Wonder Girls vs SNSD Tell me ver.

[gucci13]

SNSD IS SHIT. period..

[ice662726]

i think teayeon sunye yenny are better than the other girls XD

[3MINSofBOYFRIEND]

SNSD-BETTER VOCALS, DANCING SKILLS, MORE ENERGETIC AND LIVELY, CUTER AND PRETTIER, ..

WG can't even reach the high notes even if it's their song... so embarassing.. THEY'RE SO LAME

[directcurrent10]

@3MINSofBOYFRIEND Best ASIAN Pop Female Group 1. GIRLS' GENERATION - 701 votes 2. 2NE1 - 654 votes 3. T-ARA - 209 votes 4. AFTER SCHOOL - 100 votes 5. SCANDAL - 155 votes 6. F(X) - 147 votes 7. MISS A - 115 votes 8. KARA - 106 votes 9. 4 MINUTE - 105 votes 10. A PINK - 102 votes 11. SISTAR - 97 votes 12. WONDER GIRLS - 92 votes 13. AKB48 - 90 votes 14. SECRET - 83 votes 15. S.H.E - 48 votes 16. GIRL'S DAY - 39 votes 17. DAL SHABET - 30 votes 18. POP GIRLS - 18 votes s

[3MINSofBOYFRIEND]

@directcurrent10 and this is where the discussion ENDS...lol..

SNSD jjang...

[100PercentSone]

@directcurrent10

where did u find that plz tell me ! link !

[XedraKun]

Oke,so I made my sister~who is totally not in k-pop,she doesn`t even know snsd or wonder girls~ choose who sang it better,she said "the many girls" had better,strong voices and "the five girls" had cute voices that suited the song:) So clearly,both of them are as good,so please stop fighting :D

[tw54585]

fake - SNSD

real pop - wonder girls

[cataamanri]

SNSD ! <3

[J4praX]

in the term of voice its obviously Taeyeon beat all Wonder Girl member.. but that was only my opinion :)

[sneakernight91]

@J4praX agree with you.

[MrsKuraudoSutoraifu]

Even though SNSD was better live, I really didn't like their voices with the song. Idk, it just doesn't have that happy sound to it. Seohyun doesn't match Sohee's part at all -__- & I'm a big fan of Seobaby's voice. Sunny rocked it though ^__^ I still preferred Sunmi's voice over Tiffany & Jessica's in the verses. And I prefer Yubin's rapping. A LOT more.

[KailTrueman]

WONDER GIRLS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!1 SNSD fails to be versatile...this song is not to meant to be overly sexy...it's meant to be cute, fun, flirty, and at times sexy. SNSD was way off, their vocals as well don't measure up to WG. Their high notes are often atrocious (not just saying that, they lack strength and stability as well as tone). If SNSD had this song and not WG it would not be the phenomenon that it is today.

[erasers9876]

snsd's perf was better. but just be aware their version was a recording. lol.

[angel96520]

SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥­SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥­SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥­SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥­SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥­SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥­SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥­SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥­SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥­SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥­SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥­SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥­SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥SNSD♥

[girlluvdarma]

SNSD has better video but wondergirls video are so crappy you should put some that is good better audio

[lovetiffmushroom]

SNSD JJANG~

[XxSuperGirlzx]

SNSD is more better than Wonder Girls

[842304naomi]

Wonder Girls son lo mejor.... todas cantan super bien y son muy bellas sin lugar a dudas son las mejores en corea y el mundo....

[sneakernight91]

@842304naomi Non!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[lhey000]

girls generation.

[9923joyce]

SNSD always the Best !!!!!

[butermelo]

Sing and dance as good as the wonder girls....I beg for differ....snsd is so much better in both ways.... Wonde girls got more attention when they debut and snsd hardly any, and secretly, I was glad, because their debut song, into the new world was much more powerful and meaningful, but they were literally unnoticed, so now, when snsd conquers everything they touch, I laugh because the fact that they didn't receive instant success and fame like wonder girls helped them get to the top

[Fanylicious111]

@butermelo Agree ^^

[rachelyan2158]

Wonder girls is much better than snsd...

[xemibearr]

Just saying Snsd is more better cause there AWSOME dont ya agree ?

[SuperHusna123]

WONDERGIRLS!! FOREVER AND ALWAYS!!

