I am with Ameer ul Momineen Mullah Umer. Obeying Ameer is in Islam. If Ameer says stop fighting against Pakistani Army then they should do as Ameer says. Although the partner and those who are in the favor of Jews and Christians are just like them even though they call themselves Muslim, still since it's order of Ameer that is why one shan't attack the Pakistanin Army.
I am amazed fromwhere they got this guy, he knows nothing about pashtun culture. Pashtuns people are living on a very vast land and great peoples, respect others and wish to respect them. what he is saying is just his own imagination or for the sack of PHD , making things complicated, for those whom pashtuns society is complex, i invite just come and see how simple and innocent they are.Nope they are absolutely not complicated peoples, just follows pashtunwali
Im shocked that this guy is doing his PHD in pashtoon identity where as he doesn't know nething about pashtoons alot, i think ppl like him who r educated pashtoons or so they call themselves give a more fucked up image of pashtoons den what america has shown to it's ppl to brainwash them becoz at the end of the day they r americans dey can think watever dey want it won't change pashtoon culture or history at all but ppl like this guy gives a clear image of how pashtoon can change gradually
Another very complicated view from a Pashtun researcher on the Dynamics of Taliban, their relationship with Al Qaeeda, the Pashtun code of Honour Pashtunwali.
A view on:
1- How Osama might have violated the code by abusing Melastiya (hospitality) by being a guest and attacking a foreign country without the consent of hosts.
2- How ISI, Pakistani Army, CIA and other rest of world combined agaisnt communism to create a fundamentalist (may be extremist) band of Pashtuns (called Taliban) which was injected with the middle eastern philosophy of hard line Islamist like Syed Qutub Shaheed (oen of the pioneers of Akhwal-ul-Muslimoon, Egypt)
3- Should a certain party or group be blamed or is the current state of affairs (regarding Taliban, Al-Qaeeda, USA and their complex relationship with Pakistan) a historical move spread over decades where Pashtuns are mainly the exploited party rather than being aggressors by nature and wild by birth.
No, he's not retarded but, apparently, I am. There were a number of terms or names of groups that I would not have been able to properly comprehend had they not been in print form. So, please continue using English subtitles.
The Real News remains one of the last sources of true no spin Journalism -- in depth, informative, fact driven, multifaceted, exposing various points of view. Thank you REAL NEWS - Thank you.
@nadialejandra Thts what hes saying!
greencl0th 1 month ago
Yes they do.
FKhorasani87 4 months ago
8:33 , it isnt Mullah Omar but Mullah Dadullah
adrianalimalover 10 months ago
I am with Ameer ul Momineen Mullah Umer. Obeying Ameer is in Islam. If Ameer says stop fighting against Pakistani Army then they should do as Ameer says. Although the partner and those who are in the favor of Jews and Christians are just like them even though they call themselves Muslim, still since it's order of Ameer that is why one shan't attack the Pakistanin Army.
Waqarahmedkhattak 1 year ago
may Allah make the mujahideen victorious!!!! ameen!!
alleya619 1 year ago
I am amazed fromwhere they got this guy, he knows nothing about pashtun culture. Pashtuns people are living on a very vast land and great peoples, respect others and wish to respect them. what he is saying is just his own imagination or for the sack of PHD , making things complicated, for those whom pashtuns society is complex, i invite just come and see how simple and innocent they are.Nope they are absolutely not complicated peoples, just follows pashtunwali
ryanzafar 1 year ago
@ryanzafar ...true..i guess hez been rsearching through books written by the western ppl.
MrEseskay 8 months ago
i did not understand a thing!could you do similar show with an interpreter
jahmoma 1 year ago
Im shocked that this guy is doing his PHD in pashtoon identity where as he doesn't know nething about pashtoons alot, i think ppl like him who r educated pashtoons or so they call themselves give a more fucked up image of pashtoons den what america has shown to it's ppl to brainwash them becoz at the end of the day they r americans dey can think watever dey want it won't change pashtoon culture or history at all but ppl like this guy gives a clear image of how pashtoon can change gradually
2fan 1 year ago
@2fan What do you know of pashtuns? Are you pashtun
greencl0th 1 month ago
porkistan is real probem
121naimat 1 year ago
junaid is full of shit
AFGHANVIEW 2 years ago
great uppload thx
Pokhton 2 years ago 2
Another very complicated view from a Pashtun researcher on the Dynamics of Taliban, their relationship with Al Qaeeda, the Pashtun code of Honour Pashtunwali.
A view on:
1- How Osama might have violated the code by abusing Melastiya (hospitality) by being a guest and attacking a foreign country without the consent of hosts.
OLIVERTWOHORSE 2 years ago
2- How ISI, Pakistani Army, CIA and other rest of world combined agaisnt communism to create a fundamentalist (may be extremist) band of Pashtuns (called Taliban) which was injected with the middle eastern philosophy of hard line Islamist like Syed Qutub Shaheed (oen of the pioneers of Akhwal-ul-Muslimoon, Egypt)
OLIVERTWOHORSE 2 years ago
3- Should a certain party or group be blamed or is the current state of affairs (regarding Taliban, Al-Qaeeda, USA and their complex relationship with Pakistan) a historical move spread over decades where Pashtuns are mainly the exploited party rather than being aggressors by nature and wild by birth.
OLIVERTWOHORSE 2 years ago
911 was an inside job just look at wtc7 the command center
poodleinsky 2 years ago
webster tarpley has a better grasp on this topic.if anyone is interested.
taxisgay12 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
The taliban don't represent pashtuns.
But the pashtuns both benefit from and are harmed by the taliban
BeondaPale 2 years ago
nah, that dude had a really thick accent. I agree, keep the sub-titles :)
robertinrinrin 2 years ago
Glad they put translation there. His accent was pretty tough to understand at certain points.
GetTheCans 2 years ago 8
Next time don't put the English translation on the screen. He's not retarded!
RemiG2006 2 years ago
No, he's not retarded but, apparently, I am. There were a number of terms or names of groups that I would not have been able to properly comprehend had they not been in print form. So, please continue using English subtitles.
1140Cecile 2 years ago 5
Good stuff.
joshv89 2 years ago 2
the taliban don't represent pashtuns
sapaha39 2 years ago
As always excellent interview Real News!
The Real News remains one of the last sources of true no spin Journalism -- in depth, informative, fact driven, multifaceted, exposing various points of view. Thank you REAL NEWS - Thank you.
prayfortruejustice 2 years ago 5
Great interview!
educution 2 years ago 2
The Taliban terrorists are pashtuns !!
FardinFaryadTv 2 years ago