Personal opinion: The control you have over your voice when jumping through octaves is amazing, you are extremely talented and it's shown through the way your voice carries the song over the simple riff.
I often find my soul crushed by the hope in tragic songs, rather than the bleak segments. I believe it's this hopefulness that makes this cover so much more emotional.
Well done mate, such a good cover and played so effortlessly. Feel free to add the chords / tab to ultumate guitar because the ones there at the moment suck :) - Well done
mi piace molto, la canzone ma la tua voce e il tuo stile la rendono magica ancor di più...realy beautiful song and beautiful voice and interpretation......i won't sing whit you....
I cant belive this is as good as it gets. this truly is what covers should be. It is a nod at the perfection antony created yet i see your own focus on the meaning of the song. post some originals, i am intrigued.
This is the best cover of this song on youtube.That said,Antony sang this song in such a stylized way that any attempt to sound like him will be destined to be compared to the original and in all honesty come up way short,thus sounding more like amazing kareoke than an actual cover that is AMAZING. I think you have the voice to make an AMAZING cover of this song. But sing it with more YOU rather than just like Antony. That advice goes to every other I say make a cover.
Been searching covers of this song for the last hour. yours is the best I've heard. I love your voice so much! you've captured this song perfect. and your voice actually adds a deeper level of emotion that almost all covers haven't been able to capture.
love how the guitar is actually a part of the song rather than just something to be played along with it. if you get me.
anyway awesome is all I can say! absolutely in love with it =)
Very nice cover, certainly the best cover of this song I've seen on YouTube. You have a good voice. I can play the guitar parts myself, but I sound like someone is hurting me when I try and sing it.
וואו...פשוט להקשיב שוב ושוב.... מדהים!!!!
limorsh2 1 day ago
Personal opinion: The control you have over your voice when jumping through octaves is amazing, you are extremely talented and it's shown through the way your voice carries the song over the simple riff.
SarahAJ93 1 month ago
I don't suppose you could do the whole version? the song just seems completely empty without it.
kittehjam 1 month ago
very beautiful
241046awesomo 2 months ago
Great
DawcioTarcio 2 months ago
very good singing,very good song
ima831 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Good luck.... nice voice
krefeldw123 2 months ago
This is very hard for a man to sing, so well done.
UnderTheAffluence 2 months ago
WOW THIS IS SPECIAL, IT'S BETTER THAN THE ORIGINAL.
MrBocko77 3 months ago
awesome
cesar5698 3 months ago
incredible i feel what you fell
Gabriel57015 3 months ago
I think that this is better than the original!
johannaasaaek 3 months ago
vraiment une
très belle reprise
ErAlaux 3 months ago
Well done my friend. It's such a moving song and you played and sang it just right. Nice voice. :)
Andersgbg 4 months ago
We now have a Black Cloud Island YouTube channel!
Thank you to everyone who has posted nice things on these cover videos it's much appreciated! xxxxxxxxx
BlackCloudIsland 4 months ago
wow that was awesome!!!!!!
bskkid4eva 4 months ago
Oh my GOD! That was amazing!! Love your version!
kennethlokas 4 months ago
increible
jmacai 5 months ago
I reaaaaaally like this. Great job.
AnonimuzZ 6 months ago
gorgeous...just truly lovely.
kangfesher 6 months ago
brilliant....
MrHanks2222 6 months ago
another angel..
zalasmoon 6 months ago
magnifique
supercrevette 7 months ago
Wonderful Cover, Thank You!
AllAboutManuel 7 months ago
LOVELY.the wigs not working for you though.love&peace
gallopingfoxly 7 months ago
Great voice!!
tigery94 7 months ago
wOw *___*
MaEn095 8 months ago
hey thats really not bad...incredible song, nice one x
deuce1611 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Your voice is beautiful and does the song justice! <3
romany93 9 months ago
Your voice is beautiful and does the song justice! <3
romany93 9 months ago
wow exceptional.. amazing loved it. brilliant job
VellaCardell 9 months ago
Very impressed. Didn't expect to be writing that.
randorr 9 months ago
I absolutly love this version, you sing beautifully! : )
mitzy93 9 months ago
wow! really cool!
xXxcucciolo19 9 months ago
really nice cover, you made me cry... so i think that this means
you have reached the entire emotion of this song... thank you
MANUDIJ 9 months ago
man, you did great. duplicated it on Antony's level would be too much, but you did it your own way and you did a damn good job!
eb0nikz 10 months ago
nice voice!
rickyseabra 10 months ago
oh my god, I´m in love..
Maybarratu 10 months ago
Spellbinding
Revan1992x 10 months ago
GREAT!!!
