Truth and Origins of the Israeli / Palestinian Conflict

[saraheliz27]

I recommend you watch the movie "Promises", no matter who's side you look at it from there is tremendous loss, and this conflict is a catastrophe thats been going on for over 1300 years, the world needs to focus on peace for these nations, not who is to blame.

[makesyoumadd]

@saraheliz27 I agree with you 50%...

In order to find a solution, we must identify the problem. ONE SIDE doesn't want peace. Until the Palis want peace, they will make war. As long as they're doing that, there will be war.

[kodiak08zodiac]

Go Israel Go India is with you A billion Indians are with you...........bomb those arab shit heads to the grave........

[mrpalestineunited]

@sweetsami, Its not that the jews earned there right to live in PALESTINE. Its that they had nowhere else to go. And its mainly the European Jews that are commiting horrible crimes, such as using and denying the use of white phosphorous, minipulation of the governent, constant lies, aparthied, and the murder of the killing of an arms smugler of hamas, and yet again the lie and denial of it. The Jews are being tormented for a reason. They were destroyed in soduam and gahmorah, and will b destroyd

[makesyoumadd]

RE: "the European Jews are commiting horrible crimes such as using and denying the use of white phosphorous..."

a) Israel does not deny using White Phosphorous in Gaza.

b) Which is worse--an inaccurately fired Qassam, or an accurately fired WP? Pali militants have no idea where their rocket will impact or where it impacted. IDF carefully selects and plans each target, and observes each burst. They know exactly where the round will burst before they fire it.

[mrpalestineunited]

test

[samer7050]

palestain is arabic

[makesyoumadd]

Then why don't the Palestinians go to an Arab country? Before 1900, there weren't an Arabs (or Palis) in "Palestine."

They could go to Lebanon, or better yet, Jordan or Syria. Why do they have to occupy Jewish land?

[maxfedor1]

@makesyoumadd From Time Immemorial: The Origins of the Arab-Jewish Conflict over Palestine. when a number of scholars examined the book carefully, they concluded that it was of no scholarly value whatsoever. It ignores important parts of the documentary record, misuses the sources on which it does rely, and contains straightforward logical errors. Consequently, according to Menetrez, "Peters book has been rejected as worthless by the scholarly community around the world, including Israel"

[maxfedor1]

@makesyoumadd i dont expect you to post my comment cause the truth is your greatest enemy. I will refute your claims with scholarly work. Please show the same courtesy and refute my claims not with right wing propoganda but with true scholarly historic fact.

[makesyoumadd]

@maxfedor1

1) Good job mate! You copy/pasted your "argument" straight from Amazon book reviews.

2) Unfortunately for your argument, and if you had read the video description, this movie isn't based on or related to the book you're criticizing. No relation at all.

3) You haven't refuted anything; you haven't claimed anything. All you've done is yell something like "Liar! You're a liar, prove me wrong!"

[maxfedor1]

@makesyoumadd know its called using sources to back up my claims and not just relying on my opinion. And i was replying to your comment that there was no arabs in Palestine pre 1900. Secondly on your opinion of hamas rockets, goto to bt selem website and please tell me how many israeli's have been killed in last 10yrs from Qassam rockets.

[makesyoumadd]

@maxfedor1 Once again, you were critiquing a book that I didn't quote. You can copy and paste all the book reviews from Amazon to my video... I haven't read this book, nor have I heard of it. I didn't reference it.

If you want to discuss this video, or if you want to raise issues with this video, feel free to do so. Until you can do so intelligently, and without plagiarizing, stay away from my video.

[maxfedor1]

@makesyoumadd Because i agree with self proclaimed zionist Richard Goldstone that makes me anti semetic. That arguement is so lame. iam not anti semetic iam for all countries in the world to follow international law. Plain and simple. Iam against the bombing of ambulances, hospitals, mosques, synagogues and innocent people. Both Israel and Palestine are guilty. read human rights documents, israel's actions outnumber palestinians actions grossly

[makesyoumadd]

@maxfedor1 No, "Israel's actions" don't "outnumber palestinians actions grossly."

