Added: 4 years ago
From: CombatSpecialist18
Views: 332,265
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,131)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • it s a verry beautifull song i like this song

  • I can just imagine this song sung by the beautiful, pipsqueak Edward Elric.

  • @WithAVoiceOfAnAngel3 Yeah. :')

  • Oh how I love this song but it's to damn sad lol

  • VIC!!!

  • I love this show...it's like when u begin to watch it, you bond with that character like you know them like a friend. But when bad things happen or they are at the brink of death, you can't do anything about it. You want to help but you can't....because it's not real. But the pain feels like It is.It's just weird! That's why I love this show and the song just makes it even better. Haha I went on a tlking spree too! xD

  • oh how i love this song i play it to my horse and she lays down it made my twin sister be able to sleep without nightmares and it soothes me when i have a bad head ace oh the powers of anime

  • At my school the principal lets us sing at lunch. Today I sang Alfonsose part. I would have sang Edwards, but when my friend and I try out for the talent show that will be her part. ANYWAY, I did ok except that my voice was weak because I was so nervous, when I was done one of my friends tryed to hold my hand down because it was shaking so bad. All well it was worth it. :) AHHH! I went on a crazy talking spree here. :)

  • @GlisteningNightStar I hope the show goes well. The thing about being nervous is that it's an evil-circle. You're nervous and then you get more nervous and so on.

    Keep it cool, and think about someone/someplace you feel calm/at home.

  • always when i listen to this song it makes me want to watch the series again

  • beautiful.... just beautifull, WHY DO I HAVE TO BE SO DAMN SENTIMENTAL??!!!!!! x( #%^*^%%^*€jdvfis

  • No, tears! Don't fall down! You'll ruin my makeup! D':

  • wow

  • i love this song soo much...

    never ed could sing though, lol

  • I love love love this song! it's so wonderful *__* and it makes me sad ..with tears on my eyes

  • Once you were gone,we were not complete :(

  • can you check out my performance of bratja?

    /watch?v=HN1bVNUdTNI

    I'd really appreciate it if you comment and rated.

  • DAMN!!

    I'm a boy but this song make me against my will sad and i nearly cried

  • when my friend sang this for her vocals exam last year its actually what got me into anime.I asked her where the song was from and i was curious to see what this 'anime' was that she was talking about.

  • i zoned out in the middle of class and was singing this song in my head little didnt i know i was really singing it out loud xD... didnt get in trouble for it ether

  • I sang this to my brother in english, and he said I was a fool and I had to shut up. SOme brother he is. >:'T

  • 5 likes ill sing this to my brother

    10 likes ill sing this in a vid on youtube

    11 likes ill sing this to my boyfriend

    20 likes ill sing this to my family

  • @ali123naruto456 hahaa. hey, where's your yt-video?

  • @ali123naruto456 41 likes. you gotta sing it to the president xP

  • @LittleShinobi92 ill try XD

  • @ali123naruto456 hey by the way, you've got 40 likes :)

  • @KamikoKittyCat i know :(

  • @ali123naruto456 got the vid made :( now gotta sing to my brother boyfriend and family :( Y DID I POST THAT?!?!?!?!

  • someone should make a video with this song (This version of the song) and Zero and Ichiru Kiryu from Vampire Knight.

  • Feels like the second half was missing somethin', Alphonse's singing, and chourus at the end, that'd be Epic, WITH a capital 'E'. Someone call Maxey Whitehead and see if we can make her sing it in that voice without breaking her. :p

  • Damn this song makes me sad and want to cry.

  • IF YOU WANT TO WATCH ALL OF WOLFS RAIN GO TO cptainanime HE HAS THEM THERE AND IF YOU WANT TO WATCH ALL OF FMA AND FMAB GO TO FULLMETALDUBBED HE HAS THEM THERE!!!😃😃😃

  • ..this is the only song, that will, and has made me cry as an adult. because line for line in those lyrics are almost exactly what happened, they are nothing less than the truth. nothing held back. no go arounds. no lies. a man loses everything once its passed...

  • This song is so sad and beautiful.

    My brother should sing me this song...and maybe i forgive him...maybe.

    

  • I cry every time I hear this.

  • Aaaah Vic Mignona... Gak! *faints*

  • everytime i hear this song or the another version my mom is like 'what are they saying?' and i smile and tell her that if she dies i wouldnt know what i will do... i just lve this song, i love borth fma anf fma brotherhood

  • .. This song tears me up all the time, just for the fact that my friend Luis and I act just like Ed and Alphonse.. He is my brother to the end.

