Added: 5 years ago
From: fevercity
Views: 171,445
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (539)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Gretings Japaneses... !!

    BANZAI !!!

  • Comment removed

  • man, before i die, clint eastwood n ken watanabe r one of the few ppl i wanna meet.

  • Comment removed

  • japanese imperialism is motived by superiority, but only superiority of japanese towards people from asia, not others race.

    One of their way of propaganda which lot of soldiers and citizens believed was that they thought that USA or europenas countries could invade them, that's why they motived the colonisation as an excuse.

    Soldiers fight for the values they believe, and at the end ofthe day, you can't say one is totaly good or bad, this movie shows it.

    Very good movie...

  • MrFattyfatass is probably some fat red neck racist who has the confederate flag tattooed on his stomach..Lets just say a one Japanese soldier could take him and 5 of his friends and not care about dying

  • One of the best movies ever made much better then Flag of our fathers and i felt more for japanese then i did for americans.

  • This battle was was less than 70 years ago. It's hard to believe that we will never fight wars like that ever again with the technology we've developed since then.

    I'm an American, and I actually liked this film better than Flags of our Fathers.

  • cowardly dog japs , you hid in the ground and refused battle, but 23900 of you died against 6300 marines.

  • @MrFattyfatfatboy Congratulations, you made another pointless and unaccurate theory that no one gives a shit about! Please go home and die.

  • @TheProgramPirate congrats for the japs for rewriting history and making them selves human , im Australian and i dont forgive japs war crimes dogs.

  • @MrFattyfatfatboy Wow Autralian eh? Well I'm Filipino but I don't hate all Japanese, because there are good and bad men of each side, You probably didn't watch Letters from Iwo Jima that's why you can give sympathy to them. Plus they've done more war crimes in Asia rather in Autralia.

  • @TheProgramPirate

    The same cane be said about anyone who weren't screwed over. I for one don't hate Iraqis, my father never spoke ill of the Vietnamese. But my grandfather hated the Japaneses till the day he died.

    Lets face it none of your friends were hurt or killed by the Japanese, this all happened a long time ago hence you don't have a frame of reference against them.

  • @TheProgramPirate your filipino so yes what the japs did there was insane, yet if you go to japan it will be you who will be seen as the agressor,they have written history.

  • @MrFattyfatfatboy You're only seeing the Western's perspective, have you even watched the movie? I hated Japan because of WW2 Until I saw this movie, do not revolve on only one's perspective.

  • @TheProgramPirate you dont know what they did if you think that raping killing and genocide the japs commited were faIR.

  • @MrFattyfatfatboy I know what they did, oh please, I have a degree in Philippine history, just because there were some cruel Japanese doesn't I have to hate them all, there are good and bad people on each side. A lot of them didn't wanted to fight, they were forced the the emperor and the Kempeitai would arrest them if they think of declining. Stop thinking that you know my history better than me.

  • @MrFattyfatfatboy Plus, the "destruction" caused by Japan on Australia is incomparable to what they did on us, those aircraft carriers weren't Australian, they were filled with U.S troops. And I'm not nor will I ever defect to Japan

  • @MrFattyfatfatboy All your accusations of raping shits were right but don't you know that the American raped many japanese women when japan was occupied? Don't look from one perspective, I'm an Indonesian and trust me, the Dutch in your eyes were an innocent country which got invaded by the German in WW2 but you don't know what they did to us that time, it was horrible...

  • @TheProgramPirate

    A Movie changed your perspective on Japan role in WW2???? Why don't you try reading some books about Japans role in WW2, Start with the Rape of Nanking.

  • @CSATexan Yeah, It changed my perspective, you know why? Almost every book and movie classifies all Japanese soldiers were evil and merciless. This movie taught me that all soldiers didn't want to kill or fight, they were just forced.

  • @TheProgramPirate

    You mean all the movies made by Japan victims??

  • @CSATexan You're not understanding a single word I'm typing. Disregard this, acquire ponies

  • @TheProgramPirate

    I understand everything your posting it is your premise that I disagree with.

    Or to put it in PC Terminology (IE NEWSPEAK) How many positive stories about the Nazis would it take to change your mind about them??

  • @CSATexan Bottom line is, I don't blame the troops, I blame the Leaders for waging war.

