Carrie Underwood - Broken Wing

[paytonlynn11]

for a sec i thought it was Martina :)

[seadog1956]

If Only I was 25 Years younger and had LOT's of money .....Mabe Just Maybe ?????? AWSOME ! YOU & MARTINA , Thank's.

[thecreativemind28]

if she'd have sung that on american idol instead of when god fearin' women get the blues i think she would've had a standing ovation and better comments from the judges. this is the best vocal performance from Carrie i think :)

[171julie]

Martina and Carrie! Two of my favorites! Does not et better!

[hayloplimber]

Okay so if you have watched the america idol auditions of carrie underwood she said she loves and idolizes Martina Mcbride, wouldnt it be your dream to win american idol and sing your idols song? I mean who are some people to critic others, who have nothing no voice no thing but yet they are critisizing when she is an amazing singer with an amazing heart.

Dumb asses!

[shmily947]

I super love this song by Martina, snd Carrie did lovely.

[aubreyhoboluver34]

Love this song, all time favorite :)

[musicdrugy]

She did an awesome job on this. :)

[skibmuffin]

i agree. no one can beat martina:)

[optimussentinel66]

its like her singing randy travis's I told you so.. she puts her little stamp on it but no one is better than martina at this song

[KaylaLashae2011]

i wish there was a "love" button! (:

[12skype12]

i have probably listened to this song 10 times now :) i loooovvveee it

[BellaGartenLLC]

I love you Carrie. God bless you Carrie & Martina

[renaelynn100]

i like the way carrie sings it

[LoneCaT1000]

i luv this song and Martina and all she stands for. amen. I luv carrie too.

[shortylauralyn78]

@LoneCaT1000 amen to that

[slahyersbooks]

I absolutely love Carrie Underwood, I voted for her throughout the entire American Idol, she is a very gifted and talented person. Martina McBride is also another fantastic and beautiful singer, yes she did sing the song a whole lot better than Carrie Underwood, but that is because I think everyone is use to hearing Martina singing it. Martina and Carrie should just do a duet and get it over with, I think that would be a great and powerful duet.

[lilyarbee]

I have to agree with the above comments. Even though this is Martina's song since she is the original but Carrie in her own version sang it so beautifully.s Love to hear both versions. Both are great and talented singers!

[pinkraindrops13]

How old was she when she sang this???

[KnowYourEnemys]

@pinkraindrops13 14, you can tell her voice matured haha, check out unchained melody and tell me she hasn't matured :P

[kaitiebbugg13]

GO CARRIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!

[animebaka13]

I haven't heard this song in a few years but it's really hitting home more and more these days. i really love this song because it is so true on so many levels for me and for most of the people who listen to it. it's on of the songs that makes me think of my childhood and of home. It's made me miss and cherish them even more than i did before.

[orhamaria123456]

A great performance!

[xDianaxDisasterx]

She really ruined this song... Martina Mcbride is amazing, & no one can EVERR sing the songs she sings. What makes Martina has that Carrie doesn't , is Martina puts all of her emotion into her songs, Carrie didn't do that in this song , i'm not saying Carrie isn't good, I think she's amazing, I just perfer martina's over Carries. If I were Martina, i'd be embarrassed ...

[bkdaniels23]

@xDianaxDisasterx Lol, you go listen to her duet with Vince Gill "How Great Thou Art" and then you talk to me about Carrie adding emotion to a song. That's a song I'd like to see Martina sing better than Carrie...ha! (Sarcasm)

[lamelameblahblah]

I love Martina, Carrie and this song..but I prefer Martina's version of this song. Probably because Martina is the original artist of it, and that I don't really like covers of songs! BUT I have to say, Carrie does a great cover of it.

[Ms123Kelly]

She is great, but to the hedunlap, it's usually the newcomers or amateurs that would cover the legends songs, not the other way around. martina and carrie are both great in their own right!

[ItsBrandonSinging]

8 people have broken wings.

[thelolzbffgrlz]

OMG! She is soooo fricking pretty!!!

