I understand they both have different voices and singing styles but Phil sang this song with so much more soul, you really could feel the pain when he sang it, this is just another song for Mariah it seems
ok you may not like the way she sounds now, but millions and millions of people do. so no, she shouldn't retire. singing is singing and she still sounds amazing and 100 times better than the second best pop star currently out there
Having Mariah and Westlife on the same song is like wearing the Hope diamond at the end of a shoe string bought at a yard sale that was originally bought from the Dollar store.
@xXxMetroManxXx They're fake. Look at 1:55, clearly she's had a boob job. She's had a lot of work done. It's unfortunate she's changed so much. I miss the classy, old-school ballad queen I loved in the 90s. So sad.
@tinarocksyoyo thats one of the things that makes mariah so amazing (not her boobs, her dynamics)...its so great seeing a singer evolve, she does an amazing job staying contemporary, which is why shes so incredibly successful...she probably wouldnt have been as successful if she was still a curly haired good girl ballad singer, you must admit
@Dannoc100 Yes but my point is, she's changed. She's no longer the singer I used to love. She doesn't even sound the same. She's conformed and she will never be the same. She needs to retire from singing altogether and just be a mom. Her time is done. She peeked in the 90s.
Have to say I prefer this version....but that's probably b/c I heard this one first and already loved it before I heard the original....so there you go LOL
@DJMICICE1984 lol Phil Collins is, if you've somehow missed it, is a man. His tone is supposed to be stronger than mariah's. Nonetheless, she more than makes up for it with sheer fluidity and superior musicianship.
@stevendjie I think it's a thing.. very difficult to happen.. In portuguese is "contra todas as probabilidades" "contra as chances" ou seja algo bem improvável de acontecer.. rs
I give this 4 star because she has great voice and nice body, but I give phill collins 5 star, because he puts more power into it, mariah just doesn't seem as convincing! Overall great song with powerful lyrics and they are both good musicians!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
No version is better than the original, she is a very talented woman but she does this song no justice.. she needs to stick to own style..Phil Collins is the only one that can truely do this song justice
It's originally by Phil Collins. xD. But Mariah did a cover of it, and it is great. When I got her rainbow album, I got even more obsessed with it! Mariah's the best
Love this song!
chocoholicchic92 1 week ago
I want this video on my DROID X unit.
irvingadkins616 3 weeks ago
hey, you... carey.... i just love you.
valarangel 1 month ago
likeee <3
MrModernCinderella 1 month ago
from which album is this song ??
aema171 1 month ago
@aema171 Rainbow.
turquoise15 1 month ago
@turquoise15 thanx.
aema171 1 month ago
She is so damn beautiful.
lawdog2008 2 months ago
I wish Mariah and Phil Collins sang this as a duet
JayBarrington 2 months ago 2
She does such an incredible job slowly adding more and more power/emotion into it. That in itself is amazing.
DeadlyMixKrew 2 months ago
@DeadlyMixKrew Yeah...that's something musicians do when they're playing their respective instruments...
BlackLightning20101 1 month ago
I understand they both have different voices and singing styles but Phil sang this song with so much more soul, you really could feel the pain when he sang it, this is just another song for Mariah it seems
ColCasperUK 2 months ago
ok you may not like the way she sounds now, but millions and millions of people do. so no, she shouldn't retire. singing is singing and she still sounds amazing and 100 times better than the second best pop star currently out there
Dannoc100 3 months ago 6
Having Mariah and Westlife on the same song is like wearing the Hope diamond at the end of a shoe string bought at a yard sale that was originally bought from the Dollar store.
BrotherBoresIsBest 4 months ago 3
I still love this song. Though I never knew she did a duet with the awful Westlife.
BrotherBoresIsBest 4 months ago
my all time favourite song!
bosman24 4 months ago
she sings good , but she got AMAZING BOOBS !
xXxMetroManxXx 4 months ago
@xXxMetroManxXx They're fake. Look at 1:55, clearly she's had a boob job. She's had a lot of work done. It's unfortunate she's changed so much. I miss the classy, old-school ballad queen I loved in the 90s. So sad.
tinarocksyoyo 4 months ago
@tinarocksyoyo thats one of the things that makes mariah so amazing (not her boobs, her dynamics)...its so great seeing a singer evolve, she does an amazing job staying contemporary, which is why shes so incredibly successful...she probably wouldnt have been as successful if she was still a curly haired good girl ballad singer, you must admit
Dannoc100 3 months ago
@Dannoc100 Yes but my point is, she's changed. She's no longer the singer I used to love. She doesn't even sound the same. She's conformed and she will never be the same. She needs to retire from singing altogether and just be a mom. Her time is done. She peeked in the 90s.
tinarocksyoyo 3 months ago
fantastic interpretation. The riffs she does on "Take a look at me NOW" part are so pleasant.
