Added: 2 years ago
From: MuslimByChoice
Views: 25,767
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (423)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Comment removed

  • Please find the original PRESERVED bible in HEBREW and find translation directly from it, then you know what the truth is. Current pre-translated bible has meanings that is far deviated from the original meaning. That maybe caused by translation over translation or some human intervention.

  • To all of you the the Bible makes since if you believe in trinity, because in some verse the bible seems that is contradicting itself but that's when trinity comes in, if bible says that everyone will bow to him, Philippians 2:10, and only should they bow before God, he is God, there is no 3 gods only one God, read Philippians 2:4-11 and at end its says to the glory of God the father, that's the trinity!

  • @carranza480352 I love you Carranza.

  • @Doctorsizzle the bible is not logic for God said he was going to destroy the wisdom of the wise and the intelligence of the intelligent, right. God does whatever he wants if he wanted to make himself in 10 forms he would of done it, why is sin on this world can't God stop it, he knew adam was going to sin why did he even created him, why couldn't this world be perfect if someone who's perfect created it. God the almighty wanted it this way because he said he would destroy the wise of the wisdom

  • To imam 9:37, God is only one manifested in 3 forms. God has different names like yaweh or jehova and i am, but that doesnt mean theres more then one, he doesnt need any help but why did he create angels? They all have a role and were created for something, God was before alone but he wanted to do angels and us, why if he didn't need us, he said let all humans reign over the animals and the land in genesis

  • @RAMIREZ3480 read hebrew 1:4-16, read romans 9:5. Isaiah 9:6 and the answer to your question is in phillipians 2:5-11

  • this is sad that the history is given right here and your face...and you still consider this TEACHING LOGIC correct and holy.

  • trinity are the 3 persona of God

    God the Father

    God the Son &

    God the holy spirit

    all in 1 TRUE GOD

    we have 3 person

    flesh

    soul

    & spirit

  • @RICKYARCIAGA that doesnt make sense

  • Comment removed

  • The Trinity makes perfect sense. It's 3 instances of 1. Like the Sun - matter, heat and light. Or 3 states of water - liquid, gas and ice. It's not really hard to grasp.

  • @SmokiSounds so three gods?

  • @pluz93 Have you read what I wrote? Do liquid, gas and ice change the fact they're still water? No. Same with trinity. 3 instances of One.

  • @SmokiSounds yes I have. Yes, they exist in a three different states of matter. However, their constituents remain the same, that is 2 hydrogen atoms and 1 oxygen atom forming H2O. Lets take a look at the trinity now. God and holy spirit, they, I assume consist of the same constituent, but what about Jesus? I do not think so. He was made in flesh and bones. So, the concept is not really clear. Then again that is my understanding.

  • @pluz93 I see your confusion. Perhaps the Sun is a better example - it is 1) A mass of energy (Father), 2) Produces light (Holy Ghost), and 3) Produces heat (Son). Maybe this is a better way to understand the reality of the Trinity.

    Yes, Jesus was 100% human and 100% divine. Impossible? Well... If we're talking about God, who's omnipotent, surely there's nothing "impossible" there. But I do see where your confusion lays. "Same constituent" - that doesn't apply to a [super]natural concept.

  • @SmokiSounds Nope, still 3 different things. The explanation of the sun is just like the water. The heat, light and energy are 3 different things. And if you say God=Jesus(pbuh). They have to be the same thing. Otherwise is illogical. Is god illogical? I don't think so. That is like saying apple is apple and orange at the same time. Another thing is why do you say that Jesus(pbuh) is son of God if he is the God himself?

  • @SmokiSounds can any human being ever experience the power of the SUN('the father')? NO.

    can a human being even stand the light(holy ghost) without protection?  NO.

    can a human being stand the heat from the sun without protection? NO.

    the only we, so i've heard that a human can bear witness to the FATHER is by a non-human form.

    before the trinity doctrine was decreed by EMPEROR CONSTANTINE (his shield, the crucifix being used as an important religious symbol) what was the truth?

  • @SmokiSounds can any human being ever experience the power of the SUN(the father)? NO.

    can a human being even stand the light(holy ghost) without protection? NO.

    can a human being stand the heat from the sun without protection? NO.

    the only we, so i've heard that a human can bear witness to the FATHER is by a non-human form.

    before the trinity doctrine was decreed by EMPEROR CONSTANTINE (his shield, the crucifix being used as an important religious symbol) what was the truth?

  • @SmokiSounds 2cont. the truth was that from Jesus, the prophet...who brought a message of simplification and honesty. ONE GOD, no partners. a being of superior and omnipotent presence that humans do not share...

    without the trinity doctrine what would be lost? people can still believe in a God in which we are all indentured to and a Prophet that spoke of the presence of this GOD.

  • @doctorsizzle My friend you're lost on all levels.

    Response to this specific point: /watch?v=2dRSpJAyrJA&feature=r­elmfu

    In two words: Before Constantine there was NO debate about Trinity. The Bible forces us to accept the doctrine of Trinity, not Constantine. Now go watch the complete response.