[MathsQueen1999]

Snsd is better larh wondergirls sucks

[2GAWJUS2KOOL]

WOW YOU SONES ARE DUMB! SNSD WILL NEVER BE THE QUEENS OR GODDESS OF KPOP! WONDERGIRLS HAVE ALWAYS BEEN THE BEST AND ALWAYS WILL BE!

[sneakernight91]

@2GAWJUS2KOOL haha =)))) so stupid =)))))))))) I've never seen such A STUPID DOG like you =)) shut your mouth and take your butts away from here =))

[piguchaoren]

Actually I dun agree with u guys comparing this way cause as u can see, the video qualities are totally different. Same goes to the sound quality! Wonder Girl's video's quality is obviously not as godd as SNSD's. That's why SNSD's sound better

[madaboutsnsd]

SNSD won they r better than WG

FIGHTING SNSD!!!

[TheLvl199Network]

Everyone in SNSD can sing & dance. Look at SNSD's ballads!

Seriously, im nto a fan of both but SNSD has my vote on this.

[itsugarbunny]

Well SNSD used only their main vocals, its unfair to say Seohyun beat Sohee, you cant compare, because Sohee is a visual, not a vocal. Put her up against Yoona and they would be similar. Yoona is a visual, not a vocal.

[Girisgreencrazeiful]

@itsugarbunny either way sooyoung yuri hyoyeon and yoona are the weaker voices in SNSD. Yoona being the weakest and she would still beat Sohee

[126KISSER]

hmmm..., well, they both are good, but SNSD is way better with outstanding presentation.

[MegaYunglam]

SNSD is way better than WG !! whose with me ??

[therye85]

snsd win!

[sweetyoona3]

i bet just teayeon from snsd can even sing better than those five girls togetler in WG

[shirlaka]

I read a comment that said "SNSH shared a part that one WG had to sing all by their self" Okay, and ? It was the rap part, okay big whoop, it doesn't make that big of a difference considering that Yuri sang most of it, and Hyoyeon did the ending. It wasn't 9 vs 5 either as some of you are stating it was still 5 vs 5 SNSD, 5 vocalist and WG, Yu-Ri and Hyoyeon are dancers and if they sang Yoobin's part better than Yoobin, that means they are better rappers considering that Yoobin is a rapper.

[wuzzleywalley]

Jessica sang Sunye's part, Taeyeon sang Yenny's part, Sunmi's parts were split into two for Tiffany and Sunny thus Seohyun sings Sohee's part. Far enough Jessica, Taeyeon and Seohyun almost sing the whole song. Yoona and Sooyoung aren't singing. So if you want to be fair like how members in a group and another group, there were actually just 5 members singing and 2 rapping, the other 2 did not even sing. Conclusion, the amount of members isn't valid for doing WG any justice.

[MissElizabethLemon]

@126KISSER the video was made in 2008.....

[TheHeadmock]

@126KISSER LOL WHAT?!

[LlkawSone]

@126KISSER no snsd 2008 version too. and they did better honestly

[nospace8129]

In my opinion

I think SNSD's vocals are better than Wonder Girls'.

[RandyPhan6141995]

Usually, i would say the original is better than the remake

but in this case, SNSD is better

i just think overall, snsd has better vocals than the Wonder Girls

[BESTanime22]

las dos son igual de mejores!! :)

[TheVairocana]

Ha.. I just can't accept this video - Even SNSD sometimes performs really bad and there were some pretty good WG performances as well. It really depends on the day and if somebody who doesn't know these two groups well enough would think WG are some low quality group.

[Skizimo]

The original is always the best. If it weren't for the original then there wouldn't be any covers by other groups. If Wonder Girls had sung Gee then I would say the same thing that SNSD would obviously be better since that is their song.

[pairsir]

snsd sing better

[sembulan]

the weakest in terms of vocal in WG is Sohee.. she needs to work on that.. her part that makes SNSD win this performance! Seohyun did it better.. :)

[dwerty87great]

man tht cruel to compare like this :D

me As SNSD big fan generally pity for their competitor :p

[ivanchip9x]

SNSD best. ...



[tristianx727]

I respect WG as a group but I have to say SNSD is the better group ! Vocals, dancing, looks,and they just seem to harmonize better :) snsd fighting

[hrmmmhum]

Wonder Girls <3

[macarlulo]

SNSD waaaaaaaay better .............. seohyun 10000000000000000000 times better than sohee deal with it :D

[365sunnydays96]

Snsd did way better. There's no excuses

[dotckayp]

WG doing their own rap sounds excruciating..

