Added: 4 years ago
From: 5an1ty
Views: 651,244
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (713)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Her challenge was Vonzel Solomon with her "I know I'll never love this was again" which was a great performance. BUT... this piece of Carrie's singing swept it... THIS IS TERRIFIC

  • I just love the way her hair is like! Wish I could mess with it.

  • how about judika when sing this song? who is better?

  • It's amazing how the judges look like idiots. It's like they want to trash her but can't figure a way to do it. She is amazing!

  • Wonder if she knew she'd be so successful now. (:

  • i frickin love this woman im glad she was my first concert i ever seen and she sounds even better live.

  • just realized how legit her song choices were.

  • awsome.,

  • She SO rocked!  And she probably had less that a week to learn and practice the song. Awesome.

  • ( 2:20 ) Did he really just say that?

  • am i the only one listening to this??? bitch's destroying a classic!!!! booo!!!!

  • she has one big head

  • Comment removed

  • Damn what a performance !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • did u hear randy, he said "U can Blow Dude." lol

  • she's ok i guess, i really hated her AI attitude tho. there was one episode where she was like simon if u kick me off then u have to go to prom with me

  • .Please watch SARAH GERONIMO's version of this..much better than Carrie..tnx.

  • @miaco0919 I love Sarah Geronimo and I ADORE her version of this song, but I wouldn't say she did it better than Carrie. I have always considered this to be one of Carrie's most underrated performances. It's been years and I still go back and listen to this quite often.

  • She is so country, she is so beautiful, she is Carrie Underwood, a winner from American Idol 4!

  • amazing!....

  • I love this song!...I don't know who is Carrie but this sound is amazing!

  • @SidKane666 Carrie Underwood is a American Idol winner (2005). The best Idol EVER. Until now, she won 5 Grammy

  • And she is very pretty :o

    5 Grammy's? wauuu, really good ;)

    Thank's 4 the info

  • OMG what a voice! God bless you Carrie =)

  • Favorite AI winner ever!

  • wonderful so pround

  • you can blow. 0.0

  • I love air supply

  • i mean.... amazing...

  • 1:28 through 1:41 was the reason why she won

  • @MrThecrizman Carry Underwood is why she won.

  • @baileyyyful yea she can sing

  • @MrThecrizman thats so long lol

  • Simon shuda stayed one more year for american idol he wuda made it interesting

  • damn She killed the song

  • not that the original aint great but she brought so much more to the table. she gave this song so much more passion

  • whenever i hear this song i think of my ex wife.

  • No other American Idol contestant has ever come close to matching her!! She is the best singer ever to grace that show!

  • no one can do a 13 second note like Carrie on idol anymore....

    the current season is basically over pimping of a contestant, unlike before it's all about real talent.

  • she looks like Emily Osment

  • beautiful.

  • she kinda looks like Emily Osment. :)

  • "Cuz you could blow duuddee" lmfao

  • Wow!

  • Back when American Idol was worth watching.

  • @tipofmytongue1024 I wish I had 99999 accounts to like this.

  • @tipofmytongue1024 oooooooooooooohhhh you better preach

  • Fuck the US , hail Gadaffi!!!!!

  • by the time she has sung this song, american bombers around the world will have killed and maimed woman, children and whatever didnt run for cover . so much for their stupid greasy songs

  • @ETRobot If you don't like America, Get the ___ out!

  • @ETRobot wow whats with the hate

  • @ETRobot What are your GPS coordinates?

  • @ETRobot When you exterminate a rat's nest, do you worry about the momma and baby rats?

  • 10 seconds of "AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAAAAALLLL" rocks \m/

  • not my favorite carrie performance, but she never does a bad one!

  • so good

  • this is the talent

    not like pop stars these days they can't sing

  • pia tortilla is like a bug next to her

  • Love to watch her duet with Russel Hithcock.

  • She is so bueatifull and has a wounderfull voice

  • This is great, but Bonnie Tyler's blows me away

  • @HO1ySh33t Bonnie Tyler sings Total Eclipse of the Heart. this is Air Supply. They do sound similar, though.

  • @mooresus Air Supply was first to sing it, but Bonnie did a cover, watch?v=eIup5g0nCQQ

  • You Can Blow Dude!!