RanjitMorey 4 months ago
Her version is nice, but I'd still go with the Phil Collins version.
NYRyder1983 4 months ago
I prefer Mariah's version. Her voice flows more smoothly and elegantly, in my opinion.
BigBlyeEyes1234 4 months ago 3
Have to say I prefer this version....but that's probably b/c I heard this one first and already loved it before I heard the original....so there you go LOL
mainegabrielle 4 months ago 3
I like this version more than Phil Collins version much more
pimpdogpatrick 5 months ago 3
Lover her voice its so amazing, Nick Cannon is the luckiest guy in the world married to Mariah Carey lucky guy
pimpdogpatrick 5 months ago 3
i just realised every picture changes the main focus is her boobs hahahahah nice song tho :P
286fariz 5 months ago
nice beginning :P
urbanpoems 5 months ago
are these real?
wawrzyn1990 5 months ago
wow !
lovejonasforever123 6 months ago 2
most pics start at the chest and zoom out... are we appreciating the song or her bewbs?
TheCalmingPants 7 months ago
Phill's version is WAY better.. Carey can sing but she sure can't tip the strong voice of Phill when he sings at live Aid 1985.
DJMICICE1984 7 months ago
@DJMICICE1984 lol Phil Collins is, if you've somehow missed it, is a man. His tone is supposed to be stronger than mariah's. Nonetheless, she more than makes up for it with sheer fluidity and superior musicianship.
RanjitMorey 4 months ago
It can not be that this woman is ruining the song by Phil Collins, they really are unique.
EliasVagliente95 8 months ago 6
@EliasVagliente95 And both versions are in the same key.
JeopardyandWheelFan 7 months ago
the boops of mariah at the beginning fit with the song...very romantic...
cescomanuel 8 months ago 5
No puede ser que esta mujer este arruinando la cancion de Phil Collins, realmente son incomparables.
EliasVagliente95 9 months ago 4
the opening shot is amazingly pervy no?
JayCNelson 10 months ago 5
What a beautiful voice !!!!!
mateusbressycaino 11 months ago 2
Amazing!
barbaralovemimi 11 months ago 3
This might be even better than the phil collins version
SalamonX7 1 year ago 10
@SalamonX7 are you kidding me? this is nothing compared to Phil Collins
kirintorguardian 2 days ago
Mariah knows exactly how to get a great song and turn it into an even more spectacular version!! Only she can do it so perfectly!!
Against All Odds, Can't Take That Away, Petals and Heartbreaker are my favorites songs from Raibow album!! =)
MariahCareyAngel1 1 year ago 6
I like this version. But Phil Collins is a motherfucking legend.
souljadicktellem 1 year ago 6
@souljadicktellem so is mariah lol
jakey1126 6 months ago
MC is the GREATEST!!!!
blackbarbiie89 1 year ago 2
A great version of a classic.
steverson01 1 year ago 4
great version of a unforgetful classic.
steverson01 1 year ago 3
This version is so much better. Often times there are things we want to say, but sometimes when we have the chance to say them, it's too late :'(
mysweetbleedinglove 1 year ago 6
She's such an amazing singer!
MyMidgeetgems 1 year ago 4
no pueden hacer un video mas productivo, que enfocarle solo las tetas che... }
pcsoportemax 1 year ago 3
I lost my dad and this song reminds me of himmmmm sooo much.. R.I.P Daddy luv you and miss u
jillyjillzL3S 1 year ago 3
Damn, that girl can sing!
iivanov86 1 year ago 4
I Reall Like Her Version.
CarmenGreer79 1 year ago 7
Mariah Carey is awesome, but she should have left this one alone. Phil Collins was meant for this song.
brittdial 1 year ago
i love this song
unbroken74 1 year ago
Ti...
