I never under stood how she was able to be on the show, considering she had a previous record deal. I thought a stipulation of the show is that they could have had no prior record contracts,which she did. She may not have sold anything, but that's not really the point here.
u will gt kissed on the nearest frieday by the love of your life. 2mara wll b the bst day of ur life hwever if you dnt post ths comment 2 at least 3 wids u will die withn 2 day nw uv startd readn this dnt stp this is so scary snd ths ovr 2 5 vids in 143 mins when ur done press f6 nd ur crush's name wll appear on the screen n big letters ths is so scary cuz it actually wrks ths really wrks
Just to let everyone know she has her own band called We Are The Fallen! I meant her and she's amazing and her band is amazing as well! so you guys should totally check her band out!
They're comparing her to Amy Lee cause she's now the singer of a band compromised of ENTIRELY ex Evanescence members. That, and she covered Bring Me To Life.
@KittiiKatze It's not so much her fault...mostly Ben Moody's.He betrays Amy because she was going through really bad times,yada yada,you like her,whateva,they both are really good bands;Amy Lee is beyond amazing;but WATF needs to be more origonal.Same,allmost exactly alike,guitar reffs from Ben,exact outfits,posses...
erk it doesn't matter anymore,Amy's new album has a new release date;peace~
@KittiiKatze Well not in this Video but watch the Video from We Are The Fallen "Bury Me Alive", she really looks remarkably like Amy in that one and even her Voice sounds very similar in some parts... I didn't even know about this history of Evanescence and We Are The Fallen until about 5 minutes ago, but it really looks like Ben Moody just wanted to have a band with it's own "Amy Lee" :( I dont know but I think thats really bad of him and certainly not Carlys fault!
@romiicc87 Amy Lee HAS the vocal range; she just won't abuse it. She knows her music theory well. She even performs SICK and sounds as if she were in top condition.
@Xiomara727 . i was just at an EV consert in rio and although i am an amy lee fan, there were more cracks in her voice then a broken window. not to mention the new album is "not so good" . i hope and think she will do better, when i saw them about a year and a half ago at a secret consert in NY, she was the best i ever heard her. i also caugh the "we are the fallen" show in calif. in january and carly sounded awesome,very strong performance. "love them both equally" both great talents
@foreverecsence I watched that concert and I agree! I was like, "What's wrong, Amy? Have you got stage freight all of a sudden?" And about their new album, I agree as well; it's not really what I expected, but it's got it's good stuff! And I also saw the 'Secret Show'; indeed, she was really into it. We could feel her power. I tend to 'favor' Amy when it comes to stuff like this because she has "been into this for longer" sooo how would she be the one with inferiority complexes? Makes sense?
@KittiiKatze Simple: listen to her covering "Going Under" and all the effort she has to do on it. Look at her during live performances/concerts and videos, the make-up and clothing style, and her behavior/gestures on stage. If only it were original we'd be OK.
@Xiomara727 She was nothing close to Amy Lee before the Evanescence guys got to her :P Lots of singers do that when they get into a darker band, they match the image. Doesn't mean that's who they are in their day-to-day life.
I hate tatoos and just knew she would eventually get the boot, but damn, she could sing. Her performance in Jesus Christ Superstar was incredible. Simon needs his head examined
This might seem strange, being on youtube and all, but listen to this video with your eyes closed. Just listen. Does it sound as good as when you watch the video? Didn't think so. She is a pretty good singer but she does not deserve to be on american idol in my opinon, and I base that solely on her voice, not her image or her background, which is irrelevant in the greater agenda.
@Citadellion I disagree as well. She is an incredible singer and deserved to be on the show more than most of the others that were on there. Can you sing better?
I say Carly- 9/10, Crystal- 10/10 but still both are aweome and each singer deserved to go further. Crystal should have won and Carly was better than Jason.
@o0oMusTaNgLoVero0o Honestly if you hate American Idol then why bother watching the video?? better yet, why bother commenting?? Just because Carly made it a POP song doesn't mean it is automatically bad... it drives me crazy when people say this kind of thing... one of the best things about music is that it is limitless and can be rearranged and made into something new entirley and it doesn't have to bad. If you don't like that's fine but POP music isn't some inferior version of music
@o0oMusTaNgLoVero0o it's fine to feel that way, to each his own right, but the way you said it makes it sound like Pop music is some inferior version of music. It just bothers me when people act like that... perhaps I just interpreted your comment wrongly and i apologize; it just felt like you were talking down to people who like this type of music.
