Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (162)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I remember watching this for the first time. She's so beautiful and talented. I just love her really lol. Awe she sounds sick here tho but she still does well and fights through.

  • to replay: go to 2:36

  • She killed. Plain and simple.

    

  • Amazing performance! She puts her heart and soul into it, anyone who feels that passionately about music deserves all the success they can get.

  • i love you lady gaga <3!~

  • We love u Gaga, you are such an inspiration to all us bohemeans ;) Rock On! ~pDawg

  • she has an amazing voice she deserves to be famouse so all lady gagas haters can go do themselves

  • WHICH PIXEL IS LADY GAGA???

  • I love her performance...love u Gaga

  • i love her hair here!

  • im going here to see justin bieber what time should i get there? lol i wanna be like up front

  • Such a personal love song. <3

  • those live versions are much better than the studio one (except because of the video)

  • "HQ live." put on 240p and see what is trash D:

  • I love this song. Cos it's alot more heartfelt than alot of her other songs.

  • HQ? my ass

  • If you want you can skip forward to 2:34 seconds. I'd rather listen to her interview but for those who are in a rush skip ahead.

  • heheh she looks like a fly X3 .. i fing love her xD

  • This song is so beautiful Gaga is amazing

  • i would have so much respect for her if she dressed like a normal person and wrote more songs like this....shes so talented yet she cares more about her image and writing music that will sell than she doesnt about being a great song writer

  • @723music If you appreciate the image she tries to convey, what's the point of you trying to find a way to respect her. She's said so many times that what she wears is a way for her to test those who truly believe in her capabilities as an entertainer.

    She's testing your ability to adjust to what she does. It's your opinion if you think she wastes her time caring about her image and writing ability.

  • @723music Its sad that you can't respect someone because how different they dress. Respect is something someone should have because they deserve it, not because they 'Look Like' They should deserve it.

  • love her so much

  • looks like madonna in the Who's that girl period

  • I love her! even when she"s sick she kills it! its unfortunate that some people dont recognize her talent :(

  • Considering she was sick when she sang this, she kicked ass! You can kinda hear the pitchy parts where she was really trying to sing but her voice just wouldn't let her :) love her so much! If you want to hear what she really sounds like while singing You and I, listen to her performance on AMP radio! :)

  • I've always loved her, but when I first heard this song I was like what the heckkkkk... lol.. just because it was so different from her other records, but it is now one of my favorites! Her performance on Oprah really touched me, and I LOVE the lyrics :). Go gaga Go!

  • Love

  • What song is that at the beginning? All I heard was 'that boy is a something,' I don't know, lol

  • @starkid77 Monster it's on "The Fame Monster" What you heard is "That boy is a monster" It's really good.

  • @totallynotafangirl Oh wow, thank you, you made my day/night;)

  • perfect!

  • This version should be on the album.

  • @jfd5289 Hell no. The album has Brian May playing guitar and the We Will Rock You beat, that's star power. Having a legend play on your cd, you don't get rid of that.

  • it's amazing how this song evolved

  • I always skip to 2:35 cuz i cant wait to hear her sing this song live:)

  • I LOVE THIS VERSION BETTER! than Mutt Lange's production of the one on the album! I musch rather hear GaGa's piano version of You and I! Just love her passion for playing the piano! SO fucking talented!

  • How is the guitarist named?

  • @1mad1g1t brian may

  • @EmmaV54069 i meant the one here and the monster ball tour

  • @1mad1g1t Oww sorryy... I don't know x

  • why is this released one year later?

  • I could wish the finished song on the album were more like this, as a little monster i honestly gotta say.. Her albumversion sucks compared to this..

  • i think her voice has gotten better since shes first started. i think she must be sick here

  • She looks like marilyn monroe!

  • i want her to record an acoustic version like thisssssssssss

  • always crazy, lol

  • this version is better than the album version

  • DAMN GAGA What a Voice!! She is a true Queen

  • Just CAN"T take her seriously with those glasses...lol

  • This version is so much better than the Shania Twain version that's on the album...

  • I'm a tea crazy person ... and so's my dear Gaga <3333333 Awsome performace as USUAL!!! uh, soooo great! .... ♥_♥

  • Sounds like she has a lost voice here. or maybe her voice got really worn out from singin so much. She sing better now and has a more powerful voice now.

