You have not been giving this video its salary of "likes". Send these likes and watch. Should these commands be ignored, a disaster beyond your imagination will occur. I will be watching from Box Five.
"and what is that we were meant to have wrote? er, written" haha i love this movie!!!!! Carlotta fits the countess role better..i cant picture Christine in the huge wig and dress
@coolyo617 I agree, and I never understood why Carlotta was thought to be a bad singer. Her voice is powerful, but she is quite good. Carlotta and Christine are two totally different types of singers, I don't think they can be compared with each other. It's kind of like comparing bombers to fighters...
Was in the pit orchestra for my highschool's production of this, and it's bringing back some great memories of that beautiful score. *sigh*.....Andrew Lloyd Webber you genious!!!!
@RvenclawPadawan And we could have been such good friends... Nah, I don't have a problem with Raoul here, other than him constantly cock-blocking Erik. X3 In the book, though, he's pretty freakin whiny.
@WondersNassiri Coz they're trying to oppose the Phantom! Plus they think that Christine's slept with Raoul and that's why he wants her to be on stage!
@Cooleospongenickle The music is amazing. The plot is actually quite lacking, if you pay attention. Its not as good as the book, or as earlier versions of the screenplay or musical in that sense.
@Cooleospongenickle It's not a good adaption of the book. As someone who's experienced both, I haven't a problem with it, I quite like it, but I can see the other side.
@Cooleospongenickle Ive heard people complain about the movie from the part where they sing Phantom of The Opera cuz its, Quote, "a fucking piece of garbage made upfantasy fairly tale with things like the sun having a smiley face on it" -an ass hole
but he was probably a fucking troll, so Im guessing trolls dont like it cuz its their life work to try and piss off people with decency
i always laugh at this song. they're all like 'I HAVE A NOTE!' it's freaking hilarious how many times they keep saying that and how they all blame eachother
@tsphilly98 Who'd believe? A Diva happy to relieve a chorus girl whose gone and slept with the Patron. Raul and his soubrette entwined in loves duet. Although he may demur, he must have been with her. You may not get away with all this in a play, but if it's loudly song, and in a foreign tongue, it's just the sort of story audiences adore. In-fact, a perfect opera. <3
Ok, yes I think it is creepy that the phantom plays with dolls, but I just love the little caress he does with his fingertip to the Christine doll head.
I was watching POTO with my mom anf of course I sang along in evry song *I'm a show of xD* but when this song came up I was singing all the parts and my mom was looking me like I was an alien xD and yes I rolled the ''r'' like carlotta xD I really love her. she is my faveorite character after the Phantom of course ...
andre did ok on "damnable..." Furman did a good job on "oh it seems you got one too" because in the original london cast version the full line is "...but we have no cast!but andre have you seen the queue, oh it seems you got one too" which leads to confusion as to what he's talking about but here its very clear. the "who would have the gaul..." part was ok but like i said earlier it wouldve been better faster...because it has such a bouncy feel to it.
I like this, but im stupified by the original london casts version, because its flawless where i noticed bunches of mistakes in this one...what i noticed was from the very beginning it was too slow, i think it should be done at a tempo a bit faster than "moving along" because it makes the "who would have the gaul..." part more bouncier it pleasing, but its like they were stumbling on words through this. plus furman butchered his first solo, he was flat on the word "cheers" and stumbled end notes
I feel sorry for Carlotta's little maid peoples. They have to follow her around with that huge painting while she spazzes.. Bet that's happened more than once...
They changes SOOOO MANY words in the movie.... I don't even think it can legit be called Phantom of the Opera considering half the stuff was different from the real musical for no reason other then the director clearly not knowing anything about musical theater...
@LearnToFly1000 you do know that the stage musical was originally based on a book which was also based on fact/rumours of an actual ghost at an opera house in paris. and a lot of things do fit in with events in the book as to whether they are in the right order or not is debatable but it still means that it is following the story therefore still about the phantom of the opera
@BRACEwits One of the characters mentioned in a few lines of the book is actually a real person who lived in the cave under Opera Garnier; he's described as terrifying everyone, including the phantom himself :p
I don't understand why they don't boot Carlotta out though, nobody really likes her as much as Christine. I mean they do have the authority to do that
So we're performing Phantom at our school and I'm in the pit. We were rehearsing these songs for about two hours, so this song has been stuck in my head for two days and counting.
