This comment has received too many negative votesshow
quello dove sta internata quella deficiente di tua moglie e dove tu sei membro onorario! sei anche ottuso? ho detto che io NON CANTO...io non sono un cantante deficiente.. capito adesso? se hai problemi di comprensione mettiti un insegnate di sostegno che usi con un demente tuo pari termini molto più semplici...adesso dileguati rompicoglioni vecchio e invece che perdere tempo qua rendi la tua pensionabile età più fruttuosa facendo i pompini a parigi! togliti dalle scatole vecchio depravato!
@miaobauaugh 'non sei un cantante deficiente'?!?Sono molto sorpreso dalle tue confidenze(i tuoi commenti)dove dici che sei cito: 'deficiente,stronzo,demente, rompi coglioni,delirante,matto' vado avanti?!?!?... Leggendo i tuoi commenti sensibili pieni di 'poesia' e 'saggezza' volevo dirti:
-Sei aggressivo,frustrato,maleducato...e ti capisco bene!!!
Tu sei nato in una epoca quando la lirica italiana degli anni 50 non esisteva più!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
hahah sei ridficolo vecchio depravato! io NON SONO UN CANTANTE hahaha sei davvero ridicolo mi fai proprio pena..scarsa elasticità mentale e depravazione sono i segni che ti acocmunano...tu uno dei migliori? sei solo un povero frustrato psicolabile! impara l'educazione VECCHIO PAZZO e malato mentakle doveva essere quel poverccio bastardo di tuo padre morto che una sera che la TV era rotta decise di fare un coglione come te!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@bodiloto dimenticavo..se non sei francese allora IGNORANTE impara a scriver ein italiano che sei pessimo..ma insegnare a te la morfologia e la sintassi sarebbe come insegnare ad un bambino la teoria dei neutrini...adesso dileguati morto di fame!
Per me tu hai una voce schifosa e per questa ragione sei così frustrato!
Non devi cantare,devi curarti 'dottore' !
50 anni fa i maleducati erano Professori accanto à te!
Dai canta,voglio sentire la tua voce orrenda!
ahahahahahah
Non devi avere paura di me(in questo mestiere sono uno dei migliori,credi mi e posso aiutarti,appoggio,'maschera',interpretazione...so tutto)...ma come sei carino!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@bodiloto affatto depravato... sei così matto da vaneggiare e vivi nel tuo profondo delirio..mi dispiace...oltre che francese sei anche matto! 2 cose negativissime..se poi agigungiamo la tua ignoranza...diciamo che rientri a pieno titolo nel concetto di SCARTO SOCIALE... fortunatamente la tua età avanzata porrà presto fine alla tua inutile esistenza...vecchio MATTO
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@bodiloto evidentemente come in tutti i mestieri, anche in questo stanno gli inetti e coloro che ne capiscono poco..sei da 60 anni nel campo e significa che evidentemente non hai imparato nulla e manchi di giudizio effettivo! ignorante basta leggere il tuo commento che avevi fatto quando io ho criticato alagna...oltre che vecchio sei anche rimbambito..mi sa che devo consigliarti un bravo neurologo..adesso taci che hai perso un'altra buona occasione per stare zitto
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@bodiloto sei un campione in stronzate...sei un vecchio depravato e psicopatico oltre che ignorante...e per cortesia impara a scrivere..sei pessimo...scrivi allo stesso modo di come giudichi...e curati dillo a quella bastarda di tua moglie che vecchia come è magari davvero ne ha bisogno...campione del mio cazzo!!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@bodiloto il cretinio sei tu e tutta la gentaglia che ti circonda deficiente! e poca confidenza razza inferiore....si vede che evidetemente conosci solo alagna come tenore che è pessimo..ma poi mi chiedo..quando mai un francese ne ha capito di opera? taci che fai più bella figura!
I may be well off with this as I don't have the music in front of me but is the Bb and the A after it majorly off where they should be????? Don't get me wrong, I think he is fantastic but it seems off to my ears!
Does he have to be better than every tenor that came before him, just to be really enjoyable? That seems toohigh a standard for any one to attain. I think he's great, despite that, or perhaps because, he is different from the previous generation of great tenors.
colora40 How funny read all these boys who criticize Alagna and other young men .As I wrote before men can`t look young goodloking goodsinging,men.Every woman who has still hormones at right end of body are ready to give him what ever he needs.It helps not much to to carry dead bodys to stages,they don`t sing any moore.Try to lisen who are still alive and enjoi it.
colora40 How funny read all these boys who criticize Alagna and pther young men .As I wrote before men can`t look young goodloking goodsinging,men.Every woman who has still hormones at right end of body are ready to give him what ever he needs.It helps not much to to carry dead bodys to stages,they don`t sing any moore.Try to lisen who are still alive and enjoi it.