@o0oMusTaNgLoVero0o Beatles was pop. as far as i know its what they always where called. they didnt like it but it was pop. what michael jackson did with this song was also pop, while it rocked more then the original
if she wasnt in that shitty band we are the fallen she could make really good music.....just listen to the way she sings on here vs the band shes part of
She is very good!!! This is the best cover I've seen and heard for this song! She has lots of confidence here and her voice sounds very good! She took some risks and still pulled it off!!! :D I wish her confidence had still been there on her other performances. I think Crazy on you, Jesus Christ Superstar, and this were her best :P Blackbird and Alone were nice also... She deserved making it into the Top 4 I think :D
@elpelozzz maybe the best cover for an american idol performer yes i can agree with that. however, i believe aerosmith did by far the best cover of come together.
@graciegtxx most of AI watchers do know that carly's rendition is better than Crystal's own rendition. . . The vocal range of carly's range can wipe out Crystal's voice. . .
I <3 her and her personality! She could pull it off!<3
The only problem that she had that's why she didn't do very well in the show is a belief in herself that she could do it all, confidence. This is the best performance she ever had on the show because it shows confidence, she just didn't maintain it while moving on to the next rounds.
When Crystal did this song, Carly was the first thing that came to mind!!! Crystal is my favorite this season (after Didi got kicked out) and I wanted to hold her up to the standards of not only my favorite AI contestant EVER, but my favorite singer in general. Of course IMO, no one will ever do better than Carly, but Crystal was really good! I remember seeing this on TV and the only thing I could do was sing along. LOVE CARLY!
woohoo! i love ireland <3 i myslef am from ireland and a ginger headed girl...I am currently watching Crystal sing it and carly was much better! WOOHOO GURL POWER!
I knew it I love carlys version and I didn't no crystal was gnna sing it and I was like CRYSTAL needs 2 sing come together! And she did! Love u carly and crystal
same here singstar53, i know she will be successful with her new band, we are the fallen as well as brooke white, david archuleta, and ramiele malubay with their singing careers, loved them, will always be the best of season 7.
@jluzzitube1 Are you fucking stupid? Her record label spent 2 million trying to make her lame ass famous and they tried to promote the shit out of her. Please don't speak
@jluzzitube1 The question is which record company are talking about? She realized 3 albums under THREE separate companies, this was her FOURTH attempt. The first company collapsed, the second one fired her, the third spent 2 million trying to promote the shit out of her and in the words of amylee: "make her lame ass famous." She failed 3 times, one fired her and the other tried to launch her, she shouldn't have been on Idol.
@jluzzitube1 What's truely fucked up about Idol? Randy Jackson was a producer for the company that fired her and actually worked with her, yet pretended he had never seen her before when she came to audition.
She reminds me of Amy Lee, looks like her...and worked as a waitress like Amy...heard her said that...must be wiki...x rmb :P not to mention, she's a rocker now...Calry's part-irish, Amy is part-Scottish...partial parallels :P
This song is Of Michael! *-* She looks so cute singing it :B
amandaonealjackson 2 weeks ago
how is she a lying bitch?
phyliciax33 2 weeks ago
she's so pretty n.n ! i love her (h)
AnimaAmaranth1609 1 month ago
@gaby23diaz Mezzo hands-down unless she proves otherwise.
Syvelocin 1 month ago
I loved her and David Cook I was super happy that he won but I would have loved it if she won...i miss her :(
ReaPunx 2 months ago
@ReaPunx she is now in the band We Are The Fallen. Check her out
TheEDure 1 month ago
She was too cool for Idol anyway...
Duenas411 2 months ago 6
As much as I hate this lying bitch I actually like this version...
justschr 2 months ago
i love her SO MUCH i love her
intifadagirl 3 months ago 2
its funny how the lyrics are all wrong in the first verse :l
MsDarkdiamonds 3 months ago
Incredible performance. Never liked this song when the Beatles sang it, but Carly rocks it! A goose-bump performance.
And whatever the Beatles were using, it kindof scares me LOL
Rescuebroke 4 months ago
@Rescuebroke The beatles were waayy better...