Especially...
"Far too many notes for my taste, most of them about Christine. All we've heard since we came is Miss Daae's name..." etc.
@TheMightyPineapples That phrase has been repeating itself ad nauseum for the past couple of days. I now have to memorize the song so I don't just keep hearing that little clip!!!!
@kutekristi16 I agree - except the dresses were prone to catch fire if you stood to close to the fireplace! We have Oscar Wilde's wife to thank for stopping all that!
"Which in a word makes my casting.....ideal" No way Eric! Cristine is much too young to play The Countess and Carlotta is far too old to play The Page-Boy!
Who else agrees with that statement?
BTW, the costumes and set design in "Il Muto" are freakin' awesome!!!!!!!!!!
@smilefumble The Phantom's point was that the role of the countess calls for charm and appeal (which Christine has and which Carlotta doesn't), while the role of the pageboy is silent (so Carlotta wouldn't be screeching in his ears). He wasn't looking at their respective ages.
@smilefumble i agree, Erik is putting a hell of a lot of pressure on Christine. She is too young to play the countess (i mean what is she 18? 19?) and Carlotta is far too old to play the page boy (i assume she may be in her forties?)
@TheBatmangirl14 Haha well excuse me princess, if you wanna know all the details of the story you should read the book, I gues.. Never did it myself tbh. But I totally agree with you that Christine just doesn't fit to be the countess...
The most complicated vocal compilation and performance in the entire play. When well performed live in theatre, without the privelage of editing, it is trully magnificent. I've been fortunate enough to see it happen only twice out of attending 50 performances. Once in New York, and once in London. Also, my favorite part of the movie. Thanks for posting. Well Done!
Sigh, I know this movie was decidedly different from the opera music of the musical, but even so, they could have gotten better people to at least be able to SING. And Minnie Driver's presence is so wasted. The movie focused too much on making it sexy and not, you know... good.
"and what is it that i'm meant to have wrote *thinks* written..." that just cracks me up.... xD I really miss Notes on the soundtrack. its just so brilliant.
I just LOVE how Raoul sounds here!!! After listening to Andre and Firmin it sounds amazing. And then, after listening to Carlotta, the Phantom is even more amazing than usual.
The note confusion =D My Favourite part
EvraVostok 1 day ago
You have not been giving this video its salary of "likes". Send these likes and watch. Should these commands be ignored, a disaster beyond your imagination will occur. I will be watching from Box Five.
I remain, gentlemen, your obedient servant,
OG
flashandgreenlantern 1 day ago 3
2 people were blinded by the butt on 5:56 and pressed the wrong button
wandmo 4 days ago 3
Every time I listen to the Notes song the Phantom says he had several notes to them yet I can only count six, what is the seventh one?
Spearsy2 1 week ago
only 2 people hit the wrong button on this one :)
henrylover7 1 week ago 2
@henrylover7 Justiceee!!!! :D Nobody hates this video actually, really... :PP
Frozentear3 1 week ago
2:44 is my fav part:D he has such a magnificent voice<3333
chesterroo16 1 week ago
Still gives me goosebumps when i hear oit!
andreiitax3 2 weeks ago
the most amazing line for me: 'what new surprises lie in store?' the harmony is perfect
lololwut321 2 weeks ago 6
@lololwut321 Totally agree! One of my favourite parts too!
Frozentear3 2 weeks ago
excellent play!!!!
castmo 3 weeks ago
"Of course not!" Haha Raoul's so insulted :D
VeggieVamp762 4 weeks ago 2
"and what is that we were meant to have wrote? er, written" haha i love this movie!!!!! Carlotta fits the countess role better..i cant picture Christine in the huge wig and dress
stormwolf1517 1 month ago 2
doesn't Meg have the cutest voice ever? She sounds like a 5 year old lol
XxDazedandConfusedx1 1 month ago 4
I personally think that Carlotta fits the role a lot better. I don't think Christine would look good in that gaudy thing.
coolyo617 1 month ago 6
@coolyo617 I agree, and I never understood why Carlotta was thought to be a bad singer. Her voice is powerful, but she is quite good. Carlotta and Christine are two totally different types of singers, I don't think they can be compared with each other. It's kind of like comparing bombers to fighters...