[IIEPICNIJAFUL]

its amazing how she was one of us little, normal, KID! etc.

but now shes a big famous country singer started young small and ended up GINORMOUS

one of the best singers out there is HER!!!! thumbs up if you agree

WE ALL LOVE YOU CARRIE WHOEVER DOESNT IS AN ASSHOLE!

[OhGodisGood]

You can't beat the original

[PSNCobaltAssassin]

Love them both - but Martina was my favorite first!  :)

[z28force]

this is a joke right??

[cosangel88]

@z28force they are both great. I suppose you are jealous

[z28force]

our you people kidding me this is shit compared to Martina

[lavityjane]

My fav singer sining my fav song. :D Can it get any better than this?!

[shnovotny]

I love this song sooo much. It's one of my many favorites. Especially for the big vocal range at the end. I've gotta do this song sometime on my own

[jmk2011]

omg i love this!

[beautybee14]

@hedunlap ...are you fo real? carrie and martina are both great in their own right but martina is one of the most talented female vocalists of the past few decades in ANY musical genre. SHE DOESN'T COVER CARRIE'S SONGS BECAUSE SHE DOESN'T HAVE TO. it works the other way around because martina's a legend and carrie's a (somewhat) newcomer. you can hear in the soprano parts of this song that carrie doesn't quite emit her voice with the same strength as the wonderful ms. martina mcbride. RESPEKT

[oboeandpianolvr96]

She is absolutely gorgeous and has a beautiful voice!! Love Carrie! :)

[freak4jesus212]

i love you carrie....thats all i can say:)

[9899peacelover]

LVOE CARR IE UNDERWOOD AND MARTINA MCBRIDE

[LuvCUTS]

Carrie was like 13 or 14 years old when she recorded this. One hell of a vocalist!

[psuncar]

People, people, people. First of all, who cares if Martina sang this song and got oscars, grammies and various other shiny and prestigious awards. If you sit down to compare who sang the song better, its going to be a dead vote. Clearly this is martina's song, she is the original, no one will do this song like she does. However, this is Carrie, and she can sing too. She does the song justice for a younger crowd. Do not crucify her for it. It is a song afterall, and she did sing it well.

[Mpatnode28]

@psuncar I wish i could ''like'' this a million times :)

[psuncar]

@Mpatnode28 im glad you agree. :-)

[jessbear1979]

@psuncar Well said!!! I'm a big Heart fan and when Carrie came out and sang 'Alone' on American Idol I was BLOWN AWAY! I didn't compare her to Ann Wilson. I was like, "Wow. She did this song justice." And she does this song justice. I'm sure Ms. McBride was honored that Carrie sang this song. Again, thank you for your comment. :-)

[psuncar]

@jessbear1979 You're welcome. I am glad you agree.

[SidneySupreme]

@psuncar I agree friend!!! Yesss Bitch! Werqqq!

[karen101101101]

stop comparing martina and carrie! carrie obviously loves martina's songs and respects her a lot so just appreciate her effort on this song! she did great!

[MsTreysongz1]

@karen101101101 she said that martina is her idol!

[WCMPromotions]

Martina kills her on this song. Literally! Carrie's power, range, control, and passion do not come out in this twangy, stupid version of the song. This is like listening to a demo tape.

[care4country]

@WCMPromotions lol this IS a demo! she sung it when she was 13,14. LOL

[MagicSkyGiant]

carrie reminds me of a country version of kelly clarkson... :P

[sherrenee0610]

Martina voice is amazing. Carrie ruins this song.

[cucu323]

Carrie has more fans Than Martina. I love the video.

[xxxchris1891]

even this ''14 year old'' Carrie Underwood can surpassed ''present-day'' Taylor Swift.. What a vocals! And with the Martina thing, I think Carrie herself won't say that she did it better.. I mean, Carrie's like a big fan of Martina..

[markos077]

i guess im deaf then

[ALostCauze]

She's got such a great voice :] And she's so pretty. I love that I can understand every word she sings in every song she sings. <3

[taker161]

that long note at the end is just amazing!