Beatles4Eva123 3 months ago
I didnt wanna hear talking so i skipped to 0:41 and I pissed myself...
cityskater1997 6 months ago
Wow, amazed...(me) lol
123MissLizzie 6 months ago
0:41 scares the shit out of me
TheTomito44 7 months ago
shes in a metal band now
shadowromeo22 8 months ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fuck u bitcchhhhhhhhhh! i hope u will die!!! you are so ugly fucking slug
VivienneRoi 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
huh, that girl is so ugly, god damn it, trap her in her house and throw away the key please
originalnickname93 8 months ago
I never under stood how she was able to be on the show, considering she had a previous record deal. I thought a stipulation of the show is that they could have had no prior record contracts,which she did. She may not have sold anything, but that's not really the point here.
pris72 8 months ago
man, she is so fuckable
jemlebeau 9 months ago 6
LORD!! She ruined my favorite song. D; Damn wannabes.
HeyAdena 9 months ago
@HeyAdena then listen 2 someone else
LibbyGardner 7 months ago
Ok, so I've watched a few clips of Carly Smithson and have come to the conclusion that she is awesome!
...what makes me sad is that all her amazing talent is being wasted on We Are The Fallen. She could be doing so much more...
Lozzalay 9 months ago
On the project she notes pulls better than rock band WE ARE THE FALLEN! Why is it so crap ?????
Andrey2011Zhur 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
To quote Kiyoshi617,
"More like 16 tons of bass.
<333"
DuffleMuffins 10 months ago
Puncture steals songs
TheEvanecencia 10 months ago
Like If Liz Gillies sent u here!
Tiv109 10 months ago
What season is this??
Tiv109 10 months ago
If Liz Gillies sent you here
mrlovesjesus811 10 months ago 35
who the hell is this crystal?
PuteraMeor 10 months ago
She was on idol season 10 today(in the audience)
And they didnt acknowledge her......grr....
r0ck99videos 10 months ago
I watched her on TV for that year of American Idol.
FireIce33music 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
season 7 best season. a few of the top ten including carly are alot better than winners of other seasons
ki857 11 months ago
Comment removed
ki857 11 months ago
Love this cover! her voice is amazing!
blueruby008 11 months ago
love that accent
IcyScythe 11 months ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
This was her best performance.
Argentina891 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
u will gt kissed on the nearest frieday by the love of your life. 2mara wll b the bst day of ur life hwever if you dnt post ths comment 2 at least 3 wids u will die withn 2 day nw uv startd readn this dnt stp this is so scary snd ths ovr 2 5 vids in 143 mins when ur done press f6 nd ur crush's name wll appear on the screen n big letters ths is so scary cuz it actually wrks ths really wrks
Twilightcastlover 1 year ago
Just to let everyone know she has her own band called We Are The Fallen! I meant her and she's amazing and her band is amazing as well! so you guys should totally check her band out!
ShortyIsInTheHouse 1 year ago
simply a.m.a.z.i.n.g carly was always my favorite, she definitely should have won
XxLindsayBFAxX 1 year ago 3
Why is everyone comparing her to Amy Lee???? If her voice and her vocal range has to be compared to anyone, it should be Celine Dion's.
Suspiria316 1 year ago
@Suspiria316
They're comparing her to Amy Lee cause she's now the singer of a band compromised of ENTIRELY ex Evanescence members. That, and she covered Bring Me To Life.
Syvelocin 1 year ago
@Syvelocin Ah ok thank you for clarifying that for me :)
Suspiria316 1 year ago
@Syvelocin With the exception of Marty O'Brien (their bassist)
RealistRapture 11 months ago
Comment removed
sueellen360 11 months ago
She sing sooo beatiful!!
mccartneymylife 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Carley is a lying sack of shit!
justschr 1 year ago
I really don't see how she is trying to be Amy Lee :/
pigeon014ninja 1 year ago
Ha, Carly is infinitey more talented than Amy Lee. Why would Carly aspire to be like someone less talented than her?
celticcutiepie 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@spadingx5903 yoս caո ԝаtϲհ tv from аll ovеr thе ԝorld οn your pс јust by dοwոlοading ѕοmе рrοgrаm, іt's gοt thoսsandѕ οf сհaոոels οn іt. juѕt ցο to linevid com (рսt а . befοrе thе сom οbvioսѕly, it ԝοո't let mе pοѕt liոkѕ fοr somе reaѕοn) іt'ѕ nοt еxactly frеe bսt it's јսst oոe tіmе pаyment аnd іt wοrkѕ really well
znpiegrandma654 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
FUCKIN AMY LEE WANNABE...-_-'' YOU CAN SUCK MY DICK BITCH! AND CHOKE ON IT TOO >=)
YurGurlSukdMe 1 year ago
I'm sorry Carly imma let you finish but Michael Jackson had the best cover of Come together of ALL TIME!!!! lmao
lacrymosa777 1 year ago
Amy Lee wanna be.
thelovelyleaf 1 year ago
@thelovelyleaf
I fail to see how she is any Amy Lee wanna be.