You call national defense "a human rights violation," while turning a blind eye to those of the pali's.

Believe it or not, Israel wants peace. Unfortunately, the pali militants are likely to make this dream impossible.

[phillipgaley]

@maxfedor1 Are you ignoring the facts that, the militant Pals. impose their will upon weak minds, thus gaining suiciders—when they themselves would not die, so? You're in ignorance of the commonly known fact that, as rocket launch points, the militants use schools, hospitals, and other facilities of humanitarian concern? These things you're well aware of—and, I'm curious concerning your rationale in justification for lack of sense of personal honor in the Palestinian militants.

[sweetsami789]

Its so sad that you guys are you using religion to justify hatred...Religion was meant to provide toleration and peace. This world is comming to an end, I dont know if I want my children to live in a world like this full of hatred, hipocracy. I dont think my husband and I are going to have kids...I am muslim, my husband Chrisitan. We are both american and my husband is in the army and I also teach him to be tolerant and to be open minded. Never hate anyone based on skin color, faith, ethnicity.

[modelfan1979]

Good point. Religion shouldn't be used to teach hatred. It is a shame that so many mosques are used to spew hatred and promote violence.

[Siilasvuo]

Arab leaders hate Isarel not for what it sometimes do bad but for all the things Israel makes well. Israel is everything the Arab nations have failed to achieve - a functioning democracy that offers its citizens a good life. Arab leaders want the conflict to continue because it diverts attention from the poverty, corruption and inequality of their own countries.

[BobbyFuckingSteele]

@Siilasvuo

Good point. The Arab leaders live in palaces while the people live like dogs. Then, the leaders tell the stupid people that their misery is because of THE JEWS.

Of course, todays DemoKKK-Rat party appears to haev similar aspirations - to bring back a feudal/plantation society where the Pelosi's/Reids live royally and we all beg for an aspirin.

[usenetposts]

Very good work. I salute you.

[Choccie124]

Why do people CHOSE to persecute Jews? I don't see what they have done. Being only 13 I have a lot to learn, but will someone kindly elaborate this fact to me. By this video I have learnt that the Arabs are greedy people who are desperate for power and 'Their Land' and the Jews just wanted somewhere to go. But everyone (well most people) are saying this video is bad....Any Help Humans?

[0e0l7i]

because Jews are clever and muslims believe they are allowed to kill jews and christians

[sweetsami789]

well what makes jews and christians allowed to kill christians...do you know when the Russian Jews immigrated to united states they were persecuted and even lynched by the christians...It can all be argued...There is nothing that justifies the killing of innocent people...Nothing...This world is full of hipocracy and its so frustrating to see it this way...This needs to change..all we are doing is seperating everybody..We are now the new generation and we need to make a change

[BobbyFuckingSteele]

@sweetsami789

sadly - you show the ignorance that Islam creates.

"what makes Christians and Jews allowed to kill Christians?" Is this what you were actually taught - that only Muslims are banned from killing, while Christians can legally kill ?

If you would remove the veil, and look around you, you'd soon see that it is Muslims who are perpetrating hate, and the best you do is defend it, because people who were far less educated in olden days, and who wised up in modern times had done the same.

[sweetsami789]

This video is right in the fact that palestine was never a declared country that the Romans were the ones that named this area Palestine but its wrong in the fact that it brings about a very biased opinion and its completely one sided. I think a good solution would be a one state but with EQUAL rights to both the palestinian and jews. Its unfair to kick the jews out...whats going on is not right...there are so many innocent people dying in the name of religion.Religion was meant for Peace

[1harmonyrockengine]

instead of being racist and religious lets be communist for humanity sake......

thats all i can say, watched horrible sins of nazi watched inhuman crimes of isareli soldier,watched kids blowing themselves off in israel,,,,who u say is right ,,everybody can argue and give evidence favoring ownself,but this humanity crisis in world can be addressed only through one world one dream and one love,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

[braintnt]

Its a fact that where ever you dig in Israel, you will only find Jewish antiquities. The land produces only Jewish heritage

The damned shrine of Satan that is built on top of the Jewish temple must come down. The abomination must not stand on holy land, it must come down and the Jewish temple be built again.