@miaobauaugh Domingo è superiore ad Alagna, ci mancherebbe non ci vuole neache tanto.. Tu dici che Io seguo la massa senza neanche conoscermi, mi dai dell'ignorante e non sai niente di Me..Ti sei risposto da solo... quando vuoi affrontare una discussione impara a rispettare anche perchè con Me rischi di rimanerci male. Saluti
Nel frattempo ascolta BARIONI, CORTIS, FLETA, CORELLI, LAURI VOLPI, GIGLI...incomincia con questi e forse capirai che il tuo DOMINGO è un DILETTANTE.
@31122051 BUENO, EN GUSTOS SE ROMPEN GENEROS, CADA QUIEN TIENE EL SUYO. ASI QUE CADA QUIEN HAGA SU APRECIACION, LO IMPORTANTE Y BELLO, ES ESCUCHAR A TODOS LOS INTERPRETES Y CADA QUIEN HAGA SU CONCLUSION.
It's a shame that Alagna was overshadowed by the Big Three, but he's considerably younger than them. He's a marveolous tenor with all the gifts: a powerful, melodic voice, incredible tone, technique and artistry. He's a great Cavaradossi: this is sublime.
This opera is actually made into a movie, so that's why. It is not a performance. We have it in our UNI library and I watched it all, it's beautiful, love the costumes, stages and all three singers, Alagna, Angela and charismatic Raimondi, would love to see them perform it !
Si allargano o meglio si forzano delle note per ottenere un timbro più scuro più adatto all'opera come in questo caso per esempio la Tosca di Puccini, ha bisogno di una vocalità che sia eroica ma rispettando l'integrità vocale... come si dice in gerco.. senza forzare i suoni, cantando quindi sul fiato.
Alagna è senza dubbio un tenore di gran rispetto ma destinato ad un repertorio più romantico (secondo me), per cui bisognerebbe vedere dal vivo come farebbe quest'opera.
he is one of the best tenors of this period.... even if i don't think he has got a good voice... it's not very strong and i got used to appreciate Pavarotti's or Domingo's voice
Frienze7, look on Amazon; yes it is on DVD. I own it and have viewed this fine production many times now. It's wonderful and his voice soars. I also own a few other of his productions on DVD - well worth the money!
What a medicority Alagna is....it is so obvious that Pavarotti pick him as his successor because he only acts to underscore ho great Pavarotti was....Pav was no fool.....I mean this kind of labored singing is not art.....get this clown off the stage for Pete's sake....
come fai a cantare cosi'non senti la voce che gira e non trovi l'impostazione ottimale x l'emissione della voce e sei pure calante sul finale studia ancora
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
His voice waggles, he sounds very artificial and the "Ls" are horrible! For me this is not a natural sound of a singer - but in fact someone who tries to play a game...
WRONG! that "waggle" you are referring to is what we singers call vibrato. :P "a game"? What the heck are you talking about? You should clear your head of the weird voices telling you to write stupid comments so you can listen to a very good performer do something i'm sure you just wish you were doing or could do.
concordo perfectamente con el carnal del coment anterior es de las mejores interpretaciones que he escuchado de esta bellisima obra, y es cierto, no podemos comparar a algana con pavarotti, es como comparar un libro con un agua de sabor, son personas distintas y estilos distintos!!!
Alagna WAS a GOOD tenor. He was never a great tenor. He is just not even that good now, ego got the better of him. Pavarotti was a PHENOMENAL bel canto tenor singing Donezetti, Bellini, and some Verdi, but Tosca? Give me a break.
....why bother singing this aria after Pavarotti sang the definitive version....this guys rendition just pales in comparison...it is so obviously inferior....guys pack it up and go home....it has already been done and done aboiut a million times better....
That is such pretentious and naive comment, as much as pavarotti has accomplished, he does not own music or roles he has sung. and other singers don't have to sing just like him. you can hold-on to your good-old- boy's recording, there are opera lovers have more broad and interesting taste.
I totally agree with you chowchow! Even if I adore Pavarotti I can't stand people who compare eeach singer to him and , any female singer to La Callas. First of all, if nobody is allow to sing because it doesn't sing like Pavs or La callas, then Opera is dead. Second I've heard horrible things from Pavs and La Callas. Third they are fucking dead! and the show must go on! and last but not least, Alagna is fucking good!
@matthieusarah he is good but I feel that for this particular role Domingo is the best or at least the best I have ever heard. This despite the fact that the first time I heard this role interpreted it was by Pavarotti back in 86 at the Metropolitan
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
ok go ahead and listen to mediocrity if you like....it's your choice....I mean is everyone deaf...can't anyone hear the obviously inferior delivery of this aria compared to pavarotti's ....I mean the difference is staggering....it's like comparing Mt. Everest and a bump in the road....thers is no need to try to redo the Cistine Chapel in a hamfisted fashion...it has already been finished to perfection, so to speak, etc...
Jesus Christ guys, on this one too? Give the Pav a rest, this is getting ridiculous. Like, goddamnit people. Light. Lyric. Tenor. Not for Puccini. Not ever.