KittiiKatze 1 year ago 56
@KittiiKatze wow,welcome to the world -.-
thelovelyleaf 1 year ago
@thelovelyleaf
Because she just happens to have dark hair, blue eyes, and sings.
Geeze, I must be an Amy Lee wanna be too!
KittiiKatze 1 year ago 3
@KittiiKatze It's not so much her fault...mostly Ben Moody's.He betrays Amy because she was going through really bad times,yada yada,you like her,whateva,they both are really good bands;Amy Lee is beyond amazing;but WATF needs to be more origonal.Same,allmost exactly alike,guitar reffs from Ben,exact outfits,posses...
erk it doesn't matter anymore,Amy's new album has a new release date;peace~
thelovelyleaf 1 year ago
@KittiiKatze Not just that you smart ass, the whole image and sound of we are the fallen too.
pete2k10 1 year ago
@KittiiKatze Minus the fact that she's the front woman for a band made up of ex-evanesence members?
acatzr800 9 months ago
@acatzr800 and what with that? that doesn't mean she's a wannabe
sueellen360 9 months ago
@KittiiKatze THANK YOU!!!!
Splash0Black 7 months ago
@KittiiKatze WOW KITTIIKATZE YOU SAID A MOUTHFULL
gotjumpedyet 6 months ago
@KittiiKatze Well not in this Video but watch the Video from We Are The Fallen "Bury Me Alive", she really looks remarkably like Amy in that one and even her Voice sounds very similar in some parts... I didn't even know about this history of Evanescence and We Are The Fallen until about 5 minutes ago, but it really looks like Ben Moody just wanted to have a band with it's own "Amy Lee" :( I dont know but I think thats really bad of him and certainly not Carlys fault!
HigherHighSymphony 6 months ago
@KittiiKatze I see the opposite. Amy may be wishing to have that high vocal range, since she used to force her voice most of the time
romiicc87 4 months ago
@romiicc87 Amy Lee HAS the vocal range; she just won't abuse it. She knows her music theory well. She even performs SICK and sounds as if she were in top condition.
Xiomara727 3 months ago
@Xiomara727 . i was just at an EV consert in rio and although i am an amy lee fan, there were more cracks in her voice then a broken window. not to mention the new album is "not so good" . i hope and think she will do better, when i saw them about a year and a half ago at a secret consert in NY, she was the best i ever heard her. i also caugh the "we are the fallen" show in calif. in january and carly sounded awesome,very strong performance. "love them both equally" both great talents
foreverecsence 3 months ago
@foreverecsence I watched that concert and I agree! I was like, "What's wrong, Amy? Have you got stage freight all of a sudden?" And about their new album, I agree as well; it's not really what I expected, but it's got it's good stuff! And I also saw the 'Secret Show'; indeed, she was really into it. We could feel her power. I tend to 'favor' Amy when it comes to stuff like this because she has "been into this for longer" sooo how would she be the one with inferiority complexes? Makes sense?
Xiomara727 3 months ago
@KittiiKatze Simple: listen to her covering "Going Under" and all the effort she has to do on it. Look at her during live performances/concerts and videos, the make-up and clothing style, and her behavior/gestures on stage. If only it were original we'd be OK.
Xiomara727 3 months ago
@Xiomara727 She was nothing close to Amy Lee before the Evanescence guys got to her :P Lots of singers do that when they get into a darker band, they match the image. Doesn't mean that's who they are in their day-to-day life.
Syvelocin 1 month ago
@KittiiKatze **Also, with Carly, it sometimes seems as if she is overrun by the instruments.
Xiomara727 3 months ago
@KittiiKatze this is before We are the fallen, fucking ignorant
amandaonealjackson 2 weeks ago
@amandaonealjackson Uh, I know that. I'm not stupid.