  • IF YOU WANT TO WATCH ALL OF WOLFS RAIN GO TO cptainanime HE HAS THEM THERE AND IF YOU WANT TO WATCH ALL OF FMA AND FMAB GO TO FULLMETALDUBBED HE HAS THEM THERE!!!😃😃😃

  • i am trying to find the viola music sheet but alas i have not found it

  • @dragonballchick254 there is sheet music from fma on ichigo's sheet music site. just google it. i found this song there as well for piano or flute. i think it should work for viola too. i hope at least xD

  • @karlmoonferon because Vic Mignogna is awesome at singing? And it's a gorgeous song either way?

  • The Russian version is so much better... Why listen to this one ?

  • Have anyone noticed that the English version is one verse shorter than the Russian one?

  • everytime i hear this song i get all sad... wonder why? lol

  • they should have let "al" sing too, because in the original the strophes don't just start with "...brother mine"; it's acually "...younger brother" and "...older brother", so basically it's ed talking to al vice versa.

  • dude... this nearly made me cry

  • Better in russian

  • T.T It made me cry!!!!

  • I have to say, I prefer this version over the russian version. Yes, the singing is better quality, But didn't hear ANY emotion from it. For all I could tell, it was a friggin love song. This verion has not only ed, in a way, singing it, but it sounds like he's grieving for his brothers loss, and that he is longing for his mother.

    They should've played this version of the song in the episode 63 of brotherhood. the beginning part right after the battle and the second half as he gets back al.

  • This song always makes me cry. When i was lil my parents seperated to different country´s. I once returned to my father and don´t see my mother very often. This song is like i am talking to myself as a brother. I just want to go to the past when my mother was ´alive´.

  • I kind of wish the part at 1:51 wasn't sung by Vic since it's supposed to be Al's part.

  • In my opinion, I cannot imagine ed singing this because of vics voice. Hate it!

  • This was an excellent discovery. While the original Russian is superior musically, hearing it in Ed's voice adds an extra depth of feeling to it.

  • Now if we could have Vic singing this in Russian.

    I'd probably die with tears in my eyes.

  • This is so sad!! It fits ed elric so well!!! :'((

  • @TheNyaakitty

    yea it does, i cried when ed tells a sad story

  • btw its shed our blood not shared our blood

  • @Pooshkariot Dude he said that in the Desc. Apparently you don't read :\

  • I keep picturing ed sing this to al

  • its a cool yet sad song awesome

  • Was the Russian version written for the anime or was it just a song that happened to fit so well with the anime?

  • @Wrestlemania24444 my guess was that it was made fr the anime

  • I cant get your links to give me an mp3 version. it either doesn't work or gives me something i cant play

  • This is so sad it makes me feel that i should be more nice to my brothe

  • @reapersfate1 hmph to bad i cant do that now i used to not be an only child T_T

  • Oh nice :D

  • Thanx

  • I love it

  • Hang on, doesn't Vic play Tamaki in the English version of OHSHC???? They sound nothing alike........

  • @iluvedward91 LAWL, Yeah Vic plays Tamaki. ;)

  • This version is good, but the Russian one is awesome!

    Maybe its because the Russian one has a choir like sound and feeling to it.

  • This makes me even more sad since I just finished the series....

  • @embertree55

    FMA FOREVER

  • This is actually a little weird, because can anyone even begin to imagine Ed just breaking into song during the series?

  • @lvskiergirl lol XD can u imagine

  • I like the japanese version more but ...

    Damn every damn version of this song make me want to hug my brother :'(

  • Oh my god, Vic has the most amazing voice ever <3

  • Comment removed

  • oouuh :) Only if you know the animé Full Metal Alchemist you know what a beautiful song this is

  • i know right so beautiful

  • It's absolutely beautiful <33.

  • I love this. <3.

  • oh lol I didn't realise, It sounds like Edd singing :3

  • @RaccooNooB

    It is Ed. It's his English voice actor XD

  • I dont think this song makes sence as a solo.

  • @TheJennyWise I agree, shame they couldn't get Al's voiceacter for this. Or did his voice change? I dunno. 

  • @Spinelblade The original al was 11 when he started he is now 18 i believe and can no longer do al's voice. For brotherhood he was replaced with a female voice actress. If she were to sing this song with Vic she would probably be a little too girly rather than seeming like a young boy imo.