EvraVostok 1 day ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Was in the pit orchestra for my highschool's production of this, and it's bringing back some great memories of that beautiful score. *sigh*.....Andrew Lloyd Webber you genious!!!!
TheGRJPBeatles 1 month ago
I actually love Carlotta cast ^^
lavendericetea 2 months ago 3
marry me Raoul.....
ShannonMarie543 2 months ago 2
@ShannonMarie543 No! He's mine!
Jk
I'm glad to see there's more Raoul fans out there than just me :D
RvenclawPadawan 2 months ago
@RvenclawPadawan And we could have been such good friends... Nah, I don't have a problem with Raoul here, other than him constantly cock-blocking Erik. X3 In the book, though, he's pretty freakin whiny.
hotnoodle101 3 weeks ago
@hotnoodle101 Hahahahaha XDD
Frozentear3 3 weeks ago
Simon Callow and Ciaran Hinds in this are brilliant as Andre and Firman!
MultiBelle22 2 months ago
I love Firmin and Andre's simultaneous "Senora no."
ImABroadwayLuver 2 months ago 2
My question is why do Firmin and Andre obsess over her when the public clearly loves Christine more?
WondersNassiri 2 months ago
@WondersNassiri Coz they're trying to oppose the Phantom! Plus they think that Christine's slept with Raoul and that's why he wants her to be on stage!
MultiBelle22 2 months ago
Not a big fan of Prima Donna, but Notes is one of my favourite songs in the movie, I wish it came on the actual soundtrack...
randomvidsinc123 2 months ago 2
@Rockstarpenguin13 it's tradition that on opening night, the managers of an opera house drink out of the leading lady's shoe
princessleia19 2 months ago 2
of COURSE not!
NarnianTrekkie 3 months ago
XDDD The rest of the cast is waving happily as Carlotta leaves angrily. XDDD
Masqueradia 3 months ago 3
Why did Firman drink out of Carlotta's shoe...?
ramah920 3 months ago
@ramah920 I've always wondered about that too...
Rockstarpenguin13 3 months ago 2
lol andre and firmin carrying carlotta
DrinkOmally 3 months ago
Comment removed
OlvenKind 3 months ago in playlist MusicalsPlaylist
As much as I love watching Ciaran Hinds, he really cannot sing... =S
MrWatson193 3 months ago
One of the only decent scenes in an otherwise very disappointing film. Minnie Driver is a joy and really hams it up a treat.
Dianaemanuel 3 months ago
LOL @ 5:35 !! she looks like the scream haha
metrostationluffer 3 months ago
gerryyyyyyyyy :D
edemjr2 3 months ago
I love Gerard's mouth!
GothicAnnamal 4 months ago
@GothicAnnamal yeahhh :)
edemjr2 3 months ago
5:27 I love carlottas voice!
princessleia19 4 months ago
@princessleia19 I agree! I really like that part too! ;D
lovewalk101 2 months ago
gosh I love raoul in this song!
princessleia19 4 months ago
I don't understand why people don't like this movie. Its so amazing >< and the characters are really well cast.
Cooleospongenickle 4 months ago 63
@Cooleospongenickle totally agree!
Frozentear3 4 months ago 9
@Cooleospongenickle people don't like this movie? :O unthinkable
UsedtoWoW 3 months ago
@Cooleospongenickle The music is amazing. The plot is actually quite lacking, if you pay attention. Its not as good as the book, or as earlier versions of the screenplay or musical in that sense.
sterlingsilverf 3 months ago 3
@Cooleospongenickle maybe because the singing was disappointing compared to real opera vocallist
ryoshi100 2 months ago
@Cooleospongenickle It's not a good adaption of the book. As someone who's experienced both, I haven't a problem with it, I quite like it, but I can see the other side.
hotnoodle101 3 weeks ago
@Cooleospongenickle Ive heard people complain about the movie from the part where they sing Phantom of The Opera cuz its, Quote, "a fucking piece of garbage made upfantasy fairly tale with things like the sun having a smiley face on it" -an ass hole
but he was probably a fucking troll, so Im guessing trolls dont like it cuz its their life work to try and piss off people with decency
rapealady 2 weeks ago
haha, rehearsed breath ^.^
wwefreak952 4 months ago
This is one of my favorite scenes of the movie, for some reason. I adore it.