Me parece una buena cancion, pero sinceramente creo que Alagna no esta a la altura de Domingo,Pavarotti y algunos otros tenores...No digo que sea malo, pero si que le falta mas fineza en su voz ...
I bought Alagna's first CD's when they were released, and I thought he was good, but not great. I like him much better now. I like his Puccini, but he is much more elegant in the French repertoire.
I'll admit that RA doesn't have the most focused, elegant tone, but it's certainly not "shouting". Listen to him in french repertoire. That's where he seems to shine, if I remember correctly.
I just find it very funny you posted the exactly same thing at nearly every performance of this song you don't like; even wondered if you deliberately looked them all up just to post this....= =
Really? Better than Pavarotti? Hardly. Domingo I can agree with (never liked him) and Carrerras is only okay, but Pavarotti is the Maestro. Greatest tenor of the last fifty years. Alagna is good, but hardly a Pav.
opera tenors have their bad nights too but there is no excuse not to act perfectly and Alagna is a great lovable actor,ok he does not have the perfect voice nowadays but who has anyway?
Bocelli has a good voice but he is not capable of singing serious operas, hence you don't see him performing particular arias that are considered to be hard.
Al principio parece un gallo pero yo tengo el DVD completo y realmente no es un gallo gallo XD es un impulso de voz que con el audio del Youtube y el ordenador se oye como un gallo.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I am partially deaf in both ears 3% hearing in total. I am blid in one eye and have leprosy which covers 102% of my body.
This guy makes me feel like I have chicken skin all over, just after ive been plucked, his singing makes me hear 20-20 and see as clear as mud. No wonder he got Booed off the stage at La scala!
Love the "mad sacrastan" washing the paintbrushes in the background. Loosely interpreted, he's imploring Mario to "paint the heathens, but leave the saints alone".
This comment has received too many negative votes show
quello dove sta internata quella deficiente di tua moglie e dove tu sei membro onorario! sei anche ottuso? ho detto che io NON CANTO...io non sono un cantante deficiente.. capito adesso? se hai problemi di comprensione mettiti un insegnate di sostegno che usi con un demente tuo pari termini molto più semplici...adesso dileguati rompicoglioni vecchio e invece che perdere tempo qua rendi la tua pensionabile età più fruttuosa facendo i pompini a parigi! togliti dalle scatole vecchio depravato!
miaobauaugh 2 months ago
@miaobauaugh 'non sei un cantante deficiente'?!?Sono molto sorpreso dalle tue confidenze(i tuoi commenti)dove dici che sei cito: 'deficiente,stronzo,demente, rompi coglioni,delirante,matto' vado avanti?!?!?... Leggendo i tuoi commenti sensibili pieni di 'poesia' e 'saggezza' volevo dirti:
-Sei aggressivo,frustrato,maleducato...e ti capisco bene!!!
Tu sei nato in una epoca quando la lirica italiana degli anni 50 non esisteva più!
Per questa ragione perdono LA TUA IGNORANZA!
Coraggio!
bodiloto 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hahah sei ridficolo vecchio depravato! io NON SONO UN CANTANTE hahaha sei davvero ridicolo mi fai proprio pena..scarsa elasticità mentale e depravazione sono i segni che ti acocmunano...tu uno dei migliori? sei solo un povero frustrato psicolabile! impara l'educazione VECCHIO PAZZO e malato mentakle doveva essere quel poverccio bastardo di tuo padre morto che una sera che la TV era rotta decise di fare un coglione come te!
miaobauaugh 2 months ago
@miaobauaugh se non è un segreto in quale ospedale psichiatrico canti ?...'dottore'?!?
ahahahahahahah
Canti come cantavano : Masini,Del Monaco,Björling,Filippeschi,Mincev,Corelli,Vickers,Aragall, Kraus, Usunov,Atlantov,Cecchele,Cossuta,Nikolov etc.!
Se non canti come loro allora taci e impara BUFFONE!
PS mi immagino che nel ospedale psichiatrico cantate ogni giorno...
Ti auguro una buona notte (hai preso già la tua medicina?...ahahahahahahaha...'dottore'...)
Non sono francese,IGNORANTE.
bodiloto 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@bodiloto dimenticavo..se non sei francese allora IGNORANTE impara a scriver ein italiano che sei pessimo..ma insegnare a te la morfologia e la sintassi sarebbe come insegnare ad un bambino la teoria dei neutrini...adesso dileguati morto di fame!
miaobauaugh 2 months ago
Comment removed
miaobauaugh 2 months ago
@miaobauaugh tu non sei un dottore,sei pazzo!
Per me tu hai una voce schifosa e per questa ragione sei così frustrato!
Non devi cantare,devi curarti 'dottore' !
50 anni fa i maleducati erano Professori accanto à te!
