"Guantanamo's Child: The Untold Story of Omar Khadr-2/2

[unicarnio]

He is not a murderer , they were invading his country and fortunately khadr, survived

the fighting that's what happen when you go to war speers and morris that's the reality of war, the jury gave him 40 years, that must be a joke, but it also show the

hatred they harbor against people from al-qaeda and they also forgot that Bush

armed them and trained them. that's is a circus!!

[TSM8088]

Omar Khadr has just admitted to murder having changed his plea and deciding to tell the truth.

He is as he always has been a murderer and war criminal.

Thankfully he will never be free again and never will he be able to come back to nor be welcomed in Canada! He will like die in Gauntanamo..

It is a great day for justice, for the war on terror, and a great day for Canada!

[pebble213]

@TSM8088 I have no words for you except that your an ignorant sheep following the herd blindly wolfing down what the media has fed you. I just hope God guides you and people similar to you.

[TSM8088]

@pebble213 That's quite a few words actually...I don't watch tv or follow the "media" and there is no "God." Speaking of sheep, how is your "flock?"

Now mind your own business you ignorant fool.

[ogfre123]

LET'S BRING ALL TERRORRISTS BACK TO CANADA, THEY ARE REAL NICE PEACEFULL FOLKS

[willbond]

Omar was in Afghanistan visiting his Great Aunt. One day, after mowing the lawn and helping her in her garden, he realized his puppy Mohameet was missing, so he went to find him. About a mile down the road he stopped at a compound to ask if they'd seen his lost puppy. Now Omar didn't know this, but the people there were Al Qaeda. U.S. Special Forces attacked just as Omar was telling the men to have a nice day and to please let him know if they saw Mohammeet....and you know the rest

[MCTRIPIDON1991]

even if he did blow that yank away, how is it a war crime? it's fair game

[Jagged85]

@MCTRIPIDON1991

According to the US's own invented "laws of war", killing and maiming millions of innocent non-American civilians is "fair game", but killing a single US soldier in self-defense is a "war crime".

The US government also assumes the public is dumb enough to believe a blinded kid with shrapnel in his eyes is capable of "murdering" someone... It's obvious they're using this kid as a scapegoat to hide the most likely fact that they killed their own soldier in a friendly fire...

[diamondcalves]

@meandcindy

I know Bush is a scammer but so is this damn refugee who 's ass should have been playing tag or hand ball not hand grenade with his family supporting. These damn discriminating refugees treat us harsh and are bigot users with conditioned attitudes of entitlement "No thanks to the sucker, idiotic, chicken sh*t, kiss ass so called Canadians. You are refugee enablers. Too much for too long. My taxes pay for these stinking baby making welfare, freedom stealing, tribe of AliBubas

[globalimportune]

Send this Muslim back where he belongs.....Canada

[Obsean10001]

He killed an american medic, shoot the little cunt and move on. Lifes a bitch people die... get over, everyone worries about khadar's rights. What about that medics right to live. Fuck em eye for an eye!

[Zitozu]

@meandcindy all's fair in war and love? lol, I didnt know you got tortured for 5 years for it.

[yeahoriginal]

poor kid, it musta been hell and he was only 15 :[

[RideMyBMW]

min 3:20 "Abdul Rama had always rebelled against his father refusing to get terrorist training"

Choices. Omar and Abdul.The former is an Al-K-da terrorist, the latter an American spy. Gotta know how to pick sides in life, boyz.

[Jagged85]

@RideMyBMW

Nonsense. Omar and Abdul. The former was a 15 year-old child, the latter a 20 year-old adult. Neither have ever been convicted of any crimes in any court of law. Gotta know how to use your brain, boy.

[RideMyBMW]

@Jagged85 "Omar and Abdul. The former was a 15 year-old child, the latter a 20 year-old adult."

min 3:20 "Abdul Rama had always rebelled against his father refusing to get terrorist training"

Choices, you fu%$in towelheads. Omar and Abdul.The former, an Al-K-da terrorist, the latter an American spy. Gotta know how to pick sides in life, ya dumb fu%$in sand nigz. Omar is now an admitted Islamic terrorist murderer and will spend his life headbutting his Kooran in prison. Harper was dead on!

