NIN - Sin (Live Kroq 2005)

[TyphoonHubert]

@ScotteDio Trent is just more muscular as an adult. He's not fat!

[ScotteDio]

Trent looks fat.

[Rockyeeful]

Love this song! Made a cover with my band :D Check my channel!

[TwinkleStarsXo]

He's so delicious, and amazing. :)

[NELLA1680]

I really don´t care what do you think, but for me Trent looks better than ever since TDS era... DID YOU SE THAT BODY??? OMG!!!!!!

[Orsidire]

One word: BADASS!

[kittykatt12321]

I don't get people calling Trent "fat"...have you seen those guns?

[Smola666]

One of the best concerts in With Teeth Era. Absolutely hilarious !

[Wortoncho]

Amazing



[digenovafilm]

Is the whole thing lip-synched? Just askin'. 

[samuelguk49]

@digenovafilm no, the vieo is just poorly ripped that the audio become slightly slower than the image you see

[Schwang17]

I don't give a shi* what Trent looks like...the dude just runs it...

[KornOil]

that fag guitar player is a one trick pony.

[KradProductions]

@KornOil I bet that "fag" has had sex with more women in the past month than you will in the next decade.

[KornOil]

@KradProductions Oh, no! Here we go, let's make stuff up with absolutely no basis. Come up with something better, scrub. I apologize if I angered you by making fun of your favorite one trick pony-fag guitar player.

[jumpyutz]

@KradProductions dont post stupid messeges.

[ryanjofre]

@KradProductions

NO sh*t. You fuking Genius's calling him fat, people get older. He's pretty damn buff. His body finally grew into his neck/head.

Most of these NIN performances with Aaron North are Priceless.

[dobneyscott]

i thought trent was a skinny dude. but that fool is yoked.

[mmmarkule]

I just love this NIN era.. the music felt so ALIVE.

[korky94]

@mmmarkule

and angry

[mmmarkule]

@korky94

yeah..

[FuneralDivine]

Ive seen god live on stage! best concert ever!

[refacm]

Nin the best

[HanumanLoki]

Fuck he's kinda ripped.

[maghriste]

This gives me goosebumps for Tuesday when the Reznor Remaster of Pretty Hate Machine comes out.

[davideburford]

WHOOOAAA!!!!=)

[obscureface]

yeaaaah-uh

XD

[fofolicious]

i can't believe im probably never gonna get the chance to see NIN inch nails live! :(

[hardminder]

@fofolicious poor you...i've seen them twice before i get to 19 years old......best shows of my life

[shade8901]

@fofolicious I have the same problem :(

[starstruckstarfuck]

ad &fmt=18 to end of URl for better sound.

[xabsolutefuturex]

@TheClarifier Are you disputing that this song has been on vinyl? Because if you are, you'd be making yourself look like an idiot. Down in It, Pretty Hate Machine, Head Like a Hole, Sin, Broken, Fixed, March of the Pigs, The Downward Spiral, Closer to God, The Perfect Drug, The Day the World Went Away, The Fragile, Things Falling Apart, The Hand That Feeds, With Teeth, Only, Survivalism, Year Zero, Capital G, Year Zero Remixed, Ghosts I-IV, AND The Slip have all been pressed on vinyl i.e. wax.

[insertclevernickname]

How cool is it that this song thats over twenty years old sounds better live today than it did on wax when it first came out.

[TheClarifier]

@insertclevernickname Wax? you are too friggin' funny!

[insertclevernickname]

@TheClarifier Its a colloquial term for albums, they actually were put out on wax discs originally. NIN's first three albums came out on records ass well as tapes. Hell I still have Dr feelgood album, came out in 89, same time as PHM. But hey, if its good for a giggle then have at er.

[takbar23]

steelundergrounder hit it right on the dot i have for the past 15 years been saying trent is the best musician ever nobody will surpass him ever

[AJKHospy]

Get that shitty ass guitar player out of there jesus

[magikman79]

Just fucking awesome!