  • holy crap she has lungs!

  • Wow.. Very powerful performance.. Are the any other song by her which is similar?

  • @xHcivic00x yes I agree you. She is one of the top singers in the world along with Justin Bieber. They are the real talents.

  • @fyasa2002 Justin Bieber, a talent. HA good joke!

  • @fyasa2002 Oh please, don't put the Bieber kid in the same sentence with Carrie Underwood. It's disgracing - and distasteful!

  • I wish she would go Rock and Roll and ditch country. One can wish right??

  • @indyfan22k I don't think many people would like that. But, if you like Carrie the rocker, check out her performances of Paradise City, Sweet Child of Mine, and Summer of 69. Also, check out her most recent of performance of Walk This Way, along with Steven Tyker himself!

  • @CMUfanenglishfreak

    I just believe the song writers for country music are morons with no talent.

    Not to mention I cannot stand the crowd that goes to country music concerts. I wish talented country girls like her and Swift would start a rock band.

  • @indyfan22k okay, that's harsh, but I hear you, and respect your opinion.

    But Swift and talented? Really? If there's one genre that requires a strong and powerful voice, if not country, then it's rock. Can you imagine Swift's puny voice tackling a hard core rocker like Losing my Religion, or even a metal like Disciple? I think that's a terrible idea.

  • @CMUfanenglishfreak

    ok I see your point. Swift would be good in a pop band ,lol/

  • Emoção!! nuss....

  • That is a god given talent. You can't teach yourself to sing like that. You are either born with a voice like that or you aren't. This was my fave AI performance in all AI history<3

  • she's my favorite A.I. winner

  • @sabvilla

    Me too!! She's the best so far! :]

  • its just amazing how she is truely the only american idol winner, that can go from sad 1 performance, then do this (perfectly may i add) the next performance

  • Carrie Underwood.Such a BIG inspiration! muy bonita,que Espiritu!

  • She sings a lot of 80's stuff. Which is totally rad.

  • Y_Y NooooooooooooooT....

    Im Cryyyyyyy

  • me in the shower can do better

  • @fyasa2002 hahahaha...

  • @fyasa2002 and then u woke up! wtf u smokin seriously! since u can do better why dont u post it up on here! ur fucken dumb!! obviously dont kno what talent is!

  • legit song choice

  • haha cingular....

  • Tears came to my eyes

  • simply incredible... those notes were flawless

  • ako c joy:))

  • god she is so sexy!! DAMN the girl can sing:)

  • You may search for " Making Love Out of Nothing at All--Lin Zhixuan 2008 concert (Part 3) 12/14 "

  • of course not this is total different

  • I like her but I hate country music. so I just wish she would join a rock band .

  • She look a lot different here...think it's her hair idk

  • @xxcountrygirl23xx it was 80's week i think

  • Does anybody else find it funny that she chose to sing a song by Air Supply when she was the only one in the room that night that didn't need any air supply, anybody who says she sucks should try sustaining those notes at the end, you don't choke on them you get back to me! And shut up Simon, LOL! ;-)

  • Comment removed

  • @JackyLinXakie

    WHO? HAHAHAHA your too funny, a no body singing better then the most succesfful american idol ever? Has this terry lin won any vocal awards? carrie has many many vocal awards including grammies... so yea i doubt it

  • Comment removed

  • @JackyLinXakie

    What years were Terry "Vocalist of the Year" and "Entertainer of the Year"? And on what planet?

  • Comment removed

  • WOW!!!!!!!!

  • who do you think is better kelly or carrie? thats a hard question

  • @MrThecrizman Kelly. I love Carrie, but I think Kelly's better because she has a wider range, more versatility, and always sings with emotion. Carrie is strong in those categories too, and she is definitely a great singer, I'd just choose Kelly, imo.

  • @ilovekelly75 thats true. either way it goes i like them both

  • what song did bowe sing ?

  • wow

  • Carrie was and is awesome! I LOVE U CAREBEAR!

  • the guys from Air Supply sounded more likc a chick than she does!

  • @BettorOffSingle : Amazingly true followed by the beegees and stylistics!

  • Is there a full version of this with her singing?????!!!!!