YUDICE2000 10 months ago
Very good job. I'm pleasantly surprised!
syolich 10 months ago
This is amazing! I love it, you have a wonderful voice =)
secret2mistakes 10 months ago
I can't stop listening to you singing this.
I listen to the original but find so much more hope in your version.
Paula x
Pallen6969 10 months ago
I can't stop listening to you singing this.
I listen to the original but find so much more hope in your version.
Paula x
Pallen6969 10 months ago 12
@Pallen6969
I often find my soul crushed by the hope in tragic songs, rather than the bleak segments. I believe it's this hopefulness that makes this cover so much more emotional.
mackvanlobster 7 months ago
I agree, Paula xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Pallen6969 6 months ago
Your voice is fantastic!! Great emotion as well! Thank you for this cover!!!!
silvernd85 11 months ago
You have made this song for me and lifted a cloud, thank you,Paulax
Pallen6969 11 months ago
Such a nice voice! Great! I loved it!
fungui02 11 months ago
Absolutly amazing !!
You made me feel the same i felt when i heard Antony's version and i thank you for that !
Hope you can make songs such great in your bands with you and your friends. Good luck !
CCannigia 11 months ago
awesome!! beautiful,,,
TheNancyRotten 11 months ago
A-m-a-z-i-n-g
danielle279 11 months ago
those two are just jellus of youre talent!
maebmusic 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Me encanta¡¡ ¡me pone los pelos de punta
BanedSpam 1 year ago
Me encanta¡¡ ¡me pone los pelos de punta
BanedSpam 1 year ago
I LOVE YOU!!!
ofrahazz 1 year ago
beautiful dude!
weeredfrog 1 year ago
Dude go to American Idol
Freeman13Arthur 1 year ago
Beautiful Falsetto ..... very nicely done ! Antony is a tough act to follow in my books .. and you pulled it off fabulously !
alannahrichardsvideo 1 year ago
Its beautiful. Great cover :)
x3lectroheadx 1 year ago
Beautiful cover
simmy2101 1 year ago
Just exelent dude! Really great. :)
TonyKwyjibo 1 year ago
Well done mate, such a good cover and played so effortlessly. Feel free to add the chords / tab to ultumate guitar because the ones there at the moment suck :) - Well done
gavdown 1 year ago
I love it! Repeated it many times. Thanks.
Taamotua 1 year ago
wow superb
xtemujinx 1 year ago
the best cover that i foud! good luck ..
88Greace 1 year ago
the best cover that i foud! good luck
88Greace 1 year ago
Very sweet, thanks :)
angerock49 1 year ago
You sure look a bit like Paul McCartney, haha!
Love this cover, one of the hardes to do in my opinion.
GerardWayFan00 1 year ago
Comment removed
GerardWayFan00 1 year ago
You kind of look like Paul McCartney. I love you, and this cover.
viictoreea 1 year ago 3
mi piace molto, la canzone ma la tua voce e il tuo stile la rendono magica ancor di più...realy beautiful song and beautiful voice and interpretation......i won't sing whit you....
barbaramelie1 1 year ago
nice =)
querertenerte 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Argghhhhh,, your talent makes me so envious! Very well done, its a beautiful song and you definitely did it justice :)
Take care
19cookie92 1 year ago
Argghhhhh,, you talent makes me so envious! Very well done, its a beautiful song and you definitely did it justice :)
Take care
19cookie92 1 year ago
Magnificent!
RebecaSunshine 1 year ago
I always hoped there was someone to cover Antony and sound amazing. I'm really glad I found you.
Morphoza 1 year ago
This is the best cover that i've ever listened!!
I can't explained that i feel when i listen this song.
Thank you for this version, your voice and guitar has surprised me.
jantpg 1 year ago
This is the best cover that i've ever listened!!
I can't explained that i feel when i listen this song.
Thank you for this version, your voice and guitar has surprised me.
jantpg 1 year ago
Bravo! You capture Antony's voice almost perfectly, and the guitar work is very well adapted!
9krt 1 year ago
¿Me podrías decir qué cuerdas tocas cuando haces el arpegio?
TheNiera22143121 1 year ago
me encanta
palloblas 1 year ago
well done.
D0ST03VSKY 1 year ago
I cant belive this is as good as it gets. this truly is what covers should be. It is a nod at the perfection antony created yet i see your own focus on the meaning of the song. post some originals, i am intrigued.
jbmayer 1 year ago
seriously top class
xtemujinx 1 year ago
Thank you to everyone who has commented, it's so nice to read these lovely things, makes these winter mornings a bit happier!
I will be doing some new stuff soon, original music, as well as maybe some covers.
thanks again!
