Added: 5 years ago
From: MellowKillerCat
Views: 42,852
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (348)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This was the best silent hill to me. a 9 out of 10. I really enjoyed this game. I'm so glad they're making an hd collection for the 360.

  • This is actually my favorite silent hill game, right next to silent hill origins. Sh3 was one of the best silent hills to me. A 9 out of ten in my book. I remember when I had this game on ps2 back in days and wish they had it on the xbox because I switched to the xbox lol. I'm just glad they're making an hd collection now I van enjoy it on the 360.

  • Silent Hill and Fatal Frame are two crazy-excellent franchises!

  • Heather is on my top 10 sexiest videogame chicks :3

  • i wanna fuck heather

  • I have it. I honestly think they should have made it easier. The monsters are extremely difficult to the point where you want to rage quit every time you get caught near one. The story is amazing however, and that's why i keep coming back and playing it. :)

    Oh, and closers scare the shit out of me. Never trust a closer. >:T

  • @gloompelt you know what monsters i hate? the slurpers -.- i hate those things

  • I never got to play this one..and it looks really good...i wanna play it so badly now

  • Is the hd collection release in Japan,Europe and america? I"m really not informed.

  • @Luigia525 it releases in March 6 in North America

  • I'd say the PC version is exactly the HD version for the consoles...

  • i'm going to buy HD collection. i've never played SH 2 and 3 and i really wanna try them. even though i think that they will be so scary that i can't beat them

  • 1,2,3 are the best silent hill games! 3 was really good, i beat it on hard difficulty thinking back to this day idk how i managed to pull that off..it always kept me on my toes and sometimes i didnt even want to open the door bacuse i didnt know what to expect but i love the silent hill series.. i hope downpour brings it back to life

  • silent hill 1,2, and 3 are the BEST survival horror games EVER. NO EXEPTIONS. I cant believe that people are comparing this with new games, this was made in like '02. The only game that can even COMPARE with these games is Siren. I cant even beat that game lol.

  • @radroach44 whats siren is it on ps3 ps2 or xbox 1 or xbox 360

  • @CastleSnowflake well the remake is for ps3 and maybe xbox 360 but the original was for ps2

  • I remember reading other Reviews from other people who played the game, and they keep thinking that Heather was ''Weak an embarrassing'' why do they want every game Character to know what their doing, like they've been there many times before, and act all bad-ass and shit? Jesus..

  • After playing this game, no other survival horrors I played or watched phase me. This game gives you balls of steel.

  • @nelsonta00 I recommend amnesia the dark descent.

  • @nelsonta00 not even dead space ?? :(

    It's not scary but the thrill is and survival mechanics are still fun

  • @nelsonta00 Have you played Fatal Frame?

  • @squerintain Fatal Frame is good. FF2 was the best and it is up there with SH3. FF's shock value is much better (great camera direction on ghost encounters) than the RE series, but in fights it feels a bit mechanical.

  • for a really old game (2003), this game had great graphics

  • @olegario39 2003 is really old to you? What the hell is Pong, then? o.o Not to start with you because of a month old comment, but really.

  • my friend wanted to borrow SH3 and gave it back the next day claiming that the game is too disturbing to progress. LOL been playing this franchise since 9 y/o

  • Any one of the first three Silent Hill games, played in a dark room, late at night, on an old CRT television = True Fear!

  • Konami is destroying the silent hill series, the hd versions of sh 2 and sh3 will not have the original voices so basically they are doing this to not pay the original actors royalties do not support this greedy bastards dont buy the HD remake!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @PS3ULTIMATE500 you dont really HAVE the HD remake in your lap do you? no? well dont complain then, as long as people who never played SH2 and 3 get to play them, its enough to accept the fact that you don't get the original voice acting, besides who cares about the voice acting? sure it can draw you in, but i wont really call the original voice acting TOP NOTCH. it was great, but nothing special. so im buying the HD remakes anyway, just to revisit my favorite games :)

  • is it for the xbox?

  • @102jaman unfortunately not, only PS2 and PC... they're releasing an HD version for the PS3, too

  • @stabber63 Awesome cant wait for the ps3one and thanks for the info :)

  • I love the character and the song from the begining , this game was my favorite game

  • PLEASE BRING SILENT HILL 1 to PSN!!!

  • @123EllDude silent hill 1 is in psn for a long time, for 5 bucks. good deal

  • Can you download this of psn and the 2nd one cus I need to play this and 2 before the collection comes out and I can't get my hands on a ps2

  • Cannot wait for the collection in hd!! :D

  • I can't wait to get the silent hill hd collection I will probably pre order it!!!

