Jolene - Brooke White [with judges' comments]

[reapblessings01]

Liked it! Simon's a hater. LOL

[katiekat09]

"you are brooke white."

"yes she is."

hahaha i love simon. :D

[SweetaRoxious]

Why did they send Alexis home? Alexis is great. She sang this song a thousand times better than Brooke.

[SweetaRoxious]

Hahahaha I love Randy's reaction to Simon. He was like :she's not a group, pfff" Hahahaha.

[Azanpopstarz]

i think simon loves country-music

[CarrieFan4Lyfe]

So much better than Alexis. :)

[CrossTheBlueLine]

Definitely not true. Alexis' performance was way better. :(

[CarrieFan4Lyfe]

LOLXD

[ebonumba12]

yep, definitely liked alexis' performance better because of the key she chose to sing it in.

[slrgtr52]

lmfao, someone who is better in the shade! hahahahahahahah

[Miiiikaa]

I liked the violin player lol.

[geeneyes61]

SIMON How do you sleep at night? that was uncalled for she did a great job on that song and the band was also great stop playing around with Paula Abdul i dont know how your girlfriend can stand you. i will buy her CD

[geeneyes61]

Brooke you did a good job on that song it is not a slow song.Brook Smiled at the audience her family is there.and how would you like to sing your heart out knowing that your family is hearing you sing and hearing that the judge's keep cutting you down thay want David to win.

[tinkershells]

dude, how can she smile while singing that song...that song is all about jealousy and anger and desperation...fake bitch

[buddylover1201]

she smiles because she is a happy person.

[Marikac86]

i thought she did a great job with this song...and she s playin the guitar as well,,, iloved it

[sourcheesepringles]

she actually sounds like carly simon here.. haha

[sourcheesepringles]

this performance is ok.. what she lacks is conviction.. maybe she hasn't experienced what dolly has experienced...overall it's forgivable...

[Allyheartzz]

Shei s AMAZING.

[plzsnow3]

dont forget shes playing the guitar maybe it distracted her lol

[plzsnow3]

she sung it well but it looks like she was a lil nervous nd i would be 2

[jennnnnnn13]

I hated the performance, but after Simon makes fun of the violin guy, I think I laughed for 10 minutes after she defended him.

"He's a very nice violin player! Please apologize!"

[CrazyHamo]

The thing is she gets personally offended by the judgements so she feels the need to cut them off and "discuss" the decisions to make it go lighter and softer for her. Talking or arguing with the Judges will Help change her feelings from Sad, to Mad-Happy, you could say.. I hope that makes sense.

[ROPEroxGV]

You said that in the other video..

[blackberryheels]

I dunno if its just me, but Brooke seems to have an especially tough time handling criticism. She never really agrees with their comments and makes it well known.

[mileycookie]

AND! Simon is allways right i count on him he really KNOWS what hes saying actually i cant stand hearing what rendy thinks or paula with her stupid talking...

[fergalicious2468]

whats happened 2 brooke white we all know and love?? she's a gr8,WONDERFUL singer n i was really sad wen she was in da bottom-3, but there isnt da same ting in her voice dat was there wen she sang "let it be"

[mybrookewhite]

VOTE FOR BROOKE! Love HEr!!!! She is one amazing gal...Might not be the champ, but she deserves to be in the top 5!!! At the least!!!!

[LuffyKisser]

She seems kinda fake. She's above average, but she's not gonna win.

[definexfreedom]

SHE DID NOT DESERVE TO BE IN THE BOTTOM THREE. Okay, so maybe it wasn't her strongest performance (although I did like it!), but there are plenty of other contestants -- most of them, in fact -- that deserved it far more than she did. I was on the verge of tears right there, the entire time. WTH?!

Brooke is amazing, plan and simple. <3 Absolute love. Amazing voice, emotional and beautiful and...yeah. She's incredible. She'll go far. I'd certainly buy all her stuff.

[jessicalynne142]

I agree completely, I LOVE this girl!!

[JSumpterluvr]

she CANT SING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[aherrold]

you CAN drink BLEACH! GO TRY IT!

[JSumpterluvr]

0she messed up the song!!!! she sings wa to low in it!!

[mohabat22]

I honestly love her.

And yes, she is like Carly Simon, and she likes Carly Simon too.

Which is ironic.

I really hope she wins!

Omg :-O Bottom 3?! I was like screaming at the television when I heard that! :-(

Lol, skip down to the main point ..

LOVE HER

[helenacolou]

She is so like carly simon!!!

And I love Carly Simon

[jessicalynne142]

Ahh, so you're a Brooke White freak too? :P I love her, everything she does. I cried when she was announced in the bottom three (that was all-around a very depressing episode).

[LilCav68]

She is good but I agree that she didn't do the song justice.

[marypoppins1968]

If she can also write and arrange music, I do believe she is the next Carly Simon. Even if she won't win here, she's gonna have a succesful career in the music industry.

[CarrieFan4Lyfe]

I still have hope though that she can pull out something great and win. :>