[sasanpify]

for some reason all the WG parts have bad quality. and it is kinda unfair because WG has 5 members and SNSD has 9. it would have been more fair if just the 5 main SNSD vocals performed (Taeyeon, Tiffany, Jessica, Seohyun, Sunny). but in my opinion SNSD has better vocals & dancing than WG no matter what but i like both SNSD & WG and i respect both :)

[RickRoRuW33]

Wonder Girl Lose To SNSD Badly, Ahha And Yet Is Wonder Girl Song

[nekokitty182]

Quit comparing and just enjoy the music :)

[MrsKuraudoSutoraifu]

Honestly, people should use their eyes. WG have 5 members. SNSD has 9. WG have to sing alot more than SNSD. SNSD shared parts that one member of WG had to sing. So stop saying shit of how SNSD can sing better. Why don't they make it "fair" & use only 5 member of SNSD? We'll talk then ;)

[Lecmar91]

@MrsKuraudoSutoraifu : technically it wasn't even 9 vs. 5. snsd's 5 vocalists(taeyeon, jessica, tiffany, seohyun and sunny) had all the singing lines minus the rap of course(yuri and hyoyeon); yoona and sooyoung didn't get any lines.  so it's basically equal. and really now, wg only has 2 vocalists compared to snsd's 5.

[Phantomhive8]

: kkab-yul's rap , EPIC .

[iloveboa1105]

oh i hate the rap part

[DaythvSubs]

I'm not a very big fan of SNSD but they have a relly good vocals ^_^

[MrSnsdforever99]

i don't want to hate wonder girl's b-coz i know how hard they work..,and so is snsd and teayeon and sunhye somewhat are friend,,,,,but base on perf,,,,,,,you can tell obviously....

[TheSONEforever]

WG can't freaking sing...not even their own song properly.LMAO

[simsvideoshahaha]

Let's just put it this way: When I was watching WG, my reaction looked like this ಠ_ಠ and when I was watching SNSD, my reaction was like this |｡◕‿‿◕｡|

[meihaelee]

I like WG's version better. :))

[caca9412]

both groups are my favourite. but i have to say that snsd did better than wonder girls.

the voices of snsd's members are always better than wonder gils~

but wonder gilrs also sang not bad.

[VampirGothic]

SNSD is very better !!

[tamachan91]

in my opinion SNSD was better than WG...i dont really follow either group so based on that video their vocals are stronger...in wg only sunye and the rapper sang good but SNSD sang better as a group...taeyeon is famous for her voice(?) but apart from that seohyun and especially yuri were amazing and considering it was the first time yuri rapped (well at least for me) my choice obviously goes to SNSD!!!

[chanathipmiew]

SNSD <3<3

[yunhyoable]

SNSD The best and this is the true !!

[arualHM]

SNSD!

[snsdndogssaranghae]

SNSD 4 SURE!!!!~~~~

[TheTokiMia]

SNSD!!!!!!!

[nandaarifianto]

SNSD all the way.....

[mseasteriffic02]

i like the version of SNSD

[armmymisswg]

I think wonder girls better than snsd. :))

[yunhyoable]

@armmymisswg

r u Sure lol !!

[LaurenGrass]

sooo, SNSD performed this to boost up their ego/arrogance?

[Lecmar91]

@LaurenGrass : it was a special stage. SNSD performed "Tell Me" and WG performed "Kissing You"

[LaurenGrass]

@Lecmar91 I like SNSD, but what i was mainly referring to was how many SNSD fans make SNSD look. They sound like jerks and make SNSD sound like arrogant ego-maniacs. They have no idea how negatively they affect the girls image when they talk like that.

[LaurenGrass]

oh and thank you. :) 

[choot08]

i respect everyone's opinions when it comes to the performance as a whole.

but srsly, we all can't deny that seohyun pwned sohee!

[katy870105]

please don't be an anti !!!

each team have their fans !!!

[yAmeLiCiOus1]

sometimes other artists can perform better than the original singers....

[AngelDevil444]

hmm.. 5 v 9... i could probly tell you who sang or danced better before even watching the video..

[HachimitsuBoy85]

@AngelDevil444 It's not the number of singers but the talent that matters... 5 vs9 doesn't mean a thing... Here's some proof I know you'll agree with.... AKB has 48 singers / dancers... but SNSD is way better than them with just 9 people.