  • vic has sutch a good voice

  • I didn't know Vic Mignogna could sing so pretty-like!

  • wow this sounds so much better in a foreign language instumental is the best tho

  • I love this song, no mater which version. This version is special, because it is, somehow, sung by Edward. (although I´m used to the german voice)

    But still I can´t help picturing Ed in a studio, too short to reach up to the microphone...

  • @ChibiAlice russian... the original song is in russian, not german

  • @Saintbalor I never said that the original song was in german. I just said that I am more used to Edward´s german voice than to his english one- nothing more.

  • @ChibiAlice aaah It kinda sounded like you did xD. But ok! Now you got me curios about the german voice hahahaha

  • @Saintbalor His german voice is awesome- a little, little, LITTLE bit like Vic Mignogna. You should check out the german dub, Edward and Roy have such awesome voices. Roy´s voice actor is also Johnny Depp´s voice in almost every movie. Edward is "just" Shia LeBeouf. *random babbling*

  • @ChibiAlice Russian

  • @ChibiAlice It's actually Russian, but I agree. It gives it a more personal feeling to have it sung by Vic Mignogna (Edward) It kinda makes me a little sadder to be honest...

  • @VivianJollivette I never said that the original song wasn´t russian, i was simply speaking about edwards german voice actor, to whom i am more used than to vic mignogna... i wasn´t talking about the original song. 

  • @ChibiAlice Oh, my mistake.. sorry I just kind of assumed without you directly stating it. And after reading this comment, curiosity took over and I checked out the German version. It is really good ^.^

  • @mastery910 I'm totally going to watch that now thanx

  • i dont know why ppl seem to hate this version. i like it in both english and russian (in soviet russia, song like you :P)

  • It's making me tearier the more I listen to it, but I can't stop. *sniffle*

  • Who ever wrote this song must of had a brother they loved dearly.

  • @secretwriter3232 This was written for the anime fullmetal alchemist in where 2 brothers from one another had done something terrible and they lost body parts and one lost his whole body but his soul got captured in a suit of armor by his brother. They then went on to restore their bodies (this is it kind off in a nutshell)

  • @mastery910 Just saying it was not captured it was bonded :D

  • awesome <3 {-:

  • This song explains Ed's and Al's relationship/situation very clearly...

  • @eddyto12

    First it's Al then it's Ed.

  • @Roserietta the third version is the karaoke version. it's basically the same as this one, just no singing.

    Sorry this one was so late. haven't been on in a while.

  • If this song doesn't rip your heart out, I don't know what will.

  • @Pevensify a bear

  • I really only like this version because it's Ed singing. Personally, I don't like Vic Mignogna, but I like a few voices he does. Ed really fit his voice, and I like how this song fits nicely.

    Being that I'm actually learning Russian, I'm going to be trying to learn the Russian version, which I think is amazing compared to this one.

  • sang* would*

  • man, if al had song his part in english... i think i wul have ripped my heart out from suchstrong emotions... this song is one of a kind.

  • love this song

  • So Ed can probably sing, judging its his voice actor.

    Its a sad song but BEAUTIFUL-3

  • I seriously need some help... e_e. I need someone who knows how to play this on the piano and is willing to play with me on the ocarina. I saw an awesome video of a couple of guys playing, one on piano and the other on ocarina. It was so beautiful. >.<. I really want to learn this song, I've already snagged the sheet music for ocarina.

  • @AkeelaPyro I'm learning how to play it on piano (keyboard) but it may take awhile cause 1. schools starting soon 2. I play by ear 3. I'm I don't know you so my parents will never let me do it -_- *sigh* lifes so unfair

  • @aang4all Hahahah. Oh, well. Life is unfair, but that's just a fact. Sadly. Somehow, I doubt we even live in the same US state, IF you even live in the US at all. Lol. I think that on the one video they each recorded their own part and then combined it on one video. O.o.

  • aww, it's cute. It's actually supposed to be Ed signing too. though the original intended for both brothers to sing, Ed was singing the first half while Al sang the second half. but Al's english voice actor didn't want to sing (he said he had no singing talent haha) so Ed's voice actor, Vic, sang the whole thing.

  • i mean 39 people are deaf

  • 39 are deaf

  • @39 dislikes(dislikers) HOW THE FUCK YOU CAN DISLIKE ONE LIKE THIS SONG !? 

  • sounds like eds singing it

  • @wolftail1999 HE IS! HIs Seiyuu!

  • I think I may have played this song maybe 27 times now, well why stop there?