[starstruckstarfuck]

reupload this as 480p please. the sound quality is abismal

[berrybright69]

trent lookin buff! excellent!!

[libbern]

Is there any place I can download these files, or just the audiofiles alone? I need to listen to this while driving...

[bzuck0]

great video quality! even better performance. 2:40min

[pjorgenson1979]

Trent Reznor, the only guy I know who could be the manliest guy in the room while wearing stockings....Now he looks like a bouncer,,,lol.

[Angeferno]

eargasm!

[jigglejuggle91]

wowmuch heavier than the orginal

[JustinWayneTM]

Trent, he scares me sometimes lol. Man looks like he could crush your skull.

[wolfboy581]

This my favorite song off of Pretty Hate Machine and the best song NIN ever recorded!

[KuzumonoStory]

Best band ever with their best live lineup. Aaron North freaking rules!

[scramdunk]

Another lesson from the master. The early stuff rules in both lyrics and music.

[madsylver]

You know some people really suck when they sing live. But not Nine Inch Nails. They fucking rule!!! Trent Reznor, what an artist!!!!

[h3r35j0nnY]

Robin Finck>Aaron North, in my opinion.

[AJKHospy]

@h3r35j0nnY totally agree.......Jerome DIllon>all their other drummers...

[oWarlock360o]

Trent is a awesome live performer

[kopaygorod]

maldita sea, es una lástima que ya no toquen

[derlemke]

I'll admit that I prefer Robin on guitar and Dannyor justin on bass/keys, but 2005-7 with jeordie( a douche) and aaron they sounded really heavy. it's fun to hear the differences between different band members.

[nemesiswontdie]

If it ever came down to Trents fist I dont want no part of that shit.

I love Sin. Probably my favorite song of PHM and I love the single.

[992171B]

Trent sounded awesome in '05!!

[godistv]

i saw him in 2009 and he was incredible!!!

[992171B]

@godistv yeah me too, fortunately! i just meant he sounded really badass in this video. ;)

[maroromamora]

jeordy on chorus(L). awsome performance. I love the style of aaron.

[mangosnake]

Aaron is chaos unleashed

[cocoabononohead]

This song is fuckin' killer live.

[steelundergrounder]

trent is the best songwriter and musician of all time

[TsunamiTruth]

good comment!..i couldn't say it any better myself i feel so lucky to have seen them live 5 times once with north on guitar and the other 4 with my favorite mr. finck!..can't wait till trent starts touring again!!

[MichaelDcodered94]

@TsunamiTruth they retired they're not playin live no more and it PISSES ME OFF!! i never got to see them live :(

[ronrutherford]

@steelundergrounder best musician of all time? Hah, if Trent heard you say that he would laugh.

[steelundergrounder]

@ronrutherford well 'the best' is only an opinion that a person has about someone everyone has different opinions on what 'the best' is so yeah maybe he would laugh but in my opinion he is

[andymurray83200]

@steelundergrounder yep, "he's the most important guy in music"(jack white)

[TwinkleStarsXo]

@steelundergrounder Most definitely agreed! ;)

[archive303]

@steelundergrounder Wake up!

[ryanjofre]

@steelundergrounder

Seriously Trent would SURELY laugh his fuking ass off if he read this. NIN will go down in history as Incredible and I'll love them forever but Greater then Pink Floyd, Bob Marley, The Who, The Doors, The Beatles, Greater then Mozart, Grater than Beethoven? Get the fuk outta here please. Study Modern and Classic Music please!

[ryanjofre]

@steelundergrounder

Just so it doesn't feel like I'm shitting on you for the sake of it.... In the Genre of *Industrial Rock* which NIN practically invented and Highly popularized post Shinny PUppy etc. NIN is the Greaest *Indsutrial Rock* songwriter and Musician of all time...period.

[steelundergrounder]

@ryanjofre I was younger and obsessed when i made that comment..... I don't think there is a greatest songwriter. Just many

[GS336]

Best live performance I've ever seen. Just plain amazing.