[litttlelamv]

the only time wonder girls were better then snsd was when yoobin rapped

[yAmeLiCiOus1]

apologies for my comment:

don't say i'm too bias ok.but let's all be honest..before i came here.i did watch some tell me live performances by WG so i know what's the real score.,cuz some peps here say it's unfair for WG cuz the low quality,but to be honest,it's hard to find HD performance of Tell me but i found one..hehe..after that i watch again the snsd version..no offense guys ok..i guess i need to agree to some peps here..SNSD did the great job.."dancing,singing and the crowd" they rock...!

[MySisterSings]

It's really obvious that SNSD is better.

[JunhSoOne]

@MySisterSings Love you~

[RandomMelodies1]

ahhh SNSD did Wonder Girls! love it!!

[heyBerlin1]

The wonder girls video has a really bad quali. You cant compare it with the high quali vid of SNSD. VERY UNFAIR!

[Girisgreencrazeiful]

@heyBerlin1 it dosnt make much of a difference u can obviously hear that wg sounds weak if the quality were higher itll sound worse.snsd sang this better then the recorded version

[lovelovelove472]

Sohee is way cuter than Seohyun ,

[franicoletan]

Okay just cut the crap man .....see wonder girs had their fame before snsd debut and they had made the wrong choice to leave korea .... then as gee came out snsd got all the fame ....wonder girls then had the hearts of america ...... ITS FAIR ...... anyway they are all kpop groups representing south korea for their music ...so just dont compare

[mewzakuroevil]

First of all..this video disgust me..Both The wonder girls & SNSD are great. I don't get why people are making videos like this.

[dhghldyd]

i'm korean, wonder girls >>>>>>>>>> snsd in this time

[musicis1able]

I vote for Snsd, but I still don't think it's fair that WonderGirl's video had low quality

[MuzickLogic]

If Wonder Girls would have not left Korea SNSD wouldn't be this big

[caighe9b]

WONDER GIRLS WIN ! :D

[miharo13]

BY my point of view, SNSD's version is better than Wonder Girls. I'm not saying that the wonder girls suck or anything, it's just that i like the way SNSD dance and sing more. The thing that bothers me about wonder girls is their fans. I mean if you don't like SNSD, no need to bash them! By viewing the videos, your just going to get the numbers of views up, and plus, the Sones are just going to hate you even more. Did snsd do anything bad to you? so please, let's try to get along k?

[eXegio]

wow ... there's such a big discrepancy in terms of recording quality

[amylalaz123]

well I think snsd was better... but this video is a bit unfair because the quality of WGs video is very bad. They would've sounded a lot better if the maker had used 480P+ clips.

[BuiNhatBao2010]

you could have picked a better quality video for Wonder Girls

[Blokok0]

snsd

[hai8520ifly]

SNSD sing live better than WGs... WGs is bad ...

[emeraldofessence]

By the way, by worse, I meant in video quality. The Wonder Girls' version is like 240p or below, while SNSD's version is like 480p or better. Completely unfair.

[emeraldofessence]

It's completely unfair to compare these two versions: one of which is of infinitely worse quality than the other.

[SuperHusna123]

sorry i like the original one that sngs from wonder girl sorry! plus wonder girls is awesome :)

[CocoCramel]

WOW !

SNSD is way better

they sang and danced perfectly :D

and it's way better than the original ver :O

*and they are prettier than WG members kekekeke*

[XiaxueKawaii]

Girl's generation 20/20

[anadunno]

the song fits to SNSD so much. it should have been their song. c; and the RAP part of WG they're like reading poem.

[mseasteriffic02]

the original version is by wonder girls. but i like the version of snsd because they can actually sing better live..

[westchinaman]

unfair videos, SNSD audio and video quality is much better then wonder girls. 

[SHINeefeatSnSd]

Okayy

[pentagon324]

SeoHyun here is so cute!!!

[yAmeLiCiOus1]

and also..when it comes to singing snsd knows how to used air when breathing that is why their voice comes out well..they are trained by years..

[vietnamxkorea]

honestly. Both are great idols. But In talent I give snsd. I loved wondergirls first. haha but the singign needs a little bit more practice

[vealace]

I honestly think it was SNSD, but the song does belong to WG .

that was the first time i've heard SNSD rap before it was epic :D

SNSD definantly topped !!

[yAmeLiCiOus1]

and i love the fanchants of SONE during the start..wow my fandom is really good when it comes to creating Fanchants for our precious girls....hahahaha

So Nyuh Shi Dae fighting!