KittiiKatze 5 days ago
i hate crystal but crystal did WAY better
MegenJoy4Fans 1 year ago
I hate tatoos and just knew she would eventually get the boot, but damn, she could sing. Her performance in Jesus Christ Superstar was incredible. Simon needs his head examined
keliata 1 year ago
she reminds me of katy perry
deontapper 1 year ago
*sigh* another failed beatles attempt by american idol
scottcastellano 1 year ago
@scottcastellano Yeah, how dare somebody put actual emotion into singing a beatles song.
MajorMatthias 1 year ago
@MajorMatthias oh look another fool who watches shit on the television, emotion my ass
scottcastellano 1 year ago
@scottcastellano At least she puts in effort, unlike John Lennon. Beatles song rule, but they suck at their own songs.
MajorMatthias 1 year ago
That was unexpectedly good... O_O
Kee715 1 year ago
This is hilarious, seeing Carly be a waistress LOL! Long way from touring the world with her band WATF. ^_^
WynterNoxArcana 1 year ago
Brilliant!!! Grand!!!!
misterdrum78 1 year ago
that was very passionate she shouldnt have been voted out. big mistake
wittyworldlee 1 year ago
This is classic...by far one of the BEST AI performances!!!!!
tatahag 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
SUCKS...!!!
calioterochavarria 1 year ago
This might seem strange, being on youtube and all, but listen to this video with your eyes closed. Just listen. Does it sound as good as when you watch the video? Didn't think so. She is a pretty good singer but she does not deserve to be on american idol in my opinon, and I base that solely on her voice, not her image or her background, which is irrelevant in the greater agenda.
Citadellion 1 year ago
@Citadellion
I politely disagree.
TheKatIsBackAgain 1 year ago
@Citadellion I disagree as well. She is an incredible singer and deserved to be on the show more than most of the others that were on there. Can you sing better?
xxviciousbeautyxx 1 year ago
shes amazing i hav her autograph!
anaiship 1 year ago
I say Carly- 9/10, Crystal- 10/10 but still both are aweome and each singer deserved to go further. Crystal should have won and Carly was better than Jason.
nyynygnyknyr1 1 year ago
Love It
geezethatscool 1 year ago
another rock song converted to pop..
this is why i hate american idol.
o0oMusTaNgLoVero0o 1 year ago
@o0oMusTaNgLoVero0o Lol. Agreed.
RebekahLorena 1 year ago
@o0oMusTaNgLoVero0o Honestly if you hate American Idol then why bother watching the video?? better yet, why bother commenting?? Just because Carly made it a POP song doesn't mean it is automatically bad... it drives me crazy when people say this kind of thing... one of the best things about music is that it is limitless and can be rearranged and made into something new entirley and it doesn't have to bad. If you don't like that's fine but POP music isn't some inferior version of music
IdolReady 1 year ago
@IdolReady honestly is it really that bad to say what i feel about it?
yes, to me it sounds bad.
because for me, something that is ROCK should stay that way..
i don't mean to offend you guys.
of course pop is good in its own way.
but something rock converted to a pop song is NOT a good idea..
especially with these kinds of songs.
not just American Idol, GLEE does the same thing.
and one more thing, the moment i hear her singing come together 'pop-ish'.
i stopped listening and posted my comment.
o0oMusTaNgLoVero0o 1 year ago
@o0oMusTaNgLoVero0o it's fine to feel that way, to each his own right, but the way you said it makes it sound like Pop music is some inferior version of music. It just bothers me when people act like that... perhaps I just interpreted your comment wrongly and i apologize; it just felt like you were talking down to people who like this type of music.
IdolReady 1 year ago
@o0oMusTaNgLoVero0o Beatles was pop. as far as i know its what they always where called. they didnt like it but it was pop. what michael jackson did with this song was also pop, while it rocked more then the original
Frusciantelandsk 1 year ago
ma irish babe
17naps 1 year ago
I... just can't like her...
valerieannhogue 1 year ago
why's everyone gotta mix the lyrics up...
even john did in his live performance vid, though he was probably high, roflmao
ryuman757 1 year ago
if she wasnt in that shitty band we are the fallen she could make really good music.....just listen to the way she sings on here vs the band shes part of
duckjockey10 1 year ago
im a music fanatic but my music listening life this just plane out sux, like big hairy balls
sweatshirt12569 1 year ago
She is very good!!! This is the best cover I've seen and heard for this song! She has lots of confidence here and her voice sounds very good! She took some risks and still pulled it off!!! :D I wish her confidence had still been there on her other performances. I think Crazy on you, Jesus Christ Superstar, and this were her best :P Blackbird and Alone were nice also... She deserved making it into the Top 4 I think :D
elpelozzz 1 year ago
@elpelozzz maybe the best cover for an american idol performer yes i can agree with that. however, i believe aerosmith did by far the best cover of come together.
jacjr6193 1 year ago
thats was great lol!!! Simmon winked at her funny part....
