Your reviews are concise, honest and all together professional. I will quibble and debate some individual ratings. I rank Sandwich Girl above Peep Fight. Molly's musicianship and charisma shine. But it's not much of a structured song. I'd give Sandwich Girl the 8 and Peep Fight the 7.5. And God of Bingo is just so punk-pop/stupid, I like it. God of Bingo gets a 6.5 or 7, just to bounce it into the top half.
Trust me, you are grateful I dropped out this round. My song was a stinky mess.
For your information, the "impossibly long word" in Mick Bordet's song is actually a real word. Personally I thought it was quite clever how he fitted it in to the song (it still got old after 10 seconds though).
Do you realize that my title was making fun of bands like Panic at the Disco, who make absurdly long titles which bear little to no resemblance to the songs they represent?
No, I didn't know it was intended to be a parody. By itself, the long title idea seemed to me more like a good opportunity to say everything that couldn't be said in the song. The irony of the title having nothing to do with the song was completely lost on me. Thanks for clarifying!
I somehow think that your rating of these songs isn't based on their actual merits, more so on just your personal preferences. It also seems convenient that the only two songs you really liked were by people who you've obviously had a previous fancy for, thus biasing your entire review. I give your review a 4 out of 10.
Fair enough. Your opinion is just as valid as mine.
If you made this review, Chances are you'd be biased by your previous musical tastes as well. I see you're already pretty good at critique. You should make a review yourself!
A very diplomatic response. I don't think you can criticize a reviewer for basing his reviews on what they like. That's what a reviewer is supposed to do!
Your reviews are concise, honest and all together professional. I will quibble and debate some individual ratings. I rank Sandwich Girl above Peep Fight. Molly's musicianship and charisma shine. But it's not much of a structured song. I'd give Sandwich Girl the 8 and Peep Fight the 7.5. And God of Bingo is just so punk-pop/stupid, I like it. God of Bingo gets a 6.5 or 7, just to bounce it into the top half.
Trust me, you are grateful I dropped out this round. My song was a stinky mess.
RockingJamboree 2 years ago
Peep Fight and I Know= AWESOME!!
tiera372 2 years ago
For your information, the "impossibly long word" in Mick Bordet's song is actually a real word. Personally I thought it was quite clever how he fitted it in to the song (it still got old after 10 seconds though).
Methionylglutaminylarginyltyrosylglutamylseryl
leucylphenylalanylalanylglutaminylleucyllysyl
glutamylarginyllysylglutamylglycylalanylpheny
lalanylvalylprolyphenylalanYlvalythreonylleuc
ylglycylaspartylprolylglycylisoleucylglutamy
lglutaminylsErylleucyllysylisoleucylaspartylt
hreonyll---
JamieTricks 3 years ago
Hahaha.
Do you realize that my title was making fun of bands like Panic at the Disco, who make absurdly long titles which bear little to no resemblance to the songs they represent?
BucketHatBobby 3 years ago
No, I didn't know it was intended to be a parody. By itself, the long title idea seemed to me more like a good opportunity to say everything that couldn't be said in the song. The irony of the title having nothing to do with the song was completely lost on me. Thanks for clarifying!
sevinPackage 3 years ago
No problem. I never even considered the idea that anyone might have taken it seriously.
Now that I think, I probably should have clarified.
I don't want people thinking I'm some pompous ass. Haha!
BucketHatBobby 3 years ago
I somehow think that your rating of these songs isn't based on their actual merits, more so on just your personal preferences. It also seems convenient that the only two songs you really liked were by people who you've obviously had a previous fancy for, thus biasing your entire review. I give your review a 4 out of 10.
TheCritchOfDitch 3 years ago
Fair enough. Your opinion is just as valid as mine.
If you made this review, Chances are you'd be biased by your previous musical tastes as well. I see you're already pretty good at critique. You should make a review yourself!
sevinPackage 3 years ago
A very diplomatic response. I don't think you can criticize a reviewer for basing his reviews on what they like. That's what a reviewer is supposed to do!
RockingJamboree 2 years ago