Dai canta,voglio sentire la tua voce orrenda!
ahahahahahah
Non devi avere paura di me(in questo mestiere sono uno dei migliori,credi mi e posso aiutarti,appoggio,'maschera',interpretazione...so tutto)...ma come sei carino!
Tu non devi cantare,prima devi curarti !
ahahahahahahahah
bodiloto 2 months ago
@AleBro83 carissimo amico,@andiroma72 e @miaobaugh sono la stessa persona!
Non perdi il tuo tempo prezioso!
bodiloto 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@bodiloto affatto depravato... sei così matto da vaneggiare e vivi nel tuo profondo delirio..mi dispiace...oltre che francese sei anche matto! 2 cose negativissime..se poi agigungiamo la tua ignoranza...diciamo che rientri a pieno titolo nel concetto di SCARTO SOCIALE... fortunatamente la tua età avanzata porrà presto fine alla tua inutile esistenza...vecchio MATTO
miaobauaugh 2 months ago
@miaobauaugh 'beato' tu dottore...mi immagino i cantanti che hai sentito tu dal vivo nella tua vita!
ahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah
Tu non sei dottore!
Tu sei un malato mentale e vivi su questa terra per dire le tue idiozie!
Cura ti !
bodiloto 2 months ago
Comment removed
bodiloto 2 months ago
Comment removed
bodiloto 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@bodiloto evidentemente come in tutti i mestieri, anche in questo stanno gli inetti e coloro che ne capiscono poco..sei da 60 anni nel campo e significa che evidentemente non hai imparato nulla e manchi di giudizio effettivo! ignorante basta leggere il tuo commento che avevi fatto quando io ho criticato alagna...oltre che vecchio sei anche rimbambito..mi sa che devo consigliarti un bravo neurologo..adesso taci che hai perso un'altra buona occasione per stare zitto
miaobauaugh 2 months ago
Comment removed
bodiloto 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@bodiloto sei un campione in stronzate...sei un vecchio depravato e psicopatico oltre che ignorante...e per cortesia impara a scrivere..sei pessimo...scrivi allo stesso modo di come giudichi...e curati dillo a quella bastarda di tua moglie che vecchia come è magari davvero ne ha bisogno...campione del mio cazzo!!!
miaobauaugh 2 months ago
@miaobauaugh caro dottore,cura ti!
Non so chi è il 'cretino'( suppongo che tu maleducato dici 'cretino' pensando che dici buongiorno...)
Io maleducato non ti do del 'cretino' perché sei dottore...
Io Alagna lo avevo sentito durante 16 anni dal vivo.
No comment!
bodiloto 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@bodiloto il cretinio sei tu e tutta la gentaglia che ti circonda deficiente! e poca confidenza razza inferiore....si vede che evidetemente conosci solo alagna come tenore che è pessimo..ma poi mi chiedo..quando mai un francese ne ha capito di opera? taci che fai più bella figura!
miaobauaugh 2 months ago
Why is the sacristan so angry? I know he's not supposed to like Cavaradossi, but this sacristan sounds so villainous. He should play Scarpia!
Loganberrymusic 2 months ago
He's voice cracks a bit.
nickgbertolotti 3 months ago
Sehr emotional und auf der anderen Seite einfach gesagt: herrliche
mitegive 4 months ago
I may be well off with this as I don't have the music in front of me but is the Bb and the A after it majorly off where they should be????? Don't get me wrong, I think he is fantastic but it seems off to my ears!
nochain2011 5 months ago
@nochain2011 I've listened to this aria performed by dozens of singers and his timing sounds right to me.
Loganberrymusic 2 months ago
une des meilleurs versions de tosca depuis callas,gobbi,merci
ininacsot 8 months ago
Qu'est-ce qu'un bel homme. Qu'est-ce qu'un homme charmant ... Je veux garder dans mon placard ... en cas de besoin ...
hahahaha.....
biacisne 8 months ago
Przepiękna aria ..Wspaniały tenor
hotellesny 9 months ago
@hotellesny tak to prawda ale ja woli jego zona Angela Gheoghiu
truvianni 8 months ago
Comment removed
bodiloto 9 months ago
@spatauser giusto!
bodiloto 9 months ago
Does he have to be better than every tenor that came before him, just to be really enjoyable? That seems toohigh a standard for any one to attain. I think he's great, despite that, or perhaps because, he is different from the previous generation of great tenors.
jenni4claire 10 months ago
colora40 How funny read all these boys who criticize Alagna and other young men .As I wrote before men can`t look young goodloking goodsinging,men.Every woman who has still hormones at right end of body are ready to give him what ever he needs.It helps not much to to carry dead bodys to stages,they don`t sing any moore.Try to lisen who are still alive and enjoi it.
colora40 11 months ago
colora40 How funny read all these boys who criticize Alagna and pther young men .As I wrote before men can`t look young goodloking goodsinging,men.Every woman who has still hormones at right end of body are ready to give him what ever he needs.It helps not much to to carry dead bodys to stages,they don`t sing any moore.Try to lisen who are still alive and enjoi it.