Rx2D 4 months ago
Carlotta [Angrily]: Where is he?!
Andre [Happily]: Oh welcome back!
Ah, this still makes me laugh. :]
ramah920 4 months ago
FUCKING PHANTOM!!! (GERARD BUTLER) IS SO FUCKING SEXY! <33333 LOL and when they're singing prima donna their faces are like..... Oh......gawd.
TheDangruslynluv 5 months ago
FUCKING PHANTOM!!! (GERARD BUTLER) IS SO FUCKING SEXY! <33333
TheDangruslynluv 5 months ago
Does anyone know what the thing is that they Give Carlotta that she's like petting besides her dog?
saxyback345 5 months ago
@saxyback345 its a muff, often used to warm your hands
hamij09 5 months ago
@saxyback345 IIRC the french name is manchon but I'm not sure the english name.
agnosticnixie 4 months ago
@saxyback345 i think it's a fur pillow :/
prettypinkangel11 4 months ago
@saxyback345 its something you put your hands in. its usually furry
101goodwitch101 4 months ago
@101goodwitch101 it's called a muff :P
nebulavision 3 months ago
i always laugh at this song. they're all like 'I HAVE A NOTE!' it's freaking hilarious how many times they keep saying that and how they all blame eachother
OMGitsKASS13 5 months ago
"il muto" is Italian for "the mute (person)", so wouldn't the silent part be better?
Kyaco2Paco 6 months ago
@Kyaco2Paco ... *facepalm*
Iced1992 6 months ago
9:00 i love Firmin and Andre's part here, ex. "A chorus girl who's gone and slept with the patron" XD
tsphilly98 6 months ago 2
@tsphilly98 Who'd believe? A Diva happy to relieve a chorus girl whose gone and slept with the Patron. Raul and his soubrette entwined in loves duet. Although he may demur, he must have been with her. You may not get away with all this in a play, but if it's loudly song, and in a foreign tongue, it's just the sort of story audiences adore. In-fact, a perfect opera. <3
hamij09 5 months ago
MINNIE DRIVER LOOKS HOT AS A PIMADONNA DAMN!!!!!!
blacksultan85 6 months ago 2
I love Piangi's voice in the background
bamfan1994 6 months ago
They screwed with Madame Giry's amazing hairstyle in this movie and now I'm upset.
SecondBananaAddams 6 months ago
ferman and andre are my favorite characters because of this song.
Rayen015 7 months ago
the viscount, herrr loverrr ;D
mmmmusu 7 months ago
Haha I love 1:45-2:03 and 2:22
peggysuegirl 7 months ago 2
Ok, yes I think it is creepy that the phantom plays with dolls, but I just love the little caress he does with his fingertip to the Christine doll head.
fishgirl1996 7 months ago 4
"far too many notes for my taste
and all of them about christine
all we've heard since we've came is my Daae's naaaam......."
best part <3
leedonaldt 7 months ago
Also, why do they want her so bad? The phantom threatened them and Christine is much better.
BTW I adore this movie/story/play
OwlCityFan26 7 months ago 2
@OwlCityFan26 They didn't want to follow the Phantom's orders because it's their theater. Plus, if Christine leaves Carlotta can stay.
coralinesbiggestfan 7 months ago
1) "And what is it that we're meant to have wrote?...written." LOL
2) I agree with the phantom:P and I love him
3) nooning her. Ew.
OwlCityFan26 7 months ago 3
Does anyone else want that "playset" of the Opera Populaire? o-o
Francine3i 7 months ago 4
Isn't that skull wax seal AWESOME?!?!
Chizpurfle52595 8 months ago 35
@Chizpurfle52595 ikr i was that frikin awesome
AlyssaHall511 1 month ago
one of my favorite musicals :), definetly top 3
pottyboy2 8 months ago
I was watching POTO with my mom anf of course I sang along in evry song *I'm a show of xD* but when this song came up I was singing all the parts and my mom was looking me like I was an alien xD and yes I rolled the ''r'' like carlotta xD I really love her. she is my faveorite character after the Phantom of course ...
SweetDeath777 8 months ago 3
can some super smart person somewhere please answer this for me? what's the difference between an operetta and a musical?!!!
14597ojai 8 months ago
He's really enjoying himself at 4:43.