RockLover08 1 year ago
carly smithson i strongly do not like you
jesuslova216 1 year ago
Please check out my cover songs of "Come Together" by The Beatles and "If I Can Dream" by Elvis on my channel.
Thanks
MultiMusic2009 1 year ago
Please, listen to my cover of "Come Together" by The Beatles
Good song!
Thanks
MultiMusic2009 1 year ago
This version didn't have as strong effect on me as Crystal's version did.
graciegtxx 1 year ago
@graciegtxx most of AI watchers do know that carly's rendition is better than Crystal's own rendition. . . The vocal range of carly's range can wipe out Crystal's voice. . .
nocturnalfantasies 1 year ago
I love you Carley you rock !!!!!!!!!!!
sneakapeeker 1 year ago
I <3 her and her personality! She could pull it off!<3
The only problem that she had that's why she didn't do very well in the show is a belief in herself that she could do it all, confidence. This is the best performance she ever had on the show because it shows confidence, she just didn't maintain it while moving on to the next rounds.
lilstacey09 1 year ago
she freking ruined the song its terrible
AlphaOmega346 1 year ago
love this version of Come Together... by far the best version of this song i have ever heard! And this is the song i love the most for that season...
ilovcharmed 1 year ago
at 2:17 it's "hair down to his knees
got to be a joker he just do what he please" come on
LovetorockJG 1 year ago
carly did it better than crystal :)
mistyeyedlass 1 year ago 4
she irish?? :D
xxx
XxXgerardsgalXxX 1 year ago 3
"potatoes!" @ 0:57 lol cause she's irish...
doubleDdog09 1 year ago
LMFAO her face @ 5:23 !!!!!
doubleDdog09 1 year ago
saw her show last night with HIM. IT WAS AMAZING. (:
zebrazebrabitch 1 year ago
carly has a band now :D We Are the Fallen! this girl Rocks! she deserve to be famous.. talented girl!!
fhmkid23 1 year ago
She should have made at least top 3.
leeflailmarch 1 year ago 2
Carly fans like me watch out for "We are the fallen" band this mAy. She's the vocalist. so happy for her. she deserves to be famous. Ü
fhmkid23 1 year ago
my brain exploded, it sucked so bad
mmorpgman101 1 year ago
she was amazing
loveurselv2 1 year ago
Stupid bitch
amyleeVSbenmoody 1 year ago
I love this video cant wait for her new album!!
mikemcfarland13 1 year ago
When Crystal did this song, Carly was the first thing that came to mind!!! Crystal is my favorite this season (after Didi got kicked out) and I wanted to hold her up to the standards of not only my favorite AI contestant EVER, but my favorite singer in general. Of course IMO, no one will ever do better than Carly, but Crystal was really good! I remember seeing this on TV and the only thing I could do was sing along. LOVE CARLY!
arturesteve 1 year ago
Carly got so underated in S7. She should have been in the finals with DC. Rock on Carly. It's all working out for you.
mermcc 1 year ago
woohoo! i love ireland <3 i myslef am from ireland and a ginger headed girl...I am currently watching Crystal sing it and carly was much better! WOOHOO GURL POWER!
kissmysass88 1 year ago
@kissmysass88 soooo good i can't get over it! woohoo!!!!!!
kissmysass88 1 year ago
lyrics a little off at the beginning, but then it got good.
lokdomar777 1 year ago
I still think this is one of the best performances ever on AI... definitely in the top 3 of Season 7 if you ask me.