[Jagged85]

@RideMyBMW

Like I said, learn to use your brain, boy. What part of "child" and "adult" don't you understand? I'm not surprised a right-wing extremist like yourself wouldn't be able to tell the difference. Hell, I wouldn't be surprised if a right-wing extremist like you one day becomes a terrorist and massacres a whole load of innocent children, like your fellow white-skinned right-wing Norwegian extremist friend...

[RideMyBMW]

@Jagged85 "I wouldn't be surprised if a right-wing extremist like you one day becomes a terrorist and massacres a whole load of innocent kids"

Click! Right on the mark you fu%$in sand nig! It took you exactly 24 h to pull the Olso card. Hey camel jock, listen up: min 3:20 "Abdul Rama had always rebelled against his father refusing to get terrorist training".

Does the word ALWAYS mean anything to you? That means Abdul ALWAYS HATED his fu%$in TERRORIST

father you sh$# for brains towel head!

[terfred]

Let him rot in prison ! No one in Canada wants him back .

[boondocksaint1968]

I hope Omar gets killed in prison , end of problem

[searchlight22]

Jesus Mary & Joseph,

It does not matter what he did. This KID was a child soldier when captured. The Canadian Gov. does not seek his release because they know he will sue us when he gets back here.

He was a brainwashed child when captured and has been jailed & tortured with the full knowledge of our Gov. & the US Admin. I hate what his family stands for, but I also know, my tax $'s will eventually be going to them.

Jesus Mary & Joseph !!!!!

[111RobinHood]

Ever since 9/11, the CIA and FBI have no proof that the 19 terrorists were involved and no proof that Al Quaeda were responsible. Why? Because it was all a fraud. This war on terrorism as stated by a CIA analyst was a hoax. America needs a scapegoat in order to pursue her political goal for a world American hegemony. America is the most belligerent and insidious nation on earth. Illegal invasions of Iraq/ Afghanistan, setting up of concentration camps, are all acts of crimes against peace.

[111RobinHood]

When Russia invaded Afghanistan, the CIA supported Islamic terrorist's groups, and helped them to get a foothold in Afghanistan! The CIA have always maintained contacts with terrorist groups and have used them for political purposes. In fact, most wars in the third world are created by the CIA. So if you want to point fingers at terrorism, know that the CIA is the most powerful and corrupt terrorist organization in the world. So please be aware of your hypocrisy.

[Normalman48]

Omar was sitting on a bench in the middle of the desert munching on a piece of roasted camel leg, when those nasty US soldiers shot Omar and took him to Cuba. Actually, he is a Bin Laden trained terrorist who was captured in a fire fight. He was shot in the battle, but the US saved his life. We do not want yet another trained terrorist in Canada. He should not be permittted to enter Canada.

His entire family should be deported.

[khashya786786]

cant agree wid u more

people r very narrow minded

they beleive wut the media tells them

y is it dat a muslims kills sum1 he is called a terrosist..n if a white soldier kills many innocent people, he is called a hero..not every1 in afganistan is a terrorist..many innocents children die everyday

i really hope Omar is brought to justice..

anyone who believes that its kk to toture a 15 year old boy..i curse them that they get treated with injustice 100 times more than Omar was!

[raynus1]

The whole Khadr family should be punted out of Canada ASAP.

Seditious low-life thugs.

[Melchersson]

The vindictive American criminals of war should stand trial at the Hague court! But sadly it will never happened! Can´t they see they destroy the foundations upon our democracy is built upon?

[terfred]

@Melchersson Omar kahdr will rot in jail for the rest of his life. Now if we could only deport the rest of this terrorist family from Canada.

The Muslim terrorists should also be tried at the Hague !!

[Melchersson]

@terfred Why does everyone thinks you take the side of the terrorists, when criticizing the Bush regime crimes! Fuck off with all of them! They nearly killed my mom and dad at 9/11!

[wasteofspace1234]

So:

The Khadrs are a family of terrorist and enemies of Canada, except for the brother. Omar is undoubtedly an enemy combatant. It doesn't matter if he was the one who threw the grenade. He's a prisoner of war. The thing that complicates it is that, technically, he's Canadian. He was borne in Canada, he is a traitor to Canada, and he need not be tried for war crimes. He ought to be tried for treason.