I wish he smiled more often throughout the movie. Looks cute. :)
mishenkamh 8 months ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
Minnie Driver is absolutely outstanding as Carlotta!!
gonasme 8 months ago 2
Comment removed
gonasme 8 months ago
andre did ok on "damnable..." Furman did a good job on "oh it seems you got one too" because in the original london cast version the full line is "...but we have no cast!but andre have you seen the queue, oh it seems you got one too" which leads to confusion as to what he's talking about but here its very clear. the "who would have the gaul..." part was ok but like i said earlier it wouldve been better faster...because it has such a bouncy feel to it.
TheEnglishQuail 9 months ago
I like this, but im stupified by the original london casts version, because its flawless where i noticed bunches of mistakes in this one...what i noticed was from the very beginning it was too slow, i think it should be done at a tempo a bit faster than "moving along" because it makes the "who would have the gaul..." part more bouncier it pleasing, but its like they were stumbling on words through this. plus furman butchered his first solo, he was flat on the word "cheers" and stumbled end notes
TheEnglishQuail 9 months ago
Gerard Butler is a great phantom
arand0mp3rs0n 9 months ago 5
@arand0mp3rs0n But Micheal IS THE PHANTOM
Invaderphantomstar11 8 months ago
Omg I'm firmin in my school's production... this song makes me want to kill something- it's SO HARD
evlainovt 9 months ago
I think the actress who plays Carlotta did a FANTASTIC job! Everyone else was just mediocre to the Original London Cast.
kyo2590 9 months ago
I feel sorry for Carlotta's little maid peoples. They have to follow her around with that huge painting while she spazzes.. Bet that's happened more than once...
vanityrox81 9 months ago
ah opening night of my school's production of phantom, im so nervous haha
cameplaitbeaucoup 9 months ago
my school is doing this in two weeks!!! cant wait
rasengan11000 10 months ago 2
WOW!!!!!!!!
fredluver111 10 months ago
They changes SOOOO MANY words in the movie.... I don't even think it can legit be called Phantom of the Opera considering half the stuff was different from the real musical for no reason other then the director clearly not knowing anything about musical theater...
LearnToFly1000 10 months ago
@LearnToFly1000 Don't forget that Andrew Lloyd Webber also produced the film. He agreed and also contributed to the changes.
LatasianDevil 9 months ago
@LatasianDevil He did?? Ehh I don't really like the changes that much. It's such an amazing script why mess with perfection?
LearnToFly1000 9 months ago
@LearnToFly1000 you do know that the stage musical was originally based on a book which was also based on fact/rumours of an actual ghost at an opera house in paris. and a lot of things do fit in with events in the book as to whether they are in the right order or not is debatable but it still means that it is following the story therefore still about the phantom of the opera
BRACEwits 9 months ago
@BRACEwits Yeahh I never read the book. I want to though.
LearnToFly1000 9 months ago
@BRACEwits One of the characters mentioned in a few lines of the book is actually a real person who lived in the cave under Opera Garnier; he's described as terrifying everyone, including the phantom himself :p
agnosticnixie 4 months ago
I don't understand why they don't boot Carlotta out though, nobody really likes her as much as Christine. I mean they do have the authority to do that
traillbits 10 months ago
Dear Raoul,
Please die in a hole.
Thank you,
~Noodlez
hotnoodle101 10 months ago 7
I love how there is that person who moons Carlotta at 5:56
Heh, that is one of my favorite dude.
IfritsHorn 10 months ago
3:36 Aw! Raoul sounds so concerned for Christine! <3
TootieLouLou11 10 months ago
I love the Phantom, but i sorta noticed that at 4:33 he strokes the removable doll head of Cristine's....kinda creepy in my opinion
NightsDarkAngel1 10 months ago
@NightsDarkAngel1 its not creepy its sweet, he loves her!
Tashastar100 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@NightsDarkAngel1 its not creepy he loves her!
Tashastar100 9 months ago
@goombamario1 no, public school.
MrBbats 10 months ago
The phantom dislikes this
MrPdiddy456 11 months ago
@Evekinz910 Because then we'd all burst into song in math class, and how would we keep things secret then? ;)
hotnoodle101 11 months ago
@frozentear3 we did do better because my school is freakin' EPIC!