  • @neoangelique911 Unfortunately no, they didn't start doing that until season 6.

  • @whitedaisy58 I'm sorry to inform you that you need to get your ears cleaned and buy Carrie's 3 albums because all of her songs are amazing as record sales attest to...Sure she sounded amazing singing on AI but she sounds equally amazing singing her own songs...Buy Carnival Ride and listen to So Small or buy Some Hearts and listen to Jesus Take The Wheel or buy Play On and listen to Temporary Home...All of Carrie's songs are worthy of #1 so listen to them all...

  • Carrie DOMINATED every week on the voting on this show more than any other Idol.

  • From the minute she opens her mouth to sing she holds everyone in the audience in the palm of her hand. Her voice is one in a million. I wish she would record a version of this song for her next album. She gives me CHILLS!! CHILLS!! CHILLS!! Another great performance by Carrie. Yes, she can SING!!

  • thinking to make love with you to find out whether making love is nothing at all with you. dont worry be happy

  • I love bonnies version but this is very good :)

  • Comment removed

  • @Huntinbear Your Mama sucks! But that don't mean I'm gonna talk about it on every youtube page!

  • Comment removed

  • @Huntinbear I'm not laughing!

  • Comment removed

  • @Huntinbear Now we see the kind of moron you are really are.

  • I love her performance of this song.

    She also looks absolutely adorable.

    I love the hair carebear.

  • Carrie makes every song her own no matter who sang it before..

  • whos that man at the end ? simson or what .

    fuck him hes always sayin things to bring contestant down but hes not right

    come on look how great carrie's carreer right now lol

  • @mniskimmy and he knows nothin but just to criticize 凸u

  • LOVE this rendition. She's a great talent.

  • Carrie is a credit to her Jewish faith!

  • @BoyJewish she's not Jewish... she's Christian.

  • shes so beautiful!!!from philippines...guys try to view sarah geronimo making love out of nothing at all she was superb!!!

  • Amazing range, great tone, fantastic delivery. A-M-A-Z-I-N-G!

  • this was great!!!

    is it just me, or does this song sound a lot like "total eclipse of the heart"??

  • @whscheerbabe yeah, haha, i kinda get confuse & mix up these two songs when i once tried singin it LOL

  • @whscheerbabe "Making Love Out of Nowhere At All" was written by Jim Steinman, who also wrote the lyrics to "Total Eclipse of the Heart", "Holding Out for a Hero", "It's All Coming Back to Me", and the entire "Bat out of Hell" album

  • @whscheerbabe "Making Love Out of Nowhere At All" was written by Jim Steinman, who also wrote the lyrics to "Total Eclipse of the Heart", "Holding Out for a Hero", "It's All Coming Back to Me", and the entire "Bat out of Hell" album

  • @whscheerbabe they sound similar because they were both written by Jim Steinman... he has a very distinctive style, it's not necessarily in the music itself that the similarities are noticed but rather the style itself... listen to anything he's written and the vocal construction of the songs as well as the piano work and you'll notice it through all of them.

  • @whscheerbabe same guy wrote it....Jim Steinman. (he also wrote most of Meatloafs songs too and that one with Celine Dion called It's all Coming Back to Me Now)

  • @whscheerbabe Bonnie Tyler sings "Total Eclipse..." and also a cover of "Making Love..." That might be why you are connecting the two. ;)

  • @whscheerbabe Jim Steinem (sic) wrote both songs.

  • @whscheerbabe Both Meat Loaf performances and Jim Steinman writer

  • @whscheerbabe This song sounds like "total eclipse of the heart" because they where both writting by Jim Stienman who also wrote most of Meatloaf's material.

  • @whscheerbabe Jim Steinman composed "Making Love Out Of Nothing At All" along with Bonnie Tyler's "Total Eclipse of the Heart" and Meat Loaf's "I Would Do Anything For Love" thats why they all sound similar. =)

  • @whscheerbabe i always get the two mixed up haha

  • what is Simon talkin' bout!!

  • i think this is perfect singing..

    she made Air Supply proud. I'm sure of that

  • I watched the recent ai and they are not even close 2 being as good as carrie. Wish there were contestants like her again.

  • Pitchy dawg