  • @SmokiSounds so what did i miss? i know that the trinity doctrine is man-made CONSTRUCT, not even done so by a league, counsel, panel, group, or gaggle of holy men!

    this doctrine, an educational tool was debated by scholars and decreed by an emperor...which is a blasphemous as erecting a bust of an emperor in a tabernacle.

    i didn't miss anything.

    thank you for your response.

  • @doctorsizzle It's not a made-man construct. I suppose you haven't watched the link I provided. There was no debate about Trinity before Constantine. It's in the Bible.

  • Salam Muslims,

    Let's do good this Ramadan. Enter the Ramadan Contest 2011.

    And show how good Muslims are.

    Click on my username or go to facebook and search RamadanContest2011.

    RamadanContest2011 (d o t) com

  • Question: How is the KORAN going to MAKE ME ANY CLOSER TO GOD THAN I AM NOW?

  • Abraham taught of one. Moses taught of one. Jesus taught of one. Mohammad peace be upon him taught of one. Paul taught of three.

  • @TheMrpalid 1)THERE IS 1 GOD: DEUTERONOMY 6:4. 1CORINTHIANS 8:4. GALATIANS 3:20. 1TIMOTHY 2:5. 2) THE TRINITY CONSISTS OF 3 PERSONS: GENESIS 1:1-2. GENESIS 1:26. GENESIS 3:22-24. GENESIS 11:7. ISAIAH 6:8. ISAIAH 48: 16-17. ISAIAH 61:1. MATTHEW 3:16-17. MATTHEW 28:19. JOHN 14:1-26. 2CORINTHIANS 13:14.

    3) EACH MEMBER OF THE TRINITY IS GOD: The Father is God: JOHN 6:27. 1PETER 1:2.

    The Son is God: JOHN 1:1. HEBREWS 1:8.

    The Holy Spirit is God: ACTS 5:3-4. 1CORINTHIANS 3:16...1 SAVIOUR JESUS!!!

  • @The3in1trinity Joshua Evans explains this concept through the Bible and Quran in the youtube video: Top 10 reasons why Jesus can't be God.

  • @TheMrpalid Joshua Evans put his cross down + ran away from the Saviour of the world. I follow the Lord Jesus Christ + have received God the Holy Spirit who leads in2 all truth. Mr Evans knows NOTHING about God or God's Word. I COULDN'T CARE LESS WHAT MR EVANS SAYS. I HAVE GIVEN THE SCRIPTURES 2 U IN MY PREVIOUS COMMENT. Take it or leave it...I follow what the Inspired Word of God says, NOT joshua evans...

  • @The3in1trinity Joshua Evans is on the right path. There are even more fromer christian preachers who are coming to the truth of Islam: Dr. Gerald Dirks, Yusuf Estes, Khalid Yasin, and the list goes on and on. Islam is the truth

  • @TheMrpalid U r not making intelligent points. U merely appeal 2 base emotions. I don't base my belief in God's Word or the Saviour Jesus Christ the Saviour of the world based on how many ppl become Muslims. Those who have been blessed 2 understand what sin is from God's perspective + how only God can deal with it, r those who accept God's way which is Grace by faith through His Son Jesus' Atoning sacrifice on the cross. My other comments with Scripture show u r wrong. 1 SAVIOUR JESUS CHRIST...

  • @The3in1trinity Ok i understand , don't listen to the muslim point of view. Listen to Award winning Bible Scholar Bart Ehrman who agrees that these things about trinity and divinity were made later on by humans

  • No you can't explain trinity. and when they do, it usually are different from one another. another calls it mysterious...pfftt. excuses

  • oh yes, i forgot something, The Biggest sin is when you whorshiping other than God. It's unforgivable sin, forever in hell. so verify your faith!

  • @DannyTheSeeker brother shirk is forgivable im muslim and its said that only Allah forgives sins that belong to him like property belongs to them u say sorry to them same with Allah he forgives sin as shirk (possibly) if u pray and promise to never believe and pray to anything else but Allah

  • @SuperMirza14 i mean if you death before taubatan nashuha.

  • it's clearly say that this man believe trinity. let me give a compare about these three person in islam. Father : God \ Allah, Holy Ghost : Jibril (Angel), Son\Jesus : Messenger of god that born miraclously. Which make any sense to you? How 3 person become 1 unity? What is christiany call of this unity form? God? Is this Unity Form that christiany worshiped? or the three separated form?

  • Can you explain the Trinity?