  • If you see Gaga through the years something happened to her voice. There her voice was good but couldn't hit high notes but now she can. Her voice used to be soft but now it sounds mature. What happened?

  • @AngryRio328

    She was allowed to make music how she wanted it. :] On Fame, Gaga was heavily beholden to her record producers, who wanted her to release a more typically female pop record with a less impressive vocal range. As time has gone on she's had more artistic control over her music, allowing her to sing how she wants to. Proof: if you listen to songs she sang when she was still Stefani she has the same smoky voice exhibited in her current music.

  • @AngryRio328 i guess it just got stronger or something? her voice has always kinda been like this when sang live... and she sings alot, so i would imagine shes kinda worn out or something.

  • ROCK N' ROLL!! GUYS JUST EXPECT THE UNEXPECTED WITH BORN THIS WAY!

  • este video lo habia visto hace mucho y me encanto la cancion...pero no la habia reconocido que sale en el nuevo disco...

  • It took me a while to like the album version of this song because this performance is so amazing!

  • ''...so it probably wont be a single''......one year later YOU PROVED US WRONG :D

  • @zemnasdarkness Hmmmmm... Uhh, Huh... Uhh, What?!!!!!

  • I think this version is better than the album version. She's amazing live!

  • WE DID IT! WE DID IT!!! 400,000,000 VIEWS ON BAD ROMANCE CONGRATS MOTHER MONSTER! NEXT MISION 500,000,000 WE CAN DID IT! AND PUT "BABY" ON THE GARBAGE!

  • ♥ I love this song

  • I LOVE YOU SO MUCH :'(♥

  • AHHH! i love her!

  • If I am serious I like this more than the album version...

  • :O :)

  • love her

  • i want to camp out for her good morning america performance in may....any suggestions from people who might have camped out for this performance??

  • she's in my hometown today but i can't afford to see her....sad face

  • i was there! yay :)

  • i was here! yay :)

  • Went to the Monster Ball last night and she played this. Such a good song!!!

  • she is very pretty when she isn't wearing some box on her head

  • God I can't wait for the studio version of this song. Who am I kidding? I can't wait for the album Born this Way!

  • She's the next queen of POP

  • @nashriquez are u kidding me? she IS the queen of pop!

  • i was there! :)

  • yay that's my birthday...:')

    don't cry angels, it's a beautiful day...

    aww she's sooo cute saying ''hi everyone..''

    yes, we truly love you Gaga!!

  • Beautiful.

  • gorgeous. absolutely gorgeous.

  • I looove this! I love Classic Rock, and this song has a strong Rock influence! It's like nothing she's done!

  • something about my "cool Nebraska guy"...who drove a muscle car like a truck right through my hear.

  • Something about that "cool Nebraska guy" and the muscle car that muscle car that drove a truck right through my heart.

  • AMAZING VOICEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE, I DONT UNDERSTAND WHY SOM PPL R COMPARING HER W THE FAKE MADONNA GAGA SINGS MADONNA DOESNT COMMON

  • raw talent is right,, she can sing pop, rock, hip hip, dance, jazz, adult comtemporary... she always have an evolving sound.

  • @Tonster1998 u r soooooooooooo rite.......

  • ACTUALLY...This song was inspired by her mother who enjoys listening to country/westrern music...and also "some guy" that owns a REALLY GREAT BAR!!!!

  • ACTUALLY...This song was inspired by her mother who enjoys listening to country/westrern music...and also "some guy" that owns a REALLY GREAT BAR!!!!

  • LMAO! at GaGa " trying " to headbang

  • Love you a million times over Mother Monster <3

  • I want the song!

  • Love this song, but why is a Nebraska guy wearing high heels?

    No. 1 song though

  • Such raw talent. I'll always love her. and she sure lives for the fans.

  • @Whatsernamerox Elle est tellement Fantastique !! C'est litlle monster ne peuve que comprendre ! maman la numero 1 !

  • 'a brand new song' haha her little monster knew about it long ago hun ;]

  • yessssss

  • Lady Gaga doing and MTV Unplugged session...now that would be amazing!

  • Love it!