  • @TheProgramPirate

    These "troops" went about on a violent rampage through Asia murder millions of people.

    Were all of the guilty?? Not all of them not even the majority of them.

    But all of the innocent troops fought to defend the guilty ones as they committed their crimes.

  • @MrFattyfatfatboy Before posting BS, try doing some research so you don't sound so stupid. The actual casualty numbers are easily found so why the crap? "Refused battle"....you are truly ignorant. 6,821 Marines died and 21,788 Japanese died. Now you don't have to hurt yourself looking.

  • @Toddinfantry dont defend those dogs the japs.

  • @MrFattyfatfatboy "Dog Japs"??? Really? How old are you, because you act about 12. Those Japanese soldiers defended an island totally and gave as good as they got. History defends them, not me. Yes, the Japanese soldiers did do many horrific acts, but as a whole the Japanese soldier was one hell of a warrior. I do not defend them, I defend the truth. The truth from over 40 years of research, learning and digging in the shadows.

  • @MrFattyfatfatboy Your numbers are wrong...way wrong and get over the "Jap dog" crap. You weren't there, you didn't suffer so you have no room to call them names. The Japanese soldier dug in and fought with skill and tenacity. Comments like yours show the greatest of ignorance.

  • @MrFattyfatfatboy "you hid in the ground and refused battle, but 23900 of you died against 6300 marines."

    It's called military strategy idiot. It's those same tactics that the Afghans used to beat the Soviets, the same tactics the NVA and VC used to beat the US. You think war is about showing your face and fighting fairly? Drop the Call of Duty and get a reality check. Do some military research.

    BTW, real mature to say "dog japs" in a movie meant to clean negative Japanese image.

  • EVERYBODY ITS STILL FUCKED UP YOU DONT BOMB A MILLION CIVILIONS JUST TO WIN AN ALREADY WON WAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @Namelessjack14

    Well Mr Arm Chair General. If the war was already won why didn't Japan surrender???

  • @Namelessjack14 Yea, well why dont you tell that to the 3000 sailors and marines in pearl harbor!! Sleeping or brushin their teeth when they were bombed. Japan Started the war and we finished it because they wouldnt surrender because they were to damn buisy running planes into our ships!!!!

  • @MrJMAN1955 it wasnt the japanese's choice to go kamikaze and yea well in my opinion were america yea japan killed many lives in pearl harbor but we killed millions of civilians which was not needed

  • @Namelessjack14

    Of course that is your opinion, You didn't have anything to loose. Far as your concerned the Japanese just sat around all day thinking up of ways to create Pokemon type cartoons.

    Let me ask you this. What would be the point that could make you support the bombing a Japanese city?? Could it be that the Japanese were executing down pilots.

    How about their executing POWs?

    How about their targeting medical teams?

  • @MrJMAN1955 Oh yeah, and the USA answered back with the most devastating weapon of all time, TWICE! That 3000 can't be compared to nearly half a million. And the US never apologized that massacre...

  • @CzombiPC

    Massacre???

    To start with when is Japan going to apologize for murdering US POWs??? Hell while we are at it didn't Japanese POW camp commanders receive orders to kill all allied POWs at the start an Allied invasion???

  • Regardless of all the racist comments, this battle was historically accurate. There are good humans on both sides of the battle. Whether it was Nazis, or Japs, there are good individuals that lived and died in battle. End the wars, end the hate

  • i have absolutely no fucking respect for them japanese monkeys

  • @Mills117 Why should people have respect for you?

  • @187nydala not me, the US. Japan tortured its American POW's. We didn't

  • @Mills117 America probably commit some of the worst war crime during WWII. But you probably didn't know that right?

  • @187nydala what the a-bomb? ya i know about that dipshit. it was either bomb them or lose over 1 million american lives. i think they deserved it. they were even dumb enough not to surrender after the first one so we had to drop another........

  • @Mills117 not only that, in Europe the americans and the british bombed relentlessly killing more civilians than you can imagen, and leveling whole cities to the ground. And the the POW that the Americans took, were not always kept alive. You see, its the victor that writes the history. 

  • @187nydala we DID NOT torture the POW's thats the point im trying to get at. and we didn't bomb cities for no reason, there had to be a reason

  • @Mills117 wow really? because yes you did. You killed off and tortured japs. You bomb raided Germany way too much. The us killed thousands if ten thousands civilians in Germany. See you are filled up with american propaganda.