    That God is Father, Son & Holy Ghost & these 3 persons are the 1 true eternal God. (John 15:26)

  • @October31st1517 ISAIAH 48:12-17. JOHN 1:1-34. JOHN 3:16-36. ISAIAH 9:6-7. JOHN 12:27-50. JOHN 14:1-26. Although the word "trinity" isn't in the Bible the concept is. God is 1 but manifests Himself in 3 persons of Father, Son + Holy Spirit. The idea that a human can FULLY understand the concept of the trinity is as impossible as FULLY understanding the nature of God. But we can understand enough 2 know that God is 1 God in 3 persons who's nature's r co-eternal + co-equal in the Godhead. Peace

  • @The3in1trinity I agree. But I would not say "NATURES" That I think would suggest 3 Gods. I would say that the 3 eternal persons share and possess the same divine NATURE. Im sure that;s what you meant.

  • @October31st1517 It's clear that my comment shows Father, Son + Holy Spirit r divine because they r God!!! If u look at my comment again u will c that the word "natures" doesn't contradict the trinity. It should b obvious that the 3 persons of the trinity r divine...I don't c how anyone can b confused. I have shown clearly that God is 3 persons who r obviously ALL God + must there4 b divine...

  • This is really great insight. The more and more I study Islam and the Quran I am seeing quite a mesh with the Quran, the Bible, The Apocrypha and the Gospel of Thomas (which is pretty astounding). The one thing the Christian and Islamic faiths have in common is that there is ONLY One God. But by which name you call Him, that is different. But even in those names...there are similarities.

  • @bradygeoffrey God's Inspired Word the Bible has NOTHING in common with the koran. God's Word shows that God sent His Son Jesus 2 die 4 the sins of the whole world: JOHN 3:16-36. Jesus confirms this: JOHN 12:27-50. Jesus is God in the flesh: ISAIAH 9:6-7. ISAIAH 48:12-16. JOHN 1:1-34. The koran denies these FUNDAMENTAL beliefs of Christianity!!! God's Word gives no support 2 the koran. U would b wise 2 ask God 2 show u His truth because u won't find it in the koran. 1 SAVIOUR JESUS CHRIST...

  • Although the word 'Trinity' does not appear in the Holy Bible, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit, do, especially in St. Matthew chapter 28, verse 19.

  • that guy responded to this video 2 mins and 41 seconds loooooooooooooool how can you respond to a 29 minute video in less than 3 minutes????

  • @malachithemessenger You say "Jesus is the son of David and the son of God"... a man who has 2 fathers in your country in your language what do you call him ??? and second point no one is smarter than God on this earth .....

  • Say: He is Allah, the One! Allah, the eternally Besought of all! He begetteth not nor was begotten. And there is none comparable unto Him. (Surah Al Ikhlas)...TAUHID!!!

  • Comment removed

  • The word TRINITY is a concept. It doesn't neeed 2 b in the Bible. The word BIBLE isn't in the Bible so Mr Estes point isn't relevant. ISAIAH 9:6-7 4tells the coming of Jesus. READ WHAT IT SAYS!

    ISAIAH 63:7-10 mentions God the Holy Spirit.

    JOHN 1:1-34 shows Jesus is God in the flesh. Notice verses 1-4; 10; 12; 14; 15; 18; 30; 36.

    JOHN 14 1-26 Jesus the Son will pray 2 His Father 2 send the Comforter who is the Holy Spirit (verse 26).

    GOD'S WORD CANNOT B REFUTED. 1 SAVIOUR JESUS CHRIST

  • @malachithemessenger Now reply to ur inbox , But God Almighty never addressed Jesus as his son in the Bible. In Psalms 2:7 God is addressing David as his begotten son. Point 2, In Matthew 1:1 God is dictating to you the geneology or generation book of Jesus Christ and He (God Almight) is tacking out Himself from that list and saying that the Jesus is the son of David.

    God is dictating his son's generation and taking out Himself, Does that make sense to you ???

  • @baloch1985 God the Father is talking about His Son Jesus. There is ONLY 1 who is BEGOTTEN of God + that is Jesus!!! Verse 22 is talking about Jesus. IT SHOULD B CLEAR THAT THIS VERSE ISN'T SAYING THAT PPL WILL B BLESSED IF THEY PUT THEIR TRUST IN DAVID.

  • @malachithemessenger The God's name is not "Jesus" it is not mention in the original manuscripts of the Bible .. Not once .. God's name is "Allah" it is mentioned in the Bible but your clever learned men removed it from the translations of the Bible ..

  • There is NOTHING like the joy Jesus brings! Glory to his name-hallelujah!

  • @Ephesians4jesus why don't you counter the arguments in the video instead of blindly following? 

  • BEGOTTON NOT MADE

  • @zacgotgame John 1:1 .. so I'm asking you what is the Greek word for "God" when it first time occurs in John 1:1 "word was with God" so what is the Greek word for "God" and what is the Greek word for "God" when it second time occurs in this verse "And the word was God" ???

  • Psalm 149:1 Praise the Lord! Sing to the Lord a new song,his praise in the assembly of the godly!

  • I will worship You for who You are! I will worship You for who You are! I will worship You for who You are-Jesus!

  • @malachithemessenger What's video doing here my brother ?? Tell me only one verse from your Bible where Jesus himself says that he is God or where he says worship me .. I want a verse from the lips of Jesus ,, I want to know what he says .. I don't want to know what Paul thinks what somebody else says or thinks .. show me the verse ..

