Added: 2 years ago
From: CarlSaganPortal
Views: 78,562
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (381)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i want that freakin warp drive moped

  • Its 2001: A Space Odyssey all over again

  • What is the proof of for example. I travel at the speed of light, and coming back from only a few minutes to find everyone i know has aged or gone? How do we know it's actually possible? It's mind boggling to say the least to say time stops for you, and a few minutes is actually decades. I want proof god damnit.

  • @matt876mma You cant travel at the speed of light, but near enough to it , time takes longer to tick at a faster speed, time in space is actually quicker than down here because the mass of the earth stretches and distorts space time. A moving clock takes longer to tick literally than a stationary one because atoms live longer at high speeds so there for it stretches time. A stationary atom decays alot faster than a moving one . Ive probably repeated myself, its proven you can look it up .

  • Comment removed

  • @youdontknowxpand we know it's possible. It happens on airplanes and on GPS satellites. Just search for time relativity on GPS...

  • So Neutrinos (supposedly) travel back in time? :0

  • @itubeyoudont we dont know for certainty whats happened yet i think 

  • carl sagans voice sounds vaguely simmilar to kermit the frogs

  • Crazy Italian scooters

  • Fuck, I want one of those scooters.

  • soo trippy when stoned

  • We need more people like Sagan and less dirtbag politicians and middle eastern dictators. In 1000 years we will either by far more advanced then we could ever dream, or we will be consigned to dwell on our weaknesses rather then our strengths.

  • last week the usa built a bomb that travels 5 times the speed of sound...

  • What a good little brother

  • This sort of rules out space travel since we would need to go near the speed of light and since you would come back decades later, you might leave and come back to see the destruction of earth.

  • I suspect Sagan would have loved the news that neutrinos may go faster than the speed of light. He would not have focused on what was wrong with his earlier point of view, but what the implications of this new discovery was. He would have considered this information the best information available at that time, and that's ok.

  • what it actually is going?? Because in a way you actually arnt travelling any faster, just say you find out someone close to you is dieing and you obviously wan to reach them in the quickest way possible, so lets say you use light speed yes to you, you arrive extreemely quick but to the observer you are delayed and might even miss there passing?? This stuff interests me but is confusing, someone care to explain?

  • @gogogogoguck Time dilation just slows down the passage of time for someone traveling at close to the speed of light. Time still moves at the same rate for everyone else. If I'm at the Sun, and I have to get back to Earth really fast, I could fly at nearly the speed of light and get there in eight or nine minutes according to everyone else; to me, it would seem to take far less.

  • to a person who is observing a ship approaching the speed of light would the ship seem as though it is slowing down as it is getting closer to light speed because time is slowing down to the ship so the observer would see this as well? Another way to put it is there is a track the ship and the people on it are travelling around this track at light speed to them the journey only takes 4 mins from point A to B but to the oberservers it takes hours so to the observers would the ships slower than..

  • I'm confused. If you slow down travelling near the speed of light... Isn't that saying you slow down as you speed up? Whaaaat? ._.

  • @BlockisticStudios It meant that you experience time at a slower rate than an observer as you travel closer to the speed of light.

  • @btkw

    But wouldn't that make light travel slower than it actually does? Wait. Does this only apply to matter? Still. Hrm.

  • @BlockisticStudios I'm no expert but i do know that light particles are massless, maybe that has something to do with it.

  • @btkw They do have mass. They don't have mass when stationary, which means you can't stop photons, they will either be absorbed completely or reflected completely. An example would be black holes, which suck in light, solely because they have mass. We also can observe stars that are hidden behind other stars because the light gets slightly bent by the star's mass and manages to pass around the star that would block our view.

  • @BlockisticStudios Lets say you have two persons in a room for 1 hour.One having fun with his friends, and other being extremely bored and having nothing to do.. even though they will spend same time in room,to one person time will appear as if going really fast, to other quite the opposite. When your brain is going "faster" and having fun, your perception of time changes and what appears as few minutes to you, to someone it feels as few hours

  • @velidagovic

    But with the speed of light, isn't time for you actually slower? Like, time affects your chemical makeup more slowly or... Sigh.

  • red light shift

  • Image watching this on tryptamines...