[floormonkeys]

I agree 100%. The rest is total, absolute bullshit meant to distract us from the truth of the matter, which you have stated wasteofspace1234

[bremenlegation]

sorry buck, but we arent animals like this little subhuman shitstain.

[0046aftonbladet]

I speak 5 languages! and have 2 university degrees. I did read your comments and I do not expect you to have understanding for anything i sad sipply cuz we are not at the same level. dont hate be happy ;) and try too read something it well do you good . Peace&love from Sweden

[0046aftonbladet]

Onormalman 50. you have the right mindset all us poor soldiers who have never done any harm, they have never shot against sicila no never shot against women on children against them poor soldiers they just go armed in any Annaland and are shot. And NO ruling does not create terrirism themselves o no. The whole world wants them to be there Yes. Nolamman = Zionist;)

[bremenlegation]

can you please learn to articulate a full sentence in english???

also where fuck is annaland and sicila?????

[0046aftonbladet]

annaland =

other country and sicila = civilians

I speak 5 languages! and have 2 university degrees. I did read your comments and I do not expect you to have understanding for anything i sad sipply cuz we are not at the same level. dont hate be happy ;) and try too read something it well do you good . Peace&love from Sweden

[0046aftonbladet]

?!?! he is only 15 than what he has done is he stil a child. Hmm wonder what well hapend if he was a 15 kid from us would kidnapas and imprisoned? wonder how people would react, "People are the most dangerous animal on this planet.

[Normalman50]

Poor Omar was just sitting on a bench chewing on a piece of roasted camel leg, and those bad US soldiers came by, shot him, and took him to Guantanamo.

You politically correct bleeding heart Canadians make me sick. "Oh", poor Omar, he's only a baby terrorist, he should not be punished "because he's a Canadian". What a bunch of crap.

[thenewrapstyle]

i won't, I'm not a terrorist. fuckface.

[PortugueseGina1]

you don't want to be Canadian when it's not convenient for you...now it's not convenient for us! see ya later terrorist!

[howie1962]

send him back to Canada but the testicles stay behind

[thenewrapstyle]

i like when he starts crying for mommy. lol

[xemraaaan]

o my God what kind of a sick saddist are you. how wd u feel if ur little brother is sitting there crying for mommy then wd u say LOL or wd u like it if someone else sees it and enjoys?? dnt forget that at the end of the day we are all humans and we shd not feel happy at the plight of others. there are conventions regarding the treatment of war prisoners and torturing a 15 yr old boy is nt honorable

[thenewrapstyle]

if my brother was an al qaida muslim islamist terrorist i would torture him myself. being from pakistan your country has supported al qaida, the taliban and global jihad for a long time. your nuke scientist also helped rogue regimes in north korea and iran obtain wmd's countries like that should never have. your country's nukes could fall into the hands of terrorists. so maybe you should worry a little less about this little shit and more about your own country.

[Normalman48]

Omar was just sitting at a bench at the local Oasis "munching on a piece of fried camel leg", when those bad US soldiers came by and shot him, and then took him away to Guantanamo.

[Normalman50]

Poor Omar was just sitting on a park bench sucking on a piece of roasted camel leg, and those bad American soldiers came by and threw granades at him. That is a terrible thing they did to Omar, shame on the US military.

[PortugueseGina1]

LOL hahaha this is funny!

[sypin]

Omar Kadhr is still imprisoned. His trial has been put on hold after General Thomas W. Hartmann embarrassingly allowed Omar's complete medical records available as well as documents suggesting omissions from the Combatant Status Review... this lead to the withdrawal of the eyewitness with a confession from Omar (wonder why).

I don't support Omar Khadr he should be detained then jailed when he's an adult- but his trial is a sick joke, Colenel Peter Brownback has proved that.

[JoePlaya87]

the world is fuckin up!

[JoePlaya87]

fuck that kid...he's an obama spawn!!

[Namari12]

joeplaya87.. what the hell are you talking about.

[JoePlaya87]

i met osama spawn...woops...

[JoePlaya87]

meant** ...im fuckin up lol

[Normalman50]

Set Omar free, but please don't send him back to Canada. His mother, sister, and brother are welfare sucking Muslims who support terrorism. We don't want Omar here to also go on Welfare.

