Added: 4 years ago
From: Eriksheart
Views: 176,481
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (99)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • wonderful! I love to hear him sing!

  • great now im going to have to watch phantom of the opera to see what happens

  • Oh, I never heard this music before... It's marvelous with the awesome voice of Josh W. Groban!!! Simply fantastic and deeply emotional!!!

  • Yes! it' sa voice! But I prefer Michael...who is more emotionnal when he sings, whith more light vibratos...more qualified.

  • I like Josh Groban's music. But MJ's version of the song "She's Out Of My Life" still is more Powerful / Moving, so very much more packed with Emotion because I can really feel the pain in the "she's out of my life" song's persona through Michael's voice..

    But Mr. Groban is Excellent in his own songs.

  • Thanks for this video and thanks for uploading this for our enjoyment.

    Beautiful!

  • Very beautiful music.

  • I m a huge fan of Josh Groban , but i must say i prefer Mickael Jackson s version...

  • @farres0031 I have to agree Michael's can't be re-done by anyone. Love Josh though!

  • WOW, fantastic duo, Phantom & Josh

  • I love this mix of Josh Groban and the Phantom! Well done.

  • I wish I had this guy's voice. I just want to talk to him so he could give some pointers, after all whats a singer like me to do with people like him in the world to eclipse me?

  • I dont care that Im a straight dude, ive seen this man is concert 7 times and I fucking love this stuff!

  • @Coreyaification Of course his music is straight,its usually about heterosexual love ,thankfully.So the music from Josh Groban and the phantom film and stage musical is very straight,for straight guys as well as straight women to enjoy.

  • @Coreyaification My boyfriend loves this song too.

  • tnx for posting the song Eriksheart. you never know how much this song reminds me of the past. Josh is great. the composer is great. but i guess every song just serves its purpose. it this song does well now and then, i.e. to remind me of something.

  • Josh, you are so talented. I listen you you almost every day and even flew from Portland to NYC to see your concert at MSG, in November. One of the highlights of my life! You have no idea how much impact - positive impact, you have on so many people! <3

  • Kocham....

  • Phantom gave his whole life for her and she threw it away. ;( I feel so bad for him. Gerard Butler is amazing. that was the perfect song though to put it to

  • I LOVE THIS VIDEO THAT WAS THE PERFECT SCENE TO DO IT GO PHANTOM!!!!!!!!!!!

    I feel bad for the poor guy though. No one ever loved him he finaly he found love and now she left him for good. ;(

  • @TheLastStarHolder Do you know Andrew Lloyd Webber created a Phantom sequel called 'Love Never Dies" ? It does have some haters but a lot of us love it. YouTube it and make up your own mind. :)

  • okey ka talaga

  • Josh has the most unbelievably gorgeous, feeling voice. This cover is proof of that.

  • Is this on one of his albums?

  • Simply BEAUTIFUL.

  • lindo ,lindo adoro josh groban.....

  • Prefer the true king of pop

  • Fits The Phantom's shock and pain perfectly. Nice job!

  • Josh you beautiful!

  • wanna be the king of pop.. unbeliveble close, but no cigar..

  • i dont know how to react in this song it hurts me so much

    i love you sheila magpusao

  • Simply beautiful!!

  • so this video make me cry ="(

  • I Love U Josh Groban U R My Favorite Male Singer

  • @Autumn8499 mine too/and michael buble

  • I don't know whether to laugh or cry pretty much sums up Gerards crying ;)

  • My two favorite things, The Phantom of the Opera and Josh Groban. Beautifully done!

  • Wow. I've never heard a high-quality version of Josh Groban singing this song. For years, this was the "lost" song from Closer that I never got to hear. Nice to hear it for the first time.

  • i love you josh groban. your fan in Brazil

  • Love Phantom of the Opera, but you make it even more beautiful..the story you can tell..amazing

  • so beautiful and soooooo sad.

  • beautiful...what else can i say

  • As usual, Josh Groban's incredible voice gives us a FANTASTIC rendition of a beautiful song.....it's just SO HARD to find a singer like Josh....they are RARE...

  • many songs use this video , is this a movie ? what's the moive name ?