  • neutrinos. that is all.

  • @BranZyme Hasn't been proven yet.

  • @Jonmad17

    Fuck off and stop living in denial. They did the test months before they released the data about it.

  • @Germanboy567 Chill. Even CERN aren't 100% sure, that's why they released the data and asked the scientific community to confirm it. Every single verifiable test has been within margin of errors.

  • @BranZyme no, no it isn't. it isn't possible for any of us to completely understand or even come close to what the CERN guys are thinking. the whole idea that the neutrino went faster than light is an explanation for the data they gathered.

  • @BranZyme Actually, there's been significant and substantial evidence for that not being true. I encourage you to look up the criticisms and papers published arguing for the results not holding weight to the conclusion.

  • @BranZyme not proven

  • GPS sattelies is a good example of a modern day appliance that HAS to take time dilation into account. Time does not tick at the same rate for us and the satellites, they are in weaker gravity and they move faster thus time dilation is in effect. Satellites internal clocks need to be resynced constantly or the positions would be FAR OFF since your position is calculated from the time it takes the signal to reach the sattelites, if the clock is wrong the time would be wrong and so would your pos.

  • I'm too high for this.

  • this just blew my mind lol

  • I want that bike

  • Is anyone else a little sad at what happened to Paulo and Vincenzo?

  • Shrooms - not even once.

  • this kid is trippin balls, just sayin

  • Is this why in Tron everything was blue and red?

  • Manly tears were shed.

  • This scene is one of the most incredible moments I've ever seen, ever, in a TV show.

  • Comment removed

  • Stupid. "THIS IS A THOUGHT EXPERIMENT" Get that through your heads.

  • @intoxicatednix make no mistake that special relativity is an observed phenomenon (which makes Einstein even more amazing, given that his thought experiments in the early 20th century have all been conclusively proven to be correct). The fact that this is a thought experiment doesn't mean much - Sagan's deriving, from empirically observed facts and scientific laws accounting for these facts, certain truths about what would indeed happen if someone were to travel at close to the speech of light.

  • if he was gone for decades... What about the fuel in the bike? Oh I get it... the bike has nothing to do with it... it's just today's means of travel.

  • Time paradox

  • lmao. Why would somebody wait that long for a brother riding on a scooter?

  • Everyone should watch this stoned at least once.

  • @Guttermouth I had the same thought before reading the comments. lol

  • What a legend Carl Sagan is... World needs more like him!

  • imagin him smashing into a wall at the speed of light....BACK TO DA FUTA

  • He experiences something even stranger... His brother accidentally gave him a glass of water with LSD.

  • My father introduced me to this video when I was about 12 or 13 years old. I was old enough to understand what they were suggesting, but not quite old enough to stick around long enough to realize that we can't really travel at the speed of light yet.

    So, naturally, I went and got my scooter--motor powered. I considered replicating what I'd seen here (or attemtping to) but then decided not to, because I didn't want to age so slowly while everyone I loved aged and withered away.

  • @Oveld

    Please leave your zealot ranting off a scientific post please. You're as welcome as a mosquito.

  • @Boywithouthat44 -- How old are you? 12?

  • if we can't even see through the lies of men, what chance will we stand against the Father of lies?

  • I have never heard the Speed of Light explained in such a depressing way.

  • @manwithouthat44 man i love his voice

  • @manwithouthat44 dude whats wrong with you not everyone has a extremely high pitched voice like justin bieber

  • @darkmaster24i1 its more how he empathizes everything. nothing against the man

  • look atwhat roflcopter is saying to me hes a n ass

  • 1 person went to the speed of light and got stuck in a paradox

  • @ubercoolist You're not funny. These jokes are not funny. I hate you.

  • @Roflcopter4b wtf i guess you cant take a joke

  • @ubercoolist What? What joke? What am I supposed to take? That statement is only valid when the joke is at my expense. Which it is not. Be more creative or die in fire. People are sick and tired of these pathetic, overused, pointless "jokes." My the fury of a thousand flames take you.

  • @Roflcopter4b dude chill you freaking creep

  • @ubercoolist I suppose. Death is indeed too good for you. Your life will be long,pointless, and painful.

