I wrote a similar comment on the other video, but I'll reiterate my point here. While this is an excellent arrangement of Erdmann's score, I prefer Heller's arrangement, for how it fits closely in tempo and dynamics to the actions in the film. Here, the music is simply playing, and the conductor almost seems ignorant of the film. Thus, the scene feels unsynchronized with the music. This is not to say this version is bad; it is quite frightening at parts, but the lack of sync detracts greatly.
I wrote a similar comment on the other video, but I'll reiterate my point here. While this is an excellent arrangement of Erdmann's score, I prefer Heller's arrangement, for how it fits closely in tempo and dynamics to the actions in the film. Here, the music is simply playing, and the conductor almost seems ignorant of the film. Thus, the scene feels unsynchronized with the music. This is not to say this version is bad; it is quite frightening at parts, but the lack of sync detracts greatly.
VideoMask93 4 months ago