[yAmeLiCiOus1]

it's obvious that i will choose SNSD because i love them,but this song belongs to WG,so just for the respect for wg,the original is better of course..but i love snsd tell version..

[ubergamer2010]

I love how people think SNSD's was lip-syncing. That means you think it sounds perfect. Considering SNSD's was obviously sung live, you've just given them a bigger compliment than you thought you did. =)

SNSD danced better, and furthermore sung MUCH better. No question about it.

[TheBeadlesWiife1]

@JoelynnHearts Taemin I thing That too :)

[devilstarsify]

This is a bias video. WG's version was not lipsynch while SNSD's is lipsynch

[PaeanOfAika]

@devilstarsify SNSD never really lipsync, maybe once or twice, but everyone does that. And this is definitely not a bias video, SNSD just have stronger voices than WG does. Honestly, even in their MV their singing was weaker. But that doesn't mean I hate WG, I have nothing against them, but they aren't as good, singing-wise, as SNSD.

[devilstarsify]

@PaeanOfAika You can listen to SNSD's MR, you will definately not dare say this again...

[yAmeLiCiOus1]

@devilstarsify

both version are live my dear...

[3MINSofBOYFRIEND]

SNSD'S rappers (yuri and hyoyeon) are way better than WG'S even SNSD do not focus on rapping and don't have a real rapper...

[MrsKuraudoSutoraifu]

@3MINSofBOYFRIEND Puhlease! Have you heard them "rapping" in RDR? Yubin pwned them. & even thought Yuri is my bias (& the only one i like in GG), Yubin definitely sounds better.

[3MINSofBOYFRIEND]

@MrsKuraudoSutoraifu it's because they don't focus on rapping.. and if you watch the way they rap on some of the live shows, they're good..

[MrsKuraudoSutoraifu]

@3MINSofBOYFRIEND I never said they sucked. I just didn't get the WOW factor I usually get when hearing rapping live.

[3MINSofBOYFRIEND]

@MrsKuraudoSutoraifu I didn't mentioned that you said they sucked...

btw, i don't care about the rapping.. I'm not fond of it.. I just noticed that SNSD have potential in rapping too...

[mingcheng123]

SNSD did it wayy better. It was ''louder'' and had way more emotions. Most importantly, SNSD has way better vocal talent.

[13MintKeys]

@SilvusX & @Ngayhomqua I don't think snsd or wg are legendary. Wg was a one hit thing,with their song "nobody",well that's what I think cuz I haven't heard about them much for a while and Snsd has gotten more known. Both are good groups...snsd is better though ahhahha

[13MintKeys]

Snsd are better at dancing and mkst snsd member can sing high and low notes. Wonders girls are pretty good but when they sing sometimes it's out of their range,and sohee isn't the best. It seems like most Companies pick girls to be in a band mostly because of their looks. I like both groups though.

[starthunder12]

I dont really care who is better SNSD are good in there own way and WG are good in there own way. So we shouldnt even compare who is better

[xXGirlofMagicXx]

SNSD DAMN BETTER!!!

[lurveeshineegal]

I tot SNSD ver. is better than Wonder Girls .. this song seems to fit mre when SNSD sings it ..

[jaymmira]

So Hee your killing me jk jk I know shes improved since the performance in this vid

[kimmaihl]

So Hee is bad!!!

[hele2402]

WONDER GIRLS are THE BEST !!

[Escarlate152]

OK, maybe I'm biased, but SNSD's vocal are much more better and stronger.

Though I gotta say Wonder Girl's rapper is quite good (Yubin, right?).

And I think WG should sing some different songs, songs where they can show little bit more power, I mean - I know Sunye can sing well (watch?v=kfwx0vlqn5E).

[FanyfanyTiffanySNSD]

SNSD singing beta ! Wonder Girl one not really nice ! 

[intriguingification]

Wonder girls rock all the way.

Not all members of SNSD can sing, but all of the members of Wonder girls CAN. 'Nuff said.

[MyKoreanDramaAddict]

@intriguingification .... all SNSD members can sing.

[mingcheng123]

@intriguingification And are you trying to say that Sohee can sing? Well, not so much. I'm sure even the weaker singers of SNSD such as Yoona sings better than Sohee. ''Nuff said.

[HaziqahHAB]

@mingcheng123 and...... sohee sings better than hyoyeon :P

[mingcheng123]

@HaziqahHAB Really? I feel Hyoyeon can sing better than Yoona even...