  • I love psychological horror, therefore, the Silent Hill is my favorite horror series.

  • SH2/3/4 graphics > 5/6/7

  • @bawitback noob it explored 200% of the hardware at the time it was a revolution

  • @fernandodchusyd no, i'm saying SH3 has better graphics than the later squeals 5/6/7.

  • better than S4

  • i have no idea why people hate shattered memories so much i personally enjoyed it much more than the orignal. i am not saying that SH1 was bad it's just that i liked the story way more because it made sense . Heather was trying to supress the memories of her dad which is why the monsters are there in the first place and towards the end (for my ending) she accepts the fact that her dad is dead and even though she is terribly upset she moves on and remembers all the good times they had together.

  • @2shadowgamer2 people dont like it because it is not scarey, which is a huge problem for a horror game, i do think its good though.

  • I think that this one had the darkest atmospheres. Normal or alternate. *SPOILER ALERT* One thing i kinda thought could have been improved was the last boss 'God' I mean it was great! But could have been a little harder or longer.

    P.S. I laughed my ass off when Claudia was jerked into the hole :p

  • they made the enemies too hard to kill in this one.. .to the point that i just ran around them all the time and it took away some of the fear of them oddly. Still this is a good game but not my fav. This game really felt DARK.

  • is the music at the beginning of the video in the game?

  • I just download the game and I started to play. And I was like: WTF?! Theres no story, I dont get it... Theres bunch of monsters right away... And I have GUN! I didnt even picked it up... I have SMG, pistol, knife... WTF AGAIN! It should be slow in beginin and then all monsters should come out after some playing, not like you know... Monsters guns, even aid kids at the very begining of the game.. I mean REALLY begining...

  • @pufixas Play past that aprt and it'll make sense.

  • @Badfish93

    I did :D

    Now I know...

  • Thumbs up if you agree he says um to much

  • Real silent hills are only the japanese made by team silent, that were silent hills 1 to 4. all other are not the same and suck , the american made by climax.

  • SH 1 TO 3 ARE ALL FUCKING CLASSICS, sh4 the room was the last decent one, the new ones are awful, they all jus lack so much creativity, it almost makes me sick how they can get away with it. they had the option to remake SH1 but fucked it up beyond repair. i was playing it an nearly fell asleep, it bored the shit outta me. the fear factor jus went straight out the window.

  • @Rilyn666 THANK YOU!!!!!! for proving my point shatered memories was a teaming pile of dog shit. thanx for provin my point to this queer that commented on my video that thinks he knows what hes talking about but he really doesnt.

  • @1SH0T2K1LLS your welcome! im so sick of hearing people say shattered memories is good :| ITS CRAP im an idiot for paying full price for it. i feel like iv been robbed

  • @Rilyn666 yeah lets just hope silent hill downpour really is the one to bring back the series. PS what happened to team silent ?

  • @1SH0T2K1LLS yeah lets hope...but iv been saying that since origins came out., shattered memories really jus killed all hope i had left for the series. i dnt expect much from downpour. im not sure what happend to team silent, mabye they moved on to other things, but i believe they sold the rights to the 3rd party developers who create these piles of tripe on cd's that we play today. to me homecoming is the only have decent one thats most recent....

  • @Rilyn666 yep I also liked origins cause it felt more like a silent hill game than home coming but then again homecoming wasnt bad but it wasnt good.

  • @Rilyn666 I think the reason why the latest silent hill games have been pretty sucky (starting from 4) is becouse the developers just cant seem to replicate the sucess of the first three games. Kind of like how the current resident evil games have been pretty lackluster. The more sequals a franchise has the more those games start to decline in quality.

  • @silenthilldomain Like the Final Fantasys, lol.

  • @silenthilldomain idk why some people say SH4 was a decline in the series. It was very disturbing, good graphics, story, and sounds. Of course, I might be biased because SH4 was the first one I played back in 04 or so. I finally got this game today for PC, and got Silent hill homecoming a few months ago for xbox 360.

    I have been playing them way out of order. When I was younger, I was never interested in these types of games because of the controls.

  • @Rilyn666 oh man shattered memories was good (atleast for me)

    yeah it wasnt scary and all that but atleast it was fun to play and i really liked how you can change game,characters and all

    it wasnt scary i will say it again because many of you think that Silent Hill games only bout horror and to scare people but it is not, it is like happiness,sadness and all emotions mixed together

    but it is depens on player so everyone have their own opinions

    SCARIEST GAME EVER IS FATAL FRAME!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @MrMindblow12 haha mate, i agree that silent hill doesnt jus make you feel scared, but a load of other emotions aswell. but shattered memories REALLY was such a let down, considering it was a reboot of the original, it could ofbeen so much better.