  • why did they boo during the fame i dont get

  • love you mother monster x

  • hear how everyone boos when the person talks about The Fame,

    I love her so much and this song is beautiful and now there is another way to play the piano;

    1. With a heel

    2. stnading on chair

    3. normally

    4. and now sitting on it

  • when they are interviewing hr, she keeps going back to the subject of her little monsters. I LOVE IT.

  • ONE person disliked this... lol-pone

  • 2:25 :)

  • she says the fame monster as "the fake monster"

  • amazingg! lady gaga roxx 

  • i agree that she is REALLY talented, cause most singers dont sound that good without technology

    but i dont like her previous songs...

  • @1990sfanCB When you say 'her previous songs' do you mean the ones on the radio? Because she has songs similar to this that never became popular, like Speechless. But all of her songs sound better acoustic.

  • That song's extremely beautiful!

  • love, love, LOVE IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    \

  • What about those who say they're booing at the moment it started to rain is for this reason that exclaim

    do not believe that if it would not be booed for so little time

  • I LOVE LADY GAGA!!! she like my hero! I love this performance! This is my favorite performance of her`s. AND I LOVE THIS SONG!!! When her new album comes out, I AM SO BUYING IT! She is so talented i love her!!!!

  • her best yet tbqfh

  • Was this song about Luc Carl? I heard they got back together. I love GaGa! =]

  • I'm just shooting in the dark here, but you think because of that baseball incident? Some people are still being pissed at her? lol.

  • y are they booing?? :( Y WOULD U BOO THIS BEAUTIFUL WOMAN??

  • @28306dc they're booing cause its raining lol they would never boo her :D

  • who cares if some people booed her.

    Lets get this nearly 20,000 People there acorrding to the Today website.

    Compare this to other recent events Like justin bieber in sydney australia.

    Thats a lot!

    She is amazing!

    And if people booed, they're probably haters. She's doing it for the True Little monsters! *Paws up*

  • @RoboWhxre they werent booing herrr!!!!!!!

  • @littlemonsteraustin It sure does sound like it! BUT WHO CARES She is amazing and we all love her <3

  • I LOVE LADY GAGA!!! she`s amazing isnt she? im like her biggest fan!!

  • she is so boring.

  • @huhu300 If you think shes boring , your life must be depressing.

    In fact , just go and get a duck and constantly hit yourself with it

    Or is that too boring for you ?

  • @SilverSparksRedFlash whattahell? grow up! it's my opinion.

  • @huhu300

    Well if you dont like it , dont comment and take yourself away...

  • @huhu300 you're a bastard with NO life

  • @littlemonsteraustin it's my opinion, respect! (Y)

  • @huhu300 then why r u watching it?

  • @JELD9325 tedium lol

  • OMG so wonderfull!!!! *.*

  • i just want the song, without all that chating in the begining :/

  • Sweet :)

  • i love this song soooo much,

    check out my cover? :-)

  • ILOVEGAGA.

    YESSS.. Im seeing her in September :DDDD <3

  • OMG!!!! GAGA IS AMAZING!!!! I LOVE HER!! GREAT SONG!

  • AHHHHHH!!! LOVE IT!!!

  • AHaAH I love her!

  • why the fcuk are they BOOING HER?

  • i recdorded this too but i couldnt get a high volume on the recording

  • Love Gaga was standing right by her side in the rain now I can't wait to see her tonight at MSG!

  • I SO love how they BOOED the hell out of her

  • @ILoveMyMusicBox09 they tried to bring her down. No homophobes bring god down!

  • @ILoveMyMusicBox09 They weren't booing.

  • @2DeNiM4 You need to clean your ears; they actually booed her for some min in the video 0:30 to 0:32

  • @ILoveMyMusicBox09 There's like 2 people that boo. There's like 19,998 people that cheer.

  • @ILoveMyMusicBox09 I was there - nbc put all the fans that slept over in the streets in the BACK & we screamed when people put signs up, blocking our minimal view. I can't remember what we were chanting at that point ("move the gate" "monsters can't see" "we camped out") - but you can hear someone scream "I CAN"T SEE!"...The boo was definitely not for her.

  • What can I say that hasn't been said a million times about her... she's just the best and so is NY...can't wait to see her tonight at the Garden!!! Goo Goo for GaGa

  • I love her hair in this video <3

  • I'm seeing her tonight, so excited!!!

  • Can you put up her "Teeth" performance!?!?!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more