  • @baloch1985 Jesus the Son of God didn't come 2boast of who He is. He was sent by His Father 2die 4all sinful mankind. If Jesus had boasted then He would have been guilty of the sin of PRIDE. Jesus shows who He is in Scripture in many passages. U can read the Word of God 4 urself. When Muslims r given Scripture they disregard it so do a little research of ur own if u really seek truth. That way u will b convinced after u have made enquiries of ur own. THOSE THAT DENY THE SON DON'T HAVE THE FATHER

  • @baloch1985 JOHN 17:11. MATTHEW 26:63-66.

  • @malachithemessenger Jesus says our God is one .. Do you understand english ?? Do you know the meaning of "our" ?? If he was the God , he must say in your Bible that worship me I'm God .. But you cannot find anything in any version of the Bible .. The word "Trinity" does not exist in the Bible .. But Quran says "Don't say God is three in one it is better for you to stop saying that" and Quran also says "God is one and Only" as it is mentioned in your Bible that God is one ..

  • @malachithemessenger But Jesus Christ says In ,,

    Mark 12:29 And Jesus answered him, The first of all the commandments is, Hear, O Israel; The Lord our God is one Lord

    And God says In ,,

    Isaiah 43:11 I, even I, am the LORD; and beside me there is no saviour

  • @baloch1985 ISAIAH 9:6-7...

  • worship the creator not the creation

  • It is a laughable thing for we as mere humans to explain Almighty God with our own understanding."Can you reason God?",you say.LOL We do not even know what tomorrow holds,and you think you can reasonably understand Almighty God with your minds.Not a chance.

  • @titus11234 Only through God's help-the indwelling Holy Spirit-can we hope to understand God.That rules out any Muslims.

  • @genesisevent2 yes that is precisely the reason why there are so many sects and denominations in Christianity with each sending all others to Hell. They all claim to have the holy spirit but send all others to hell. And right now we even had the revelation of the pope protecting padoephile priests, yet another inspiration of the Holy spirit. I am sorry to say but the holy spirit has not been able to do any thing significant over the past 2000 years. No new law brought.

  • @titus11234 yes so surely God can kill, rape, eat, steal. He can do what he wants, he can get mad and also cheat us. After all All things are possible with God are they not?

  • Can you reason in your mind an all-powerful God who created all things,is outside the realms of time(because He created it),has no beginning and no end,knows every single person by name and knows their thoughts and what they will do all the days of their life even before they were born?you cannot even explain those things about God-what makes you think you can explain the Trinity?

  • Ha! This is not what Google says. Check it out.

  • @TenderTrap86 ''This is not what Google says'' What does Google say ?

    Well this is what a Muslim says & this is what the Qur'aan says.

  • @MrBOXA01 Why don't you go find out? See the answers written by Muslims, explaining the nature of God as revealed through the Quran? Why don't you go see?

  • @TenderTrap86 Where ? show me the link bro. & anyway lets just say your right... Yes so what exactly is your point ?

  • @MrBOXA01 It's not a link. Just google "Islam, God, Unfathomable".

    If God is believed to be unfathomable, then how come I hear these Muslims in the video saying "God can't do this...God can't do that...etc..."?

    How can the unfathomable be fathomed?

    How can it be *empirically* disproved that Christianity isn't the truth? This is an argument about *belief*.

  • @TenderTrap86 Ohhhh i get it, so basically according to yu God lies, god dies, god cheats, god steals, god eats, god sleeps, god is a human. god can do anything according to you ? hahaha

  • @MrBOXA01 LOL god can never die thats y he cant do anything.

  • @AeroPolice ''God can never die thats y he cant do anything'' Lool you make absolute so sense. Well if that is your concept of God, them im afraid you are severely wrong & corrupted !

  • @MrBOXA01 I'm not saying God can do *anything*. I'm just asking you if God is more unfathomable than you think?

    I never said God lies, cheats or steals. That was you most definately putting words into my mouth. "hahahaha"

  • @TenderTrap86 Brother heres the deal, the word is NOT unfathomable, its actually what God says HE does and what he says he does NOT do, for example if someone says God can do anything, its illogical because someone can easily fool you. Well guess what, Allah doesn't say he can do anything, what he says is that HE does WHATEVER he WILLS, So yes God can do anything he wills, but God would not will to lie, he would not will to cheat, he would not will to steal because how can he be God then ?

  • @MrBOXA01 I'm not saying God can do anything.

    Stop putting words in my mouth and just answer my questions, please.

    Is it *possible* God could be a Trinity? Is it possible?

  • @TenderTrap86 Ok i understand brother, Now as for your question, ''can God be a trinity'' short answer = NO

    Its also mentioned in the Bible that God is ONE, the first commandment was GOD IS ONE. Same in Quraan, God is ONE, how can can be 3 in one ? WHY DOES GOD NEED 2 BE 3 IN ONE ?? does that mean he need's help from the other ''gods'' why is God confusing us ?? God is NOT the author of confusion, God is PERFECT, HE IS NOT 3 IN ONE, BUT ONLY ONE

    SO NO ITS NOT POSSIBLE !