    BUT FATAL FRAME :D iv jus nearly finished the 1st one an i love it, jus waiting to finish it so i can the second one.

  • @Rilyn666 well yeah shattered memories wasnt as good as i expected it to be

    i hated it that you cant fight

    those monsters are so annoying

    i think story makes this game better and do you think that origins is better? i completed origins once and got good ending and next time i will try to get bad ending and then ufo

  • Would anyone recommend me play SH

    I have Homecoming for 360 but didint actually play it

    I have a PSP so I can play SH1 and I could buy SH2, 3 for my PS2

    The only SH game Ive play is Shattered Memories which truly disappointed me as a survival horror game

    Have scary moments but not so many, it was kinda easy in almost every puzzle and too short, but still I liked the story

    Im a RE fan (except RE4 5) too

    I would like to play them but they seem extremely scary and extremely difficults (maybe)

  • @LD1E60 I would say play Silent hill 2 and 1 for survival horror. If u want more combat play silent hill 4. Homecoming was not too great of a game.

  • @hadiez12345 Thanks Im gonna play SH1 and 2 and see how they are! :D

  • @LD1E60 sorry but in terms of being scary and atmosphere silent hill shits all over resident evil, and I LOVE resident evil.

  • @Rilyn666 I know...

  • @LD1E60 yeah try Silent Hill 2 it is really scary

    there is also Silent Hill Origins for PSP and PS2 but if you didint like Shattered Memories then i think you will not really like Origins because TO ME Shattered Memories is better than Origins

    but you really need to buy Silent Hill 2

  • @MrMindblow12 Thanks I just need some money, probably Im getting it in a few days!

    But Ive also heard that Origins for a lot of people is better than Shattered Memories, cuz is more difficult and more like Silent Hill (I dont know Ive just heard)

  • @LD1E60 okay i see

    ive compeleted both games (Origins and Shattered Memories) and i must say that Shatterd Memories is difficult than Origins to me

    yeah Origins feels like Silent Hill game but i really didint like endings in Origins

    some of the endings in Shattered Memories made me almost cry

    but ofcourse it depens on player

    also you should try Silent Hill 3

    Silent Hill 3 is really scary but how i said before best game in Silent Hill series is Silent Hill 2

  • @MrMindblow12 Thanks, Im gonna try Origns too for my PSP and Im gonna try to beat Silent Hill 2 before I get 3

    I dont know some endings in Shattered Memories were good but non of them make me cry (and I cry a lot lol)

    but like you said, it depends on the player

    Thanks again you really help me!

  • @LD1E60 do yourself a favour, DNT BUY SHATTERED MEMORIES. if your curiosity overwhelms you, jus rent it.

    its a piss easy piece of shit.....and isnt scary or worthy of the title SILENT HILL

  • @Rilyn666 Too late... I BEAT IT!

    It was truly disppointing...

    Yeah it was to easy and not scary at all even if I dont totally know how a Silent Hill game is supposed to be I truly expect the others not to be like Shattered Memories!

  • my hard suddenly started to beat faster and faster then playing this game

  • i cannot see why people think silent hill 2 or 1 is more scary than this at least you went outside in that this game is just overwhelmingly depressing and claustrophobic

  • the thumbnail on this video was eery as shit.

  • The best horror game ever made

  • I never played a SH game, but for some reason love themXD ITs strange. I even have the theme songs by Akira Yamaoka for SH 3 and 4 on my MP3 playerXD I have to play some of these.

  • @Pooky1991 DUUUUDE!!!!!! you MUST play silent hill!!!! but you have to play them in order!!!! 1 to 4 !!!! if you dont have a playstation for the first one get an emulator!! NOOW!!! hahaha

  • She looks just like a character who was in eastenders

  • I personally think SIlent Hill 2 is the best.

    Awesome storyline. Awesome atmosphere.

    But I l do love them all.

  • @LottieHansis What about James?

  • okay im sorry but i have never totally liked vidoe reviews from gamespot. they are okay, they have fair and inciteful ratings, thats why i still watch em a bit. But for real, these guys need scripts. They always studder and trip over their words. Its pretty unprofessional.

  • i miss this game :\

  • started playing silent hill 2 3 days ago and just fell in love with the series dunno how this game slipped under my radar for so long cant wait to try out the other silent hills

  • @CripticX friend any one with good brain falls in love with silent hills, that are more than games, they are work of art... but sadly, you must know something, silent hill, the real games are just SH 1 to 4... made by japanese team silent, after that there were only american made by climax, crap silent hills... you must play silent hill 1 to 4, thats all. you must play them all.