[jixxer6961]

what the fuck is wrong with you guys?? are you nin fans? the band in any form was great! ive seen robin play and aaron... both of them great guitar players

[wolfboy581]

This the best live performance by Trent &

the guys!

[DJSouthernTech]

Lol spectraspectacle maybe he might do a James Brown and take some of his pay when he plays the wrong note. Definetly one of my fav NIN songs.

[HavokkG1]

that guitar player at that time always pissed me off

[gatoradeee]

Aaron North? He went to my high school and he played in a band in a garage with my friend's brother before he was in nine inch nails.

[HavokkG1]

yeah im not saying hes bad but I always felt like he didnt really fit but same with the guitar player they have now,

[spectraspectacle]

2:00 The bass player plays the wrong note (one half step above the intended note) and Trent seems to give him a dirty look at 2:05. haha

[robinfinckisgod]

I doubt it was actually a dirty look. Trents made his fair sure of wrong notes in his time, and as a musician, he'll understand when others dont get everything perfect.

[Hackmoune]

you´re retard that wasn´t a dirty look, its just Trent likes to do those kind of "pantomimes" in his live performances

[SHAVOISCOOL]

Is there a DVD that i can get this concert on?

[TheHarmonicaChick]

amazing!!!!!!! my next halo tattoo

[Bobnumerotres]

Best concert they ever did IMO.

[rokrkim]

what is,, or where is kroq?

is that name of rock fest??

[1badassmothafucka]

kroq is a rock station in L.A., and they put on a lot of concerts, and this is probably one of their shows, and kroq is actually pronounced "K-Rock"

[bohottie]

I was at the With Teeth tour when they were in Chicago. By far the best concert I've ever been to...Nine Inch Nails is AMAZING live. I can't remember for sure if they played this song...I'm pretty sure they did (hey it was 5 years ago, give me a break =D)

[thescarface1989pt4]

Wow the energy is awesome!

[GreciaTheKool]

damn, trent is a sexxy beast!!!

i wish he'd fuck me like an animal!!

[elhoobanebre]

i must say i wasnt to sure of aaron north but after watching him manipulate the sounds coming out his guitar i give him mad props i still prefer the finck/renholder era but i enjoy this lineup too

[Beefe666]

alive god

[nevans2008]

This is my favorite version of Sin by far

[karavo]

REZNOR THE PROFET!

[phastasm]

deadly

[twochicksONEcamera]

why is trent so buff ? I'm used to him wiht long hair and skinny .

[kurthoop]

he's been buff for about the past 8 years now, check him out lately he's a tank now

[altiyuzalti]

i love aaron north's guitar playing.

[trentisgod92]

fuck yeah.

[plusquamverbis]

REZNOR IS BUFFED

[sugarfreaky]

bellissimaaa!!

[liquid1122]

They played this yesterday when I saw them in Maryland & I was so excited cause I thought they stopped playing it! NIN Rules!!!

[warlockboyburns]

amazing as ever

[DivisionbyZer0]

prefer the bass line done on synthesizer but still good.

[SimonRivas]

me too. I think Trent wanted to re-work everything especially songs he's been playing for ages.Plus With teeth was more lean and much more of a "straight up" rock album so I think he wanted re-arrange older songs to match.

[obscureface]

yeah!

sort of like sex you try new things!

^^

[zlatan0831]

En lo personal me gustan mas las letras de Trent por que pueden llegar a tener multiples significados, solo el sabe en verdad que significa cada una de sus letras, la musica de Maynard me gusta, pero despues de escucharla varias veces aburre un poco....

[666DemonsOHell]

the lighting is awesome

[olirazor]

!!NIN 4evah!!

[Sprong4]

this is amazing:)

[denialo16]

puro gringo mmm, ese reznor es bien chingon yeah

[Rip721]

2:42 ..... Air piano? or "Spooky fingers" ???

[fofolicious]

This is so amazinggg!

I think his voice has gotten much betterr

[AnaTwiggy]

Aaron is great, but I definitely prefer Robin... And Twiggy kicks ass!!