  • @MrBOXA01 The Trinity is one God. There is no confusion about that.

    Matter is one. Yet matter can be a solid, liquid or gas. Three, yet one.

    Space is one. Yet space has three dimensions, haight, width, depth.

    Time is one, yet it has three aspects: past present and future.

    Doesn't verse 5:69 in the Quran say that Christians are monothiests? And, that they will not griee because they believe in God and the Last Day?

  • @TenderTrap86 ''The Trinity is one god'' ok so who has more power Jesus or the father ? Jesus said ''i can of myself do nothing'' Jesus said ''my father is greater then i'' so thats a contradiction, because they should be equal ? and if one is above another then that means theres more then one God ? see thats what im talking about the Trinity is FALSE, WHO FIRST MADE UP THIS TRINITY THING ??  NOT JESUS

    & Yes that what it says..

  • @MrBOXA01 Christ said the Father is greater than Himself, because He had two natures on Earth: one *divine*, and the other *human*. God became man and subjected Himself to His very own law. God greatly humiliated Himself by taking on the human nature.

    The Trinity is distinct, yet it is one and equal in everything. God the Son is eternal and equal with the Father and Holy Ghost. Jesus Christ was not created, but begotten.

    The Nicene Creed expounds: "I believe in one God..."

  • @TenderTrap86 ''he was begotten'' OMG so does that mean the father had sex with the holy spirit and they produced Jesus ?? what rubbish, & guess what, the word ''begotten'' has been removed from the bible by 50 different denominations, they say it was a fabrication, and it does not exist in the new international version. I dont know what kind of God you worship but i gotta tell you, your wrong & Jesus NEVER claimed to be God.

  • @MrBOXA01 I wholly dislike condescending attitudes, especially in this thype of setting. Ad hominem attacks are the recourse of the foolish and defeated.

    The true Christian Church is the Roman Catholic Church. The Catholic Church doesn't rely on Sacred Scripture, alone. Scripture can be interpreted many different ways, as you already pointed out. The Church also relies on Tradition. It's a mixture of both, scripture and tradition.

    - "Jesus NEVER claimed to be God." -

    Matthew 16: 15-17

  • @TenderTrap86 The verses you have given me do not claim Jesus is god. There is not a single verse in the bible where jesus says ''im god'' or where he says ''worship me''

  • @MrBOXA01 Uh, yes it does.

    Matt.16:15-17

    " “But what about you?” he asked. “Who do you say I am?” Simon Peter answered, “You are the Messiah, the Son of the living God.” Jesus replied, “Blessed are you, Simon son of Jonah, for this was not revealed to you by flesh and blood, but by my Father in heaven.

    *Flesh and blood* had not revealed it. That means Christ didn't reveal it, Himself. This was an ultimate confession of total faith. Which is why Christ says to Peter: "Blessed are you".

  • @TenderTrap86 Brother first of all, the word ''son'' used here, does NOT refer as a 'begotten' son but as in saying like were children of God, we are from god, Its like that.

    According to your Bible God has sons by the tons adam was the son of god, abraham was the son of god, moses,david,noah,jesus, etc.. are all sons of god according to your bible, but it doesnt refer to an actual son, but as in a show of respect.

    So again he never claimed to be God.

  • @MrBOXA01 Semantics? Fine. But, remember that the Catholic Church doesn't rely only on scripture, as was already stated. It's also tradtion, and the earliest traditions expound that Christ, in fact, was God.

    Also, remember the Catholic Church is the only faith that actually takes Christ at His *literal* word. No semantics.

    Another thing to remember is that unlike Islam, Christianity is a great mystery, the same way sex is a mystery: it has the power to breed thoughts.

  • @TenderTrap86 Brother, The Catholic Church, The Christians have all been corrupted. Jesus NEVER claimed to be God, it was however some guys named John, Matthew, Luke, that came up with this idea. The Bible has been changed several times. You do NOT have the original Bible, it does NOT exist. It was all these people AFTER about 300 years after Jesus departed that they came up with this ''Trinity'' & ''Son of God'' idea.

  • @MrBOXA01 So, your response is that they just made it up? The same can be said of Muhammed. That's not a good arguement at all.

  • @TenderTrap86 ''The same can be said for Muhammad'' So what about all these scientific miracles in the Qur'aan that only recently science has come to know ? how could an illiterate person that lived 1400 years ago in the desert could have known all these scientific miracles ? for example how a human being is formed when inside the womb, how the earth came into existence, etc.. All these miracles, your science has found out recently, was already mentioned 1400 years ago.

  • @MrBOXA01 If something is described as scientific, how can it be a miralce? A miracle is a miracle. End of story.