  • @187nydala it was just us the bombed germany? and again, we bombed them at certain points, not meaning to kill civilians. and what proof do you have that we killed and "tortured" japs? even IF we did, it was to no extent of the japanese

  • @Mills117 see your trying to rationalize torture. "not to the extent" you are so filled up with propaganda. And the bombing by the allies. (Mostly UK and US) killed at least half a million all over the world.

  • @187nydala proof that we tortured POW's? and the civilians that we bombed? i bet every single spot bombed was oil, factories, or bases. not meaning to kill civilians

  • @187nydala Yeah, don't forget about the 20+ million Russian who died under Stalin's communist reign and Hitler's Fascist extermination attempt of the Jews. NO government is perfect, Democracy is the best of them all.

  • @187nydala

    That was the war that Axis initiated against the allies. Why do you sound shocked that the allies used a somewhat similar tactic.

  • @CSATexan because the allied were suposed to be the "good guys" yet they kill almost a million civilians. Thats not good.

  • @187nydala

    So the US and UK just went about killing German people for no reason what so ever. The US was kicking back watching some silly game of Baseball and one day said. "FUCK THIS IS BORING LETS GO KILL SOME GERMANS."

    That is what happened in the war right???

  • @CSATexan when did I say that? War itself is a crime. But it's funny how the victors write the history. Why were the allies so good? the "heros" were not that much better than the "evil" axis.

  • @187nydala

    hmmmm lets see, just what did the Japanese do to occupied nations and compare that to what the US did to occupied Japan.

  • @CSATexan stop the comparing, both are bad, If I kill your friend and you kill my friend, are you a good guy for doing that?

  • @187nydala

    Depends, perhaps your friend is a child molester who liked to shove his cock into little girls. Then ya, I would say that guy needs killing

  • @CSATexan You still killed a man, and not only ONE man but a million of innocent ones, You did not only kill the molester, you killed his entire family now, and the friends of the family, and they were all innocent.

  • @CSATexan ok, But thats not what you only did, you also killed his innocent family and friends to the family, who were all innocent.

  • @187nydala

    First of all I didn't do crap, I wasn't even alive during the war.

    But I will play the game by your rules. HOW DO YOU MAKE JAPAN QUIT?

  • @187nydala: The Nazis started the war in Europe, and the Japanese started the war in Asia. Both countries fought in the hitherto most inhumane way. I can't really see how anyone can complain that both Germany and Japan got a dose of the very same medicine that they had administered to their victims.

    One shouldn't forget either that both Germany and Japan were treated relatively nicely after teh war. I dare not think how Hitler and Hirohito would have acted if they had won the war.

  • @ErichMustermann1 So how is what the allied did not a war crime? Bombing Europe to its core. Killing a million civilians. Is that not a crime yes or no?

  • @187nydala: The Nazis started bombing civilian targets in Poland, France and the Netherlands and didn't give a damn how many non-combattants they killed. They went on to carry out air raids against British civilian targets, so little wonder that Britain, which unlike Poland or France had a significant air force, decided to hit back. This is simply what happens when you start a war. If you can't handle your enemy's strike-back, you'd better not start a f*cking war, that's all there is to say.

  • @187nydala

    You didn't answer the question. HOW DO YOU MAKE JAPAN QUIT? SURRENDER? GIVE UP?

    How ever yo want to call it

  • @Mills117  actually you did, but your country doesn't want you to know....like usual

  • @TalonMercenary ya sure we did clearly japan didn't cover it up

  • I thought this film was excellent. It is important to remember and reflect on the struggle and ordeal of the average infantry soldier, regardless of the side they fight on and to recognize that soldiers inherent humanity. One thing cannot be quibbled about though: the brutish, racist evil that fueled Japanese imperialism. At their height, they were killing 20,000 civilians a week. Atrocities on both sides? Yes, absolutely. Comparable in size, scope and degree of inhumanity? Not even close.

  • @Dusted000 I agree 100% with everything you said intill "Comparable in size scope and degree of inhumanity? Not even close" All i have to say is the atomic bomb. There is NO WAY atomic weapons were used on civilians without a racist evil attitude toward the people of japan. It was a risk America was willing to take. To me that is the exact racist evil fueled by both sides.