[asunagullo]

Congratulations makesyoumad, a fantastic video, it destroys all the stupid ideas about a Palestinian state, how bad Jews are and how cute and tender are poor palestinians. The world doesn't know the real history, because our biased media, brainwashes people. We have to say with clear and loud voice Arabs don't have the so called Plaestian state because of Arab's greed, they wanted all. Arabs deny reality, they go on saying they will reconquer my country 500 years after we expelled them.

[Basiltheking]

The palestinians were offerd a state under the conditions that SETTLEMENTS CONTINUE, AND THEY GIVE UP THEIR HOMES IN JERUSALEM AND ESSENTIALLY THEIR LIVES IN THE HOLY LAND. way to leave out facts Asshole. Horrible video

[nazareneson37]

you are wrong. in 99 barak offered arafat 90% or so of the west bank and gaza without settelments and blew his bluff!!! he had no intention of recognising Israel. I know from my arab neighbors that in arab culture you tell lies that suit you untill you belive them... the state of israel has done its fair share of dirty tricks but if you compare they come out much better than the arabs. the arab nation spreads from iraq to marroco , give us some space.

[kooger06]

no one could promise a peoples land to another people

[aprilapril1234]

The Ten Commandments; You shall not kill, Neither shall you steal. Neither shall you desire your neighbours house, or field, or male or female slave, or ox, or donkey, or anything that belongs to your neighbour.

[asunagullo]

Upps I guess that Muslims have not heared about it.. you kill and kill and kill, and terrorize people and steal people's peace and land by occupying our countries and trying to impose your dirty culte on us.

[walnutwally]

Well dude I suggest u read history. There is no such thing as Palestinian race or culture. In fact the word Palestine comes from Philistine of Greek origin. Current occupants in Palestine are from other Arab states. Whereas Jews have been in Israel 3000 yrs ago.But most importantly never curse Israel as it God's chosen nation. Hitler failed, Arabs failed wht does that tell u? Peace.

[Basiltheking]

I suggest YOU read history the palestinians because all of your facts are varrifiably wrong. Palestinians have settled these lands for 3,000 years since the exit of jews to europe. More importantly there is a Palestinian Race and culture . Who are you to declare israel as gods chosen nation. Israelis need to stop trying to get the last word and just support peace WERE BOTH SIDES ARE SATISFIED

[asunagullo]

Jews never "exit" to Europe, some did, some stayed in what today is Israel, the old land of the Hebrew, some stayed in what today are Muslim countries in which they have lived for more than 2000 years, until YOU expelled them.Not only you need to read but to study a bit: there is not a Palestinian race; What a stupidity!!!! or culture (to start with there is no culture at all in those lands), the so called Palestinians are Egyptians or Jordans, all the same race.... same bigotry & same hate.

[AnUntoldChapter]

Poor zionazi

I do pity for your retard mindset

Palestinians = Canaanites

In the Hebrew Bible, the "Land of Canaan" extends from Lebanon southward across Gaza to the "Brook of Egypt" and eastward to the Jordan River Valley

There was no such country name Jordan .

[AnUntoldChapter]

Archaeologic and genetic data support that

Palestinians came from the ancient Canaanites

who extensively mixed with Egyptians, Mesopotamian and

Anatolian peoples in ancient times. Thus, Palestinian-

Jewish rivalry is based in cultural and religious, but not in

genetic, differences. The relatively close relatedness of both

The owner of the video filtering my comments and rating so guess who is lying in his part

[makesyoumadd]

I think you mean something like "muslim archaeologists and geneticists believe that......"

Your list of favorites reveals your racism towards Jewish people.