MrBbats 11 months ago
@MrBbats yh right u probs went to a special school
goombamario1 10 months ago
9:23 Carlotta looks like a wedding cake :)
wincipoet 11 months ago 2
I dunno, I think my highschool did better than this...
MrBbats 11 months ago
@MrBbats Sure it did! ;)
Frozentear3 11 months ago 40
@MrBbats Shut up this is A GOOD MOVIE!!!!
jadegirl47 8 months ago
@MrBbats what school was it? I saw it at University High school they preformed it amazingly!
nani159753 7 months ago
@MrBbats My school just did this for our Spring Performance, I was part of the stage crew :)
KiloAlpha1337 7 months ago
@KiloAlpha1337 Lucky i want to be in this play but im only in 7th grade -_-
coralinesbiggestfan 7 months ago 2
@MrBbats I know mine did. I should know, I was in pit for it. I listened to each song about a million times. If I may ask, what school do you go to?
Sychs1 6 months ago
These are my fave songs in Phantom! Ciaran Hinds and Simon Callow are wicked as Andre and Firman!
MultiBelle22 11 months ago 4
"And what is that we're meant to have wrote..*awkward pause* written?" kills me ever time in the show
popprincess6253 11 months ago 3
"The role of the pageboy, which makes my casting, in a word, ideal."
Hahaha, one of the best lines. And I love his little smirk after saying that.
rach64xoxo 11 months ago 3
Oh! Erik knows how make chaos ^_^
This is my favourite song. Great one!:)
"Of course not!" heheh...
EllethwenEldarwen 1 year ago 5
So we're performing Phantom at our school and I'm in the pit. We were rehearsing these songs for about two hours, so this song has been stuck in my head for two days and counting.
Especially...
"Far too many notes for my taste, most of them about Christine. All we've heard since we came is Miss Daae's name..." etc.
TheMightyPineapples 1 year ago 3
@TheMightyPineapples That phrase has been repeating itself ad nauseum for the past couple of days. I now have to memorize the song so I don't just keep hearing that little clip!!!!
Chizpurfle52595 8 months ago
Why cant we all still dress like this? its stunning! :)
kutekristi16 1 year ago 114
@kutekristi16 OOOOH I know right! :O
Frozentear3 1 year ago 21
@Frozentear3
A lady up the road still dresses much like Carlotta does in this. And it's bloody amazing to look at
DemonDartz 11 months ago 4
@kutekristi16 because those things are hard to walk/run/do anything inin
smilyface61 11 months ago
@kutekristi16 I agree - except the dresses were prone to catch fire if you stood to close to the fireplace! We have Oscar Wilde's wife to thank for stopping all that!
MultiBelle22 5 months ago
@kutekristi16 except for the wigs lol
JulieWinchester 3 months ago
@kutekristi16 seriously! i love victorian dress!!!! then again... those corsets can really do damage on ur ribs.... still luv it tho!!
RaverYuuki 3 months ago
"And did you send it?"
"Of course not!"
"As if he would."
"You didn't send it?"
"Of course not!"
Oh Raoul, you get me everytime :D
LulovestheJoBros 1 year ago 4
I LOVE Minnie Driver as Carlotta. although Minnie isn't doing her own singing her acting is great. i also love the costumes in this movie.
turkeypopcorn 1 year ago 3
I just wish they casted the woman who can for Mimi instead of plopping in an actress without the talent for the role.
valhos11 1 year ago
Firman and andre would make exellent chucklebrothers :D
mozarttheraver123 1 year ago
I love what Raoul's wearing!! :3
Invaderphantomstar11 1 year ago
My highschool has been putting on this production, this scene was one of our biggest crowdpleaser.
NoblemanNick 1 year ago
I love Carlotta's voice and accent!!
SweetDeath777 1 year ago
isn't this the letter you wrote?
and what is it that we were ment to have wrote.. ah written. :)
emmaANO 1 year ago 5
I can't believe the woman who played Carlotta voices Jane in Tarzan. Wow.
itsmeyoudorkrly 1 year ago
omg madame giry looks just like my drama director!!! sshe was on broadway for a while
GahoolienFlyte208 1 year ago
Just wondering...
Why would andre and firmin write a note telling raoul that he will never see christine again?
yoyololodadodo 1 year ago
These two men make the show. They're so cute!