colora40 11 months ago
@miaobauaugh SONO D'ACCORDO
andyroma72 1 year ago
no me gusta mucho alagna pero aqui suena muy bien.
ezev8logos 1 year ago
@miaobauaugh Domingo è superiore ad Alagna, ci mancherebbe non ci vuole neache tanto.. Tu dici che Io seguo la massa senza neanche conoscermi, mi dai dell'ignorante e non sai niente di Me..Ti sei risposto da solo... quando vuoi affrontare una discussione impara a rispettare anche perchè con Me rischi di rimanerci male. Saluti
Nel frattempo ascolta BARIONI, CORTIS, FLETA, CORELLI, LAURI VOLPI, GIGLI...incomincia con questi e forse capirai che il tuo DOMINGO è un DILETTANTE.
AleBro83 1 year ago 11
@AleBro83 INCREDIBILE HAI SPEZZATO UNA LANCIA IN FAVORE DI DOMINGO...
andyroma72 1 year ago
ha sempre cantato male!Bellissima voce usata male!
liEder89 1 year ago
@liEder89 Pas tout à fait d'accord,mais presque!
abracadabranque 1 year ago
NO, EL MEJOR INTERPRETE DE MARIO CARAVADOSSI, ES JOSEP CARRERAS
artugons 1 year ago
@artugons : NO, EL MEJOR INTERPRETE DE MARIO CAVARADOSSI ES FRANCO CORELLI.
31122051 1 year ago
@31122051 BUENO, EN GUSTOS SE ROMPEN GENEROS, CADA QUIEN TIENE EL SUYO. ASI QUE CADA QUIEN HAGA SU APRECIACION, LO IMPORTANTE Y BELLO, ES ESCUCHAR A TODOS LOS INTERPRETES Y CADA QUIEN HAGA SU CONCLUSION.
artugons 1 year ago
Placido Domingo is the best Mario Caravadossi for ever!!!!
Unplacidista 1 year ago
cut at about 1:30 ............. couldnt even sing this in one piece
saiserieht 1 year ago
alagna is great but domingo is the best
guycc1 1 year ago
I like him and yes, the opera must go on with the new ones. Voice is different but the variety is the good part in here.
Gabofeles 1 year ago
My little killer send it to me to express his feelings , his sense and great Love to me !
Romantic are you Tran Xuan Nghia :)
p.s. may be one day you will sing me this aria to me :)
NinoUrushadze1 1 year ago
tenor di merda !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! fuck you
10fredo 1 year ago
he is not singing at all hahaha...
mauriciomille 1 year ago
This is a great performance ! Not only a marvellous singer but also a perfect actor (and a good looking one !)
Danielle from Belgium
0105199 1 year ago 4
Roberto Alagna is the most charasmatic singer I have seen.
ballet701 1 year ago
It's a shame that Alagna was overshadowed by the Big Three, but he's considerably younger than them. He's a marveolous tenor with all the gifts: a powerful, melodic voice, incredible tone, technique and artistry. He's a great Cavaradossi: this is sublime.
jd1906sf 1 year ago
Quanto é bello !!! e bravo
sopranobrasileira 1 year ago
so the staff of the metropolitan en the scale are amateurs. "that's you're interpretation"
fredericsem 1 year ago
bohhhhhhhhhh mi sa tanto che e' una lagna questa
rinarix1 1 year ago
Preferisco Lando Bartolini.
olartetenor 2 years ago
Comment removed
TheGmck 2 years ago
Why on playback singing?
mikulka73 2 years ago
@mikulka73
This opera is actually made into a movie, so that's why. It is not a performance. We have it in our UNI library and I watched it all, it's beautiful, love the costumes, stages and all three singers, Alagna, Angela and charismatic Raimondi, would love to see them perform it !
martinkoklingacik 2 years ago
is a master piece!! i love it!!
lacon3dom 2 years ago 3
Yes very enjoyable
tuppey66 2 years ago 3
Voir ( entendre ) Placido Domingo dans le même rôle .
Amitiés à tous ... :-)
francesca7564 2 years ago
Ouch.
Webarton 2 years ago
i wasnt expecting him to be this good. Was marvelous.
musoph21 2 years ago 6
In jeder Hinsicht grauenhaft (auch der Sagrestano...,) fürchterliches Geschmiere,
wotansings 2 years ago
secondo me quel giorno ha registrato solo quest'aria così si è permesso di allargare un po' suoni.... ma... va be..
MrDerere1 2 years ago
si ma perchè allargare i suoni ???? sono veramente brutti porca miseria
AleBro83 2 years ago
Si allargano o meglio si forzano delle note per ottenere un timbro più scuro più adatto all'opera come in questo caso per esempio la Tosca di Puccini, ha bisogno di una vocalità che sia eroica ma rispettando l'integrità vocale... come si dice in gerco.. senza forzare i suoni, cantando quindi sul fiato.