  • @pearlsoftt Try Haunting Ground. Very similar and from what I've heard, more polished.

  • silent Hill had the best use of atmosphere. I don't know of a game before it that you could actaully call scary. I like RE, but don't make me laugh by calling it scary.

    Silent Hill 2's enviroment and atmosphere was a dissapointment comapared to the first one, but I find it's themes and deep metaphorical underlining to be disturbing plus.

    Heather is probably the best protagonist in the series. Lets face it, James and Harry were . . . kinda stupid, and a little boring

  • 4:20

    The what filter? What does it do and why would someone want it off. I don't know what that is...

  • I've just started playing this game, and I'm liking it a lot. Heather is great, it's fun to play as her. I'm finding that instead of wanting to fight the monsters I am afraid of them, since they are so dangerous (and freaky), and would prefer to avoid them - as it should be. The problem with the unhelpful camera angles sometimes only increases this fear. It's a relief to enter a room of silence - the sound is the most disturbing part of the game, even if nothing is there the sound is menacing!

  • is the game scary

  • @chrisrat123

    it has it's moments it has more of a ''very unleasent I don't want to be here'' feel

    but hey don't take my word for it after all I think telletubies is scary as hell :P

  • wow for a game from 2003, the graphics are still considered great until now, and the atmosphere is very creepy!

  • she has a flash light on her boob

  • @fatalis4

    Dont you mean her BOOBIE?

  • @fatalis4 Lol *Does Peter Griffin Laugh*

  • holy crap, this was the second silent hill game i ever played (2 was my first), and this one was very disturbing!

  • God damn everyone in these silent hill games are emo!

  • the first game was the one that scared the most people. the other games just started gettin gayer.

  • SH3 has great graphics for PS2. I can't believe there are tons of people comparing old games to new ones, that's fucking ridiculous

  • @naierer Graphics don't make the newer SH games better than the old. The old ones are emotional masterpieces. New ones? HA, nothing special, just a group of morons raping the franchise.

  • @naierer because most of those old games are way better than any of the shit that they come out with today and therefore its an umfair battle to call of duty because call of duty cant compete with any of these gems.

  • The better the graphics get the less scary it is

  • i think that silent are some the most atmopheric and emersive games of all time

  • my favorite Silent Hill games would have to be 1-3 and Homecoming The Room was good but i prefer Silent Hill games to actually be set in Silent Hill because i love the foggy atmosphere and when the environment changes so that it looks gritty and rusty is really creepy

  • Silent Hill 3 to this day is still the scariest out of the whole series! The first one was scary for its time, and the second one wasn't really scary until the prison and the hotel. Silent Hill 3 is my all time fav!

  • 3:00 scared the crap outta me! 0_0

  • "Anyone who's a fan of the silent hill series, and anyone who's fan of the survival horror series" They bother me.

  • @linkin702 I meant the gamespot host's. Survial horror isn't a series........

  • ive played and beaten every silent hill game and this one caught my eye and i thought was very scary because number 1 you have a very eerie environment 2 you dont run ass fast and 3 your playing a teen aged girl which makes it more scary :] i love this game and i think its better than alot of resident evil games...i also like how its physiologically scary and not like monsters just coming out :}

  • lol I remember awing at the graphics of the game back then

  • I really like silent hill 4 but it's not at all like the first 3 however i still think it's as good as the others. It just depends what you like, it really was a huge change when they brought 4 out though.

  • silent hill 3 scared me abit more than the others

  • 2, 3, 4, and shattered memories are my favs.

    i didnt like homecoming.

  • What about Silent Hill 1?

  • it was better than origins and homecoming, but i havnt beaten it yet

  • The first one I watched was SH4. After watching the other 3 games I see why some peaple don't consider it as good as the other 3. 4 is scary but somethings just missing.

  • I've watched lets plays of the first 4 SH games and out of all of them I like SH3 the most. SH1 and 2 are scary but theres something about SH3 that I found the most unnerving and I think Heather is a badass protaganist exspecially given the f*** up events surrounding her birth. SH1 would be my second fave because even though it had PS1 graghics it still made me go WTF. I thought 2 had a good story (PYrimid head-shivers-) but I like the other 2 better.

  • these are the best series of games they are all round perfect everyone should have at one point played 1 game in the series :)

  • Can anyone tell me what games I could try?  I like the SH series, and plan on getting the original SH, SH 3, and SH Shattered Memories. Maybe origins. But I'm not big on playing a male character. I play games like Fatal Frame and the clock tower series, and american mcgees Alice.