MrsGButler1995 1 year ago 3
I love these songs XD
happynessish 1 year ago 2
the lyrics are diffrent :(
TheMibs56 1 year ago
"Which in a word makes my casting.....ideal" No way Eric! Cristine is much too young to play The Countess and Carlotta is far too old to play The Page-Boy!
Who else agrees with that statement?
BTW, the costumes and set design in "Il Muto" are freakin' awesome!!!!!!!!!!
smilefumble 1 year ago 2
@smilefumble The Phantom's point was that the role of the countess calls for charm and appeal (which Christine has and which Carlotta doesn't), while the role of the pageboy is silent (so Carlotta wouldn't be screeching in his ears). He wasn't looking at their respective ages.
lekszi46 1 year ago 2
@lekszi46 At least in my opinion Carlotta was very appealing as the Countess.
smilefumble 1 year ago
@smilefumble Ok, but this was all about the Phantom's opinion. Next time maybe the writers will want your opinion instead of the Phantom's. :)
lekszi46 1 year ago
@lekszi46 That line aways makes me laugh- the Phantom is such a sarcastic bugger lol!
GothicAnnamal 6 months ago
@GothicAnnamal that 1 more of his attractive features
shadowspys 6 months ago
@smilefumble i agree, Erik is putting a hell of a lot of pressure on Christine. She is too young to play the countess (i mean what is she 18? 19?) and Carlotta is far too old to play the page boy (i assume she may be in her forties?)
TheBatmangirl14 1 year ago
@TheBatmangirl14 Actually, while shooting this movie, she was only sixteen. When the film was released in 2004, she was only eightteen.
Frozentear3 1 year ago
@Frozentear3 i knew how old the actress was, I was talking about Christine as a character
TheBatmangirl14 1 year ago
@TheBatmangirl14 Haha well excuse me princess, if you wanna know all the details of the story you should read the book, I gues.. Never did it myself tbh. But I totally agree with you that Christine just doesn't fit to be the countess...
Frozentear3 1 year ago
@TheBatmangirl14 It's never quite stated; in the book she just graduated from the conservatoire so she should be in early 20s
agnosticnixie 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The most complicated vocal compilation and performance in the entire play. When well performed live in theatre, without the privelage of editing, it is trully magnificent. I've been fortunate enough to see it happen only twice out of attending 50 performances. Once in New York, and once in London. Also, my favorite part of the movie. Thanks for posting. Well Done!
MagnetoMasterOfEvil 1 year ago
Comment removed
MagnetoMasterOfEvil 1 year ago
"Senora PARDON us!"
0Charlotte666 1 year ago
the magic of music
SamuelChung94 1 year ago
Sigh, I know this movie was decidedly different from the opera music of the musical, but even so, they could have gotten better people to at least be able to SING. And Minnie Driver's presence is so wasted. The movie focused too much on making it sexy and not, you know... good.
bwahahachick 1 year ago
What a way to run a business indeed!
arrieletjuh 1 year ago
Comment removed
ItsKelseyRemi 1 year ago
"and what is it that i'm meant to have wrote *thinks* written..." that just cracks me up.... xD I really miss Notes on the soundtrack. its just so brilliant.
Eldvingar 1 year ago 4
Bye bye Carly!!
DelilahAmelia 1 year ago
Andre's Of course not! and at about 6 minutes what does Madame giry say?
ChristinaDestler 1 year ago
@ChristinaDestler i dont hear the first thing, but i hear " the angel sees, the angel knows "
xHollyBolly 1 year ago
Andre's Of course not!
ChristinaDestler 1 year ago
"And what is it that we're meant to have wrote-- ah, written".
LOL. You have to appreciate a musical that cares more for proper grammar than whether or not a verse rhymes.
I love this song so much. It's one of my absolute favorites. Actually, it's in my top 5 fromPotO soundtrack.
Rx2D 1 year ago 6
i dont really like firmin here, hes singing alot slower
TheMibs56 1 year ago
I just LOVE how Raoul sounds here!!! After listening to Andre and Firmin it sounds amazing. And then, after listening to Carlotta, the Phantom is even more amazing than usual.
ChasingAllThoseStars 1 year ago 8
this used to scare me but know it doesnt
Lydni 1 year ago
this music is so much better than the music now a days
qwertyytrewq71 1 year ago