  • @Roflcopter4b i made a joke now leve me alone i really dont care what you say to me because you are just some random creeper that picks on kids and trys to rape them

  • @ubercoolist I love it when people literally can think of no way to defend themselves and resort to cheap insults. Keep it up. You only bury yourself further.

  • @Roflcopter4b its a joke other people made jokes on this video to chill the fuck down and come back when you get some damn self control

  • @ubercoolist I'm completely in control. You're the one making lousy, overused, pathetic jokes. Lesson is, an please do learn it, THINK BEFORE YOU SLAP SOME COMMENT ON A VIDEO. Will someone actually want to read this?

  • @Roflcopter4b thts the thing i do know it so i wanted to make a joke because i already know it and im sorry if i offended you but im done fighting

  • How could anyone consciously dislike this video? This video explains a fairly complex idea so simply that anyone can understand it. Carl Sagan was one of the greatest human beings to ever exist. I would gladly give up the entire cast of Jersey Shore for just one more Carl.

  • @CElkins0011 Jersey Shore? I would give up every reality show that exists, and basically ever show that is on television if Carl comes to existence again.

  • @BallerzTV haha agreed. Obviously there is an infinite number of idiots I would gladly trade for another Carl but that was the first group of idiots I could think of haha

  • I used to watch this happily with my parents when I was a child. I remember this scene very vividly. I'm amazed to see it again on youtube after all these years.

  • I just learned an entire chapter of my physics textbook with this video.

  • "grown up, moved on, and died..." HAHA!

  • @horbergaren

    i lol'd

  • If hell is where Cal Sagan is, that's where I want go

  • If hell is where Cal Sagan is, that's where I want go

  • gracias por subir el video

    Saludos.

  • so...ultimately you go the same distance in the same amount of time...or a far greater amount of time? you perceive it as traveling ultra-fast, but everyone else perceives it at regular speed? theres either something fundamentally wrong or carls just too damn smart for me.

  • /watch?v=S4hjoT7ttnY

  • smoke weed every day

    

  • Haha this is so trippy

  • Mind=blown.

  • I wondered if ET existed in the andromeda galaxy and we sent a vessle of some sort near the speed of light to them and back it would still take centuries before we know of its findings. If it was maned then they would have come back to the future and may find flying Deloreans! Sick!

  • So a photon is a light "particle" (I know, I know), and it travels at the speed of light. So it experiences 0% of the time that the rest of the world experiences.

    The photon's journey, to the photon, seems instantaneous. If this photon is emitted by a light bulb, its travel from the filament to your eye - to the photon - is instantaneous. This means that to the photon, time does not exist, and all of its positions occur simultaneously.

  • @sobeita Okay, 10thdim.

  • The end had me choking up

  • So insecure are people about their own views they have to criticize an alternate point of thinking when that's not even the subject of the video? Goddamn, you Atheists and Theists are just buttfuck stupid.

  • OK, but I don't believe the view would retreat  and dilate so symmetrically. X-D

  • Mind equals fucked.

  • makes sense, when i close my eyes in the car for about 5 minutes and open them everything seems bluer

  • Jesus. I'll take some of whatever he's smoking.

  • Paolo be trippin serious balls

  • "Your NOSE is just a little closer to me than your ears."

  • Having a bug hit you, when you're traveling at the speed of light..... WOULD SUCK! :)

  • @ghpink Having a bug hit you at the speed of light might go right through you! It's gotta go somewhere.

  • @Lakerbballfan Maybe :) According to Einsteins theories, a bug traveling at the speed of light (which it can't be done) would have 0 mass. So it's all good. This is being revised by the String theory, so maybe Einstein was wrong. At any rate, getting hit with bugs SUCKS! Even 0 mass bugs. At least for the bug it does :) haha

  • @ghpink Yeah, and a bug traveling at the speed of light would flatten out and disintegrate well before it hit us! Our own bodies at 4Gs I think, would endure being crushed. The bug? At 40mph it splats on a windshield. So much for the speed of light! lol

  • @ghpink Technically it's the other way around- things with zero mass travel at the speed of light. ;)

  • Can still remember watching this as a kid and being blown away

  • Italians sure know how to make a bike

  • @talking1717 It's a scooter.

  • jeez this is awsome after a smoke lol...just needs a pink floyd soundtrack behind it.