ImAlex612 1 year ago
very sensual voice love yu mariah yu r the best
gorginia20 1 year ago 2
i think eli mattson's performance of this song is unforgettable!
devondjackson 1 year ago
i know this is a stupid question, but... what does "against all odds" mean?
stevendjie 1 year ago
@stevendjie I think it's a thing.. very difficult to happen.. In portuguese is "contra todas as probabilidades" "contra as chances" ou seja algo bem improvável de acontecer.. rs
tubaraum89 1 year ago
@stevendjie en français "contre toute attente" ou toute chances! but if u re portugueshe tubaraum ' s translation is good!
minouche411 1 year ago
anything Mariah touches turns to gold her voice is mesmerizing.
javoneybaby 1 year ago 6
Well,,, she got the boobies ,,Phil don't have ha ha ,and he doesn't look as she is lol
donn695 1 year ago
@donn695 duh shes a woman asshole
tooboyish 1 year ago
wow..
smexiidya 1 year ago 2
the boob shots??? WTF!!! this woman deserves respect
gayforpay69 1 year ago 3
@Brambletalon25 lool yep and i dont think she did great i think she did ok
TheRoyaldiamond 1 year ago
paige miles is singing this on american idol as we speak!
rayna876 1 year ago
I give this 4 star because she has great voice and nice body, but I give phill collins 5 star, because he puts more power into it, mariah just doesn't seem as convincing! Overall great song with powerful lyrics and they are both good musicians!
MrMetallica775 2 years ago
beautiful song
5*!
DreamingGirlStefania 2 years ago 2
baby this song tells what aim feeling now
i gonna miss you when you go back to croatia
marco i love you!!
sweet kisses
esperence
xKATARINAAAx 2 years ago
where are the lyrics??
spagnolina1993 2 years ago
don't really think that phil collins' version and her version can be compared....they're just so different.
kavira16 2 years ago 62
this song really helped me with situations that were hard. go mariah!
taylorstorch 2 years ago 3
i love this song! simply amazing!
AliciaGirl20 2 years ago 5
j'avais oublié le petit salut du matin , pardon
nchq 2 years ago
Mariah is a Natural SONG BIRD
bahamasgirl72 2 years ago 52
I love The Postal Service 's version
VickiGru 2 years ago
Its an amazing song, i think Leona lewis would be good at it too
AutumnSilencex 2 years ago 4
i love it too! ;)
xxholz97 2 years ago 9
i love this song...and this version it's definitely the best
lululemon66 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
No version is better than the original, she is a very talented woman but she does this song no justice.. she needs to stick to own style..Phil Collins is the only one that can truely do this song justice
MarcusEClay 2 years ago
Well i agree with you! Phil Collins Version is much better!!
mikeheronmufc09 2 years ago
Is right!!!
sheylazayas 2 years ago
She's amazing :).
Rezzie29 2 years ago 5
she can sing anything
bahamasgirl72 2 years ago 8
i love song so much i started crying when i was listining to it caause it reminded me of my granadad:(
Miss you so much grandad !
TillyLurvesJoeJonas 2 years ago 7
LOVE IT.LOVE IT.LOVEI T.
lilandalishow 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is a great song but it sounds way better when phil collins sings it.
eeyore61058 2 years ago
No, she is much better.
MimiWent 2 years ago 7
uh.... those pics!!! What a beautiful woman
hkyktms 2 years ago 4
beautiful song!!!
schehrazada1324 2 years ago 5
the best version i agree too!!
anaruxandra 3 years ago 9
Comment removed
Robinschatje 3 years ago
by far the best version
and you rock for posting the recording
most youtube vids of this are the live or westlife versions
when she goes for it @ 2:48 the harmonics ringing all through her head are just ridiculous
i live for this
theblueangel28 3 years ago 9
gtbh i prefer this one :)
128saz 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
teehee......... boobies =)
bmsk8mag 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
+ lyrics?????????? where are ther lyrics
jpmendolera 3 years ago
in description, where else?!
JackyliciousR 3 years ago 6
i love this song so fuxxin much
8335890 3 years ago 5
very good job !!
MARIAHTHEBABYGIRL 3 years ago 4
i love mariah she is great
mariahemc2 3 years ago 3
i just starting singing this and didnt relise who sang it and now i luv it soooo much!!!
gecco2603 3 years ago 2
It's originally by Phil Collins. xD. But Mariah did a cover of it, and it is great. When I got her rainbow album, I got even more obsessed with it! Mariah's the best
mcphr3ak3 3 years ago 4
Love this song!!
booksandtoys 3 years ago 5
i did not know mariah had redone this song but i love it.
sexyleeza2 3 years ago 3
Love this vidoe! I luv when she says "Turn around and see me cry'! LUV IT! MIMI Rocks!
Tammie082 3 years ago 3
I Love This Song I Personally Like The Mariah Version Much Better Than The Original Phil Collins Version.
DivasForeverChannel 3 years ago