Alagna è senza dubbio un tenore di gran rispetto ma destinato ad un repertorio più romantico (secondo me), per cui bisognerebbe vedere dal vivo come farebbe quest'opera.
MrDerere1 2 years ago
he is one of the best tenors of this period.... even if i don't think he has got a good voice... it's not very strong and i got used to appreciate Pavarotti's or Domingo's voice
miaobauaugh 2 years ago
divino
MrPeppe8660 2 years ago
Frienze7, look on Amazon; yes it is on DVD. I own it and have viewed this fine production many times now. It's wonderful and his voice soars. I also own a few other of his productions on DVD - well worth the money!
artj22850 2 years ago 12
Love it.
JasonDavis1969 2 years ago 3
Was this filmed as a production? It can be bought?
Frienze7 2 years ago 7
Yes it can be bought. I got mine on Ebay.
JasonDavis1969 2 years ago
que chido creo que le baritono le estorba al tenor en esta bella aria ,pero en fin yo no la escribi, JE;!!
reivajthepianist 2 years ago
Es necesario porque sino dios no lo perdona... jaja.
Bsonnete 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Je l'aime bien notre Roberto mais son final "sca-a-a" n'est pas juste: un peu haut.
louvet66 2 years ago
Personnellement je ne trouve pas...
19olivier72 2 years ago
e magnifico i m italy
kalel3900 2 years ago 3
radiologu¡is stuppid your coment,
stupid words.
brabissimo alagna powerfull voice,brabisssimo¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡
malagarcha 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
What a medicority Alagna is....it is so obvious that Pavarotti pick him as his successor because he only acts to underscore ho great Pavarotti was....Pav was no fool.....I mean this kind of labored singing is not art.....get this clown off the stage for Pete's sake....
radiologist301 2 years ago
come fai a cantare cosi'non senti la voce che gira e non trovi l'impostazione ottimale x l'emissione della voce e sei pure calante sul finale studia ancora
associazioneliricadi 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
His voice waggles, he sounds very artificial and the "Ls" are horrible! For me this is not a natural sound of a singer - but in fact someone who tries to play a game...
deviljulian 2 years ago
WRONG! that "waggle" you are referring to is what we singers call vibrato. :P "a game"? What the heck are you talking about? You should clear your head of the weird voices telling you to write stupid comments so you can listen to a very good performer do something i'm sure you just wish you were doing or could do.
SoundAndFury12 2 years ago 3
SHUT UP baritone !! the tenors singing lol lol :)
DDLeone 2 years ago 5
Aqui entre a alimentar el ego
armoniamg59 2 years ago
This film is very nice but I agree with 'GermanOperaSinger' that Alagna is good but not great. For me hi is too laboured.
TraVoiBelle 2 years ago
Comment removed
TraVoiBelle 2 years ago
i love him he is GREATTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT!!!
madicks3 2 years ago 5
Eccellente canto e interpretazione.. il miglior Cavaradossi ascoltato di recente
dayalhari 2 years ago
bueno le perdonamos el desafine?
nusael 3 years ago
concordo perfectamente con el carnal del coment anterior es de las mejores interpretaciones que he escuchado de esta bellisima obra, y es cierto, no podemos comparar a algana con pavarotti, es como comparar un libro con un agua de sabor, son personas distintas y estilos distintos!!!
eliyin 3 years ago
para ltodos los imbesiles criticos,que buscan la perfeccion que no existe ,que siempre estan a la espera del que decae un poco para
hacer leña de el, bastardos no existe la perfeccion.Y ESTA BIEN QUE HACI SEA.
BRAVO ALGANA MAGNIFICA INTERPRETACION¡¡¡¡¡
malagarcha 3 years ago
Se dice "Asi sea" ignorante, no sabes nada del Bel Canto, vete a escuchar tu vallenato.
Demolition69XXX 2 years ago
Alagna WAS a GOOD tenor. He was never a great tenor. He is just not even that good now, ego got the better of him. Pavarotti was a PHENOMENAL bel canto tenor singing Donezetti, Bellini, and some Verdi, but Tosca? Give me a break.
GermanOperaSinger 3 years ago 7
I have to say that you are wrong, Pavarotti sing Tosca very well.
Demolition69XXX 2 years ago 2
Hey Demolition69, I'm with you. The big guy sang Tosca as good as any. Puccini would have loved him. In my humble opinion.
joelweisberg 2 years ago
sounds good. the lower tones sound strange and the tone is different. but tenors are for middle c and above. good for cavaradossi.
btsg 3 years ago
Bellissima aria, la poesia di Puccini ben si sposa con la corposa voce di Alagna.
lucyllebalth80 3 years ago
Was he a tiny bit sharp at the end?
joeboo36 3 years ago
"E te beltade ignota cinta di chiome bionde..." che poema, che voce che colore, Grande Puccini. Ottimo Alagna
glucio47 3 years ago
...MAGNIFICO!!
tapadillo415 3 years ago
bravisimo!!!!!!!!!
adri235 3 years ago
alagna is a great tenor. ppl really need to lighten up about the pavarotti supreme. ther are other great singers other than the late great pavarotti.
oprachik 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
....why bother singing this aria after Pavarotti sang the definitive version....this guys rendition just pales in comparison...it is so obviously inferior....guys pack it up and go home....it has already been done and done aboiut a million times better....
radiologist301 3 years ago
That is such pretentious and naive comment, as much as pavarotti has accomplished, he does not own music or roles he has sung. and other singers don't have to sing just like him. you can hold-on to your good-old- boy's recording, there are opera lovers have more broad and interesting taste.