[hamerah]

helmut, what are the candaian or other occuying forces doing in Afganistan, have any of these countries attacked america or canada? who exactuly are u, the bullies of world, torturing children, khadar was 15 years of age. what would u do if your home is attacked, your family members murdered? he wasn't not involved in anything, no proof. I hope the crimes your countries have committed against humanity at large come one day to haunt you.

[TheTruthHurtsYou]

Get your facts right hamerah before you look even sillier.

Khadr was not at his home nor were any of his family members with him at that time. In fact daddy was in Pakistan involved in other terrorist activity and mommy was back here in Canada sponging off the welfare system. Omar was in Afghansitan for one reason only and got caught.

BTW hamerah. what country are you from that has never fired a gun before?

[JJJadm]

noooooooooooo,american what have you become?You are the beast the prophet talked about.

[supaco0p05]

He was a child when captured & was in Afganistan at the behest of his father. He didn't have a choice. If he was brainwashed with anti-western bias by his father from a very early age, then his parents are the culprits not he. He is no different than the children living in cult compounds or the young American girl kidnapped and brainwashed by some weirdo. She was walking around in public covered from head to toe and never tried to escape. It is called "Stockholm Syndrome".. look it up.

.

[HelmutHedd]

How come these lefties never speak of shame concerning Canada's disgraceful conduct in the torture of Bill Sampson and the murder of Zahre Kazemi? Yet they have no problem attacking our ally over alleged treatment of one of our traitors based on nonsense they hear in the media.

[Katharsis2006]

Cool. Umm Why can't you look past "left" and "right", "conservative" or "liberal" bs. That's such a confined way of thinking. It's just a matter of justice. A fair trial! Are you against a fair trial in Canada for a Canadian citizen?? Forget the fact that he's a Canadian citizen... Are you against a fair trial? lol wtf. That is the basic right for any human being... According to International law OR the Canadian Charter of Rights.. Or even most religious scriptures.

[HelmutHedd]

Khadr was not in Canada. The Canadian charter does not apply.

As such, he is a POW. He should be held as long the conflict continues. POW's don't get trials.

Khadr was engaged in battle against a coalition containing Canadian troops. He qualifies as a traitor. Only leftist imbeciles would care about this shitstain on humanity's landscape.

[Katharsis2006]

How can people call him a terrorist without him even being convicted for any crimes as of yet. I hope those comments were not made by Canadians! A fair trial is necessary for this kid. A fair trial in Canada. I can't believe our government has sat by idly for this long. It's ridiculous! What the hell is Harper doing? This is not what Canada stands for. As the Supreme Court rules in May 2008, Ottawa is complicit in the abuse of Omar Khadr.

I am ashamed of my country.

[parkdale420]

FUCK YOU!! Let him rot where he lies...Little cocksucker!Canada doesn't want him!!

[Mystria]

ok first off they are not a family of terrorists. They defended their country when the soviets invaded and along with Osama bin Laden were funded by the USA, fought alongside US soldiers during that invasion and were supplied with the same guns they are using against the US and Canadian soldiers now...so why were they our allies then and terrosists now?

[HelmutHedd]

Of course they're not terrorists. They just played cards with Bin Laden and the rest. It was like a social club. Sometimes they played charades. Little Omar did a wonderful impression of Reagan. Idiot.

Oh, by the way, are the Khadrs 'Canadian' or not? Their background is also Pakistani, not Afghan. Last time I looked at a map Pakistan and Afghanistan were two different countries.

[Mystria]

Canadian and they have all the same rights as any other Canadian regardless of their country of orgin.

[HelmutHedd]

You said: "They defended their country when the soviets invaded and along with Osama bin Laden were..." Their original country was Pakistan, not Afghanistan. The family heritage was Pakistani, not Afghan. What part of that are you missing?

As Canadians, their Canadian rights are only valid when they are in Canada - he wasn't in Canada.

[HelmutHedd]

Khadr's father was actually Egyptian. The family bounced between Pakistan (for terrorist activities) and Canada (for health care paid for by people like me)

[HelmutHedd]

Go back to your bong and talking about yoga and Starbucks. Leave the involved topics to the adults.

[parkdale420]

Golf Clap....