  • Comment removed

  • I watched this on Cosmos the other day, and completely blew my mind. Why the F*CK isn't the world funding research of this?! TIME TRAVEL IS TECHNICALLY POSSIBLE FOR F*CKS SAKE. Ok bye. :] Ps. F*ck.

  • @BedroomBassist Nope. Causality. You can only move forward.

  • @UltimaXG2 Oh yeah I realise that.. but it's still pretty amazing!

  • @BedroomBassist Yep. And, conveniently, it makes fast-traveling across the galaxy completely and utterly impractical.

  • In short, light is always traveling the same speed, then again we define space and time by light so light is always going straight too, it's the universe that curves and slows down.

    Sidenote for anyone interested

    With the LHC now its cool, H+ going ~the speed of light, get added energy, so they, instead of going faster, expand in size.

  • I don't understand how they can age differently.. like why can't they be growing at the same time.. Fucks my mind up

  • @lazer46 Time travels slower for you if you're travelling near the speed of light. What seems like 10 minutes at 200,000 Km/s might be 10 years for those standing still. I know, it's extremely odd, but that's why it's so interesting! :D

  • @onlynameithoughtof That is a really confusing paradox:  instead of traveling fast to save time, one would have to give many years to light speed to be able to travel in a destination that would feel like a short time.

  • @uploader109

    Paolo: I'm in a hurry, gotta go now

    Vinchenzo: ok, just don't travel near the speed of light

    Paolo: O_O

  • tige55, even if it took a decade to accelerate to the speed of light, you would still have to accelerate by 30,000 km/s every year. That's about 82 km/s acceleration increase every day. Which is equal to 295,200 km/h every day.

  • @stuckvanilla I was meaning over like hundreds of years haha. By the time we have developed systems to even try to reach light speed we would have to create some crazy dampening fields to counter the inertia that would destroy you, is what I am saying. Like a time dilution field or a inertial dampening field.

  • The Italians sure make some sick mopeds

  • that kid is trippin on acid.

  • for decades people saw the coloured object that would pass by in an instant. until finally it stopped, at which point a boy named poalo appeared.

  • god dammit

  • Vincenzo: Is it my turn yet, Paulo?

  • to alot this must have been a mind fuck

  • Why does the time go much faster because you travel the speed of light?

    Then the time should go slower for the people around you, and in their point of view it should look like you're moving really slow

  • @Galentw that's what I still cannot understand. Traveling at the speed of light to an observer would actually be considered a very slow way to travel if time for them goes by faster than for those traveling at near light speed.

  • this is the saddest story ever

  • I doubt that we will ever use light speeds to travel around the universe,Who would volunteer for a journey knowing that when you return,All your friends and relatives would be dead.

  • @arobekie its the only way to travel farther than we can now

  • whoa i didn't get it

    WHY DID TIME PASS FASTER?.....

  • @Galentw time itself didn't pass faster, the kid on the moped was moving so fast, time 'dilated' in/around him

  • @Galentw If you look at it like this, if your travling in a car, and your driving east, the faster you go, the shorter the time it takes for you to get there, and if you go faster then the speed of light, or at the speed of light, it takes you MUCH less time for YOU to get there, however, the world has gone slower then you

  • So... Traveling at the speed of light is actually in the normal (world as we know it now) world a slower method of travel?...

  • Even if you went with 10 times the speed of light, you will still not get there in time. Some places are millions of light if not billions of light years away.

    __ You want to get there? You talk to me! __

    :)

  • @MeX2004 Yeah but if you went 10 times the speed of light, your concept of time would change radically.

  • @TehAl3X I would not get into time dilation thingy at this time.

    I used to think that what a waste of beautiful and huge universe. Then I notice something almost unbelievable and impossible. Did you know that trillions of tons of material is being transported throughout the galaxy but we cannot see how but we can only see it once it get there? In other words, you cannot see or detect the matter the whole time it is in transit but you can see it once it appears at the destination.

  • @TehAl3X I had to use a little logic that if millions of tons/sec of material shows up at point B than it must have originated somewhere far at point A. You just cannot detect it while it is in transit only when it gets to the destination. This tells me that there is another way of transport through space we are just not aware of where distance between point A and point B means little. The only thing I am not sure of is that whether there is a short distance involved or is it instantaneous.