MrChowChow 3 years ago 7
I totally agree with you chowchow! Even if I adore Pavarotti I can't stand people who compare eeach singer to him and , any female singer to La Callas. First of all, if nobody is allow to sing because it doesn't sing like Pavs or La callas, then Opera is dead. Second I've heard horrible things from Pavs and La Callas. Third they are fucking dead! and the show must go on! and last but not least, Alagna is fucking good!
matthieusarah 3 years ago 44
This comment has received too many negative votes show
True, Alagna is good. But, not as good as Pavarotti was. LOL, there you go.
Nater389 3 years ago
@matthieusarah he is good but I feel that for this particular role Domingo is the best or at least the best I have ever heard. This despite the fact that the first time I heard this role interpreted it was by Pavarotti back in 86 at the Metropolitan
truvianni 7 months ago
You need to learn more about music and the performing arts. Your comments disclose how little you really know!!
tanto1948 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ok go ahead and listen to mediocrity if you like....it's your choice....I mean is everyone deaf...can't anyone hear the obviously inferior delivery of this aria compared to pavarotti's ....I mean the difference is staggering....it's like comparing Mt. Everest and a bump in the road....thers is no need to try to redo the Cistine Chapel in a hamfisted fashion...it has already been finished to perfection, so to speak, etc...
radiologist301 3 years ago
Jesus Christ guys, on this one too? Give the Pav a rest, this is getting ridiculous. Like, goddamnit people. Light. Lyric. Tenor. Not for Puccini. Not ever.
tenortime51 3 years ago 2
Ruben Dominguez
farddah 3 years ago
Yeah!
aguacun 3 years ago
Wonderfull!
I feel like a child discovering a-new something that I have forgotten.
Thaxs
4tild 3 years ago
2me ha le vocali troppo aperte...CECCHELE,MARIO DEL MONACO,CORELLI..I MIGLIORI PER SEMPRE
W CECCHELE...
rickyelmeio 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Alagna can sing for Il Divo, nothing else.
gonzalojosevb 3 years ago
better than many others of his generations
themolenga 3 years ago
Agree...but not in this kind of opera repertory. He is nemorino, romeo...roles like those... not Cavaradossi, Radames, Manrico...
aguacun 3 years ago
I love Roberto and his voice!
ViolettaValery25 3 years ago 4
Not bad. Not my favorite (lack of focus, intonation spots and (imo) an odd characterization), but certainly not the worst I've heard.
Iareto 3 years ago 2
Aunque no es la mejor voz para esta Opera, aquí canta muy bien, fraseando con fuerza y expresión...bravo
liricraker 3 years ago
That was so beautiful. The best I've ever heard out all other tenors
lty2k84 3 years ago 2
exelent perfomance. bravo alagna
zootreta 3 years ago 2
Me parece una buena cancion, pero sinceramente creo que Alagna no esta a la altura de Domingo,Pavarotti y algunos otros tenores...No digo que sea malo, pero si que le falta mas fineza en su voz ...
PEro aun asi me gusta XD
misio15 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Search
Giancarlo Monsalve recondita armonia
GREAT!!!!
BENEDETTOVXI 3 years ago
I bought Alagna's first CD's when they were released, and I thought he was good, but not great. I like him much better now. I like his Puccini, but he is much more elegant in the French repertoire.
Brahmsfourth 3 years ago
If someone knows what "well shouted" is pleas let me know. Thanks: Jason
JasonDavis1969 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what is it that you don't understand??
The word "well" or the word "shout"?
Look them up in a dictionary
maestraconway 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
thanks for that
and now go to hell.
JasonDavis1969 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
moron!
maestraconway 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
now do you understand that or do I have to explain that to you??
maestraconway 3 years ago
whats rong with you
JasonDavis1969 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Do you mean "Wrong"? I see you can't even write...
maestraconway 3 years ago
i agree. there is no sweetness to his voice. he is poweful though. he sings "through his penis"
Teltcher 3 years ago
I'll admit that RA doesn't have the most focused, elegant tone, but it's certainly not "shouting". Listen to him in french repertoire. That's where he seems to shine, if I remember correctly.
chcknpie04 3 years ago 3
what dos well shouted mean?
JasonDavis1969 3 years ago
well shouted!
maestraconway 3 years ago
what dos well shouted ?