  • @compooky You can say, "There is NO WAY...", but that doesn't make it so. Was there a racist hatred for the Japanese by American GI's? Of Course. Was that why they dropped the atomic bomb? Of course not. Read up on the battles of Guadalcanal, Peleliu, and Okinawa. 50,000 American casualties on Okinawa alone. The invasion of Japan would have been the biggest bloodbath in history, exceeding the bombs. When you see 2500 dead men come back every week, ending the war, not race, is what's important.

  • @compooky And I would also suggest you read up on the torture, rape, murder and enslavement that the Japanese inflicted on their neighbors and those who fought them. Again...atrocities on all sides? Yes. Equal in scope and inhumanity. Not. Even. Close.

  • @Dusted000 germany and japan work as perfect examples of why people have to be cerfull. it culd happen here. those people where no difrent from us. hell, it acutaly has happend in usa, slavery, the indian genocide. best way to fight against inhumanity is cold and hard education.

  • @gethsoftware Your examples are flawed. Slavery is a system that has been perpetrated by every race, color and creed throughout human existence. Because American's in the antebellum south 150 years ago continued to practice it does not mean we are "no different". Japan and Germany both invaded numerous countries and slaughtered their peoples by the millions...65 years ago. I believe that we are all capable of awful things. But the US is simply too multi-ethnic to go down those identical paths .

  • At the archaelogical site at the start of the film, I think Clint must have surely said at some point to the crew "There are two kinds of people in this film, those with guns, and those who dig. You dig".

  • every body in world war 2 was brave and storgest and some are weekly war mean be storg and rights

  • This movie is a masterpiece. Everything from the cast to the music was excellent. Important to see the other side to every story

  • Watch Letters from Iwo Jima first before Flags of Our Fathers.

  • @toMUCHskillHD

    I did....because I was more interested in the Japanese side anyway. Im leaning towsrds liking Letters from Iwo Jima better as the Japanese soldiers (well, some officers) may have been fucking dicks but a lot of them looked like decent people. How the US marines acted was a bit more annoying. Then again ive seen enough roughhousing/macho bullshit IRL so the marines' behavior reminded me of that more hence my bias.

  • @Warsie It's true, we always percieve the Japanese as these animalistic killers out for American blood, but ultimately many of them were as brave and courageous as us in many aspects. However, not so sure about most of them being good people esp. the ones who attacked China... the idea of Japanese supremacy was pretty well stamped in and the Japanese style of subjugation took war back 600 years.

  • @horeslayer

    regarding the second sino-japanese war, I guess it depended on the soldiers. The Nanjing Incident shows there was a lot of dickishness, and some of that came from officers ("three alls" policy in northern China). Not to mention other things.

  • @Warsie doesn't matter... If I was the one doing the killing, raping and stealing, even if I was just following orders, I would still be very much in the wrong.

  • @horeslayer

    the massacres in china were well helped by chinese collaborators who served japanese interest, just like french collaborators helped nazis during France occupation. Lot of people tend to forget that, that's was the same in indochina and dutch colonies in Asia. The european forces in these countries collaborated to the massacres too.

    Japanese imperialism was evil, but the worst is that big part of german or japanese soldiers were maintened in ignorance about that.

  • @tatianaf1000 Helped is a key word here. The Japanese were still largely the ones who carried it out. Does that mean that every Japanese soldier knew about this across the front? Of course not. Did the Japanese military leadership still sanction this massacre? Absolutely.

  • @horeslayer

    i agree but the collaborators (the elites ones at least) perfectly knew that what the japaense elite was doing was bad, but they still choose to collaborate (the same as nazi collaborators), what means that they are at last as responsible as them, i think that these collaborators were never judged and some of them highly participate in some crimes like the Naking massacre.

    People tend to forget that these collaborators were one of the reasons of japan "sucess"to conquer and kill.

  • @tatianaf1000 I'm not arguing that they're just as guilty, but it was the Japanese's idea and it certainly doesn't detract from their role as the main perpetrators. Just because someone else helped doesn't make them any less guilty.

  • It's a shame we glorify hideous monsters. We should bury and forget those men rather than give them pride and respect. They don't deserve it.

  • @Redtrooper2 What monsters?