[rebawag]

Doesn't compare to Martinas !

[lifewriter2006]

MARTINA ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!! SORRY MARTINA WILL ALWAYS SING BETTER THEN CARRIE UNDERWOOD THATS A FACT AND FOR THE DUMBASSES WHO SAY CARRIE SINGS THIS BETTER THAN MARTINA ! UR DEATH.

[jahspromise]

@lifewriter2006

It's "deaf", not "death."

[scastimonia]

@19countryboy89

Martina is tied with Reba for most times winning the CMA "Female Vocalist of the Year" at four.

[19countryboy89]

Carrie is AMAZING!!!! She sings this song way better than Martina. I mean Martina is great in her own right... But Carrie Underwood is the best female country singer EVER! C'mon Entertainer of the Year twice in a row. I would like to see Martina McBride or even Faith Hill do that.

[bmbattles890]

I wish my hair would do like that! :)

[JBmusicLovers]

Was this when she was 14?

[lhadyLizsa098]

Wow! Best singer.. I ♥ her!

[dinosauricon]

Leann Rimes, Carrie Underwood and Martina McBride are 3 best vocalists in country music right now

[CoriLiley]

I can't even find the words to describe how much I love Carrie.

She really is something special.

She is flawless with everything she sings.

LoveLoveLoveLoveLoveLoveLoveLo­veLove

[icheer4les09]

I love that she can actually hold her own, unlike most people who cover Martina.

[raksan4083]

Carrie was a teen when she recorded this.Martina was a adult Compare them today.Carrie is better by a mile but even then Carrie could hit a high note and hold it longer full voice than Martina.Martina is Great but Carrie is the best Country Female Singer since Patsy Cline as far as a vocalist goes and can sing anything.

[rhinoducky]

Nobody sings it like Martina, but she has way passed Martina, but in that particular song, my vote is to Martina. But still a fantastic job

[rytanya26]

Martina is untouchable. However, Carrie is one of the few who can actually cover a Martina song respectfully. Carrie is well on her way to becoming one of the best vocalist ever. Even Dolly, Reba and Martina said so.

[msUniverse4lyf]

CARRIE has surpassed martina for a thousand miles already!!!!!!!!

[JayMe2823]

She was fourteen when she sang this

[gone2farcampagin]

lol well i guess that martina sings the songs that are written for HER and to suit her voice...and the same with carrie.but i am guessing that the human brain automatically prefers the orginal artisits verison as it being the one they heard first...sorta LOL carrie sings beauitfully though :)

[mmmalazar]

I love Martina And Carrie and this song!!!

[babyforever96]

martina ,carrie,and jordan are awsome at hte song but it a great song has to come from adn awsome righter so martina is better then all of them

[hedunlap]

I've heard Carrie sing Martina songs, and she covers them great, but I've never heard Martina sing a Carrie song. My guess is Martina can't sing a Carrie song better than Carrie. I don't think it's possible for anyone to sing a Carrie song better than Carrie. Youtube is full of lameasses trying to cover Carrie and they all suck except for a guy covering her song "Change".

[iTellyoueveryting]

@hedunlap Haha, aside from the technical aspects like hitting notes, Martina could hit them, someone doing a song "Better" than someone else is subjective. It depends on the person.

[AllieMAE21]

@hedunlap Martina doesn't have to cover Carrie's songs. she's far better than Carrie will ever be. Martina has proven time and time again she can sing anything she damn well pleases and dominates every song she sings. NO ONE will EVER be as good as Martina McBride

[hedunlap]

@AllieMAE21 I agree, Martina is great. But so is Carrie.

[AllieMAE21]

Carrie is good but no where near the league Martina is in.

[hedunlap]

oh bullshit.

[AllieMAE21]

maybe in time Carrie may join the league of country greatness but never will she match or be better than Martina

[tabsandy]

@hedunlap agreed

[JayMe2823]

@AllieMAE21 uh he was fourteen when she sang this, she would sing it much better now.