JasonDavis1969 3 years ago
I just find it very funny you posted the exactly same thing at nearly every performance of this song you don't like; even wondered if you deliberately looked them all up just to post this....= =
manfredmm 3 years ago 5
i posted at 2 and thay are not the same song
JasonDavis1969 3 years ago
= = I didn't mean you, I meant the "well shouted!"
manfredmm 3 years ago 9
o.k. im sorry
JasonDavis1969 3 years ago
I'm going to see Tosca in May and from what i see it will be great opera.
JasonDavis1969 3 years ago
yes, just don't see it where Alagna is singing Cavaradossi or you'll feel that you were ripped off. That was my feeling!
picapin 3 years ago
Much nicer than any of the much more famous (yet less deserving in my opinion) Three Tenors.
Verrrrry nice!
hotqueekboi 3 years ago
Really? Better than Pavarotti? Hardly. Domingo I can agree with (never liked him) and Carrerras is only okay, but Pavarotti is the Maestro. Greatest tenor of the last fifty years. Alagna is good, but hardly a Pav.
Iareto 3 years ago
don't really agree with the Pavarotti statement here.....
wilvivas 3 years ago
alagna great singing I love his voice it so different. it has that distinguishable timbre like pavarotti had!
operaman20 3 years ago
Very good!
novice1959 3 years ago 2
Who is singing at the time of 1 min. 12 sec.?
bailaga 3 years ago
roberto alagna.
Artisticz 3 years ago
I meant basso singer...
bailaga 3 years ago
blahahaha the answer is Andrea Bocelli is it! Get a grip you twat.
karlobarlo 3 years ago
uhh, Alagna is one of the best tenors singing nowadays...if you don't like the way he does it, go up there and do it better...I bet you can't.
Bravo Alagna.
jonadamora 3 years ago 3
I've got the Domingo/Freni recording. This doesn't hold a candle to it. Give me mine every time!
balletnut 3 years ago
nice little break at 0:18
could have done himself a favor and done a retake.
raythetse 3 years ago
opera tenors have their bad nights too but there is no excuse not to act perfectly and Alagna is a great lovable actor,ok he does not have the perfect voice nowadays but who has anyway?
smartsteve 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The Answer is - Andrea Bocelli.
Artisticz 4 years ago
andrea Boccelli has an angelic voice and I like him very much but he does not have an opera Tenor's voice that will make an opera house shake!
smartsteve 4 years ago
Sounds like an amateur's opinion.
Bocelli has a good voice but he is not capable of singing serious operas, hence you don't see him performing particular arias that are considered to be hard.
nebel82 4 years ago
Very good, but my vote goes to the great maestro, Franco Corelli
ucrebel59 4 years ago 3
Listen to Luciano Pavarotti in Tosca, in 1992 at the Met : THAT'S OPERA ! Alagna must improve. He does not hold this aria.
WANK83 4 years ago 2
Nothing special!
Aetion 4 years ago
Al principio parece un gallo pero yo tengo el DVD completo y realmente no es un gallo gallo XD es un impulso de voz que con el audio del Youtube y el ordenador se oye como un gallo.
mateuet91 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I am partially deaf in both ears 3% hearing in total. I am blid in one eye and have leprosy which covers 102% of my body.
This guy makes me feel like I have chicken skin all over, just after ive been plucked, his singing makes me hear 20-20 and see as clear as mud. No wonder he got Booed off the stage at La scala!
cityboating 4 years ago
Aprendan, así se debe cantar, lo digo con fundamento, es uno de los mejores, no sean envidiosos, por favor!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
BPVYP 4 years ago
While he is not my favorite tenor...he is the best actor...he feels the role.
Favorite tenor? Pavarotti and James Valenti
bitterbroad 4 years ago
Nie podoba mi się ten głos - wg mnie Alagna nie śpiewa czysto wysokich partii:(
Agulon 4 years ago
Love the "mad sacrastan" washing the paintbrushes in the background. Loosely interpreted, he's imploring Mario to "paint the heathens, but leave the saints alone".
jellyfish53 4 years ago
i love this guy, a great example of how ego and talent don't mix.
emalaithdies 4 years ago
I just love the way his voice cracks at di verse
ragnarkisten 4 years ago
...why?
LordMoe9 4 years ago
i love this scene, wonderfull
koutak1s 4 years ago
le sale un gallo al comienzo, pero está bien.
OperaGhost1990 4 years ago
Que??????? aprendé operaghost, el apodo te queda bien, por lo fantasma que sos!!!
BPVYP 4 years ago
Good but bland...He will never reach the heights of Corelli and others.
If this is 3 stars. Corellis version is 5 stars+!!
maxhansendk 4 years ago 3
right! I think so too!!!
MadOperaGirl 4 years ago
I disagree, because although Corelli's voice is magnificent, I think Alagna acts the piece far better.
chcknpie04 4 years ago 3