[HelmutHedd]

Mystria: "...when the soviets invaded and along with Osama bin Laden were funded by the USA, fought alongside US soldiers during that invasion..."

How much weed do you smoke? US soldiers did not fight against the Soviets in the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan. FFS.

[Mystria]

ahh,personal attacks, the adult way of debating.Omar is Canadian He was 15 when he supposedly threw the grenade,and even if he did he was a child "soldier".Many Sudanese child soldiers were given a new start and refuge in the USA and Canada and are upstanding citizens. Why then the double standard in this conflict?And why are we breaking international law in order to do so? As for the US involvement they did all the training and supplied the weapons...check your facts HelmutHedd.

[HelmutHedd]

You tell me to check my facts after you stated that US soldiers fought in Afghanistan against the soviet invasion? Clue in.

[Mystria]

You still aren't responding to what really matters here...its ILLEGAL to hold a child "soldier" in a military prison. It is ILLEGAL to torture those held as POW's.

I'd LOVE to see the reaction to waterboarding if it was done to an American...and I'd bet you would hate it if ANY of the methods used to"gain information"were used on you.

There is NO ROOM for double standards in a democratic country.

That is the ultimate argument.

What do you have to say to that?

Are you a democratic hypocrite?

[HelmutHedd]

You assume that POWs are being tortured. As I said, awakening and moving Khadr during questioning was not torture. Got anything like, you know... proof. By the way, prisoners claiming to be tortured isn't proof...they have been known to lie, you know.

Read " Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights of the Child on the involvement of children in armed conflict". This UN document says nothing about not detaining unlawful combatants or where they can't be detained.

[HelmutHedd]

Waterboarding is done to some American military and espionage personnel as part of training in counter-terrorism and in case of capture by an enemy. This is commonly known. When will you tire of making yourself seem stupid and hopelessly uninformed?

[Mystria]

So you REALLY think that its the same when you are being waterboarded by your friends as it is when you are being waterboarded by people who invaded your country under false pretenses?Thats just crazy, people believe they are going to drown,they want people to believe they are about to die,have you ever read what it feels like to have water filling your mouth and nose,choking trying to catch a breath while youre yelled at to answer questions to be put under if you dont have the answer they want?

[HelmutHedd]

Waterboarding has been proven to be a relatively effective form of coercion. You may think lighting up a doobie and talking about their feelings might work with these people, but the people who actually question them don't. I suspect their knowledge of the subject is superior to yours. I'm also not as concerned as you are about the well-being of terrorists.

[Mystria]

What is with your weed smoking jabs? Would you like me to reflect what my imagination paints you out to be from your comments? I'm just stating what I feel is wrong with this situation, and you are stating your side. This is not personal, this is a life and a war and one situation that brought a 15 year old not only in the line of fire but in a prison that condones methods of "questioning" that I find unethical and debase for adults much less a 15 year old. You disagree.

so we agree to disagree

[HelmutHedd]

I'm not particularly concerned with what your imagination conjures up about me. I couldn't care less what you think.

It wasn't the United States or Canada that put this treacherous bastard in the line of fire. Remember that. He is a traitor to Canada and the Marines should have killed him on the spot. That would have been perfectly legal. Next time I hope they don't repeat their mistake. Kill the bastards on the field and cut down on the paperwork. It's better for the environment too.

[Katharsis2006]

I don't understand where idiots like you come from? That lack simple compassion for human life. I am sure you lack basic understanding, and comprehension of international humanitarian law, so here's some advice. Instead of forming your own opinions, it would be best for you to just follow what majority of respected human rights organizations say about these kinds of issues. Follow their reports, and may be you just might not seem like such an ignorant and arrogant fool.

[HelmutHedd]

Katharsis2006 - I don't understand how bleeding heart lefties agree with murdering the unborn while allowing brutal murderers to live and be released back into society. I don't understand how idiot lefties attacking Harper over Khadr said nothing about Canada's inactions regarding Bill Sampson's torture and Zahre Kazemi's murder.

You may be sure I lack an understanding of the legalities of the case.

Anytime you want to discuss the legalities - bring it on.

[Katharsis2006]

There is nothing to discuss.. But if you want to... Sure.

The legalities of trying a child soldier. Anyone that is under the age of 18 qualifies as a child soldier. He was 15. No child soldier has EVER been tried on an international level.