  • The waiter starts cracking up @ 4:19 . hes like wtf are u saying?

  • Speed of light is very friggin fast

  • perfect explanation

  • Why we do not care about the factor of speed and time when we calculate the distance between the Earth and the Sun.

  • would it be hard to drive a moped at the spedd of light

  • @HappyGamerMan Not if you tune it up enough, my friend done it a couple of years ago... havn't seen him since

  • @HappyGamerMan , Sagan is presupposing a universe in which the speed of light is about 40 mph, for the sake of giving viewers an example that's easy to think about.

  • @HappyGamerMan Sagan is presupposing a universe in which the speed of light is about 40 mph, for the sake of giving viewers an example that's easy to think about.

  • @theseaotter He was a master at explaining brilliant and complicated thoughts and ideas ina way that common folks like us could understand and that's a rare gift.. hopefully there will be another like him..

  • @HappyGamerMan It would be hard to do anything at the

    speed of light.  If you've ever been on an airplane then you

    about the "G force" feeling you get when taking off. In an

    airplane : You are only traveling at a few hundred MPH.

    If you were traveling at the speed of light : Then it would surely

    kill you. At least that is what I am thinking.

  • @tomdugan123 It's not the speed that's the problem, it's the acceleration (how quickly you are _changing_ speed). Once the plane is in level flight, you're going a few hundred miles an hour, but you can move with no problem- you're not accelerating. SImilarly, going near light speed wouldn't prove fatal as long as you get up to speed gradually.

  • @kailefipne @tomdugan123 Its partly right.

    Its because of gravity that you will get killed from acceleration. If you accelerate in zero gravity, you will not feel and G-force acting upon you. Hence, traveling at speed of light will not kill you. Mind you everything has a gravity, anything with mass has gravity, it just depends on how much mass (gravity) that object has to influence the force that acts upon you when you accelerate.

  • @RotaryKnight Yes, but doesn't relativity posit that as your speed approaches the speed of light, your mass approaches infinity?

  • @zakalwe30 if that was true, light waves would be making holes in us.

  • @zakalwe30 I know what you mean though, Im am not experienced in these sort of things, I only have basic understanding of sorts.

    people say mass is increased as you reach closer to speed of light, but from what I understand, people confuse mass with momentum, or energy

  • @RotaryKnight zakalwe30 is right. Mass does approach infinity. So my rest mass is 80kg but if I travel very fast it increases. Photons have a rest mass of 0, so when they travel at the speed of light, this is multiplied by a factor of infinity. So that is why photons have a finite mass.

  • @RotaryKnight Wrong. Newtonian physics state that an object in motion will stay in motion, and an object at rest will stay at rest unless acted upon by an outside force. If you were to suddenly accelerate to the speed of light, you would disintegrate because of this law. Your body does not want to go that fast. The acceleration of 0 to 183000 miles per second would tear you to shreds. The Force would be infinity. F = ma. If a is infinite, then you have infinite force on you.

  • @plzplz12232 What if the acceleration to light speed took years? If you increased your speed so minutely that you barely felt the acceleration? would you still be ripped to shreds? haha

  • @tige55 in other words, yes, that shit will fuck you up badly.

  • my jizz flys at the speed of light!

  • @duhhh187 "my jizz flys at the speed of light!" What? At least Hirosima bomb level event every time you jizz? Your life must be hard. :)

  • I remember watching this while in my 8th grade science class. This explained things so much.

  • How do we know that at the speed of light images become "smaller"?

  • I remember watching this when it first aired on tv - god I feel old! RIP Carl Sagan.

  • so going 99.9% the speed of light slows time down significantly for you, yet your still moving about the universe at 99.9% the speed of light, would this mean that instead of witnessing 300000km go by every second you would see the universe passing many times faster? effectively from your perception going "warp speed"?

  • Intelligent men are soooo sexy. I need one of those.

  • @AAnneC your on the wrong website to meet any of those!!

  • Speed of light is a known law, but it is modified by the fact the each part of the Universe--to the smallest parts--has its own time effect. Relativity really is profound, that a beam-of-light, from your flashlight, on a train traveling