01049407 1 year ago 2
Carly >> Crystal...though I really like crystal :D
pooiGirl 1 year ago
I adore Crystal but this one goes to Carly!
jppuertorico85 1 year ago 53
I like both Crystal and Carly's take on the song. BOTH are great.
chrisal09 1 year ago 2
started good but ended on a bad note...
largo4life 1 year ago
Carly still killed Crystal. I do love Crystal though.
ammo776 1 year ago 12
nooo way did crystal sing this better than carly.
emilyhannah47 1 year ago 2
I knew it I love carlys version and I didn't no crystal was gnna sing it and I was like CRYSTAL needs 2 sing come together! And she did! Love u carly and crystal
xxGaGaooolalaxx 1 year ago
i love her version. crystal's right now is good too.
stormcloud847 1 year ago
And there goes Come Together, killed by this bird
LasgalenOsten 1 year ago
GREAT performance, can you imagine anyone of the contestants on S9 doing this?
mermcc 1 year ago 2
@mermcc Crystal is doing it and I can't wait to hear her take on it
danpeak 1 year ago
Trust American Idol to foster the abortion of a wonderful song.
MrRasnarok 1 year ago
Surprised that i remember all those performances from 2 yrs ago but cant remember anything from this season>.>
kodolol 1 year ago 3
@kodolol OMG that happens to me too i remeber all the top 12 names and everything from two years ago and i cant even remeber em this year
emilia223 1 year ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She just massicred johns music.
Anechy98 1 year ago
i can't believe she lost against whoever that other person because the other person started messed up and restarted *cough cough*
th3wat3rnat1on123 1 year ago 2
i love this preformance =]
twilightseriesfan28 1 year ago 2
She has a fantastic voice but I don't think it's really suited to this song.
tomtom255 1 year ago
same here singstar53, i know she will be successful with her new band, we are the fallen as well as brooke white, david archuleta, and ramiele malubay with their singing careers, loved them, will always be the best of season 7.
bn31260 1 year ago
until this day i have not forgot this performance :)
singstar53 1 year ago 3
same here!
season 7 was the best
LennyMW 1 year ago 2
i love it!
nhadz16 1 year ago
she messed up on the words....good job...
bradlairric 1 year ago
I know ! Big time in the first verse .
Anechy98 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
clearly this is not live...
DIVENTNA 1 year ago
clearly is live...
ShaneGater 1 year ago 9
she has wicked talent
lisapunky 1 year ago 9
having a record out doesnt break any rules if the record company goes under and fails to launch her
jluzzitube1 2 years ago 24
@jluzzitube1 Are you fucking stupid? Her record label spent 2 million trying to make her lame ass famous and they tried to promote the shit out of her. Please don't speak
amyleeVSbenmoody 1 year ago
@jluzzitube1 The question is which record company are talking about? She realized 3 albums under THREE separate companies, this was her FOURTH attempt. The first company collapsed, the second one fired her, the third spent 2 million trying to promote the shit out of her and in the words of amylee: "make her lame ass famous." She failed 3 times, one fired her and the other tried to launch her, she shouldn't have been on Idol.
emightis 1 year ago
@emightis released not realized*
emightis 1 year ago
@jluzzitube1 What's truely fucked up about Idol? Randy Jackson was a producer for the company that fired her and actually worked with her, yet pretended he had never seen her before when she came to audition.
emightis 1 year ago
@jluzzitube1 they never found out because she was recorded under a different name.
Gale1543 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
To bad she borke the rules, is being used by ben moody and almost ruined evanescence, she wouldve made an amazing solo artist
DarkGaia77818 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
she messed up
TheMrDeadmanwalking 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Dumb bitch mixed up the lyrics...
23xkingdomkeyx23 2 years ago
@23xkingdomkeyx23 she said she would at the intro.
HAHAHAHAPOKEFAN97 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
That still doesn't give her the right to do it, haha.
23xkingdomkeyx23 2 years ago
john wuld be proud ^^
s8ter1115 2 years ago
love her accent and i also love how it completely disappears when she sings
dergru 2 years ago 4
LOL :31 LOL
MrBurgundy76 2 years ago
she broke the rules because she had a record out befor idol
gojaydeego2 2 years ago
Love this performance. She killed it...
Keiffie88 2 years ago
Best Version Ever !!
moorlikeu 2 years ago
She reminds me of Amy Lee, looks like her...and worked as a waitress like Amy...heard her said that...must be wiki...x rmb :P not to mention, she's a rocker now...Calry's part-irish, Amy is part-Scottish...partial parallels :P
joanngelic 2 years ago 2
sorry but nothing like beatles...
and