[evilfetus4]

Yah I prefer Robin to glad he is back

[blvdnight]

342526th reason why Aaron North Rocks

[avelione]

And 5 stars for the director!

[avelione]

That night had some really strange energy. I still think that none of next shows was so....... intense....although all are brilliant

[ICHnaemonidae]

so much testosterone!

[calypso694]

TWIGGY HELL YEAH !!

[MmYewStupidSob]

What song is the intro an outtake from?

[ac1dfr3ak1zback]

Beside you in time (with-teeth)

[starstruckstarfuck]

@ac1dfr3ak1zback

cant select 480p quality anymore.....

[SimonRivas]

From one of the Sin remixes.Either dub or long.

[the6sin6boy6]

2 words - Twiggy Ramirez

[unconditionallykool]

one word for this song: Twiggy :)

[feckkol]

Very good vesion. Intensive_5*

[SmileBit299]

You are wrong and heres why. All of his recent work is far too accessable and simple. His song structure is laughable at best and very repetitive. Sorry but true music fans would know this. Its not worth talking to you. Bye.

[beauhr10]

Maynard even admitted that he rarely came up with the core structure of any song, whether it be Tool or APC, and said, "I can work very well under parameters. I'm more of a reactive artist that a creative one." You have to give every member of Tool equal credit for the magic that they make, because they aren't Gun's and Roses with one asshole telling everyone what to do. So why don't you get off of Maynard's dick, because he doesn't like it anyway.

[beauhr10]

And NIN is awesome if you have the same feelings for the things he talks about. NIN and Tool are both awesome bands, and I agree that people sometimes focus too much on Trent, but you say that and then turn around and put your hypocrite mouth on Maynard's cock. So just stfu and enjoy the music you want to listen to and stop reporting what you think, and then contradicting yourself. No one cares what you think.

[matxx82]

What would people focus on besides Trent? he writes all the music and does pretty much everything himself (unless of course he is touring then he has to get people to help him).

[beauhr10]

And yes, I was talking about "SmileBit299."

[beer4me88]

just throwing this out there but adam jones and danny carey do most of the constructing in tool

[JakeP555]

Exactly. MJK has repeatedly said that Danny, Adam, and Justin write the music and he later adds the lyrics and does some fine tuning to the song as a whole. They pretty much wrote most of the "Lateralus" album while MJK was with APC. Check out the 2007 Revolver issue featuring TOOL. Talk about it there. Peace.

[ToolKid21]

But Maynard WRITES the lyrics right???

[JakeP555]

Yeah, of course. Like I said, after DC,AJ,and JC have wrote the music, then MJK will listen to it and write the lyrics. This is all according to the band members. In the Revolver issue, they said while MJK was touring with APC, that they pretty much wrote the entire "Lateralus" album while MJK was on the road. Then, MJK added the lyrics and did some fine tuning later on. It is a collaboration of all of them together.

[ToolKid21]

ok just making sure beause my dumb cousin said that Maynard didnt warite he lyrics, and that the band, Adam, Justin, and Danny worte it, i have no idea where he got that from, but luckily i never believed him

[KGecko]

Like to see you do better. In the mean time shut the fuck up.

[hippygrass]

god nin is so much better then tool

[jjatds]

Why do you have to compare them? Totally different bands. I don't understand why people have to feel like their band is the best ever. They are both amazing in their own ways.

[hollock1]

Raznor is experimenting, he is pushing limits of music further than anybody else. Sometimes it sound great, sometimes it sucks, but thanks to people like this, music goes ahead...

[charlieandrosie]

I would sure like to have been at this concert! Thanks for posting it all!

[BluBel123]

He is so sweaty there

[TheBackseatJesus]

Hey fuckers, stop arguing a pointless argument in a fucking youtube video comments. It's pointless and stupid. Both Maynard and Reznor are good artists.