    

  • Ken Watanabe was a PERFECT pick for this movie. He is one of my favorite actors to begin with. One thing I strongly suggest, is watching first "Flags of our Fathers" and then "Letters from Iwo-Jima" together. It makes the story of the battle all the more poignant.

  • I will never understand how war is until were in one.

  • did the american live or die ????

  • @chucknorris742617000 dead in the morning of second day, with smile on his face 

  • ANYONE WHO FUKENS talk shit about Eastwood can KISS MY aSS!!!!!!!!

  • This film is a lot better than Saving Private Ryan.

  • His movie Grantrino is also great movie!!!

  • I really like how he put scenes from flags of our fathers in Letters, really lets us know that its all clint eastwood, great movies both of them.

    BTW, everybody, today, as I type this comment, it is the date of the flag raising over Mt. Suribachi, pray with me, and lets honor the souls of those that lost their lives on that Island.

  • These are two films that SHOULD have won best picture hands down. Instead we got... what? I can't even remember.

  • クールな悲しい映画

    

  • is the other called flags from iwo jima?

  • @soulleskill  "Flags of our Fathers"

  • @soulleskill

    no it was flags from our fathers

  • hands down ! >-- Downfall was the best

  • best film ive ever seen

  • Great film. Better than anything that ass wipe Spike Lee ever produced.

  • This is way better than Flags of Our Fathers. Letters of Iwo Jima made an impact on me, whereas Flags of Our Fathers in my opinion just was a war movie among others.

    I guess its the cultural differences. Americans just attack a place with totally overpowered forces and cry, when 10 of their own die. The Japanese were blown to pieces, but many of them just fought on.

    Then again, mabye I see resemblance between this war and the Winter war and thus cheer for the Japanese in this movie...

  • @SaunaFinland true my friend nut their all movies you never know how it really was .

  • @SaunaFinland true my friend but their all movies you never know how it really was .

  • he shud of won... 

  • i laugh when i seen that cover art for iwo jima

    手纸=toliet paper!

  • @sam9116 Original meaning of the word was a paper in a pocket or on your desk. Chinese used it as toilet paper. Japanese used it for memo paper.

  • @sam9116 No. It's 手紙 not 手纸 ;) And it doesn't mean memo paper as w88w88 said, it's just "letter" nowadays. I can imagine it's fun for Chinese people though ^^

  • My Father was in World War II. He was in the Navy Air Corps. They treated the Japanese Detainees very well. They gave them the food to prepare the way they wanted it, and they gave them whatever was needed to sustain them. They never tortured them. Wish I could say the same for the Japanese to our American Soldiers. Yes, war is a terrible thing. War is a punishment for sin. Man's inhumanity to man is due to a flawed soul! Let the Japanese make their own film.

  • @caroln1858 Didnt you watch the video? Clint made a movie first on the american side and then a movie on the other side, japan. it show the humanity of the two sides and the inhumanity of the war

  • @caroln1858 your stupid u probably play cod waw all day. Im american and i actually like it more wen directors show a bunch of americans dieing u know y? because litterally every movie is with a bunch of Germans Italians and japanese getting killed when they were just like us. And this was the first movie i saw from the axis prospective. This is my favorite ww2 movie hands down. I hate fellow americans like u, go kill urself from getting mad from that unrealistic cod waw shit.

  • First of all, thanks for uploading this. Second, no matter what country you are from, no one will like the horrors of war. It's a cruel world we live in, and hopefully the United States, no, the world, to ever have a battle like Iwo Jima. I pay my respects.

  • This was better than flags of our fathers in my opinion.

  • Wonderful movie, Not alot of movies I know that portays the enemy's point of view.

  • i wish they woukd play it in the cinema  :((

  • Japanese were brave in world war 2

  • @lol02468 yeah, especially when they were slaughtering chinese

  • @lol02468 yes they were brave, but also cruel, disgusting, unhuman and etc... this movie were focused only in fancy... they showed a captain who is kind to the prisoners and a soldier who is incapable to kill a fly all this with a honorific music... amazing bullshit!

  • @kitsune090 different culture.

  • letters was much better than flags because it was actually about the conflict instead of about the selling bond

  • how can the guy at 4:20 get hit when the shots gets past him ?? :/

  • @omgomg113

    When the plane shoots like that, it's not plain bullets going down. They aren't straight forward, since the aircraft isn't. It moves in the air, even though the sands is a straight line. Well almost, so i can see your point ;)

  • Eastwood is senile and is dishonest. There was only one US marine taken prisoner by the Japs on Iwo his name was Ralph Ignatowski. Compare the film with reality.