    All the great empires had phenomenal scientific discoveries. This is historical evidence: The Ancient Greeks used a computer to precisely calculate the movement of the planets and constellations. It tracked the solar and lunar cycles. It tracked the hours of the day, days of the week, week of months and months of the year.

    Does this prove that Zues is the true god?

  • @TenderTrap86 Because all these ''scientific'' proven facts that have been recently discovered now was already their in the Qur'aan 1400 years ago, & that is a miracle. The Qur'aan is the miracle of miracles.

    I dont know who 'Zues' is, but if he was God, then he must have scripture/book, that has scientific miracles, it should have something that NO other book has.. Just like the Quraan.

    There is ONLY One God & Muhammad is his FINAL Messenger...

  • @MrBOXA01 The Ancient Sumerians knew that the universe was heliocentric. That's proof they're right about how they worshipped their gods.

    The Romans knew about germ theory over 1500 years before it became standard medical knowledge. This proves Jupiter is almighty.

    Some anthropologists claim that the Egyptians knew how to fly airplanes. This proves that Anubis should be worshipped.

    Do you see where I'm going with this?

    You're reasoning about science in the Quran doesn't hold up.

  • @TenderTrap86 GIVE ME PROOF, SCIENTIFIC PROOF !

  • @MrBOXA01 The Quran is insufficient, the way you're talking about it.

    The Big Bang as we know it today isn't the first "big bang" theory ever proposed. Likewise, Darwinian evolution isn't the first "evolutionist" theory ever proposed. The ancient Greeks believed in something similiar.

    And, how do you know the Big Bang is even true? All it can ever be is speculation. Science is observable, testable, repeatable and applicable. All the Big Bang will ever be, at most, is just an assumption.

  • @TenderTrap86 The Qur'aan also describes the Human Embryology in so much detail that modern scientists have even accepted Islam after reading the verses that were written 1400 years ago. Quran, 23:12-14

    Who could have mentioned the Human Embryology in such detail 1400 years ago ?

  • @MrBOXA01 Think of all the great anceint empires. In that part of the world, as far as history can tell, there was the great civilization of Egypt, then Greece and then Rome. They all made huge scientific discoveries thousands of years ago. Modern scientists, anthropoligists and historians are finding out that what we modern folk think of as recent discoveries, are actualy re-discoveries.

    What empire came after Rome: the Arab Empire. It's no surprise the Arabs followed in their footsteps.

  • @TenderTrap86 Brother, r yu a Christian ?

  • @MrBOXA01 Yes.

  • @TenderTrap86 Brother, can i ask you why are you a Christian ? i guess you were born Christian.. Brother, Jesus NEVER claimed to be God, he is NOT God, he is Prophet & Messenger sent by God, just like all the prophets & messengers, eg.. moses,abraham,noah,david,jesus­,muhammad etc.. why do you worship Jesus ? ( i guess you were born from a christian family) But just wake up for a minute, how many times has the Bible changed ? ALOT!. Look how confusing there Bible is, God does NOT confuse people.

  • @MrBOXA01 Christians are not *explicitly* born Christians. Christians are baptized, then they become Christians explicitly. Everyone of them. Much the same way Muslims look at reversion. The Catholic Church believes that everybody in the world is implictly Christian; that the grace of God does not fail them just because they are not explicitly part of His Church. This is what is known as Natural Law; that everybody knows the God's divine laws and precepts, intrinsically; "a priori' knowledge.

  • @TenderTrap86 Please just study Islam for a bit, & see what it says about Jesus & all the prophets. We worship the same God as Jesus worshiped (the father) ''THE ONE GOD'' that Jesus always quotes is the same God we Muslims worship. I request you to Please spend about half an hour of your precious life & read the Qur'aan, then tell me what you think.

  • @MrBOXA01 The Roman Catholic Church uses only one Bible. Catholicism is a composite of scripture and *tradition*. We have the writings of the Apostolic and Church Fathers which help us decipher what it was that the original Apostles of Christ believed. If the faith was based off of scripture alone, it wouldn't be sufficient, for scripture can be interpreted many different ways. Which is why there are so many different Bibles. People have broken from the Apostolic faith, and started their own.

  • @TenderTrap86 I respect you for being honest that Christians have been corrupted & have made their 'own' belief & concepts. You say "The Catholic Church believes that everybody in the world is implicitly Christian"

    Well guess what ? We Muslims believe that EVERY SINGLE creature in this universe is a Muslim. You might laugh but here is the reason. A Muslim means 'Submitting your will to God', So a baby is a Muslim because it is submitting its will to God & the baby is INNOCENT.

  • @MrBOXA01 How do you know if every single creature is Muslim? Does that include predators that prey upon pigs?

    Catholics also believes children are innocent. In the Catholic Church, children are not permitted to to recieve the Our Lord inthe Eucharist until they have reached the age of reason, which is about 7-10 y/o. But, before their First Communion, they are required to make a sacramental confession. I like to think of sacramental confession as the "Catholic shahada", over and over again.