  • XO mixed emotions happy and very sad XD i love you fullmetal

  • x10000000000000000000000000000­000000000000000000000000000000

    likeeeeeeeee~~~~~~~~~~~

    DEPRESSING.

  • this is such a good song!!! i only wish they had a different singer for al's part, but still! super awesome! i love vic!

  • this is so beautiful!! Did he sing any others??

  • Russian version is better, movies (especially anime) and musics shouldn't be dubbed.

  • Every time i'm waiting for an episode of FMA to buffer, i listen to all 3 versions of this song.... It's just that amazing.

  • @MattKitten There's 3? I've heard this one and the Russian version... What's the other?

  • this song actually brings tears to my eyes and i am a very hardy person <3 :'(

  • I just realized that this version is missing a verse from Al's part D:

  • @KyuubiLoup There is? *feels sad I didn't know*

    Could you find me a video that might have one or something? :o

  • @MochiccinoWuvsCoffee it's not Vic but try blackrose1m's version, found hers a while ago.

  • omg Ed is my fav character!... well, aside from Mustang. I really wish my brother could be more like him.

  • Edward, you need a record deal. ;_;

    Inb4 Vic is the voice actor.

  • Isn't the singer the voice of Edward? I just heard it somewhere and wondered if it was true...

  • @purpleheart3000 ya its vic mignogna the voice acter! cool huh? its like ed's singing it!

  • Every day i wish for a brother...its beautiful how they can be nice to each other but still have fights and get over it quickly! :) this is why i love FMA and why this is the best song in the world

  • Comment removed

  • How to forget and forgive? I think i forgot that too...

  • fma is one of my favourite anime. every death is just as important for a child as it is for a leutenant, and they always make you cry. even some of the deaths of the homunculi.

    R.I.P

    Trisha

    Hoenheim

    Nina

    Alexander

    Maes Hughes

    Lust

    Wrath

    Greed

  • @GamerInari Also:

    Edward's other self.

    Alphonse Hiedrich.

    Every god damn child that got killed.

  • @waj9876 i cant believe i forgot about al's other self, but i honestly dont remember ed having another self, probably cuz i missed half of the episode when ed first appeared in the other world

  • @GamerInari Edward was inside his other self's body. Something...not good, happens.

  • I prefer the Russian as well but come on his voice isn't that bad.

  • Beautiful song!! T_T

  • -Plays along with an ocarina-

  • All we can do is live.

  • im almost in tears everytime i hear this cause i get flashbacks of the manga, anime and movie in my head and i remember how real and sad it was i was cryin after the movie but its not all sad i loves the bit about the miniskirts and dogs lol

  • love it

  • This song has about 1000000 times more meaning when Vic sings it XD

  • I know this show isn't real but it can really reflect on real life, like someone blames him or herself for another family members death

  • vic mignona is one of the gods of voice acting

    hes right up there with dan green, brian drummond, and jason griffith......wait what?

  • This is so much better than that autotuned crap that everybody listens to... I just wish there was a way we could bring beautiful songs like this out to the light so they're popular rather than that other crap. =/ It's really kinda sad. I hate to compare something like this to that crap, I just thought I'd make a point about. I love this song. Vic Mignogna's voice is amazing!

  • @CV01MikuHatsune What music r u talking about?

  • @CV01MikuHatsune Stop being close minded and love all music for what it is

  • @CV01MikuHatsune i agree

  • damn FMA toying with my emotions!!<:')

  • 38 People lost their brothers in alchemic freak accidents!

  • I cried. T_T I love FMA so much. It's truly an amazing anime.

  • reminds me of Si Deus me Relinquit from Kuroshitsuji. it has the same "what the hell have i done?" tone to it.

  • Comment removed

  • sounds like sonata artica and the singer who sings in the song shy

  • the voice sounds like edwards

  • @snowispain it's the guy who plays edward. ;)

  • @snowispain because it's his voice actor.

  • I love this song ...*_*

  • It's weird to find the English version of this. I even found a finnish version. I would say the Finnish is the best together with the Russian one. Somehow the emotion, and drama is lost in the English version. Maybe it's just because I understand English. But probably also that the Russian original singers put in so much more emotion and power into the song. (watch the live version of the FMA festival) Oh well it's all subjective.

  • @LadyAresha, that's because it is Ed.

    Well, his voice actor.

    :]

  • @rejecttingruto oh, ok, i didn't know that

    haha, i never know the actors names in anything

  • 62,671 veiws are from me.