I enjoy your version more than Heather Nova. It sounds...more flow-y and mellow. Don't think I'm being disrespectful or anything, but it sounds more whine-y, for lack of a better word. I just think it blends better into the music. I really do enjoy this. Thanks so much for singing it and sharing it. :D
I like it. Other people like it. That's all that counts. You're way too critical. It's a good song. I like Heather Nova's voice, because it's not perfect. She has character.
i have heard this song, both versions. this is probably one of peter gabriel's best songs. the original version was released on the album security, and a remix was released on "shaking the tree." the album security was recorded on a fairlight 100, which was the pre-cursor to the synclavier. And yes heather sounds bland on this song. her vocal doesn't sit well in the track, and the track itself sounds stilted and clunky.
i have listened to the original version, and even the remix from "shaking the tree." this is probably one of peter gabriel's best songs. it was first released on the album security, and it was done on a fairlight 100, which was the pre-cursor to the synclavier. as far as this version goes, it is bland. heather sounds awkward on it. her voice doesn't sit well in the track and the track itself sounds clunky and stilted.
hey this is not peter !!! :-/
voycham 6 months ago
Very good.
kmmangel444 6 months ago
GREAT VOICE!
Nicole48273 6 months ago
wtf
evebathory 9 months ago
Nice I love this song. And I love YOU singing it. There is a powerful message in here.
healinghands28 1 year ago
Yeesh.
743one 2 years ago
Perfect! You Got The Touch On This One!
fastway39 2 years ago
I enjoy your version more than Heather Nova. It sounds...more flow-y and mellow. Don't think I'm being disrespectful or anything, but it sounds more whine-y, for lack of a better word. I just think it blends better into the music. I really do enjoy this. Thanks so much for singing it and sharing it. :D
tonicolewithlove 2 years ago
I like it!! Very excellent singing! American Idol sounding good to you? :) Try out!
ShinbiBelldandy 2 years ago
A cute voice and a great song , what could be better ? Keep singing ! ( it is not your fault Peter Gabriel did not back you up properly . )
ebmstudios 2 years ago
I like it. Other people like it. That's all that counts. You're way too critical. It's a good song. I like Heather Nova's voice, because it's not perfect. She has character.
kmmangel444 3 years ago
i have heard this song, both versions. this is probably one of peter gabriel's best songs. the original version was released on the album security, and a remix was released on "shaking the tree." the album security was recorded on a fairlight 100, which was the pre-cursor to the synclavier. And yes heather sounds bland on this song. her vocal doesn't sit well in the track, and the track itself sounds stilted and clunky.
larissanpw 3 years ago
i have listened to the original version, and even the remix from "shaking the tree." this is probably one of peter gabriel's best songs. it was first released on the album security, and it was done on a fairlight 100, which was the pre-cursor to the synclavier. as far as this version goes, it is bland. heather sounds awkward on it. her voice doesn't sit well in the track and the track itself sounds clunky and stilted.
larissanpw 3 years ago
5 stars for that great singing
doneice18 3 years ago