More legalities... Let's see... Ever heard of the concept of "innocent until proven guilty"? If we're talking about our legal system, then it rests on that very basic notion. And there are no exceptions to that. Yes.. Let's talk about legalities.

[givebirthathome]

Yes, we are not fighting for our lives against one unfortunate boy,dragged into a war zone by his family, and reportedly subjected to being used bodily as a brush to wipe up excrement. As a Ron Paul supporter, I don't think I count as a "bleeding heart liberal" and I object very much to my gov't funding the kind of sadism Khadr was subjected to, which is a bigger threat to our republic than terrorism.

[Mystria]

UN convention on the rights of the child state that under international law a child soldier accused of war related crimes must not be held in an adult facility unless no option is available in the short term but then must be moved when possible....so the US had to put him in Guantanamo because there was no othe ropening other than a base in Cuba of all places...?

[HelmutHedd]

I have the document in another window as I write this. It says nothing about keeping alleged child soldiers in an 'adult facility'. But hey, never let the truth get in the way of a good myth. By the way, Khadr is 21 now.

[Mystria]

he was 15 when he was captured...the fact that hes 21 now has no weight in the issue other than the fact his righs have been trampled for 6 years.

[HelmutHedd]

I'll tell you whose rights are being trampled - mine and other Canadians whose country and tax dollars are being used by this shitstain on humanity's landscape.

The fact that your heart is bleeding over Khadr doesn't mask the fact that you've come up with nothing to prove the claims you make. Much of the nonsense you've written is false and fictional. Your knowledge of history is almost non-existent. I don't care about your 'feelings' - I care about my country and the people that serve it.

[parkdale420]

I feel like standing for the national anthem...OHHH CAAAANAAAADAAAA....LOL Good point!Fuck this little CUNT!!His family should be eating cockmeat sammiches too!!

[Mystria]

The double standard of sanctioning waterboarding, freezing temperatures, sleep deprivation for POW's when these methods would be shut down if they tried passing these to "break" a suspected murderer in the US...and its stupid in the first place, any information is completely unreliable. I'd lie my ass off to get out of any situation like those they use to garner intel. The proof is in convicted murderers who "confessed" under sleep deprivation and were exonerated through DNA evidence.

[HelmutHedd]

Khadr wasn't sleep deprived. He was awakened and moved every three hours during interrogations. There is a distinction here. You haven't got anything right yet - do you intend to ever actually cite something that is accurate?

[Mystria]

you may not think being moved every 3 hours is sleep deprivation but I and many others would if put in that situation.

[HelmutHedd]

You're really reaching here. It isn't sleep deprivation and even if it was, it doesn't qualify as torture. In my line of work, I've functioned for days with less sleep than Khadr received.

[parkdale420]

Well...If you kill someone maybe you should lose some sleep!LOL

[FuckNewbs]

FAG , NEWB , NIGGER , CUNT , PRICK , YOU PROB FUCK YOUR MOM SUCK YOUR DADS DICK DIG UP GRAVES AND FUCK DEAD FAMILY MEMBERS

Mystria there u go i attacked 4 u :P

[xkhbvc]

Wow Americans are such fags, a person defends his freedom, rights, family and country and hes called a terrorist for fighting back? Soldiers are taught to expect death american nazis so don't be like "OMG he killed a soldier! Kill him already omg!" America caused most of the shit thats going on this world, an example is bombing Japan, which killed way more than the bomb in pearl harbour. So american are not terrorists? Wow what fags

[HelmutHedd]

Khadr was supposedly a Canadian citizen, he wasn't a citizen of Afghanistan. He was fighting against a coalition of nations, including Canada, engaged in Afghanistan.

One thing he was not fighting for was Canada's freedoms and rights. You are misinformed, he was fighting against them. He was fighting for religious tyranny and the brutal oppression of people (especially women)in Afghanistan.

[Katharsis2006]

If indeed he was fighting against them then sure, let's give him a fair trial? lol... Wtf's wrong with you? You don't believe in the right to a fair trial for someone? Go live under some tyrannical government then. You'll be more at home there. Have you no faith in our legal system.. I'm pretty sure you're not Canadian.. but we have a pretty good system here. All I'm saying is he should be repatriated back to Canada, followed by a fair trial. Why're you so vehemently opposed to this?