TheVileDarlingSetTV 1 year ago 6
@TheVileDarlingSetTV
This is the best cover of this song on youtube.That said,Antony sang this song in such a stylized way that any attempt to sound like him will be destined to be compared to the original and in all honesty come up way short,thus sounding more like amazing kareoke than an actual cover that is AMAZING. I think you have the voice to make an AMAZING cover of this song. But sing it with more YOU rather than just like Antony. That advice goes to every other I say make a cover.
ceasefire1120 10 months ago
@TheVileDarlingSetTV hello. a friend of mine recently passed away and I was really hoping to get these chords. thank you.
bustedspeaker222 8 months ago
This is the best cover I have ever heard of this song. I stand in awe of you. Totally moving and believable!
EstMeaVita2011 1 year ago
Wish I could find a place to sing like this and not be ebarrassed by who's listening in! :P
EddzzMandela 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you are a "crack"
lococ21 1 year ago
I'm offically in love with you :| This is my favourite song XD xx
TheBleaaach 1 year ago
nicee
fluffynaq 1 year ago
amazing!!
Cauboi89 1 year ago
Your really good at that :)
meganmox96 1 year ago
hey whats the chords for this song? also wuld love 2 hear a cover of fistful of love, u hav a great voice
badmuthafucka23 1 year ago
best cover of this song i've heard on youtube :)
TheRealShellyJ 1 year ago
Wow, great voice.
gohel50 1 year ago
Nice cover dude...but I've got one question for you...do you want a smack??
Hope your well mate.
Jayspee11 1 year ago
Beauty voice.
Better cover.
You're so good.
DitricaVerde 1 year ago
I like so much your voice :)
onetoportela 1 year ago
AMAZING JOB!! :) I could fall asleep to your voice! (Is that weird?)
MusicQueen161 1 year ago
Been searching covers of this song for the last hour. yours is the best I've heard. I love your voice so much! you've captured this song perfect. and your voice actually adds a deeper level of emotion that almost all covers haven't been able to capture.
love how the guitar is actually a part of the song rather than just something to be played along with it. if you get me.
anyway awesome is all I can say! absolutely in love with it =)
afairytaledreamer 1 year ago
i love your voice. you're amazing !
kisses of spain (L)
crepusculosandra 1 year ago
LOVE IT!!!!!! <3
vincentlux 1 year ago
salut bravo super reprise .bonjours de france
mezzototo 1 year ago
Awww that is SO very beautiful! well done, man, well done!! :)
waxarlequin 1 year ago
LOVE IT!
Lacrismo 1 year ago
best cover ever. sweet voice, sweet guitar tabs....LOVE IT.
Lacrismo 1 year ago
love it
TLoland 1 year ago
'Easy' by Joanna Newsom would be a good one for you
and really very good job, You've brought something real and different to to a quite hackneyed format
AProudAtheist 1 year ago
WOW!
nothing more to say,amazing dude!
muzzstarr14 1 year ago
Bravo , belle reprise.... Ce n'est pas chose aisée .
calexico526 1 year ago
ey it´s a geat cover!
guarduli 1 year ago
Amazing... Best vocals i've seen for this music. Congrats
Trepzel 1 year ago
omg stunning
wishywashydark 1 year ago
Just... Beautiful.
mythicalmonk 1 year ago
It can't compare to the original. But you do the best cover I've ever seen! :)
Bleubaihr 1 year ago
muy BONITO !!!!BRAVO !
chumati 1 year ago
Oh what a beautiful voice.It was such a pleasure to listen to you.Really.
elishebaal 1 year ago
Very nice cover, certainly the best cover of this song I've seen on YouTube. You have a good voice. I can play the guitar parts myself, but I sound like someone is hurting me when I try and sing it.
Mancuso64 1 year ago
Amazing cover :D
AimPayne 1 year ago
Great cover i love your Voice!!!!!
PowerBoat1234 1 year ago
Great job! I love your voice!
ivanrumi 1 year ago
awesome, real passion thank you
CanyonTVinc 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wow. Best cover on youtube by far. Your voice is incredible.
I didn't think people had the guts to do a cover to this song.
This song makes me so sad.
Have you done a cover to Cripple and the Starfish?
shamkhalovaf72 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wow. Best cover on youtube by far. Your voice is incredible.
I didn't think people had the guts to do a cover to this song.
This song makes me so sad.
