I heard about how great this rendition and come here. But sorry to say that, the style simply doesn't fit the song at all. Just imagine a guy trying to persuade his ex-girl who has attempted suicide to forget about him in such a playful manner...... I bet this girl will just go kill herself. Honestly, this is not even a good version, this is a silly one.
I guess some people care more about style than emotion.
there is a line that says hes afraid of the cemmmetary....
and dont give her flowers cause the scar has to heal. which means the girl is dead and hes not giving her flowers. thats how i see it, let me look at it again closely. where is the line about cutting wrist? and its a guy to a girl... not a girl to a guy.. the original eason version.
My god!! You think the guy is sending flower to the girl who's already dead??? 花瓣鋪滿心裡墳場才害怕, this is "心裡"墳場, not a real one. The girl is alive, otherwise what is that guy doing?
苦心選中"今天"想車你回家....情人節不要說穿 只敢撫你髮端 She is still alive "today", which is Valentine's day. The silly guy in fact picked the wrong day to make the conversation....留在汽車裡取暖 應該怎麼規勸 "怎麼可以將手腕忍痛劃損", this silly guy doesn't know how to convince her it's over because she is emotionally unstable.
可能佢唱功好好,但係佢唱呢首歌真唔好聽!
abc981142 7 months ago
好難聽...
ericericfok 9 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
劉美君的唱功實在一流.佢唱得比陳EASON好N咁多倍.後生一輩學下前輩咩先係唱歌啦.
safarihk 1 year ago
i just think she chose the wrong song... the style really does not match the lyrics...
bethni 3 years ago
I heard about how great this rendition and come here. But sorry to say that, the style simply doesn't fit the song at all. Just imagine a guy trying to persuade his ex-girl who has attempted suicide to forget about him in such a playful manner...... I bet this girl will just go kill herself. Honestly, this is not even a good version, this is a silly one.
I guess some people care more about style than emotion.
expiredoldbiscuit 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
suicide? i dont think this song is about suicide. i think its about the girl being dead. why else would there be cemmetary in the lyrics
macauboy 3 years ago
- the cemmentary line is just a metaphor symbolizing the death of their relationship
- there is a line about cutting her wrist, clearly the girl has attempted suicide or at least expressed the thought to the guy.
expiredoldbiscuit 3 years ago 3
there is a line that says hes afraid of the cemmmetary....
and dont give her flowers cause the scar has to heal. which means the girl is dead and hes not giving her flowers. thats how i see it, let me look at it again closely. where is the line about cutting wrist? and its a guy to a girl... not a girl to a guy.. the original eason version.
macauboy 3 years ago
My god!! You think the guy is sending flower to the girl who's already dead??? 花瓣鋪滿心裡墳場才害怕, this is "心裡"墳場, not a real one. The girl is alive, otherwise what is that guy doing?
苦心選中"今天"想車你回家....情人節不要說穿 只敢撫你髮端 She is still alive "today", which is Valentine's day. The silly guy in fact picked the wrong day to make the conversation....留在汽車裡取暖 應該怎麼規勸 "怎麼可以將手腕忍痛劃損", this silly guy doesn't know how to convince her it's over because she is emotionally unstable.
expiredoldbiscuit 3 years ago
I see, Prudence has actually changed the lyrics a bit. That makes a bit more sense.
expiredoldbiscuit 3 years ago
你又點q知係心裡的墳場ah?
macauboy 3 years ago
not every song suits the jazz feel. sorry, don't like it.
myk09 3 years ago 12
fabulous~ I like it. *MUCH* *MUCH* more than the run-of-the-mill original :P
echoicq 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
唔係果個feel,純粹賣弄!
Joannalc 3 years ago
一直覺得首歌overrated.劉美君這個version好好多!!
angpc 3 years ago
劉美君果然係劉美君~!
唱得好有風格,好有味道!!
冇睇呢個演唱會真係一個遺憾!!!
好彩我兩場都睇晒~~!!
kingking2808 3 years ago 3