cristobalcampos... while gilmore is a great guitarist i have to disagree in saying hes the best. Jimmy Page is better and im a Led Zeppelin fan but the best is and always will be Jimi Hendrix.
@tall1958 There is no "best" guitarist. They all have different styles of playing. It's comparing apples to oranges to bananas to mangos, etc. It's all personal opinion.
For example, I think Page was absolutely horrible live, and only managed to play well in the studio. Does that make him less of a guitarist than Gilmour? No, because its my subjective opinion.
This is not his best vocal, as it seems he may be sick or be having trouble with his throat. But make no mistake, David can still blow. Don't believe me, check out another link on here from 2007, which is after this, and listen. His voice is still amazing, and his guitar playing I don't even need to comment on.
That's the most fundamental difference between Waters and Gilmour. Waters likes things to be exactly precise every time while Gilmour likes to create sound on the fly with his mind and soul, that's why there are so many versions of this solo and ALL are amazing. I can't say I like any version better than others. Each time I listen, I hear a new note or 2 that appeal to me.
@logiotek You're absolutely right as far as Gilmour switching it up every performance. I've got to say, the second solo from "Remember that Night" is probably his best though, in my opinion anyways. I loved the addition of the pinch harmonics, and he hit every note bang on, and showed a lot of feeling.
Gilmour rocks
lene2free 5 days ago
my idols... love u
RIP Mr. Rick
Long life to Gilmour
shefow 1 month ago
Wish this was in HD..... I think this might be the best solo he ever did.
fordescortracer 4 months ago
brilliant.... but.... the best solo was in Pulse!
korvanallica 8 months ago
the singer of rogers part (is that richard? ) pisses me off... i dont like how he cuts words off
Rokky616 1 year ago
@Rokky616 Does he?
tfn105 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
on 1:30 there's a bass guitar error #fact#
MsMeMyself19 1 year ago
whata happens at 6:43? hahahha a mistake jus like in 1:30
FuhrerKaiser 1 year ago
on 1:30 there's a bass guitar error ;)
echoes80 1 year ago
cristobalcampos... while gilmore is a great guitarist i have to disagree in saying hes the best. Jimmy Page is better and im a Led Zeppelin fan but the best is and always will be Jimi Hendrix.
tall1958 1 year ago
@tall1958 There is no "best" guitarist. They all have different styles of playing. It's comparing apples to oranges to bananas to mangos, etc. It's all personal opinion.
For example, I think Page was absolutely horrible live, and only managed to play well in the studio. Does that make him less of a guitarist than Gilmour? No, because its my subjective opinion.
DonKael 1 year ago
@tall1958 you deff havnt seen pulse : )
tomnuytkensmusic 5 months ago
Comment removed
darthdude1016 2 years ago
Dave has an amazing vioce
phillydude782422 2 years ago
This is great, I really think it's cool that Rick is singing the verses here.
crk1121 2 years ago
Comment removed
darthdude1016 2 years ago
Comment removed
darthdude1016 2 years ago
Comment removed
Fabriskull 2 years ago
A melhor de sempre
joaoyoutuve 2 years ago
NICE VERY NICE
vagelis130676 3 years ago
Hello
Is there anybody in there Just nod if you can hear me
andrewpogor 3 years ago
wow, 6:43 - 6:44 Mistakes.
nukkerone 3 years ago
Comment removed
YGibsonY 2 years ago
Hail Gilmour...COmfortably numb the best song
Gilmour eh o kra amo essa musica
Fabriskull 3 years ago 3
Rick...
The long sleeping can ease your pain.
You are now in comfortably numb as you sing.
odysseynz 3 years ago
Rest in Peace
Rick Wright
Eslach 3 years ago
lovely vocals as usual from Rick :O))
MarkGreenwood60 3 years ago
Gilmour the best guitarrist in the world
lucicciu3 3 years ago 27
This has been flagged as spam show
@lucicciu3
sure, and your god is the only one. sure.
AshtarKommando 8 months ago
yes it seems but its still awesome
LordDagon2 3 years ago
This is not his best vocal, as it seems he may be sick or be having trouble with his throat. But make no mistake, David can still blow. Don't believe me, check out another link on here from 2007, which is after this, and listen. His voice is still amazing, and his guitar playing I don't even need to comment on.
kidchave12 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it seems that he lost his voice...
nukkerone 4 years ago
Are you kidding? He sounds better than ever and he's 60 years old.
logiotek 3 years ago
who havent't had a dream once of going to a nach and play guitar and sing like Gilmour??
He's a legend in the music world, hees woise will never fade!
tuborgsommer 3 years ago
his solos are so different and yet so enthralling in live performances of this song
vpanwar 4 years ago
That's the most fundamental difference between Waters and Gilmour. Waters likes things to be exactly precise every time while Gilmour likes to create sound on the fly with his mind and soul, that's why there are so many versions of this solo and ALL are amazing. I can't say I like any version better than others. Each time I listen, I hear a new note or 2 that appeal to me.
logiotek 4 years ago 12
@logiotek You're absolutely right as far as Gilmour switching it up every performance. I've got to say, the second solo from "Remember that Night" is probably his best though, in my opinion anyways. I loved the addition of the pinch harmonics, and he hit every note bang on, and showed a lot of feeling.
DonKael 1 year ago
richard wright sounds fantastic.
sethmanjette12 4 years ago
he is the best!
TrelleborgtheLegend 4 years ago 4
was this show televised, or did you get this video from another source?
arnoldlayne2 4 years ago
nice thanks ;)
persianmilad 4 years ago
LOL
Awesome
NatanaelPereira 4 years ago
thanks great video
cspig85 4 years ago
great video
spirtof666 5 years ago 2