[HelmutHedd]

I don't think Khadr should get a trial anywhere at this time.

He is a POW and was a child-soldier. The US is bound by two things regarding his detention: 1)Geneva POW Conventions and 2)Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights of the Child on the involvement of children in armed conflict(UN). The US can hold him until the conflict ends.

To summarize, the Geneva Conventions provide rules for his detention. The UN protocol is easily obtainable on-line and a short read.

[FuckNewbs]

FAGGET

[barilko5551]

Bullshit.....the murdering islamic prick was a young man - hes a murderer plain and simple - he took a life yet his was saved - tells you something doesnt it? Screw him and his family - most canadians (i am one) DO NOT want this bastard brought bach here - i want him to rot somewhere other this this country - and take his moronic islamic sister too! God Bless America

[dredragon7]

YESSS that fucker deserves to burn in hell. The only reason why people are fighting for him to be released is because hes canadian if it was some iraqi people would say he deserves to die. fucking hypocrites

[Mystria]

If he was an Iraqi child "soldier" I'd be just as angry.

What suprises me is that a country that prides itself on spreading humanitarian ideals, truth and the American way will throw all that away because they are scared. Ideals are meant to be held onto regardless of fear, the government sanction of torture offshore in Guantanamo flies in the face of everything fought for by the American people.

right now America is a country that removes the rights of its people and people around the world.

[hammadthegreat]

i guess u put the nukes dug into ur pants near ur ass, be carefull, it cn explode anytym.

[RiAlGoVa]

What is the difference about John Phillip Walker Lindh: 27 yrs, captured in 2001, Sentenced to 20 yrs in 2002 (only 1 year after he was captured); eligible for release in 17 years and waiting for a Presidential commutation to lower his twenty year sentence; in a medium-security prison, and this guy: 22, captured in 2002, after 6 yrs he is still waiting for judgement in Guantanamo famous for human rigths violations?

Sure John Phillip Walker Lindh is an american-born white guy. Sorry Omar.

[hammadthegreat]

n secondly there is some serious "brain washing american citizens" by western media goin in the US

[parkdale420]

Then how do you explain my opinion?I am Canadian and think this shit stain should rot where he is!

[FuckNewbs]

CUZ U PROB WATCH FOX NEWS ALSO

[hammadthegreat]

an innocent 15 yr old killed a fully armed soldier.

i didnt know such poor medication goes in USA to make americans metaly fit.

[jbm8312]

He wasn't innocent you dumbass. He killed the soldier with a grenade! If he was old enough to go through the Taliban's terrorist training then he was old enough to pay the consequences for his actions. He's lucky he even made it out alive, he should've been shot on site.

[UnreleasedWKR]

So he killed a soldier, big deal! There are far more worse cases than his. It wasn't like he chose to be in terrorist training. You must understand that he is only 15 when he through the grenade, which means he was a minor. Think of it at the age of 15 you still have your whole life ahead of you. People can always change.

[adlerbr12]

the entire khadr family should be asked to get out of Canada, does of you who are asking for this jack asses release should go and live in Afghanistan for a few months and see how you are welcomed,he is part of a terrorist family and he will be treated that way. and so he should, his mother said on the radio that she would be proud of her kids if they would be suicide bomber and die to become marders,

what a sweet woman,there is an eye witness to his crime and he will punished, good for us

[parkdale420]

Riiight!LOL A fire "fight" So uhhh don't you think if he had the chance he would have killed the people against him?This is why WAR doesn't work anymore..Always some dummys saying..Oh the poor ENEMY!Fuck the enemy!!They Die We Live!!

[laylanjoy]

What a shame! Those countries declare themselves to be lands of freedom and human rights!! Bullshit!! He didn't have a trial yet!!!

[parkdale420]

Hey no problem...This little shit stain needs to rot where he lies.I would hope he doesn't make it back to Canada EVER!!Hope he gets a cock-meat sammich too..LOL

[bbbbbrianC]

Keep the SOB where he is, he wasn't a crying p***y when he killed that soilder, if he wants to cry now like a B***H!!! to bad... FEEL NO PITTY FOR THIS MURDERER and all the other murderers like him. 15 or 50 a terrorist is only that, a terrorist... don't hide behind age... if he gets out he will only do more harm or feed others to do the same

[TeaPlz]

its not a matter of whether or not he shouldn't be punished for his crime. yes he killed the American soldier, but he's a Canadian not an American. if he is to be punished let be by a fair trial in Canada, and not laughable farse of a trail he world get at that american concentration camp.