[SmileBit299]

Oh and one more thing...I dont listen to MGMT because theyll be around in 20 years you idiot. I listen to them because they write awesome music. If they start sucking Ill drop them like I dropped Reznor. I will not blindly listen to them even though they suck like you. Fucking get a life and stop thinking Reznor has anything left in the tank. The guy is a hack and his current fans are pathetic.

[InternetMovieAddict8]

something about SmileBit telling others to "get a life" just seems so... ironic :)

[Marcoago]

It's strange seeing Trent of 2005 sing a song as old as Sin. Really rock! But i prefer the old version.

[CraigHic]

Amazing

[carlinhos5000]

the best song...

[sogrunge]

I love how people who hate artists are still watching the videos of them and then take time to write why they hate them.... Personally, i don't hate any artist, hate is too strong a word, i just know what artists i like and leave the others alone. I mean i'm not into McFly, so i don't go watch any McFly videos on here and say i hate them.... The people that do this are called "cunts".

End of.

[GS336]

Shut your freakin' mouth you idiotic little turd. You obviously wouldn't know good music if it slapped you in the face. Trent Reznor is a GOD of music. If you can't accept that, too bad.

[SmileBit299]

You're a moron. I dont talk to people who are stupid. Trent Rezner is great. I will admit that. His voice still sucks as does his songwriting. Honestly look at his lyrics. It looks like the diary of some angry high school kid. Nothing like Maynard James Keenan from Tool. That is like night and day.

[bythasword]

Trent's songwriting is top notch. His voice has gone off with age i admit but who fucking cares. MJK's lyrics might be complicated but its just as emotional as trents and they're totally different artists. one is better than the other..its just art. maynard cant play all the instruments and compose songs like trent. but they both are great

[SmileBit299]

What is your definition of songwriting? It must be different from mine because even critics who favor Reznor know his songwriting is at the level of a 10th grade high school student. Maynard embaresses Reznor as far as composing and singing goes.

[drapdv]

Why don't you find somewhere else to be a douchebag? I wonder if you do this in real life. "Hey, your dinner looks like it sucks." "Your kid seems stupid." "Your wife is ugly." How would you like it if someone started wanking off on all those super cool MGMT videos you have favorited? Let's see if they're still around in 20 years...

[SmileBit299]

At least Im not a blind fan like you. Maynard James Keenan of Tool is ten times more talented than this hack yet I dont drool over everything he does. Puscifer sucks. I have no respect for people like you who think everything about their favorite artist is great. You are a joke. Go listen to the radio faggot.

[drapdv]

"Nothing like Maynard James Keenan from Tool." "Maynard embaresses (sic) Reznor as far as composing and singing goes." "Maynard James Keenan of Tool is ten times more talented than this hack yet I dont drool over everything he does."

ha ha

[SmileBit299]

Puscifer is a joke. Its awful music and MJK should stop doing it. JUST LIKE EVERYTHING Reznor has done in the past 10 years. At least MJK has released 10,000 days and 13th step recently. Fuck reznor.

[Amrcnhdchrg]

seriously man why go to a NIN song just to bash on Reznor? He single handedly brought industrial rock to the mainstream; simple as that. If you don't like his voice fine, go listen to someone else ... I personally think he's a genius

[zedvin]

from wich dvd is this?

[molliesmania9]

i wanna take aaron north, spread him on a piece of bread, fold it in half and fucking devour it. the end.

[jfunny27]

wow...... you don't this any talent like this anymore. sadly i think it will end with NIN if rap becomes anymore popular. Go NIN and Trent! YOU KNOW WHAT REAL MUSIC IS !!!!!!

[Andrew305boi]

effing great..

[radovest]

Thumb me if you think that Aaron is hell of a guitarist.

[badluckshadow13]

I love that "woah" it's like the song became so intense Trent was surprised.

[bubblebubbletea]

Aaron North is so fucking amazing, easily the best live guitarist NIN has ever had.

[Itnelagd]

He is such a good singer

[Itnelagd]

I LOVE THIS

[BreakingGlass77]

Twiggy!

[dundeevial]

and aaron!