet carlisle would have voted no but he didn't want to lose his son so he said yes

[JPEGUE611]

im sure rosaley didnt want her in the family

shes always being so obnoxious towards her.

[paigelewis96]

THIS FILM IS THE BEST!

i missed this part off the film because i went too the toilet :(

[Lulipaz]

awe.... lol thats funny... its ok....

[puccaXrocks]

lol poor u

i would have held it in :D

[TheTwilightfan411]

100% because i think they what bella to be apart of there family (but rosile)

[candyrox1231]

Well from emmet 100%! But D don't know about the others.......... P.S. Love ur shirt Dana!!!!

[xXxTwilightFreakxXx]

i think they were all pretty sure. Esme already loves her like a daughter; Jasper says "it will be a relief not to want to kill you;" Alice of course voted yes, and the "hell yea" from Emmett pretty much solidified his answer. Carlisle wasnt opposed to it either.

[41595]

i think edward was the one who was pretty much close to his vote as to say no because he always said he wanted bella to live a normal human life but how can she when edward cant be human for her so what other way can happen then for bella to become a vampire....... see everything works out great now they can get really intamite with each other

[lovingrussian]

This sounds weird but I think Edward might have. Because I k ow he wants her to be Vampire so they can live for evertogether and doesnt have to hurt her everytime they get sexual. But yah probably maybe... Jasper?? Becuz you know his whole history thing and with the new born vampires?!! Idk I just thought it might be JASPER for some reason LOL I like thT nAme

[xXHildiXHostileXx]

I didn't get to see the midnight premiere, I have to wait till tomorrow but whatever =)

[OeCdGuRl]

Not at all. They are absolutely sure about their choices.

[Marpa1998Skater]

I luv Breaking Dawn because they get married! I CAN'T WAIT FOR BREAKING DAWN! EEEP!

[mofyam89]

@Marpa1998Skater

me too, its my favourite one :)

[zweetcel]

emmett bcs hes gunna miss bella's blushing... :) ive read the books u see...

[AdrienneFrailey]

Didn't Rosalie say she didn't want Bella turned, while admitting that it wasn't because she hated Bella, but that she (Rosalie) had not made the choice to become a vampire, and she didn't want Bella to lose all of the good things that come with humanity? All the things Rosalie missed about it?

[mffn1989]

they were 100% sure about their vote.

[sophiapammela]

i dont think so... i think they all love her exept 4 rosalie and than they would b pleased if so happened!

[jump5freak90]

I don't think so. I think everyone would want her to be a part of the family...

[Banjokazooiemaster]

lol End

[jesusfreaksupergirl]

i think all the Cullens except Carlisle were 100% in their initial vote. Jasper would've been a toss up but with the trouble he has being around humans as it is, i figured his vote would be yes no matter. Carlisle's vote could have changed if the situation was different, like if it made more sense for Bella to remain human or if Edward wasn't going to go kill himself after Bella died anyways.

[nixichixi85]

i hate this chapter! ahh! who would wanna marry sparkle boy?? oh wait..bella would...

[brittanirocks22]

i was expecting all the votes except Jaspers

Edward: NO. he didnt want to take away bella's soul.

Alice: YES. she always knew she would be that way

Rosalie: NO. She says, "i wouldnt have choose this for myself"

Esme: YES. she already thinks of her as part of her family

Emmet: HELL YES. well

Jasper: YES ??? i think he want her to b a vamp so he didnt have the temptation to bite her anymore

Carlise: YES he thinks that this is the only way for them too be together.

[twilightnight16]

Carlisle had definately thought this through and knew what his decision was if asked. Emmett loves Bella like a sister and he totally wants her as part of their family. Alice told Bella on the flight to Italy that she would change her herself if Edward didn't get on it. Esme wants Edward to be happy and thinks that Bella a a vampire is the best way for him to be happy and he will stay with her family forever. Jasper seems to care about Bella and doesn't want to put her in danger so he wants her

[twilightnight16]

to be human so he won't hurt her.

Rosalie just wants Bella to have what she didn't have the choice in having (read Eclipse) and she doesn't want Bella to regret her decision.

Edward doesn't believe that vampires have souls so he absolutely refuses to say "Yes" because he loves her to much to risk her soul. Bella relizes this and tries to make him change his mind.

If Charlie got a vote he would say... (what do you think?)

Reply and let me know what you think Charlie and Renee would say.

[puccaXrocks]

i think Charlie would be freaked out even if they were veggies i mean he didnt want Bella on a bike imagine with a vampir

Renee... well she wasnt mad with her wen (SPOLER) she was engaged so it prob woulndnt bother her much except that she might be nervous bout edward being in bellas room every night

[redips]

Charlie would probably say NO

I believe Renee would say YES

[NiniPanini01]

I live in england and it comes out today but really late and I also had school today....And sooo i'm going to see it tomorrow and i'm really excited!

[Kumo102]

I saw New Moon yesterday at midnight it was totally better than Twilight!!!!!!!!!!