    Can anyone help me find some more good games?

  • @xXMidnightdoveXx If you want to play as a girl you could try some of the resident evils.

  • @blaster702 actually I'm not big on any of the Resident Evil games. I'm more for the games like what I listed below.

  • @xXMidnightdoveXx

    Sorry this is a bit late to reply, but you could try looking into a game called The Path. I haven't played it before, but I know it has all girl characters.

  • @blaster702 Though I am willing to try Resident Evil: The Nightmare Chronicles...If I can get my hands on a wii game system...

  • @xXMidnightdoveXx Yeah me neither but other than what you already have I couldnt think of anything else where you can play as a girl without a character creater

  • Haunting Ground and Rule Of Rose are survival horror games where u only play as a girl... u should try them out.. they r rare so ebay or amazon is youre best shot..

  • Personally, i loved Origins and shattered memories, im not a massive fan of the original, the camera angle just puts me off.

  • u should check out Haunting Ground and Rule of Rose

  • @sn0d I already know about them...I just forgot to mention them...

  • Haunting Ground just might be a game your looking for.

  • this game looks very interesting, but is it really worth it? i mean the graphics are the best but what about the game play?

  • I really recommend this game, its fantastic, I just finished it

  • Best Silent Hill game ever.

    If u liked 1 and 2 this is better.

  • The games I hold close to my heart are The Room, Origins, and Homecoming.People say that these are the worst games of the series but I like them because they're the ones I played fist until a friend recommended I play the first three.I have to say, I like them all, some more than others but I really enjoyed them.I hated that "The Room" had a shitload of backtracking but other than that, they were all really great games and I wanna play them all over again very soon.

  • @bosspersonfighter Go watch Fungo and Twin Perfect's TRSHE

  • @bosspersonfighter I'm sorry but homecoming has nothing on Silent hill 2 in my opinion

  • @bosspersonfighter Silent hill 4: the room was still made by Konami though. That was the first one I played. Recently played SH homecoming last year. It was good, but not like the first 4.

    I hope silent hill 6 can have the same disturbing music, and atmosphere like the first 4.

  • don't, homecoming is way too cliche. if u r into action games then hell yah

  • Whats the grainfilter???? :S

  • anyone notice that the radio was only ever realy useful in the first game i barley even noticed it in 2 and 3

  • SH, SH2, and SH3 are the only games as far as I am conserned. SH4 wasn't intended to be an SH game. SH2 is STILL epic. SH1 has aged, but still makes me Shite my pants. SH3 was a contiuation of SH1, so it feels like you are playing SH1 part 2 with better graphics. SH5, SH0, and everything else can just jump off a cliff into a chasim of Hell as far as I am conserned. They may be good games, but they are not SH.

  • you litle piece of shet >_>

  • Graphics don't mean everything.

    In my opinion the first silent hill had the best atmosphere. Homecoming wasn't as scary. It was scary but more americanized horror.

  • @leosignit Homecoming was ok but not scary..the lst one is the scariest!!!

  • @leosignit Yeah agreed about Homecoming. It didn't have that grainy creepy feeling that the older games had.

  • @leosignit still its pathetic that no wii game looks as good

  • @leosignit mate if i could give u 500 thumbs up for that comment i would, nobody can comprehend the atmosphere of the first game. it was a fucking MASTERPIECE. im a proud owner of it an i will take it to the fuckin grave with me.

  • fuck you piece of shit graphic isnt everything and now go keep play gta fucker

  • all Silent Hill games are like a bad hit of acid

  • @DvDPlaya way to condone drug use

  • @CrimsonRGU If anything hes doing the opposite. Also why do you give so much of a fuck? ;)

  • @kevin12305 either ur very offended cuz idk ur a junkie or ur jst another one of those angry canadians

    and dont u know sarcasm?

  • SH3 has better graphics than SH2 and there are more types of monsters and it has more locations. I also think that it's scarier than its predecessor, but the characters and the story in SH2 are just utterly awesome and there's always something new to discover and to speculate!

    SH2 is my favorite but it always feels fresh to play SH3! Or the combination of SH1 and SH3...

  • silent hill 2 is my faw:)

  • DONT FUCK UP SH:Wii!!!

  • I believe they already did :(

  • nah, if u watched the newer videos on it it actually seems good. looks like they put alot of work in it. dont judge b4 u play

  • Sh3 is great but the reason why I think Sh2 is better is that the locations are more connected to your character james.

    The Hotel (its obvious cause this is where he and his wife mary checked in)

    the park (they spent a lot of time there)

    The hospital (his wife got hospitalized)

    The prison