  • the movie's called 'The Phantom of the Opera'

  • this man is incredible - amazing

  • you combined my favorite musical with my favorite singer. THANK YOU!

  • vonderful i love this song so mutch...

    She´s out of life is a song thet makes mee cry!

  • *sigh* so beautiful~

  • Wonderful singer, wonderful video. YAY!

  • Beautiful, wonderful!

  • Wow! Amazing video!

  • I LOVE YOU JOSH GROBAN :))))

  • ...5:17 am...25 april....its out of my hand....i keep her deep inside...she's out of my life....

  • sorry to hear that.

  • 2 oclock in the morning,and i am in tears he is fabulous

  • darn. 1.22am and the whole apartment complex is quiet save for this song.

  • Beautiful version of Michael Jackson`s classic "She`s out of my life". I love the song and I thought - nobody can do it better than Michael.

    Josh - you did it great!

  • composed by tom bahler and originally sang by michael jackson. such a beeeaaautiful song...sang more beautifully by josh groban!

  • Not so...they both sang it beautifully. No ego needed here. MJ sang this very soulfully.

  • beautifully sang from the heart ! bravo, josh!!!

  • that was beautiful. great job!!

  • Wow, that was actually a good rendition of the classic Michael Jackson hit. Loved it!

  • such a very good rendition, i could feel the emotion in joshs songs, he always makes me shiver

  • even i don't know how much i love u josh!!

  • i love this song very much...

  • omg Eriksheart.....

    thank you for this video...

    i first seen this in Toronto at the Pantages Theatre when i was 16--15 years later im still in love with Phantom!!!!

    so glad they made this movie!!!!

  • what movie is this? can anyone tell me?

  • Phantom of the Opera

  • wow..wonder how he sings like this!!

  • I LOVE JOSH GROBAN CAN YOU TELL ME IS JOSH GROBAN  is COMEING TO DUBLIN Ireland in 2008/2009

  • I have never heard this song before beautifull

    can you tell me what album this off??

    Many thanks.

  • very beautiful!

  • Can anyone help me figure out where i might find this song and his other ones from his cd with you..and the song your the only place? they aren't on itunes and i really want them!

  • You can buy the "With You" cd on ebay. I just got a brand new one for I think $6 on ebay.

  • those songs are usually on his limited internet editions. your the only place is on his internet edition of closer and basically you'll be lucky if you find it for under $200. there is a cd that has 'with you' and a couple other ones like 'my heart was home again' but not 'your the only place' or 'she's out of my life.'

    the moral is, buy the limited internet editions before they sell out or you will never own the song:) good luck.

  • LOL thanks!

  • Any guesses who the songwriter was referring to?

  • yes. Tom Bahler the writer was with Karen Carpenter (the carpenters singer) and she left him after he fathered a child from another woman.

  • Nothing beats Michael Jackson's version, but Josh is crazy good too.

  • Love this song!!!

    Josh Groban has an amazing voice!

  • I'm addicted to Josh Groban music. I love all his songs. And this one fits good with your vid.

  • I've always loved this song! Josh Groban sings it much better than 98 degrees (spelling?) Thank you!! Thank you so much

  • um this was micheal jackson's song.. fyi..& i think he sang it better to begin with.. but this guy still does a good job

  • I think michael jackson has done way better than he did

  • this is my song to my ex-gf after we broke up... i love this song so much coz the pain still remains here in my heart

  • The Phantom himself...always makes me think of Michael Crawford. :)

  • yah! i love josh!

  • Thanks for this...I am fond of Josh's recording of my song...you did a wonderful video interpretation.

    Tom Bahler

  • Nice song, didn't know it before. 5 stars ;)

  • How did you get a hold of the song? I can't find it anywhere?

  • It's on Josh's closer album "Internet Edition".

  • ...which I neglected to buy, not knowing that the bonus tracks were limited edition. :[

  • nice version of the song! Gosh did w/o so much effort. i like this version. the pics are great too. good job!

  • I love him too!!!!!!!!!!He's the greatest!

  • Josh!!! omg, i love him and this song... Grobanites!!! yay

  • I love Josh Groban so much! Thanks for sharing!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more