[AnUntoldChapter]

Muslim archaeologists and geneticists hahahaha

Well i don't know If they lie like zionists archaeologists and geneticists in their part of stories hhahahaha

no muslim sources read it LIAR

The Origin of Palestinians and Their

Genetic Relatedness With Other

Mediterranean Populations

Antonio Arnaiz-Villena, Nagah Elaiwa, Carlos Silvera,

Ahmed Rostom, Juan Moscoso,

Eduardo Gómez-Casado, Luis Allende, Pilar Varela,

and Jorge Martínez-Laso

[makesyoumadd]

Did you know that archaeologists in Yemen were tearing down an old mosque. In the attic they discovered a Koran from 700-800 AD. It was very, very different than the Koran that you read every day.

[akhan62]

mahmoud abbas is an assole who works for u guys false again isreal always broke the peace deal and killed yizak rabin before he could give a independant country dont for get muslims always saved ur asses before getting kicked by the christians and u guys in return stabbed us and spread hatred about muslims in ur media

[salarocker]

and guess wat...that applies to any bible,torrah or wateva have you...

[kambridge967]

Are you serious what makes the quran that they found 700-800 ad so diffrent from the one today plz tell me.

[makesyoumadd]

In 1972, during the restoration of the Great Mosque of Sanaa, laborers stumbled upon a mountain of parchment, paper, damaged books and individual pages of Arabic text, fused together 1300 yrs of rain and dampness. They found thousands of early Koranic verses and manuscripts far older than the present Koran. Moreover, these manuscripts are written in a script that originates from the Hijaz—the region where Mo lived, which makes them the earliest authentic copies of the Koran ever.

[maxfedor1]

@makesyoumadd Reviewing the book for the November 28, 1985 issue of The New York Times, Israeli historian Yehoshua Porath described the book as a "sheer forgery," adding that "[i]n Israel, at least, the book was almost universally dismissed as sheer rubbish except maybe as a propaganda weapon."

[makesyoumadd]

@maxfedor1

1) you only need to post your anti-semitic spam once.

2) I wasn't quoting from a book.

3) This copy/paste job off of Amazon's book review section doesn't prove anything. All it shows is that one Israeli historian disagrees with a book not related to this video.

Try again.

[maxfedor1]

@makesyoumadd Reviewing the book for the November 28, 1985 issue of The New York Times, Israeli historian Yehoshua Porath described the book as a "sheer forgery," adding that "[i]n Israel, at least, the book was almost universally dismissed as sheer rubbish except maybe as a propaganda weapon."

[maxfedor1]

@makesyoumadd Reviewing the book for the November 28, 1985 issue of The New York Times, Israeli historian Yehoshua Porath described the book as a "sheer forgery," adding that "[i]n Israel, at least, the book was almost universally dismissed as sheer rubbish except maybe as a propaganda weapon."

[Greyshark09]

There are significant genetic differences between Palestinian arabs and Judeans. Genetic maps of local populations show about 50-60% of identity between Bedouns and Palestinians, thus making them the most arabized population outside arabia. Farther more Galilean arabs Haplotype is identical the one of arab tribes in the vicinity of S'naa, and another in Algeria - proving a Qahtani migration from Yemen to Israel. It is well known Palestinians are mixed people, but mostly pure arabs.

[ye32]

AnUntoldChapter

How could "genetic data support that

Palestinians came from the ancient Canaanites..."??

Do we have DNA samples from the Cnaanites???

NO!!!

You are just another ignoratnt liar.

[Adilgz]

Dumbass isreali nation

[jeff14463]

the truth hurts mate

[MayTheJew]

good job

[MayTheJew]

good job .

[MayTheJew]

nice job !!!

[MrsDoGood2]

watch?v=WfVeG64LXKY

[sleadhead420]

if they are fucking lies then whats the truth.how much land do you usless fucking habebs need over their

[ramzauno]

well I guess the Nazi knew things that we don't know......

[BenfWalker]

Wait a sec.. I never actually figured this out, but why do people hate Jews so much? Especially Muslims. What is the history there? Also if so many people didn't want Israel to exist, then why did everyone let them migrate into that territory? Anyone can message me, because I'd really like to know the details.

[vballstar5]

Amazing Video!

[dffs0029]

Nice vid man!!!

[ZeroShift5000]

awesome job on debunking liberal and Islamic lies!!

[DigitalCodex]

good video