[spinto1989]

@hedunlap You are correct! Martina probably can't sing Carrie songs because Carrie's high notes are hard to hit... However Martina McBride vocals and dedication is splendid! I love them both to be honest... No war here.. God Bless You :-)

[Sam7svu]

@hedunlap What a great disrespect you have. My guess the reason you haven't heard Martina sing a Carrie song is because she's been in the business for 20+ years so why would she be singing a song from someone who has only been in the business for what 7 years? You don't hear Reba singing a Carrie song & you don't hear Alan Jackson singing a Luke Bryan song. You'll start 2 notice a pattern if you haven't already. Carrie only sang Martina's songs on AI & before you don't hear her singing them now.

[i0dare0you]

@hedunlap As a carrie fan your quite emberrassing, theres no reason to disrespect successfull artists in order to appreciate Carrie as well. Be mature if your going to represent us Carrie fans, and level headed instead of throwing unneeded red meat around to start crap on You tube. 

[dixiebabe317]

@hedunlap Theres no reason for Martina to. Carrie started it in Idol to show her strengths. Martina has already had her years of fame and isnt trying to stay in spotlight too much and put out singles all the time like Carrie is still doing. One is still somewhat in beginning of her career the other already had her years in spotlight. Dont get me wrong Im not hating on Carrie at all but remember MArtina worked her way like hell to get to where she did and Carrie came when reality shows

[dixiebabe317]

@hedunlap started coming in and helped make becoming famous just showing up tv. Some deserve it like Carrie and Kelly, others not so much like the Jersey Shore idiots. Again I love Carrie but Martinas voice is so distinctive and Carrie still has a while to go before comparing to those like Reba, Dolly, Martina and Faith. But again theres no reason for any older singers to cover newer artists as they have proven their talent. You can not compare the two by simply saying that.

[kmschicks]

@hedunlap maybe martina wants her own songs!

[ecdcheerleader247]

@hedunlap Most people will never be able to correctly cover her songs because she has an incredible range. 

[NeveerThere]

@hedunlap

Martina Is amazing, Carrie is the new one of her, as much as I LOVEE Carrie Underwood, I love my Martina, she's a true star, after all these years shes still going stronge, dont bash another Amazing singer to say how much you like a singer, personally I think this song should have just stayed a Martina song, because its not a carrie style song...

[lifewriter2006]

Ok Carrie is good but sorry but there is no way that Carrie could ever hold a candle to Martina McBride and no Martina sings better on a A Broken Wing and Independence so dont even say Carrie is better because she is not ...... Martina and Reba Will always be the best singers in countty!!! NO ONE CAN OVER POWER MARTINA OR REBA

[StrayedAngel]

totally agree with u on that but I think Carrie is the only one who could sing a Martina song and actually keep the tune! Of cource she can never be as good as Martina but she does do an amazing job on her Martina's covers!

[GinaGlocksenFan]

@lifewriter2006 Carrie can.

[underwoodrockz]

at this time carrie are still teen if im not mistaken..

[fellowutuber98]

Martina is better but carrie is soo good,

martina has more emotions

[GinaGlocksenFan]

No, Carrie has a far better voice IMO.

[BH90210rocks]

martina and carrie are my all-time favorite singers... but this goes to martina, she puts more spunk into it... carrie has guts singing this song... but martina sings it better

[kristiegirl33]

great job by carrie on this song. :)

[CuteCookieL]

Love her! Go Carrie!

[bookcreator]

Carrie sings Independence Day better but Martina sings Broken Wing better

[RAGS123abc]

i agree with you - carrie is my favorite, but martina does this song with more feeling.

[BigDawg1990]

I know it's not that great, but Carrie is between 16 and 18 when this was recorded. She made 3 demo cd's before she got american idol

[2k5hockey]

When and where did Carrie record this?

[BigDawg1990]

when she was 16 or 18, she made 3 demo cd's before she did american idol, one at 12 and 13, one between 16 and 18, and a live one at 20

[Lennox2269]

OMG she looks absolutely flawless in that picture, and sounds amazing! i can't help but love her. she is sooo talented! :)