  • @TenderTrap86 Unlike the Christians who believe the baby is born with sin.

  • @MrBOXA01 Yeah, It's funny. During the Protestant Reformation, there were really only three Protestant sects that broke off from the Catholic Church. From then to now, they have multiplied, exponentially, to, literally, over 30,000 sects, and each one believes something different from the next. They have different versions of the Bible and interpret it to their own satisfaction, not God's.

    The Catholic Church, however, remains firm in the Apostolic faith; upheld for almost 2,000 years.

  • @TenderTrap86 Because Muslim in Arabic means ''Submitting your will to God.'' Now lets see for example look at the Trees, what do you see, what are the trees doing ? they are doing exactly what they were made to do. Look at the sky, look at the clouds, look at the sun, what are they doing ? EXACTLY what they are made to do. So they are submitting their will to God. Understand ? might be a very deep philosophy, but the knowledgeable person would understand. & Yes EVERYTHING is a Muslim.

  • @MrBOXA01 A pitpull that rips off a toddler's face is doing God's will? A child molester?

    I believe in one God.

    Matter is one thing. Yet, matter can be three: liquid, solid or gas. Is liquid the partner of gas? Or solid the partner of liquid? No. It is the same thing: it is matter, but under a different form. Each being unique.

    If you come to a Christian who believes that the Trinity means "partners", they are heretical or ignorant. That is not Christianity.

    There is only one God.

  • @TenderTrap86 Brother first of all the animal's are creatures of God, they do not have free will/choice like we do. Even if an animal does kill a toddler, guess what ? that toddler will go straight to paradise anyway. So its a blessing in disguise, this is all from the wisdom of God. Now as for your statement you say ''matter can be three: liquid, solid or gas. Is liquid the partner of gas?'' Now scientifically i do agree that Matter can be in 3 forms, solid liquid and gas.

  • @MrBOXA01 - "Even if an animal does kill a toddler, guess what ? that toddler will go straight to paradise anyway. So its a blessing in disguise" -

    I dare you to go tell the parents that. I dare you.

    Speaking from the Roman Catholic Church: there is only *one* God. We believe in one God. No matter how much Muslims try to prove this is false, they will never suceed, because we do only believe in *one* God. Doesn't the Quran say that Christianity is monotheism in 5:69? What's the problem?

  • @TenderTrap86 Well when worshipping Son is not the same as worshipping holy spirit and worshipping the father is not the same as the son, they are all distinct having no connection whatsoever i.e independant of each other. They cannot be one. Also, if Jesus is God than God sent himself and got himself murdered himself since he loved himself? How is Jesus the "only begotten "son of God? Did God have sex with a women?

  • @MatrixOfDynamism JOHN 1:1-34. JOHN 3:10-36. JOHN 12:27-50. JOHN 1:14. 1 JOHN 4:1-15.

  • @TenderTrap86 But scientifically we also know that the component of matter remains the same, H20, two items of hydrogen and one item of oxygen, the components remain the same, the forms keep on changing.

  • @TenderTrap86 Now lets see the concept of Trinity, (father,son & holy ghost) you say form changes, ok for the sake of argument i agree, DOES THE COMPONENT CHANGE ? God & Holy Spirit is made of spirit, human beings are made of flesh and bones, they aren't the same. Human beings require to eat, God doesn't require to eat to survive, they ain't the same.

  • @MrBOXA01 PSALM 8:5. ISAIAH 9:6-7. HEBREWS 2:9-18. ISAIAH 48:12-17.

  • @TenderTrap86 & this is testified by Jesus Christ himself Luke 24:36/39 "They were startled and frightened, thinking they saw a ghost. 38 He said to them, “Why are you troubled, and why do doubts rise in your minds? 39 Look at my hands and my feet. It is I myself! Touch me and see; a ghost does not have flesh and bones, as you see I have.”

  • @TenderTrap86 So this is scientifically not possible, FATHER, SON, HOLY SPIRIT... & the concept of Trinity, the word "Trinity" doesn't exist anywhere in the Bible, but it is there in the Qur'aan...

    "And do not say, "Three"; desist - it is better for you. Indeed, Allah is but one God. Exalted is He above having a son. To Him belongs whatever is in the heavens and whatever is on the earth. And sufficient is Allah as Disposer of affairs." Qur'aan 4:171

  • @MrBOXA01 - "the word "Trinity" doesn't exist anywhere in the Bible, but it is there in the Qur'aan..." -

    I already told you that Roman Catholicism doesn't believe that the Bible alone is the source of truth. Many people can interpret the Bible in many different ways.

    It's like what's going on in the Muslim world, right now. There are Muslims who think that the Quran justifies genocide. This is the road personal interpretation of scripture leads down. No true unity of faith.

  • @TenderTrap86 You know what brother, lets make a deal... On the day of Judgment lets see what happens. If im right, don't tell God that you did not know about Islam & i never warned you...

    If your right, im willing to go to HELLFIRE FOREVER

    I PROMISE YOU...