[NicNat22]

So upsetting.

[HelmutHedd]

Sleep deprivation isn't torture - enduring left-wing stupidity is.

[Mystria]

you try moving cells every 3 hours and be alone all the time except for your jailers...I bet you'd cry like a baby after a week...he did it for months and was alone for years. You like to think its easy so you can justify it as not being cruel, but it is, and youd say it was if they did it to you.

and he was just 15 when they started torturing him, thats illegal under international law and charges should be brought against the US government for war crimes.

[HelmutHedd]

It was illegal that he was on the battlefield. It wasn't the Americans who put him there. That's why they judged his status as 'unlawful combatant' and have held him at Gitmo. There's no question that killing him on the battlefield is legal - next time they won't make the same mistake.

Being moved every three hours isn't torture. It hasn't been done for his entire captivity either. Try learning some facts.

This left-wing stupidity is torturous. You're a war-criminal.

[Mystria]

I said MONTHS not his entire captivity...but he was alone without contact with any family or friends for 6 years...just his lawyer when he got one that is.

its not about left wing or right wing...its about international law being broken, and the fact remains that he was 15 and it was illegal to have put him in Guatanamo in the first place.

[HelmutHedd]

He was an unlawful combatant-he shouldn't have been on the battlefield. The US treated him as a POW, which he was. Under the child-soldiers protocols, the United States obligation was to try to rehabilitate him. Prove that they weren't. To rehabilitate him the US had to detain him- what else could they do?

[Mystria]

prove that they were trying to rehabilitate him...sorry cant be done because they dident.

Detaining and rehabilitation could have been done in a facility better equiped for a child soldier than Guantanamo.

[HelmutHedd]

Rehabilitation takes time. Rehabilitation isn't always successful. Most people in jail are repeat offenders. Khadr was thoroughly indoctrinated by Al Qaeda and was a willing participant. No doubt he would be resistant - he did betray his own country.

When did you visit Gitmo? What are you basing your judgement of the facility on? The media?

You demand 'innocent until proven guilty' for a treacherous terrorist yet do not give the same to the United States. You've proven nothing.

[MGFFMM]

Fuck you to...stupid American

[parkdale420]

Fuck this little cocksucker!!What about the guy who was blown apart from a grenade??As a Canadian I think this little bastard should die for killing an American.

[DeadCatX2]

And I'm proud to be an American, where I know we use torture. And I won't forget the men who died, to fight a war of lies. And I'll gladly stand up, next to Bush, and defend him still today. Cause there ain't no doubt I have no soul...God Bless The U-S-A....

[MGFFMM]

If you really believe that an aeroplane crush agains the Penthagon....and disappear ...keep hidden the true.

Good Luck...but please God save us from these Us people

[windmillcrusader]

Poor kid, just because he hangs with a posse, kills two soldiers and then he throws a grenade and kills another, he shouldn't be treated like that. He should get a nice bed, 77 virgins, the whole 9 yards.

[goingjapanese]

Judging by the bullet holes in his chest, he's not the only killer that was there at the time.

[fatt1966]

this kid isnt canadian at all!we dont want him back in canada!shoot him or hang him now!

[Mystria]

poor kid should never have been put in jail, much less Guantanamo. He is a child soldier if anything, and all child soldiers have rights and protections signed by the US, so what makes Omar different than a child soldier from Sudan or any other recent conflict area? This whole situation is sick, he could have been treated like a child at 15 and have graduated high school by now back in Canada where he belongs.

release our son.

[goingjapanese]

He's a solider, not a 'child soldier', and it doesn't matter if he threw a grenade or not. Don't people have the right to defend themselves from a foreign invader?

[Mystria]

He was a child under international law, and all people have a right to defend themselves against a forign invader, but in this case he was forign too as he is a Canadian...none the less it is the country his parents were born in and he has family that live there too.

[jbg42]

Great posting.