Have you done a cover to Cripple and the Starfish?
shamkhalovaf72 1 year ago
Comment removed
shamkhalovaf72 1 year ago
MAN YOU SOUND LIKE HIM LOOK LIKE HIM AND BOY CAN PLAY A MEAN GUITAR AND YOU MADE THE HAIRS STAND UP ON THE BACK OF MY NECK AWSOME
dazrazuk 1 year ago
amazing
Оо
imbohdancold 1 year ago
Aww Maaaan!!..Twas' amazing..Thanks muchly
: )
BrodyLuv2 1 year ago
Wow!!!!
kangfesher 1 year ago
100th "Liked it" =]
i really did. was getting tired of going from cover to cover video of this song. luckily i found you before giving up ;)
really good job, dear!
ferdicamacho 1 year ago
Beautiful :')
Made me cry!
ArynIsWhatWeAimFor 1 year ago
Thanx!
borisstring 1 year ago
INCREIBLE =)
TheallGuays 1 year ago
Beautiful cover, sersiously lovely.
MissAppleWhispers 1 year ago
Amazing vocal pal, this makes me want to take all my vids down. Great job!
SnurgyBob 1 year ago
Great version! A very dificult song to sing along and you did it quite well ;) Keep on singing!
viniciusb1 1 year ago
i love the sincerity in your voice and the simplicity of the guitar.very good.
r1ch4rd69 1 year ago
You're AWESOME!!
great voice and you play perfect!
I love it! :) congratulations!
viusomiant 1 year ago
Best guitar and vocals i've seen on here! Did you tab it yourself? Amazing :D
Rocksyism 1 year ago 3
@Rocksyism thanks very much!
nah to be honest i just had a listen and guessed (perhaps incorrectly but nevermind!)
i am not the guitar player in the band really but i can just about bluff it!
we are doing a couple of new covers really soon with luke playing guitar, who is a million times better than me!
thanks again though!
TheVileDarlingSetTV 1 year ago
i love it! you maked me cry!!!!
peQeStyLe69yeaH 1 year ago
i love itttttt x
wklize 1 year ago
<3 beautiful voice
TheRainPouringOut 1 year ago
Nice
cobalthammer 1 year ago
UNBELIEVABLE! That was terrific! Insanely amazing! Can't find any other word to describe my feeling right now.. WOW.
brokenharbor 1 year ago 2
Excellent - well done :)
craigieboy123 1 year ago
wowh! amazing voice and awesome cover
i like this one more even than the original one! =)
neverfeelalone 1 year ago
(your voice is beautiful....)
Im speechless. Thats all I can say.....
Aidan0128 1 year ago
Wow*_*
good job
I love you:DDD
you have a perfect voice
Freeman13IL 1 year ago
WOW....just magic....
benharpette 1 year ago
This is beautiful, just about to do a little cover of it myself. You have a beautiful tone to your voice, love it! Siobhan x
tofuhappy 1 year ago
very very nice keep it up XD
Taekwun 1 year ago
you do this damn good.
Antony has an amazing (almost angelic) voice, but i still like your cover
bluemakesgreen 1 year ago
good job!
Iaminthecloset 1 year ago
Honey fills your voice, seasoned in sadness. Thank you! Great!
Long live his Highness, Antony!
onceuponatimeinhell 1 year ago
nice!
SoulBullets 1 year ago
wow.
your voice is beautiful.
schatzlady04 1 year ago
i like
mistakenshyness 1 year ago
I am a huge Antony and the Johnsons fan as obviously you are.
Your voice is lovely, filled with passion and emotion.
Well done... this song is a real challenge.
HesitateB4 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the best of the covers i've heard of this song, but i don't know why is one of the less seen!!!! life is unfair, but you're very very good :)
pamsoso 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the best of the covers i've heard of this song, but i don't know why is one of the less seen!!!! life is unfair, but you're very very good :)
pamsoso 1 year ago
the best of the covers i've heard of this song, but i don't know why is one of the less seen!!!! life is unfair, but you're very very good :)
pamsoso 1 year ago
the best of the covers i've heard of this song, but i don't know why is one of the less seen!!!! life is unfair, but you're very very good :)
pamsoso 1 year ago
You sing with a lot of passion. Beautiful voice and presence. I love this song.
apryleshowers 1 year ago
good rendition.
armadillozenith 1 year ago
very nice! vocals wern't perfect but thats how its ment to be.. great cover
Paddyslippers 1 year ago
Nice you got the original feeling of the song, great voice.
jsilke 1 year ago
fantastique................one other star !
parnepar 1 year ago
Absolutely amazing! What a nice cover, what a voice, what a pretty guitar playing!!!
Congratulations from Spain.
uxdmons 1 year ago
CRACKKKKKKKKKKKKK!
adgime92 2 years ago
wow :)
workforidlethumbs 2 years ago 13
so so so so so nice!!!!
Osesuna 2 years ago 7
marry me?
jariberry 2 years ago 2
ole ahi tu poya eso es very good en andaluz !!!!!
oeoeoeoeoo
zeroffsinger 2 years ago