[pinkneondiamonds]

i know it was so good and my mom was so mad because of how it ended and how it left you hanging but it was so good

[Kumo102]

Poor Jacob, his face was so sad. But I didn't like how it ended either. I can't wait till Eclipse comes out!

[woodsmic1]

seriously??

OMG i am totally jealous right now!

how was it?

[Kumo102]

The movie was SO good. It was totally worth sleeping for only 5 hours till school! You just have to go see it!!!

[serenaflora]

Well from Emmett, Alice, Esme and Carlisle, I was expecting "Yes votes." ... We knew that Edward would have said "No"... Rosalie wasn't no shocker... it was Jasper's "Yes" that shocked me. I guess he doesn't want to be the only one in the family suffering with the diet. I guess he also doesn't want her human because he's afraid he might try to take another bite.

[browneyedbrunette813]

I highly doubt those are his motivations.....

[serenaflora]

I talking about Jasper... not Edward btw.

[browneyedbrunette813]

lol..I know...

[myImmortalluv4u]

They are fine about Bella being a vampire except for Edward and Rosalie.

Rosalie is jealous and she also want to be human. You'll understand her during eclipse...

[njandaa4evr]

with her stuff being in the floor board makes me believe girl never cleans around her truck

[TwilightxxxxFanpire]

i think they were all sure but rosalie is just jealous so if bella becomes a vampire she will really get evryting she wants and if rosalie cant have the life she wants than neither can bella

[ParamoreFan208]

I think that they're 100% sure about their vote.

[kreeti21lol]

Jasper cuz he is a new vegi

[SeraphimCramer]

No. Carlisle probably wouldn't have cared either way if it hadn't been for the issue of the Volturi. Btw, why didn't Edward ask Bella if she would marry him AFTER she was a vampire when age didn't matter anymore? It wouldn't have been nearly as awkward.

[ThePinkipromise]

Sadly..most of this is not in the movie..just the CUllen and the other part..

[astroboynu1]

im in australia. saw it 12:01am 20th of November. soz usa but SUCK IT coz FINALLY australia got something before you! :)

[luvmydogs4ever]

lol this made me laugh xD

[lovelygirl3147]

wow....

[TwilightxxxxFanpire]

haha ok but in 2012 you die first...

[puccaXrocks]

yeh go Australia

[ThePinkipromise]

i saw the movie alredy..you guys are going to die..whit the ending

[tishi1988]

question: they were all 100% sure. they have never seen edward happier and why would they do that to their brother??

[CLAC92]

im seeing the movie with my friend tomorrow

omg SOOO excited :D it will be amazingggg!

[natylowz]

y not midnight

[CLAC92]

because my friend has school in the morning

[kittyonemeow2]

Seating on the theater ready to see the movie 2 more hours to go! Can't wait any more!

[kbug95]

i think emmet of course was sure, i mean he says "hell yes" haha, alice can see the future so she was sure, esme is prob.all 4 havin another child but u neva know there could be a little no in there and jasper is one of those ppl u just dont know bout but u see in breakin dawn tht he really does love and care 4 bella as a sister, for carlise is ok wit it and loves bella like evry1 but its hard 2 see his 1st son SO upset bout the change and how edward is upset bout his family "going against him"

[BenjiXAddictX4Ever]

I'm Pretty Sure They All Were 100% Sure In Their Votes =]

[Mrstwilightfreak16]

Can't wait :D

I don't think any of them would of changed. Rosealie dose truly like her but didn't want her to change because she can have a normal human life, the thing Rose craves. But Emmet Jasper Alice Esme Carlise and Edward all love her too much. Edward said no because he values her too much. But the rest of the Cullens want her in the family. :D

({Im so going to see it tomarrow! Can not wait!})

[ecarodiaz]

i think they all were 100% sure to vote her because they knew edward happiness was her, ofcourse he is mad that they would turn her but at the long run what matter is that they love each other and they are going to be happy with each other

[RetroXKitty]

Yay, seeing it in 3 hours! woot(:

[blackelfxxx]

lol it come out yesterday in australia suckers (: seeing it on 22nd which is ur 21st usa

[SurayyahT]

2morro

2morro

2morro

omg

omg

omg

omg

cant wait cant wait NEW MOON NEW MOON NEW MOON

[kodochaiscool1]

they all wantes it too happen

[ClarissaMogentern]

tomorrow, tomorrow ill see it tomorrow. its only a aday awaaaaaayyyyyyy!!!I think tha the only cullen who was close to voting against Bella becoming a vampire was Alice. Alice was one of the first to say no it was not nessasary, agreeing with edward.

[Brigita1618]

i saw it just got home from cinema LOVE IT just bit annoyed they didnt totally stick to the places that certain things happen in the book. BUT OMG EDWARD N JACOB ALL I CAN SAY IS OMG lol

[mkystich72]

I was in shock when Jasper said yes. I thought for sure he would be one of the no's.