    Is that a deal ??

  • @MrBOXA01 According to the Quran (5:69), I shall grieve not, for I believe in one God.

    I don't want you to go to eternal hellfire, forvever.

  • @TenderTrap86 OK. If I'm right, then promise me you will NOT complain to God at the Day of Judgment, & you will not say to God that I (we the Muslims) never told you about Islam & belief in One God...

    If you are right, then at the day of Judgment, you can either humiliate me in front the world or do anything you wish..

    This life is VERY short, we do not know when we are gong to die. Death is very unpredictable.. So hopefully i will see you soon.. Inshallah (God Willing)

  • @MrBOXA01 If I complain at the Day of Judgement, who would listen anyway?

    I don't want to humiliate you, ever.

  • @TenderTrap86 there are muslims who think that "Quran justifies genocide" but the Qur'an does not do so. It is just their imagination, day dreaming.

  • @TenderTrap86 Brother, you haven't answered my question, do you believe in ONE God ? Do you believe that this God has NO partners & is unique ?

  • @TenderTrap86 Answer honestly..

  • @TenderTrap86 Brother, do you believe in ONE God ?

  • @TenderTrap86  The Qur'aan describes the mountains 1400 years ago !!

    ''Have We not made the earth as a bed, and the mountains as pegs''? (Quran, 78:6-7)

  • @TenderTrap86 Modern earth sciences have proven that mountains have deep roots under the surface of the ground (see figure 9) and that these roots can reach several times their elevations above the surface of the ground.2 So the most suitable word to describe mountains on the basis of this information is the word ‘peg,’ since most of a properly set peg is hidden under the surface of the ground.

  • @TenderTrap86 The history of science tells us that the theory of mountains having deep roots was introduced only in the latter half of the nineteenth century.

  • @TenderTrap86 Can i ask you, when was the Big Bang discovered ? hmm 100 years back ? 200 years back, The Qur'aan mentioned the Big Bang 1400 years ago.

    ''Do not the Unbelievers see that the heavens and the earth were joined together (as one unit of creation), before we clove them asunder? We made from water every living thing. Will they not then believe?'' Qur'aan 21:30

    Who could have mentioned 1400 years ago that every living thing is made from water ?

  • @TenderTrap86 That in itself is proof that Muhammad was the Last & Final Messenger sent to Mankind.

  • @TenderTrap86 As far as your statement that you say ''Christianity is a great mystery''. Brother that does NOT make sense, why does God want to confuse us, i don't get it. If God had a scripture, it should be Original and to the point, it should be PERFECT, & that is exactly how the Qur'aan is, PERFECT ! NOT CHANGED EVEN ONCE. NOT A SINGLE WORD HAS BEEN CHANGED SINCE IT HAS BEEN REVEALED 1400 YEARS AGO, UNLIKE THE BIBLE WHICH HAS BEEN CHANGED SEVERAL TIMES.

  • @TenderTrap86 Its clearly mentioned "Ye men of Israel, hear these words; Jesus of Nazareth, a man approved of God among you by miracles and wonders and signs, which God did by him in the midst of you, as ye yourselves also know."

    [The Bible, Acts 2:22]

  • @TenderTrap86 I hope you understand that now my brother in humanity...

  • If Muslims believe that God is unfathomable, how can it be ruled out that God isn't trinitarian? 

  • @TenderTrap86 "Muslims believe God is unfathomable"

    I don't know what Muslims you have been talking to but i can undoubtedly tell you that we Muslims do NOT believe God is unfathomable. Allah says he is ONE and there is NO other God (s) beside him. Allah says he is unique and NOTHING like the creation. However it is the Christians that have been heavily corrupted and made the idea of the so called 'trinity'. It is clearly mentioned in Mark 12:29 "Hear, O Israel; The Lord our God is one Lord."

  • @TenderTrap86 It is the CHRISTIANS that have corrupted themselves & have made their own concept of God. God clearly says he is ONE. Is that too difficult to understand ? Now lets see the trinity if it makes any sense.. Christians say God is 3 in 1 however he is still One, they say the son (Jesus) (also God according to Christians)

    came down to this earth as a man, and he ate/slept/went to the toilet, however he is still God aswell.

  • @TenderTrap86 Jesus prayed to the father (also God) so it means he prayed to himself, DOES THAT MAKE ANY SENSE !!!! IM GETTING MAD !!!!! CHRISTIANS ARE CORRUPTED!!!!!!!! THERE IS ONLY ONE GOD. NOT 3 IN ONE. NOT 1 IN 3 BUT JUST ONE AND THERE IS NOTHING LIKE HIM, HE DOES NOT HAVE ANY PARTNERS OR ANY OTHER GODS BESIDE HIM. THAT IS THE TRUE GOD (ALLAH)

  • @MrBOXA01 Is God unfathomable, or not? Yes or no?

  • @TenderTrap86  NO

  • Sheikh! Why are brother Muslim accept Jesus?