  • @poeds sorry buddy, but actually two marines were taken. They were Ralph and Lt. Sokol

  • @777seventy it was many more you're noob...

    sorry but actually many did get prisoner...

  • @poeds just one ? lol

    it was many you're noob...

    idiot...

    Use you're brain kid...

  • @poeds read at wikipedia huh?

    I read MANY MANY books about the pacific war and almost EVERY causality thing there is WRONG!!!

    But you american is best people can NEVER see the truth can you?

    I seriousley feel sorry for you people... but it will always be ignorance and stupidity in our world...

    But thinking that just one of about 110 thousand american invaders did survive or get catched by japanese is JUST stupidity....

  • Iwo Jima must have been a hell

  • @TheBartinater1 yeah...

    It is a reason that the people who were fighting at that island say that they not fear hell because they have been there already...

  • Class film!

    One of the best war films ever!

    It gets across a different culture and point of point of view to an american audience which is no bad thing.

    By the end of this film you have a profound respect for the normal Japanese soldiers and indeed soldiers of any nation.

  • clin eastwood is a gread director....

  • This movie and Flags of our Fathers were filmed at the same time right? The beach attack looked familiar I think its from Flags of our Fathers.......

  • WOW incredible film. It shows the concept view of a Japanese slodier, that they died with honor and for their country.

  • What a film. I feel that the comments below suffices as an explanation for my deep admiration for this masterpiece. It is a film I will never forget.

  • This and Der Untergang are my favorite movies.

  • This is unlike the typical Spielberg epics of 'Saving Private Ryan' that only exist to highlight the brutality and savagery of all war. Instead, Eastwood's approach is incredibly original and more builds itself on the foundation of its characters rather than actual battle.

    It is sad to think that such a fine piece of work is underrated heavily considering its improvement from 'Flags of our Fathers'. One of the best I've seen.

  • @tokyocityrat Europeans also forced many people in many partsof Asia to become addicted to opium and were forced to pay taxes for opium

  • were did they film this?

    esspecialy the mt. sarabachtin parts?

  • i have so much respect for Clint Eastwood. The man sees things for what they really are. "it boils down to young men being sent off to end their lives prematurely, no matter what side your on". which brings me to the statement of "in war there is no victor" PERIOD.

  • best war movie i loved it

  • Nice movie! I love it!

  • Clint Eastwood is a hero. :))

  • good job for clint eastwood

  • I've seen many, many war movies and Letters From Iwo Jima by far one of the best I've ever seen. I will never in my lifetime understand why it didn't win best picture. Truly an amazing film that touches all of humanity no matter what race or nationality you are.

  • I'm pretty sure it didn't win cause Clint Eastwood is a republican. For example, Why did Gran Torino not get nominated for anything!?

  • @ryanalan29 Pretty interesting that a Republican would make an anti-war film.

  • This isn't an anti-war film.

  • @ryanalan29 It clearly is.

  • Nope. It's not. Sorry!

  • @ryanalan29 gran torino was amazing

  • @420Guitar420 i agree.. but i dont actually believe in awards,, you dont need an award just to know theyre good, it's an awesome movie

  • @420Guitar420 Would you rate it as highly as missing in action 2?

  • @420Guitar420 I agree with you BIG TIME!!!!

  • @420Guitar420 Definately dude. It was much better than The Departed. It was ridiculously better. Thumbs up.

  • @420Guitar420 they should make a version of this but in Iraq, from both perspectives.

  • @420Guitar420 i think it won best foreign movie or sometin

  • Letters and Flags are excellent films.

  • @RDKF13 I felt that Flags of Our Fathers was a bit difficult to follow because it would go from Iwo Jima to after and back to Iwo Jima.

  • boom

  • ah, i did not see your post and commented above ). these were main reasons, along some others of course

  • yes, this is true. but you have to learn why the Peal Harbor attack was made. the Japs were not completely crazy and started attacking. Of course I do not justify the Japanese Empire launching the attack, but they had a reason, and of course it was the very very last alternative for them to attack. From what I read and think, I believe so.