[TheGirlfromyear3000]

the movie doesn't end this way, i saw it in the premiere

your gonna laugh so much in the end cause it will leave u hanging

they do decide that she should turn into a vampire, all but Rosalie and Edward ofcourse.

but the ending is like WTF?! :]

[gabrielalulaa]

omg tell me how it ends please

[TheGirlfromyear3000]

SPOILER

he propose to her and they just cut it off!!

i totally saw it coming

jacob edward and bella are talking that if he bites her he breaks the treaty and jake has to kill bella and he turns in to a wolf because she tells him he would choose edward over him and jacob leaves then edward says he would only bit her if he would marry her and then the credits start to roll :[

[vetgurl123]

omg please tell me the ending!!! So i'm prepared???!!!! please!!! lol

[tallblondnloud]

Emmett just cant so "no" he has to say "Hell Yes"

[xoxoserenagirl]

Maybe Emmett lol because he prob would have liked to put up for a fight!

[dancechick1008]

I think some of them almost said No because of Edward. He was furious with the decision, and they all knew that would happen. There insticent was to tell the truth and they did. They all voted yes. This is my favorite chapter in the book. I can't wait to see it in the movie.

[RikkiTikki29]

Tomorrow Tomorrow! I'm going to see the movie tomorrow! OME So Forkin' Excited!

[karenec17]

Tomorrow people, tomorrow!

I finally get to see this movie. I'm excited beyond words.

I've been waiting for this for monthssssss.

I like the picture of Edward kneeling beside her bed. It makes me anxiousssssss.

[xxloveDisxx]

i am so insanely happy for new moon !

[BlackButterfly447]

This has got to be one of my top five chapters in this book.

[keriann91]

i just got back from seeing new moon omg what a film :D:D:D:D

[bitch4ville]

was it as good as the book? omg, i'm dying to see it. I don't wanna wait. :(

[keriann91]

nothing is as gd as the book but it is equally as gd as the book with a really gd few twists and turns

[bitch4ville]

well i'm waiting for someone to post it online haha, i'm too busy to go and see it and all tickets are sold out anyway.

[bekahandhaileyshow]

maybe esme becuase she would not want bella in pain,definetly not Emmet but im pretty sure everyone was 100% sure!

[megzreed]

i've gotta go see it 2moro at 7 :( coz no1 had a car but all the same so so excited ;DDDD

[kelliroxxo]

Lol same. I was gonna goo but all my friends moms wouldnt let them.

[xXScribbledLoveXx]

im sooooo excited im gonna see newmoon at midnight if only i saw it at twilight 2moro...uhhhh bad pun huh :(

[GaurdianCinta]

i saw it last nite :D

trust me , its a very gud movie:d

[princessmaee]

hehehe, imma leave in like a few minutes to wait in line to get our seats since we got our tickets ; so excited ! :D

[freakmommy]

i may have thought that carlise was going 2 vote Bella no. The only is wuz b/c in the book he wuz lookin for not only the most better answer.

[LAUTNERLOVERforeverX]

yay!! there going to finish the series before the movie comes out (: just in time ha ha ha

[FurtureSims]

u got cut off at the end...

[enchantedmistress06]

I think they were 100% sure that if Bella became a vampire like them it would make their son/brother very happy and more willing to "exist". During the months of the split Edward couldn't be around them with Bella their family is complete.

[hoagiesalad]

OMG GUYS!  Two more hours until it comes it!

[3nr1qu3k1k3]

DaNG! AM Goin To Go SEE NEW MOON in a FeW Hours! excited :D

[TheVanessa979]

Whoo!

I am so excited I am going to the premier tonight.

at 12:00AM

in exactly three hours!

I am so excited I bought my ticket yesterday.

:D

[twilightjonasfan01]

I think that everybody was really 100% sure... cept Rosalie.. she was really thinking about saying 'yes' but then she told her the truth. Team Cullen! =)

[PunkGirlzRulez]

I say no for some reason i really dont feel like supporting my answer i already do that in math :P

[pinkprincess81992]

yes yes yes yes!!!!! idk y! NEW MOON 2MARROW AND IM GONNA SEE IT!

[LadyParis123]

new moon tomorrow!!!!!

lolz u should do this for eclipse to, that would be nice

but i think that they all would probably say yes, because they know that if bella got old and died edward would have a spaz. so ya

[mirsa001]

OMG bout to go c the movie im so happy!!!MY WAIT IS OVER!!!!!!:)

[extraordinarygeek]

Jasper voted for Bella because of Alice and because he didn't want to kill her anymore. Everyone just wanted the drama to end... and it didn't. :]

[puccaXrocks]

every1 cept Emmet maybe

[xSparklecupcakex]

Mabey Alice? She cares alot about bella.

[PrincessHv101]

never mind about 3rd,

[PrincessHv101]

so excited 2 see the movie. \i think they were 100 percent sure. 3rd

[yarvh00]

NEW MOON IS TOMORROW :D

[PrincessHv101]

I AM SOOOOO EXCITED TOO! NEW MOON ROCKS

[WhenBadGuysTakeOver]

wow! CAN'T WAIT 2 C THE MOVIE!

[OMGitsH0lly]

3rd =D

i want to see the movei

[MJMrox]

about to see the movie!!!!!!!!

[iCommentVids]

Me tooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!

[iCommentVids]

Shit man!